Search Results: "Russ Allbery"

9 November 2013

Russ Allbery: Review: Fantasy & Science Fiction, July/August 2011

Review: Fantasy & Science Fiction, July/August 2011
Editor: Gordon van Gelder
Issue: Volume 121, No. 1 & 2
ISSN: 1095-8258
Pages: 258
Nothing of particular interest in the book reviews in this issue, although I was entertained to see Charles de Lint review a collection of the Prince Valiant strip. I have memories of that strip being one of the most boring works of art created by mankind. De Lint, of course, quite likes it. Our tastes seem to be very disjoint, although I have to admit that I've not read it collected and it may be more coherent and more interesting in that format. The science column in this issue, by Paul Doherty and Pat Murphy, deserves special mention. It's on roshambo (rock-paper-scissors), human difficulties with randomness, and strategy in roshambo competitions. It's also the first essay I've read that clearly explains how there can be strategy to roshambo, and why that strategy is worth studying. Even though the primary topic of the column is randomness, it's worth reading from the perspective of strategy in competitive human vs. human games. "Bronsky's Dates with Death" by Peter David: Anyone familiar with PAD's body of work will immediately expect a humorous story with some deeper thoughtful bits, and that's exactly what this is. Bronsky, the title character, is a man almost incapable of saying exactly what's on his mind, and what's on his mind is his eventual death. Not that it bothers him that much; he's just thinking a lot about it. But his incessant discussion of it certainly bothers the people around him. This leads to a few entertaining exchanges with his family, and then to more entertaining exchanges with Death. Or Deaths, as there appear to be several different kinds. I found the exact metaphysics a bit confused, but the ending was still touching and a bit funny. (7) "The Way It Works Out and All" by Peter S. Beagle: This is a reprint of a special fund-raising story about Avram Davidson, so a lot of it was lost on me given that I know almost nothing about Davidson and have yet to get to any of his novels I own. But even without that background, it's a diverting story of hidden and parallel worlds and unexpected explorations. There isn't all that much in the way of a plot, but it's a nice bit of characterization set against a fun SF twist. (6) "Less Stately Mansions" by Rob Chilson: This is a story about conservatism in life, about a farmer staying on his farm and resisting change, and about nostalgia, but I liked it much better than I normally like stories with those themes. It's set against a future world in which climate change is making life increasingly untenable. Humans are migrating into space colonies of various types, but Jacob refuses. This frustrates some parts of the family who want a piece of the substantial cash-out he's being offered for his farm, which of course makes Jacob even more stubborn. It's more of an elegy than a story, but I think it captures a particular stubborn mood, and a conscious decision to go with what one knows even if it doesn't have a long future, quite well. (7) "The Ants of Flanders" by Robert Reed: This is the novella of the issue, and, as you might expect from the author, it's thoughtful, meaty, and satisfying. At the start of the book, the planet is visited by an extraterrestrial ship (or ships it's not entirely clear at first). One of the people near one landing is Bloch, a huge teenager who has an odd lack of natural fear. He stays near the center of the story as Reed slowly develops a cosmology and a galactic political background that makes it clear humans may be incidental to everything that's happening. I liked this. It's a touch depressing in spots, and Bloch is a strange protagonist, but the cosmology is not the normal SF background and sparks some thoughts about how a status quo would be maintained by powers that don't care much about individual lives. The interlude with the leopard is nicely done, even if its significance is inobvious at first. (7) "Hair" by Joan Aiken: This is one of those weird Gothic horror stories about creepy families and half-explained supernatural events that some people love and that do nothing for me. (3) "The Witch of Corinth" by Steven Saylor: This is straight historical fantasy, featuring a Roman and his Greek tutor (heroes, apparently, of a series of historical mysteries) visiting the ruins of Corinth and encountering some bloody and dangerous local conflicts. It's slow and atmospheric, carried along by good characterization and description of ruins. It's not that much of a mystery the characters don't figure things out as much as stick around until the answer becomes obvious but it kept me entertained throughout a sizable story. Numerous elements of the story appear to be fantasy and then get other explanations, but there is a fantasy twist to the ending. (6) "Sir Morgravain Speaks of Night Dragons and Other Things" by Richard Bowes: This odd story is set among the knights of King Arthur on Avalon, where they sleep (mostly), awaiting their call to aid Britain again. Most of the story is told as one-sided dialogue from Morgravain, interspersed with some italic narration. Again, not much of a plot; the story, as such, is figuring out what Morgravain is doing and the point of his interactions with the other knights. I thought it was slight and oddly pointless, but I may have just missed the point. (4) "Someone Like You" by Michael Alexander: A time travel story, but one that's less about time travel per se than about examining and speculating about the alternate paths childhood could take and whether those changes produce different people. It takes some time to figure out what's going on, during which Alexander fills in the protagonist's past and the murder mystery that drives the tale. The time travel mechanism is blatantly hand-waved, making this more of a fantasy than an SF story, which matches the emphasis on emotion and psychology. It's not a bad story, and I think I see where the author was going with the slowly-constructed central conflict, but I still found it hard to take the conflict that seriously. One of the problems with time travel is that undermining of causality also undermines finality of decisions and consequences in ways that can rob stories of their punch. (6) "The Ramshead Algorithm" by KJ Kabza: The first-person protagonist is a well-respected and experienced fixer in a world of chaos and dimensional connection, a world with physics and inhabitants very much unlike ours. But the story doesn't spend much time there; his connection to his home earth is threatened, and he returns to try to stabilize it, which leads to the reader discovering that his family considers him a worthless appendage on a wealthy business family whose sole purpose in life is to stay out of their way. And his portal is rooted in a hedge maze that his father intends to demolish. This is one of those stories that gets more interestingly complex the deeper one gets into it. Ramshead's family is badly screwed up along multiple axes, but not without some hope of redemption. He's desperate and ineffective in his home universe, but more confident and capable when it comes to dealing with dimensional portal problems (although he still seems very young and relies on tools given to him by others). And there's always more going on than it first appears, and not as few obvious villains as it first appears. Good stuff, although I would have liked to understand more about Ramshead's world. (7) Rating: 7 out of 10

7 November 2013

Russ Allbery: Review: Muse of Fire

Review: Muse of Fire, by John Scalzi
Publisher: Subterranean
Copyright: 2012
Printing: 2013
ISBN: 1-59606-639-3
Format: Kindle
Pages: 28
This is another separately-published short work by Scalzi probably a novelette, although I didn't do a word count. Since it's separately published and has its own ISBN, it gets its own separate review page. At present, it's $1 on the Kindle (and probably elsewhere). I've read a variety of these now, and while the quality of Scalzi's short works varies (as with everyone), I've generally enjoyed them. This is the first one I've read that I really didn't like. The premise is promising enough. Ben Patton is a scientist or engineer of some sort (I don't recall if the story is specific) working on plasma physics for a corporation. He has a nervous tic involving playing with a lighter and an obsession with fire, which his co-workers tolerate (and his boss does not tolerate). The reason for that tic is something he keeps secret: he sees a beautiful woman named Hestia in any flames that he's looking at. For him, she's his muse, and his untouchable obsession. He's mangled one hand trying to touch her. But she appears in fire because she's trapped in hell. There are all sorts of great places Scalzi could have gone with this. Musae and inspiration by themselves are fodder for many stories. The woman's name is Hestia, which is immediately recognizable as the Greek goddess of the hearth and who is extremely important to Greek religious life (although she's definitely not a muse, but I'd even let that pass). That raises more story possibilities around the transition of religion and the effect on worshiped gods, including the way Christian missionaries called "pagan" gods and goddesses devils and indeed did claim they were from hell. There are interesting science and magic crossover possibilities between plasma physics and a muse of fire. And there is, of course, the whole rescue from hell angle, which has generated many a story going back to ancient Greek drama. As you might have guessed from this catalog and my disappointment, Scalzi didn't go any of those directions. He provides some good characterization of the passions and discomfort of Ben's life, shows us the practicalities of his relationship with Hestia, and sets up dramatic tension, all well and good. And then takes the most obvious, least interesting, and least satisfying twist possible. I was getting nervous as I got closer and closer to the end of the story and Scalzi had yet to develop any of the interesting possible directions, but even then I didn't expect the train wreck ending. Even a simplistic "happily ever after" ending would have been preferable. He did catch me by surprise, but only because I wouldn't have expected any author to take that easy of a way out of the story. I can't build up a proper rant while avoiding spoilers, but I will say that Scalzi even manages to walk straight into a rather nasty stereotype in the process. I'm not sure what happened here, but it didn't work, and it's far below the normal standards of Scalzi's work. Such a shame, too, since the setting had so much potential. Avoid. Rating: 4 out of 10

5 November 2013

Russ Allbery: git-pbuilder 1.30

This is a glue script to integrate git-buildpackage with cowbuilder or pbuilder. Guido G nther provided a patch to make it use the correct URL for the backports archive for wheezy and later when setting up a new build chroot. I also updated my email address, since I'm slowly transitioning to using a permanent email address I control for my various software projects. This script really should be rewritten in Python and just become part of the git-buildpackage package rather than having a separate existence, which I will get to in my copious spare time. (I do want to get back to using Python.) In the meantime, if you want to download a separate copy, you can still find the latest version on my scripts page.

