Search Results: "Russ Allbery"

1 March 2014

Russ Allbery: Review: Air Apparent

Review: Air Apparent, by Mark Monmonier
Publisher: University of Chicago
Copyright: 1999
Printing: 2000
ISBN: 0-226-53423-5
Format: Trade paperback
Pages: 232
Subtitled "how meteorologists learned to map, predict, and dramatize the weather," Air Apparent is a history of weather maps. Mapping the weather is a surprisingly new field, dating only from the early 19th century when a combination of scientific understanding and the ability to combine scattered observations made it practical. They're also a particularly tricky problem since weather is inherently three-dimensional, and even to the present day nearly all of our maps are two-dimensional. Monmonier starts with the earliest observational maps and the attempts to use them for prediction and tracks developments up to the late 1990s, with TV weathermen and (simple) interactive web data viewers. I got a copy of this book after Paul Krugman mentioned it. I don't know a lot about weather forecasting or weather maps, but I remembered finding the science of weather fronts and maps of them fascinating in high school, and I hoped I'd get the same feeling from this. Unfortunately, I probably need to stop reading Monmonier's books; they always sound interesting, but I don't enjoy reading them. One thing that's important to know is that this is not a history of meteorology. One can't hold that against the book, of course, because it never claimed to be. But it has just enough of a history of meteorology mixed into its history of map-making to make at least this reader wish he were reading that other book. I like maps, I really do, but I was hoping for either a book that melded a history of the science of weather forecasting with the maps that were used in that science, or a book that dove deep into the effective and ineffective ways to make weather maps (ideally, Edward R. Tufte for maps). This is neither; it's little more or less than a detailed history of the making of weather maps. Each time it gets close to a clear explanation of the underlying meteorology, it finds a map to examine and skips the rest of the explanation. I kept almost understanding the underlying science, but not enough to really understand the goals of the map makers, or why one presentation was better than another, or how those presentations were used to make forecasts or track weather data. I think I would have found this book more interesting in conjunction with a full history of meteorology, but I suspect that a history of meteorology would include enough about the maps to render this book largely redundant for the casual reader. The other problem I had with this book is that it's very dry. Monmonier is clearly trying, and clearly cares a lot about his topic, but the book has no flow. I kept getting lost in the barrage of names, arguments over technique, and struggles for government funding. It's hard to put a finger on why the book didn't grab me; the closest I can come is that it's a book stuffed full of facts. Monmonier did exhaustive historical research on weather map making, saved numerous quotes from original documents, and laid it all out chronologically. That's fine if you just want the information, but I was looking to be entertained in the process, and that didn't happen. I think the problems get worse in the second half of the book, when weather satellites and computers enter the picture and the laborious, manual map-making fall out, although maybe I was just exhausted with the book by then. The early history of weather maps at least has the benefit of showing the logistical struggles behind creating an effective weather service: insufficient observation points, slow communication methods, and the need for skilled map-makers to turn measurements into visual representations. Once computers and satellite photography enter the picture, the science matters even more, and I think the reader needs a better understanding of the underlying science to make sense of the results. Air Apparent has a tendency to provide a brief introduction to the type of data, a detailed chronological history, and then a discussion of the ways of presenting and representing that data, without ever getting the reader to care about the data itself or see how it ties into forecasting. Part of the problem, I suspect, is that the history of meteorology seems to be full of sensible, careful people who largely did sensible, careful things with the data they had available at the time. This is great for the advancement of science, and not so helpful at making a history engrossing. I wish I could say that I was glad I read this book for the information, if not the presentation, but unfortunately I didn't retain much. I needed some sort of structure or frame on which to hang all of the specifics, some sense of story or controversy or at least scientific understanding, and I didn't get it. It took me a couple of months to finish this book because I kept setting it down to read other things, and I only finished it out of a combination of stubbornness and knowledge that other people liked it. If the topic sounds interesting, well, this book exists, and it's gotten several good reviews. But I'm afraid I can't recommend it. Rating: 4 out of 10

