Ulrike Uhlig: Breaking the chain reaction of reactions to reactions
Sometimes, in our day-to-day-interactions, communication becomes disruptive,
resembling a chain of reactions to reactions to reactions. Sometimes we lose the
capacity to express our ideas and feelings. Sometimes communication just gets stuck,
maybe conflict breaks out. When we see these same patterns over and over again, this
might be due to the ever same roles that we adopt and play. Learnt in
childhood, these roles are deeply ingrained in our adult selves, and acted out
as unconscious scripts. Until we notice and work on them.
This is a post inspired by contents from my mediation training.
In the 1960s, Stephen Karpman has thought of a model of human communication
that maps the destructive interactions which occur between people. This map is known as the drama triangle.
Karpman defined three roles that interact with each other. We can play one
role at work, and a different one at home, and another one with our children.
Or we can switch from one role to the other in just one conversation. The three
roles are:
- The Persecutor. I'm right. It's all your fault. The Persecutor acts out criticism, accusation, and condemnation. Their behavior is controlling, blaming, shaming, oppressive, hurtful, angry, authoritarian, superior. They know everything better, they laugh about others, bully, shame, or belittle them. The Persecutor discounts others' value, looking down on them. Persecutor's thought: I'm okay, you're not okay.
- The Victim. I'm blameless. Poor me. The Victim feels not accepted by others, oppressed, helpless, hopeless, powerless, ashamed, inferior. The Victim thinks they are unable or not good enough to solve problems on their own. The Victim discounts themselves. Victim's thought: I'm not okay, you're okay.
- The Rescuer. I'm good. Let me help you! The Rescuer is a person who has unsolicited and unlimited advice concerning the Victim's problems. They think for the Victim, and comfort them, generally without having been asked to do so. The Rescuer acts seemingly to help the Victim but rescuing mostly helps them to feel better themselves, as it allows them to ignore their own anxieties, worries, or shortcomings. The Rescuer needs a Victim to rescue, effectively keeping the Victim powerless. The Rescuer discounts others' abilities to think and act for themselves, looking down on them. Rescuer's thought: I'm okay, you're not okay.
Acey Choy has created the Winner triangle, in 1990, as an attempt to transform social interactions away from drama. Her winner triangle shifts our perceptions of the roles: the Victim becomes the Vulnerable, the Rescuer becomes the Caring, the Persecutor becomes the Assertive.
Persecutor Rescuer Assertive Caring
I'm right. I'm good. I have needs. I'm listening.
---------------------- ----------------------
\ / \ /
\ / \ /
\ / \ /
\ / \ /
\ / \ /
\ / \ /
\ / \ /
\ / \ /
\ / \ /
\ / \ /
\/ \/
Victim Vulnerable
I'm blameless. I'm struggling.
Karpman Dreaded Drama Triangle Choy's Winner Triangle
The Assertive "I have needs." has a calling, aims at change, initiates,
and gives feedback. Skills to learn: The Assertive needs to
learn to identify their needs, communicate them, and negotiate with
others on eye level without shaming, punishing, or belittling them. The Assertive needs to learn to give constructive feedback, without dismissing others. (In the workplace, it could be helpful to have a space for this.) The Assertive could benefit from learning to use I-Statements.
The Caring "I'm listening." shows good will and sensitivity, cares, is empathic and
supportive. Skills to learn: The Caring needs to learn to respect the
boundaries of others: trusting their abilities to think, problem solve and
talk for themselves. Therefore, the Caring could benefit from improving their active listening skills. Furthermore the Caring
needs to learn to identify and respect their own boundaries and not to do things only because it makes them feel better about themselves.
The Vulnerable "I'm struggling." has the skill of seeing and naming problems. Skills to learn: The Vulnerable
needs to learn to acknowledge their feelings and needs, practice self-awareness, and self-compassion. They need to untie their self-esteem from the validation of other people. They need to learn to take care of themselves, and to strengthen their problem solving and decision making skills.
What has this got to do with autonomy and power structures?
Each of these interactions is embedded in larger society, and, as said above,
we learn these roles from childhood. Therefore, we perpetually reproduce power
structures, and learnt behavior. I doubt that fixing this on an individual
level is sufficient to transform our interactions outside of small groups,
families or work places. Although that would be a good start.
We can see that the triangle holds together because the Victim, seemingly
devoid of a way to handle their own needs, transfers care of their needs to the
Rescuer, thereby giving up on their autonomy. The Rescuer is provided by the
Victim with a sense of autonomy, knowledge, and power, that only works while
denying the Victim their autonomy. At the same time, the Persecutor denies
everyone else's needs and autonomy, and feels powerful by dismissing others.
I've recently mentioned the importance of autonomy in order to avoid burnout, and as a means to control one's own life.
If the Rescuer can acknowledge being in the triangle, and give the Victim autonomy, by supporting them with
compassion, empathy, and guidance, and at the same time respecting their own
boundaries, we could find even more ways to escape the drama triangle.
Notes
My description of the roles was heavily inspired by the article Escaping Conflict and the Karpman Drama Triangle that has a lot more detail on how to escape the triangle, and how to recognize when we're moving into one of the roles. While the article is informing families living with a person suffering from a spectrum of Borderline Personality Disorder, the content applies to any dysfunctional interaction.


Here is my monthly update covering what I have been doing in the free software world during March 2020 (






Some of you might have noticed that I m into keyboards since a few
years ago into mechanical keyboards to be precise.
Preface
It basically started with the


A new release 0.4.17 of
The fourth maintenance release 1.0.4 of 
Welcome to gambaru.de. Here is my monthly report (+ the first week in March) that covers what I have been doing for Debian. If you re interested in Java, Games and LTS topics, this might be interesting for you.
Debian Games










ELTS - Wheezy
Wouter s tasks
Wouter s props, needed to complete his tasks
Bike tour leg at Cape Town Stadium.
Seeking out 29 year olds.
Wouter finishing his lemon and actually seemingly enjoying it.
Reciting South African national anthem notes and lyrics.
The national anthem, as performed by Wouter (I was actually impressed by how good his pitch was).
Accommodation at the lodge
Debian swirls everywhere
I took a canoe ride on the river and look what I found, a paddatrapper!


A bit of digital zoomage of previous image.
Time to say the vows.
Just married. Thanks to Sue Fuller-Good for the photo.
Except for one character being out of place, this was a perfect fairy tale wedding, but I pointed Wouter to