Search Results: "rra"

24 March 2020

Norbert Preining: KDE/Plasma 5.18 for Debian

Update 2020-04-03: Please see this post for updated location of the packages!!! Now for i586 and amd64 architectures! I have been trying out the Plasma Desktop for one week now, and I am very positively surprised. Compared to the clumsy history of KDE3, the current desktop is extremely small-footprint and smooth, surprisingly. Integration is as expected great, and mixing programs from the other world (Gtk/Gnome) works also extremely smooth.
If there are a few things I would change, then mostly the chaos about kwallet and Gnome keyring. I would love to have one secret storage, and it seems that Gnome Keyring is preferrable, but this is in flux at the moment. Also, it is not that pressing, because I have moved all my passwords into pass and thus don t need the secret storage that much anymore. So, after a bit of working with Plasma, I realized that Debian still ships an old version, the most recent being 5.18.3 LTS. Thus, I embarked onto a journey of updating all the necessary packages, and there are a lot: in total 106 packages I did update (and one new one!) until I finally had a new plasma-desktop package available. If you are interested, there are binaries for amd64 and sources in my Debian repository (WARNING: These packages are for Debian/sid and maybe testing, and cannot be used with Buster!):
deb https://www.preining.info/debian unstable kde
deb-src https://www.preining.info/debian unstable kde
As usual, don t forget to import my GPG key, and all packages are without warranty :-; There are two packages that I didn t manage to update: kde-gtk-config which has changed a lot and contains far less files, and breeze-icons which fails on its own symlink tests. If anyone has an idea, please let me know. If other packages are missing, please also drop me a line and I ll try to update them. Enjoy.

Russ Allbery: Review: Lost in Math

Review: Lost in Math, by Sabine Hossenfelder
Publisher: Basic
Copyright: June 2018
ISBN: 0-465-09426-0
Format: Kindle
Pages: 248
Listening to experts argue can be one of the better ways to learn about a new field. It does require some basic orientation and grounding or can be confusing or, worse, wildly misleading, so some advance research or Internet searches are warranted. But it provides some interesting advantages over reading multiple popular introductions to a field. First, experts arguing with each other are more precise about their points of agreement and disagreement because they're trying to persuade someone who is well-informed. The points of agreement are often more informative than the points of disagreement, since they can provide a feel for what is uncontroversial among experts in the field. Second, internal arguments tend to be less starry-eyed. One of the purposes of popularizations of a field is to get the reader excited about it, and that can be fun to read. But to generate that excitement, the author has a tendency to smooth over disagreements and play up exciting but unproven ideas. Expert disagreements pull the cover off of the uncertainty and highlight the boundaries of what we know and how we know it. Lost in Math (subtitled How Beauty Leads Physics Astray) is not quite an argument between experts. That's hard to find in book form; most of the arguments in the scientific world happen in academic papers, and I rarely have the energy or attention span to read those. But it comes close. Hossenfelder is questioning the foundations of modern particle physics for the general public, but also for her fellow scientists. High-energy particle physics is facing a tricky challenge. We have a solid theory (the standard model) which explains nearly everything that we have currently observed. The remaining gaps are primarily at very large scales (dark matter and dark energy) or near phenomena that are extremely difficult to study (black holes). For everything else, the standard model predicts our subatomic world to an exceptionally high degree of accuracy. But physicists don't like the theory. The details of why are much of the topic of this book, but the short version is that the theory does not seem either elegant or beautiful. It relies on a large number of measured constants that seem to have no underlying explanation, which is contrary to a core aesthetic principle that physicists use to judge new theories. Accompanying this problem is another: New experiments in particle physics that may be able to confirm or disprove alternate theories that go beyond the standard model are exceptionally expensive. All of the easy experiments have been done. Building equipment that can probe beyond the standard model is incredibly expensive, and thus only a few of those experiments have been done. This leads to two issues: Particle physics has an overgrowth of theories (such as string theory) that are largely untethered from experiments and are not being tested and validated or disproved, and spending on new experiments is guided primarily by a sense of scientific aesthetics that may simply be incorrect. Enter Lost in Math. Hossenfelder's book picks up a thread of skepticism about string theory (and, in Hossenfelder's case, supersymmetry as well) that I previously read in Lee Smolin's The Trouble with Physics. But while Smolin's critique was primarily within the standard aesthetic and epistemological framework of particle physics, Hossenfelder is questioning that framework directly. Why should nature be beautiful? Why should constants be small? What if the universe does have a large number of free constants? And is the dislike of an extremely reliable theory on aesthetic grounds a good basis for guiding which experiments we fund?
Do you recall the temple of science, in which the foundations of physics are the bottommost level, and we try to break through to deeper understanding? As I've come to the end of my travels, I worry that the cracks we're seeing in the floor aren't really cracks at all but merely intricate patterns. We're digging in the wrong places.
Lost in Math will teach you a bit less about physics than Smolin's book, although there is some of that here. Smolin's book was about two-thirds physics and one-third sociology of science. Lost in Math is about two-thirds sociology and one-third physics. But that sociology is engrossing. It's obvious in retrospect, but I hadn't thought before about the practical effects of running out of unexplained data on a theoretical field, or about the transition from more data than we can explain to having to spend billions of dollars to acquire new data. And Hossenfelder takes direct aim at the human tendency to find aesthetically appealing patterns and unified explanations, and scores some palpable hits.
I went into physics because I don't understand human behavior. I went into physics because math tells it how it is. I liked the cleanliness, the unambiguous machinery, the command math has over nature. Two decades later, what prevents me from understanding physics is that I still don't understand human behavior. "We cannot give exact mathematical rules that define if a theory is attractive or not," says Gian Francesco Giudice. "However, it is surprising how the beauty and elegance of a theory are universally recognized by people from different cultures. When I tell you, 'Look, I have a new paper and my theory is beautiful,' I don't have to tell you the details of my theory; you will get why I'm excited. Right?" I don't get it. That's why I am talking to him. Why should the laws of nature care what I find beautiful? Such a connection between me and the universe seems very mystical, very romantic, very not me. But then Gian doesn't think that nature cares what I find beautiful, but what he finds beautiful.
The structure of this book is half tour of how physics judges which theories are worthy of investigation and half personal quest to decide whether physics has lost contact with reality. Hossenfelder approaches this second thread with multiple interviews of famous scientists in the field. She probes at their bases for preferring one theory over another, at how objective those preferences can or should be, and what it means for physics if they're wrong (as increasingly appears to be the case for supersymmetry). In so doing, she humanizes theory development in a way that I found fascinating. The drawback to reading about ongoing arguments is the lack of a conclusion. Lost in Math, unsurprisingly, does not provide an epiphany about the future direction of high-energy particle physics. Its conclusion, to the extent that it has one, is a plea to find a way to put particle physics back on firmer experimental footing and to avoid cognitive biases in theory development. Given the cost of experiments and the nature of humans, this is challenging. But I enjoyed reading this questioning, contrarian take, and I think it's valuable for understanding the limits, biases, and distortions at the edge of new theory development. Rating: 7 out of 10

22 March 2020

Enrico Zini: Notable people

Lotte Reiniger. The Unsung Heroine of Early Animation
history people wikipedia
Lotte Reiniger pioneered early animation, yet her name remains largely unknown. We pay homage to her life and work, and reflect on why she never received the recognition she deserves.
Stephen Wolfram shares what he learned in researching Ada Lovelace's life, writings about the Analytical Engine, and computation of Bernoulli numbers.
Elizabeth Cochran Seaman[1] (May 5, 1864[2] January 27, 1922), better known by her pen name Nellie Bly, was an American journalist who was widely known for her record-breaking trip around the world in 72 days, in emulation of Jules Verne's fictional character Phileas Fogg, and an expos in which she worked undercover to report on a mental institution from within.[3] She was a pioneer in her field, and launched a new kind of investigative journalism.[4] Bly was also a writer, inventor, and industrialist.
Delia Ann Derbyshire (5 May 1937 3 July 2001)[1] was an English musician and composer of electronic music.[2] She carried out pioneering work with the BBC Radiophonic Workshop during the 1960s, including her electronic arrangement of the theme music to the British science-fiction television series Doctor Who.[3][4] She has been referred to as "the unsung heroine of British electronic music,"[3] having influenced musicians including Aphex Twin, the Chemical Brothers and Paul Hartnoll of Orbital.[5]
Charity Adams Earley (5 December 1918 13 January 2002) was the first African-American woman to be an officer in the Women's Army Auxiliary Corps (later WACS) and was the commanding officer of the first battalion of African-American women to serve overseas during World War II. Adams was the highest ranking African-American woman in the army by the completion of the war.

18 March 2020

Antoine Beaupr : How can I trust this git repository?

Join me in the rabbit hole of git repository verification, and how we could improve it.