14 February 2014

Gergely Nagy: I love Free Software

I love Free Software! I love Free Software, and the people behind it. Even though I have been a free software user and developer for more than a decade now, there's still more to be amazed at, still more to contribute, and still more to learn. I love the Free Software community, because it never ceases to amaze me. It's not just about the technical side, but the social, human side of it, too!During the past year, I came to another milestone in my career: as of july first, I am a Free Software developer, and enjoying every moment of it. This is a feat that could not have been done without there being demand for what I do, without the free software community as a whole. For that, I owe you all a big thank you, you make it possible for me to make my dream come true. I can only hope that through my work, and through my example, I can contribute back enough.To this day, I take delight in contributing to free software, be it a Lisp on Python (or projects built in it), any of my own projects, syslog-ng, Google Summer of Code mentoring, Debian work - any and all of that are great fun. Even processing NEW is (I really should do that more often)! It's an endless source of not only entertainment and knowledge, but inspiration too.Whenever I read something as amazing as Russ Allbery's mail on the Debian technical committee impasse, I realize just how amazing people we have in our community, and how much we all can learn from them, and how much we owe them. This is yet another reason why I feel that contributing to Free Software is a passion many can share, because it teaches us good values too, atop of being technically excellent.I love Free Software, because without it, I would be lost. Thank you.

7 February 2014

Russ Allbery: Things I learn from reading Reddit

I am apparently an Ent. I think that's one of the nicest things that anyone has said about me this year. I'm feeling quite delighted by it. I'm not sure it's the character from Lord of the Rings that fits me the best, and for personal reasons I have to default to identifying with Gwaihir, but it definitely captures a substantial component of my personality. Hoom.

6 February 2014

Russ Allbery: New init system feature!

The Debian Technical Committee has concluded that all of the available init systems were missing a key technical feature, and, in the spirit of free software, has gone ahead and fixed that lack. All init systems currently packaged for Debian can now double as test case generators for Condorcet vote analysis. I'm not sure if this counts as an NMU. In the event that the Debian project votes on a General Resolution on the default init system, this blog post should be considered striken in its entirety and replaced by the most complex email message from Anthony Towns that the reader can find.

29 January 2014

Russ Allbery: remctl 3.8

remctl is the middleware system that we use everywhere at Stanford. It's a very simple way to run commands, constrained by ACLs, over a GSS-API-authenticated with good encryption. This release doesn't have a lot of obvious user-visible changes. Rather, it's an internal refactoring and cleanup release that will make further changes easier. The major change is that the process event loop, which runs the command and sends its output back over the wire to the client, now uses libevent. This makes the code cleaner and fixes various problems previously caused by portability, such as the lack of proper handling of SIGCHLD forcing a short poll interval to see if the child had exited. While working on that, I also found and cleaned up several other minor issues: the maximum output per remctl token now matches the protocol maximum, rather than the arbitrary and strange choice of 65,000 octets, and I fixed a few minor memory leaks in the server and client that no one probably would have noticed. The server also now writes its PID file atomically. You can get the latest release from the remctl distribution page.

Russ Allbery: rra-c-util 5.2

Another release of my general collection of utility libraries, Autoconf probes, general test cases, and similar things. The major change in this release is the addition of Autoconf probes and portability wrappers for libevent. Now included are Autoconf macros to probe for libevent (mandatory or optional) either via pkg-config or not, following the pattern of other probes in rra-c-util. Also included is a portability wrapper, probes, and some additional glue code that allows programs to be written against the libevent 2.x API and work (mostly) with the libevent 1.4 API, albeit with some missing functionality. This release fixes the systemd unit directory probe to not produce shell errors if pkg-config isn't available on the local system. It also fixes a syntax error when building portable/krb5.h with a C++ compiler. There are multiple improvements to the Kerberos and process TAP add-ons: memory is properly freed in all processes, making exhaustive memory allocation analysis easier; process output is flushed after stopping the process instead of before; the method used to stop processes is cleaner; a memory leak when running via fakeroot has been fixed; and full use is made of the new test_cleanup_register API in C TAP Harness. This release also adds a new message_handlers_reset function that restores all message handlers to their defaults and frees any memory allocated to set different handlers. This again is mostly useful when doing exhaustive memory allocation testing. You can get the latest release from the rra-c-util distribution page.

Russ Allbery: C TAP Harness 3.0

This is my test harness and C and shell library for writing test suites using the Test Anything Protocol (also used by Perl). The changes in this release aren't that major, but I changed one API in a non-backward-compatible way, so I bumped the major revision. That change is to test_cleanup_register, whose callback functions now take two arguments instead of one. The first, as before, indicates whether the test case succeeded or failed. The second is now true if the callback is running in the primary process (the one in which plan or plan_lazy was called), and false otherwise. Callback functions are now called for all processes, not just the primary one. This allows cleanup of per-process resources, like memory, in the child processes, which allows for easier valgrind analysis. Also in this release, the test harness was modified to reopen standard input to /dev/null when running a set of tests from a list, rather than inheriting standard input from the test driver. The test harness also now cleans up all extraneous copies of open file descriptors used during the setup of standard input, output, and error to avoid leaking harmless but noticeable file descriptors to tests. You can get the latest release from the C TAP Harness distribution page.

