Search Results: "sto"

17 March 2025

Vincent Bernat: Offline PKI using 3 YubiKeys and an ARM single board computer

An offline PKI enhances security by physically isolating the certificate authority from network threats. A YubiKey is a low-cost solution to store a root certificate. You also need an air-gapped environment to operate the root CA.
PKI relying on a set of 3 YubiKeys: 2 for the root CA and 1 for the intermediate CA.
Offline PKI backed up by 3 YubiKeys
This post describes an offline PKI system using the following components: It is possible to add more YubiKeys as a backup of the root CA if needed. This is not needed for the intermediate CA as you can generate a new one if the current one gets destroyed.

The software part offline-pki is a small Python application to manage an offline PKI. It relies on yubikey-manager to manage YubiKeys and cryptography for cryptographic operations not executed on the YubiKeys. The application has some opinionated design choices. Notably, the cryptography is hard-coded to use NIST P-384 elliptic curve. The first step is to reset all your YubiKeys:
$ offline-pki yubikey reset
This will reset the connected YubiKey. Are you sure? [y/N]: y
New PIN code:
Repeat for confirmation:
New PUK code:
Repeat for confirmation:
New management key ('.' to generate a random one):
WARNING[pki-yubikey] Using random management key: e8ffdce07a4e3bd5c0d803aa3948a9c36cfb86ed5a2d5cf533e97b088ae9e629
INFO[pki-yubikey]  0: Yubico YubiKey OTP+FIDO+CCID 00 00
INFO[pki-yubikey] SN: 23854514
INFO[yubikit.management] Device config written
INFO[yubikit.piv] PIV application data reset performed
INFO[yubikit.piv] Management key set
INFO[yubikit.piv] New PUK set
INFO[yubikit.piv] New PIN set
INFO[pki-yubikey] YubiKey reset successful!
Then, generate the root CA and create as many copies as you want:
$ offline-pki certificate root --permitted example.com
Management key for Root X:
Plug YubiKey "Root X"...
INFO[pki-yubikey]  0: Yubico YubiKey CCID 00 00
INFO[pki-yubikey] SN: 23854514
INFO[yubikit.piv] Data written to object slot 0x5fc10a
INFO[yubikit.piv] Certificate written to slot 9C (SIGNATURE), compression=True
INFO[yubikit.piv] Private key imported in slot 9C (SIGNATURE) of type ECCP384
Copy root certificate to another YubiKey? [y/N]: y
Plug YubiKey "Root X"...
INFO[pki-yubikey]  0: Yubico YubiKey CCID 00 00
INFO[pki-yubikey] SN: 23854514
INFO[yubikit.piv] Data written to object slot 0x5fc10a
INFO[yubikit.piv] Certificate written to slot 9C (SIGNATURE), compression=True
INFO[yubikit.piv] Private key imported in slot 9C (SIGNATURE) of type ECCP384
Copy root certificate to another YubiKey? [y/N]: n
You can inspect the result:
$ offline-pki yubikey info
INFO[pki-yubikey]  0: Yubico YubiKey CCID 00 00
INFO[pki-yubikey] SN: 23854514
INFO[pki-yubikey] Slot 9C (SIGNATURE):
INFO[pki-yubikey]   Private key type: ECCP384
INFO[pki-yubikey]   Public key:
INFO[pki-yubikey]     Algorithm:  secp384r1
INFO[pki-yubikey]     Issuer:     CN=Root CA
INFO[pki-yubikey]     Subject:    CN=Root CA
INFO[pki-yubikey]     Serial:     1
INFO[pki-yubikey]     Not before: 2024-07-05T18:17:19+00:00
INFO[pki-yubikey]     Not after:  2044-06-30T18:17:19+00:00
INFO[pki-yubikey]     PEM:
-----BEGIN CERTIFICATE-----
MIIBcjCB+aADAgECAgEBMAoGCCqGSM49BAMDMBIxEDAOBgNVBAMMB1Jvb3QgQ0Ew
HhcNMjQwNzA1MTgxNzE5WhcNNDQwNjMwMTgxNzE5WjASMRAwDgYDVQQDDAdSb290
IENBMHYwEAYHKoZIzj0CAQYFK4EEACIDYgAERg3Vir6cpEtB8Vgo5cAyBTkku/4w
kXvhWlYZysz7+YzTcxIInZV6mpw61o8W+XbxZV6H6+3YHsr/IeigkK04/HJPi6+i
zU5WJHeBJMqjj2No54Nsx6ep4OtNBMa/7T9foyMwITAPBgNVHRMBAf8EBTADAQH/
MA4GA1UdDwEB/wQEAwIBhjAKBggqhkjOPQQDAwNoADBlAjEAwYKy/L8leJyiZSnn
xrY8xv8wkB9HL2TEAI6fC7gNc2bsISKFwMkyAwg+mKFKN2w7AjBRCtZKg4DZ2iUo
6c0BTXC9a3/28V5aydZj6rvx0JqbF/Ln5+RQL6wFMLoPIvCIiCU=
-----END CERTIFICATE-----
Then, you can create an intermediate certificate with offline-pki yubikey intermediate and use it to sign certificates by providing a CSR to offline-pki certificate sign. Be careful and inspect the CSR before signing it, as only the subject name can be overridden. Check the documentation for more details. Get the available options using the --help flag.

The hardware part To ensure the operations on the root and intermediate CAs are air-gapped, a cost-efficient solution is to use an ARM64 single board computer. The Libre Computer Sweet Potato SBC is a more open alternative to the well-known Raspberry Pi.1
Libre Computer Sweet Potato single board computer relying on the Amlogic S905X SOC
Libre Computer Sweet Potato SBC, powered by the AML-S905X SOC
I interact with it through an USB to TTL UART converter:
$ tio /dev/ttyUSB0
[16:40:44.546] tio v3.7
[16:40:44.546] Press ctrl-t q to quit
[16:40:44.555] Connected to /dev/ttyUSB0
GXL:BL1:9ac50e:bb16dc;FEAT:ADFC318C:0;POC:1;RCY:0;SPI:0;0.0;CHK:0;
TE: 36574
BL2 Built : 15:21:18, Aug 28 2019. gxl g1bf2b53 - luan.yuan@droid15-sz
set vcck to 1120 mv
set vddee to 1000 mv
Board ID = 4
CPU clk: 1200MHz
[ ]

The Nix glue To bring everything together, I am using Nix with a Flake providing:
  • a package for the offline-pki application, with shell completion,
  • a development shell, including an editable version of the offline-pki application,
  • a NixOS module to setup the offline PKI, resetting the system at each boot,
  • a QEMU image for testing, and
  • an SD card image to be used on the Sweet Potato or another ARM64 SBC.
# Execute the application locally
nix run github:vincentbernat/offline-pki -- --help
# Run the application inside a QEMU VM
nix run github:vincentbernat/offline-pki\#qemu
# Build a SD card for the Sweet Potato or for the Raspberry Pi
nix build --system aarch64-linux github:vincentbernat/offline-pki\#sdcard.potato
nix build --system aarch64-linux github:vincentbernat/offline-pki\#sdcard.generic
# Get a development shell with the application
nix develop github:vincentbernat/offline-pki

  1. The key for the root CA is not generated by the YubiKey. Using an air-gapped computer is all the more important. Put it in a safe with the YubiKeys when done!

15 March 2025

Scarlett Gately Moore: KDE snaps fixed, Thank you for your support

KDE MascotKDE Mascot
Thank you everyone for keeping the lights on for a bit longer. KDE snaps have been restored. I also released 24.12.3! In addition, I have moved most snaps to core24. The remaining snaps need newer qt6/kf6, which is a WIP. The Bad luck girl has been hit once again with another loss, so with that, I will be reducing my hours on snaps while I consider my options for my future. I am still around, just a bit less. Thanks again everyone, if you can get me through one more ( lingering broken arm ) surgery I would be forever grateful! https://gofund.me/d5d59582

14 March 2025

Ravi Dwivedi: Libreoffice Conference 2024 in Luxembourg

Last year, I attended the annual LibreOffice Conference in Luxembourg with the help of a generous travel grant by The Document Foundation (TDF). It was a three-day event from the 10th to the 12th of October 2024, with an additional day for community meetup on the 9th. Luxembourg is a small (twice as big as Delhi) country in Western Europe. After going through an arduous visa process, I reached Luxembourg on the 8th of October. Upon arriving in Luxembourg, I took a bus to the city center, where my hotel Park Inn was located. All the public transport in Luxembourg was free of cost. It was as if I stepped in another world. There were separate tracks for cycling and a separate lane for buses, along with good pedestrian infrastructure. In addition, the streets were pretty neat and clean.
Luxembourg's Findel Airport
Separate cycling tracks in Luxembourg
My hotel was 20 km from the conference venue in Belval. However, the commute was convenient due to a free of cost train connection, which were comfortable, smooth, and scenic, covering the distance in half an hour. The hotel included a breakfast buffet, recharging us before the conference.
This is what trains look like in Luxembourg
Pre-conference, a day was reserved for the community meetup on the 9th of October. On that day, the community members introduced themselves and their contributions to the LibreOffice project. It acted as a brainstorming session. I got a lovely conference bag, which contained a T-Shirt, a pen and a few stickers. I also met my long time collaborators Mike, Sophie and Italo from the TDF, whom I had interacted only remotely till then. Likewise, I also met TDF s sysadmin Guilhem, who I interacted before regarding setting up my LibreOffice mirror.
Conference bag
The conference started on the 10th. There were 5 attendees from India, including me, while most of the attendees were from Europe. The talks were in English. One of the talks that stood out for me was about Luxchat a chat service run by the Luxembourg government based on the Matrix protocol for the citizens of Luxembourg. I also liked Italo s talk on why document formats must be freedom-respecting. On the first night, the conference took us to a nice dinner in a restaurant. It offered one more way to socialize with other attendees and explore food at the same time.
One of the slides of Italo's talk
Picture of the hall in which talks were held
On the 11th of October, I went for a walk in the morning with Biswadeep for some sightseeing around our hotel area. As a consequence, I missed the group photo of the conference, which I wanted to be in. Anyway, we enjoyed roaming around the picturesque Luxembourg city. We also sampled a tram ride to return to our hotel.
We encountered such scenic views during our walk
Another view of Luxembourg city area
The conference ended on the 12th with a couple of talks. This conference gave me an opportunity to meet the global LibreOffice community, connect and share ideas. It also gave me a peek into the country of Luxembourg and its people, where I had good experience. English was widely known, and I had no issues getting by. Thanks to all the organizers and sponsors of the conference!

Dima Kogan: Getting precise timings out of RS-232 output

For uninteresting reasons I need very regular 58Hz pulses coming out of an RS-232 Tx line: the time between each pulse should be as close to 1/58s as possible. I produce each pulse by writing an \xFF byte to the device. The start bit is the only active-voltage bit being sent, and that produces my pulse. I wrote this obvious C program:
#include <stdio.h>
#include <stdlib.h>
#include <stdbool.h>
#include <sys/ioctl.h>
#include <unistd.h>
#include <fcntl.h>
#include <termios.h>
#include <stdint.h>
#include <sys/time.h>
static uint64_t gettimeofday_uint64()
 
    struct timeval tv;
    gettimeofday(&tv, NULL);
    return (uint64_t) tv.tv_sec * 1000000ULL + (uint64_t) tv.tv_usec;
 
int main(int argc, char* argv[])
 
    // open the serial device, and make it as raw as possible
    const char* device = "/dev/ttyS0";
    const speed_t baud = B9600;
    int fd = open(device, O_WRONLY O_NOCTTY);
    tcflush(fd, TCIOFLUSH);
    struct termios options =  .c_iflag = IGNBRK,
                              .c_cflag = CS8   CREAD   CLOCAL ;
    cfsetspeed(&options, baud);
    tcsetattr(fd, TCSANOW, &options);
    const uint64_t T_us = (uint64_t)(1e6 / 58.);
    const uint64_t t0 = gettimeofday_uint64();
    for(int i=0; ; i++)
     
        const uint64_t t_target = t0 + T_us*i;
        const uint64_t t1       = gettimeofday_uint64();
        if(t_target > t1)
            usleep(t_target - t1);
        write(fd, &((char) '\xff' ), 1);
     
    return 0;
 