Problem statement As part of my work on automating install procedures at Tor, I ended up doing things like:
git clone REPO
./REPO/bootstrap.sh
... something eerily similar to the infamous curl pipe bash method which I often decry. As a short-term workaround, I relied on the SHA-1 checksum of the repository to make sure I have the right code, by running this both on a "trusted" (ie. "local") repository and the remote, then visually comparing the output:
$ git show-ref master
9f9a9d70dd1f1e84dec69a12ebc536c1f05aed1c refs/heads/master
One problem with this approach is that SHA-1 is now considered as flawed as MD5 so it can't be used as an authentication mechanism anymore. It's also fundamentally difficult to compare hashes for humans. The other flaw with comparing local and remote checksums is that we assume we trust the local repository. But how can I trust that repository? I can either:
  1. audit all the code present and all the changes done to it after
  2. or trust someone else to do so
The first option here is not practical in most cases. In this specific use case, I have audited the source code -- I'm the author, even -- what I need is to transfer that code over to another server. (Note that I am replacing those procedures with Fabric, which makes this use case moot for now as the trust path narrows to "trust the SSH server" which I already had anyways. But it's still important for my fellow Tor developers who worry about trusting the git server, especially now that we're moving to GitLab.) But anyways, in most cases, I do need to trust some other fellow developer I collaborate with. To do this, I would need to trust the entire chain between me and them:
  1. the git client
  2. the operating system
  3. the hardware
  4. the network (HTTPS and the CA cartel, specifically)
  5. then the hosting provider (and that hardware/software stack)
  6. and then backwards all the way back to that other person's computer
I want to shorten that chain as much as possible, make it "peer to peer", so to speak. Concretely, it would eliminate the hosting provider and the network, as attackers.

OpenPGP verification My first reaction is (perhaps perversely) to "use OpenPGP" for this. I figured that if I sign every commit, then I can just check the latest commit and see if the signature is good. The first problem here is that this is surprisingly hard. Let's pick some arbitrary commit I did recently:
commit b3c538898b0ed4e31da27fc9ca22cb55e1de0000
Author: Antoine Beaupr  <anarcat@debian.org>
Date:   Mon Mar 16 14:37:28 2020 -0400
    fix test autoloading
    pytest only looks for file names matching  test  by default. We inline
    tests inside the source code directly, so hijack that.
diff --git a/fabric_tpa/pytest.ini b/fabric_tpa/pytest.ini
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..71004ea
--- /dev/null
+++ b/fabric_tpa/pytest.ini
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+[pytest]
+# we inline tests directly in the source code
+python_files = *.py
That's the output of git log -p in my local repository. I signed that commit, yet git log is not telling me anything special. To check the signature, I need something special: --show-signature, which looks like this:
commit b3c538898b0ed4e31da27fc9ca22cb55e1de0000
gpg: Signature faite le lun 16 mar 2020 14:37:53 EDT
gpg:                avec la clef RSA 7B164204D096723B019635AB3EA1DDDDB261D97B
gpg: Bonne signature de  Antoine Beaupr  <anarcat@orangeseeds.org>  [ultime]
gpg:                 alias  Antoine Beaupr  <anarcat@torproject.org>  [ultime]
gpg:                 alias  Antoine Beaupr  <anarcat@anarc.at>  [ultime]
gpg:                 alias  Antoine Beaupr  <anarcat@koumbit.org>  [ultime]
gpg:                 alias  Antoine Beaupr  <anarcat@debian.org>  [ultime]
Author: Antoine Beaupr  <anarcat@debian.org>
Date:   Mon Mar 16 14:37:28 2020 -0400
    fix test autoloading
    pytest only looks for file names matching  test  by default. We inline
    tests inside the source code directly, so hijack that.
Can you tell if this is a valid signature? If you speak a little french, maybe you can! But even if you would, you are unlikely to see that output on your own computer. What you would see instead is:
commit b3c538898b0ed4e31da27fc9ca22cb55e1de0000
gpg: Signature made Mon Mar 16 14:37:53 2020 EDT
gpg:                using RSA key 7B164204D096723B019635AB3EA1DDDDB261D97B
gpg: Can't check signature: No public key
Author: Antoine Beaupr  <anarcat@debian.org>
Date:   Mon Mar 16 14:37:28 2020 -0400
    fix test autoloading
    pytest only looks for file names matching  test  by default. We inline
    tests inside the source code directly, so hijack that.
Important part: Can't check signature: No public key. No public key. Because of course you would see that. Why would you have my key lying around, unless you're me. Or, to put it another way, why would that server I'm installing from scratch have a copy of my OpenPGP certificate? Because I'm a Debian developer, my key is actually part of the 800 keys in the debian-keyring package, signed by the APT repositories. So I have a trust path. But that won't work for someone who is not a Debian developer. It will also stop working when my key expires in that repository, as it already has on Debian buster (current stable). So I can't assume I have a trust path there either. One could work with a trusted keyring like we do in the Tor and Debian project, and only work inside that project, that said. But I still feel uncomfortable with those commands. Both git log and git show will happily succeed (return code 0 in the shell) even though the signature verification failed on the commits. Same with git pull and git merge, which will happily push your branch ahead even if the remote has unsigned or badly signed commits. To actually verify commits (or tags), you need the git verify-commit (or git verify-tag) command, which seems to do the right thing:
$ LANG=C.UTF-8 git verify-commit b3c538898b0ed4e31da27fc9ca22cb55e1de0000
gpg: Signature made Mon Mar 16 14:37:53 2020 EDT
gpg:                using RSA key 7B164204D096723B019635AB3EA1DDDDB261D97B
gpg: Can't check signature: No public key
[1]$
At least it fails with some error code (1, above). But it's not flexible: I can't use it to verify that a "trusted" developer (say one that is in a trusted keyring) signed a given commit. Also, it is not clear what a failure means. Is a signature by an expired certificate okay? What if the key is signed by some random key in my personal keyring? Why should that be trusted?

Worrying about git and GnuPG In general, I'm worried about git's implementation of OpenPGP signatures. There has been numerous cases of interoperability problems with GnuPG specifically that led to security, like EFAIL or SigSpoof. It would be surprising if such a vulnerability did not exist in git. Even if git did everything "just right" (which I have myself found impossible to do when writing code that talks with GnuPG), what does it actually verify? The commit's SHA-1 checksum? The tree's checksum? The entire archive as a zip file? I would bet it signs the commit's SHA-1 sum, but I just don't know, on the top of my head, and neither do git-commit or git-verify-commit say exactly what is happening. I had an interesting conversation with a fellow Debian developer (dkg) about this and we had to admit those limitations:
<anarcat> i'd like to integrate pgp signing into tor's coding practices more, but so far, my approach has been "sign commits" and the verify step was "TBD" <dkg> that's the main reason i've been reluctant to sign git commits. i haven't heard anyone offer a better subsequent step. if torproject could outline something useful, then i'd be less averse to the practice. i'm also pretty sad that git remains stuck on sha1, esp. given the recent demonstrations. all the fancy strong signatures you can make in git won't matter if the underlying git repo gets changed out from under the signature due to sha1's weakness
In other words, even if git implements the arcane GnuPG dialect just so, and would allow us to setup the trust chain just right, and would give us meaningful and workable error messages, it still would fail because it's still stuck in SHA-1. There is work underway to fix that, but in February 2020, Jonathan Corbet described that work as being in a "relatively unstable state", which is hardly something I would like to trust to verify code. Also, when you clone a fresh new repository, you might get an entirely different repository, with a different root and set of commits. The concept of "validity" of a commit, in itself, is hard to establish in this case, because an hostile server could put you backwards in time, on a different branch, or even on an entirely different repository. Git will warn you about a different repository root with warning: no common commits but that's easy to miss. And complete branch switches, rebases and resets from upstream are hardly more noticeable: only a tiny plus sign (+) instead of a star (*) will tell you that a reset happened, along with a warning (forced update) on the same line. Miss those and your git history can be compromised.

Possible ways forward I don't consider the current implementation of OpenPGP signatures in git to be sufficient. Maybe, eventually, it will mature away from SHA-1 and the interface will be more reasonable, but I don't see that happening in the short term. So what do we do?

git evtag The git-evtag extension is a replacement for git tag -s. It's not designed to sign commits (it only verifies tags) but at least it uses a stronger algorithm (SHA-512) to checksum the tree, and will include everything in that tree, including blobs. If that sounds expensive to you, don't worry too much: it takes about 5 seconds to tag the Linux kernel, according to the author. Unfortunately, that checksum is then signed with GnuPG, in a manner similar to git itself, in that it exposes GnuPG output (which can be confusing) and is likely similarly vulnerable to mis-implementation of the GnuPG dialect as git itself. It also does not allow you to specify a keyring to verify against, so you need to trust GnuPG to make sense of the garbage that lives in your personal keyring (and, trust me, it doesn't). And besides, git-evtag is fundamentally the same as signed git tags: checksum everything and sign with GnuPG. The difference is it uses SHA-512 instead of SHA-1, but that's something git will eventually fix itself anyways.

kernel patch attestations The kernel also faces this problem. Linus Torvalds signs the releases with GnuPG, but patches fly all over mailing list without any form of verification apart from clear-text email. So Konstantin Ryabitsev has proposed a new protocol to sign git patches which uses SHA256 to checksum the patch metadata, commit message and the patch itself, and then sign that with GnuPG. It's unclear to me what this solves, if anything, at all. As dkg argues, it would seem better to add OpenPGP support to git-send-email and teach git tools to recognize that (e.g. git-am) at least if you're going to keep using OpenPGP anyways. And furthermore, it doesn't resolve the problems associated with verifying a full archive either, as it only attests "patches".

jcat Unhappy with the current state of affairs, the author of fwupd (Richard Hughes) wrote his own protocol as well, called jcat, which provides signed "catalog files" similar to the ones provided in Microsoft windows. It consists of a "gzip-compressed JSON catalog files, which can be used to store GPG, PKCS-7 and SHA-256 checksums for each file". So yes, it is yet again another wrapper to GnuPG, probably with all the flaws detailed above, on top of being a niche implementation, disconnected from git.

