Search Results: "rra"

6 December 2025

Simon Josefsson: Reproducible Guix Container Images

Around a year ago I wrote about Guix Container Images for GitLab CI/CD and these images have served the community well. Besides continous use in CI/CD, these Guix container images are used to confirm reproducibility of the source tarball artifacts in the releases of Libtasn1 v4.20, InetUtils v2.6, Libidn2 v2.3.8, Libidn v1.43, SASL v2.2.2, Guile-GnuTLS v5.0.1, and OATH Toolkit v2.6.13. See how all those release announcements mention a Guix commit? That s the essential supply-chain information about the Guix build environment that allows the artifacts to be re-created. To make sure this is repeatable, the release tarball artifacts are re-created from source code every week in the verify-reproducible-artifacts project, that I wrote about earlier. Guix s time travelling feature make this sustainable to maintain, and hopefully will continue to be able to reproduce the exact same tarball artifacts for years to come. During the last year, unfortunately Guix was removed from Debian stable. My Guix container images were created from Debian with that Guix package. My setup continued to work since the old stage0 Debian+Guix containers were still available. Such a setup is not sustainable, as there will be bit-rot and we don t want to rely on old containers forever, which (after the removal of Guix in Debian) could not be re-produced any more. Let this be a reminder how user-empowering features such as Guix time-travelling is! I have reworked my Guix container image setup, and this post is an update on the current status of this effort. The first step was to re-engineer Debian container images with Guix, and I realized these were useful on their own, and warrant a separate project. A more narrowly scoped project makes will hopefully make it easier to keep them working. Now instead of apt-get install guix they use the official Guix guix-install.sh approach. Read more about that effort in the announcement of Debian with Guix. The second step was to reconsider my approach to generate the Guix images. The earlier design had several stages. First, Debian+Guix containers were created. Then from those containers, a pure Guix container was created. Finally, using the pure Guix container another pure Guix container was created. The idea behind that GCC-like approach was to get to reproducible images that were created from an image that had no Debian left on it. However, I never managed to finish this. Partially because I hadn t realized that every time you build a Guix container image from Guix, you effectively go back in time. When using Guix version X to build a container with Guix on it, it will not put Guix version X into the container but will put whatever version of Guix is available in its package archive, which will be an earlier version, such as version X-N. I had hope to overcome this somehow (running a guix pull in newly generated images may work), but never finished this before Guix was removed from Debian. So what could a better design look like? For efficiency, I had already started experimenting with generating the final images directly from the Debian+Guix images, and after reproducibility bugs were fixed I was able to get to reproducible images. However, I was still concerned that the Debian container could taint the process somehow, and was also concerned about the implied dependency on non-free software in Debian. I ve been using comparative rebuilds using similar distributions to confirm artifact reproducibility for my software projects, comparing builds on Trisquel 11 with Ubuntu 22.04, and AlmaLinux 9 with RockyLinux 9 for example. This works surprisingly well. Including one freedom-respecting distribution like Trisquel will detect if any non-free software has bearing on artifacts. Using different architectures, such as amd64 vs arm64 also help with deeper supply-chain concerns. My conclusion was that I wanted containers with the same Guix commit for both Trisquel and Ubuntu. Given the similarity with Debian, adapting and launching the Guix on Trisquel/Debian project was straight forward. So we now have Trisquel 11/12 and Ubuntu 22.04/24.04 images with the same Guix on them. Do you see where the debian-with-guix and guix-on-dpkg projects are leading to? We are now ready to look at the modernized Guix Container Images project. The tags are the same as before:
registry.gitlab.com/debdistutils/guix/container:latest
registry.gitlab.com/debdistutils/guix/container:slim
registry.gitlab.com/debdistutils/guix/container:extra
registry.gitlab.com/debdistutils/guix/container:gash
The method to create them is different. Now there is a build job that uses the earlier Guix+Trisquel container (for amd64) or Guix+Debian (for arm64, pending Trisquel arm64 containers). The build job create the final containers directly. Next a Ubuntu reproduce job is launched that runs the same commands, failing if it cannot generate the bit-by-bit identical container. Then single-arch images are tested (installing/building GNU hello and building libksba), and then pushed to the GitLab registry, adding multi-arch images in the process. Then the final multi-arch containers are tested by building Guile-GnuTLS and, on success, uploaded to the Docker Hub. How would you use them? A small way to start the container is like this:
jas@kaka:~$ podman run -it --privileged --entrypoint=/bin/sh registry.gitlab.com/debdistutils/guix/container:latest
sh-5.2# env HOME=/ guix describe # https://issues.guix.gnu.org/74949
  guix 21ce6b3
    repository URL: https://git.guix.gnu.org/guix.git
    branch: master
    commit: 21ce6b392ace4c4d22543abc41bd7c22596cd6d2
sh-5.2# 
The need for --entrypoint=/bin/sh is because Guix s pack command sets up the entry point differently than most other containers. This could probably be fixed if people want that, and there may be open bug reports about this. The need for --privileged is more problematic, but is discussed upstream. The above example works fine without it, but running anything more elaborate with guix-daemon installing packages will trigger a fatal error. Speaking of that, here is a snippet of commands that allow you to install Guix packages in the container.
cp -rL /gnu/store/*profile/etc/* /etc/
echo 'root:x:0:0:root:/:/bin/sh' > /etc/passwd
echo 'root:x:0:' > /etc/group
groupadd --system guixbuild
for i in $(seq -w 1 10); do useradd -g guixbuild -G guixbuild -d /var/empty -s $(command -v nologin) -c "Guix build user $i" --system guixbuilder$i; done
env LANG=C.UTF-8 guix-daemon --build-users-group=guixbuild &
guix archive --authorize < /share/guix/ci.guix.gnu.org.pub
guix archive --authorize < /share/guix/bordeaux.guix.gnu.org.pub
guix install hello
GUIX_PROFILE="/var/guix/profiles/per-user/root/guix-profile"
. "$GUIX_PROFILE/etc/profile"
hello
This could be simplified, but we chose to not hard-code in our containers because some of these are things that probably shouldn t be papered over but fixed properly somehow. In some execution environments, you may need to pass --disable-chroot to guix-daemon. To use the containers to build something in a GitLab pipeline, here is an example snippet:
test-amd64-latest-wget-configure-make-libksba:
  image: registry.gitlab.com/debdistutils/guix/container:latest
  before_script:
  - cp -rL /gnu/store/*profile/etc/* /etc/
  - echo 'root:x:0:0:root:/:/bin/sh' > /etc/passwd
  - echo 'root:x:0:' > /etc/group
  - groupadd --system guixbuild
  - for i in $(seq -w 1 10); do useradd -g guixbuild -G guixbuild -d /var/empty -s $(command -v nologin) -c "Guix build user $i" --system guixbuilder$i; done
  - export HOME=/
  - env LANG=C.UTF-8 guix-daemon --build-users-group=guixbuild &
  - guix archive --authorize < /share/guix/ci.guix.gnu.org.pub
  - guix archive --authorize < /share/guix/bordeaux.guix.gnu.org.pub
  - guix describe
  - guix install libgpg-error
  - GUIX_PROFILE="//.guix-profile"
  - . "$GUIX_PROFILE/etc/profile"
  script:
  - wget https://www.gnupg.org/ftp/gcrypt/libksba/libksba-1.6.7.tar.bz2
  - tar xfa libksba-1.6.7.tar.bz2
  - cd libksba-1.6.7
  - ./configure
  - make V=1
  - make check VERBOSE=t V=1
More help on the project page for the Guix Container Images. That s it for tonight folks, and remember, Happy Hacking!

4 December 2025

Colin Watson: Free software activity in November 2025

My Debian contributions this month were all sponsored by Freexian. I had a bit less time than usual, because Freexian collaborators gathered in Marseille this month for our yearly sprint, doing some planning for next year. You can also support my work directly via Liberapay or GitHub Sponsors. OpenSSH I began preparing for the second stage of the GSS-API key exchange package split (some details have changed since that message). It seems that we ll need to wait until Ubuntu 26.04 LTS has been released, but that s close enough that it s worth making sure we re ready. This month I just did some packaging cleanups that would otherwise have been annoying to copy, such as removing support for direct upgrades from pre-bookworm. I m considering some other package rearrangements to make the split easier to manage, but haven t made any decisions here yet. This also led me to start on a long-overdue bug triage pass, mainly consisting of applying usertags to lots of our open bugs to sort them by which program they apply to, and also closing a few that have been fixed, since some bugs will eventually need to be reassigned to GSS-API packages and it would be helpful to make them easier to find. At the time of writing, about 30% of the bug list remains to be categorized this way. Python packaging I upgraded these packages to new upstream versions: I packaged django-pgtransaction and backported it to trixie, since we plan to use it in Debusine; and I adopted python-certifi for the Python team. I fixed or helped to fix several other build/test failures: I fixed a couple of other bugs: Other bits and pieces Code reviews

1 December 2025

Russ Allbery: Review: Forever and a Day

Review: Forever and a Day, by Haley Cass
Series: Those Who Wait #1.5
Publisher: Haley Cass
Copyright: 2020
ISBN: 979-8-5902-5966-3
Format: Kindle
Pages: 101
Forever and a Day is a coda to Haley Cass's self-published sapphic romance novel Those Who Wait. There is no point in reading it unless you have already read and enjoyed the full book and wanted more of a denouement. Given that Those Who Wait is a romance novel, it is definitionally not a spoiler to reveal that Sutton and Charlotte ended up together. This novella is seven scenes sketching out the next few years of their lives, interspersed with press clippings and social media commentary. These tie up loose ends, give the characters a bit more time together, throw in one more conflict and resolution, add one more sex scene, and stick a few exclamation points after the happily ever after. I am the sort of person who likes long denouements in stories, so I'm the target audience for this sort of sequel that's essentially additional chapters to the book. (The funniest version of this I've read is Jacqueline Carey's Saints Astray.) They are usually not great literature, since there are good reasons for not including these chapters in the book. That is exactly what this is: a few more chapters of the characters being happy, entirely forgettable, and of interest only to people who want that. Cass does try to introduce a bit of a plot via some light family conflict, which was sweet and mostly worked, and some conflict over having children, which was very stereotyped and which I did not enjoy as much. I thought the earlier chapters of this novella were the stronger ones, although I do have to give the characters credit in the later chapters for working through conflict in a mature and fairly reasonable way. It does help, though, when the conflict is entirely resolved by one character being right and the other character being happily wrong. That's character conflict on easy mode. I was happy to see that Sutton got a career, although as in the novel I wish Cass had put some more effort into describing Sutton's efforts in building that career. The details are maddeningly vague, which admittedly matches the maddeningly vague description of Charlotte's politics but which left me unsatisfied. Charlotte's political career continues to be pure wish fulfillment in the most utterly superficial and trivialized way, and it bothered me even more in the novella than it did in the novel. We still have absolutely no idea what she stands for, what she wants to accomplish, and why anyone would vote for her, and yet we get endless soft-focus paeans to how wonderful she will be for the country. Her opponents are similarly vague to the point that the stereotypes Cass uses to signal their inferiority to Charlotte are a little suspect. I'm more critical of this in 2025 than I would have been in 2015 because the last ten years have made clear the amount of damage an absolute refusal to stand for anything except hazy bromides causes, and I probably shouldn't be this annoyed that Cass chose to vaguely gesture towards progressive liberalism without muddying her romance denouement with a concrete political debate. But, just, gah. I found the last chapter intensely annoying, in part because the narrative of that chapter was too cliched and trite to sufficiently distract me from the bad taste of the cotton-candy politics. Other than that, this was minor, sweet, and forgettable. If you want another few chapters of an already long novel, this delivers exactly what you would expect. If the novel was plenty, nothing about this novella is going to change your mind and you can safely skip it. I really liked the scene between Charlotte and Sutton's mom, though, and I'm glad I read the novella just for that. Rating: 6 out of 10