This tries to make sure that each write() call happens at 58Hz. I need these pulses to be regular, so I need to also make sure that the time between each userspace write() and when the edge actually hits the line is as short as possible or, at least, stable. Potential reasons for timing errors:
  1. The usleep() doesn't wake up exactly when it should. This is subject to the Linux scheduler waking up the trigger process
  2. The write() almost certainly ends up scheduling a helper task to actually write the \xFF to the hardware. This helper task is also subject to the Linux scheduler waking it up.
  3. Whatever the hardware does. RS-232 doesn't give you any guarantees about byte-byte timings, so this could be an unfixable source of errors
The scheduler-related questions are observable without any extra hardware, so let's do that first. I run the ./trigger program, and look at diagnostics while that's running. I look at some device details:
# ls -lh /dev/ttyS0
crw-rw---- 1 root dialout 4, 64 Mar  6 18:11 /dev/ttyS0
# ls -lh /sys/dev/char/4:64/
total 0
-r--r--r-- 1 root root 4.0K Mar  6 16:51 close_delay
-r--r--r-- 1 root root 4.0K Mar  6 16:51 closing_wait
-rw-r--r-- 1 root root 4.0K Mar  6 16:51 console
-r--r--r-- 1 root root 4.0K Mar  6 16:51 custom_divisor
-r--r--r-- 1 root root 4.0K Mar  6 16:51 dev
lrwxrwxrwx 1 root root    0 Mar  6 16:51 device -> ../../../0000:00:16.3:0.0
-r--r--r-- 1 root root 4.0K Mar  6 16:51 flags
-r--r--r-- 1 root root 4.0K Mar  6 16:51 iomem_base
-r--r--r-- 1 root root 4.0K Mar  6 16:51 iomem_reg_shift
-r--r--r-- 1 root root 4.0K Mar  6 16:51 io_type
-r--r--r-- 1 root root 4.0K Mar  6 16:51 irq
-r--r--r-- 1 root root 4.0K Mar  6 16:51 line
-r--r--r-- 1 root root 4.0K Mar  6 16:51 port
drwxr-xr-x 2 root root    0 Mar  6 16:51 power
-rw-r--r-- 1 root root 4.0K Mar  6 16:51 rx_trig_bytes
lrwxrwxrwx 1 root root    0 Mar  6 16:51 subsystem -> ../../../../../../../class/tty
-r--r--r-- 1 root root 4.0K Mar  6 16:51 type
-r--r--r-- 1 root root 4.0K Mar  6 16:51 uartclk
-rw-r--r-- 1 root root 4.0K Mar  6 16:51 uevent
-r--r--r-- 1 root root 4.0K Mar  6 16:51 xmit_fifo_size
Unsurprisingly, this is a part of the tty subsystem. I don't want to spend the time to really figure out how this works, so let me look at all the tty kernel calls and also at all the kernel tasks scheduled by the trigger process, since I suspect that the actual hardware poke is happening in a helper task. I see this:
# bpftrace -e 'k:*tty* /comm=="trigger"/
                 printf("%d %d %s\n",pid,tid,probe);  
               t:sched:sched_wakeup /comm=="trigger"/
                 printf("switching to %s(%d); current backtrace:", args.comm, args.pid); print(kstack());   '
...
3397345 3397345 kprobe:tty_ioctl
3397345 3397345 kprobe:tty_check_change
3397345 3397345 kprobe:__tty_check_change
3397345 3397345 kprobe:tty_wait_until_sent
3397345 3397345 kprobe:tty_write
3397345 3397345 kprobe:file_tty_write.isra.0
3397345 3397345 kprobe:tty_ldisc_ref_wait
3397345 3397345 kprobe:n_tty_write
3397345 3397345 kprobe:tty_hung_up_p
switching to kworker/0:1(3400169); current backtrace:
        ttwu_do_activate+268
        ttwu_do_activate+268
        try_to_wake_up+605
        kick_pool+92
        __queue_work.part.0+582
        queue_work_on+101
        rpm_resume+1398
        __pm_runtime_resume+75
        __uart_start+85
        uart_write+150
        n_tty_write+1012
        file_tty_write.isra.0+373
        vfs_write+656
        ksys_write+109
        do_syscall_64+130
        entry_SYSCALL_64_after_hwframe+118
3397345 3397345 kprobe:tty_update_time
3397345 3397345 kprobe:tty_ldisc_deref
... repeated with each pulse ...
Looking at the sources I see that uart_write() calls __uart_start(), which schedules a task to call serial_port_runtime_resume() which eventually calls serial8250_tx_chars(), which calls some low-level functions to actually send the bits. I look at the time between two of those calls to quantify the scheduler latency:
pulserate=58
sudo zsh -c \
  '( echo "# dt_write_ns dt_task_latency_ns";
     bpftrace -q -e "k:vfs_write /comm==\"trigger\" && arg2==1/
                      \$t=nsecs(); if(@t0)   @dt_write = \$t-@t0;   @t0=\$t; 
                     k:serial8250_tx_chars /@dt_write/
                      \$t=nsecs(); printf(\"%d %d\\n\", @dt_write, \$t-@t0); "
   )' \
  vnl-filter                  \
    --stream -p dt_write_ms="dt_write_ns/1e6 - 1e3/$pulserate",dt_task_latency_ms=dt_task_latency_ns/1e6 \
  feedgnuplot  \
    --stream   \
    --lines    \
    --points   \
    --xlen 200 \
    --vnl      \
    --autolegend \
    --xlabel 'Pulse index' \
    --ylabel 'Latency (ms)'
Here I'm making a realtime plot showing The raw data as I tweak things lives here. Initially I see big latency spikes:
timings.scheduler.1.noise.svg
These can be fixed by adjusting the priority of the trigger task. This tells the scheduler to wake that task up first, even if something else is currently using the CPU. I do this:
sudo chrt -p 90  pidof trigger 
And I get better-looking latencies:
timings.scheduler.2.clean.svg
During some experiments (not in this dataset) I would see high helper-task timing instabilities as well. These could be fixed by prioritizing the helper task. In this kernel (6.12) the helper task is called kworker/N where N is the CPU index. I tie the trigger process to cpu 0, and priorities all the relevant helpers:
taskset -c 0 ./trigger 58
pgrep -f kworker/0   while   read pid     sudo chrt -p 90 $pid  
This fixes the helper-task latency spikes. OK, so it looks like on the software side we're good to within 0.1ms of the true period. This is in the ballpark of the precision I need; even this might be too high. It's possible to try to push the software to do better: one could look at the kernel sources a bit more, to do smarter things with priorities or to try an -rt kernel. But all this doesn't matter if the serial hardware adds unacceptable delays. Let's look. Let's look at it with a logic analyzer. I use a saleae logic analyzer with sigrok. The tool spits out the samples as it gets them, and an awk script finds the edges and reports the timings to give me a realtime plot.
samplerate=500000;
pulserate=58.;
sigrok-cli -c samplerate=$samplerate -O csv --continuous -C D1 \
  mawk -Winteractive  \
    "prev_logic==0 && \$0==1 \
       
       iedge = NR;
       if(prev_iedge)
        
         di = iedge -prev_iedge;
         dt = di/$samplerate;
         print(dt*1000);
        
       prev_iedge = iedge;
      
      
       prev_logic=\$0;
       "   feedgnuplot --stream --ylabel 'Period (ms)' --equation "1000./$pulserate title \"True $ pulserate Hz period\""
On the server I was using (physical RS-232 port, ancient 3.something kernel):
timings.hw.serial-server.svg
OK This is very discrete for some reason, and generally worse than 0.1ms. What about my laptop (physical RS-232 port, recent 6.12 kernel)?
timings.hw.serial-laptop.svg
Not discrete anymore, but not really any more precise. What about using a usb-serial converter? I expect this to be worse.
timings.hw.usbserial.svg
Yeah, looks worse. For my purposes, an accuracy of 0.1ms is marginal, and the hardware adds non-negligible errors. So I cut my losses, and use an external signal generator:
timings.hw.generator.svg
Yeah. That's better, so that's what I use.

11 March 2025

Freexian Collaborators: Debian Contributions: Debian.Social administration, DebConf 25 preparations, Fixing Time-based test failure in Python requests package and more! (by Anupa Ann Joseph)

Debian Contributions: 2025-02 Contributing to Debian is part of Freexian s mission. This article covers the latest achievements of Freexian and their collaborators. All of this is made possible by organizations subscribing to our Long Term Support contracts and consulting services.

Debian.Social administration, by Stefano Rivera Over the last year, the Debian.social services outgrew the infrastructure that was supporting them. The matrix bridge in particular was hosted on a cloud instance backed by a large expensive storage volume. Debian.CH rented a new large physical server to host all these instances, earlier this year. Stefano set up Incus on the new physical machine and migrated all the old debian.social LXC Containers, libvirt VMs, and cloud instances into Incus-managed LXC containers. Stefano set up Prometheus monitoring and alerts for the new infrastructure and a Grafana dashboard. The current stack of debian.social services seem to comfortably fit on the new machine, with good room to grow.

DebConf 25, by Santiago Ruano Rinc n and Stefano Rivera DebConf 25 preparations continue. The team is currently finalizing a budget. Stefano helped to review the current budget proposals and suggest approaches for balancing it. Stefano installed a Zammad instance to organize queries from attendees, for the registration and visa teams. Santiago continued discussions with possible caterers so we can have options for the different diet requirements and that could fit into the DebConf budget. Also, in collaboration with Anupa, Santiago pushed the first draft changes to document the venue information in the DebConf 25 website and how to get to Brest.

Time-based test failure in requests, by Colin Watson Colin fixed a fun bug in the Python requests package. Santiago Vila has been running tests of what happens when Debian packages are built on a system in which time has been artificially set to somewhere around the end of the support period for the next Debian release, in order to make it easier to do things like issuing security updates for the lifetime of that release. In this case, the failure indicated an expired test certificate, and since the repository already helpfully included scripts to regenerate those certificates, it seemed natural to try regenerating them just before running tests. However, this failed for more obscure reasons and Colin spent some time investigating. This turned out to be because the test CA was missing the CA constraint and so recent versions of OpenSSL reject it; Colin sent a pull request to fix this.

Priority list for outdated packages, by Santiago Ruano Rinc n Santiago started a discussion on debian-devel about packages that have a history of security issues and that are outdated regarding new upstream releases. The goal of the mentioned effort is to have a prioritized list of packages needing some work, from a security point of view. Moreover, the aim of publicly sharing the list of packages with the Debian Developers community is to make it easier to look at the packages maintained by teams, or even other maintainers where help could be welcome. Santiago is planning to take into account the feedback provided in debian-devel and to propose a tooling that could help to regularly bring collective awareness of these packages.

Miscellaneous contributions
  • Carles worked on English to Catalan po-debconf translations: reviewed translations, created merge requests and followed up with developers for more than 30 packages using po-debconf-manager.
  • Carles helped users, fixed bugs and implemented downloading updated templates on po-debconf-manager.
  • Carles packaged a new upstream version of python-pyaarlo.
  • Carles improved reproducibility of qnetload (now reported as reproducible) and simplemonitor (followed up with upstream and pending update of Debian package).
  • Carles collaborated with debian-history package: fixed FTBFS from master branch, enabled salsa-ci and investigated reproducibility.
  • Emilio improved support for automatically marking CVEs as NOT-FOR-US in the security-tracker, closing #1073012.
  • Emilio updated xorg-server and xwayland in unstable, fixing the last round of security vulnerabilities.
  • Stefano prepared a few PyPy and cPython uploads, and started the python3.13-only transition.
  • Helmut Grohne sent patches for 24 cross build failures.
  • Helmut fixed two problems in the Debian /usr-merge analysis tool. In one instance, it would overmatch Debian bugs to issues and in another it would fail to recognize Pre-Depends as a conflict mechanism.
  • Helmut attempted making rebootstrap work for gcc-15 with limited success as very many packages FTBFS with gcc-15 due to using function declarations without arguments.
  • Helmut provided a change to the security-tracker that would pre-compute /data/json during database updates rather than on demand resulting in a reduced response time.
  • Colin uploaded OpenSSH security updates for testing/unstable, bookworm, bullseye, buster, and stretch.
  • Colin fixed upstream monitoring for 26 Python packages, and upgraded 54 packages (mostly Python-related, but also PuTTY) to new upstream versions.
  • Colin updated python-django in bookworm-backports to 4.2.18 (issuing BSA-121), and added new backports of python-django-dynamic-fixture and python-django-pgtrigger, all of which are dependencies of debusine.
  • Thorsten Alteholz finally managed to upload hplip to fix two release critical and some normal bugs. The next step in March would be to upload the latest version of hplip.
  • Faidon updated crun in unstable & trixie, resolving a long-standing request of enabling criu support and thus enabling podman with checkpoint/restore functionality (With gratitude to Salvatore Bonaccorso and Reinhard Tartler for the cooperation and collaboration).
  • Faidon uploaded a number of packages (librdkafka, libmaxminddb, python-maxminddb, lowdown, tox, tox-uv, pyproject-api, xiccd and gdnsd) bringing them up to date with new upstream releases, resolving various bugs.
  • Lucas Kanashiro uploaded some ruby packages involved in the Rails 7 transition with new upstream releases.
  • Lucas triaged a ruby3.1 bug (#1092595)) and prepared a fix for the next stable release update.
  • Lucas set up the needed wiki pages and updated the Debian Project status in the Outreachy portal, in order to send out a call for projects and mentors for the next round of Outreachy.
  • Anupa joined Santiago to prepare a list of companies to contact via LinkedIn for DebConf 25 sponsorship.
  • Anupa printed Debian stickers and sponsorship brochures, flyers for DebConf 25 to be distributed at FOSS ASIA summit 2025.
  • Anupa participated in the Debian publicity team meeting and discussed the upcoming events and tasks.
  • Rapha l packaged zim 0.76.1 and integrated an upstream patch for another regression that he reported.
  • Rapha l worked with the Debian System Administrators for tracker.debian.org to better cope with gmail s requirement for mails to be authenticated.