The Update Framework One more thing dkg correctly identified is:
<dkg> anarcat: even if you could do exactly what you describe, there are still some interesting wrinkles that i think would be problems for you. the big one: "git repo's latest commits" is a loophole big enough to drive a truck through. if your adversary controls that repo, then they get to decide which commits to include in the repo. (since every git repo is a view into the same git repo, just some have more commits than others)
In other words, unless you have a repository that has frequent commits (either because of activity or by a bot generating fake commits), you have to rely on the central server to decide what "the latest version" is. This is the kind of problems that binary package distribution systems like APT and TUF solve correctly. Unfortunately, those don't apply to source code distribution, at least not in git form: TUF only deals with "repositories" and binary packages, and APT only deals with binary packages and source tarballs. That said, there's actually no reason why git could not support the TUF specification. Maybe TUF could be the solution to ensure end-to-end cryptographic integrity of the source code itself. OpenPGP-signed tarballs are nice, and signed git tags can be useful, but from my experience, a lot of OpenPGP (or, more accurately, GnuPG) derived tools are brittle and do not offer clear guarantees, and definitely not to the level that TUF tries to address. This would require changes on the git servers and clients, but I think it would be worth it.

Other Projects

OpenBSD There are other tools trying to do parts of what GnuPG is doing, for example minisign and OpenBSD's signify. But they do not integrate with git at all right now. Although I did find a hack] to use signify with git, it's kind of gross...

Golang Unsurprisingly, this is a problem everyone is trying to solve. Golang is planning on hosting a notary which would leverage a "certificate-transparency-style tamper-proof log" which would be ran by Google (see the spec for details). But that doesn't resolve the "evil server" attack, if we treat Google as an adversary (and we should).

Python Python had OpenPGP going for a while on PyPI, but it's unclear if it ever did anything at all. Now the plan seems to be to use TUF but my hunch is that the complexity of the specification is keeping that from moving ahead.

Docker Docker and the container ecosystem has, in theory, moved to TUF in the form of Notary, "a project that allows anyone to have trust over arbitrary collections of data". In practice however, in my somewhat limited experience, setting up TUF and image verification in Docker is far from trivial.

Android and iOS Even in what is possibly one of the strongest models (at least in terms of user friendliness), mobile phones are surprisingly unclear about those kind of questions. I had to ask if Android had end-to-end authentication and I am still not clear on the answer. I have no idea of what iOS does.

Conclusion One of the core problems with everything here is the common usability aspect of cryptography, and specifically the usability of verification procedures. We have become pretty good at encryption. The harder part (and a requirement for proper encryption) is verification. It seems that problem still remains unsolved, in terms of usability. Even Signal, widely considered to be a success in terms of adoption and usability, doesn't properly solve that problem, as users regularly ignore "The security number has changed" warnings... So, even though they deserve a lot of credit in other areas, it seems unlikely that hardcore C hackers (e.g. git and kernel developers) will be able to resolve that problem without at least a little bit of help. And TUF seems like the state of the art specification around here, it would seem wise to start adopting it in the git community as well. Update: git 2.26 introduced a new gpg.minTrustLevel to "tell various signature verification codepaths the required minimum trust level", presumably to control how Git will treat keys in your keyrings, assuming the "trust database" is valid and up to date. For an interesting narrative of how "normal" (without PGP) git verification can fail, see also A Git Horror Story: Repository Integrity With Signed Commits.

17 March 2020

Mike Gabriel: Time for home office! Time for X2Go?

Most of us IT people should be in home office by now. If not, make sure you'll arrange that with your employers, cooperation partners, contractors, etc. Please help flatten the curve. X2Go as your Home Office solution If your computer at work runs a GNU/Linux desktop and you can SSH into it, then it might be time for you to try out X2Go [1]. Remote desktop access under GNU/Linux. Free Support for simple Client-Server Setups If your daily work is related to health care, municipal work, medical research, etc. (all those fields that are currently working under very high demands), please join the #x2go IRC channel on Freenode [2] and I'll do my very best to help you with setting up X2Go. Professional Support for Large Scale Setups If you run a business and need X2Go support site-wide, brokerage support, etc. please consider asking for professional support [3]. References

16 March 2020

Ulrike Uhlig: Deconstructing the term control freak

Control freaks. You may have called people like this. Or you may have been called one yourself. Maybe you got angry. Or, on the contrary, you felt like being a control freak is a feature, because who would notice all these little details that are not exactly perfect if not you? This post is an attempt to deconstruct the term. Etymological considerations Control - from latin contra- rotulus - refers to the copy of an account register as a means of verification of the original register. So control is about keeping track, not making mistakes, i.e. it's about doing a perfect calculation. The meaning of control in our society is linked to authority, or to policing like in crowd control. What English calls an inspector, is a Kontrolleur in German or contr leur in French. The word is also linked to manufacturing, as in quality control. We also talk about being in control, which is linked to the desire of being autonomous, to be able to act on one's own account. Being in control can also designate a need to preserve one's own integrity: if I have integrity (in the sense of feeling whole), I can self-determine, which is the most fundamental requirement for having one's own identity. Freak - refers to someone who does not fit the norm. Calling someone a freak is per se problematic, because it blames a person for being atypical, abnormal. Freak is a word that, while pointing a finger at difference, at the same time denies people the right to be different and diverse. People can reappropriate such words to make it clear that not fitting the norm is a wanted expression of their diversity we can see that if we follow the history of the word queer for an example. Types of control freaking To me, being a control freak is mostly a feature, if it's about controlling my own life and my own effectiveness. Control freaking becomes troublesome when it's about controlling other people's effectiveness. And it becomes highly problematic when it's about controlling other people's lives. Controlling one's own life Having control over one's own life is a basic human need. In particular people who are part of minorities, people who face discrimination and oppression every day have an increased need for self-determination, and the need to see their existence and their identity acknowledged and accepted by the rest of the world. Too often do we experience that other people (generally the ones with privilege, or not facing the same oppression) try to own the narrative over our lives (1)(2). Calling this control freakish is missing the point, and is probably a sign of looking at it from a perspective of privilege. Controlling one's own effectiveness People produce things. People write code, make ceramics, or write texts, for example. People have a need to control their own effectiveness: they set up routines, product tests, documentation. This type of control is a feature, and can help to release better software, better texts, or perfectly burnt clay pots ultimately controlling one's own effectiveness helps to learn from one's mistakes and to improve routines over time. The grey zone The grey zone describes the zone in between wanting to control one's own effectiveness and wanting to control other people's effectiveness. Here we could situate the type of control freak who does not delegate tasks to others for fear of seeing them done differently then they had expected them to be done. This can be harmful particularly to the person who does not delegate: they can get overworked or burnt out. This type of control freakism might be linked to perfectionism. Controlling other people's effectiveness When we work with other people, our own effectiveness might get in the way of other people's effectiveness, or vice versa. Indeed, it happens - not only in work contexts - that people find themselves in setups in which mutual responsibilities and autonomies conflict with one another because one person is dependent on the other for making decisions or moving things forward as they see fit. (There is generally a relation of dependency between two conflicting parties that is worth looking at (3).) Add to this the fact that, when delegating a task, some people have a hard time also delegating the responsibility and autonomy needed to resolve the task. They lack trust that another person can also do the work, or want that person to do the work exactly in the same way they would do it. (In some cases this can be related to Founder's Syndrome and can result in organizations staying stuck with one or a small group of founders holding knowledge and power, and preventing the organization from growing. Page 11 in the booklet "Working with conflict in our groups" describes how such an informal hierarchy can come into being in grassroot groups.) The (perfectly valid) need behind this type of control freaking could be to make sure that a group of people builds a successful product, releases a fact-checked documentary, or creates a publication without mistakes. But controlling other people's effectiveness as a strategy to satisfy this need can create a non-cooperative climate in which people do not meet each other on eye level, but are dependent on each other, experience a lack autonomy, a break of boundaries, or sometimes feel authority to be overexerted. Acknowledging the need to build a good product, it is possible to create the appropriate strategies to guarantee that the involved people can meet each other on eye level: for example by clearly defining and documenting role-responsibility-accountability along with appropriate decision making processes, or by distributing leadership ( you should totally click on that link!), by looking at inclusive leadership models, by learning from past mistakes, by instating feedback cycles, by making boundaries between the direction of an organization and the day-to-day work clear. An organization I work with has the rule that people can make decisions for themselves if the decision only affects their work, while decisions that affect a team should be made with the team, and decisions that affect the organization as a whole need to be made at the organizational level. They call that a no-brainer, but in organizations with traditional hierarchies, or in grown grassroot environments that have never clearly defined and assigned responsibilities and accountabilities (aka "functional roles") this is not so obvious at all. Controlling someone else's life This type of control freak does not only desire to control their own life but for a reason or another wants to know and control what other people do, think (especially about the control freak), decide, or how they live. In some cases, this type of control freak might even want to force upon others things they should do as a way to be accepted by the control freak. It's what we call narcissism, harassment, abuse. It is unacceptable. Conclusion In summary, the distinctions I came up with in this post describe the boundaries along which control freakism takes hold of someone else's effectiveness or life and ultimately prevents them from self-determining. In German we have the word bergriffig which describes that someone is infringing someone else's boundaries they are over - grabbing, seizing, grasping, taking hold of. Which type of control freak are you, if any?

(1) Like when a West-Berliner in a round of 15 East Germans arrogantly talks about the time when the wall came down and tells the story that he could not go shopping between Thursdays and Sundays because the East Germans bought too many products in the supermarkets while this event marked an unimaginable rift in the biographies of 17 million East Germans, 15 of whom are sitting right in front of him. Thirty years after 1989, many of us are finally starting to question this publicly ( links in German language).

(2) Women experience it similary regularly, see Men Explain Things to me, a book by Rebecca Solnit.