15 January 2014

Russ Allbery: kadmin-remctl 3.6

Another minor tweak to the remctl backend for Kerberos administrative functions that we use at Stanford. This still isn't the long-awaited rewrite that might make this more generally useful outside of Stanford's specific requirements. This release adds support for setting a password expiration on newly-created accounts via a configuration setting in the local configuration file. The password expiration period can be configured per-instance. (Eventually, this should be handled via policy support instead, but this was easier for my immediate purposes.) This release also maps password quality error messages on create or reset_passwd to generic messages in the Heimdal backend. This is only of interest to sites such as ours that have patched Heimdal to do password quality checks for administrative actions as well as user-initiated password changes. The kadmin protocol unfortunately doesn't have a way to pass back the verbose password quality error. You can get the latest version from the kadmin-remctl distribution page.

9 January 2014

Russ Allbery: Review: Honeyed Words

Review: Honeyed Words, by J.A. Pitts
Series: Sarah Beauhall #2
Publisher: Tor
Copyright: July 2011
ISBN: 0-7653-2907-7
Format: Trade paperback
Pages: 412
Honeyed Words is a direct sequel to Black Blade Blues and probably doesn't make sense to read out of order. Sarah, Katie, their friends, and Katie's family are still recovering from the climactic events of Black Blade Blues and licking their wounds, but things are slowly looking up. Sarah is getting more comfortable openly expressing her sexuality, although there are still tensions, and her relationships are improving. The city of Vancouver also seems to be recovering. But major political shifts among the nonhuman races have echoes and ramifications, and after a kidnapped singer and a murdered dwarf, Sarah is pulled back into the turmoil. If you liked the world-building in Black Blade Blues, Honeyed Words is more of the same, but with more variety. Pitts adds elves to dwarves and dragons, shows considerably more of the supernatural world beneath the surface of human cities, and introduces Sarah to some new types of danger. There are a few more glimmers of the history of Sarah's sword and the nature of the gods in this universe, but still nothing conclusive. Pitts broadens the world-building rather than deepening it. But I liked the new characters. Teenage elves with obsessions make for great characters, and the demon who shows up about halfway through is delightful. As with the first book, this is mostly a story of things happening to Sarah while she tries to muddle through as best she can. There isn't much in the way of grand strategy or of seizing control of the plot. She just tries to do the right thing and gets lots of help from lots of friends. But the plot moves right along, and it's mixed with a healthy sense of normality that I find refreshing. She needs work as a blacksmith, she's trying to support a friend without having much money of her own, the living arrangements this forces are a bit of a strain for her own relationships, and her broken relationship with her family continues to lurk. Much urban fantasy is built around the premise of a regular person thrust into a fantasy world, but much of it then discards normal life once the supernatural starts. I think Pitts does a particularly good job of keeping his protagonist's life grounded in the ongoing mundane problems of living. It's also more fun to read about Sarah when she isn't quite as angstful. Over the course of Honeyed Words, she seems to be growing into a person who can accept who she is and feel secure about her place in the world. That's nice to see. The downside to this book is that, while it's full of quite a lot of stuff, not all of it coheres that horribly well. It has a certain "middle book" feel. The major plot resolves, but with some significant lingering consequences and something of a cliff-hanger last chapter. Most of the threads left open by the first book are still open here. There's character growth, and setup for some resolution, but not a lot of actual resolution. I still like this series, though. I like urban fantasy that isn't about vampires and werewolves; berserker blacksmiths and Norse legend has much more appeal, and I want to read more of it. Pitts's writing is a bit clunky and probably won't win many rewards, but it's serviceable and I think improving. If you enjoyed the first book, it's worth looking for this one as well. Followed by Forged in Fire. Rating: 7 out of 10

6 January 2014

Russ Allbery: remctl 3.7

remctl is the middleware layer that we use everywhere at Stanford. It's a simple GSS-API-authenticated network service that supports running commands with ACLs. There are client bindings available for a wide variety of programming languages. This release fixes a couple of irritating bugs: the client library leaked memory when remctl_set_ccache was used (which was affecting mod_webkdc from WebAuth), and Net::Remctl::Backend didn't validate argument counts correctly when one of the arguments came from standard input (which affected krb5-sync). I also worked around a bug in RHEL 5's Module::Build, and added sanity checking to Net::Remctl and related classes to ensure that the object argument wasn't undef. Also new in this release are support in the remctld server for systemd startup notification and socket activation, and (via the -Z) flag) support for upstart's expect stop synchronization method. This is mostly a "clearing the decks" release in advance of more significant work. The next release will replace the server event loop with libevent, in preparation for further improvements in how the server can handle persistent worker children. You can get the latest release from the remctl distribution page.