9 March 2025

Lisandro Dami n Nicanor P rez Meyer: Bah a Blanca floods - Mother nature says: no Nuremberg for you today

Update 20250309 13:20-03:00 - How to help A friend of mine living in the USA sent me this link to help the flood victims: Support Bah a Blanca (Argentina) Flood Victims Original blog post These are not good news. In fact, much the contrary. Compared to the real issue, the fact that I'm not able to attend Embedded World at Nuremberg is, well, a detail. Or at least that's what I'm forcing myself to believe, as I REALLY wanted to be there. But mother nature said otherwise. Plaza Dr. Alberto Martinelli - Barrio Parque Las Ca itas Park "D. Alberto Martinelli", Las Ca itas, Bah a Blanca (Google Maps) Bah a Blanca , the city I live, has received a lot on rainfall. Really, a lot. Let me introduce the number like this: the previous highest recorded measurement was 170mm (6.69 inch)... in a month. Yesterday Friday 07 we had more than 400mm (15.75 inch) in 9 hours. But those are just numbers. Some things are better seen in images. I'll start with some soft ones. Streetk sink 1 Streetk sink 2 Sink in Fournier street near Cambaceres (Google Maps) I also happen to do figure skating in the same school of the 4 times world champions (where "world" means the whole world) Roller Dreams precision skating team - Instagram, from Club El Nacional. Our skating rink got severely damaged with the hail we had like 3 weeks ago (yes, we had hail too!!!). Now it's just impossible: Roller Dreams CEN skating rink The "real" thing Let's get to the heavy, heartbreaker part. I did go to downtown Bah a Blanca, but during night, so let me share some links, most of them in Spanish, but images are images: My alma matter, Universidad Nacional del Sur, lost its main library, great part of the Physics department and a lot of labs :-( A nearby town, General Cerri, had even worst luck. In Bah a Blanca, a city of 300k+ people, has around 400 evacuated people. General Cerri, a town of 3000? people, had at least 800. Bah a Blanca, devil's land Every place has its legends. We do too. This land was called "Huecuv Map ", something like "Devil's land" by the original inhabitants of the zone, due to its harsh climate: string winters and hot summers, couple with fierce wind. But back in 1855 the Cacique (chief) Jos Mar a Bulnes Yanquetruz had a peace agreement with commander Nicanor Otamendi. But a battle ensued, which Yanquetruz won. At this point history defers depending upon who tells it. Some say Yanquetruz was assigned a military grade as Captain of the indigenous auxiliary forces and provided a military suit, some say he stole it, some say this was a setup of another chief wanting to disrupt peace. But what is known is that Yanquetruz was killed, and his wife, the "machi" (sorceress), issued a curse over the land that would last 1000 years, and the curse was on the climate. Aftermath No, we are not there yet. This has just happened. The third violent climate occurrence in 15 months. The city needs to mourn and start healing itself. Time will say.

Niels Thykier: Improving Debian packaging in Kate

The other day, I noted that the emacs integration with debputy stopped working. After debugging for a while, I realized that emacs no longer sent the didOpen notification that is expected of it, which confused debputy. At this point, I was already several hours into the debugging and I noted there was some discussions on debian-devel about emacs and byte compilation not working. So I figured I would shelve the emacs problem for now. But I needed an LSP capable editor and with my vi skills leaving much to be desired, I skipped out on vim-youcompleteme. Instead, I pulled out kate, which I had not been using for years. It had LSP support, so it would fine, right? Well, no. Turns out that debputy LSP support had some assumptions that worked for emacs but not kate. Plus once you start down the rabbit hole, you stumble on things you missed previously.
Getting started First order of business was to tell kate about debputy. Conveniently, kate has a configuration tab for adding language servers in a JSON format right next to the tab where you can see its configuration for built-in LSP (also in JSON format9. So a quick bit of copy-paste magic and that was done. Yesterday, I opened an MR against upstream to have the configuration added (https://invent.kde.org/utilities/kate/-/merge_requests/1748) and they already merged it. Today, I then filed a wishlist against kate in Debian to have the Debian maintainers cherry-pick it, so it works out of the box for Trixie (https://bugs.debian.org/1099876). So far so good.
Inlay hint woes Since July (2024), debputy has support for Inlay hints. They are basically small bits of text that the LSP server can ask the editor to inject into the text to provide hints to the reader. Typically, you see them used to provide typing hints, where the editor or the underlying LSP server has figured out the type of a variable or expression that you did not explicitly type. Another common use case is to inject the parameter name for positional arguments when calling a function, so the user do not have to count the position to figure out which value is passed as which parameter. In debputy, I have been using the Inlay hints to show inherited fields in debian/control. As an example, if you have a definition like:
Source: foo-src
Section: devel
Priority: optional
Package: foo-bin
Architecture: any
Then foo-bin inherits the Section and Priority field since it does not supply its own. Previously, debputy would that by injecting the fields themselves and their value just below the Package field as if you had typed them out directly. The editor always renders Inlay hints distinctly from regular text, so there was no risk of confusion and it made the text look like a valid debian/control file end to end. The result looked something like:
Source: foo-src
Section: devel
Priority: optional
Package: foo-bin
Section: devel
Priority: optional
Architecture: any
With the second instances of Section and Priority being rendered differently than its surrendering (usually faded or colorlessly). Unfortunately, kate did not like injecting Inlay hints with a newline in them, which was needed for this trick. Reading into the LSP specs, it says nothing about multi-line Inlay hints being a thing and I figured I would see this problem again with other editors if I left it be. I ended up changing the Inlay hints to be placed at the end of the Package field and then included surrounding () for better visuals. So now, it looks like:
Source: foo-src
Section: devel
Priority: optional
Package: foo-bin  (Section: devel)  (Priority: optional)
Architecture: any
Unfortunately, it is no longer 1:1 with the underlying syntax which I liked about the previous one. But it works in more editors and is still explicit. I also removed the Inlay hint for the Homepage field. It takes too much space and I have yet to meet someone missing it in the binary stanza. If you have any better ideas for how to render it, feel free to reach out to me.
Spurious completion and hover As I was debugging the Inlay hints, I wanted to do a quick restart of debputy after each fix. Then I would trigger a small change to the document to ensure kate would request an update from debputy to render the Inlay hints with the new code. The full outgoing payloads are sent via the logs to the client, so it was really about minimizing which LSP requests are sent to debputy. Notably, two cases would flood the log:
  • Completion requests. These are triggered by typing anything at all and since I wanted to a change, I could not avoid this. So here it was about making sure there would be nothing to complete, so the result was a small as possible.
  • Hover doc requests. These are triggered by mouse hovering over field, so this was mostly about ensuring my mouse movement did not linger over any field on the way between restarting the LSP server and scrolling the log in kate.
In my infinite wisdom, I chose to make a comment line where I would do the change. I figured it would neuter the completion requests completely and it should not matter if my cursor landed on the comment as there would be no hover docs for comments either. Unfortunately for me, debputy would ignore the fact that it was on a comment line. Instead, it would find the next field after the comment line and try to complete based on that. Normally you do not see this, because the editor correctly identifies that none of the completion suggestions start with a \#, so they are all discarded. But it was pretty annoying for the debugging, so now debputy has been told to explicitly stop these requests early on comment lines.
Hover docs for packages I added a feature in debputy where you can hover over package names in your relationship fields (such as Depends) and debputy will render a small snippet about it based on data from your local APT cache. This doc is then handed to the editor and tagged as markdown provided the editor supports markdown rendering. Both emacs and kate support markdown. However, not all markdown renderings are equal. Notably, emacs's rendering does not reformat the text into paragraphs. In a sense, emacs rendering works a bit like <pre>...</pre> except it does a bit of fancy rendering inside the <pre>...</pre>. On the other hand, kate seems to convert the markdown to HTML and then throw the result into an HTML render engine. Here it is important to remember that not all newlines are equal in markdown. A Foo<newline>Bar is treated as one "paragraph" (<p>...</p>) and the HTML render happily renders this as single line Foo Bar provided there is sufficient width to do so. A couple of extra newlines made wonders for the kate rendering, but I have a feeling this is not going to be the last time the hover docs will need some tweaking for prettification. Feel free to reach out if you spot a weirdly rendered hover doc somewhere.
Making quickfixes available in kate Quickfixes are treated as generic code actions in the LSP specs. Each code action has a "type" (kind in the LSP lingo), which enables the editor to group the actions accordingly or filter by certain types of code actions. The design in the specs leads to the following flow:
  1. The LSP server provides the editor with diagnostics (there are multiple ways to trigger this, so we will keep this part simple).
  2. The editor renders them to the user and the user chooses to interact with one of them.
  3. The interaction makes the editor asks the LSP server, which code actions are available at that location (optionally with filter to only see quickfixes).
  4. The LSP server looks at the provided range and is expected to return the relevant quickfixes here.
This flow is really annoying from a LSP server writer point of view. When you do the diagnostics (in step 1), you tend to already know what the possible quickfixes would be. The LSP spec authors realized this at some point, so there are two features the editor provides to simplify this.
  1. In the editor request for code actions, the editor is expected to provide the diagnostics that they received from the server. Side note: I cannot quite tell if this is optional or required from the spec.
  2. The editor can provide support for remembering a data member in each diagnostic. The server can then store arbitrary information in that member, which they will see again in the code actions request. Again, provided that the editor supports this optional feature.
All the quickfix logic in debputy so far has hinged on both of these two features. As life would have it, kate provides neither of them. Which meant I had to teach debputy to keep track of its diagnostics on its own. The plus side is that makes it easier to support "pull diagnostics" down the line, since it requires a similar feature. Additionally, it also means that quickfixes are now available in more editors. For consistency, debputy logic is now always used rather than relying on the editor support when present. The downside is that I had to spend hours coming up with and debugging a way to find the diagnostics that overlap with the range provided by the editor. The most difficult part was keeping the logic straight and getting the runes correct for it.
Making the quickfixes actually work With all of that, kate would show the quickfixes for diagnostics from debputy and you could use them too. However, they would always apply twice with suboptimal outcome as a result. The LSP spec has multiple ways of defining what need to be changed in response to activating a code action. In debputy, all edits are currently done via the WorkspaceEdit type. It has two ways of defining the changes. Either via changes or documentChanges with documentChanges being the preferred one if both parties support this. I originally read that as I was allowed to provide both and the editor would pick the one it preferred. However, after seeing kate blindly use both when they are present, I reviewed the spec and it does say "The edit should either provide changes or documentChanges", so I think that one is on me. None of the changes in debputy currently require documentChanges, so I went with just using changes for now despite it not being preferred. I cannot figure out the logic of whether an editor supports documentChanges. As I read the notes for this part of the spec, my understanding is that kate does not announce its support for documentChanges but it clearly uses them when present. Therefore, I decided to keep it simple for now until I have time to dig deeper.
Remaining limitations with kate There is one remaining limitation with kate that I have not yet solved. The kate program uses KSyntaxHighlighting for its language detection, which in turn is the basis for which LSP server is assigned to a given document. This engine does not seem to support as complex detection logic as I hoped from it. Concretely, it either works on matching on an extension / a basename (same field for both cases) or mime type. This combined with our habit in Debian to use extension less files like debian/control vs. debian/tests/control or debian/rules or debian/upstream/metadata makes things awkward a best. Concretely, the syntax engine cannot tell debian/control from debian/tests/control as they use the same basename. Fortunately, the syntax is close enough to work for both and debputy is set to use filename based lookups, so this case works well enough. However, for debian/rules and debian/upstream/metadata, my understanding is that if I assign these in the syntax engine as Debian files, these rules will also trigger for any file named foo.rules or bar.metadata. That seems a bit too broad for me, so I have opted out of that for now. The down side is that these files will not work out of the box with kate for now. The current LSP configuration in kate does not recognize makefiles or YAML either. Ideally, we would assign custom languages for the affected Debian files, so we do not steal the ID from other language servers. Notably, kate has a built-in language server for YAML and debputy does nothing for a generic YAML document. However, adding YAML as a supported language for debputy would cause conflict and regressions for users that are already happy with their generic YAML language server from kate. So there are certainly still work to be done. If you are good with KSyntaxHighlighting and know how to solve some of this, I hope you will help me out.
Changes unrelated to kate While I was working on debputy, I also added some other features that I want to mention.
  1. The debputy lint command will now show related context to diagnostic in its terminal report when such information is available and is from the same file as the diagnostic itself (cross file cases are rendered without related information). The related information is typically used to highlight a source of a conflict. As an example, if you use the same field twice in a stanza of debian/control, then debputy will add a diagnostic to the second occurrence. The related information for that diagnostic would provide the position of the first occurrence. This should make it easier to find the source of the conflict in the cases where debputy provides it. Let me know if you are missing it for certain diagnostics.