19 November 2025

Dirk Eddelbuettel: #055: More Frequent r2u Updates

Welcome to post 55 in the R4 series. r2u brings CRAN packages for R to Ubuntu. We mentioned it in the R4 series within the last year in posts #54 about faster CI, #48 about the r2u keynote at U Mons, #47 reviewing r2u it at its third birthday, #46 about adding arm64 support, and #44 about the r2u for mlops talk. Today brings news of an important (internal) update. Following both the arm64 builds as well as the last bi-annual BioConductor package update (and the extension of BioConductor coverage to arm64), more and more of our build setup became automated at GitHub. This has now been unified. We dispatch builds for amd64 packages for jammy (22.04) and noble (24.04) (as well as for the arm64 binaries for noble ) from the central build repository and enjoy the highly parallel build of the up to fourty available GitHub Runners. In the process we also switched fully to source builds. In the past, we had relied on p3m.dev (formerly known as ppm and rspm) using its binaries. These so-called naked binaries are what R produces when called as R CMD INSTALL --build. They are portable with the same build architecture and release, but do not carry packaging information. Now, when a Debian or Ubuntu .deb binary is built, the same step of R CMD INSTALL --build happens. So our earlier insight was to skip the compilation step, use the p3m binary, and then wrap the remainder of a complete package around it. Which includes the all-important dependency information for both the R package relations (from hard Depends / Imports / LinkingTo or soft Suggests declarations) as well as the shared library dependency resolution we can do when building for a Linux distribution. That served us well, and we remain really grateful for the p3m.dev build service. But it also meant were dependending on the clock and cadence of p3m.dev. Which was not really a problem when it ran reliably daily, and early too, included weekends, and showed a timestamp of last updates. By now it is a bit more erratic, frequently late, skips weekends more regularly and long stopped showing when it was last updated. Late afternoon releases reflecting the CRAN updates ending one and half-days earlier is still good, it s just not all that current. Plus there was always the very opaque occurrencem where maybe one in 50 packages or so would not even be provided as a binary so we had to build it anyway the fallback always existing, and was used for both BioConductor (no binaries) and arm64 (no binaries at first, this now changed). So now we just build packages the standard way, albeit as GitHub Actions. In doing so we can ignore p3m.dev, and rather follow the CRAN clock and cadence (as for example CRANberries does), and can update several times a day. For example early this morning (Central time) we ran update for the then-new 28 source packages resulting in 28 jammy and 36 noble binary packages; right now in mid-afternoon we are running another build for 37 source packages resuling in 37 jammy and 47 noble packages. (Packages without a src/ directory and hence no compilation can be used across amd64 and arm64; those that do have src/ are rebuilt for arm64 hence the different sets of jammy and noble packages as only the latter has arm64 now.) This gets us packages from this morning into r2u which p3m.dev should have by tomorrow afternoon or so. And with that r2u remains Fast. Easy. Reliable. Pick all three! and also a little more predictable and current in its delivery. What s not to like?

This post by Dirk Eddelbuettel originated on his Thinking inside the box blog. If you like this or other open-source work I do, you can now sponsor me at GitHub.

12 November 2025

Dirk Eddelbuettel: digest 0.6.38 on CRAN: Several Updates

Release 0.6.38 of the digest package arrived at CRAN today and has also been uploaded to Debian. digest creates hash digests of arbitrary R objects. It can use a number different hashing algorithms (md5, sha-1, sha-256, sha-512, crc32, xxhash32, xxhash64, murmur32, spookyhash, blake3,crc32c, xxh3_64 and xxh3_128), and enables easy comparison of (potentially large and nested) R language objects as it relies on the native serialization in R. It is a mature and widely-used package (with 86.8 million downloads just on the partial cloud mirrors of CRAN which keep logs) as many tasks may involve caching of objects for which it provides convenient general-purpose hash key generation to quickly identify the various objects. This release, the first in about fifteen months, updates a number of items. Carl Pearson suggested, and lead, a cleanup of the C API in order to make more of the functionality accessibly at the source level of other packages. This is ongoing / not yet complete but lead to several nice internal cleanups, mostly done by Carl. Several typos were corrected, mostly in Rd files, by Bill Denney, who also improved the test coverage statistics. Thierry Onkelinx and I improved the sha1 functionality. Sergey Fedorov improved an endianness check that matter for his work on PowerPC. I updated the blake3 hasher, expanded the set of ORCID IDs for listed contributors, updated the continuous integration setup, reinstated code coverage reports, refreshed / converted the documentation site setup, and made general updates and edits to the documentation. The release was prepared a week ago, and held up a few days until an affected package was updated: it requested raw returns where none were previously delivered (for xxhash64) but now are so it needed to not reqest them. It was then seen that another package made some assumptions about our DESCRIPTION file; this has been addressed at its end via a pull request we submitted (that remains unmerged). This delayed processing at CRAN for a few days and as it happens, hours after the packages was updated at CRAN today I heard from the ever-so-tireless Brian Ripley about an SAN issue on arm64 only. He kindly provided a fix; it needed a cast. Checking this on amd64 against our Rocker-based ASAN and UBSAN containers (where is remains impossible to replicate, this issue is apparently known for some arm64 issues) another micro-issue (of a missing final argument NULL missing in one .Call()) was detected. I plan to fix both of these in a follow-up release next week. My CRANberries provides a summary of changes to the previous version. For questions or comments use the issue tracker off the GitHub repo. For documentation (including the changelog) see the documentation site. If you like this or other open-source work I do, you can now sponsor me at GitHub.

This post by Dirk Eddelbuettel originated on his Thinking inside the box blog. Please report excessive re-aggregation in third-party for-profit settings.

9 November 2025

Colin Watson: Free software activity in October 2025

About 95% of my Debian contributions this month were sponsored by Freexian. You can also support my work directly via Liberapay or GitHub Sponsors. OpenSSH OpenSSH upstream released 10.1p1 this month, so I upgraded to that. In the process, I reverted a Debian patch that changed IP quality-of-service defaults, which made sense at the time but has since been reworked upstream anyway, so it makes sense to find out whether we still have similar problems. So far I haven t heard anything bad in this area. 10.1p1 caused a regression in the ssh-agent-filter package s tests, which I bisected and chased up with upstream. 10.1p1 also had a few other user-visible regressions (#1117574, #1117594, #1117638, #1117720); I upgraded to 10.2p1 which fixed some of these, and contributed some upstream debugging help to clear up the rest. While I was there, I also fixed ssh-session-cleanup: fails due to wrong $ssh_session_pattern in our packaging. Finally, I got all this into trixie-backports, which I intend to keep up to date throughout the forky development cycle. Python packaging For some time, ansible-core has had occasional autopkgtest failures that usually go away before anyone has a chance to look into them properly. I ran into these via openssh recently and decided to track them down. It turns out that they only happened when the libpython3.13-stdlib package had different versions in testing and unstable, because an integration test setup script made a change that would be reverted if that package was ever upgraded in the testbed, and one of the integration tests accidentally failed to disable system apt sources comprehensively enough while testing the behaviour of the ansible.builtin.apt module. I fixed this in Debian and contributed the relevant part upstream. We ve started working on enabling Python 3.14 as a supported version in Debian. I fixed or helped to fix a number of packages for this: I upgraded these packages to new upstream versions: I packaged python-blockbuster and python-pytokens, needed as new dependencies of various other packages. Santiago Vila filed a batch of bugs about packages that fail to build when using the nocheck build profile, and I fixed several of these (generally just a matter of adjusting build-dependencies): I helped out with the scikit-learn 1.7 transition: I fixed or helped to fix several other build/test failures: I fixed some other bugs: I investigated a python-py build failure, which turned out to have been fixed in Python 3.13.9. I adopted zope.hookable and zope.location for the Python team. Following an IRC question, I ported linux-gpib-user to pybuild-plugin-pyproject, and added tests to make sure the resulting binary package layout is correct. Rust packaging Another Pydantic upgrade meant I had to upgrade a corresponding stack of Rust packages to new upstream versions: I also upgraded rust-archery and rust-rpds. Other bits and pieces I fixed a few bugs in other packages I maintain: I investigated a malware report against tini, which I think we can prove to be a false positive (at least under the reasonable assumption that there isn t malware hiding in libgcc or glibc). Yay for reproducible builds! I noticed and fixed a small UI deficiency in debbugs, making the checkboxes under Misc options on package pages easier to hit. This is merged but we haven t yet deployed it. I notced and fixed a typo in the Being kind to porters section of the Debian Developer s Reference. Code reviews

Russell Coker: AMD Video Driver Issues

I have had some graphics hangs on my HP z640 workstation which seem to always be after about 4 days of uptime, in one instance running Debian kernel 6.16.12+deb14+1 I got the following kernel error:
kernel: amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: [drm] *ERROR* [CRTC:58:crtc-0] flip_done timed out
Then I got the following errors from kwin_wayland:
kwin_wayland_wrapper[19598]: kwin_wayland_drm: Pageflip timed out! This is a bug in the amdgpu kernel driver
kwin_wayland_wrapper[19598]: kwin_wayland_drm: Please report this at https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/drm/amd/-/issues
kwin_wayland_wrapper[19598]: kwin_wayland_drm: With the output of 'sudo dmesg' and 'journalctl --user-unit plasma-kwin_wayland --boot 0'
In another instance running Debian kernel 6.12.48+deb13 I got the kernel errors at the bottom of the post (not in the RSS feed). A google result suggested putting the following on the kernel command line which has the downside of increasing the idle power, but given that it s a low power GPU (that I selected when I was using a system without a PCIe power cable) a bit of extra power use shouldn t matter much. But it didn t seem to change anything.
amdgpu.runpm=0 amdgpu.dcdebugmask=0x10
I had tried out the Debian/Unstable kernel 6.16.12-2 which didn t work with my USB speakers and had problems with the HDMI sound through my monitor but still had AMD GPU issues. This all seemed to start with the PCIe errors being reported on this system [1]. So I m now wondering if the PCIe errors were from the GPU not the socket/motherboard. The GPU in question is a Radeon RX560 4G which cost $246.75 back in about 2021 [2]. I could buy a new one of those on ebay for $149 or one of the faster AMD cards like Radeon RX570 that are around the same price. I probably have a Radeon R7 260X in my collection of spare parts that would do the job too (2G of VRAM is more than sufficient for my desktop computing needs). Any suggestions on how I should proceed from here?
[419976.222647] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu: GPU fault detected: 146 0x0138482c
[419976.222659] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu:  for process mpv pid 141328 thread vo pid 141346
[419976.222662] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu:   VM_CONTEXT1_PROTECTION_FAULT_ADDR   0x00101427
[419976.222664] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu:   VM_CONTEXT1_PROTECTION_FAULT_STATUS 0x0404802C
[419976.222666] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu: VM fault (0x2c, vmid 2, pasid 32810) at page 1053735, read from 'TC0' (0x54433000) (72)
[419986.245051] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu: Dumping IP State
[419986.245061] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu: Dumping IP State Completed
[419986.255152] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu: ring gfx timeout, signaled seq=11839646, emitted seq=11839648
[419986.255158] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu: Process information: process mpv pid 141328 thread vo pid 141346
[419986.255209] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu: GPU reset begin!
[419986.503030] amdgpu: cp is busy, skip halt cp
[419986.658198] amdgpu: rlc is busy, skip halt rlc
[419986.659270] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu: BACO reset
[419986.884672] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu: GPU reset succeeded, trying to resume
[419986.885398] [drm] PCIE GART of 256M enabled (table at 0x000000F402000000).
[419986.885413] [drm] VRAM is lost due to GPU reset!
[419987.021051] [drm] UVD and UVD ENC initialized successfully.
[419987.120999] [drm] VCE initialized successfully.
[419987.193302] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu: GPU reset(1) succeeded!
[419987.194117] [drm:amdgpu_cs_ioctl [amdgpu]] *ERROR* Failed to initialize parser -125!
[419997.509120] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu: Dumping IP State
[419997.509131] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu: Dumping IP State Completed
[419997.519145] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu: ring gfx timeout, signaled seq=11839650, emitted seq=11839652
[419997.519152] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu: Process information: process kwin_wayland pid 3577 thread kwin_wayla:cs0 pid 3615
[419997.519158] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu: GPU reset begin!
[419997.772966] amdgpu: cp is busy, skip halt cp
[419997.928138] amdgpu: rlc is busy, skip halt rlc
[419997.929165] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu: BACO reset
[419998.164705] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu: GPU reset succeeded, trying to resume
[419998.165412] [drm] PCIE GART of 256M enabled (table at 0x000000F402000000).
[419998.165427] [drm] VRAM is lost due to GPU reset!
[419998.311054] [drm] UVD and UVD ENC initialized successfully.
[419998.411006] [drm] VCE initialized successfully.
[419998.476272] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu: GPU reset(2) succeeded!
[419998.476363] [drm:amdgpu_cs_ioctl [amdgpu]] *ERROR* Failed to initialize parser -125!
[420008.773202] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu: Dumping IP State
[420008.773212] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu: Dumping IP State Completed
[420008.773240] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu: ring gfx timeout, but soft recovered
=== the above sequence of 3 repeated many times (narrator's voice "but it did not recover") ===
[420130.933612] rfkill: input handler disabled
[420135.594195] rfkill: input handler enabled
[420145.734076] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu: Dumping IP State
[420145.734085] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu: Dumping IP State Completed
[420145.744099] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu: ring gfx timeout, signaled seq=11839790, emitted seq=11839792
[420145.744105] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu: Process information: process kwin_wayland pid 3577 thread kwin_wayla:cs0 pid 3615
[420145.744111] amdgpu 0000:02:00.0: amdgpu: GPU reset begin!
There were more kernel messages, but they were just repeats and after a certain stage there probably isn t any more data worth getting.