Raphaël Hertzog: My Free Software Activities in December 2013

This is my monthly summary of my free software related activities. If you re among the people who made a donation to support my work (147.56 , thanks everybody!), then you can learn how I spent your money. Otherwise it s just an interesting status update on my various projects. The Debian Administrator s Handbook Cover of the Debian Administrator's Handbook (Wheezy edition)I spent a good chunk of December on the book. First finalizing the English version and getting it out (BTW, just for the launch, there s a 10% discount on the paperback that lasts only until January 9th!). Then working on updating the French translation. Eyrolles will publish a new edition of the French book based on this translation. Expect some further news about this during January! Debian France I contributed to many discussions within Debian France. Starting with a complaint that most events are organized in Paris, I proposed to map the location of Debian France members. We added new fields in the membership management page so that members can add their GPS coordinates and Fr d ric Decou made some experiments with Openstreetmap. Someone else (Kiriarat) volunteered to write the required glue code. A manual map is currently maintained on the website. Sample logo receivedIn the discussions about the setup of the Debian France shop, I suggested to update our logo with a nicer looking one. We got a few suggestions and after further discussions with Alexandre Delano and Sylvestre Ledru, we organized a small contest to entice designers to submit a logo proposal to us (the winner earns a set of Debian goodies). We got 46 proposals (see my favorite on the right)! The board is currently pre-selecting the logos and setting up the final vote for our members. The winner shall be announced at the end of the upcoming mini-debconf in Paris. I also continued the work to finalize new bylaws and new internal rules. They shall be adopted during the next general assembly which will happen during the mini-debconf. Misc Debian Work WordPress maintenance. I mentored Pablo Vasquez to do his first small contribution to the WordPress packaging. I really appreciate this but he s not yet ready to assume maintenance of a big package like WordPress on his own. I got multiple other offers of help and pinged them all while filing #733726 to coordinate the work on the new upstream version. But I got no reply :-( Handing over packages to new maintainers is hard Init system discussion. The technical committee has the hard task of picking the default init system that will replace the traditional System V init (see #727708). I followed this huge discussion closely and contributed a bit where I add something meaningful to say. Final decision is expected sometimes in January. FWIW, I share entirely Russ Allbery s point of view in those discussions. I have been running systemd on some of my computers for a few months already. Fixing lxc in stable. The lxc package in stable has a non-working debian template. I really dislike documenting that things are broken so instead of doing that in the Debian Administrator s Handbook, I opted to do something about it. I prepared a non maintainer upload for stable (see #680469 for the problem and #732358 for the stable update request). Misc stuff. I sponsored a tcpdf upload. I filed an enhancement request on Publican to have it keep processing instructions present in translations. I uploaded new versions of publican-librement and debian-handbook. I filed #732678 against git-buildpackage because it failed to properly call lintian when given the -A dpkg-buildpackage argument. Thanks See you next month for a new summary of my activities.

No comment Liked this article? Click here. My blog is Flattr-enabled.

Russ Allbery: rra-c-util 5.1

The primary addition in this release is the Autoconf macros and header wrapper that I developed for lbcd to add systemd support. These are inspired by the code in systemd's daemon(7) man page but adjusted for my normal software conventions. This is just preliminary and doesn't yet stub out all of the functions, only the ones I've needed so far. Also in this release, I fixed a bug with process_start_fakeroot, and hence with remctld_start_fakeroot, introduced in the last release when I rewrote the TAP process management add-on. You can get the latest release from the rra-c-util distribution page.

5 January 2014

Russ Allbery: More on displaying files with head

That was fun! Since my previous entry on using head to display the contents of several files in a form that's easy to cut and paste, multiple people have sent elaborations or related tricks. It seemed like it would be a good idea to post a roundup, since I learned a bunch. Multiple people (I think Josh Triplett was the first) pointed out that one can avoid having to pick a sufficiently large value of -n by instead using:
    head -n -0 *.install
With GNU head at least, a negative number says to print out all lines of the file except that many at the end, so -0 displays the whole file, regardless of size. Unfortunately, while this works anywhere that I am likely to run it, it's not specified by POSIX, while the original is. Another variation, pointed out by Buck Huppmann, is:
    tail -n +0 *.install
The +0 syntax is required by POSIX, unlike the -0 syntax for head... but unfortunately POSIX doesn't require that tail supports multiple files and the headers, although it does for head. Buck also pointed out that including the -v flag will always force the header even if there's only one file, which is useful. (Although be warned that -v isn't a POSIX-recognized flag.) Markus Raab also pointed out the xsel utility, which I'd heard of but hadn't ever used. If the goal is to cut and paste the output, using:
    head -v -n -0 *.install   xsel -i
avoids the cut part by dumping the result directly into the X selection. Buck pointed out xclip, which does the same thing. Both can be used with the -o flag inside an editor to paste as well if you don't want to reach for a mouse. In vi :r !xclip -o, and in Emacs, C-u M-! xclip -o. Finally, Guillem Jover metioned that:
    grep . *.install
does sort of the same thing with a different output format that may be more useful depending on what you're doing. (I find it less human-readable but more machine-parsable.)