Russ Allbery: Review: Asimov's, August 2011

Review: Asimov's Science Fiction, August 2011
Editor: Sheila Williams
Issue: Volume 35, No. 8
ISSN: 1065-2698
Pages: 112
The editorial this issue is about the Dell Magazines Award, so newsy without a lot of content (particularly since we don't get to read the winners). Silverberg's column is much more interesting, focusing on the complex rules of the honor code of the Albanian highlands and pointing out that there's more complexity and strangeness in things we can find on Earth than in a lot of science fiction. Even within the rules of real human cultures. James Patrick Kelly's column this issue is an interesting summary of what graduates of the Clarion writing workshop learned, in their own words. It's a nice barrage of quick writing tips, and an interesting view of what people take away from a writing workshop. The book review column this issue is Peter Heck's normal workman-like job. "The End of the Line" by Robert Silverberg: Someday, I really should read Lord Valentine's Castle. As you might guess from this comment, this is another Majipoor story. This one follows an official who is part of an advance party for the Coronal Lord, the ruler (of sorts). He's decided, as part of those duties, to take the opportunity to learn more about the aboriginal people of Majipoor: the somewhat mysterious metamorphs, or Piurivar. I'm not that familiar with the history of Majipoor, since all I've read is this story and one other, none of the novels. Apparently, knowing that the official in question is named Stiamot will place this story for more familiar readers. For the unfamiliar, such as myself, there's a lot of politics here and what's clearly background for a major event in the world, but as a standalone story it's a bit unsatisfying (and grim). It's not that clear why things had to turn out the way they did, and the characters seem largely without agency. It's well-written, but mostly a story for fans of the series, I think. (6) "Corn Teeth" by Melanie Tem: This is a tight third-person story about a human child raised by alien foster parents, and it's deeply disturbing. Not because of the fostering, which appears wonderful and loving, but because it's a train wreck sort of story: the reader can see the horrible coming and can't do anything about it (and it turns out even worse than one might expect). It's also a story built around failure of communication and failure of empathy, and has a monumentally depressing ending, the kind that leaves scars. I'm sure all of this is entirely intentional; it seems very well-written. But I really didn't want this much horrible misunderstanding and depressing hopelessness in my reading. (2) "Watch Bees" by Philip Brewer: I rather liked this story even if the protagonist is an awful person. The story is set in a future of bioengineered insects and hard economic times, and it features a man who is supposedly working his way from farm to farm to get back home. What he's actually after is more complicated and is closely related to the defense systems that keep intruders off of farms. You might guess some of the rest from the title. It's a story about understanding layered defense systems, and about economic warfare. I didn't care much for any of the characters, but the story is well-plotted and kept me interested in seeing what would happen next. (6) "For I Have Lain Me Down on the Stones of Loneliness and I'll Not Be Back Again" by Michael Swanwick: By Swanwick, so it's a little odd, but I found this story surprisingly moving and ambiguous. It's about an American of Irish descent, a trip to Ireland, and a love affair with a fierce Irish nationalist, all set against an SF background of an Earth conquered by benevolent aliens. It's angry, uncertain, fanatical, and realistic by turns, and left me with profound mixed feelings. I think it does a good job capturing in a brief story the emotional complexities of what it means to give onself to a cause. (7) "We Were Wonder Scouts" by Will Ludwigsen: This is a short and odd story about a variant of the Boy Scouts founded by a man who is a little too obsessed with the paranormal, and an outing in the woods that turns rather creepy. It's a type of story that I'm not very fond of: one that twists the delight of discovery into something dark and mundane. I suppose you could call it horror; it's more horror than fantasy, at least. Anyway, not my thing. (3) "Pairs" by Zachary Jernigan: This story, on the other hand, isn't as dark as it seems like it should be from the setup. Humans have been conquered and enslaved by more powerful alien races, and now human souls are a profitable business. The protagonist is a person who has been embodied in a spaceship, and who works with (and monitors) another largely insane embodied person as they work as couriers, carrying souls to their buyers. But neither of them are as fully under control as they might appear, which is the point of the story. There is no grand tale of redemption, and the price is high, but I found the psychological portrayal oddly satisfying and faintly hopeful, and I was intrigued by the world background. (7) "Paradise is a Walled Garden" by Lisa Goldstein: The cover story, this is by far the best story of the issue. It's steampunk, set in a world where Muslim civilization was not pressed back by Christianity and continues to thrive into the reign of Queen Elizabeth as, among other things, makers of automata. A girl has managed to get herself a job in a British factory by posing as a boy and is the first to sound the alarm when the automata that do most of the work go strangely (and violently) haywire. That leads to her being assigned to the subsequent delegation to Al-Andulus (Muslim Spain, if you're not familiar with that name from history). The protagonist is the best part of this story. She's thoughtful, resourceful, and delights in learning things, something that she's rarely had the opportunity to do. She's also utterly unintimidated. In Al-Andulus, she thrives, despite the contempt of the leader of the expedition and some dangerous intrigues around the source of the anomalous behavior. I won't spoil the ending, but it's a delight, leaving the reader with a lot of hope for her future. I also liked the portrayal of the Muslim world, which is engrossed in its own business and has its own advantages and disadvantages, but is at least open to and focused on learning and technological development. The contrast with the superstitious British delegation is both pointed and historically grounded in Muslim relations with Europe around the point of divergence of Goldstein's world. (8) Rating: 7 out of 10