  2. The diagnostics analysis of debian/control will now identify and flag simple duplicated relations (complex ones like OR relations are ignored for now). Thanks to Matthias Geiger for suggesting the feature and Otto Kek l inen for reporting a false positive that is now fixed.

Closing I am glad I tested with kate to weed out most of these issues in time before the freeze. The Debian freeze will start within a week from now. Since debputy is a part of the toolchain packages it will be frozen from there except for important bug fixes.

8 March 2025

Debian Brasil: MiniDebConf Belo Horizonte 2024 - a brief report

From April 27th to 30th, 2024, MiniDebConf Belo Horizonte 2024 was held at the Pampulha Campus of UFMG - Federal University of Minas Gerais, in Belo Horizonte city. MiniDebConf BH 2024 banners This was the fifth time that a MiniDebConf (as an exclusive in-person event about Debian) took place in Brazil. Previous editions were in Curitiba (2016, 2017, and 2018), and in Bras lia 2023. We had other MiniDebConfs editions held within Free Software events such as FISL and Latinoware, and other online events. See our event history. Parallel to MiniDebConf, on 27th (Saturday) FLISOL - Latin American Free Software Installation Festival took place. It's the largest event in Latin America to promote Free Software, and It has been held since 2005 simultaneously in several cities. MiniDebConf Belo Horizonte 2024 was a success (as were previous editions) thanks to the participation of everyone, regardless of their level of knowledge about Debian. We value the presence of both beginner users who are familiarizing themselves with the system and the official project developers. The spirit of welcome and collaboration was present during all the event. MiniDebConf BH 2024 flisol 2024 edition numbers During the four days of the event, several activities took place for all levels of users and collaborators of the Debian project. The official schedule was composed of: MiniDebConf BH 2024 palestra The final numbers for MiniDebConf Belo Horizonte 2024 show that we had a record number of participants. Of the 224 participants, 15 were official Brazilian contributors, 10 being DDs (Debian Developers) and 05 (Debian Maintainers), in addition to several unofficial contributors. The organization was carried out by 14 people who started working at the end of 2023, including Prof. Lo c Cerf from the Computing Department who made the event possible at UFMG, and 37 volunteers who helped during the event. As MiniDebConf was held at UFMG facilities, we had the help of more than 10 University employees. See the list with the names of people who helped in some way in organizing MiniDebConf Belo Horizonte 2024. The difference between the number of people registered and the number of attendees in the event is probably explained by the fact that there is no registration fee, so if the person decides not to go to the event, they will not suffer financial losses. The 2024 edition of MiniDebconf Belo Horizonte was truly grand and shows the result of the constant efforts made over the last few years to attract more contributors to the Debian community in Brazil. With each edition the numbers only increase, with more attendees, more activities, more rooms, and more sponsors/supporters. MiniDebConf BH 2024 grupo

MiniDebConf BH 2024 grupo Activities The MiniDebConf schedule was intense and diverse. On the 27th, 29th and 30th (Saturday, Monday and Tuesday) we had talks, discussions, workshops and many practical activities. MiniDebConf BH 2024 palestra On the 28th (Sunday), the Day Trip took place, a day dedicated to sightseeing around the city. In the morning we left the hotel and went, on a chartered bus, to the Belo Horizonte Central Market. People took the opportunity to buy various things such as cheeses, sweets, cacha as and souvenirs, as well as tasting some local foods. MiniDebConf BH 2024 mercado After a 2-hour tour of the Market, we got back on the bus and hit the road for lunch at a typical Minas Gerais food restaurant. MiniDebConf BH 2024 palestra With everyone well fed, we returned to Belo Horizonte to visit the city's main tourist attraction: Lagoa da Pampulha and Capela S o Francisco de Assis, better known as Igrejinha da Pampulha. MiniDebConf BH 2024 palestra We went back to the hotel and the day ended in the hacker space that we set up in the events room for people to chat, packaging, and eat pizzas. MiniDebConf BH 2024 palestra Crowdfunding For the third time we ran a crowdfunding campaign and it was incredible how people contributed! The initial goal was to raise the amount equivalent to a gold tier of R$ 3,000.00. When we reached this goal, we defined a new one, equivalent to one gold tier + one silver tier (R$ 5,000.00). And again we achieved this goal. So we proposed as a final goal the value of a gold + silver + bronze tiers, which would be equivalent to R$ 6,000.00. The result was that we raised R$7,239.65 (~ USD 1,400) with the help of more than 100 people! Thank you very much to the people who contributed any amount. As a thank you, we list the names of the people who donated. MiniDebConf BH 2024 doadores Food, accommodation and/or travel grants for participants Each edition of MiniDebConf brought some innovation, or some different benefit for the attendees. In this year's edition in Belo Horizonte, as with DebConfs, we offered bursaries for food, accommodation and/or travel to help those people who would like to come to the event but who would need some kind of help. In the registration form, we included the option for the person to request a food, accommodation and/or travel bursary, but to do so, they would have to identify themselves as a contributor (official or unofficial) to Debian and write a justification for the request. Number of people benefited: The food bursary provided lunch and dinner every day. The lunches included attendees who live in Belo Horizonte and the region. Dinners were paid for attendees who also received accommodation and/or travel. The accommodation was held at the BH Jaragu Hotel. And the travels included airplane or bus tickets, or fuel (for those who came by car or motorbike). Much of the money to fund the bursaries came from the Debian Project, mainly for travels. We sent a budget request to the former Debian leader Jonathan Carter, and He promptly approved our request. In addition to this event budget, the leader also approved individual requests sent by some DDs who preferred to request directly from him. The experience of offering the bursaries was really good because it allowed several people to come from other cities. MiniDebConf BH 2024 grupo Photos and videos You can watch recordings of the talks at the links below: Thanks We would like to thank all the attendees, organizers, volunteers, sponsors and supporters who contributed to the success of MiniDebConf Belo Horizonte 2024. MiniDebConf BH 2024 grupo Sponsors Gold: Silver: Bronze: Organizers

7 March 2025

Paulo Henrique de Lima Santana: Bits from FOSDEM 2025

This year I was at FOSDEM 2025, and it was the fifth edition in a row that I participated in person (before it was in 2019, 2020, 2023 and 2024). The event took place on February 1st and 2nd, as always at the ULB campus in Brussels. We arrived on Friday at lunchtime and went straight to the hotel to drop off our bags. This time we stayed at Ibis in the city center, very close to the hustle and bustle. The price was good and the location was really good for us to be able to go out in the city center and come back late at night. We found a Japanese restaurant near the hotel and it was definitely worth having lunch there because of the all-you-can-eat price. After taking a nap, we went out for a walk. Since January 31st is the last day of the winter sales in the city, the streets in the city center were crowded, there were lots of people in the stores, and the prices were discounted. We concluded that if we have the opportunity to go to Brussels again at this time, it would be better wait to buy clothes for cold weather there.
Fosdem 2025
Unlike in 2023 and 2024, the FOSDEM organization did not approve my request for the Translations DevRoom,so my goal was to participate in the event and collaborate at the Debian booth. And also as I always do, I volunteered to operate the broadcast camera in the main auditorium on both days, for two hours each. The Debian booth:
Fosdem 2025
Me in the auditorium helping with the broadcast:
Fosdem 2025
2 weeks before the event, the organization put out a call for interested people to request a room for their community s BoF (Birds of a Feather), and I requested a room for Debian and it was approved :-) It was great to see that people were really interested in participating at the BoF and the room was packed! As the host of the discussions, I tried to leave the space open for anyone who wanted to talk about any subject related to Debian. We started with a talk from MiniDebConf25 organizers, that will be taking place this year in France. Then other topics followed with people talking, asking and answering questions, etc. It was worth organizing this BoF. Who knows, the idea will remain in 2026.
Fosdem 2025
Carlos (a.k.a Charles), Athos, Ma ra and Melissa talked at Fosdem, and Kanashiro was one for organizers of Distributions DevRoom
Fosdem 2025
During the two days of the event, it didn t rain or get too cold. The days were sunny (and people celebrated the weather in Brussels). But I have to admit that it would have been nice to see snow like I did in 2019. Unlike last year, this time I felt more motivated to stay at the event the whole time. Deixo meu agradecimento especial para o Andreas Tille, atual L der do Debian que aprovou o meu pedido de passagens para que eu pudesse participar dos FOSDEM 2025. Como sempre, essa ajuda foi essencial para viabilizar a minha viagem para Bruxelas. I would like to give my special thanks to Andreas Tille, the current Debian Leader, who approved my request for flight tickets so that I could join FOSDEM 2025. As always, this help was essential in making my trip to Brussels possible. And once again Jandira was with me on this adventure. On Monday we went for a walk around Brussels and we also traveled to visit Bruges again. The visit to this city is really worth it because walking through the historic streets is like going back in time. This time we even took a boat trip through the canals, which was really cool.
Fosdem 2025

Fosdem 2025

6 March 2025

Antoine Beaupr : Nix Notes

Meta In case you haven't noticed, I'm trying to post and one of the things that entails is to just dump over the fence a bunch of draft notes. In this specific case, I had a set of rough notes about NixOS and particularly Nix, the package manager. In this case, you can see the very birth of an article, what it looks like before it becomes the questionable prose it is now, by looking at the Git history of this file, particularly its birth. I have a couple of those left, and it would be pretty easy to publish them as is, but I feel I'd be doing others (and myself! I write for my own documentation too after all) a disservice by not going the extra mile on those. So here's the long version of my experiment with Nix.

Nix A couple friends are real fans of Nix. Just like I work with Puppet a lot, they deploy and maintain servers (if not fleets of servers) with NixOS and its declarative package management system. Essentially, they use it as a configuration management system, which is pretty awesome. That, however, is a bit too high of a bar for me. I rarely try new operating systems these days: I'm a Debian developer and it takes most of my time to keep that functional. I'm not going to go around messing with other systems as I know that would inevitably get me dragged down into contributing into yet another free software project. I'm mature now and know where to draw the line. Right? So I'm just testing Nix, the package manager, on Debian, because I learned from my friend that nixpkgs is the largest package repository out there, a mind-boggling 100,000 at the time of writing (with 88% of packages up to date), compared to around 40,000 in Debian (or 72,000 if you count binary packages, with 72% up to date). I naively thought Debian was the largest, perhaps competing with Arch, and I was wrong: Arch is larger than Debian too. What brought me there is I wanted to run Harper, a fast spell-checker written in Rust. The logic behind using Nix instead of just downloading the source and running it myself is that I delegate the work of supply-chain integrity checking to a distributor, a bit like you trust Debian developers like myself to package things in a sane way. I know this widens the attack surface to a third party of course, but the rationale is that I shift cryptographic verification to another stack than just "TLS + GitHub" (although that is somewhat still involved) that's linked with my current chain (Debian packages). I have since then stopped using Harper for various reasons and also wrapped up my Nix experiment, but felt it worthwhile to jot down some observations on the project.

Hot take Overall, Nix is hard to get into, with a complicated learning curve. I have found the documentation to be a bit confusing, since there are many ways to do certain things. I particularly tripped on "flakes" and, frankly, incomprehensible error reporting. It didn't help that I tried to run nixpkgs on Debian which is technically possible, but you can tell that I'm not supposed to be doing this. My friend who reviewed this article expressed surprised at how easy this was, but then he only saw the finished result, not me tearing my hair out to make this actually work.

Nix on Debian primer So here's how I got started. First I installed the nix binary package:
apt install nix-bin
Then I had to add myself to the right group and logout/log back in to get the rights to deploy Nix packages:
adduser anarcat nix-users
That wasn't easy to find, but is mentioned in the README.Debian file shipped with the Debian package. Then, I didn't write this down, but the README.Debian file above mentions it, so I think I added a "channel" like this:
nix-channel --add https://nixos.org/channels/nixpkgs-unstable nixpkgs
nix-channel --update
And I likely installed the Harper package with:
nix-env --install harper
At this point, harper was installed in a ... profile? Not sure. I had to add ~/.nix-profile/bin (a symlink to /nix/store/sympqw0zyybxqzz6fzhv03lyivqqrq92-harper-0.10.0/bin) to my $PATH environment for this to actually work.

Side notes on documentation Those last two commands (nix-channel and nix-env) were hard to figure out, which is kind of amazing because you'd think a tutorial on Nix would feature something like this prominently. But three different tutorials failed to bring me up to that basic setup, even the README.Debian didn't spell that out clearly. The tutorials all show me how to develop packages for Nix, not plainly how to install Nix software. This is presumably because "I'm doing it wrong": you shouldn't just "install a package", you should setup an environment declaratively and tell it what you want to do. But here's the thing: I didn't want to "do the right thing". I just wanted to install Harper, and documentation failed to bring me to that basic "hello world" stage. Here's what one of the tutorials suggests as a first step, for example:
curl -L https://nixos.org/nix/install   sh
nix-shell --packages cowsay lolcat
nix-collect-garbage
... which, when you follow through, leaves you with almost precisely nothing left installed (apart from Nix itself, setup with a nasty "curl pipe bash". So while that works in testing Nix, you're not much better off than when you started.