4 January 2014

Russ Allbery: lbcd 3.5.1

This is a small bug-fix release of this load-balancing system status daemon. The primary purpose of the release is to merge the various fixes to the new systemd unit files that I made in the Debian package after a broader code review. This release also fixes a long-lived oversight and sets lbcd's listening sockets to close-on-exec so that they're not inherited by external weight commands (already handled under systemd by socket activation) and improves the lbcd man page. You can get the latest version from the lbcd distribution page.

3 January 2014

Russ Allbery: A quick copy-paste UNIX trick

I ran across this trick a long time ago and now use it regularly, but it occurred to me today that I don't remember seeing anyone else mention it. So, just in case it helps someone else: I often find myself wanting to copy and paste the contents of several small files into an email message, particularly when explaining Debian packaging. I want to show all the file contents with little headers showing which lines come from each file. This gets tedious if I actually do this file-by-file. The obvious approaches, from including them into my editor to cat'ing them one-by-one and pasting them, are tedious and require writing the headers by hand. Obviously, cat doesn't help, since it obliterates the difference between the files. What does help, however, is good old head (or tail, for that matter). People normally use those utilities with standard input or a single file, but you can give them multiple files, and they do just about exactly what you want. Consider this shell transcript:
    % head -n 20 *.install
    ==> liblog4shib-dev.install <==
    usr/bin/log4shib-config
    usr/include/*
    usr/lib/*/lib*.a
    usr/lib/*/lib*.so
    usr/lib/*/pkgconfig/log4shib.pc
    usr/share/aclocal/log4shib.m4
    debian/log4shib-config.1 usr/share/man/man1
    ==> liblog4shib-doc.install <==
    usr/share/doc/log4shib-*/api/html usr/share/doc/liblog4shib-doc
    ==> liblog4shib1.install <==
    usr/lib/*/lib*.so.*
Just pick some value for -n that's longer than any of the files (I normally want to show the contents of small files anyway), run head on all the files whose contents you want to show, and then you can cut and paste its full output directly into your email message. Bonus: This behavior is even guaranteed by POSIX (something that I didn't realize until I checked while writing this post).

1 January 2014

Russ Allbery: 2013 Book Reading in Review

What a strange year. 2013 was marked by a whole sequence of entirely unexpected events, including multiple major work upheavals. For large chunks of the year, I had very little time or emotional energy for personal reading goals, and particularly for writing reviews. I declared personal amnesty on most of my intentions halfway through the year, and all the totals will reflect that. On the plus side (although not for reading and reviews), it was a great year for video games. Next year, there will be no specific goals. Between continuing work fallout, a very busy project schedule, my intent to keep playing a lot of video games, and various other personal goals I want to take on, I'm going to take the pressure off of reading. Things will be read and reviews will be written (and I'm going to make more of an effort to write reviews shortly after reading books), but I'm not going to worry about how many. The below statistics are confined to the books I reviewed in 2013. I read six more books that I've not yet reviewed, due to the chaos at the end of the year. Those will be counted in 2014. There were no 10 out of 10 books this year, partly due to the much lower reading totals and partly due to my tendency this year to turn to safe comfort reading, which is reliably good but unlikely to be exceptional. There were, however, several near-misses that were worth calling out. My favorite book of the year was Neal Stephenson's Anathem, which narrowly missed a 10 for me due to some fundamental problems with the plot premise. But this is still an excellent book: the best novel about the practice of science and philosophy that I've ever read. Also deserving mention are K.E. Lane's And Playing the Role of Herself, lovely and intelligent lesbian romance that's likely to appeal even to people who would not normally try that genre, and Guy Gavriel Kay's River of Stars. The latter isn't quite at the level of Kay's earlier Under Heaven, but it's still an excellent work of alternate historical fiction in a memorable setting. A special honorable mention goes to Lisa O'Donnell's The Death of Bees. It requires a lot of warnings for very dark subject matter and a rather abrupt ending, but it's been a long time since I've cared that much about the characters of a book. My favorite non-fiction book of the year was Gary J. Hudson's They Had to Go Out, a meticulously researched account of a tragic Coast Guard mission. The writing is choppy, the editing could have been better, and it's clear that the author is not a professional writer, but it's the sort of detailed non-fiction account that can only be written by someone who's been there and lived through similar experiences. Also worth mentioning is Mark Jason Dominus's Higher Order Perl, which was the best technical book I read all year and which I found quite inspiring for my own programming. The full analysis includes some additional personal reading statistics, probably only of interest to me.