(3) By the way, rather than having "recruited the wrong person" conflict may intrinsically arise as part of certain work relationships, simply due to the inter-dependencies of roles or workers, like in a delivery chain.

12 March 2020

Julien Danjou: One year of Mergify

One year of MergifyIt has been close to a year now that I've incorporated my new company, Mergify. I've been busy, and I barely wrote anything about it so far. Now is an excellent time to take a break and reflect a bit on what happened during those last 12 months.
One year of Mergify

What problem does Mergify solve?Mergify is a powerful automation engine for GitHub pull requests. It allows you to automate everything and especially merging. You write rules, and it handles the rest.
One year of MergifyExample of rule matching returned in GitHub checks
For example, let's say you want your pull request to be merged, e.g., once your CI passes and the pull request has been approved. You just write such a rule, and our engine merges the pull request as soon as it's ready.We also deal with more advanced use cases. For instance, we provide a merge queue so your pull requests are merged serially and tested by your CI one after another avoiding any regression in your code.Our goal is to make pull request management and automation easy. You can use your bot to trigger a rebase of your pull requests, or a backport to a different branch, just with a single comment.
One year of MergifySome people like to make bots talk to each other.

A New AdventureMergify is the first company that I ever started. I did run some personal businesses before, created non-profit organizations, built FOSS projects but I never created a company from scratch, even less with an associate.Indeed, I've chosen to build the company with my old friend Mehdi. We've known each others for 7 years now, and have worked together all that time on different open-source projects. Having worked with each other for so long has probably been a critical factor in the success of our venture so far.I had little experience sharing the founding seats with someone, and tons of reading seemed to indicate that it would be a tough ride. Picking the right business partner(s) can be a hard task. Luckily, after working so much time together, Mehdi and I both know our strengths and weaknesses well enough to be able to circumvent them. On the other hand, we both have similar backgrounds as software engineers. That does not help to cover all the hats you need to wear when building a company. Over time, we found arrangements to cover most of those equally between us.We don't have any magical advice to give on this. As in every relationship, communication is the key, and the #1 factor of success.

Getting UsersI don't know if we got lucky, but we got users and customers pretty early. We used a few cooperative projects as guinea pigs first, and they were brave enough to try our service and give us feedback. No repository has been harmed during this first phase!Then, as soon as we managed to get our application on the GitHub Marketplace, we saw a steady number of users coming to us.This has been fantastic as it allowed us to get feedback rapidly. We set up a form asking users for feedback after they used Mergify for a couple of weeks. What we hear is that users were happy, that the documentation was confusing and that some features were buggy or missing. We planned all of those ideas as our future work in our roadmap, using the principles we described a few months ago.
How we handle our roadmap for Mergify
Whatever you re building a company, a product, or a house a time comes where you need planning. Pushing random buttons to move forward does not work anymore. You need to take a step back to
One year of Mergify
If you're curious, you can read this article.
We tried various strategies to get new users, but so far, organic growth has been our #1 way of onboarding new users. Like many small startups out there, we're not that good at marketing and executing strategies.We provide our service for free for open-source projects We are now powering many organizations, such as Mozilla, Amazon Web Services, Ceph and Fedora.

Working with GitHubWorking with GitHub has been complicated. When you build an application for a marketplace, your business is entirely dependent on the platform you develop for both in terms of features and quality of service.In our case, we hit quite many bugs with GitHub. Their support has mostly been fast to answer, but some significant issues are still opened months later. The truth is that the GitHub API could deserve more love and care from GitHub. For example, their GraphQL API is a work in progress for years and miss out many essential features.
One year of MergifyGitHub service status is not always green.
We dealt and still deal with all those issues. It obviously impacts our operations and decreases our overall velocity. We regularly have to find new ways to sidestep GitHub limitations.You have no idea how we wished for GitHub to be open-source. The idea of not having access to their code and understand how it works is so frustrating that we publish our engine as an open-source project. That allows all of our users to see how it works and even propose enhancements.
One year of Mergify

Automate all the wayWe're a tiny startup, and we decided to bootstrap our company. We never took any funding. From the beginning, it has been clear to us that we had to think and act like we had no resources. We're built around a scarcity mindset. Every decision we make is based on the assumption that we basically are very limited in terms of money and time.We basically act like any wrong choice we do could (virtually) kill the company. We only do what is essential, we ship fast, and we automate everything.For example, we have built our whole operation about CI/CD systems, and pushing any new fix or feature in production is done in a matter of minutes. It's not uncommon for us to push a fix from our phone, just by reviewing some code or editing a file.

GrowthWe're extremely happy with our steady growth and more users using our service. We now manage close to 30k repositories and merge 15k pull requests per month for our users.That's a lot of mouse clicks saved!If you want to try Mergify yourself, it's a single click log-in using your GitHub account. Check it out!

7 March 2020

Matthias Klumpp: Introducing the MetaInfo Creator

This year s FOSDEM conference was a lot of fun one of the things I always enjoy most about this particular conference (besides having some of the outstanding food you can get in Brussels and meeting with friends from the free software world) is the ability to meet a large range of new people who I wouldn t usually have interacted with, or getting people from different communities together who otherwise would not meet in person as each bigger project has their own conference (for example, the amount of VideoLAN people is much lower at GUADEC and Akademy compared to FOSDEM). It s also really neat to have GNOME and KDE developers within reach at the same place, as I care about both desktops a lot. An unexpected issue This blog post however is not about that. It s about what I learned when talking to people there about AppStream, and the outcome of that. Especially when talking to application authors but also to people who deal with larger software repositories, it became apparent that many app authors don t really want to deal with the extra effort of writing metadata at all. This was a bit of a surprise to me, as I thought that there would be a strong interest for application authors to make their apps look as good as possible in software catalogs. A bit less surprising was the fact that people apparently don t enjoy reading a large specification, reading a long-ish intro guide with lots of dos and don ts or basically reading any longer text at all before being able to create an AppStream MetaInfo/AppData file describing their software. Another common problem seems to be that people don t immediately know what a reverse-DNS ID is, the format AppStream uses for uniquely identifying each software component. So naturally, people either have to read about it again (bah, reading!  ) or make something up, which occasionally is wrong and not the actual component-ID their software component should have. The MetaInfo Creator It was actually suggested to me twice that what people really would like to have is a simple tool to put together a MetaInfo file for their software. Basically a simple form with a few questions which produces the final file. I always considered this a nice to have, but not essential feature, but now I was convinced that this actually has a priority attached to it. So, instead of jumping into my favourite editor and writing a bunch of C code to create this make MetaInfo file form as part of appstreamcli, this time I decided to try what the cool kids are doing and make a web application that runs in your browser and creates all metadata there. So, behold the MetaInfo Creator! If you click this link, you will end up at an Angular-based web application that will let you generate MetaInfo/AppData files for a few component-types simply by answering a set of questions. The intent was to make this tool as easy to use as possible for someone who basically doesn t know anything about AppStream at all. Therefore, the tool will: For the Meson feature, the tool simply can not generate a use this and be done script, as each Meson snippet needs to be adjusted for the individual project. So this option is disabled by default, but when enabled, a few simple Meson snippets will be produced which can be easily adjusted to the project they should be part of. The tool currently does not generate any release information for a MetaInfo file at all, This may be added in future. The initial goal was to have people create any MetaInfo file in the first place, having projects also ship release details would be the icing on the cake. I hope people find this project useful and use it to create better MetaInfo files, so distribution repositories and Flatpak repos look better in software centers. Also, since MetaInfo files can be used to create an inventory of software and to install missing stuff as-needed, having more of them will help to build smarter software managers, create smaller OS base installations and introspect what software bundles are made of easily. I welcome contributions to the MetaInfo Creator! You can find its source code on GitHub. This is my first web application ever, the first time I wrote TypeScript and the first time I used Angular, so I d bet a veteran developer more familiar with these tools will cringe at what I produced. So, scratch that itch and submit a PR!  Also, if you want to create a form for a new component type, please submit a patch as well. C developer s experience notes for Angular, TypeScript, NodeJS This section is just to ramble a bit about random things I found interesting as a developer who mostly works with C/C++ and Python and stepped into the web-application developer s world for the first time. For a project like this, I would usually have gone with my default way of developing something for the web: Creating a Flask-based application in Python. I really love Python and Flask, but of course using them would have meant that all processing would have had to be done on the server. One the one hand I could have used libappstream that way to create the XML, format it and validate it, but on the other hand I would have had to host the Python app on my own server, find a place at Purism/Debian/GNOME/KDE or get it housed at Freedesktop somehow (which would have taken a while to arrange) and I really wanted to have a permanent location for this application immediately. Additionally, I didn t want people to send the details of new unpublished software to my server. TypeScript I must say that I really like TypeScript as a language compared to JavaScript. It is not really revolutionary (I looked into Dart and other ways to compile $stuff to JavaScript first), but it removes just enough JavaScript weirdness to be pleasant to use. At the same time, since TS is a superset of JS, JavaScript code is valid TypeScript code, so you can integrate with existing JS code easily. Picking TS up took me much less than an hour, and most of its features you learn organically when working on a project. The optional type-safety is a blessing and actually helped me a few times to find an issue. It being so close to JS is both a strength and weakness: On the one hand you have all the JS oddities in the language (implicit type conversion is really weird sometimes) and have to basically refrain from using them or count on the linter to spot them, but on the other hand you can immediately use the massive amount of JavaScript code available on the web. Angular The Angular web framework took a few hours to pick up there are a lot of concepts to understand. But ultimately, it s manageable and pretty nice to use. When working at the system level, a lot of complexity is in understanding how the CPU is processing data, managing memory and using the low-level APIs the operating system provides. With the web application stuff, a lot of the complexity for me was in learning about all the moving parts the system is comprised of, what their names are, what they are, and what works with which. And that is not a flat learning curve at all. As C developer, you need to know how the computer works to be efficient, as web developer you need to know a bunch of different tools really well to be productive. One thing I am still a bit puzzled about is the amount of duplicated HTML templates my project has. I haven t found a way to reuse template blocks in multiple components with Angular, like I would with Jinja2. The documentation suggests this feature does not exist, but maybe I simply can t find it or there is a completely different way to achieve the same result. NPM Ecosystem The MetaInfo Creator application ultimately doesn t do much. But according to GitHub, it has 985 (!!!) dependencies in NPM/NodeJS. And that is the bare minimum! I only added one dependency myself to it. I feel really uneasy about this, as I prefer the Python approach of having a rich standard library instead of billions of small modules scattered across the web. If there is a bug in one of the standard library functions, I can submit a patch to Python where some core developer is there to review it. In NodeJS, I imagine fixing some module is much harder. That being said though, using npm is actually pretty nice there is a module available for most things, and adding a new dependency is easy. NPM will also manage all the details of your dependency chain, GitHub will warn about security issues in modules you depend on, etc. So, from a usability perspective, there isn t much to complain about (unlike with Python, where creating or using a module ends up as a fight the system event way too often and the question which random file do I need to create now to achieve what I want? always exists. Fortunately, Poetry made this a bit more pleasant for me recently). So, tl;dr for this section: The web application development excursion was actually a lot of fun, and I may make more of those in future, now that I learned more about how to write web applications. Ultimately though, I enjoy the lower-level software development and backend development a bit more. Summary Check out the MetaInfo Creator and its source code, if you want to create MetaInfo files for a GUI application, console application, addon or service component quickly.