5 November 2025

Reproducible Builds: Reproducible Builds in October 2025

Welcome to the October 2025 report from the Reproducible Builds project! Welcome to the very latest report from the Reproducible Builds project. Our monthly reports outline what we ve been up to over the past month, and highlight items of news from elsewhere in the increasingly-important area of software supply-chain security. As ever, if you are interested in contributing to the Reproducible Builds project, please see the Contribute page on our website. In this report:

  1. Farewell from the Reproducible Builds Summit 2025
  2. Google s Play Store breaks reproducible builds for Signal
  3. Mailing list updates
  4. The Original Sin of Computing that no one can fix
  5. Reproducible Builds at the Transparency.dev summit
  6. Supply Chain Security for Go
  7. Three new academic papers published
  8. Distribution work
  9. Upstream patches
  10. Website updates
  11. Tool development

Farewell from the Reproducible Builds Summit 2025 Thank you to everyone who joined us at the Reproducible Builds Summit in Vienna, Austria! We were thrilled to host the eighth edition of this exciting event, following the success of previous summits in various iconic locations around the world, including Venice, Marrakesh, Paris, Berlin, Hamburg and Athens. During this event, participants had the opportunity to engage in discussions, establish connections and exchange ideas to drive progress in this vital field. Our aim was to create an inclusive space that fosters collaboration, innovation and problem-solving. The agenda of the three main days is available online however, some working sessions may still lack notes at time of publication. One tangible outcome of the summit is that Johannes Starosta finished their rebuilderd tutorial, which is now available online and Johannes is actively seeking feedback.

Google s Play Store breaks reproducible builds for Signal On the issue tracker for the popular Signal messenger app, developer Greyson Parrelli reports that updates to the Google Play store have, in effect, broken reproducible builds:
The most recent issues have to do with changes to the APKs that are made by the Play Store. Specifically, they add some attributes to some .xml files around languages are resources, which is not unexpected because of how the whole bundle system works. This is trickier to resolve, because unlike current expected differences (like signing information), we can t just exclude a whole file from the comparison. We have to take a more nuanced look at the diff. I ve been hesitant to do that because it ll complicate our currently-very-readable comparison script, but I don t think there s any other reasonable option here.
The full thread with additional context is available on GitHub.

Mailing list updates On our mailing list this month:
  • kpcyrd forwarded a fascinating tidbit regarding so-called ninja and samurai build ordering, that uses data structures in which the pointer values returned from malloc are used to determine some order of execution.
  • Arnout Engelen, Justin Cappos, Ludovic Court s and kpcyrd continued a conversation started in September regarding the Minimum Elements for a Software Bill of Materials . (Full thread)
  • Felix Moessbauer of Siemens posted to the list reporting that he had recently stumbled upon a couple of Debian source packages on the snapshot mirrors that are listed multiple times (same name and version), but each time with a different checksum . The thread, which Felix titled, Debian: what precisely identifies a source package is about precisely that what can be axiomatically relied upon by consumers of the Debian archives, as well as indicating an issue where we can t exactly say which packages were used during build time (even when having the .buildinfo files).
  • Luca DiMaio posted to the list announcing the release of xfsprogs 6.17.0 which specifically includes a commit that implements the functionality to populate a newly created XFS filesystem directly from an existing directory structure which makes it easier to create populated filesystems without having to mount them [and thus is] particularly useful for reproducible builds . Luca asked the list how they might contribute to the docs of the System images page.

The Original Sin of Computing that no one can fix Popular YouTuber @laurewired published a video this month with an engaging take on the Trusting Trust problem. Titled The Original Sin of Computing that no one can fix, the video touches on David A. Wheeler s Diverse Double-Compiling dissertation. GNU developer Janneke Nieuwenhuizen followed-up with an email (additionally sent to our mailing list) as well, underscoring that GNU Mes s current solution [to this issue] uses ancient softwares in its bootstrap path, such as gcc-2.95.3 and glibc-2.2.5 . (According to Colby Russell, the GNU Mes bootstrapping sequence is shown at 18m54s in the video.)

Reproducible Builds at the Transparency.dev summit Holger Levsen gave a talk at this year s Transparency.dev summit in Gothenburg, Sweden, outlining the achievements of the Reproducible Builds project in the last 12 years, covering both upstream developments as well as some distribution-specific details. As mentioned on the talk s page, Holger s presentation concluded with an outlook into the future and an invitation to collaborate to bring transparency logs into Reproducible Builds projects . The slides of the talk are available, although a video has yet to be released. Nevertheless, as a result of the discussions at Transparency.dev there is a new page on the Debian wiki with the aim of describing a potential transparency log setup for Debian.

Supply Chain Security for Go Andrew Ayer has setup a new service at sourcespotter.com that aims to monitor the supply chain security for Go releases. It consists of four separate trackers:
  1. A tool to verify that the Go Module Mirror and Checksum Database is behaving honestly and has not presented inconsistent information to clients.
  2. A module monitor that records every module version served by the Go Module Mirror and Checksum Database, allowing you to monitor for unexpected versions of your modules.
  3. A tool to verifies that the Go toolchains published in the Go Module Mirror can be reproduced from source code, making it difficult to hide backdoors in the binaries downloaded by the go command.
  4. A telemetry config tracker that tracks the names of telemetry counters uploaded by the Go toolchain, to ensure that Go telemetry is not violating users privacy.
As the homepage of the service mentions, the trackers are free software and do not rely on Google infrastructure.

Three new academic papers published Julien Malka of the Institut Polytechnique de Paris published an exciting paper this month on How NixOS could have detected the XZ supply-chain attack for the benefit of all thanks to reproducible-builds. Julien outlines his paper as follows:
In March 2024, a sophisticated backdoor was discovered in xz, a core compression library in Linux distributions, covertly inserted over three years by a malicious maintainer, Jia Tan. The attack, which enabled remote code execution via ssh, was only uncovered by chance when Andres Freund investigated a minor performance issue. This incident highlights the vulnerability of the open-source supply chain and the effort attackers are willing to invest in gaining trust and access. In this article, I analyze the backdoor s mechanics and explore how bitwise build reproducibility could have helped detect it.
A PDF of the paper is available online.
Iy n M ndez Veiga and Esther H nggi (of the Lucerne University of Applied Sciences and Arts and ETH Zurich) published a paper this month on the topic of Reproducible Builds for Quantum Computing. The abstract of their paper mentions the following:
Although quantum computing is a rapidly evolving field of research, it can already benefit from adopting reproducible builds. This paper aims to bridge the gap between the quantum computing and reproducible builds communities. We propose a generalization of the definition of reproducible builds in the quantum setting, motivated by two threat models: one targeting the confidentiality of end users data during circuit preparation and submission to a quantum computer, and another compromising the integrity of quantum computation results. This work presents three examples that show how classical information can be hidden in transpiled quantum circuits, and two cases illustrating how even minimal modifications to these circuits can lead to incorrect quantum computation results.
A full PDF of their paper is available.
Congratulations to Georg Kofler who submitted their Master s thesis for the Johannes Kepler University of Linz, Austria on the topic of Reproducible builds of E2EE-messengers for Android using Nix hermetic builds:
The thesis focuses on providing a reproducible build process for two open-source E2EE messaging applications: Signal and Wire. The motivation to ensure reproducibility and thereby the integrity of E2EE messaging applications stems from their central role as essential tools for modern digital privacy. These applications provide confidentiality for private and sensitive communications, and their compromise could undermine encryption mechanisms, potentially leaking sensitive data to third parties.
A full PDF of their thesis is available online.
Shawkot Hossain of Aalto University, Finland has also submitted their Master s thesis on the The Role of SBOM in Modern Development with a focus on the extant tooling:
Currently, there are numerous solutions and techniques available in the market to tackle supply chain security, and all claim to be the best solution. This thesis delves deeper by implementing those solutions and evaluates them for better understanding. Some of the tools that this thesis implemented are Syft, Trivy, Grype, FOSSA, dependency-check, and Gemnasium. Software dependencies are generated in a Software Bill of Materials (SBOM) format by using these open-source tools, and the corresponding results have been analyzed. Among these tools, Syft and Trivy outperform others as they provide relevant and accurate information on software dependencies.
A PDF of the thesis is also available.

Distribution work Michael Plura published an interesting article on Heise.de on the topic of Trust is good, reproducibility is better:
In the wake of growing supply chain attacks, the FreeBSD developers are relying on a transparent build concept in the form of Zero-Trust Builds. The approach builds on the established Reproducible Builds, where binary files can be rebuilt bit-for-bit from the published source code. While reproducible builds primarily ensure verifiability, the zero-trust model goes a step further and removes trust from the build process itself. No single server, maintainer, or compiler can be considered more than potentially trustworthy.
The article mentions that this goal has now been achieved with a slight delay and can be used in the current development branch for FreeBSD 15 .
In Debian this month, 7 reviews of Debian packages were added, 5 were updated and 11 were removed this month adding to our knowledge about identified issues. For the Debian CI tests Holger fixed #786644 and set nocheck in DEB_BUILD_OPTIONS for the 2nd build..
Lastly, Bernhard M. Wiedemann posted another openSUSE monthly update for their work there.

Upstream patches The Reproducible Builds project detects, dissects and attempts to fix as many currently-unreproducible packages as possible. We endeavour to send all of our patches upstream where appropriate. This month, we wrote a large number of such patches, including:

Website updates Once again, there were a number of improvements made to our website this month including: In addition, a number of contributors added a series of notes from our recent summit to the website, including Alexander Couzens [ ], Robin Candau [ ][ ][ ][ ][ ][ ][ ][ ][ ] and kpcyrd [ ].

Tool development diffoscope version 307 was uploaded to Debian unstable by Chris Lamb, who made a number of changes including fixing compatibility with LLVM version 21 [ ], an attempt to automatically attempt to deploy to PyPI by liaising with the PyPI developers/maintainers (with this experimental feature). [ ] In addition, Vagrant Cascadian updated diffoscope in GNU Guix to version 307.