Russ Allbery: Review: The Female Man

Review: The Female Man, by Joanna Russ
Publisher: Beacon
Copyright: 1975
Printing: 1986
ISBN: 0-8070-6299-5
Format: Trade paperback
Pages: 214
The Female Man is one of the most famous novels of feminist science fiction, written by a giant of the field. Joanna Russ was one of the strongest writers of the first era of explicitly feminist SF and one of the most challenging. Along with Alice Sheldon (James Tiptree, Jr.) and Sheri Tepper, she's probably the best known author whose approach tended towards the directly confrontational. She was also a noted essayist, critic, and reviewer; her book How to Suppress Women's Writing is one of the most famous works of feminist literary criticism. That said, I wasn't sure what to expect from this book. I'd heard that it was about four different women: Jeannine, Joanna, Janet, and Jael. They're parallels of sorts but from far different cultures, alternate worlds displaced in time. I'd also heard that it was full of biting, accurate sarcasm, which is certainly the case. This is a book written from a place of righteous anger combined with keen social observation and a desire to point out how different the world could be. And how toxic male behavior towards women currently is. What it's not, however, is much of a novel, in the sense of having a clear plot that carries the reader through the book. There is a story of sorts, which revolves around the appearance of Janet in Joanna's time. Janet is a native of Whileaway, an alternate future Earth in which there are no men at all and social organization is significantly different. We get a fairly detailed description of her life and of some Whileaway customs over the course of the book. But they're mixed with excerpts from the lives of both Jeannine (from an alternate past in which the Great Depression never ended) and Joanna. If Janet's story is a sort of utopian alternate future, following the basic model of female separatist societies, Jeannine's is the dystopia drawn from our past. She's locked entirely into traditional gender roles and the desire to catch a man and be a wife. I found her the hardest character to read about by far, largely because she locks herself into the worst constraints of that role. She's almost entirely passive, and she's devoted to a man for whom it's difficult to have any respect at all. Janet is interesting in part because she's not particularly exceptional in either ability or intelligence. She just reflects the Whileaway culture, which leads to some sharp conflicts with the norms of Joanna's time. It's a very effective tactic for alienating the reader from current gender roles (or, at least, roles from the 1970s) and showing how absurd they appear with a different set of starting assumptions. Russ makes the point clearly; this is not a book that tends towards the subtle, although it can be a little hard to track the characters' progress through alternate timelines. Towards the end of the book, they meet the fourth character. (This is not really the sort of book that is possible to spoil by summary.) Jael is by far the most aggressive of any of them, the closest that any of them come to the caricature of a "man-hating feminist." One of the strengths of The Female Man is that, by the time the story reaches her, I at least was feeling quite a lot of sympathy towards her aggressively violent approach, after watching Joanna be put down and Jeannine simper ineffectually. However, it's worth nothing that Janet, the representative of the supposed utopia, does not agree with Jael or her methods, and the relationship between their worlds is interestingly complex. None of the four characters are exactly wrong (although Jeannine comes close); none of them are entirely right either. They're all struggling in different ways with how to define femininity. While the quiet and simplicity of Janet's world has definite appeal, it's the sort of utopia that one isn't sure one would actually want. And Jael has some pointed commentary on how wanting such a world is one thing, but the acts required to create it is quite another. I can see why this book is so well-known. Many of the scenes that show gender relations and male behavior are both painful and funny. Reading it forty years after it was written, it's clear that social norms have changed; men do and say things here that they would no longer be able to get away with, that are clearly from another era. But it's also clear that some of the underlying attitudes have not changed, just been cloaked in different language. And Russ's bluntness here is refreshing: this book does not pull its punches, both in openly ridiculing sexist behavior, and in showing how oppressive it is for women. That said, it didn't work as a story for me, in part because the plot is sketchy at best. It's a collection of individual excerpts and commentary, only some of which are shaped like a story. Much of it feels stream of consciousness, and when cut between three different viewpoints, it's also occasionally confusing. There are also a few too-obvious characters: some of the men, particularly in Jael's section, but also Jeannine, who I never liked even after she starts changing her mind about women's roles. I wanted a bit more story and a bit less introspection. I think this is an important book that's worth reading, and sadly it's not as obsolete as one would like. But I don't think it's entirely successful as a novel. Best treated as a piece of literary history. Rating: 6 out of 10