3 November 2013

Russ Allbery: Review: The Walls of Westernfort

Review: The Walls of Westernfort, by Jane Fletcher
Series: Celaeno #2
Publisher: Bold Strokes
Copyright: 2004
Printing: March 2005
ISBN: 1-60282-349-9
Format: Kindle
Pages: 320
While this is the first book of the Celaeno series that I've read, it turns out to be the second book in the series. This is somewhat difficult to determine from sources on-line since the first three books in the series were published in the same year, but it's fairly obvious from reading synopses after having finished one of the books. I don't think it does any great damage to the story to read it out of order (indeed, it preserves the suspense around some plot elements), but you may want to seek out The Temple at Landfall first. Natasha Ionadis is a member of the Guard. The military services are divided into three parts in her world: the Rangers, who defend cities against bandits and others in the countryside; the Militia, who maintain law and order in the cities; and the Guard, who are responsible for guarding the temples and protecting the rituals and teachings of the state religion. She is a devout worshiper of Celaeno and delighted to be part of the Guard. But, as this book opens, she gets a very unexpected mission for a young private: a suicide mission into the heart of a heretic group in the wilds, heretics who have successfully defied the official religion and are in danger of setting up a self-sustaining community. The Walls of Westernfort has the surface trappings of a fantasy and does include some magic, but it slowly develops into more of a character story with a medieval (or, more accurately, medieval-inspired) backdrop. At the start, it appears that this mission will be an opportunity for Natasha to find the mentors and companions that she's never had before, but then her encounter with the heretics turns her world upside down. They're not the monsters that she had imagined, although their beliefs are still outrageous to her. One heretic in particular affects her deeply and introduces a strong lesbian romance element to the plot that dominates the rest of the book. I enjoyed the slow emergence of one aspect of the setting (that I'm about to spoil, so skip to the next paragraph if you don't want to hear it, although it would already be spoiled by reading the predecessor book or most of the blurbs). This is a world devoid of men; all the characters are women. This isn't part of the plot; it's just the unremarked normal. Fletcher tosses in a hand-waving explanation about halfway through, but it's only discussed in passing and never mentioned again. I really enjoy this technique, and enjoyed watching how long it took in the book before I noticed. There are so many books out there where men are the unremarked normal that it's a refreshing change to read the opposite (and notice how little it really matters), although it does require throwing in implausible magic to solve the problem of procreation. (That's apparently more the topic of The Temple at Landfall.) Plot-wise, The Walls of Westernfort is not complicated. The shape of the plot after Natasha's first encounter with the heretics is not likely to surprise any reader. But it's a simple plot well-executed, with distinct and fleshed-out characters and steady helpings of people being thoughtful and reasonable. The basic story carries plenty of natural conflict; Fletcher doesn't need to add much additional tension and wisely chooses not to, keeping the focus tightly on Natasha and her conflict between duty and conscience. I liked both of the people involved in the romance and could believe they'd fall in love, and I also liked that the romance was significant but not decisive. It's part of what helps Natasha expand her view of the world, but one could see how she would have made the right decision in the end even if the romance had not been present. The story does force some significant secret-keeping, but it doesn't draw cheap tension from mundane failure to communicate. All of the communication gaps here are believable and honest, driven by the characters' backgrounds, and absolutely necessary. I'm hypersensitive to romance plots based on communication failure, and I wasn't even grumbling. The series this book reminds me the most of is another lesbian romance in a fantasy-style setting: Catherine M. Wilson's When Women Were Warriors. The Walls of Westernfort is not as deep or philosophical, it's a bit more black and white in its morality, and I don't think it's quite as good of a book, but for me it had a similar tone of good people trying to do the right thing and finding one's way through ethical mazes. It's a bit slow to get started, but by the time Natasha's critical decision point arrived, I was fully invested in the story and had a hard time putting it down. Recommended if you're in the mood for a relatively light faux-medieval fantasy romance. I'm not rushing out to grab the other books in the series, but they went on my want list and I'll probably get them at some point. Followed by Rangers at Roadsend in the publication order sense, but apparently it's a prequel. Rating: 7 out of 10

2 November 2013

Russ Allbery: Review: Fantasy & Science Fiction, May/June 2011

Review: Fantasy & Science Fiction, May/June 2011
Editor: Gordon van Gelder
Issue: Volume 120, No. 5 & 6
ISSN: 1095-8258
Pages: 258
The editorial in this issue is about the investigation into the troubling death of long-time contributor F. Gwynplain MacIntyre (which was not his real name). It's disturbing, but to me it underscores one of the things that I love about the Internet: people for whom life isn't working very well can still find an outlet, make friendships, and control how they choose to present themselves to the world on-line. That's something quite valuable, and part of why the pushes for "real names" always gives me pause. Somewhat thematically related, this issue also features a non-fiction essay by Maria E. Alonzo about her investigation of Jesse Francis McComas, her great-uncle but better known to the SF community as one of the founding editors of F&SF and co-editor of the famous classic anthology Adventures in Time and Space. This is mostly a curiosity, but it's fun to read about the sense of triumph in tracking down lost family history. This issue also features a Chris Moriarty book review column, always a plus, as well as a few positive reviews of obscure superhero movies by Kathi Maio (plus the required grumbling about a more mainstream film). "The Final Verse" by Chet Williamson: This is more of a horror story than I would normally like, but I got pulled into the investigation of an old bluegrass song and the guesswork and footwork required to track down where it came from. Williamson does a good job with the tone and first-person narration, and the degree to which the protagonist cares about the song to the exclusion of the horrific happenings of the story blunts the horror. Not quite my thing, but I thought it was well-done and played well with the possible meanings of song lyrics. (6) "Stock Photos" by Robert Reed: This is well-written, like nearly all Reed stories, but it lacked enough clues for the reader for me. It's a very short story about a man who's out mowing his lawn when approached by two strangers who apparently want to take photographs of him for stock image collections. Then things get rather weird, but without any explanation, and the ending lost me completely. Frustrating. (It is partially explained by the later "The Road Ahead" story in this same issue.) (4) "The Black Mountain" by Albert E. Cowdrey: From one of F&SF's most reliable story-tellers to another, and this is a more typical story. Cowdrey offers an abandoned and very strange cathedral for an obscure religion, a conflict over a development project, and some rather creepy results, all told in Cowdrey's entertaining fashion. Some places you just don't mess with. (6) "Agent of Change" by Steven Popkes: Told Dos-Passos-style with news excerpts, web sites, and the transcript of an emergency committee, this story shows the discovery of Godzilla, or something akin to Godzilla, in the Pacific, where it's destroying whaling vessels. I do like this style of storytelling, and here it mixes well with humor and a bit of parody as Popkes shows how each different news outlet puts its own recognizable spin on the story. The story isn't particularly memorable, and it doesn't end so much as just stop, but it was fun. (7) "Fine Green Dust" by Don Webb: This story is dedicated to Neal Barrett, which will give SFF short story readers a warning of weirdness to come. In a near future where global warming as continued to make summers even more miserable, the protagonist happens across a naked woman painted green. The green turns out to be a sun block that claims to assist humans in metamorphosis into animals. Most of the story is the protagonist trying to decide what to think of that, interspersed with staring at his neighbor's naked daughter. It's mildly amusing if you don't think about it too much and don't mind the rather prominent male gaze. (5) "Rampion" by Alexandra Duncan: The novella of the story, this is set in Muslim Spain some time during the long fights between Muslims and Christians in the north. It's told as two parallel stories: one telling the protagonist's first meeting with his love, and the second following him as a blind man, some time later, deciding whether, and how, to re-engage with the world. The style feels like fantasy, but there's very little overt fantasy here, and the story could be read as historical adventure. It's good adventure, though; conventional in construction, but with some romance and some drama and a good ending. (7) "Signs of Life" by Carter Scholz: This is to science fiction what "Rampion" is to fantasy: not really SF in the classic sense, but fiction about the process of science. The protagonist works on gene sequencing and is mildly obsessed with a visualization of junk DNA in an attempt to find patterns in it. Like a lot of fiction about science, it's primarily concerned with office politics, grant funding, and an awful boss. There is a faint touch of the supernatural, but that strand of the story doesn't amount to much. There's a happy ending of sorts, but the story left me with a bad taste in my mouth, and I'd completely forgotten it by the time I sat down to write this review. (4) "Starship Dazzle" by Scott Bradfield: I've never seen much in Bradfield's ongoing series of stories about Dazzle, the talking dog. In this one, he's sent via rocket on a one-way trip into outer space and ends up making a bizarre sort of first contact. Like the other Dazzle stories, it's full of attempts at humor that don't really work for me, even though you'd think I'd be sympathetic to the mocking of our commercialization of everything. The ending is just silly, and not in a good way. (3) "The Old Terrologist's Tale" by S.L. Gilbow: I love the setup for this story. It's set in some sort of far future in which terraforming has become routine, and a group of people are telling each other stories over drinks. The first-person protagonist is a terrologist, someone who designs planets (and the technology is available to do this almost from scratch). The conversation is taking a turn towards the humiliating, with a politician belittling the work of terrologists, when an old terrologist who has been listening quietly starts telling a story about designing worlds, both mundane and dangerously beautiful. Gilbow does a great job here capturing blithe self-importance, the habit of belittling other people's technical work, and revenge via storytelling with a nasty barb. This was my favorite story of the issue. (7) "Altogether Elsewhere, Vast Herds of Reindeer" by Ken Liu: This is a rather odd but quite touching story about mothers, daughters, nature, connection, and uploading. It's set after a singularity, in a time when all humans are uploaded into computers and exploring higher dimensions, digital natives in a much deeper sense than is meant today. But Rene 's mother is an Ancient, from before the singularity and still three-dimensional, and she wants to spend some time with her daughter. That leads to a memorable moment of connection, without pulling Rene entirely out of her father's world. Well done. (7) "The Road Ahead" by Robert Reed: Two Reed stories in one issue! And this one is a sequel to "Stock Photos" from earlier, since apparently I wasn't the only one who found it hopelessly confusing. It provides some backstory and makes a bit more sense of the first story, and that also makes it a more interesting story in its own right. The stock photo concept wasn't entirely a lie, as I had thought it was after the first story. There is analysis, anticipation, and trends behind who the pair take pictures of. But this story explores some internal tension, some conflict between them and some knowledge that the woman has that the man doesn't. And in the process it makes everything creepier, but also more interesting, and provides a hint at a really dark way of viewing the news media. I would say that this salvages "Stock Photos," except that I don't think "Stock Photos" is necessary now that one can read this story. (7) "Music Makers" by Kate Wilhelm: This is another story about investigation of the history of music, mingled with the supernatural, but unlike the story that opened this issue, it's not horror. Rather, it's a gentle and sweet fantasy about the power of music and benevolent ghosts and a community coming together. It's a positive and happy note on which to end the issue. (6) Rating: 6 out of 10