Finally, if you are interested in contributing to the Reproducible Builds project, please visit our Contribute page on our website. However, you can get in touch with us via:

28 October 2025

Russ Allbery: Review: Those Who Wait

Review: Those Who Wait, by Haley Cass
Publisher: Haley Cass
Copyright: 2020
ISBN: 979-8-9884929-1-7
Format: Kindle
Pages: 556
Those Who Wait is a stand-alone self-published sapphic romance novel. Given the lack of connection between political figures named in this book and our reality, it's also technically an alternate history, but it will be entirely unsatisfying to anyone who reads it in that genre. Sutton Spencer is an English grad student in New York City. As the story opens, she has recently realized that she's bisexual rather than straight. She certainly has not done anything about that revelation; the very thought makes her blush. Her friend and roommate Regan, not known for either her patience or her impulse control, decides to force the issue by stealing Sutton's phone, creating a profile on a lesbian dating app, and messaging the first woman Sutton admits being attracted to. Charlotte Thompson is a highly ambitious politician, current deputy mayor of New York City for health and human services, and granddaughter of the first female president of the United States. She fully intends to become president of the United States herself. The next step on that path is an open special election for a seat in the House of Representatives. With her family political connections and the firm support of the mayor of New York City (who is also dating her brother), she thinks she has an excellent shot of winning. Charlotte is also a lesbian, something she's known since she was a teenager and which still poses serious problems for a political career. She is therefore out to her family and a few close friends, but otherwise in the closet. Compared to her political ambitions, Charlotte considers her love life almost irrelevant, and therefore has a strict policy of limiting herself to anonymous one-night stands arranged on dating apps. Even that is about to become impossible given her upcoming campaign, but she indulges in one last glance at SapphicSpark before she deletes her account. Sutton is as far as possible from the sort of person who does one-night stands, which is a shame as far as Charlotte is concerned. It would have been a fun last night out. Despite that, both of them find the other unexpectedly enjoyable to chat with. (There are a lot of text message bubbles in this book.) This is when Sutton has her brilliant idea: Charlotte is charming, experienced, and also kind and understanding of Sutton's anxiety, at least in app messages. Maybe Charlotte can be her mentor? Tell her how to approach women, give her some guidance, point her in the right directions. Given the genre, you can guess how this (eventually) turns out. I'm going to say a lot of good things about this book, so let me get the complaints over with first. As you might guess from that introduction, Charlotte's political career and the danger of being outed are central to this story. This is a bit unfortunate because you should not, under any circumstances, attempt to think deeply about the politics in this book. In 550 pages, Charlotte does not mention or expound a single meaningful political position. You come away from this book as ignorant about what Charlotte wants to accomplish as a politician as you entered. Apparently she wants to be president because her grandmother was president and she thinks she'd be good at it. The closest the story comes to a position is something unbelievably vague about homeless services and Charlotte's internal assertion that she wants to help people and make real change. There are even transcripts of media interviews, later in the book, and they somehow manage to be more vacuous than US political talk shows, which is saying something. I also can't remember a single mention of fundraising anywhere in this book, which in US politics is absurd (although I will be generous and say this is due to Cass's alternate history). I assume this was a deliberate choice and Cass didn't want politics to distract from the romance, but as someone with a lot of opinions about concrete political issues, the resulting vague soft-liberal squishiness was actively off-putting. In an actual politician, this would be an entire clothesline of red flags. Thankfully, it's ignorable for the same reason; this is so obviously not the focus of the book that one can mostly perform the same sort of mental trick that one does when ignoring the backdrop in a cheap theater. My second complaint is that I don't know what Sutton does outside of the romance. Yes, she's an English grad student, and she does some grading and some vaguely-described work and is later referred to a prestigious internship, but this is as devoid of detail as Charlotte's political positions. It's not quite as jarring because Cass does eventually show Sutton helping concretely with her mother's work (about which I have some other issues that I won't get into), but it deprives Sutton of an opportunity to be visibly expert in something. The romance setup casts Charlotte as the experienced one to Sutton's naivete, and I think it would have been a better balance to give Sutton something concrete and tangible that she was clearly better at than Charlotte. Those complaints aside, I quite enjoyed this. It was a recommendation from the same BookTuber who recommended Delilah Green Doesn't Care, so her recommendations are quickly accumulating more weight. The chemistry between Sutton and Charlotte is quite believable; the dialogue sparkles, the descriptions of the subtle cues they pick up from each other are excellent, and it's just fun to read about how they navigate a whole lot of small (and sometimes large) misunderstandings and mismatches in personality and world view. Normally, misunderstandings are my least favorite part of a romance novel, but Sutton and Charlotte come from such different perspectives that their misunderstandings feel more justified than is typical. The characters are also fairly mature about working through them: Main characters who track the other character down and insist on talking when something happens they don't understand! Can you imagine! Only with the third-act breakup is the reader dragged through multiple chapters of both characters being miserable, and while I also usually hate third-act breakups, this one is so obviously coming and so clearly advertised from the initial setup that I couldn't really be mad. I did wish the payoff make-up scene at the end of the book had a bit more oomph, though; I thought Sutton's side of it didn't have quite the emotional catharsis that it could have had. I particularly enjoyed the reasons why the two characters fall in love, and how different they are. Charlotte is delighted by Sutton because she's awkward and shy but also straightforward and frequently surprisingly blunt, which fits perfectly with how much Charlotte is otherwise living in a world of polished politicians in constant control of their personas. Sutton's perspective is more physical, but the part I liked was the way that she treats Charlotte like a puzzle. Rather than trying to change how Charlotte expresses herself, she instead discovers that she's remarkably good at reading Charlotte if she trusts her instincts. There was something about Sutton's growing perceptiveness that I found quietly delightful. It's the sort of non-sexual intimacy that often gets lost among the big emotions in romance novels. The supporting cast was also great. Both characters have deep support networks of friends and family who are unambiguously on their side. Regan is pure chaos, and I would not be friends with her, but Cass shows her deep loyalty in a way that makes her dynamic with Sutton make sense. Both characters have thoughtful and loving families who support them but don't make decisions for them, which is a nice change of pace from the usually more mixed family situations of romance novel protagonists. There's a lot of emotional turbulence in the main relationship, and I think that only worked for me because of how rock-solid and kind the supporting cast is. This is, as you might guess from the title, a very slow burn, although the slow burn is for the emotional relationship rather than the physical one (for reasons that would be spoilers). As usual, I have no calibration for spiciness level, but I'd say that this was roughly on par with the later books in the Bright Falls series. If you know something about politics (or political history) and try to take that part of this book seriously, it will drive you to drink, but if you can put that aside and can deal with misunderstandings and emotional turmoil, this was both fun and satisfying. I liked both of the characters, I liked the timing of the alternating viewpoints, and I believed in the relationship and chemistry, as improbable and chaotic as some of the setup was. It's not the greatest thing I ever read, and I wish the ending was a smidgen stronger, but it was an enjoyable way to spend a few reading days. Recommended. Rating: 7 out of 10

27 October 2025

Russ Allbery: Review: On Vicious Worlds

Review: On Vicious Worlds, by Bethany Jacobs
Series: Kindom Trilogy #2
Publisher: Orbit
Copyright: October 2024
ISBN: 0-316-46362-0
Format: Kindle
Pages: 444
On Vicious Worlds is a science fiction thriller with bits of cyberpunk and a direct sequel to These Burning Stars. This is one of those series where each book has massive spoilers for the previous book and builds on characters and situations from that book. I would not read it out of order. It is Bethany Jacobs's second novel. Whooboy, how to review this without spoilers. There are so many major twists in the first book with lingering consequences that it's nearly impossible. I said at the end of my review of These Burning Stars that I was impressed with the ending for reasons that I can't reveal. One thread of this book follows the aftermath: What do you do after the plan? If you have honed yourself for one purpose, can you repurpose yourself? The other thread of the book is a murder mystery. The protectors of the community are being picked off, one by one. The culprit might be a hacker so good that they are causing Jun, the expert hacker of the first book, serious problems. Meanwhile, the political fault lines of the community are cracking open under pressure, and the leaders are untested, exhausted, and navigating difficult emotional terrain. These two story threads alternate, and interspersed are yet more flashbacks. As with the first book, the flashbacks fill in the backstory of Chono and and Esek. This time, though, we get Six's viewpoint. The good news is that On Vicious Worlds tones down the sociopathy considerably without letting up on the political twists. This is the book where Chono comes into her own. She has much more freedom of action, despite being at the center of complicated and cut-throat politics, and I thoroughly enjoyed her principled solidity. She gets a chance to transcend her previous role as an abuse victim, and it's worth the wait. The bad news is that this is very much a middle book of a trilogy. While there are a lot of bloody battles, emotional drama, political betrayals, and plot twists, the series plot has not advanced much by the end of the book. I would not say the characters were left in the same position they started the character development is real and the perils have changed but neither would I say that any of the open questions from These Burning Stars have resolved. The last book I read used science-fiction world-building to tell a story about moral philosophy that was somewhat less drama-filled than one might have expected. That is so not the case here. On Vicious Worlds is, if anything, even more dramatic than the first book of the series. In Chono's thread, the slow burn attempt to understand Six's motives has been replaced with almost non-stop melodrama, full of betrayals, reversals, risky attempts, and emotional roller coasters. Jun's part of the story is a bit more sedate at first, but there too the interpersonal drama setting is headed towards 10. This is the novel equivalent of an action movie. Jun, and her part of the story, are fine. I like the new viewpoint character, I find their system of governance somewhat interesting (although highly optimized for small groups), and I think the climax worked. But I'm invested in this series for Chono and Six. Both of them, but particularly Six, are absurdly over the top, ten people's worth of drama stuffed into one character, unable to communicate in anything less than dramatic gestures and absurd plans, but I find them magnetically fascinating. I'm not sure if written characters can have charisma, but if so, they have it. I liked this entry in the series, but then I also liked the first book. It's trauma-filled and dramatic and involved a bit too much bloody maiming for my tastes, but this whole series is about revolutions and what happens when you decide to fight, and sometimes I'm in the mood for complicated and damaged action heroes who loathe oppression and want to kill some people. This is the sort of series book that will neither be the reason you read the series nor the reason why you stop reading. If you enjoyed These Burning Stars, this is more of the same, with arguably better character development but less plot catharsis. If you didn't like These Burning Stars, this probably won't change your mind, although if you hated it specifically because of Esek's sociopathy, I think you would find this book more congenial. But maybe not; Jacobs is still the same author, and most of the characters in this series are made of sharp edges. I'm still in; I have already pre-ordered the next book. Followed by This Brutal Moon, due out in December of 2025 and advertised as the conclusion. Rating: 7 out of 10