Rolling back everything Now that I have stopped using Harper, I don't need Nix anymore, which I'm sure my Nix friends will be sad to read about. Don't worry, I have notes now, and can try again! But still, I wanted to clear things out, so I did this, as root:
deluser anarcat nix-users
apt purge nix-bin
rm -rf /nix ~/.nix*
I think this cleared things out, but I'm not actually sure.

Side note on Nix drama This blurb wouldn't be complete without a mention that the Nix community has been somewhat tainted by the behavior of its founder. I won't bother you too much with this; LWN covered it well in 2024, and made a followup article about spinoffs and forks that's worth reading as well. I did want to say that everyone I have been in contact with in the Nix community was absolutely fantastic. So I am really sad that the behavior of a single individual can pollute a community in such a way. As a leader, if you have all but one responsability, it's to behave properly for people around you. It's actually really, really hard to do that, because yes, it means you need to act differently than others and no, you just don't get to be upset at others like you would normally do with friends, because you're in a position of authority. It's a lesson I'm still learning myself, to be fair. But at least I don't work with arms manufacturers or, if I would, I would be sure as hell to accept the nick (or nix?) on the chin when people would get upset, and try to make amends. So long live the Nix people! I hope the community recovers from that dark moment, so far it seems like it will. And thanks for helping me test Harper!

Russell Coker: 8k Video Cards

I previously blogged about getting an 8K TV [1]. Now I m working on getting 8K video out for a computer that talks to it. I borrowed an NVidia RTX A2000 card which according to it s specs can do 8K [2] with a mini-DisplayPort to HDMI cable rated at 8K but on both Windows and Linux the two highest resolutions on offer are 3840*2160 (regular 4K) and 4096*2160 which is strange and not useful. The various documents on the A2000 differ on whether it has DisplayPort version 1.4 or 1.4a. According to the DisplayPort Wikipedia page [3] both versions 1.4 and 1.4a have a maximum of HBR3 speed and the difference is what version of DSC (Display Stream Compression [4]) is in use. DSC apparently causes no noticeable loss of quality for movies or games but apparently can be bad for text. According to the DisplayPort Wikipedia page version 1.4 can do 8K uncompressed at 30Hz or 24Hz with high dynamic range. So this should be able to work. My theories as to why it doesn t work are: To get some more input on this issue I posted on Lemmy, here is the Lemmy post [5]. I signed up to lemmy.ml because it was the first one I found that seemed reasonable and was giving away free accounts, I haven t tried any others and can t review it but it seems to work well enough and it s free. It s described as A community of privacy and FOSS enthusiasts, run by Lemmy s developers which is positive, I recommend that everyone who s into FOSS create an account there or some other Lemmy server. My Lemmy post was about what video cards to buy. I was looking at the Gigabyte RX 6400 Eagle 4G as a cheap card from a local store that does 8K, it also does DisplayPort 1.4 so might have the same issues, also apparently FOSS drivers don t support 8K on HDMI because the people who manage HDMI specs are jerks. It s a $200 card at MSY and a bit less on ebay so it s an amount I can afford to risk on a product that might not do what I want, but it seems to have a high probability of getting the same result. The NVidia cards have the option of proprietary drivers which allow using HDMI and there are cards with DisplayPort 1.4 (which can do 8K@30Hz) and HDMI 2.1 (which can do 8K@50Hz). So HDMI is a better option for some cards just based on card output and has the additional benefit of not needing DisplayPort to HDMI conversion. The best option apparently is the Intel cards which do DisplayPort internally and convert to HDMI in hardware which avoids the issue of FOSS drivers for HDMI at 8K. The Intel Arc B580 has nice specs [6], HDMI 2.1a and DisplayPort 2.1 output, 12G of RAM, and being faster than the low end cards like the RX 6400. But the local computer store price is $470 and the ebay price is a bit over $400. If it turns out to not do what I need it still will be a long way from the worst way I ve wasted money on computer gear. But I m still hesitating about this. Any suggestions?

5 March 2025

Reproducible Builds: Reproducible Builds in February 2025

Welcome to the second report in 2025 from the Reproducible Builds project. Our monthly reports outline what we ve been up to over the past month, and highlight items of news from elsewhere in the increasingly-important area of software supply-chain security. As usual, however, if you are interested in contributing to the Reproducible Builds project, please visit our Contribute page on our website. Table of contents:
  1. Reproducible Builds at FOSDEM 2025
  2. Reproducible Builds at PyCascades 2025
  3. Does Functional Package Management Enable Reproducible Builds at Scale?
  4. reproduce.debian.net updates
  5. Upstream patches
  6. Distribution work
  7. diffoscope & strip-nondeterminism
  8. Website updates
  9. Reproducibility testing framework

Reproducible Builds at FOSDEM 2025 Similar to last year s event, there was considerable activity regarding Reproducible Builds at FOSDEM 2025, held on on 1st and 2nd February this year in Brussels, Belgium. We count at least four talks related to reproducible builds. (You can also read our news report from last year s event in which Holger Levsen presented in the main track.)
Jelle van der Waa, Holger Levsen and kpcyrd presented in the Distributions track on A Tale of several distros joining forces for a common goal. In this talk, three developers from two different Linux distributions (Arch Linux and Debian), discuss this goal which is, of course, reproducible builds. The presenters discuss both what is shared and different between the two efforts, touching on the history and future challenges alike. The slides of this talk are available to view, as is the full video (30m02s). The talk was also discussed on Hacker News.
Zbigniew J drzejewski-Szmek presented in the ever-popular Python track a on Rewriting .pyc files for fun and reproducibility, i.e. the bytecode files generated by Python in order to speed up module imports: It s been known for a while that those are not reproducible: on different architectures, the bytecode for exactly the same sources ends up slightly different. The slides of this talk are available, as is the full video (28m32s).
In the Nix and NixOS track, Julien Malka presented on the Saturday asking How reproducible is NixOS: We know that the NixOS ISO image is very close to be perfectly reproducible thanks to reproducible.nixos.org, but there doesn t exist any monitoring of Nixpkgs as a whole. In this talk I ll present the findings of a project that evaluated the reproducibility of Nixpkgs as a whole by mass rebuilding packages from revisions between 2017 and 2023 and comparing the results with the NixOS cache. Unfortunately, no video of the talk is available, but there is a blog and article on the results.
Lastly, Simon Tournier presented in the Open Research track on the confluence of GNU Guix and Software Heritage: Source Code Archiving to the Rescue of Reproducible Deployment. Simon s talk describes design and implementation we came up and reports on the archival coverage for package source code with data collected over five years. It opens to some remaining challenges toward a better open and reproducible research. The slides for the talk are available, as is the full video (23m17s).

Reproducible Builds at PyCascades 2025 Vagrant Cascadian presented at this year s PyCascades conference which was held on February 8th and 9th February in Portland, OR, USA. PyCascades is a regional instance of PyCon held in the Pacific Northwest. Vagrant s talk, entitled Re-Py-Ducible Builds caught the audience s attention with the following abstract:
Crank your Python best practices up to 11 with Reproducible Builds! This talk will explore Reproducible Builds by highlighting issues identified in Python projects, from the simple to the seemingly inscrutable. Reproducible Builds is basically the crazy idea that when you build something, and you build it again, you get the exact same thing or even more important, if someone else builds it, they get the exact same thing too.
More info is available on the talk s page.

Does Functional Package Management Enable Reproducible Builds at Scale? On our mailing list last month, Julien Malka, Stefano Zacchiroli and Th o Zimmermann of T l com Paris in-house research laboratory, the Information Processing and Communications Laboratory (LTCI) announced that they had published an article asking the question: Does Functional Package Management Enable Reproducible Builds at Scale? (PDF). This month, however, Ludovic Court s followed up to the original announcement on our mailing list mentioning, amongst other things, the Guix Data Service and how that it shows the reproducibility of GNU Guix over time, as described in a GNU Guix blog back in March 2024.

reproduce.debian.net updates The last few months have seen the introduction of reproduce.debian.net. Announced first at the recent Debian MiniDebConf in Toulouse, reproduce.debian.net is an instance of rebuilderd operated by the Reproducible Builds project. Powering this work is rebuilderd, our server which monitors the official package repositories of Linux distributions and attempt to reproduce the observed results there. This month, however, Holger Levsen:
  • Split packages that are not specific to any architecture away from amd64.reproducible.debian.net service into a new all.reproducible.debian.net page.
  • Increased the number of riscv64 nodes to a total of 4, and added a new amd64 node added thanks to our (now 10-year sponsor), IONOS.
  • Discovered an issue in the Debian build service where some new incoming build-dependencies do not end up historically archived.
  • Uploaded the devscripts package, incorporating changes from Jochen Sprickerhof to the debrebuild script specifically to fix the handling the Rules-Requires-Root header in Debian source packages.
  • Uploaded a number of Rust dependencies of rebuilderd (rust-libbz2-rs-sys, rust-actix-web, rust-actix-server, rust-actix-http, rust-actix-server, rust-actix-http, rust-actix-web-codegen and rust-time-tz) after they were prepared by kpcyrd :
Jochen Sprickerhof also updated the sbuild package to:
  • Obey requests from the user/developer for a different temporary directory.
  • Use the root/superuser for some values of Rules-Requires-Root.
  • Don t pass --root-owner-group to old versions of dpkg.
and additionally requested that many Debian packages are rebuilt by the build servers in order to work around bugs found on reproduce.debian.net. [ ][[ ][ ]
Lastly, kpcyrd has also worked towards getting rebuilderd packaged in NixOS, and Jelle van der Waa picked up the existing pull request for Fedora support within in rebuilderd and made it work with the existing Koji rebuilderd script. The server is being packaged for Fedora in an unofficial copr repository and in the official repositories after all the dependencies are packaged.

Upstream patches The Reproducible Builds project detects, dissects and attempts to fix as many currently-unreproducible packages as possible. We endeavour to send all of our patches upstream where appropriate. This month, we wrote a large number of such patches, including:

Distribution work There as been the usual work in various distributions this month, such as: In Debian, 17 reviews of Debian packages were added, 6 were updated and 8 were removed this month adding to our knowledge about identified issues.
Fedora developers Davide Cavalca and Zbigniew J drzejewski-Szmek gave a talk on Reproducible Builds in Fedora (PDF), touching on SRPM-specific issues as well as the current status and future plans.
Thanks to an investment from the Sovereign Tech Agency, the FreeBSD project s work on unprivileged and reproducible builds continued this month. Notable fixes include:
The Yocto Project has been struggling to upgrade to the latest Go and Rust releases due to reproducibility problems in the newer versions. Hongxu Jia tracked down the issue with Go which meant that the project could upgrade from the 1.22 series to 1.24, with the fix being submitted upstream for review (see above). For Rust, however, the project was significantly behind, but has made recent progress after finally identifying the blocking reproducibility issues. At time of writing, the project is at Rust version 1.82, with patches under review for 1.83 and 1.84 and fixes being discussed with the Rust developers. The project hopes to improve the tests for reproducibility in the Rust project itself in order to try and avoid future regressions. Yocto continues to maintain its ability to binary reproduce all of the recipes in OpenEmbedded-Core, regardless of the build host distribution or the current build path.
Finally, Douglas DeMaio published an article on the openSUSE blog on announcing that the Reproducible-openSUSE (RBOS) Project Hits [Significant] Milestone. In particular:
The Reproducible-openSUSE (RBOS) project, which is a proof-of-concept fork of openSUSE, has reached a significant milestone after demonstrating a usable Linux distribution can be built with 100% bit-identical packages.
This news was also announced on our mailing list by Bernhard M. Wiedemann, who also published another report for openSUSE as well.

diffoscope & strip-nondeterminism diffoscope is our in-depth and content-aware diff utility that can locate and diagnose reproducibility issues. This month, Chris Lamb made the following changes, including preparing and uploading versions 288 and 289 to Debian:
  • Add asar to DIFFOSCOPE_FAIL_TESTS_ON_MISSING_TOOLS in order to address Debian bug #1095057) [ ]
  • Catch a CalledProcessError when calling html2text. [ ]
  • Update the minimal Black version. [ ]
Additionally, Vagrant Cascadian updated diffoscope in GNU Guix to version 287 [ ][ ] and 288 [ ][ ] as well as submitted a patch to update to 289 [ ]. Vagrant also fixed an issue that was breaking reprotest on Guix [ ][ ]. strip-nondeterminism is our sister tool to remove specific non-deterministic results from a completed build. This month version 1.14.1-2 was uploaded to Debian unstable by Holger Levsen.