31 October 2013

Russell Coker: Links October 2013

Wired has an interesting article by David Samuels about the Skybox, a small satellite (about the size of a bar fridge) that is being developed to provide cheap photographs of the Earth from low orbit [1]. Governments of major countries will probably try to limit what they do, but if they can prove that it s viable then someone else from a different jurisdiction will build similar satellites. Alice Dreger gave an interesting TED talk about the various ways that people can fall outside the expected genetic sex binary [2]. The short film Love is All You Need has an interesting way of showing the way that non-straight kids are treated [3]. The Guardian has an interesting article by Ranjana Srivastava about doctors and depression [4]. Don Marti wrote an interesting post about believing bullshit as a way of demonstrating group loyalty [5]. Zacqart Adam Green wrote an interesting article for the Falkvinge blog about the way that the Ouya gaming console can teach children about free software and political freedom [6]. Read more at www.ouya.tv [7]. It s a pity that the Ouya is not conveniently sold outside the US and the UK, with shipping it would probably cost a lot more than $99 in Australia. Tim Chevalier wrote an interesting post for Geek Feminism about the unintended consequences of some codes of conduct [8]. Tim Chevalier wrote an interesting Geek Feminism post about Wikipedia describing how the Neutral Point Of View is a way of representing the views of people in power [9]. Ramin Shokrizade wrote an interesting article for Gamasutra about the Free 2 Play (F2P) techniques [10]. The concept of F2P games is that the game can be installed for free but requires regular small payments to make the game easier, apparently some people pay $3000 per year or more. The TED blog has an interesting interview with Jack Andraka, a teenager who invented a new test for pancreatic cancer (and also ovarian and lung cancer) that is cheaper, faster, and less invasive than other tests [11]. The blog post also has a link to Jack s TED talk.

26 October 2013

Russ Allbery: Review: Why We Fail

Review: Why We Fail, by Victor Lombardi
Publisher: Rosenfeld Media
Copyright: 2013
ISBN: 1-933820-17-9
Format: Kindle
Pages: 248
Subtitled Learning from Experience Design Failures, Why We Fail is a case study book. It defines experience design, discusses the usefulness of analyzing failure, and then walks through ten marketplace failures attributed to failures of user experience (as opposed to engineering or user interface) and tries to draw some conclusions about those failures and how they could have been prevented. Lombardi then presents a more general (if fairly simple) framework for iterative experience design, along with some discussion of how that approach could have helped in these cases. Hardware and software designs can work properly but still fail with users and customers because the overall experience isn't right. Sometimes this is because something else got there first with more market share and people got used to it, sometimes it's because a system is too complicated, sometimes it's too simple, sometimes it's just uninspiring. Most of the news media coverage and many of the blog posts on this topic look to inspirational examples of successes. Lombardi points out here that successes can be accidental and failures are often more informative, a concept already common in many more mature areas of engineering. His hope, with Why We Fail, is to push a broader industry practice of taking apart and analyzing the failures. User experience design is still in its infancy, since many of the complex interactions now possible in modern hardware and software have just recently crossed into levels of complexity that qualify as experiences rather than interactions, and could benefit from more rigor. The concept sounds great. The approach in Why We Fail is at least interesting; Lombardi tells good stories, and I think they do tell some useful lessons. Drawing general principles is harder, which is always the weakness of case-study books. Lombardi's own attempt doesn't go far beyond a familiar mantra of the scientific method, small and responsive teams, cross-functional teams with flexibility to address a whole range of technical and business issues, and honest and forthright analysis of and iteration after failure. All of this is doubtless good advice; none of it should surprise anyone with even a smattering of engineering background or familiarity with current software design philosophy. The heart of the book is in the stories, and I did like that Lombardi captured a wide range of different designs. Included are embedded systems (BMW's iDrive), traditional software packages, web services of various types, and even a protocol (OAuth). Some were vaguely familiar and some were not familiar at all, although I don't follow UI and UX discussions to any large extent. In each case, Lombardi gives a short but effective introduction to the problem space and the product, walks through the design choices, and then talks about the failure. Usefully, he doesn't stop with the failure but continues the story through the reaction of the company to the failure and any subsequent actions they took, which in some cases contain their own useful lessons. All of this, I should note, is a bit far afield of my own area of expertise (architectural building blocks and sub-surface components without as much direct interaction with the user), so I'm not the best person to judge the quality and originality of the analysis. But I liked Lombardi's approach and his analysis of multiple possible failure causes, and all of his conclusions seemed quite plausible and sensible given the case studies as described. I'm best-qualified to judge the chapter on OAuth, since I've worked extensively on web authentication systems, and his analysis of the challenges and user experiences in that case closely match my own. I didn't notice any significant errors, which is hopefully a good sign for the rest of the book. As one might expect from a short book about a complex field aimed mostly at starting a conversation, there isn't much here that's earth-shattering, nor are there simple extractable principles that will make your experience designs better. As always, the takeaway boils down to "invest time and resources into this and try to think about it systematically," which of course is true of every possible axis of improvement for any product. (The challenge is usually where to spend those limited resources.) I will also note in passing that Lombardi assumes an entirely market-driven metric for success, and all of the case studies are exclusively commercial not unexpected, since that's where most of the money and a lot of the resources are, but not that helpful for bespoke work where the nature of the problem is subtlely different. But, despite the expected shortcomings and the inherent weakness of the case study approach to analysis, which tries to pluralize anecdote to get data I enjoyed this book. I also got at least one useful trick out of it: the premortem, to look for potential failure points in the experience before rolling out, or even designing, the product. It's a fairly light-weight book, but I think it's moderately inspirational, and I wholeheartedly concur with Lombardi on the merits of failure analysis as an engineering approach. Rating: 7 out of 10