26 October 2025

Russ Allbery: Review: Ancestral Night

Review: Ancestral Night, by Elizabeth Bear
Series: White Space #1
Publisher: Saga Press
Copyright: 2019
ISBN: 1-5344-0300-0
Format: Kindle
Pages: 501
Ancestral Night is a far-future space opera novel and the first of a series. It shares a universe with Bear's earier Jacob's Ladder trilogy, and there is a passing reference to the events of Grail that would be a spoiler if you put the pieces together, but it's easy to miss. You do not need to read the earlier series to read this book (although it's a good series and you might enjoy it). Halmey Dz is a member of the vast interstellar federation called the Synarche, which has put an end to war and other large-scale anti-social behavior through a process called rightminding. Every person has a neural implant that can serve as supplemental memory, off-load some thought processes, and, crucially, regulate neurotransmitters and hormones to help people stay on an even keel. It works, mostly. One could argue Halmey is an exception. Raised in a clade that took rightminding to an extreme of suppression of individual personality into a sort of hive mind, she became involved with a terrorist during her legally mandated time outside of her all-consuming family before she could make an adult decision to stay with them (essentially a rumspringa). The result was a tragedy that Halmey doesn't like to think about, one that's left deep emotional scars. But Halmey herself would argue she's not an exception: She's put her history behind her, found partners that she trusts, and is a well-adjusted member of the Synarche.
Eventually, I realized that I was wasting my time, and if I wanted to hide from humanity in a bottle, I was better off making it a titanium one with a warp drive and a couple of carefully selected companions.
Halmey does salvage: finding ships lost in white space and retrieving them. One of her partners is Connla, a pilot originally from a somewhat atavistic world called Spartacus. The other is their salvage tug.
The boat didn't have a name. He wasn't deemed significant enough to need a name by the authorities and registries that govern such things. He had a registration number 657-2929-04, Human/Terra and he had a class, salvage tug, but he didn't have a name. Officially. We called him Singer. If Singer had an opinion on the issue, he'd never registered it but he never complained. Singer was the shipmind as well as the ship or at least, he inhabited the ship's virtual spaces the same way we inhabited the physical ones but my partner Connla and I didn't own him. You can't own a sentience in civilized space.
As Ancestral Night opens, the three of them are investigating a tip of a white space anomoly well off the beaten path. They thought it might be a lost ship that failed a transition. What they find instead is a dead Ativahika and a mysterious ship equipped with artificial gravity. The Ativahikas are a presumed sentient race of living ships that are on the most alien outskirts of the Synarche confederation. They don't communicate, at least so far as Halmey is aware. She also wasn't aware they died, but this one is thoroughly dead, next to an apparently abandoned ship of unknown origin with a piece of technology beyond the capabilities of the Synarche. The three salvagers get very little time to absorb this scene before they are attacked by pirates. I have always liked Bear's science fiction better than her fantasy, and this is no exception. This was great stuff. Halmey is a talkative, opinionated infodumper, which is a great first-person protagonist to have in a fictional universe this rich with delightful corners. There are some Big Dumb Object vibes (one of my favorite parts of salvage stories), solid character work, a mysterious past that has some satisfying heft once it's revealed, and a whole lot more moral philosophy than I was expecting from the setup. All of it is woven together with experienced skill, unsurprising given Bear's long and prolific career. And it's full of delightful world-building bits: Halmey's afthands (a surgical adaptation for zero gravity work) and grumpiness at the sheer amount of gravity she has to deal with over the course of this book, the Culture-style ship names, and a faster-than-light travel system that of course won't pass physics muster but provides a satisfying quantity of hooky bits for plot to attach to. The backbone of this book is an ancient artifact mystery crossed with a murder investigation. Who killed the Ativahika? Where did the gravity generator come from? Those are good questions with interesting answers. But the heart of the book is a philosophical conflict: What are the boundaries between identity and society? How much power should society have to reshape who we are? If you deny parts of yourself to fit in with society, is this necessarily a form of oppression? I wrote a couple of paragraphs of elaboration, and then deleted them; on further thought, I don't want to give any more details about what Bear is doing in this book. I will only say that I was not expecting this level of thoughtfulness about a notoriously complex and tricky philosophical topic in a full-throated adventure science fiction novel. I think some people may find the ending strange and disappointing. I loved it, and weeks after finishing this book I'm still thinking about it. Ancestral Night has some pacing problems. There is a long stretch in the middle of the book that felt repetitive and strained, where Bear holds the reader at a high level of alert and dread for long enough that I found it enervating. There are also a few political cheap shots where Bear picks the weakest form of an opposing argument instead of the strongest. (Some of the cheap shots are rather satisfying, though.) The dramatic arc of the book is... odd, in a way that I think was entirely intentional given how well it works with the thematic message, but which is also unsettling. You may not get the catharsis that you're expecting. But all of this serves a purpose, and I thought that purpose was interesting. Ancestral Night is one of those books that I liked more a week after I finished it than I did when I finished it.
Epiphanies are wonderful. I m really grateful that our brains do so much processing outside the line of sight of our consciousnesses. Can you imagine how downright boring thinking would be if you had to go through all that stuff line by line?
Also, for once, I think Bear hit on exactly the right level of description rather than leaving me trying to piece together clues and hope I understood the plot. It helps that Halmey loves to explain things, so there are a lot of miniature infodumps, but I found them interesting and a satisfying throwback to an earlier style of science fiction that focused more on world-building than on interpersonal drama. There is drama, but most of it is internal, and I thought the balance was about right. This is solid, well-crafted work and a good addition to the genre. I am looking forward to the rest of the series. Followed by Machine, which shifts to a different protagonist. Rating: 8 out of 10

23 October 2025

Russ Allbery: Review: Politics on the Edge

Review: Politics on the Edge, by Rory Stewart
Publisher: Penguin Books
Copyright: 2023, 2025
Printing: 2025
ISBN: 979-8-217-06167-9
Format: Kindle
Pages: 429
Rory Stewart is a former British diplomat, non-profit executive, member of Parliament, and cabinet minister. Politics on the Edge is a memoir of his time in the UK Parliament from 2019 to 2019 as a Tory (Conservative) representing the Penrith and The Border constituency in northern England. It ends with his failed run against Boris Johnson for leader of the Conservative Party and Prime Minister. This book provoked many thoughts, only some of which are about the book. You may want to get a beverage; this review will be long. Since this is a memoir told in chronological order, a timeline may be useful. After Stewart's time as a regional governor in occupied Iraq (see The Prince of the Marshes), he moved to Kabul to found and run an NGO to preserve traditional Afghani arts and buildings (the Turquoise Mountain Foundation, about which I know nothing except what Stewart wrote in this book). By his telling, he found that work deeply rewarding but thought the same politicians who turned Iraq into a mess were going to do the same to Afghanistan. He started looking for ways to influence the politics more directly, which led him first to Harvard and then to stand for Parliament. The bulk of this book covers Stewart's time as MP for Penrith and The Border. The choice of constituency struck me as symbolic of Stewart's entire career: He was not a resident and had no real connection to the district, which he chose for political reasons and because it was the nearest viable constituency to his actual home in Scotland. But once he decided to run, he moved to the district and seems sincerely earnest in his desire to understand it and become part of its community. After five years as a backbencher, he joined David Cameron's government in a minor role as Minister of State in the Department for Environment, Food, and Rural Affairs. He then bounced through several minor cabinet positions (more on this later) before being elevated to Secretary of State for International Development under Theresa May. When May's government collapsed during the fight over the Brexit agreement, he launched a quixotic challenge to Boris Johnson for leader of the Conservative Party. I have enjoyed Rory Stewart's writing ever since The Places in Between. This book is no exception. Whatever one's other feelings about Stewart's politics (about which I'll have a great deal more to say), he's a talented memoir writer with an understated and contemplative style and a deft ability to shift from concrete description to philosophical debate without bogging down a story. Politics on the Edge is compelling reading at the prose level. I spent several afternoons happily engrossed in this book and had great difficulty putting it down. I find Stewart intriguing since, despite being a political conservative, he's neither a neoliberal nor any part of the new right. He is instead an apparently-sincere throwback to a conservatism based on epistemic humility, a veneration of rural life and long-standing traditions, and a deep commitment to the concept of public service. Some of his principles are baffling to me, and I think some of his political views are obvious nonsense, but there were several things that struck me throughout this book that I found admirable and depressingly rare in politics. First, Stewart seems to learn from his mistakes. This goes beyond admitting when he was wrong and appears to include a willingness to rethink entire philosophical positions based on new experience.
I had entered Iraq supporting the war on the grounds that we could at least produce a better society than Saddam Hussein's. It was one of the greatest mistakes in my life. We attempted to impose programmes made up by Washington think tanks, and reheated in air-conditioned palaces in Baghdad a new taxation system modelled on Hong Kong; a system of ministers borrowed from Singapore; and free ports, modelled on Dubai. But we did it ultimately at the point of a gun, and our resources, our abstract jargon and optimistic platitudes could not conceal how much Iraqis resented us, how much we were failing, and how humiliating and degrading our work had become. Our mission was a grotesque satire of every liberal aspiration for peace, growth and democracy.
This quote comes from the beginning of this book and is a sentiment Stewart already expressed in The Prince of the Marshes, but he appears to have taken this so seriously that it becomes a theme of his political career. He not only realized how wrong he was on Iraq, he abandoned the entire neoliberal nation-building project without abandoning his belief in the moral obligation of international aid. And he, I think correctly, identified a key source of the error: an ignorant, condescending superiority that dismissed the importance of deep expertise.
Neither they, nor indeed any of the 12,000 peacekeepers and policemen who had been posted to South Sudan from sixty nations, had spent a single night in a rural house, or could complete a sentence in Dinka, Nuer, Azande or Bande. And the international development strategy written jointly between the donor nations resembled a fading mission statement found in a new space colony, whose occupants had all been killed in an alien attack.
Second, Stewart sincerely likes ordinary people. This shone through The Places in Between and recurs here in his descriptions of his constituents. He has a profound appreciation for individual people who have spent their life learning some trade or skill, expresses thoughtful and observant appreciation for aspects of local culture, and appears to deeply appreciate time spent around people from wildly different social classes and cultures than his own. Every successful politician can at least fake gregariousness, and perhaps that's all Stewart is doing, but there is something specific and attentive about his descriptions of other people, including long before he decided to enter politics, that makes me think it goes deeper than political savvy. Third, Stewart has a visceral hatred of incompetence. I think this is the strongest through-line of his politics in this book: Jobs in government are serious, important work; they should be done competently and well; and if one is not capable of doing that, one should not be in government. Stewart himself strikes me as an insecure overachiever: fiercely ambitious, self-critical, a bit of a micromanager (I suspect he would be difficult to work for), but holding himself to high standards and appalled when others do not do the same. This book is scathing towards multiple politicians, particularly Boris Johnson whom Stewart clearly despises, but no one comes off worse than Liz Truss.
David Cameron, I was beginning to realise, had put in charge of environment, food and rural affairs a Secretary of State who openly rejected the idea of rural affairs and who had little interest in landscape, farmers or the environment. I was beginning to wonder whether he could have given her any role she was less suited to apart perhaps from making her Foreign Secretary. Still, I could also sense why Cameron was mesmerised by her. Her genius lay in exaggerated simplicity. Governing might be about critical thinking; but the new style of politics, of which she was a leading exponent, was not. If critical thinking required humility, this politics demanded absolute confidence: in place of reality, it offered untethered hope; instead of accuracy, vagueness. While critical thinking required scepticism, open-mindedness and an instinct for complexity, the new politics demanded loyalty, partisanship and slogans: not truth and reason but power and manipulation. If Liz Truss worried about the consequences of any of this for the way that government would work, she didn't reveal it.
And finally, Stewart has a deeply-held belief in state capacity and capability. He and I may disagree on the appropriate size and role of the government in society, but no one would be more disgusted by an intentional project to cripple government in order to shrink it than Stewart. One of his most-repeated criticisms of the UK political system in this book is the way the cabinet is formed. All ministers and secretaries come from members of Parliament and therefore branches of government are led by people with no relevant expertise. This is made worse by constant cabinet reshuffles that invalidate whatever small amounts of knowledge a minister was able to gain in nine months or a year in post. The center portion of this book records Stewart's time being shuffled from rural affairs to international development to Africa to prisons, with each move representing a complete reset of the political office and no transfer of knowledge whatsoever.
A month earlier, they had been anticipating every nuance of Minister Rogerson's diary, supporting him on shifts twenty-four hours a day, seven days a week. But it was already clear that there would be no pretence of a handover no explanation of my predecessor's strategy, and uncompleted initiatives. The arrival of a new minister was Groundhog Day. Dan Rogerson was not a ghost haunting my office, he was an absence, whose former existence was suggested only by the black plastic comb.
After each reshuffle, Stewart writes of trying to absorb briefings, do research, and learn enough about his new responsibilities to have the hope of making good decisions, while growing increasingly frustrated with the system and the lack of interest by most of his colleagues in doing the same. He wants government programs to be successful and believes success requires expertise and careful management by the politicians, not only by the civil servants, a position that to me both feels obviously correct and entirely at odds with politics as currently practiced. I found this a fascinating book to read during the accelerating collapse of neoliberalism in the US and, to judge by current polling results, the UK. I have a theory that the political press are so devoted to a simplistic left-right political axis based on seating arrangements during the French Revolution that they are missing a significant minority whose primary political motivation is contempt for arrogant incompetence. They could be convinced to vote for Sanders or Trump, for Polanski or Farage, but will never vote for Biden, Starmer, Romney, or Sunak. Such voters are incomprehensible to those who closely follow and debate policies because their hostile reaction to the center is not about policies. It's about lack of trust and a nebulous desire for justice. They've been promised technocratic competence and the invisible hand of market forces for most of their lives, and all of it looks like lies. Everyday living is more precarious, more frustrating, more abusive and dehumanizing, and more anxious, despite (or because of) this wholehearted embrace of economic "freedom." They're sick of every complaint about the increasing difficulty of life being met with accusations about their ability and work ethic, and of being forced to endure another round of austerity by people who then catch a helicopter ride to a party on some billionaire's yacht. Some of this is inherent in the deep structural weaknesses in neoliberal ideology, but this is worse than an ideological failure. The degree to which neoliberalism started as a project of sincere political thinkers is arguable, but that is clearly not true today. The elite class in politics and business is now thoroughly captured by people whose primary skill is the marginal manipulation of complex systems for their own power and benefit. They are less libertarian ideologues than narcissistic mediocrities. We are governed by management consultants. They are firmly convinced their organizational expertise is universal, and consider the specific business of the company, or government department, irrelevant. Given that context, I found Stewart's instinctive revulsion towards David Cameron quite revealing. Stewart, later in the book, tries to give Cameron some credit by citing several policy accomplishments and comparing him favorably to Boris Johnson (which, true, is a bar Cameron probably flops over). But I think Stewart's baffled astonishment at Cameron's vapidity says a great deal about how we have ended up where we are. This last quote is long, but I think it provides a good feel for Stewart's argument in this book.
But Cameron, who was rumoured to be sceptical about nation-building projects, only nodded, and then looking confidently up and down the table said, "Well, at least we all agree on one extremely straightforward and simple point, which is that our troops are doing very difficult and important work and we should all support them." It was an odd statement to make to civilians running humanitarian operations on the ground. I felt I should speak. "No, with respect, we do not agree with that. Insofar as we have focused on the troops, we have just been explaining that what the troops are doing is often futile, and in many cases making things worse." Two small red dots appeared on his cheeks. Then his face formed back into a smile. He thanked us, told us he was out of time, shook all our hands, and left the room. Later, I saw him repeat the same line in interviews: "the purpose of this visit is straightforward... it is to show support for what our troops are doing in Afghanistan". The line had been written, in London, I assumed, and tested on focus groups. But he wanted to convince himself it was also a position of principle. "David has decided," one of his aides explained, when I met him later, "that one cannot criticise a war when there are troops on the ground." "Why?" "Well... we have had that debate. But he feels it is a principle of British government." "But Churchill criticised the conduct of the Boer War; Pitt the war with America. Why can't he criticise wars?" "British soldiers are losing their lives in this war, and we can't suggest they have died in vain." "But more will die, if no one speaks up..." "It is a principle thing. And he has made his decision. For him and the party." "Does this apply to Iraq too?" "Yes. Again he understands what you are saying, but he voted to support the Iraq War, and troops are on the ground." "But surely he can say he's changed his mind?" The aide didn't answer, but instead concentrated on his food. "It is so difficult," he resumed, "to get any coverage of our trip." He paused again. "If David writes a column about Afghanistan, we will struggle to get it published." "But what would he say in an article anyway?" I asked. "We can talk about that later. But how do you get your articles on Afghanistan published?" I remembered how the US politicians and officials had shown their mastery of strategy and detail. I remembered the earnestness of Gordon Brown when I had briefed him on Iraq. Cameron seemed somehow less serious. I wrote as much in a column in the New York Times, saying that I was afraid the party of Churchill was becoming the party of Bertie Wooster.
I don't know Stewart's reputation in Britain, or in the constituency that he represented. I know he's been accused of being a self-aggrandizing publicity hound, and to some extent this is probably true. It's hard to find an ambitious politician who does not have that instinct. But whatever Stewart's flaws, he can, at least, defend his politics with more substance than a corporate motto. One gets the impression that he would respond favorably to demonstrated competence linked to a careful argument, even if he disagreed. Perhaps this is an illusion created by his writing, but even if so, it's a step in the right direction. When people become angry enough at a failing status quo, any option that promises radical change and punishment for the current incompetents will sound appealing. The default collapse is towards demagogues who are skilled at expressing anger and disgust and are willing to promise simple cures because they are indifferent to honesty. Much of the political establishment in the US, and possibly (to the small degree that I can analyze it from an occasional news article) in the UK, can identify the peril of the demagogue, but they have no solution other than a return to "politics as usual," represented by the amoral mediocrity of a McKinsey consultant. The rare politicians who seem to believe in something, who will argue for personal expertise and humility, who are disgusted by incompetence and have no patience for facile platitudes, are a breath of fresh air. There are a lot of policies on which Stewart and I would disagree, and perhaps some of his apparent humility is an affectation from the rhetorical world of the 1800s that he clearly wishes he were inhabiting, but he gives the strong impression of someone who would shoulder a responsibility and attempt to execute it with competence and attention to detail. He views government as a job, where coworkers should cooperate to achieve defined goals, rather than a reality TV show. The arc of this book, like the arc of current politics, is the victory of the reality TV show over the workplace, and the story of Stewart's run against Boris Johnson is hard reading because of it, but there's a portrayal here of a different attitude towards politics that I found deeply rewarding. If you liked Stewart's previous work, or if you want an inside look at parliamentary politics, highly recommended. I will be thinking about this book for a long time. Rating: 9 out of 10