1 March 2020

Paul Wise: FLOSS Activities February 2020

Changes

Issues

Review

Administration
  • Debian wiki: deploy changes, unblock IP addresses, approve new accounts, auto-approve email domains

Communication

Sponsors The apt-offline backport and purple-discord uploads were sponsored by my employer. All other work was done on a volunteer basis.

20 November 2017

Louis-Philippe V ronneau: DebConf Videoteam sprint report - day 1

Another videoteam report! We've now been hacking for a full day and we are slowly starting to be productive. It's always hard to get back in a project when you haven't touched it in a while... Anyway, let's start this report with some important announcement: we finally have been able to snap a good picture of the airbnb's cat! The airbnb's cat No more nagging me about the placeholder image from Wikipedia I used in yesterday's report! Set up Our hacking space Here's what the team did today: tumbleweed Stefano started the day by hacking away on our video archive. We eventually want to upload all our videos to YouTube to give them exposure, but sadly our archive metadata is in a pretty poor shape. With the script tumbleweed wrote, we can scrape the archive for matches against the old DebConf's pentabarf XML we have. tumbleweed also helped Ivo with the ansible PXE setup he's working on. Some recent contributions from a collaborator implemented new features (like a nice menu to choose from) but also came with a few annoying bugs. ivodd Ivo continued working on the PXE setup today. He also tried to break our ansible setup by using fresh installs with different user cases (locales, interfaces, etc.), with some success. The reason he and Stefano are working so hard on the PXE boot is that we had a discussion about the future of our USB install method. The general consensus on this was although we would not remove it, we would not actively maintain it anymore. PXE is less trouble for multiple machines. For single machines or if you don't control the DHCP server, using ansible manually on a fresh Debian install will be the recommended way. olasd After a very long drive, olasd arrived late in the evening with all our gear. Hurray! We were thus able to set up some test boxes and start wiring the airbnb properly. Tomorrow will certainly be more productive with all this stuff at our disposition. pollo Today I mainly worked on setting up our documentation website. After some debate, we decided that sphinx was the right tool for the job. I am a few pages in and if I work well I think we'll have something to show for at the end of the sprint! I also was thrown back into ansible after witnessing a bug in the locale management. I'm still rusty, but it's slowly coming back to me. Let's end this blog post with a picture of the neon pineapple that sits on the wall of the solarium. Upside down this picture is even more troubling

15 November 2017

Kees Cook: security things in Linux v4.14

Previously: v4.13. Linux kernel v4.14 was released this last Sunday, and there s a bunch of security things I think are interesting: vmapped kernel stack on arm64
Similar to the same feature on x86, Mark Rutland and Ard Biesheuvel implemented CONFIG_VMAP_STACK for arm64, which moves the kernel stack to an isolated and guard-paged vmap area. With traditional stacks, there were two major risks when exhausting the stack: overwriting the thread_info structure (which contained the addr_limit field which is checked during copy_to/from_user()), and overwriting neighboring stacks (or other things allocated next to the stack). While arm64 previously moved its thread_info off the stack to deal with the former issue, this vmap change adds the last bit of protection by nature of the vmap guard pages. If the kernel tries to write past the end of the stack, it will hit the guard page and fault. (Testing for this is now possible via LKDTM s STACK_GUARD_PAGE_LEADING/TRAILING tests.) One aspect of the guard page protection that will need further attention (on all architectures) is that if the stack grew because of a giant Variable Length Array on the stack (effectively an implicit alloca() call), it might be possible to jump over the guard page entirely (as seen in the userspace Stack Clash attacks). Thankfully the use of VLAs is rare in the kernel. In the future, hopefully we ll see the addition of PaX/grsecurity s STACKLEAK plugin which, in addition to its primary purpose of clearing the kernel stack on return to userspace, makes sure stack expansion cannot skip over guard pages. This stack probing ability will likely also become directly available from the compiler as well. set_fs() balance checking
Related to the addr_limit field mentioned above, another class of bug is finding a way to force the kernel into accidentally leaving addr_limit open to kernel memory through an unbalanced call to set_fs(). In some areas of the kernel, in order to reuse userspace routines (usually VFS or compat related), code will do something like: set_fs(KERNEL_DS); ...some code here...; set_fs(USER_DS);. When the USER_DS call goes missing (usually due to a buggy error path or exception), subsequent system calls can suddenly start writing into kernel memory via copy_to_user (where the to user really means within the addr_limit range ). Thomas Garnier implemented USER_DS checking at syscall exit time for x86, arm, and arm64. This means that a broken set_fs() setting will not extend beyond the buggy syscall that fails to set it back to USER_DS. Additionally, as part of the discussion on the best way to deal with this feature, Christoph Hellwig and Al Viro (and others) have been making extensive changes to avoid the need for set_fs() being used at all, which should greatly reduce the number of places where it might be possible to introduce such a bug in the future. SLUB freelist hardening
A common class of heap attacks is overwriting the freelist pointers stored inline in the unallocated SLUB cache objects. PaX/grsecurity developed an inexpensive defense that XORs the freelist pointer with a global random value (and the storage address). Daniel Micay improved on this by using a per-cache random value, and I refactored the code a bit more. The resulting feature, enabled with CONFIG_SLAB_FREELIST_HARDENED, makes freelist pointer overwrites very hard to exploit unless an attacker has found a way to expose both the random value and the pointer location. This should render blind heap overflow bugs much more difficult to exploit. Additionally, Alexander Popov implemented a simple double-free defense, similar to the fasttop check in the GNU C library, which will catch sequential free()s of the same pointer. (And has already uncovered a bug.) Future work would be to provide similar metadata protections to the SLAB allocator (though SLAB doesn t store its freelist within the individual unused objects, so it has a different set of exposures compared to SLUB). setuid-exec stack limitation
Continuing the various additional defenses to protect against future problems related to userspace memory layout manipulation (as shown most recently in the Stack Clash attacks), I implemented an 8MiB stack limit for privileged (i.e. setuid) execs, inspired by a similar protection in grsecurity, after reworking the secureexec handling by LSMs. This complements the unconditional limit to the size of exec arguments that landed in v4.13. randstruct automatic struct selection
While the bulk of the port of the randstruct gcc plugin from grsecurity landed in v4.13, the last of the work needed to enable automatic struct selection landed in v4.14. This means that the coverage of randomized structures, via CONFIG_GCC_PLUGIN_RANDSTRUCT, now includes one of the major targets of exploits: function pointer structures. Without knowing the build-randomized location of a callback pointer an attacker needs to overwrite in a structure, exploits become much less reliable. structleak passed-by-reference variable initialization
Ard Biesheuvel enhanced the structleak gcc plugin to initialize all variables on the stack that are passed by reference when built with CONFIG_GCC_PLUGIN_STRUCTLEAK_BYREF_ALL. Normally the compiler will yell if a variable is used before being initialized, but it silences this warning if the variable s address is passed into a function call first, as it has no way to tell if the function did actually initialize the contents. So the plugin now zero-initializes such variables (if they hadn t already been initialized) before the function call that takes their address. Enabling this feature has a small performance impact, but solves many stack content exposure flaws. (In fact at least one such flaw reported during the v4.15 development cycle was mitigated by this plugin.) improved boot entropy
Laura Abbott and Daniel Micay improved early boot entropy available to the stack protector by both moving the stack protector setup later in the boot, and including the kernel command line in boot entropy collection (since with some devices it changes on each boot). eBPF JIT for 32-bit ARM
The ARM BPF JIT had been around a while, but it didn t support eBPF (and, as a result, did not provide constant value blinding, which meant it was exposed to being used by an attacker to build arbitrary machine code with BPF constant values). Shubham Bansal spent a bunch of time building a full eBPF JIT for 32-bit ARM which both speeds up eBPF and brings it up to date on JIT exploit defenses in the kernel. seccomp improvements
Tyler Hicks addressed a long-standing deficiency in how seccomp could log action results. In addition to creating a way to mark a specific seccomp filter as needing to be logged with SECCOMP_FILTER_FLAG_LOG, he added a new action result, SECCOMP_RET_LOG. With these changes in place, it should be much easier for developers to inspect the results of seccomp filters, and for process launchers to generate logs for their child processes operating under a seccomp filter. Additionally, I finally found a way to implement an often-requested feature for seccomp, which was to kill an entire process instead of just the offending thread. This was done by creating the SECCOMP_RET_ACTION_FULL mask (n e SECCOMP_RET_ACTION) and implementing SECCOMP_RET_KILL_PROCESS. That s it for now; please let me know if I missed anything. The v4.15 merge window is now open!