30 December 2013

Russ Allbery: Init system evaluation thanks

Most people who follow Debian are probably aware that we're currently in the middle of a major debate over the future of Debian's init system. Over the past month, and particularly over the past week, I undertook an evaluation of two of the options in that debate, using one of my packages as a test bed. I also did a lot of reading, filed a few bugs, and asked a bunch of questions. That's an extension of the questions I've been asking and discussions I've been participating in around init systems for the past year plus. I have been keeping my opinions and writeups confined to the relevant Techncial Committee bug report so that they can be read in context with their rebuttals. There are a lot of thoughtful and well-informed opinions here, of which mine are only one, and several of my conclusions have been inaccurate or at least not complete, so the context is important. You can find the full traffic in the Technical Committee bug. Most of the discussion, in a threaded view, is in the Technical Committee archives for December. However, in one of the messages I sent today, I tried to show my appreciation for the people who have assisted with this evaluation over the past week, month, and years, and I think that section deserves broader distribution outside of the ongoing discussion. It is therefore included below. Throughout this evaluation process, my interactions with upstart and systemd upstream developers and Debian packagers have been uniformly excellent. Bug reports filed against both systemd and upstart have received excellent and timely response, and all involved have been quite willing to explain things I've misunderstood, correct my false starts, and discuss technical and practical aspects of their designs. I was particularly impressed by the clear effort that the systemd and upstart maintainers in Debian have put into fully integrating their init systems in such a way that makes them easy to test and use with existing Debian packages. This includes but is not limited to update-rc.d support, invoke-rc.d support, status synchronization with sysvinit, past Policy discussion, and attention to upgrade paths and init-switching use cases. I also want to particularly thank the OpenRC upstream development team for their involvement in this process and their contributions to the discussion. I personally don't think that package is a good match for Debian's needs on Linux, but that's through no fault of the people involved, and I think they would be an excellent upstream if that package looked like a good fit for the needs of any of Debian's non-Linux ports. I also want to thank Petter Reinholdtsen, Roger Leigh, and everyone else who has worked on the sysvinit package over the years, the insserv conversion to dependency-based boot, and the inclusion of LSB support. If it weren't for their hard work, we would be in a far worse position than we are today. It's often hard to see people discussing the inadequacies of something into which you put years of hard work. I want to call attention to their long-term contributions to the distribution, and to the number of Debian systems that have booted through their efforts over the years.

Lars Wirzenius: Thoughtful, inspiring words from Russ

Russ Allbery has written up summaries of the research he's done in preparation of a Debian Technical Committee vote on default init system in Debian's next release. The mails are long, and well worth reading completely if the topic interests you at all, but I'd like to quote separately a few paragraphs that I found thoughtful, and inspiring, in the greater Debian context and not just for the init system discussion. From "init system other points, and conclusion":
Here again, I think we have an opportunity for Debian to be more innovative and forward-looking in what we attempt to accomplish in the archive by adopting frameworks that let us incorporate the principles of least privilege and defense in depth into our standard daemon configurations.
And later, from the same mail:
I think we should make wise decisions about which areas we want to invest project effort. I dislike investing significant project effort in catch-up efforts that, when complete, merely get us back to where we would have been if we'd chosen a different solution. I don't think that's wise stewardship of project resources. I want to see Debian focus its efforts on places where we can make a real difference, where we can be leaders. That means adopting the best-of-breed existing solutions and building on top of them, not reinventing wheels and thereby starting from a trailing position.
From "loose ends for init system decision":
It is not, in general, necessary to justify what you want to do in Debian. It doesn't matter if it's going to be used by thousands of people or two people. If you can do your work to the standards that we expect to be maintained across the archive, and without negative impact on Debian's other contributors, you can work on whatever you love. And, furthermore, we all support each other in our passions. Debian is built on a culture of deference to other people's work, and reasonable accomodation to the projects that other people want to work on. Now, there is a fine balance here. Deference to other people's work does not mean a requirement to join their work. Reasonable accomodation does not mean that every Debian developer is required to test their software on non-Linux ports. The goal is that all of us should be empowered to work on the things we are passionate about, which implicitly includes being empowered to not work on the things that are not of interest to us. Therefore, for some efforts, and specifically for the non-Linux port efforts, the work is mostly born by the porters. They're expected to test, diagnose problems, and submit patches. The deference and reasonable accomodation that we expect of Debian contributors is to merge those patches when they are reasonable, to not undermine the porting effort when there is a reasonable approach that preserves it, and to be aware of the implications of their packaging for those ports in the broad sense (such as qualifying build-dependencies with [linux-any] where appropriate). We do not expect Debian contributors to reject significant new upstream versions or significant new integrations because they will affect the non-Linux ports, or, for that matter, other projects in Debian. We do expect those changes to follow the standards that we expect of Debian as a whole, and that porting efforts will be treated with deference and reasonable accomodation.
I won't offer a comment on these quotes I prefer to let them speak for themselves but I will say I find these to be among the wisest things said within Debian all year.