11 October 2025

John Goerzen: A Mail Delivery Mystery: Exim, systemd, setuid, and Docker, oh my!

On mail.quux, a node of NNCPNET (the NNCP-based peer-to-peer email network), I started noticing emails not being delivered. They were all in the queue, frozen, and Exim s log had entries like:
unable to set gid=5001 or uid=5001 (euid=100): local delivery to [redacted] transport=nncp
Weird. Stranger still, when I manually ran the queue with sendmail -qff -v, they all delivered fine. Huh. Well, I thought, it was a one-off weird thing. But then it happened again. Upon investigating, I observed that this issue was happening only on messages submitted by SMTP. Which, on these systems, aren t that many. While trying different things, I tried submitting a message to myself using SMTP. Nothing to do with NNCP at all. But look at this:
 jgoerzen@[redacted] R=userforward defer (-1): require_files: error for /home/jgoerzen/.forward: Permission denied
Strraaannnge . All the information I could find about this, even a FAQ entry, said that the problem is that Exim isn t setuid root. But it is:
-rwsr-xr-x 1 root root 1533496 Mar 29  2025 /usr/sbin/exim4
This problem started when I upgraded to Debian Trixie. So what changed there? There are a lot of possibilities; this is running in Docker using my docker-debian-base system, which runs a regular Debian in Docker, including systemd. I eventually tracked it down to Exim migrating from init.d to systemd in trixie, and putting a bunch of lockdowns in its service file. After a bunch of trial and error, I determined that I needed to override this set of lockdowns to make it work. These overrides did the trick:
ProtectClock=false
PrivateDevices=false
RestrictRealtime=false
ProtectKernelModules=false
ProtectKernelTunables=false
ProtectKernelLogs=false
ProtectHostname=false
I don t know for sure if the issue is related to setuid. But if it is, there s nothing that immediately jumps out at me about any of these that would indicate a problem with setuid. I also don t know if running in Docker makes any difference. Anyhow, problem fixed, but mystery not solved!

10 October 2025

Reproducible Builds: Reproducible Builds in September 2025

Welcome to the September 2025 report from the Reproducible Builds project! Welcome to the very latest report from the Reproducible Builds project. Our monthly reports outline what we ve been up to over the past month, and highlight items of news from elsewhere in the increasingly-important area of software supply-chain security. As ever, if you are interested in contributing to the Reproducible Builds project, please see the Contribute page on our website. In this report:

  1. Reproducible Builds Summit 2025
  2. Can t we have nice things?
  3. Distribution work
  4. Tool development
  5. Reproducibility testing framework
  6. Upstream patches

Reproducible Builds Summit 2025 Please join us at the upcoming Reproducible Builds Summit, set to take place from October 28th 30th 2025 in Vienna, Austria! We are thrilled to host the eighth edition of this exciting event, following the success of previous summits in various iconic locations around the world, including Venice, Marrakesh, Paris, Berlin, Hamburg and Athens. Our summits are a unique gathering that brings together attendees from diverse projects, united by a shared vision of advancing the Reproducible Builds effort. During this enriching event, participants will have the opportunity to engage in discussions, establish connections and exchange ideas to drive progress in this vital field. Our aim is to create an inclusive space that fosters collaboration, innovation and problem-solving. If you re interesting in joining us this year, please make sure to read the event page which has more details about the event and location. Registration is open until 20th September 2025, and we are very much looking forward to seeing many readers of these reports there!

Can t we have nice things? Debian Developer Gunnar Wolf blogged that George V. Neville-Neil s Kode Vicious column in Communications of the ACM in which reproducible builds is mentioned without needing to introduce it (assuming familiarity across the computing industry and academia) . Titled, Can t we have nice things?, the article mentions:
Once the proper measurement points are known, we want to constrain the system such that what it does is simple enough to understand and easy to repeat. It is quite telling that the push for software that enables reproducible builds only really took off after an embarrassing widespread security issue ended up affecting the entire Internet. That there had already been 50 years of software development before anyone thought that introducing a few constraints might be a good idea is, well, let s just say it generates many emotions, none of them happy, fuzzy ones. [ ]

Distribution work In Debian this month, Johannes Starosta filed a bug against the debian-repro-status package, reporting that it does not work on Debian trixie. (An upstream bug report was also filed.) Furthermore, 17 reviews of Debian packages were added, 10 were updated and 14 were removed this month adding to our knowledge about identified issues. In March s report, we included the news that Fedora would aim for 99% package reproducibility. This change has now been deferred to Fedora 44 according to Phoronix. Lastly, Bernhard M. Wiedemann posted another openSUSE monthly update for their work there.

Tool development diffoscope version 306 was uploaded to Debian unstable by Chris Lamb. It included contributions already covered in previous months as well as some changes by Zbigniew J drzejewski-Szmek to address issues with the fdtump support [ ] and to move away from the deprecated codes.open method. [ ][ ] strip-nondeterminism version 1.15.0-1 was uploaded to Debian unstable by Chris Lamb. It included a contribution by Matwey Kornilov to add support for inline archive files for Erlang s escript [ ]. kpcyrd has released a new version of rebuilderd. As a quick recap, rebuilderd is an automatic build scheduler that tracks binary packages available in a Linux distribution and attempts to compile the official binary packages from their (purported) source code and dependencies. The code for in-toto attestations has been reworked, and the instances now feature a new endpoint that can be queried to fetch the list of public-keys an instance currently identifies itself by. [ ] Lastly, Holger Levsen bumped the Standards-Version field of disorderfs, with no changes needed. [ ][ ]

Reproducibility testing framework The Reproducible Builds project operates a comprehensive testing framework running primarily at tests.reproducible-builds.org in order to check packages and other artifacts for reproducibility. In August, however, a number of changes were made by Holger Levsen, including:
  • Setting up six new rebuilderd workers with 16 cores and 16 GB RAM each.
  • reproduce.debian.net-related:
    • Do not expose pending jobs; they are confusing without explaination. [ ]
    • Add a link to v1 API specification. [ ]
    • Drop rebuilderd-worker.conf on a node. [ ]
    • Allow manual scheduling for any architectures. [ ]
    • Update path to trixie graphs. [ ]
    • Use the same rebuilder-debian.sh script for all hosts. [ ]
    • Add all other suites to all other archs. [ ][ ][ ][ ]
    • Update SSH host keys for new hosts. [ ]
    • Move to the pull184 branch. [ ][ ][ ][ ][ ]
    • Only allow 20 GB cache for workers. [ ]
  • OpenWrt-related:
    • Grant developer aparcar full sudo control on the ionos30 node. [ ][ ]
  • Jenkins nodes:
    • Add a number of new nodes. [ ][ ][ ][ ][ ]
    • Dont expect /srv/workspace to exist on OSUOSL nodes. [ ]
    • Stop hardcoding IP addresses in munin.conf. [ ]
    • Add maintenance and health check jobs for new nodes. [ ]
    • Document slight changes in IONOS resources usage. [ ]
  • Misc:
    • Drop disabled Alpine Linux tests for good. [ ]
    • Move Debian live builds and some other Debian builds to the ionos10 node. [ ]
    • Cleanup some legacy support from releases before Debian trixie. [ ]
In addition, Jochen Sprickerhof made the following changes relating to reproduce.debian.net:
  • Do not expose pending jobs on the main site. [ ]
  • Switch the frontpage to reference Debian forky [ ], but do not attempt to build Debian forky on the armel architecture [ ].
  • Use consistent and up to date rebuilder-debian.sh script. [ ]
  • Fix supported worker architectures. [ ]
  • Add a basic excuses page. [ ]
  • Move to the pull184 branch. [ ][ ][ ][ ]
  • Fix a typo in the JavaScript. [ ]
  • Update front page for the new v1 API. [ ][ ]
Lastly, Roland Clobus did some maintenance relating to the reproducibility testing of the Debian Live images. [ ][ ][ ][ ]