Website updates There were a large number of improvements made to our website this month, including:

Reproducibility testing framework The Reproducible Builds project operates a comprehensive testing framework running primarily at tests.reproducible-builds.org in order to check packages and other artifacts for reproducibility. In January, a number of changes were made by Holger Levsen, including:
  • reproduce.debian.net-related:
    • Add a helper script to manually schedule packages. [ ][ ][ ][ ][ ]
    • Fix a link in the website footer. [ ]
    • Strip the emojis from package names on the manual rebuilder in order to ease copy-and-paste. [ ]
    • On the various statistics pages, provide the number of affected source packages [ ][ ] as well as provide various totals [ ][ ].
    • Fix graph labels for the various architectures [ ][ ] and make them clickable too [ ][ ][ ].
    • Break the displayed HTML in blocks of 256 packages in order to address rendering issues. [ ][ ]
    • Add monitoring jobs for riscv64 archicture nodes and integrate them elsewhere in our infrastructure. [ ][ ]
    • Add riscv64 architecture nodes. [ ][ ][ ][ ][ ]
    • Update much of the documentation. [ ][ ][ ]
    • Make a number of improvements to the layout and style. [ ][ ][ ][ ][ ][ ][ ]
    • Remove direct links to JSON and database backups. [ ]
    • Drop a Blues Brothers reference from frontpage. [ ]
  • Debian-related:
    • Deal with /boot/vmlinuz* being called vmlinux* on the riscv64 architecture. [ ]
    • Add a new ionos17 node. [ ][ ][ ][ ][ ]
    • Install debian-repro-status on all Debian trixie and unstable jobs. [ ]
  • FreeBSD-related:
    • Switch to run latest branch of FreeBSD. [ ]
  • Misc:
    • Fix /etc/cron.d and /etc/logrotate.d permissions for Jenkins nodes. [ ]
    • Add support for riscv64 architecture nodes. [ ][ ]
    • Grant Jochen Sprickerhof access to the o4 node. [ ]
    • Disable the janitor-setup-worker. [ ][ ]
In addition:
  • kpcyrd fixed the /all/api/ API endpoints on reproduce.debian.net by altering the nginx configuration. [ ]
  • James Addison updated reproduce.debian.net to display the so-called bad reasons hyperlink inline [ ] and merged the Categorized issues links into the Reproduced builds column [ ].
  • Jochen Sprickerhof also made some reproduce.debian.net-related changes, adding support for detecting a bug in the mmdebstrap package [ ] as well as updating some documentation [ ].
  • Roland Clobus continued their work on reproducible live images for Debian, making changes related to new clustering of jobs in openQA. [ ]
And finally, both Holger Levsen [ ][ ][ ] and Vagrant Cascadian performed significant node maintenance. [ ][ ][ ][ ][ ]
If you are interested in contributing to the Reproducible Builds project, please visit our Contribute page on our website. However, you can get in touch with us via:

Otto Kek l inen: Will decentralized social media soon go mainstream?

Featured image of post Will decentralized social media soon go mainstream?In today s digital landscape, social media is more than just a communication tool it is the primary medium for global discourse. Heads of state, corporate leaders and cultural influencers now broadcast their statements directly to the world, shaping public opinion in real time. However, the dominance of a few centralized platforms X/Twitter, Facebook and YouTube raises critical concerns about control, censorship and the monopolization of information. Those who control these networks effectively wield significant power over public discourse. In response, a new wave of distributed social media platforms has emerged, each built on different decentralized protocols designed to provide greater autonomy, censorship resistance and user control. While Wikipedia maintains a comprehensive list of distributed social networking software and protocols, it does not cover recent blockchain-based systems, nor does it highlight which have the most potential for mainstream adoption. This post explores the leading decentralized social media platforms and the protocols they are based on: Mastodon (ActivityPub), Bluesky (AT Protocol), Warpcast (Farcaster), Hey (Lens) and Primal (Nostr).

Comparison of architecture and mainstream adoption potential
Protocol Identity System Example Storage model Cost for end users Potential
Mastodon Tied to server domain @ottok@mastodon.social Federated instances Free (some instances charge) High
Bluesky Portable (DID) ottoke.bsky.social Federated instances Free Moderate
Farcaster ENS (Ethereum) @ottok Blockchain + off-chain Small gas fees Moderate
Lens NFT-based (Polygon) @ottok Blockchain + off-chain Small gas fees Niche
Nostr Cryptographic Keys npub16lc6uhqpg6dnqajylkhwuh3j7ynhcnje508tt4v6703w9kjlv9vqzz4z7f Federated instances Free (some instances charge) Niche

1. Mastodon (ActivityPub) Screenshot of Mastodon Mastodon was created in 2016 by Eugen Rochko, a German software developer who sought to provide a decentralized and user-controlled alternative to Twitter. It was built on the ActivityPub protocol, now standardized by W3C Social Web Working Group, to allow users to join independent servers while still communicating across the broader Mastodon network. Mastodon operates on a federated model, where multiple independently run servers communicate via ActivityPub. Each server sets its own moderation policies, leading to a decentralized but fragmented experience. The servers can alternatively be called instances, relays or nodes, depending on what vocabulary a protocol has standardized on.
  • Identity: User identity is tied to the instance where they registered, represented as @username@instance.tld.
  • Storage: Data is stored on individual instances, which federate messages to other instances based on their configurations.
  • Cost: Free to use, but relies on instance operators willing to run the servers.
The protocol defines multiple activities such as:
  • Creating a post
  • Liking
  • Sharing
  • Following
  • Commenting

Example Message in ActivityPub (JSON-LD Format)
json
 
 "@context": "https://www.w3.org/ns/activitystreams",
 "type": "Create",
 "actor": "https://mastodon.social/users/ottok",
 "object":  
 "type": "Note",
 "content": "Hello from #Mastodon!",
 "published": "2025-03-03T12:00:00Z",
 "to": ["https://www.w3.org/ns/activitystreams#Public"]
  
 
Servers communicate across different platforms by publishing activities to their followers or forwarding activities between servers. Standard HTTPS is used between servers for communication, and the messages use JSON-LD for data representation. The WebFinger protocol is used for user discovery. There is however no neat way for home server discovery yet. This means that if you are browsing e.g. Fosstodon and want to follow a user and press Follow, a dialog will pop up asking you to enter your own home server (e.g. mastodon.social) to redirect you there for actually executing the Follow action on with your account. Mastodon is open source under the AGPL at github.com/mastodon/mastodon. Anyone can operate their own instance. It just requires to run your own server and some skills to maintain a Ruby on Rails app with a PostgreSQL database backend, and basic understanding of the protocol to configure federation with other ActivityPub instances.

Popularity: Already established, but will it grow more? Mastodon has seen steady growth, especially after Twitter s acquisition in 2022, with some estimates stating it peaked at 10 million users across thousands of instances. However, its fragmented user experience and the complexity of choosing instances have hindered mainstream adoption. Still, it remains the most established decentralized alternative to Twitter. Note that Donald Trump s Truth Social is based on the Mastodon software but does not federate with the ActivityPub network. The ActivityPub protocol is the most widely used of its kind. One of the other most popular services is the Lemmy link sharing service, similar to Reddit. The larger ecosystem of ActivityPub is called Fediverse, and estimates put the total active user count around 6 million.

2. Bluesky (AT Protocol) Screenshot of Bluesky Interestingly, Bluesky was conceived within Twitter in 2019 by Twitter founder Jack Dorsey. After being incubated as a Twitter-funded project, it spun off as an independent Public Benefit LLC in February 2022 and launched its public beta in February 2023. Bluesky runs on top of the Authenticated Transfer (AT) Protocol published at https://github.com/bluesky-social/atproto. The protocol enables portable identities and data ownership, meaning users can migrate between platforms while keeping their identity and content intact. In practice, however, there is only one popular server at the moment, which is Bluesky itself.
  • Identity: Usernames are domain-based (e.g., @user.bsky.social).
  • Storage: Content is theoretically federated among various servers.
  • Cost: Free to use, but relies on instance operators willing to run the servers.

Example Message in AT Protocol (JSON Format)
json
 
 "repo": "did:plc:ottoke.bsky.social",
 "collection": "app.bsky.feed.post",
 "record":  
 "$type": "app.bsky.feed.post",
 "text": "Hello from Bluesky!",
 "createdAt": "2025-03-03T12:00:00Z",
 "langs": ["en"]
  
 

Popularity: Hybrid approach may have business benefits? Bluesky reported over 3 million users by 2024, probably getting traction due to its Twitter-like interface and Jack Dorsey s involvement. Its hybrid approach decentralized identity with centralized components could make it a strong candidate for mainstream adoption, assuming it can scale effectively.

3. Warpcast (Farcaster Network) Farcaster was launched in 2021 by Dan Romero and Varun Srinivasan, both former crypto exchange Coinbase executives, to create a decentralized but user-friendly social network. Built on the Ethereum blockchain, it could potentially offer a very attack-resistant communication medium. However, in my own testing, Farcaster does not seem to fully leverage what Ethereum could offer. First of all, there is no diversity in programs implementing the protocol as at the moment there is only Warpcast. In Warpcast the signup requires an initial 5 USD fee that is not payable in ETH, and users need to create a new wallet address on the Ethereum layer 2 network Base instead of simply reusing their existing Ethereum wallet address or ENS name. Despite this, I can understand why Farcaster may have decided to start out like this. Having a single client program may be the best strategy initially. One of the decentralized chat protocol Matrix founders, Matthew Hodgson, shared in his FOSDEM 2025 talk that he slightly regrets focusing too much on developing the protocol instead of making sure the app to use it is attractive to end users. So it may be sensible to ensure Warpcast gets popular first, before attempting to make the Farcaster protocol widely used. As a protocol Farcaster s hybrid approach makes it more scalable than fully on-chain networks, giving it a higher chance of mainstream adoption if it integrates seamlessly with broader Web3 ecosystems.
  • Identity: ENS (Ethereum Name Service) domains are used as usernames.
  • Storage: Messages are stored in off-chain hubs, while identity is on-chain.
  • Cost: Users must pay gas fees for some operations but reading and posting messages is mostly free.

Example Message in Farcaster (JSON Format)
json
 
 "fid": 766579,
 "username": "ottok",
 "custodyAddress": "0x127853e48be3870172baa4215d63b6d815d18f21",
 "connectedWallet": "0x3ebe43aa3ae5b891ca1577d9c49563c0cee8da88",
 "text": "Hello from Farcaster!",
 "publishedAt": 1709424000,
 "replyTo": null,
 "embeds": []
 

Popularity: Decentralized social media + decentralized payments a winning combo? Ethereum founder Vitalik Buterin (warpcast.com/vbuterin) and many core developers are active on the platform. Warpcast, the main client for Farcaster, has seen increasing adoption, especially among Ethereum developers and Web3 enthusiasts. I too have an profile at warpcast.com/ottok. However, the numbers are still very low and far from reaching network effects to really take off. Blockchain-based social media networks, particularly those built on Ethereum, are compelling because they leverage existing user wallets and persistent identities while enabling native payment functionality. When combined with decentralized content funding through micropayments, these blockchain-backed social networks could offer unique advantages that centralized platforms may find difficult to replicate, being decentralized both as a technical network and in a funding mechanism.

4. Hey.xyz (Lens Network) The Lens Protocol was developed by decentralized finance (DeFi) team Aave and launched in May 2022 to provide a user-owned social media network. While initially built on Polygon, it has since launched its own Layer 2 network called the Lens Network in February 2024. Lens is currently the main competitor to Farcaster. Lens stores profile ownership and references on-chain, while content is stored on IPFS/Arweave, enabling composability with DeFi and NFTs.
  • Identity: Profile ownership is tied to NFTs on the Polygon blockchain.
  • Storage: Content is on-chain and integrates with IPFS/Arweave (like NFTs).
  • Cost: Users must pay gas fees for some operations but reading and posting messages is mostly free.

Example Message in Lens (JSON Format)
json
 
 "profileId": "@ottok",
 "contentURI": "ar://QmExampleHash",
 "collectModule": "0x23b9467334bEb345aAa6fd1545538F3d54436e96",
 "referenceModule": "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
 "timestamp": 1709558400
 

Popularity: Probably not as social media site, but maybe as protocol? The social media side of Lens is mainly the Hey.xyz website, which seems to have fewer users than Warpcast, and is even further away from reaching critical mass for network effects. The Lens protocol however has a lot of advanced features and it may gain adoption as the building block for many Web3 apps.

5. Primal.net (Nostr Network) Nostr (Notes and Other Stuff Transmitted by Relays) was conceptualized in 2020 by an anonymous developer known as fiatjaf. One of the primary design tenets was to be a censorship-resistant protocol and it is popular among Bitcoin enthusiasts, with Jack Dorsey being one of the public supporters. Unlike the Farcaster and Lens protocols, Nostr is not blockchain-based but just a network of relay servers for message distribution. If does however use public key cryptography for identities, similar to how wallets work in crypto.
  • Identity: Public-private key pairs define identity (with prefix npub...).
  • Storage: Content is federated among multiple servers, which in Nostr vocabulary are called relays.
  • Cost: No gas fees, but relies on relay operators willing to run the servers.

Example Message in Nostr (JSON Format)
json
 
 "id": "note1xyz...",
 "pubkey": "npub1...",
 "kind": 1,
 "content": "Hello from Nostr!",
 "created_at": 1709558400,
 "tags": [],
 "sig": "sig1..."
 

Popularity: If Jack Dorsey and Bitcoiners promote it enough? Primal.net as a web app is pretty solid, but it does not stand out much. While Jack Dorsey has shown support by donating $1.5 million to the protocol development in December 2021, its success likely depends on broader adoption by the Bitcoin community.