24 October 2013

Russ Allbery: Review: Applied Cryptography

Review: Applied Cryptography, by Bruce Schneier
Publisher: John Wiley & Sons
Copyright: 1996
ISBN: 0-471-11709-9
Format: Trade paperback
Pages: 621
This is the next entry in the series of Russ reading books that he bought years ago and never got around to reading. Thankfully, this time, the book has aged somewhat better. This review is for the second edition of Applied Cryptography, published in 1996. Given how important computer security has become, and how central cryptography is to computer security, one might think that the passage of 17 years would make a book effectively obsolete. This turns out not to be the case. Yes, Rijndael (the current AES standard and the most widely-used block cipher), Camellia (the up-and-comer in the block cipher world), and the SHA-2 hash postdate this book and aren't discussed. Yes, there have been some further developments in elliptic-curve public-key cryptography. And yes, much of the political information in this book, as well as the patent situation for public-key cryptosystems, is now mostly of historical interest. But a surprising amount of this book still applies directly. Partly that's because much of Applied Cryptography is focused on general principles, classes of algorithms, and cryptographic protocols, and those do not change quickly. A rather amazing number of techniques and protocols still in widespread use today originated in the 1970s. Block ciphers, stream ciphers, cipher modes, public-key systems, signature systems, hash functions, key exchange, secret splitting, key management, and other, similar topics have not changed substantially. And even in the area of specific algorithms, DES is still in use (unfortunately) and its analysis is valuable for understanding any block cipher. RC4, Triple DES, CAST, RSA, MD4, MD5, and SHA-1 are still part of the cryptography landscape, and Schneier was already warning against using MD5 in 1996. The source code included in this book has, thankfully, been made obsolete by widely-available, high-quality free implementations of all common ciphers, available for any modern operating system. But the math, the explanations, and much of the cryptanalysis is still quite relevant. While it contains a comprehensive introduction to cryptographic concepts, Applied Cryptography is structured more like a reference manual than a tutorial. The first two chapters provide some foundations. Then, a wide variety of protocols, from the common to the completely esoteric, are discussed across the subsequent four chapters. There are four chapters on the basics of ciphers, another chapter on the mathematics, and then the longest part of the book: twelve chapters that provide a tour of all major and several interesting minor protocols that existed in 1996. These are organized into block ciphers, stream ciphers (and pseudo-random number generators), hash functions, and public-key systems. An entire chapter is devoted to the history and analysis of DES, and I think that was my favorite chapter of the book. Not only is it worth understanding how DES works, but it also provides a comprehensive introduction to the complexities of block cipher design, the politics of interactions with the NSA, and a fascinating history of early computer cryptosystems. Finally, Applied Cryptography closes with chapters on real-world systems and on politics. The politics section is mostly a historical curiosity, as is much of the chapter on real-world systems. Schneier discusses some of the PKCS and X.509 protocols here but doesn't use SSL as one of his examples despite its specification predating this book (perhaps the most glaring omission of the book). But he does discuss Kerberos (which is of personal interest to me), and it was useful to see it analyzed in the broader context of this sort of book. Those who read Schneier's blog regularly, or who have read any of his other books, will know that he's concise, incisive, and very readable, even with difficult material. I think he does err on the side of compactness this is not a book that handholds the reader or explains something more than once but there's a lot of ground to cover, so I can't really blame him. Expect to have to read the more difficult parts several times, and (at least on a first read) expect to just skip past some of the most complex sections as probably not worth the effort. But I think Schneier does a great job structuring the book so that one comes away with a high-level impression and overview sufficient to make informed guesses about capabilities and relative difficulty even if one doesn't have the patience to work through the details. I suspect most readers will want to skim at least part of this book. Unless you're willing to do a lot of background reading to understand the math, or a lot of careful study to follow the detailed descriptions and flaws in often-obscure algorithms, the algorithm discussions start to blend together. I found myself skipping a lot of the math and focusing on the basic descriptions and the cryptanalysis, particularly for the obscure ciphers. Many of the algorithms are also highly opaque and of obscure benefit; I doubt I will ever care about blind signatures or oblivious transfer, and I struggled to wrap my mind around the details of bit commitment (although it's apparently important in zero knowledge proofs, which in turn are relevant to authentication). But this is not the sort of book where you have to read every word. It's very well-structured, provides clear resynchronization points for readers who have had enough of a particular topic, and marks the topics that are more obscure or of dubious general usefulness. The most useful parts of this book, in my opinion, are the basic conceptual introductions to each class of cryptographic algorithm or protocol, and those chapters are excellent. I've been working in applied computer security, at the application and deployment level, for years, and this is the first time that I've felt like I really understood the difference between a block cipher and a stream cipher, or the implications of block cipher mode selection. Applied Cryptography is also a fascinating exercise in adjusting one's intuition for where the complexity lies. It's a memorable experience to move from the chapters on block ciphers, full of S-boxes and complex mixing and magic numbers, into the far more straightforward mathematical analysis of stream ciphers. Or the mathematical simplicity of RSA (although quite a bit of complexity is lurking on the cryptanalysis side, much of which is only touched on here). Of more historical interest, but still quite impressive, is that Applied Cryptography doubles as a comprehensive literature review. Not only does it cover nearly every algorithm in use at the time, it discusses the cryptography literature on nearly every topic with brief summaries of results and lines of investigation. The references section is a stunning 66 pages of small print featuring 1,653 references, and those are mentioned and put in context throughout the book. I'm not personally interested in chasing those lines of research further, and of course 17 years means there are many new papers that are as important to read today, but it's obvious that this book would have been an amazing and invaluable map to the research territory when it was first published. There are now newer books on this topic that you should consider if you're purchasing a book today. Cryptography Engineering in particular is in my to-read pile, and I'm interested to see how much of this book it could replace, although I believe it's lighter on the mathematical analysis and details. But I think Applied Cryptography still has a place on the bookshelf of any computer security professional. Schneier is succinct, detailed, straightforward, and comprehensive, at least for 1996, and I know I'll be reaching for this book the next time I forget the details of CFB mode and then get hopelessly confused by the Wikipedia article on the topic. Rating: 8 out of 10

23 October 2013

Russ Allbery: Review: Lean In

Review: Lean In, by Sheryl Sandberg & Nell Scovell
Publisher: Alfred A. Knopf
Copyright: March 2013
ISBN: 0-385-34994-7
Format: Hardcover
Pages: 217
Lean In is normally listed as written only by Sheryl Sandberg, which is also what's on the dust jacket, but the inside cover says "with Nell Scovell." Given what that normally means for celebrity books, supported by comments in the acknowledgments, I'm listing it as co-written by Scovell. However, much of the book is written in the first person and is clearly meant to be Sandberg's voice, so I will mostly refer to Sandberg as the author for the rest of the review. I was unfair to this book. Lean In made quite a splash when it first came out, since the named author is the Chief Operating Officer of Facebook, a former vice president of Google, and one of the most prominent female executives in the business world. The subtitle is Women, Work, and the Will to Lead, and the normal Internet summary was that it focused on how women could change their behavior to be more effective and successful in the business world. Throw in some ridiculous review hyperbole (one New York Times writer compared it to The Feminine Mystique, which is a bit like the comparison of every extruded fantasy product with The Lord of the Rings) and I was ready to hate this book. It's work advice from someone in a very privileged position, and it seemed to have a distinct whiff of victim-blaming. It's obvious, however, from the first few pages that Sandberg was very aware of this trap and had no intent of falling into it. This is hard: giving practical advice to women on how to navigate a sexist culture runs a severe risk of victim-blaming even with the best of intentions, particularly since part of the sexism of the culture is a pervasive impression that women aren't doing enough. But I think Lean In handles that about as well as one could while still writing a book focused on practical advice rather than revolutionary change. Sandberg is clear that many things women can do to help their careers shouldn't be necessary, and she takes some time, in each section, to talk about the shape of any structural unfairness that she's seen. What advice she offers here is clearly in the spirit of how to navigate a system that is unfair and unequal, but which can be navigated and can be made more fair by more women participating. This is a very practical book, with more in common with business self-help books than with feminist critiques. It's also a narrowly targeted book, not that you'd guess this from the number of copies it's sold and the sort of publicity it got. Lean In is advice to female executives about how to navigate the top levels of US business culture, with a strong eye for issues of feminism, gender-based double standards, and potential traps of self-sabotage. It offers a blend of encouragement, practical tips, and some forthright analysis that tries to bring to the surface internalized sexism and perceived barriers and limitations for female executives so that they can be addressed and hopefully overcome. It's not in any way a revolutionary book, either with respect to business culture or with respect to gender roles; rather, it's an open acknowledgment of a whole bunch of problems combined with practical advice for how to work around those problems until they can be solved. For the most part, it doesn't attempt to address how to solve the problems. There is nothing wrong with that as a focus for a book. Lean In has attracted a fair bit of criticism in some circles, but, after reading the book, I think a lot of that criticism is predicated on assuming different goals than this book actually has. Contrary to various glowing reviews, Lean In is not a book that's going to change the world; rather, it's a book that might help a narrow band of the population in a specific job and career path navigate problems of sexism and gender expectations and be more effective. Read in that light, it struck me as honest, open, considered, and well aware of its own limitations. Sandberg says repeatedly that many of the options she discusses simply aren't available to most women, and that women may not be in a position to be able to make the decisions she made. She's quite forthright about the limitations of her own experience and the limitations of the advice that she offers, and I think deserves full points for honesty. Similarly, when it comes to business culture, Lean In is not about changing that culture for the better. It's about navigating that culture as it exists. Here, I think Sandberg is less aware of the limitations of this perspective; there is far less acknowledgment in Lean In that executive culture may be inherently toxic as there is of the limitations that women face in business. But while Sandberg has an obvious blind spot, this is not a paean to overwork. It has some excellent advice about work-life balance, including the need to put strict limits on the amount of time one spends in the office and the necessity for someone to pick up substantial burdens in the home if one of the members of a household is going to pursue a business executive job. I was worried, going in, that Lean In would excuse, justify, or idealize the culture of exploitation so common with salaried jobs in the United States, but it really doesn't. As with feminism, it doesn't pick any deep fights, and those with a "kill it with fire" gut reaction towards US executive culture (such as myself) will find the bland acceptance of it irritating, but this is more of an issue with reader expectations than with the book. One should not expect a highway map to point out that trains are more efficient. So, I'm willing to stand up for Lean In to a degree. This is not a bad book. It's very readable, parts are quite interesting, and some of Sandberg's observations about the intersection of gender expectations and executive culture were worth hearing. I learned some things from it. But I think one should read it in full awareness of its limitations. This is a book of practical advice that will only be of direct use to 10% of the population, and which could be generalized with some effort to maybe 25%. It has little to say to women who are not in white-collar, professional jobs, and its applicability to women who aren't aiming for executive careers is a bit hazy. It's the kind of book that's full of anecdotes about how Sandberg got parking spots reserved for pregnant women at Google by talking to the founders about it, or about how to negotiate salary when offered an executive position, which are vaguely interesting but of dubious practical benefit to people who aren't offered jobs where salary and benefit negotiation is available. This isn't the fault of the book, but at times it is rather stunning how different (and how much more tractable) the world looks to someone with the wealth and personal connections that Sandberg has. (To her credit, Sandberg does seem to be aware of this and does acknowledge it.) If you are a female executive, or a male executive interested in developing your empathy and understanding of how institutional sexism affects your colleagues, I suspect Lean In would be quite helpful. If you're not, I think it's mostly a curiosity. But it's also well-written, well-organized, probably available in most libraries in the United States, and provides anecdotal data to help build a more complete picture of the concerns and experiences of female executives. Unless you're in the specific target audience, I'm not sure I'd recommend going out of your way to find it, but it's probably worth reading if it falls into your lap. Rating: 7 out of 10