Upstream patches The Reproducible Builds project detects, dissects and attempts to fix as many currently-unreproducible packages as possible. We endeavour to send all of our patches upstream where appropriate. This month, we wrote a large number of such patches, including:

Finally, if you are interested in contributing to the Reproducible Builds project, please visit our Contribute page on our website. However, you can get in touch with us via:

21 September 2025

Gunnar Wolf: We, Programmers A Chronicle of Coders from Ada to AI

This post is a review for Computing Reviews for We, Programmers A Chronicle of Coders from Ada to AI , a book published in Addison-Wesley
When this book was presented as available for review, I jumped on it. After all, who doesn t love reading a nice bit of computing history, as told by a well-known author (affectionaly known as Uncle Bob ), one who has been immersed in computing since forever? What s not to like there? Reading on, the book does not disappoint. Much to the contrary, it digs into details absent in most computer history books that, being an operating systems and computer architecture geek, I absolutely enjoyed. But let me first address the book s organization. The book is split into four parts. Part 1, Setting the Stage, is a short introduction, answering the question Who are we? ( we being the programmers, of course). It describes the fascination many of us felt when we realized that the computer was there to obey us, to do our bidding, and we could absolutely control it. Part 2 talks about the giants of the computing world, on whose shoulders we stand. It digs in with a level of detail I have never seen before, discussing their personal lives and technical contributions (as well as the hoops they had to jump through to get their work done). Nine chapters cover these giants, ranging chronologically from Charles Babbage and Ada Lovelace to Ken Thompson, Dennis Richie, and Brian Kernighan (understandably, giants who worked together are grouped in the same chapter). This is the part with the most historically overlooked technical details. For example, what was the word size in the first computers, before even the concept of a byte had been brought into regular use? What was the register structure of early central processing units (CPUs), and why did it lead to requiring self-modifying code to be able to execute loops? Then, just as Unix and C get invented, Part 3 skips to computer history as seen through the eyes of Uncle Bob. I must admit, while the change of rhythm initially startled me, it ends up working quite well. The focus is no longer on the giants of the field, but on one particular person (who casts a very long shadow). The narrative follows the author s life: a boy with access to electronics due to his father s line of work; a computing industry leader, in the early 2000s, with extreme programming; one of the first producers of training materials in video format a role that today might be recognized as an influencer. This first-person narrative reaches year 2023. But the book is not just a historical overview of the computing world, of course. Uncle Bob includes a final section with his thoughts on the future of computing. As this is a book for programmers, it is fitting to start with the changes in programming languages that we should expect to see and where such changes are likely to take place. The unavoidable topic of artificial intelligence is presented next: What is it and what does it spell for computing, and in particular for programming? Interesting (and sometimes surprising) questions follow: What does the future of hardware development look like? What is prone to be the evolution of the World Wide Web? What is the future of programming and programmers? At just under 500 pages, the book is a volume to be taken seriously. But space is very well used with this text. The material is easy to read, often funny and always informative. If you enjoy computer history and understanding the little details in the implementations, it might very well be the book you want.

Joey Hess: cheap DIY solar fence design

A year ago I installed a 4 kilowatt solar fence. I'm revisiting it this Sun Day, to share the design, now that I have prooved it out.
The solar fence and some other ground and pole mount solar panels, seen through leaves.
Solar fencing manufacturers have some good simple designs, but it's hard to buy for a small installation. They are selling to utility scale solar mostly. And those are installed by driving metal beams into the ground, which requires heavy machinery. Since I have experience with Ironridge rails for roof mount solar, I decided to adapt that system for a vertical mount. Which is something it was not designed for. I combined the Ironridge hardware with regular parts from the hardware store. The cost of mounting solar panels nowadays is often higher than the cost of the panels. I hoped to match the cost, and I nearly did. The solar panels cost $100 each, and the fence cost $110 per solar panel. This fence was significantly cheaper than conventional ground mount arrays that I considered as alternatives, and made a better use of a difficult hillside location. I used 7 foot long Ironridge XR-10 rails, which fit 2 solar panels per rail. (Longer rails would need a center post anyway, and the 7 foot long rails have cheaper shipping, since they do not need to be shipped freight.) For the fence posts, I used regular 4x4" treated posts. 12 foot long, set in 3 foot deep post holes, with 3x 50 lb bags of concrete per hole and 6 inches of gravel on the bottom.
detail of how the rails are mounted to the posts, and the panels to the rails
To connect the Ironridge rails to the fence posts, I used the Ironridge LFT-03-M1 slotted L-foot bracket. Screwed into the post with a 5/8 x 3 inch hot-dipped galvanized lag screw. Since a treated post can react badly with an aluminum bracket, there needs to be some flashing between the post and bracket. I used Shurtape PW-100 tape for that. I see no sign of corrosion after 1 year. The rest of the Ironridge system is a T-bolt that connects the rail to the L-foot (part BHW-SQ-02-A1), and Ironridge solar panel fasteners (UFO-CL-01-A1 and UFO-STP-40MM-M1). Also XR-10 end caps and wire clips. Since the Ironridge hardware is not designed to hold a solar panel at a 90 degree angle, I was concerned that the panels might slide downward over time. To help prevent that, I added some additional support brackets under the bottom of the panels. So far, that does not seem to have been a problem though. I installed Aptos 370 watt solar panels on the fence. They are bifacial, and while the posts block the back partially, there is still bifacial gain on cloudy days. I left enough space under the solar panels to be able to run a push mower under them.
Me standing in front of the solar fence at end of construction
I put pairs of posts next to one-another, so each 7 foot segment of fence had its own 2 posts. This is the least elegant part of this design, but fitting 2 brackets next to one-another on a single post isn't feasible. I bolted the pairs of posts together with some spacers. A side benefit of doing it this way is that treated lumber can warp as it dries, and this prevented much twisting of the posts. Using separate posts for each segment also means that the fence can traverse a hill easily. And it does not need to be perfectly straight. In fact, my fence has a 30 degree bend in the middle. This means it has both south facing and south-west facing panels, so can catch the light for longer during the day. After building the fence, I noticed there was a slight bit of sway at the top, since 9 feet of wooden post is not entirely rigid. My worry was that a gusty wind could rattle the solar panels. While I did not actually observe that happening, I added some diagonal back bracing for peace of mind.
view of rear upper corner of solar fence, showing back bracing connection
Inspecting the fence today, I find no problems after the first year. I hope it will last 30 years, with the lifespan of the treated lumber being the likely determining factor. As part of my larger (and still ongoing) ground mount solar install, the solar fence has consistently provided great power. The vertical orientation works well at latitude 36. It also turned out that the back of the fence was useful to hang conduit and wiring and solar equipment, and so it turned into the electrical backbone of my whole solar field. But that's another story.. solar fence parts list
quantity cost per unit description
10 $27.89 7 foot Ironridge XR-10 rail
12 $20.18 12 foot treated 4x4
30 $4.86 Ironridge UFO-CL-01-A1
20 $0.87 Ironridge UFO-STP-40MM-M1
1 $12.62 Ironridge XR-10 end caps (20 pack)
20 $2.63 Ironridge LFT-03-M1
20 $1.69 Ironridge BHW-SQ-02-A1
22 $2.65 5/8 x 3 inch hot-dipped galvanized lag screw
10 $0.50 6 gravel per post
30 $6.91 50 lb bags of quickcrete
1 $15.00 Shurtape PW-100 Corrosion Protection Pipe Wrap Tape
N/A $30 other bolts and hardware (approximate)
$1100 total (Does not include cost of panels, wiring, or electrical hardware.)

18 September 2025

John Goerzen: Running an Accurate 80 25 DOS-Style Console on Modern Linux Is Possible After All

Here, in classic Goerzen deep dive fashion, is more information than you knew you wanted about a topic you ve probably never thought of. I found it pretty interesting, because it took me down a rabbit hole of subsystems I ve never worked with much and a mishmash of 1980s and 2020s tech. I had previously tried and failed to get an actual 80x25 Linux console, but I ve since figured it out! This post is about the Linux text console not X or Wayland. We re going to get the console right without using those systems. These instructions are for Debian trixie, but should be broadly applicable elsewhere also. The end result can look like this: Photo of a color VGA monitor displaying a BBS login screen (That s a Wifi Retromodem that I got at VCFMW last year in the Hayes modem case)

What s a pixel? How would you define a pixel these days? Probably something like a uniquely-addressable square dot in a two-dimensional grid . In the world of VGA and CRTs, that was just a logical abstraction. We got an API centered around that because it was convenient. But, down the VGA cable and on the device, that s not what a pixel was. A pixel, back then, was a time interval. On a multisync monitor, which were common except in the very early days of VGA, the timings could be adjusted which produced logical pixels of different sizes. Those screens often had a maximum resolution but not necessarily a native resolution in the sense that an LCD panel does. Different timings produced different-sized pixels with equal clarity (or, on cheaper monitors, equal fuzziness). A side effect of this was that pixels need not be square. And, in fact, in the standard DOS VGA 80x25 text mode, they weren t. You might be seeing why DVI, DisplayPort, and HDMI replaced VGA for LCD monitors: with a VGA cable, you did a pixel-to-analog-timings conversion, then the display did a timings-to-pixels conversion, and this process could be a bit lossy. (Hence why you sometimes needed to fill the screen with an image and push the center button on those older LCD screens) (Note to the pedantically-inclined: yes I am aware that I have simplified several things here; for instance, a color LCD pixel is made up of approximately 3 sub-dots of varying colors, and that things like color eInk displays have two pixel grids with different sizes of pixels layered atop each other, and printers are another confusing thing altogether, and and and . MOST PEOPLE THINK OF A PIXEL AS A DOT THESE DAYS, OK?)

What was DOS text mode? We think of this as the standard display: 80 columns wide and 25 rows tall. 80x25. By the time Linux came along, the standard Linux console was VGA text mode something like the 4th incarnation of text modes on PCs (after CGA, MDA, and EGA). VGA also supported certain other sizes of characters giving certain other text dimensions, but if I cover all of those, this will explode into a ridiculously more massive page than it already is. So to display text on an 80x25 DOS VGA system, ultimately characters and attributes were written into the text buffer in memory. The VGA system then rendered it to the display as a 720x400 image (at 70Hz) with non-square pixels such that the result was approximately a 4:3 aspect ratio. The font used for this rendering was a bitmapped one using 8x16 cells. You might do some math here and point out that 8 * 80 is only 640, and you d be correct. The fonts were 8x16 but the rendered cells were 9x16. The extra pixel was normally used for spacing between characters. However, in line graphics mode, characters 0xC0 through 0xDF repeated the 8th column in the position of the 9th, allowing the continuous line-drawing characters we re used to from TUIs.

Problems rendering DOS fonts on modern systems By now, you re probably seeing some of the issues we have rendering DOS screens on more modern systems. These aren t new at all; I remember some of these from back in the days when I ran OS/2, and I think also saw them on various terminals and consoles in OS/2 and Windows. Some issues you d encounter would be:
  • Incorrect aspect ratio caused by using the original font and rendering it using 1:1 square pixels (resulting in a squashed appearance)
  • Incorrect aspect ratio for ANOTHER reason, caused by failing to render column 9, resulting in text that is overall too narrow
  • Characters appearing to be touching each other when they shouldn t (failing to render column 9; looking at you, dosbox)
  • Gaps between line drawing characters that should be continuous, caused by rendering column 9 as empty space in all cases

Character set issues DOS was around long before Unicode was. In the DOS world, there were codepages that selected the glyphs for roughly the high half of the 256 possible characters. CP437 was the standard for the USA; others existed for other locations that needed different characters. On Unix, the USA pre-Unicode standard was Latin-1. Same concept, but with different character mappings. Nowadays, just about everything is based on UTF-8. So, we need some way to map our CP437 glyphs into Unicode space. If we are displaying DOS-based content, we ll also need a way to map CP437 characters to Unicode for display later, and we need these maps to match so that everything comes out right. Whew. So, let s get on with setting this up!