Will any of these replace X/Twitter? As usage patterns vary, the statistics are not fully comparable, but this overview of the situation in March 2025 gives a decent overview.
Platform Total Accounts Active Users Growth Trend
Mastodon ~10 million ~1 million Steady
Bluesky ~33 million ~1 million Steady
Nostr ~41 million ~20 thousand Steady
Farcaster ~850 thousand ~50 thousand Flat
Lens ~140 thousand ~20 thousand Flat
Mastodon and Bluesky have already reached millions of users, while Lens and Farcaster are growing within crypto communities. It is however clear that none of these are anywhere close to how popular X/Twitter is. In particular, Mastodon had a huge influx of users in the fall of 2022 when Twitter was acquired, but to challenge the incumbents the growth would need to significantly accelerate. We can all accelerate this development by embracing decentralized social media now alongside existing dominant platforms. Who knows, given the right circumstances maybe X.com leadership decides to change the operating model and start federating contents to break out from a walled garden model. The likelyhood of such development would increase if decentralized networks get popular, and the encumbents feel they need to participate to not lose out.

Past and future The idea of decentralized social media is not new. One early pioneer identi.ca launched in 2008, only two years after Twitter, using the OStatus protocol to promote decentralization. A few years later it evolved into pump.io with the ActivityPump protocol, and also forked into GNU Social that continued with OStatus. I remember when these happened, and that in 2010 also Diaspora launched with fairly large publicity. Surprisingly both of these still operate (I can still post both on identi.ca and diasp.org), but the activity fizzled out years ago. The protocol however survived partially and evolved into ActivityPub, which is now the backbone of the Fediverse. The evolution of decentralized social media over the next decade will likely parallel developments in democracy, freedom of speech and public discourse. While the early 2010s emphasized maximum independence and freedom, the late 2010s saw growing support for content moderation to combat misinformation. The AI era introduces new challenges, potentially requiring proof-of-humanity verification for content authenticity. Key factors that will determine success:
  • User experience and ease of onboarding
  • Network effects and critical mass of users
  • Integration with existing web3 infrastructure
  • Balance between decentralization and usability
  • Sustainable economic models for infrastructure
This is clearly an area of development worth monitoring closely, as the next few years may determine which protocol becomes the de facto standard for decentralized social communication.

4 March 2025

Paul Tagliamonte: Reverse Engineering (another) Restaurant Pager system

Some of you may remember that I recently felt a bit underwhelmed by the last pager I reverse engineered the Retekess TD-158, mostly due to how intuitive their design decions were. It was pretty easy to jump to conclusions because they had made some pretty good decisions on how to do things. I figured I d spin the wheel again and try a new pager system this time I went for a SU-68G-10 pager, since I recognized the form factor as another fairly common unit I ve seen around town. Off to Amazon I went, bought a set, and got to work trying to track down the FCC filings on this model. I eventually found what seemed to be the right make/model, and it, once again, indicated that this system should be operating in the 433 MHz ISM band likely using OOK modulation. So, figured I d start with the center of the band (again) at 433.92 MHz, take a capture, test my luck, and was greeted with a now very familiar sight. Same as the last goarounds, except the premable here is a 0 symbol followed by 6-ish symbol durations of no data, followed by 25 bits of a packet. Careful readers will observe 26 symbols above after the preamble I did too! The last 0 in the screenshot above is not actually a part of the packet rather, it s part of the next packet s preamble. Each packet is packed in pretty tight.

By Hand Demodulation Going off the same premise as last time, I figured i d give it a manual demod and see what shakes out (again). This is now the third time i ve run this play, so check out either of my prior two posts for a better written description of what s going on here I ll skip all the details since i d just be copy-pasting from those posts into here. Long story short, I demodulated a call for pager 1, call for pager 10, and a power off command.
What Bits
Call 1 1101111111100100100000000
Call 101101111111100100010100000
Off 1101111111100111101101110
A few things jump out at me here the first 14 bits are fixed (in my case, 11011111111001), which means some mix of preamble, system id, or other system-wide constant. Additionally, The last 9 bits also look like they are our pager the 1 and 10 pager numbers (LSB bit order) jump right out (100000000 and 010100000, respectively). That just leaves the two remaining bits which look to be the action 00 for a Call , and 11 for a Power off . I don t super love this since command has two bits rather than one, the base station ID seems really long, and a 9-bit Pager ID is just weird. Also, what is up with that power-off pager id? Weird. So, let s go and see what we can do to narrow down and confirm things by hand.

Testing bit flips Rather than call it a day at that, I figure it s worth a bit of diligence to make sure it s all correct so I figured we should try sending packets to my pagers and see how they react to different messages after flipping bits in parts of the packet. I implemented a simple base station for the pagers using my Ettus B210mini, and threw together a simple OOK modulator and transmitter program which allows me to send specifically crafted test packets on frequency. Implementing the base station is pretty straightforward, because of the modulation of the signal (OOK), it s mostly a matter of setting a buffer to 1 and 0 for where the carrier signal is on or off timed to the sample rate, and sending that off to the radio. If you re interested in a more detailed writeup on the steps involved, there s a bit more in my christmas tree post. First off, I d like to check the base id. I want to know if all the bits in what I m calling the base id are truly part of the base station ID, or perhaps they have some other purpose (version, preamble?). I wound up following a three-step process for every base station id:
  • Starting with an unmodified call packet for the pager under test:
    • Flip the Nth bit, and transmit the call. See if the pager reacts.
    • Hold SET , and pair the pager with the new packet.
    • Transmit the call. See if the pager reacts.
    • After re-setting the ID, transmit the call with the physical base station, see if the pager reacts.
  • Starting with an unmodified off packet for the pager system
  • Flip the Nth bit, transmit the off, see if the pager reacts.
What wound up happening is that changing any bit in the first 14 bits meant that the packet no longer worked with any pager until it was re-paired, at which point it begun to work again. This likely means the first 14 bits are part of the base station ID and not static between base stations, or some constant like a version or something. All bits appear to be used. I repeated the same process with the command bits, and found that only 11 and 00 caused the pagers to react for the pager ids i ve tried. I repeated this process one last time with the pager id bits this time, and found the last bit in the packet isn t part of the pager ID, and can be either a 1 or a 0 and still cause the pager to react as if it were a 0. This means that the last bit is unknown but it has no impact on either a power off or call, and all messages sent by my base station always have a 0 set. It s not clear if this is used by anything likely not since setting a bit there doesn t result in any change of behavior I can see yet.

Final Packet Structure After playing around with flipping bits and testing, the final structure I was able to come up with based on behavior I was able to observe from transmitting hand-crafted packets and watching pagers buzz:
base id
command
pager id
???

Commands The command section bit comes in two flavors either a call or an off command.
Type Id (2 bits) Description
Call00Call the pager identified by the id in pager id
Off11Request pagers power off, pager id is always 10110111
As for the actual RF PHY characteristics, here s my best guesses at what s going on with them:
What Description
Center Frequency 433.92 MHz
Modulation OOK
Symbol Duration 1300us
Bits 25
Preamble 325us of carrier, followed by 8800us of no carrier
I m not 100% on the timings, but they appear to be close enough to work reliabily. Same with the center frequency, it s roughly right but there may be a slight difference i m missing.

Lingering Questions This was all generally pretty understandable another system that had some good decisions, and wasn t too bad to reverse engineer. This was a bit more fun to do, since there was a bit more ambiguity here, but still not crazy. At least this one was a bit more ambiguous that needed a bit of followup to confirm things, which made it a bit more fun. I am left with a few questions, though which I m kinda interested in understanding, but I ll likely need a lot more data and/or original source: Why is the command two bits here? This was a bit tough to understand because of the number of bits they have at their disposal given the one last bit at the end of the packet that doesn t seem to do anything, there s no reason this couldn t have been a 16 bit base station id, and an 8 bit pager id along with a single bit command (call or off). When sending an off why is power off that bit pattern? Other pager IDs don t seem to work with off , so it has some meaning, but I m not sure what that is. You press and hold 9 on the physical base station, but the code winds up coming out to 0xED, 237 or maybe -19 if it s signed. I can t quite figure out why it s this value. Are there other codes? Finally what s up with the last bit? Why is it 25 bits and not 24? It must take more work to process something that isn t 8 bit aligned and all for something that s not being used!

2 March 2025

Jonathan McDowell: RIP: Steve Langasek

[I d like to stop writing posts like this. I ve been trying to work out what to say now for nearly 2 months (writing the mail to -private to tell the Debian project about his death is one of the hardest things I ve had to write, and I bottled out and wrote something that was mostly just factual, because it wasn t the place), and I ve decided I just have to accept this won t be the post I want it to be, but posted is better than languishing in drafts.] Last weekend I was in Portland, for the Celebration of Life of my friend Steve, who sadly passed away at the start of the year. It wasn t entirely unexpected, but that doesn t make it any easier. I ve struggled to work out what to say about Steve. I ve seen many touching comments from others in Debian about their work with him, but what that s mostly brought home to me is that while I met Steve through Debian, he was first and foremost my friend rather than someone I worked with in Debian. And so everything I have to say is more about that friendship (and thus feels a bit self-centred). My first memory of Steve is getting lost with him in Porto Alegre, Brazil, during DebConf4. We d decided to walk to a local mall to meet up with some other folk (I can t recall how they were getting there, but it wasn t walking), ended up deep in conversation (ISTR it was about shared library transititions), and then it took a bit longer than we expected. I don t know how that managed to cement a friendship (neither of us saw it as the near death experience others feared we d had), but it did. Unlike others I never texted Steve much; we d occasionally chat on IRC, but nothing major. That didn t seem to matter when we actually saw each other in person though, we just picked up like we d seen each other the previous week. DebConf became a recurring theme of when we d see each other. Even outside DebConf we went places together. The first time I went somewhere in the US that wasn t the Bay Area, it was to Portland to see Steve. He, and his family, came to visit me in Belfast a couple of times, and I did road trip from Dublin to Cork with him. He took me to a volcano. Steve saw injustice in the world and actually tried to do something about it. I still have a copy of the US constitution sitting on my desk that he gave me. He made me want to be a better person. The world is a worse place without him in it, and while I am better for having known him, I am sadder for the fact he s gone.

1 March 2025

Debian Brasil: Debian Day 30 years online in Brazil


title: Debian Day 30 years online in Brazil description: by Paulo Henrique de Lima Santana (phls) published: true date: 2025-03-01T17:39:03.284Z tags: blog, english editor: markdown dateCreated: 2023-08-25T16:00:00.000Z In 2023 the traditional Debian Day is being celebrated in a special way, after all on August 16th Debian turned 30 years old! To celebrate this special milestone in the Debian's life, the Debian Brasil community organized a week with talks online from August 14th to 18th. The event was named Debian 30 years. Two talks were held per night, from 7:00 pm to 10:00 pm, streamed on the Debian Brasil channel on YouTube totaling 10 talks. The recordings are also available on the Debian Brazil channel on Peertube. We had the participation of 9 DDs, 1 DM, 3 contributors in 10 activities. The live audience varied a lot, and the peak was on the preseed talk with Eriberto Mota when we had 47 people watching. Thank you to all participants for the contribution you made to the success of our event. Veja abaixo as fotos de cada atividade: Nova gera o: uma entrevista com iniciantes no projeto Debian Nova gera o: uma entrevista com iniciantes no projeto Debian Instala o personalizada e automatizada do Debian com preseed Instala o personalizada e automatizada do Debian com preseed Manipulando patches com git-buildpackage Manipulando patches com git-buildpackage debian.social: Socializando Debian do jeito Debian debian.social: Socializando Debian do jeito Debian Proxy reverso com WireGuard Proxy reverso com WireGuard Celebra o dos 30 anos do Debian! Celebra o dos 30 anos do Debian! Instalando o Debian em disco criptografado com LUKS Instalando o Debian em disco criptografado com LUKS O que a equipe de localiza o j  conquistou nesses 30 anos O que a equipe de localiza o j conquistou nesses 30 anos Debian - Projeto e Comunidade! Debian - Projeto e Comunidade! Design Gr fico e Software livre, o que fazer e por onde come ar Design Gr fico e Software livre, o que fazer e por onde come ar

Guido G nther: Free Software Activities February 2025

Another short status update of what happened on my side last month. One larger blocks are the Phosh 0.45 release, also reviews took a considerable amount of time. From the fun side debugging bananui and coming up with a fix in phoc as well as setting up a small GSM network using osmocom to test more Cell Broadcast thingies were likely the most fun parts. phosh phoc phosh-osk-stub phosh-tour phosh-mobile-settings pfs libphosh-rs meta-phosh libcmatrix Debian gmobile feedbackd grim Wayland protocols g4music wlroots qbootctl bananui-shell libssc ModemManager Waycheck Bug reports Reviews This is not code by me but reviews on other peoples code. The list is a slightly incomplete. Thanks for the contributions! Help Development If you want to support my work see donations. Comments? Join the Fediverse thread