2017, Kees Cook. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 License.
Creative Commons License

12 November 2017

Russ Allbery: Review: Night Moves

Review: Night Moves, by Pat Green
Publisher: Aquarius
Copyright: 2014
ISBN: 0-9909741-1-1
Format: Kindle
Pages: 159
In the fall of 2012, Pat Green was a preacher of a failing church, out of a job, divorced for six months, and feeling like a failure at every part of his life. He was living in a relative's house and desperately needed work and his father had been a taxi driver. So he got a job as a 6pm to 6am taxi driver in his home town of Joliet, Illinois. That job fundamentally changed his understanding of the people who live in the night, how their lives work, and what it means to try to help them. This is nonfiction: a collection of short anecdotes about life as a cab driver and the people who have gotten a ride in Green's cab. They're mostly five or six pages long, just a short story or window into someone's life. I ran across Pat Green's writing by following a sidebar link from a post on Patheos (probably from Love, Joy, Feminism, although I no longer remember). Green has an ongoing blog on Patheos about raising his transgender son (who appears in this collection as a lesbian daughter; he wasn't out yet as transgender when this was published), which is both a good sample of his writing and occasionally has excerpts from this book. Green's previous writing experience, as mentioned at several points in this collection, was newspaper columns in the local paper. It shows: these essays have the succinct, focused, and bite-sized property of a good newspaper article (or blog post). The writing is a little rough, particularly the remembered dialogue that occasionally falls into the awkward valley between dramatic, constructed fictional dialogue and realistic, in-the-moment speech. But the stories are honest and heartfelt and have the self-reflective genuineness of good preaching paired with a solid sense of narrative. Green tries to observe and report first, both the other person and his own reactions, and only then try to draw more general conclusions. This book is also very hard to read. It's not a sugar-coated view of people who live in the night of a city, nor is it constructed to produce happy endings. The people who Green primarily writes about are poor, or alone, or struggling. The story that got me to buy this book, about taking a teenage girl to a secret liaison that turned out to be secret because her liaison was another girl, is heartwarming but also one of the most optimistic stories here. A lot of people die or just disappear after being regular riders for some time. A lot of people are desperate and don't have any realistic way out. Some people, quite memorably, think they have a way out, and that way out closes on them. The subtitle of this book is "An Ex-Preacher's Journey to Hell in a Taxi" and (if you followed the link above) you'll see that Green is writing in the Patheos nonreligious section. The other theme of this collection is the church and its effect on the lives of people who are trying to make a life on the outskirts of society. That effect is either complete obliviousness or an active attempt to make their lives even worse. Green lays out the optimism that he felt early in the job, the hope that he could help someone the way a pastor would, guide her to resources, and how it went horribly wrong when those resources turned out to not be interested in helping her at all. And those stories repeat, and repeat. It's a book that makes it very clear that the actual practice of Christianity in the United States is not about helping poor or marginalized people, but there are certainly plenty of Christian resources for judging, hurting people, closing doors, and forcing abused people back into abusive situations, all in the name of God. I do hope some Christians read this and wince very hard. (And lest the progressive Christians get too smug, one of the stories says almost as brutal things about liberal ministries as the stories of conservative ones.) I came away feeling even more convinced by the merits of charities that just give money directly to poor people. No paternalism, no assuming that rich people know what they need, no well-meaning intermediary organizations with endless rules, just resources delivered directly to the people who most need resources. Ideally done by the government and called universal basic income. Short of constructing a functional government that builds working public infrastructure, and as a supplement even if one has such a government (since infrastructure can't provide everything), it feels like the most moral choice. Individual people may still stay mired in awful situations, but at least that isn't compounded by other people taking their autonomy away and dictating life to them in complete ignorance. This is a fairly short and inexpensive book. I found it very much worth reading, and may end up following Green's blog as well. There are moments of joy and moments of human connection, and the details of the day-to-day worries and work style of a taxi driver (in this case, one who drives a company car) are pretty interesting. (Green does skip over some parts for various reasons, such as a lot of the routine fares and most of the stories of violence, but does mention what he's skipping over.) But it's also a brutal book, because so many people are hurting and there isn't much Green can do about it except bear witness and respect them as people in a way that religion doesn't. Recommended, but brace yourself. Rating: 8 out of 10

7 November 2017

Don Armstrong: Autorandr: automatically adjust screen layout

Like many laptop users, I often plug my laptop into different monitor setups (multiple monitors at my desk, projector when presenting, etc.) Running xrandr commands or clicking through interfaces gets tedious, and writing scripts isn't much better. Recently, I ran across autorandr, which detects attached monitors using EDID (and other settings), saves xrandr configurations, and restores them. It can also run arbitrary scripts when a particular configuration is loaded. I've packed it, and it is currently waiting in NEW. If you can't wait, the deb is here and the git repo is here. To use it, simply install the package, and create your initial configuration (in my case, undocked):
 autorandr --save undocked
then, dock your laptop (or plug in your external monitor(s)), change the configuration using xrandr (or whatever you use), and save your new configuration (in my case, workstation):
autorandr --save workstation
repeat for any additional configurations you have (or as you find new configurations). Autorandr has udev, systemd, and pm-utils hooks, and autorandr --change should be run any time that new displays appear. You can also run autorandr --change or autorandr --load workstation manually too if you need to. You can also add your own ~/.config/autorandr/$PROFILE/postswitch script to run after a configuration is loaded. Since I run i3, my workstation configuration looks like this:
 #!/bin/bash
 xrandr --dpi 92
 xrandr --output DP2-2 --primary
 i3-msg '[workspace="^(1 4 6)"] move workspace to output DP2-2;'
 i3-msg '[workspace="^(2 5 9)"] move workspace to output DP2-3;'
 i3-msg '[workspace="^(3 8)"] move workspace to output DP2-1;'
which fixes the dpi appropriately, sets the primary screen (possibly not needed?), and moves the i3 workspaces about. You can also arrange for configurations to never be run by adding a block hook in the profile directory. Check it out if you change your monitor configuration regularly!

4 November 2017

Louis-Philippe V ronneau: Migrating my website to Pelican

After too much time lying to myself, telling myself things like "I'll just add this neat feature I want on my blog next week", I've finally made the big jump, ditched django and migrated my website to Pelican. I'm going to the Cambridge Mini-Debconf at the end of the month for the Debconf Videoteam Autumn sprint and I've taken the task of making daily sprint reports for the team. That in return means I have to publish my blog on Planet Debian. My old website not having feeds made this a little hard and this perfect storm gave me the energy to make the migration happen. Anyway, django was fun. Building a (crappy) custom blogging engine with it taught me some rough basics, but honestly I don't know why I ever thought it was a good idea. Don't get me wrong: django is great and should definitely be used for large and complicated websites. My blog just ain't one. Migrating to Pelican was pretty easy since it also uses Jinja2 templates and generates content from Mardown. The hardest part was actually bending it to replicate the weird and specific behavior I wanted it to have. So yeah, woooo, I migrated to Pelican. Who cares, right? Well, if you are amongst the very, very few people who read the blog posts I mainly write for myself, you'll be please to know that: Here's a bonus picture of a Pelican from Wikimedia, just for the sake of it: A pelican

3 November 2017

Reproducible builds folks: Reproducible Builds: Weekly report #131

Here's what happened in the Reproducible Builds effort between Sunday October 22 and Saturday October 28 2017: Past Events Upcoming/current events Documentation updates Bernhard Wiedemann started The Unreproducible Package which "is meant as a practical way to demonstrate the various ways that software can break reproducible builds using just low level primitives without requiring external existing programs that implement these primitives themselves. It is structured so that one subdirectory demonstrates one class of issues in some variants observed in the wild." Reproducible work in other projects Hush, a fork of ZCash, opened an issue into reproducible builds. A new tag was added to lintian (lint checker for Debian packages) to ensure that changelog entry timestamps are strictly increasing. This avoids certain real-world issues with identical timestamps, documented in Debian #843773. Packages reviewed and fixed, and bugs filed Patches sent upstream: Debian bug reports: Reviews of unreproducible packages 14 package reviews have been added, 35 have been updated and 28 have been removed in this week, adding to our knowledge about identified issues. 1 issue type has been updated: Weekly QA work During our reproducibility testing, FTBFS bugs have been detected and reported by: strip-nondeterminism development Version 0.040-1 was uploaded to unstable by Mattia Rizzolo. It included contributions already covered by posts of the previous weeks, as well as new ones from: reprotest development Development continued in git: buildinfo.debian.net development Development continued in git: reproducible-website development Misc. This week's edition was written by Ximin Luo, Chris Lamb, Bernhard M. Wiedemann and Holger Levsen & reviewed by a bunch of Reproducible Builds folks on IRC & the mailing lists.