29 December 2013

Russ Allbery: Review: The Incrementalists

Review: The Incrementalists, by Steven Brust & Skyler White
Publisher: Tor
Copyright: September 2013
ISBN: 0-7653-3422-4
Format: Hardcover
Pages: 304
The Incrementalists are a secret society that has been in continuous existence for forty thousand years. The members are immortal... sort of (more on that in a moment). They are extremely good at determining what signals, triggers, and actions have the most impact on people, and adept at using those triggers to influence people's behavior. And they're making the world better. Not in any huge, noticeable way, just a little bit, here and there. Incrementally. Brust and White completely had me with this concept. There are several SF novels about immortals, but (apart from the vampire subgenre) they mostly stay underground and find ways to survive without trying to change the surrounding human society. I love the idea of small, incremental changes, and I was looking forward to reading a book about how that would work. How do they choose what to do? How do they find the right place to push? What long-term goals would such an organization pursue, and what governance structure would they use? I'm still wondering about most of those things, sadly, since that isn't what this novel is about at all. I should be fair: a few of those questions hover in the background. There are some political arguments (that parallel arguments on Brust's blog), and a tiny bit about governance. But mostly this is a sort of romance, a fight over identity, and an extensive exploration of the mental "garden" that the Incrementalists use and build to hold their memories and share information with each other. The story revolves around two Incrementalists: Phil, who is one of the leaders and has one of the longest continuous identities of any of the group, and Renee, a new recruit by Phil who picks up the memories and capabilities (sort of) of the recently-deceased Incrementalist Celeste. Phil is the long-term insider, although a fairly laid-back one. Renee is the outsider, the one to which the story is happening at the beginning, who is taught how the Incrementalists' system works. The Incrementalists is told in alternating first-person viewpoint sections by Phil and Renee (making me wonder if the characters were each written by one of the authors). Once I got past my disappointment over this book not being quite what I wanted, the identity puzzles that Brust and White play with here caught my attention. The underlying "magic" of the Incrementalists is based on the "memory palace" concept of storing memories via visualizations, but takes it into something akin to personal alternate worlds. Their immortality isn't through physical immortality, but rather the ability to store their memories and personality in their garden, which is their term for the memory palace, and then have it imposed on someone else: a combination of reincarnation, mental takeover, and mental merging. This makes for complex interpersonal relationships and complex interactions between memory, belief, and identity, not to mention some major ethical issues, which come to a head in Phil and Renee's relationship and Celeste's lingering meddling. I think Brust and White are digging into some interesting questions of character here. There's a lot of emphasis in The Incrementalists on the ease with which people can be manipulated, and the Incrementalists themselves are far from immune. Choice and personal definition are both questionable concepts given how much influence other people have, how many vulnerabilities everyone carries with them, and how much one's opinions are governed by one's life history. That makes identity complex, and raises the question of whether one can truly define oneself. But, while all these ideas are raised, I think The Incrementalists dances around them more than engages them directly. It's similar to the background hook: yes, these people are slowly improving the world, and we see a little bit of that (and a little bit of them manipulating people for their own convenience), but the story doesn't fully engage with the idea. There's a romance, a few arguments, some tension, some world-building, but I don't feel like this book ever fully committed to any of them. One of the occasional failure modes of Brust for me is insufficient explanation and insufficient clarity, and I hit that here. My final impression of The Incrementalists is interesting, enjoyable, but vaguely disappointing. It's still a good story with some interesting characters and nice use of the memory palace concept, and I liked Renee throughout (although I think the development of the love story is disturbingly easy and a little weird). But I can't strongly recommend it, and I'm not sure if it's worth seeking out. Rating: 7 out of 10

Next.

Previous.