11 October 2013

Russ Allbery: kadmin-remctl 3.5

No, I still haven't written the generic Perl bindings for Kerberos that I really want to write (although I have made a bit more forward progress in writing the beginnings of some of the add-ons to Config::AutoConf that I would need in order to do so). This is just another bug-fix release for our remctl backend for doing kadmin actions. Most of the fixes this time are around password changes. kadmin-remctl does password changes by running kpasswd under Expect, but its timeouts weren't long enough for our production environment under some conditions (particularly when propagating passwords into Active Directory). This release both fixes that and clears up some Perl warnings if we still hit timeouts. It also recognizes the new form of Heimdal kpasswd prompts in the upcoming 1.6 release and stops mapping password quality errors to more generic error messages. (I'm fixing that problem in krb5-strength instead.) Also in this release, the Heimdal backend has been improved to use get rather than list to check whether a principal exists (not sure why it was ever using list), and to check the existence of a principal before enabling or disabling so that it can produce better error messages. You can get the latest release from the kadmin-remctl distribution page.

Russ Allbery: krb5-strength 2.1

This is a quick bug-fix release, since of course there was a significant bug in the recent 2.0 release. In this case, it was a problem with the build: if you configured the package without CDB support, it didn't build. Apparently I didn't retest that after doing some refactoring. I have good test suite techniques for reasonable code coverage, but not for testing various variant configurations at the Autoconf level. This is what a continuous build infrastructure would be good for, I know. We even have one sitting around; someday, I should invest in hooking my projects up to it. Anyway, also in this release is the start of an Autoconf fix so that --with-tinycdb without an argument works correctly, but I have more Autoconf work to do (also affecting rra-c-util). I also tweaked the error messages returned by the non-CrackLib portions of krb5-strength so that they would hopefully be more comprehensible to users while still being technically accurate. You can get the latest release from the krb5-strength distribution page.

10 October 2013

Russ Allbery: Review: 2312

Review: 2312, by Kim Stanley Robinson
Publisher: Orbit
Copyright: 2012
ISBN: 0-316-19280-5
Format: Kindle
Pages: 563
Swan Er Hong is a native of Mercury, granddaughter of one of the most influential women in the solar system. Alex, known as the Lion of Mercury, has just died as the story opens, and Swan is mourning. But she's also discovering that something else has been going on, something that Alex had not confided in her. Something that involves an inspector from the asteroids, a scientist from Titan, and a message Alex left in the event of her death, asking Swan to convey something personally to another scientist on Io. And then Mercury is attacked and the situation becomes much more complicated. 2312 is, like most Robinson novels, built on top of monumental world-building. The date is given away by the title; the setting is a solar system full of terraforming, habitats, and explosive human colonization. There are human settlements on every world that could possibly sustain them, including a terraformed Mars and a vast in-progress terraforming project on Venus. Mercury, Song's home, supports the city known as Terminator, a shielded habitat that travels around the planet on rails, pushed forward by the thermal expansion of metal at sunrise. Humans have scattered across the solar system and changed everything they've touched, even the asteroids. Many of those have been repurposed as long-haul shuttles: self-contained habitats on carefully-designed routes on which people live for months or years until they get to their destinations. Parts of this book are gorgeous. One of Robinson's strengths is creating images of the vastness of space, science, and human endeavor that feel plausible and inspiring at the same time. The setting of 2312 frees him to go wild with mega construction projects, and he takes full advantage. Parts of the book inspire the same sense of awe as the Hoover Dam or the Great Wall of China, transplanted into space and backed with neat scientific ideas to ponder. (Even if the more skeptical will note certain human habitation hazards, such as prolonged weightlessness and radiation, are mostly hand-waved away.) Unusually for a Robinson novel, 2312 also features an interesting and vibrant protagonist. Usually I can barely remember Robinson's protagonists five minutes after I finish the book, but Swan is so impulsive, erratic, and emotionally intense that I doubt I'll forget her. Her past is stuffed with outrageous risks and intense creativity: having songbird neurons transplanted into her brain, ingesting extraterrestrial bacteria, designing habitats in the asteroid belt, and creating art on the plains of Mercury. As the story gets underway, she meets the oversized and mellow Wahram; at first, she finds him boring, but then they're thrown together by one of the best set pieces of the book, and both they and the reader discover they work well together. Wahram serves as a straight man and as a stand-in for the reader's opinion, showing Swan all the more clearly in contrast. All this sounds quite promising. Unfortunately, what makes 2312 an ambitious failure rather than an excellent story is the story part. Robinson has built an amazing world, but he doesn't seem to know what to do with it. His economy, at least outside of Earth (and more on that in a moment), is essentially post-scarcity. Few of the characters we meet seem to have any concept of fiscal or practical limitation. They head across the solar system on a moment's notice, take vacations in habitats, or head to favorite spots for the view. It felt like Robinson was trying to write a Culture story. Unlike Banks, however, he struggles with generating a plot. 2312 is, in structure, a murder mystery. The characters witness a crime, survive it, and then intend to investigate it, and the crime appears to grow and link to fault lines in their society. This could have worked, but it has two problems: their society is only barely coherent enough for the reader to perceive the potential fault lines, and Robinson seems to have no idea how to construct a mystery plot. There is no sense of coherence to Swan and Wahram's approach, no sense of a gathering of clues, and very little sense of drama. All of the plot revelations are either dropped in Swan's lap by another character at a convenient moment or generated by Swan refusing to take the plot of the book seriously. The characters do essentially no meaningful investigation on-camera and show almost no investment in the outcome of the plot. When the climax comes, it's all weirdly forgettable. There are also large sections of the book that appear to have nothing to do with the rest of the plot, and that's where the unfortunate interval on Earth comes in. Robinson takes advantage of the scenes on Earth to do a bit of alienation and shows how foreign and strange and stifling Earth feels to someone who grew up outside of its atmosphere. Parts of this work, but he puts the plot on hold to do it. And parts of it do not work at all. The most glaring example is Swan and Wahram's bizarre bit of attempted charity in Africa, which comes across as stunningly high-handed and arrogant. This could be in character, particularly for Swan (who is not long on empathy), but, if so, the book doesn't signal to the reader that it should be read that way. Instead, there are some side (or snide) comments that seem to indicate Robinson knows nothing about the economic arc of Africa from the past twenty years. And when their absurd, botched, condescending charity plan fails for all the obvious reasons, the characters, and apparently the novel, throw up their hands and write Earth off as a stagnant lost cause that can't accept the imposition of a good idea and go back to the plot, never apparently caring about Earth again. Almost as frustrating is the way that these interludes are tied back into the story, which is usually through Swan getting ridiculously lucky on her random encounter rolls. It felt like whenever Robinson needed to make progress in the plot, Swan would just accidentally run into exactly the right person or situation to bring up the next plot point or to have some investigation make sense. (Not that Swan usually figured this out. Normally, the inspector explains it to her.) The author's finger was planted so firmly on the scales that it destroyed my suspension of disbelief and made a mockery of the idea that the characters were actually investigating anything. 2312 is built around a skeleton of a plot, but the lack of engagement with it, the lack of tension and emotion, the way the next developments are generally narrated to the protagonists and the reader, and the repeated use of random encounters to steer it left me without much reason to care. Robinson tries a few twists, but since the story never felt committed to its plot anyway, those twists feel less like planned complications and more like another random veer in the road. It didn't help that the final outcome was more prosaic and forgettable than the book had been implying it would be. There is a lot to like here. I'm very pleased to see Robinson finally write a memorable protagonist, and he's very good at both world-building and set pieces. But it needed a plot, and it needed a more coherent and complete cultural backdrop for its characters. Without both, it fell back into the typical Robinson trap: gorgeous moments separated by a whole lot of boring, and an overall impression of a construction tour rather than a story. There are bits of it I loved and still remember, particularly Song and Wahram in the tunnels of Mercury (which is possibly the best extended characterization Robinson has ever written). But the book as a whole is a mess, and I can't recommend wading through it for the good parts. Rating: 5 out of 10