2 November 2017

Steinar H. Gunderson: Introducing Narabu, part 5: Encoding

Narabu is a new intraframe video codec. You probably want to read part 1, part 2, part 3 and part 4 first. At this point, we've basically caught up with where I am, so thing are less set in stone. However, let's look at what qualitatively differentiates encoding from decoding; unlike in interframe video codecs (where you need to do motion vector search and stuff), encoding and decoding are very much mirror images of each other, so we can intuitively expect them to be relatively similar in performance. The procedure is DCT, quantization, entropy coding, and that's it. One important difference is in the entropy coding. Since our rANS encoding is non-adaptive (a choice made largely for simplicity, but also because our streams are so short) works by first signaling a distribution and then encoding each coefficient using that distribution. However, we don't know that distribution until we've DCT-ed all blocks in the picture, so we can't just DCT each block and entropy code the coefficients on-the-fly. There are a few ways to deal with this: As you can see, tons of possible strategies here. For simplicity, I've ended up with the former, although this could very well be changed at some point. There are some interesting subproblems, though: First of all, we need to decide the data type of this temporary array. The DCT tends to concentrate energy into fewer coefficients (which is a great property for compression!), so even after quantization, some of them will get quite large. This means we cannot store them in an 8-bit texture; however, even the bigger ones are very rarely bigger than 10 bits (including a sign bit), so using 16-bit textures wastes precious memory bandwidth. I ended up slicing the coefficients by horizontal index and then pairing them up (so that we generate pairs 0+7, 1+6, 2+5 and 3+4 for the first line of the 8x8 DCT block, 8+15, 9+14, 10+13 and 11+12 for the next line, etc.). This allows us to pack two coefficients into a 16-bit texture, for an average of 8 bits per coefficient, which is what we want. It makes for some slightly fiddly clamping and bit-packing since we are packing signed values, but nothing really bad. Second, and perhaps surprisingly enough, counting efficiently is nontrivial. We want a histogram over what coefficients are used the more often, ie., for each coefficient, we want something like ++counts[dist][coeff] (recall we have four distinct distributions). However, since we're in a massively parallel algorithm, this add needs to be atomic, and since values like e.g. 0 are super-common, all of our GPU cores will end up fighting over the cache line containing counts[dist][0]. This is not fast. Think 10 ms/frame not fast. Local memory to the rescue again; all modern GPUs have fast atomic adds to local memory (basically integrating adders into the cache, as I understand it, although I might have misunderstood here). This means we just make a suitably large local group, build up our sub-histogram in local memory and then add all nonzero buckets (atomically) to the global histogram. This improved performance dramatically, to the point where it was well below 0.1 ms/frame. However, our histogram is still a bit raw; it sums to 1280x720 = 921,600 values, but we want an approximation that sums to exactly 4096 (12 bits), with some additional constraints (like no nonzero coefficients). Charles Bloom has an exposition of a nearly optimal algorithm, although it took me a while to understand it. The basic idea is: Make a good approximation by multiplying each frequency by 4096/921600 (rounding intelligently). This will give you something that very nearly rounds to 4096 either above or below, e.g. 4101. For each step you're above or below the total (five in this case), find the best single coefficient to adjust (most entropy gain, or least loss); Bloom is using a heap, but on the GPU, each core is slow but we have many of them, so it's better just to try all 256 possibilities in parallel and have a simple voting scheme through local memory to find the best one. And then finally, we want a cumulative distribution function, but that is simple through a parallel prefix sum on the 256 elements. And then finally, we can take our DCT coefficients and the finished rANS distribution, and write the data! We'll have to leave some headroom for the streams (I've allowed 1 kB for each, which should be ample except for adversarial data and we'll probably solve that just by truncating the writes and accepting the corruption), but we'll compact them when we write to disk. Of course, the Achilles heel here is performance. Where decoding 720p (luma only) on my GTX 950 took 0,4 ms or so, encoding is 1,2 ms or so, which is just too slow. Remember that 4:2:2 is twice that, and we want multiple streams, so 2,4 ms per frame is eating too much. I don't really know why it's so slow; the DCT isn't bad, the histogram counting is fast, it's just the rANS shader that's slow for some reason I don't understand, and also haven't had the time to really dive deeply into. Of course, a faster GPU would be faster, but I don't think I can reasonably demand that people get a 1080 just to encode a few video streams. Due to this, I haven't really worked out the last few kinks. In particular, I haven't implemented DC coefficient prediction (it needs to be done before tallying up the histograms, so it can be a bit tricky to do efficiently, although perhaps local memory will help again to send data between neighboring DCT blocks). And I also haven't properly done bounds checking in the encoder or decoder, but it should hopefully be simple as long as we're willing to accept that evil input decodes into garbage instead of flagging errors explicitly. It also depends on a GLSL extension that my Haswell laptop doesn't have to get 64-bit divides when precalculating the rANS tables; I've got some code to simulate 64-bit divides using 32-bit, but it doesn't work yet. The code as it currently stands is in this Git repository; you can consider it licensed under GPLv3. It's really not very user-friendly at this point, though, and rather rough around the edges. Next time, we'll wrap up with some performance numbers. Unless I magically get more spare time in the meantime and/or some epiphany about how to make the encoder faster. :-)

27 October 2017

Russ Allbery: Review: The Black Gryphon

Review: The Black Gryphon, by Mercedes Lackey & Larry Dixon
Series: Mage Wars #1
Publisher: DAW
Copyright: 1994
Printing: January 1995
ISBN: 0-88677-643-0
Format: Mass market
Pages: 460
The Mage Wars series (or the Gryphon series, which isn't its official title but which is in all of the titles) is part of the sprawling Valdemar mega-series, but it's a prequel to all of the other stories. It's also slightly challenging if you're reading in publication order, since it was published simultaneously with the Mage Storms series. If you're following publication order, in theory you should interleave the two series, but I hate doing that. I'm therefore reading it after Mage Winds and before Mage Storms. We'll see whether that was a good idea when I get to the next series. You could, if you really wanted to, read this series before any other Valdemar book. As a prequel from the deep past of Valdemar's world, it doesn't depend on the other series, and you'll get a rediscovery of lost knowledge feel from later books. The downside is that it's a rather boring introduction, and that order would spoil a lot of the revelatory flow of the other series (particularly Elspeth's adventures in the Mage Winds books). I'm now getting into the Valdemar books that I've only read once. I've been putting off continuing my Valdemar re-read because this series was next and I remember being rather bored with it the first time I read it. But I'm re-reading for the world-building and background as much as for the characters, and this is a huge chunk of world background that fills in the bones underneath Winds of Fate and its sequels. Here's why Dhorisha is a crater, here's why the Pelagiris forests are such a mess, here's where Ma'ar starts, here's the origin of both the gryphons and K'Leshya, and here, finally, we get to see the legendary Urtho on the page. The problem with writing novels set in the epic backstory of your universe is that it's hard to live up to the drama that readers have invented for themselves. A lot of The Black Gryphon is background to events Valdemar readers already know will happen, creating a corresponding lack of surprise. I reached the end of the book and said "yup, that's pretty much what everyone said had happened." Lackey and Dixon do try to do some interesting things here, one of which being the backgrounding of the war. The Black Gryphon starts in the middle of a long-running conflict between Urtho and Ma'ar and doesn't follow the generals or the battles. The protagonists, instead, are a kestra'chern (a type of psychiatrist and spiritual healer who also uses sex, with the expected conflicts of people who incorrectly think of them as prostitutes) and the eventual leader of the gryphons (Skandranon, who is referenced in later books and who provides the title). We get some combat scenes from Skandranon and later another gryphon, but a lot of the book is Amberdrake fighting the effects of the war instead of the details of the war itself. There's a deep and moving story in that idea, and in some of the attached love stories that play out in the army camps. There's also a great story somewhere around Urtho: a brilliant but detached mage who is way out of his depth trying to run an army but smart enough to gather good people around him. He's also a creator of new life, including the gryphons. The Black Gryphon tries to talk about Urtho's paternalism, the weird emotional currents of his relationship with his creations, and the places Urtho keeps things from others for, supposedly, their own good. If this book had looked a bit deeper at the support structure for an army that's trying to be humane, or at the ways in which Urtho strays far too close to being an abusive tyrant through inaction despite having the best of intentions at every step, I think it could have said something significant. Unfortunately, that's not this book. This book is full of relentlessly black and white morality (the flaw of much of the Valdemar series) that bleaches away interesting shades of grey. Urtho is good and wise by authorial fiat, and Ma'ar is the same utterly irredeemable force of evil that he is in other books. The story skitters over Urtho's odd tyrannies, making them all better with the pure power of friendship and good intentions. There just isn't much emotional depth, and while I don't expect that of Lackey in general, this story really needed that depth to work. What we get instead is repetition, as Lackey and Dixon hit the same emotional notes with Amberdrake repeatedly. This is one of those books that makes me wonder if Lackey was trying to write too many novels in a short time than was good for their individual quality. (Collaborations often mean that the lesser-known name is doing all the work, but Dixon is Lackey's husband and the tone of the book is sufficiently Lackey that I don't think that happened here.) It felt padded by Amberdrake turning over the same emotional rocks repeatedly, to largely the same effect. This is, in short, not Lackey's finest effort, although it does have its moments. As always, Lackey is at her best when writing psychological healing narratives. Zhaneel's story is a bit too easy, but the dynamic between Amberdrake and Winterhart is the best part of the book. And The Black Gryphon does tell the reader exactly what led up to the Cataclysm and why. There are no major surprises, but there are some small ones, and it's a nice payoff for the lore-obsessed (like me). This is missable unless you want the full world-building behind Valdemar's past, and it's not the best writing. But if you're heavily invested in the Valdemar universe, it's at least readable and provides an important bit of the history. Followed by The White Gryphon. Rating: 5 out of 10

