I already got some feedback about the
"device driver check CD"-thing. People got confused about it, so I will tell you a bit more about my intentions (although I wanted to start doing this not until next week, duuh).
What is wrong with current live systems?
There are already several Debian-based live systems and they are doing a great job. But, from the Debian perspective, most of them have one or more of the following disadvantages:
- They are unofficial projects, developed outside of Debian.
- They mix different distributions, e.g. testing and unstable.
- They support i386 only.
- They change package's behavior and/or appearance by stripping them down to save space.
- They including unofficial packages.
- They ship custom kernels with additional patches not part of Debian.
- They are large and slow due to their sheer size and thus not suitable for rescue issues.
- They are not available in different flavours, e.g. CDs, DVDs, USB-stick and netboot images
Why create our own live system?
Debian is the Universal Operating System: IMHO we should have an official live system for showing arround and to officially represent the true, one and only Debian system with the following main advantages:
- It's an official Debian subproject.
- It reflects the (current) state of one distribution.
- It runs on as much architectures as possible.
- It consists of unchanged Debian packages only.
- It does not contain any unofficial package.
- It uses an unaltered Debian kernel-image with no additional patches (except from live system specific ones which maybe required).
Creating the Debian Live framework
Such a life system framework would allow to create different images for different scenarios:
- A small "base-system" for rescue purposes.
- A normal "desktop-system" for demonstration purposes.
- A special "diagnose-system" for device functionallity and detection purposes.
The last one is this "confusing" thing I mentioned before. Wouldn't it be nice to have a live system to easy detect hardware? Imagine, you could take such an image, burn it on a CD or copy it on a USB-stick, go to your hardware shop and boot it. Since this system would use only official Debian packages, you can easily verify if your favourite piece of hardware is supported by Debian. Doubts like "it runs with Knoppix, so hopefully it runs with Debian too" are history by that.
Maybe someone could implement then some sort of application which checks the hardware against
Kenshis Debian GNU/Linux hardware compatibility list and displays some sort of report about the compatibility level of the tested hardware.
I will definitely work on that goal. But first, I have to do a bit of research about the best techniques and create the framework arround it...
Thanks to
Myon for setting up the record
live.debian.net.