Russ Allbery: One more haul

Just a few more recently-released books that I had to pick up. Sheila Bair Bull by the Horns (non-fiction)
Elizabeth Bear Book of Iron (sff)
Steven Brust & Skyler White The Incrementalists (sff)
J.M. Coetzee The Childhood of Jesus (mainstream)
Elizabeth Wein Rose Under Fire (mainstream)
Walter Jon Williams Knight Moves (sff) Time to get back into the reading habit. That's the plan for the next couple of weeks.

8 October 2013

Russ Allbery: Review: Grimspace

Review: Grimspace, by Ann Aguirre
Series: Sirantha Jax #1
Publisher: Ace
Copyright: March 2008
ISBN: 0-441-01599-9
Format: Mass market
Pages: 312
Sirantha Jax is a jumper: a person with the rare genetic ability to jump spaceships through the shortcut dimension of grimspace. It's a science fiction idea with a long pedigree. It creates a separate in-group for the characters to belong to, a society with its own rules, and sets up tension with the rest of the institutions of the world. In Aguirre's version, jumpers can provide the transition but direction in grimspace has to be done by a pilot, and the jumper and the pilot develop a deep psychic bond. Jax had been jumping with her husband piloting, but on their last trip their ship crashed, killing everyone on board except her. As Grimspace opens, Jax is in a treatment facility that's much more like a prison. In theory, they're trying to figure out whether she's still able to (and safe to allow to) jump. In practice, something quite a bit more sinister is going on, a fact that the reader senses early but only learns more about after Jax is helped to escape. Scarred, deeply depressed, and nearly suicidal, she's pulled into the subversive plans of a small ship of renegades who are trying to break open the Corp monopoly on grimspace travel and their tight hold over every jumper. But she's not sure whether she trusts them, or whether she cares enough about their crusade to truly join in. Grimspace follows well-trod SF paths of special cadres of pilots and navigators, lawless corners of space with local warlords, and rebellion against smothering centralization, but its first-person protagonist and point of view have more in common with urban fantasy. It's written in first-person and, at times, nearly stream of consciousness from Jax's perspective, and Jax displays plenty of profanity, acidic commentary, and emotional angst. If her special ability were shapeshifting or magic instead of jumping spaceships, one could easily see her as the typical burned-out urban fantasy detective. I liked that. It's a fun point of view when it's written well, and it felt fresh when applied to a science fiction background instead of the more typical fantasy. That said, Grimspace has a rather rough start. Jax isn't sure what's going on at first and also isn't sure she cares, and I thought that carried over to the reader's experience. The first section of the book is rough and jagged, with staccato bursts of character introduction, world-building that doesn't quite cohere, and an extended stop on a very odd outback planet that felt to me like a repurposed stage from a western. Part of the early problem is that Jax and the reader are being intentionally kept in the dark about the real goal of this group, but part of the problem is also that none of the characters start off as very likable. That includes Jax, who is a complete mess and who is both scared and despairing to the point of being almost nihilistic. The world-building unfortunately does not carry the reader through that part of the story, and at about eighty pages in I wasn't sure I was going to like this book. It does, however, get much better. For one, Jax calms down and starts making emotional connections with the rest of the crew, and that lets her demonstrate skills as a fearless problem solver. For another, while the goal of the group of people she's fallen in with isn't exactly deep, it does make sense and it does slowly become a cause the reader (and Jax) can believe in. The frenetic pace of introduction and discovery also slows down, the cast stabilizes, and the surroundings get a bit less weird (and a bit more conventional for a science fiction novel). I didn't care for the alien baby subplot I rarely do but the rest of the story slowly pulled me in. One thing Aguirre did extremely well was surprise me. There are several points later in the book where Jax gets put in a fairly typical high-stress position and does something very atypical in reaction to it, twisting the story into a shape quite a bit unlike what I had been expecting. That made Jax feel like a true free agent, establishing her independence and her desire to control her own life, and that appealed to me. Aguirre also palms one card exceptionally well, setting up an ending that I thought was the best set of scenes in the whole book, and that had me thoroughly engrossed. One can see the bones of the urban fantasy heroine inside Jax's character, but they're fresh and interesting in an SF world, and they work better than I would have expected. There is a romance, in fitting with the urban fantasy inspiration, and it didn't quite work for me, but Aguirre also builds in a reason why it might not make sense and makes it spiky and fragile without being too cliched. By the end of the book, I was, if not entirely persuaded, at least willing to go along for the ride. And that's the best summary of Grimspace, I think. Parts of it don't make a great deal of sense, and parts of it are quite choppy. But I liked Jax once she starts getting a handle on her trauma, the other characters grew on me, and the plot surprised me in some interesting ways. It's not the smoothest or most polished SF novel I've read, but it has a lot of energy and an unusual genre mix. I think I'll stick along for the ride. Followed by Wanderlust. Rating: 7 out of 10