26 October 2017

Russ Allbery: Review: Waypoint Kangaroo

Review: Waypoint Kangaroo, by Curtis C. Chen
Series: Kangaroo #1
Publisher: Thomas Dunne
Copyright: June 2016
ISBN: 1-250-08179-3
Format: Kindle
Pages: 312
Disclaimer: Curtis was a classmate of mine at Stanford and part of the same social circle. That was a surprisingly long time ago. Kangaroo is a spy (and, for this book, you should think James Bond). Agency training, fake identities, lots of gadgets, grumpy yet ridiculously competent support staff... the typical package. But Kangaroo also has a special power, which is the entire reason he ended up in the position he has. He's apparently the only person in the world who can open the pocket: a hole into another dimension, which can function as infinite storage and quite a bit more. Waypoint Kangaroo opens with the tail end of a mission and Kangaroo in action, as an introduction to Kangaroo's first-person narrative voice, job, and the capabilities of the pocket. But the real story starts when Kangaroo is sent on vacation. The office is being audited, Kangaroo hasn't had time off basically ever, and his boss insists on a trip to Mars on the space equivalent of a cruise ship. No work. An expense account. Just relax and have fun. Kangaroo isn't sure he knows how to not work. Or how to avoid boredom when trying hard to not work. It leads to probably ill-advised decisions like falling in love at first glance with the chief engineer, or going on entirely unauthorized spacewalks in the middle of the night. It's very lucky for him that the captain of this commercial cruise ship appears to also work for his agency. And it's good for his inability to stop working that there's a murder on board. For a first novel, this is refreshingly free of a lot of first novel problems. It's lean, well-structured, easy to follow, moves right along, and doesn't feel over-stuffed with exposition or world-building. There's an interplanetary war in the past background, and of course a lot of loving description of the precise mechanics of the pocket and the tricks with momentum and retrieval Kangaroo can do with it, but the book never falls into too much explanation. And the plot is satisfyingly twisty. It's an action story plot, to be clear: don't expect deep puzzles or complex deduction. But there are enough players and hidden motives to keep things interesting. The downside is that I didn't like Kangaroo very much. He's a bit of an ass. Some of this goes with the spy novel territory, and some of it is good (if occasionally grating) characterization. Kangaroo doesn't know how to turn off the part of his brain that makes everything a mission. But his flippant, know-it-all attitude got on my nerves after a book full of first-person narration, and while (full credit to Curtis here) the romance in this book is clearly consensual and stays well away from the creepy romances so common in spy stories, the love-at-first sight bits and some of Kangaroo's awkward reactions provoked more eye-rolling than enjoyment. A lot of this is just personal taste, but that's the peril of books told with first-person narration. The reader has to really like the protagonist to spend a whole book in their head. If that relationship doesn't click, the supporting characters have a harder time salvaging the experience. Waypoint Kangaroo avoids the problem of too many loving descriptions of guns, partly because it's a spy novel and instead has loving descriptions of spy equipment in a future that supports implanted devices. I think there was a smidgen too much of this, but it was within genre conventions and spy stuff is more interesting than guns. But (and I admit that this is probably idiosyncratic), it also had way too many loving descriptions of alcohol and one drunk scene. I don't care to ever read another book with a drunk protagonist (particularly first-person), and I care considerably less about alcohol than I do about spy equipment or guns. That said, I still liked this well enough that I'll probably buy the sequel. (No cliffhangers; Waypoint Kangaroo is a complete story. But this is a character who could easily support a long episodic series.) The pocket is a neat gimmick, the world background is at least mildly interesting, and some of the supporting characters were excellent. (Particularly the security chief and the engineer.) I might even warm to Kangaroo over time if subsequent stories stay more on his creative fast-talking rather than his drinking and awkward romances. I don't think this is quite good enough for me to recommend it, but if you're in the mood for a light and fast-moving first-person Bond-style story with science fiction trappings, it does deliver. Rating: 6 out of 10

24 October 2017

Daniel Silverstone: Introducing the car

For many years now, I have been driving a diesel based VW Passat Estate. It has served me very well and been as reliable as I might have hoped given how awful I am with cars. Sadly Gunther was reaching the point where it was going to cost more per year to maintain than the car was worth, and also I've been being more and more irked by not having a car from the future. I spent many months doing spreadsheets, trying to convince myself I could somehow afford a Tesla of some variety. Sadly I never quite managed it. As such I set my sights on the more viable BEVs such as the Nissan Leaf. For a while, nothing I saw was something I wanted. I am quite unusual it seems, in that I don't want a car which is a "Look at me, I'm driving an electric car" fashion statement. I felt like I'd never get something which looked like a normal car, but happened to be a BEV. Then along came the Hyundai Ioniq. Hybrid, Plug-in Hybrid, and BEV all looking basically the same, and not in-your-face-special. I began to covet. Eventually I caved and arranged a test drive of an Ioniq plug-in hybrid because the BEV was basically on 9 month lead. I enjoyed the drive and was instantly very sad because I didn't want a plug-in hybrid, I wanted a BEV. Despondent, I left the dealership and went home. I went online and found a small number of second-hand Ioniq BEVs but as I scrolled through the list, none seemed to be of the right trim level. Then, just as I was ready to give up hope, I saw a new listing, no photo, of the right thing. One snag, it was 200 miles away. No matter, I rang the place, confirmed it was available, and agreed to sleep on the decision. The following morning, I hadn't decided to not buy, so I called them up, put down a deposit to hold the car until I could test drive it, and then began the long and awkward process of working out how I would charge the car given I have no off-street parking so I can't charge at home. (Yeah yeah, you'd think I'd have checked that first, but no I'm just not that sensible). Over the week I convinced myself I could do it, I ordered RFID cards for various schemes, signed up with a number of services, and then, on Friday last week, I drove down to a hotel near the dealership and had a fitful night's sleep. I rocked up to the dealership exactly as they opened for business, shook the hand of the very helpful salesman who had gone through the purchase process with me over the phone during the week, and got to see the car. Instant want coursed through me as I sat in it and decided "Yes, this somehow feels right". I took the car for about a 45 minute test drive just to see how it felt relative to the plug-in hybrid I'd driven the week before and it was like night and day. The BEV felt so much better to drive. I was hooked. Back to the dealership and we began the paperwork. Emptying Gunther of all of the bits and bobs scattered throughout his nooks and crannies took a while and gave me a chance to say goodbye to a car which, on reflection, had actually been a pleasure to own, even when its expensive things went wrong, more than once. But once I'd closed the Passat for the last time, and handed the keys over, it was quite a bittersweet moment as the salesman drove off in what still felt like my car, despite (by this point) it not being so. Sitting in the Ioniq though, I headed off for the 200 mile journey back home. With about 90% charge left after the test drive, I had two stops planned at rapid chargers and I headed toward my first. Unfortunately disaster struck, the rapid (50KW) charger refused to initialise, and I ended up with my car on the slower (7KW) charger to get enough juice into it to drive on to the next rapid charger enabled service station. When I got the message that my maximum charge period (45m) had elapsed, I headed back to the car to discover I couldn't persuade it to unlock from the car. Much hassle later, and an AA man came and together we learned that it takes 2 to tango, one to pull the emergency release in the boot, the other to then unplug the cable. Armed with this knowledge, I headed on my way to a rapid charger I'd found on the map which wasn't run by the same company. Vainly hoping that this would work better, I plugged the car in, set the charger going, and headed into the adjacent shop for a rest break. I went back to the car about 20 minutes later to see the charger wasn't running. Horror of horrors. I imagined maybe some nasty little oik had pressed 'stop' so I started the charger up again, and sat in the car to read my book. After about 3 minutes, the charge stopped. Turns out that charger was slightly iffy and couldn't cope with the charge current and kept emergency-stopping as a result. The lovely lady I spoke to about it directed me to a nearby (12 miles or so, easily done with the charge I had) charger in the grounds of a gorgeous chateau hotel. That one worked perfectly and I filled up. I drove on to my second planned stop and that charge went perfectly too. In fact, every charge since has gone flawlessly. So perhaps my baptism of failed charges has hardened me to the problems with owning a BEV. I've spent the past few days trying different charge points around Manchester enjoying my free charge capability, and trying different names for the car before I finally settled on which is a reasonable Korean boy's name (since the car is Korean I even got to set that as the bluetooth ID) and it's roughly pronounced sock/gin which are two wonderful things in life. I'm currently sat in a pub, eating a burger, enjoying myself while suckles on the teat of "free" electricity to make up for the fact that I've developed a non-trivial habit of leaving Audi drivers in the dust at traffic lights. Further updates may happen as I play with Android Auto and other toys in an attempt to eventually be able to ask the car to please "freeze my buttocks" (a feature it has in the form of air-conditioned seats.)

19 October 2017

Lior Kaplan: Hacktoberfest 2017 @ Tel Aviv

I gave my Midburn creating an open source community talk in Hacktoberfest 2017 @ Tel Aviv. This is the local version of an initiative by DigitalOcean and GitHub. I was surprised about the vibe both the location and the organizers gave the event, and the fact they could easily arrange t-shirts, pizzas and beer. Looking at the github search, it seem the worldwide event brings many new contributions. I think we have something to learn how to do a mass concept like that. Especially when it crosses both project limits and country limits. (e.g. not a local bug squashing party).
Filed under: Open source businesses

Next.

Previous.