Selecting the proper video mode As explained in my previous post, proper hardware support for DOS text mode is limited to x86 machines that do not use UEFI. Non-x86 machines, or x86 machines with UEFI, simply do not contain the necessary support for it. As these are now standard, most of the time, the text console you see on Linux is actually the kernel driving the video hardware in graphics mode, and doing the text rendering in software. That s all well and good, but it makes it quite difficult to actually get an 80x25 console. First, we need to be running at 720x400. This is where I ran into difficulty last time. I realized that my laptop s LCD didn t advertise any video modes other than its own native resolution. However, almost all external monitors will, and 720x400@70 is a standard VGA mode from way back, so it should be well-supported. You need to find the Linux device name for your device. You can look at the possible devices with ls -l /sys/class/drm. If you also have a GUI, xrandr may help too. But in any case, each directory under /sys/class/drm has a file named modes, and if you cat them all, you will eventually come across one with a bunch of modes defined. Drop the leading card0 or whatever from the directory name, and that s your device. (Verify that 720x400 is in modes while you re at it.) Now, you re going to edit /etc/default/grub and add something like this to GRUB_CMDLINE_LINUX_DEFAULT:
video=DP-1:720x400@70
Of course, replace DP-1 with whatever your device is. Now you can run update-grub and reboot. You should have a 720x400 display. At first, I thought I had succeeded by using Linux s built-in VGA font with that mode. But it looked too tall. After noticing that repeated 0s were touching, I got suspicious about the missing 9th column in the cells. stty -a showed that my screen was 90x25, which is exactly what it would show if I was using 8x16 instead of 9x16 cells. Sooo . I need to prepare a 9x16 font.

Preparing a font Here s where it gets complicated. I ll give you the simple version and the hard mode. The simple mode is this: Download https://www.complete.org/downloads/CP437-VGA.psf.gz and stick it in /usr/local/etc, then skip to the Activating the font section below. The font assembled here is based on the Ultimate Oldschool PC Font Pack v2.2, which is (c) 2016-2020 VileR and licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License. My psf file is derived from this using the instructions below.

Building it yourself First, install some necessary software: apt-get install fontforge bdf2psf Start by going to the Oldschool PC Font Pack Download page. Download oldschool_pc_font_pack_v2.2_FULL.zip and unpack it. The file we re interested in is otb - Bm (linux bitmap)/Bm437_IBM_VGA_9x16.otb. Open it in fontforge by running fontforge BmPlus_IBM_VGA_9x16.otb. When it asks if you will load the bitmap fonts, hit select all, then yes. Go to File -> generate fonts. Save in a BDF, no need for outlines, and use guess for resolution. Now you have a file such as Bm437_IBM_VGA_9x16-16.bdf. Excellent. Now we need to generate a Unicode map file. We will make sure this matches the system s by enumerating every character from 0x00 to 0xFF, converting it from CP437 to Unicode, and writing the appropriate map. Here s a Python script to do that:
for i in range(0, 256):
    cp437b = b'%c' % i
    uni = ord(cp437b.decode('cp437'))
    print(f"U+ uni:04x ")
Save that file as genmap.py and run python3 genmap.py > cp437-uni. Now, we re ready to build the psf file:
bdf2psf --fb Bm437_IBM_VGA_9x16-16.bdf \
  /dev/null cp437-uni 256 CP437-VGA.psf
By convention, we normally store these files gzipped, so gzip CP437-VGA.psf. You can test it on the console with setfont CP437-VGA.psf.gz. Now copy this file into /usr/local/etc.

Activating the font Now, edit /etc/default/console-setup. It should look like this:
# CONFIGURATION FILE FOR SETUPCON

# Consult the console-setup(5) manual page.

ACTIVE_CONSOLES="/dev/tty[1-6]"

CHARMAP="UTF-8"

CODESET="Lat15"
FONTFACE="VGA"
FONTSIZE="8x16"
FONT=/usr/local/etc/CP437-VGA.psf.gz

VIDEOMODE=

# The following is an example how to use a braille font
# FONT='lat9w-08.psf.gz brl-8x8.psf'
At this point, you should be able to reboot. You should have a proper 80x25 display! Log in and run stty -a to verify it is indeed 80x25.

Using and testing CP437 Part of the point of CP437 is to be able to access BBSs, ANSI art, and similar. Now, remember, the Linux console is still in UTF-8 mode, so we have to translate CP437 to UTF-8, then let our font map translate it back to CP437. A weird trip, but it works. Let s test it using the Textfiles ANSI art collection. In the artworks section, I randomly grabbed a file near the top: borgman.ans. Download that, and display with:
clear; iconv -f CP437 -t UTF-8 < borgman.ans
You should see something similar to but actually more accurate than the textfiles PNG rendering of it, which you ll note has an incorrect aspect ratio and some rendering issues. I spot-checked with a few others and they seemed to look good. belinda.ans in particular tries quite a few characters and should give you a good sense if it is working.

Use with interactive programs That s all well and good, but you re probably going to want to actually use this with some interactive program that expects CP437. Maybe Minicom, Kermit, or even just telnet? For this, you ll want to apt-get install luit. luit maps CP437 (or any other encoding) to UTF-8 for display, and then of course the Linux console maps UTF-8 back to the CP437 font. Here s a way you can repeat the earlier experiment using luit to run the cat program:
clear; luit -encoding CP437 cat borgman.ans
You can run any command under luit. You can even run luit -encoding CP437 bash if you like. If you do this, it is probably a good idea to follow my instructions on generating locales on my post on serial terminals, and then within luit, set LANG=en_us.IBM437. But note especially that you can run programs like minicom and others for accessing BBSs under luit.

Final words This gave you a nice DOS-type console. Although it doesn t have glyphs for many codepoints, it does run in UTF-8 mode and therefore is compatible with modern software. You can achieve greater compatibility with more UTF-8 codepoints with the DOS font, at the expense of accuracy of character rendering (especially for the double-line drawing characters) by using /usr/share/bdf2psf/standard.equivalents instead of /dev/null in the bdf2psf command. Or you could go for another challenge, such as using the DEC vt-series fonts for coverage of ISO-8859-1. But just using fonts extracted from DEC ROM won t work properly, because DEC terminals had even more strangeness going on than DOS fonts.

11 September 2025

Jonathan Wiltshire: Debian stable updates explained: security, updates, and point releases

Please consider supporting my work in Debian and elsewhere through Liberapay. Debian stable updates work through three main channels: point releases, security repositories, and the updates repository. Understanding these ensures your system stays secure and current.

A note about suite names Every Debian release, or suite, has a codename the most recent major release was trixie, or Debian 13. The codename uniquely identifies that suite. We also use changeable aliases to add meaning to the suite s lifecycle. For example, trixie currently has the alias stable, but when forky becomes stable instead, trixie will become known as oldstable. This post uses either codenames or aliases depending on context. In source lists, codenames are generally preferred since that avoids surprise major upgrades right after a release is made.

The stable suites (point releases) stable and oldstable (currently trixie and bookworm) are only updated during a point release. This is a minor update released to a major version. For example, 13.1 is the first minor update to trixie. It s not possible to install older minor versions of a suite except via the snapshots mechanism (not covered here). It s possible to view past versions via snapshot.debian.org, which preserves historical Debian archives. There are also the testing and unstable aliases for the development suites. However, these are not relevant for users who want to run officially released versions. Almost every stable installation of Debian will be opted into a stable or oldstable base suite. An example APT source might look like:
Type: deb
URIs: http://deb.debian.org/debian
Suites: trixie
Components: main
Signed-By: /usr/share/keyrings/debian-archive-keyring.pgp
Or, in legacy sources.list style:
deb https://deb.debian.org/debian trixie main

The security suites (DSAs explained) For urgent security-related updates, the Security Team maintains a counterpart suite for each stable suite. These are called stable-security and oldstable-security when maintained by Debian s security team, and oldstable-security, oldoldstable-security, etc when maintained by the LTS team. Example APT source:
Type: deb
URIs: https://deb.debian.org/debian-security
Suites: trixie-security
Components: main
Signed-By: /usr/share/keyrings/debian-archive-keyring.pgp
Or, in legacy sources.list style:
deb https://deb.debian.org/debian-security trixie-security main
The Debian installer enables the security suites by default. Debian Security Announcements (DSAs) are published to debian-security-announce@lists.debian.org.

The updates suites (SUAs and maintenance) For urgent non-security updates, the final recommended suites are stable-updates and oldstable-updates. This is where updates staged for a point release, but needed sooner, are published. Examples include virus database updates, timezone changes, urgent bug fixes for specific problems and corrections to errors in the release process itself. Example APT source:
Type: deb
URIs: https://deb.debian.org/debian
Suites: trixie-updates
Components: main
Signed-By: /usr/share/keyrings/debian-archive-keyring.pgp
Or, in legacy sources.list style:
deb https://deb.debian.org/debian trixie-updates main
Debian enables the updates suites by default. Stable Update Announcements (SUAs) are published to debian-stable-announce@lists.debian.org. This is also where announcements of forthcoming point releases are published.

Summary These are the recommended suites for all production Debian systems:
SuiteExample codenamePurposeAnnouncements
stabletrixieBase suite containing all the available software for a release. Point releases every 2 4 months including lower-severity security fixes that do not require immediate release.Debian Release Announcements on debian-announce
stable-securitytrixie-securityUrgent security updates.Debian Security Announcements on debian-security-announce
stable-updatestrixie-updatesUrgent non-security updates, data updates and release maintenance.Stable Update Announcements on debian-stable-announce
After a release moves from oldstable to unsupported status, Long Term Support (LTS) takes over for several more years. LTS provides urgent security updates for selected architectures. For details, see wiki.debian.org/LTS. If you d like to stay informed, the official Debian announcement lists and release.debian.org share the latest schedules and updates.
Photo by Brian Wangenheim on Unsplash

Gunnar Wolf: Saying _hi_ to my good Reproducible Builds friends while reading a magazine article

Just wanted to share I enjoy reading George V. Neville s Kode Vicious column, which regularly appears on some of ACM s publications I follow, such as ACM Queue or Communications. Today I was very pleasantly surprised, while reading the column titled Can t we have nice things Kode Vicious answers to a question on why computing has nothing comparable to the beauty of ancient physics laboratories turned into museums (i.e. Faraday s laboratory) by giving a great hat tip to a project stemmed off Debian, and where many of my good Debian friends spend a lot of their energies: Reproducible builds. KV says:
Once the proper measurement points are known, we want to constrain the system such that what it does is simple enough to understand and easy to repeat. It is quite telling that the push for software that enables reproducible builds only really took off after an embarrassing widespread security issue ended up affecting the entire Internet. That there had already been 50 years of software development before anyone thought that introducing a few constraints might be a good idea is, well, let s just say it generates many emotions, none of them happy, fuzzy ones.
Yes, KV is a seasoned free software author. But I found it heart warming that the Reproducible Builds project is mentioned without needing to introduce it (assuming familiarity across the computing industry and academia), recognized as game-changing as we understood it would be over ten years ago when it was first announced, and enabling of beauty in computing. Congratulations to all of you who have made this possible! RB+ACM

8 September 2025

Thorsten Alteholz: My Debian Activities in August 2025

Debian LTS This was my hundred-thirty-fourth month that I did some work for the Debian LTS initiative, started by Raphael Hertzog at Freexian. During my allocated time I uploaded or worked on: I also continued my work on suricata and could backport all patches. Now I have to do some tests with the package. I also started to work on an openafs regression and attended the monthly LTS/ELTS meeting. Debian ELTS This month was the eighty-fifth ELTS month. During my allocated time I uploaded or worked on: I could also mark the CVEs of libcoap as not-affected. I also attended the monthly LTS/ELTS meeting.Of course like for LTS, As suricata had been requested for Stretch as well now, I didn t not finish my work here. Debian Printing This month I uploaded a new upstream version or a bugfix version of: This work is generously funded by Freexian! Debian Astro This month I uploaded a new upstream version or a bugfix version of: Debian IoT This month I uploaded a new upstream version or a bugfix version of: Debian Mobcom This month I uploaded a new upstream version or a bugfix version of: misc This month I uploaded a new upstream version or a bugfix version of: On my fight against outdated RFPs, I closed 31 of them in August. FTP master Yeah, Trixie has been released, the tired bones need to be awaken again :-). This month I accepted 203 and rejected 18 packages. The overall number of packages that got accepted was 243.

Next.

Previous.