Russ Allbery: krb5-strength 2.0

This is a rather huge release of my password strength checking package for Heimdal and MIT Kerberos KDCs, incorporating quite a bit of new work as well as some substantial restructuring. The largest change is that MIT Kerberos is now fully supported, not just with provided patches, thanks to work by Greg Hudson and MIT. The package can now build plugins for either MIT or Heimdal, as well as an external password quality program for Heimdal (the preferred method for that implementation). Alongside that change, the plugin installation path has changed to fit the layout of MIT plugins (as well as I understand it). This version also now supports password dictionaries other than CrackLib. You can generate a CDB dictionary from a wordlist using a utility included in the package and use it instead of or as a supplement to CrackLib. This dictionary lookup uses a much simpler set of permutations (the password as given plus removing some leading and trailing characters), providing a simpler approach suitable for much larger dictionaries. (CrackLib does a lot of transformations before dictionary lookup that are dubious, such as ignoring case and punctuation.) Also in this release are new configuration options to control additional checks: minimum password length (independent of whatever length CrackLib requires), requiring at least one non-alphabetic character, and rejecting non-ASCII or non-printable characters. The latter isn't to make the password stronger, but to prevent user frustration since those characters often can't be reliably entered in different situations and can result in an unreproducible password, particularly since Kerberos doesn't define a password normalization. In support of these changes, and to make testing easier, the plugin can be configured without a dictionary of any kind, or with any combination of CDB and CrackLib dictionaries. The checks for passwords based on principals are now more comprehensive, checking not only the local part but also each component of the principal with leading or trailing digits. Since many sites put their institution name in the Kerberos realm, this will also check for passwords based on the institution name. There are also some fixes to the internal CrackLib implementation, in case it is used instead of the system CrackLib, to better handle long passwords by scaling the test for simplistic passwords. You can get the latest release from the krb5-strength distribution page.

6 October 2013

Russ Allbery: AFS::PAG 1.01

This is a small bug-fix release for my AFS::PAG Perl module, which wraps the libkafs or libkopenafs interface. I apparently had only thoroughly tested the build system when the internal libkafs replacement was used, and it didn't build properly if real AFS libraries were available. That should now be fixed, and I also fixed the metadata to note that autodie is required. You can get the latest version from the AFS::PAG distribution page.

Russ Allbery: podlators 2.5.3

This is a quick bug-fix release of my collection of POD formatters. When I fixed a problem with the latest Pod::Simple and added some tests, I had assumed that the behavior of Pod::Simple with invalid POD would always be the same. Unfortunately, for the particular invalid POD that triggered the bug, versions of Pod::Simple from Perl 5.16 and earlier didn't produce any errors. That caused the test case to fail everywhere since it didn't find the error section it expected. This release now skips those specific tests on older versions, while still ensuring that no unexpected exceptions or warnings are thrown. It also fixes a documentation bug I noticed while working on other things. You can get the latest release from CPAN or from the podlators distribution page.

Russ Allbery: Review: Captain Vorpatril's Alliance

Review: Captain Vorpatril's Alliance, by Lois McMaster Bujold
Series: Vorkosigan #14
Publisher: Baen
Copyright: November 2012
ISBN: 1-4516-3845-0
Format: Kindle
Pages: 432
This is the fourteenth book in the long-running Vorkosigan series (not counting a few side works). It shifts viewpoint characters, following Ivan Vorpatril instead of either Miles or Cordelia, and could be read on its own since the necessary background is at least briefly explained. But it's probably best read in its proper context in the larger series, since otherwise many of the prior events mentioned here won't have much resonance. Ivan Vorpatril, Miles's cousin, has appeared in multiple previous books along with the rest of Miles's extended family, but he's stayed out of the center of the plot. And he clearly likes it that way. Ivan is not at all ambitious, tries to avoid politics, and just wants to live a quiet life (insofar as that's possible in the Barrayan military), sleep with a few women, and stay out of trouble. But given his relations and his job as aide-de-camp to an admiral this doesn't always work. In this book, the not working comes in the form of Byerly, ImpSec (Imperial Security, the Barrayan equivalent of the CIA), and a request to find out more about a woman who seems to be the target of a bounty. Fairly quickly, Ivan finds himself hopelessly entangled in both politics and in someone else's complex life, and is not entirely sure what to do about either. It's been months since I read this book and I'm only now writing a review, in part because I find it hard to know what to say about it. While Ivan doesn't have Miles's manic energy, the tone of this book is very similar to the rest of the Vorkosigan series, as is the plot and most of the characters. Ivan tries a more laid-back approach and doesn't actively seek danger the way that Miles does, but his persistent efforts to do the right thing in the face of unexpected events lead mostly to the same places. There's a bit of humor, a bit of danger, some galactic politics, some scheming, and a slow process of understanding other people better in short, Captain Vorpatril's Alliance is very similar to the thirteen books that proceeded it. This is obviously not a bad thing. If you've read this far in the series, more of the same is probably just fine. I enjoyed the book. Bujold is great at telling stories, the plot mostly moved right along, and I quite liked the two women Ivan meets over the course of the story. But there wasn't much about the story that grabbed me or, I suspect, that I will find particularly memorable. One reason for my somewhat "meh" reaction is that the core of this story is a romance, and while much of that romance is well-done, there is a large segment in the middle of the book where the suspense of the plot derives mostly from one of the two characters refusing to confide in the other. This is Bujold, so this isn't as much of a train wreck as it might be in the hands of another author, and it is for valid plot reasons. But even with those justifications, I never like that plot element. There were about a hundred pages where I wanted to grab Tej and shake some sense into her, which doesn't endear a character to me. And the leads in a romance, at least this sort of romance, should be endearing. I think one reason why Bujold went for that approach to building tension is that there weren't a lot of options available. The basic outlines of what's going to happen are obvious from early in the book and essentially forced by the structure of the series. We know from past books that Ivan is both trustworthy and related to a staggering variety of powerful people, almost all of whom are highly competent and honorable. It's fairly obvious that, as soon as the necessary people trust Ivan and let him and his family solve their problems, all the problems will be solved. It's also fairly obvious how the romances will play out, and that all the new characters will end up a little in awe of how competent and trustworthy all the Barrayans are (a few misdirections aside). Therefore, much of the book, for a long-time reader of the series, involves waiting until those things happen, and meanwhile getting increasingly annoyed at characters who refuse to trust obviously trustworthy people. All that said, I still quite liked the beginning of the book, because Tej and Rish are a wonderful pair and have a great interpersonal dynamic, and the very end of the book once everyone gets past the communication problems and the plot can deliver on its promises. Both together make up for some noticeable sagging in the middle section of the book. Captain Vorpatril's Alliance is not up to the standards of the most memorable books of the series, but it's a solid dose of "more of the same" and provides its money's worth of entertainment. I'm still hoping for more Ekaterin and more fireworks in the next book, though. Rating: 7 out of 10

5 October 2013

Russ Allbery: Miscellaneous haul

Despite the fact that I've had very little time to either read or write reviews, I haven't stopped buying a few books here and there. And, of course, Powell's Indiespensable keeps coming. Matt Bell In the House Upon the Dirt Between the Lake and the Woods (mainstream)
Steven Brust Orca (sff)
Steven Brust Dragon (sff)
John W. Campbell Collected Editorials from Analog (non-fiction)
Jane Fletcher The Walls of Westernfort (sff)
Mira Grant How Green This Land, How Blu This Sea (sff)
Tate Hallaway Tall, Dark, & Dead (sff)
Diana Wynne Jones Howl's Moving Castle (sff)
Rebecca Lee Bobcat and Other Stories (mainstream)
Victor Lombardi Why We Fail (non-fiction)
George R.R. Martin & Gardner Dozois (ed.) Songs of Love and Death (sff anthology)
Seanan McGuire In Sea-Salt Tears (sff)
Seanan McGuire Late Eclipses (sff)
Justina Robson Selling Out (sff)
John Scalzi Muse of Fire (sff)
Mark Slouka Brewster (mainstream)
Tor.com (ed.) The Stories (sff anthology)
Carrie Vaughn Kitty and the Midnight Hour (sff) This is a wide variety of random stuff, including some stuff that was free (the Tor.com anthology, which is every piece of short fiction they've published and is about 4000 pages, the Campbell editorials from the Internet Archive) and a lot of stuff that was on sale. As well as another two shipments of Indiespensible. The Brust books I've already read and are already in the family, but I hooked a friend of mine on the Vlad Taltos series, and those were the only two that I both didn't have and that weren't available on Kindle. So I picked them up while he was visiting so that he could read the whole series.

Next.

Previous.