28 February 2025

Petter Reinholdtsen: Brushing up on old packages in Xiph and Debian

Since my motivation boost in the beginning of the month caused me to wrap up a new release of liboggz, I have used the same boost to wrap up new editions of libfishsound, liboggplay and libkate too. These have been tagged in upstream git, but not yet published on the Xiph download location. I am waiting for someone with access to have time to move the tarballs there, I hope it will happen in a few days. The same is the case for a minor update of liboggz too. As I was looking at Xiph packages lacking updates, it occurred to me that there are packages in Debian that have not received a new upload in a long time. Looking for a way to identify them, I came across the ltnu script from the devscripts package. It can sort by last update, packages maintained by a single user/group, and is useful to figure out which packages a single maintainer should have a look at. But I wanted a archive wide summary. Based on the UDD SQL query used by ltnu, I ended up with the following command:
#!/bin/sh
env PGPASSWORD=udd-mirror psql --host=udd-mirror.debian.net --user=udd-mirror udd --command="
select source,
       max(version) as ver,
       max(date) as uploaded
from upload_history
where distribution='unstable' and
      source in (select source
                 from sources
                 where release='sid')
group by source
order by max(date) asc
limit 50;"
This will sort all source packages in Debian by upload date, and list the 50 oldest ones. The end result is a list of packages I suspect could use some attention:
           source                        ver                    uploaded        
-----------------------------+-------------------------+------------------------
 xserver-xorg-video-ivtvdev    1.1.2-1                   2011-02-09 22:26:27+00
 dynamite                      0.1.1-2                   2011-04-30 16:47:20+00
 xkbind                        2010.05.20-1              2011-05-02 22:48:05+00
 libspctag                     0.2-1                     2011-09-22 18:47:07+00
 gromit                        20041213-9                2011-11-13 21:02:56+00
 s3switch                      0.1-1                     2011-11-22 15:47:40+00
 cd5                           0.1-3                     2011-12-07 21:19:05+00
 xserver-xorg-video-glide      1.2.0-1                   2011-12-30 16:50:48+00
 blahtexml                     0.9-1.1                   2012-04-25 11:32:11+00
 aggregate                     1.6-7                     2012-05-01 00:47:11+00
 rtfilter                      1.1-4                     2012-05-11 12:50:00+00
 sic                           1.1-5                     2012-05-11 19:10:31+00
 kbdd                          0.6-4                     2012-05-12 07:33:32+00
 logtop                        0.4.3-1                   2012-06-05 23:04:20+00
 gbemol                        0.3.2-2                   2012-06-26 17:03:11+00
 pidgin-mra                    20100304-1                2012-06-29 23:07:41+00
 mumudvb                       1.7.1-1                   2012-06-30 09:12:14+00
 libdr-sundown-perl            0.02-1                    2012-08-18 10:00:07+00
 ztex-bmp                      20120314-2                2012-08-18 19:47:55+00
 display-dhammapada            1.0-0.1                   2012-12-19 12:02:32+00
 eot-utils                     1.1-1                     2013-02-19 17:02:28+00
 multiwatch                    1.0.0-rc1+really1.0.0-1   2013-02-19 17:02:35+00
 pidgin-latex                  1.5.0-1                   2013-04-04 15:03:43+00
 libkeepalive                  0.2-1                     2013-04-08 22:00:07+00
 dfu-programmer                0.6.1-1                   2013-04-23 13:32:32+00
 libb64                        1.2-3                     2013-05-05 21:04:51+00
 i810switch                    0.6.5-7.1                 2013-05-10 13:03:18+00
 premake4                      4.3+repack1-2             2013-05-31 12:48:51+00
 unagi                         0.3.4-1                   2013-06-05 11:19:32+00
 mod-vhost-ldap                2.4.0-1                   2013-07-12 07:19:00+00
 libapache2-mod-ldap-userdir   1.1.19-2.1                2013-07-12 21:22:48+00
 w9wm                          0.4.2-8                   2013-07-18 11:49:10+00
 vish                          0.0.20130812-1            2013-08-12 21:10:37+00
 xfishtank                     2.5-1                     2013-08-20 17:34:06+00
 wap-wml-tools                 0.0.4-7                   2013-08-21 16:19:10+00
 ttysnoop                      0.12d-6                   2013-08-24 17:33:09+00
 libkaz                        1.21-2                    2013-09-02 16:00:10+00
 rarpd                         0.981107-9                2013-09-02 19:48:24+00
 libimager-qrcode-perl         0.033-1.2                 2013-09-04 21:06:31+00
 dov4l                         0.9+repack-1              2013-09-22 19:33:25+00
 textdraw                      0.2+ds-0+nmu1             2013-10-07 21:25:03+00
 gzrt                          0.8-1                     2013-10-08 06:33:13+00
 away                          0.9.5+ds-0+nmu2           2013-10-25 01:18:18+00
 jshon                         20131010-1                2013-11-30 00:00:11+00
 libstar-parser-perl           0.59-4                    2013-12-23 21:50:43+00
 gcal                          3.6.3-3                   2013-12-29 18:33:29+00
 fonts-larabie                 1:20011216-5              2014-01-02 21:20:49+00
 ccd2iso                       0.3-4                     2014-01-28 06:33:35+00
 kerneltop                     0.91-1                    2014-02-04 12:03:30+00
 vera++                        1.2.1-2                   2014-02-04 21:21:37+00
(50 rows)
So there are 8 packages last uploaded to unstable in 2011, 12 packages in 2012 and 26 packages in 2013. I suspect their maintainers need help and we should all offer our assistance. I already contacted two of them and hope the rest of the Debian community will chip in to help too. We should ensure any Debian specific patches are passed upstream if they still exist, that the package is brought up to speed with the latest Debian policy, as well as ensure the source can built with the current compiler set in Debian. As usual, if you use Bitcoin and want to show your support of my activities, please send Bitcoin donations to my address 15oWEoG9dUPovwmUL9KWAnYRtNJEkP1u1b.

Joey Hess: WASM Wayland Web (WWW)

So there are only 2 web browser engines, and it seems likely there will soon only be 1, and making a whole new web browser from the ground up is effectively impossible because the browsers vendors have weaponized web standards complexity against any newcomers. Maybe eventually someone will succeed and there will be 2 again. Best case. What a situation. So throw out all the web standards. Make a browser that just runs WASM blobs, and gives them a surface to use, sorta like Wayland does. It has tabs, and a throbber, and urls, but no HTML, no javascript, no CSS. Just HTTP of WASM blobs. This is where the web browser is going eventually anyway, except in the current line of evolution it will be WASM with all the web standards complexity baked in and reinforcing the current situation. Would this be a mass of proprietary software? Have you looked at any corporate website's "source" lately? But what's important is that this would make it easy enough to build new browsers that they would stop being a point of control. Want a browser that natively supports RSS? Poll the feeds, make a UI, download the WASM enclosures to view the posts. Want a browser that supports IPFS or gopher? Fork any browser and add it, the mantenance load will be minimal. Want to provide access to GPIO pins or something? Add an extension that can be accessed via the WASI component model. This would allow for so many things like that which won't and can't happen with the current market duopoly browser situation. And as for your WASM web pages, well you can still use HTML if you like. Use the WASI component model to pull in a HTML engine. It doesn't need to support everything, just the parts of web standards that you want to use. Or you can do something entitely different in your WASM that is not HTML based at all but a better paradigm (oh hi Spritely or display postscript or gemini capsules or whatever). Dual innovation sources or duopoly? I know which I'd prefer. This is not my project to build though.

Antoine Beaupr : testing the fish shell

I have been testing fish for a couple months now (this file started on 2025-01-03T23:52:15-0500 according to stat(1)), and those are my notes. I suspect people will have Opinions about my comments here. Do not comment unless you have some Constructive feedback to provide: I don't want to know if you think I am holding it Wrong. Consider that I might have used UNIX shells for longer that you have lived. I'm not sure I'll keep using fish, but so far it's the first shell that survived heavy use outside of zsh(1) (unless you count tcsh(1), but that was in another millenia). My normal shell is bash(1), and it's still the shell I used everywhere else than my laptop, as I haven't switched on all the servers I managed, although it is available since August 2022 on torproject.org servers. I first got interested in fish because they ported to Rust, making it one of the rare shells out there written in a "safe" and modern programming language, released after an impressive ~2 year of work with Fish 4.0.

Cool things Current directory gets shortened, ~/wikis/anarc.at/software/desktop/wayland shows up as ~/w/a/s/d/wayland Autocompletion rocks. Default prompt rocks. Doesn't seem vulnerable to command injection assaults, at least it doesn't trip on the git-landmine. It even includes pipe status output, which was a huge pain to implement in bash. Made me realized that if the last command succeeds, we don't see other failures, which is the case of my current prompt anyways! Signal reporting is better than my bash implementation too. So far the only modification I have made to the prompt is to add a printf '\a' to output a bell. By default, fish keeps a directory history (but separate from the pushd stack), that can be navigated with cdh, prevd, and nextd, dirh shows the history.

Less cool I feel there's visible latency in the prompt creation. POSIX-style functions (foo() true ) are unsupported. Instead, fish uses whitespace-sensitive definitions like this:
function foo
    true
end
This means my (modest) collection of POSIX functions need to be ported to fish. Workaround: simple functions can be turned into aliases, which fish supports (but implements using functions). EOF heredocs are considered to be "minor syntactic sugar". I find them frigging useful. Process substitution is split on newlines, not whitespace. you need to pipe through string split -n " " to get the equivalent. <(cmd) doesn't exist: they claim you can use cmd foo - as a replacement, but that's not correct: I used <(cmd) mostly where foo does not support - as a magic character to say 'read from stdin'. Documentation is... limited. It seems mostly geared the web docs which are... okay (but I couldn't find out about ~/.config/fish/conf.d there!), but this is really inconvenient when you're trying to browse the manual pages. For example, fish thinks there's a fish_prompt manual page, according to its own completion mechanism, but man(1) cannot find that manual page. I can't find the manual for the time command (which is actually a keyword!) Fish renders multi-line commands with newlines. So if your terminal looks like this, say:
anarcat@angela:~> sq keyring merge torproject-keyring/lavamind-
95F341D746CF1FC8B05A0ED5D3F900749268E55E.gpg torproject-keyrin
g/weasel-E3ED482E44A53F5BBE585032D50F9EBC09E69937.gpg   wl-copy
... but it's actually one line, when you copy-paste the above, in foot(1), it will show up exactly like this, newlines and all:
sq keyring merge torproject-keyring/lavamind-
95F341D746CF1FC8B05A0ED5D3F900749268E55E.gpg torproject-keyrin
g/weasel-E3ED482E44A53F5BBE585032D50F9EBC09E69937.gpg   wl-copy
Whereas it should show up like this:
sq keyring merge torproject-keyring/lavamind-95F341D746CF1FC8B05A0ED5D3F900749268E55E.gpg torproject-keyring/weasel-E3ED482E44A53F5BBE585032D50F9EBC09E69937.gpg   wl-copy
Note that this is an issue specific to foot(1), alacritty(1) and gnome-terminal(1) don't suffer from that issue. I have already filed it upstream in foot and it is apparently fixed already. Globbing is driving me nuts. You can't pass a * to a command unless fish agrees it's going to match something. You need to escape it if it doesn't immediately match, and then you need the called command to actually support globbing. 202[345] doesn't match folders named 2023, 2024, 2025, it will send the string 202[345] to the command.

Blockers () is like $(): it's process substitution, and not a subshell. This is really impractical: I use ( cd foo ; do_something) all the time to avoid losing the current directory... I guess I'm supposed to use pushd for this, but ouch. This wouldn't be so bad if it was just for cd though. Clean constructs like this:
( git grep -l '^#!/.*bin/python' ; fdfind .py )   sort -u
Turn into what i find rather horrible:
begin; git grep -l '^#!/.*bin/python' ; fdfind .py ; end   sort -ub
It... works, but it goes back to "oh dear, now there's a new langage again". I only found out about this construct while trying:
  git grep -l '^#!/.*bin/python' ; fdfind .py     sort -u 
... which fails and suggests using begin/end, at which point: why not just support the curly braces? FOO=bar is not allowed. It's actually recognized syntax, but creates a warning. We're supposed to use set foo bar instead. This really feels like a needless divergence from standard. Aliases are... peculiar. Typical constructs like alias mv="\mv -i" don't work because fish treats aliases as a function definition, and \ is not magical there. This can be worked around by specifying the full path to the command, with e.g. alias mv="/bin/mv -i". Another problem is trying to override a built-in, which seems completely impossible. In my case, I like the time(1) command the way it is, thank you very much, and fish provides no way to bypass that builtin. It is possible to call time(1) with command time, but it's not possible to replace the command keyword so that means a lot of typing. Again: you can't use \ to bypass aliases. This is a huge annoyance for me. I would need to learn to type command in long form, and I use that stuff pretty regularly. I guess I could alias command to c or something, but this is one of those huge muscle memory challenges. alt . doesn't always work the way i expect.

Next.

Previous.