Search Results: "ag"

12 April 2017

Daniel Pocock: What is the risk of using proprietary software for people who prefer not to?

Jonas berg has recently blogged about Using Proprietary Software for Freedom. He argues that it can be acceptable to use proprietary software to further free and open source software ambitions if that is indeed the purpose. Jonas' blog suggests that each time proprietary software is used, the relative risk and reward should be considered and there may be situations where the reward is big enough and the risk low enough that proprietary software can be used. A question of leadership Many of the free software users and developers I've spoken to express frustration about how difficult it is to communicate to their family and friends about the risks of proprietary software. A typical example is explaining to family members why you would never install Skype. Imagine a doctor who gives a talk to school children about the dangers of smoking and is then spotted having a fag at the bus stop. After a month, if you ask the children what they remember about that doctor, is it more likely to be what he said or what he did? When contemplating Jonas' words, it is important to consider this leadership factor as a significant risk every time proprietary software or services are used. Getting busted with just one piece of proprietary software undermines your own credibility and posture now and well into the future. Research has shown that when communicating with people, what they see and how you communicate is ninety three percent of the impression you make. What you actually say to them is only seven percent. When giving a talk at a conference or a demo to a client, or communicating with family members in our everyday lives, using a proprietary application or a product or service that is obviously proprietary like an iPhone or Facebook will have far more impact than the words you say. It is not only a question of what you are seen doing in public: somebody who lives happily and comfortably without using proprietary software sounds a lot more credible than somebody who tries to explain freedom without living it. The many faces of proprietary software One of the first things to consider is that even for those developers who have a completely free operating system, there may well be some proprietary code lurking in their BIOS or other parts of their hardware. Their mobile phone, their car, their oven and even their alarm clock are all likely to contain some proprietary code too. The risks associated with these technologies may well be quite minimal, at least until that alarm clock becomes part of the Internet of Things and can be hacked by the bored teenager next door. Accessing most web sites these days inevitably involves some interaction with proprietary software, even if it is not running on your own computer. There is no need to give up Some people may consider this state of affairs and simply give up, using whatever appears to be the easiest solution for each problem at hand without thinking too much about whether it is proprietary or not. I don't think Jonas' blog intended to sanction this level of complacency. Every time you come across a piece of software, it is worth considering whether a free alternative exists and whether the software is really needed at all. An orderly migration to free software In our professional context, most software developers come across proprietary software every day in the networks operated by our employers and their clients. Sometimes we have the opportunity to influence the future of these systems. There are many cases where telling the client to go cold-turkey on their proprietary software would simply lead to the client choosing to get advice from somebody else. The free software engineer who looks at the situation strategically may find that it is possible to continue using the proprietary software as part of a staged migration, gradually helping the user to reduce their exposure over a period of months or even a few years. This may be one of the scenarios where Jonas is sanctioning the use of proprietary software. On a technical level, it may be possible to show the client that we are concerned about the dangers but that we also want to ensure the continuity of their business. We may propose a solution that involves sandboxing the proprietary software in a virtual machine or a DMZ to prevent it from compromising other systems or "calling home" to the vendor. As well as technical concerns about a sudden migration, promoters of free software frequently encounter political issues as well. For example, the IT manager in a company may be five years from retirement and is not concerned about his employer's long term ability to extricate itself from a web of Microsoft licenses after he or she has the freedom to go fishing every day. The free software professional may need to invest significant time winning the trust of senior management before he is able to work around a belligerant IT manager like this. No deal is better than a bad deal People in the UK have probably encountered the expression "No deal is better than a bad deal" many times already in the last few weeks. Please excuse me for borrowing it. If there is no free software alternative to a particular piece of proprietary software, maybe it is better to simply do without it. Facebook is a great example of this principle: life without social media is great and rather than trying to find or create a free alternative, why not just do something in the real world, like riding motorcycles, reading books or getting a cat or dog? Burning bridges behind you For those who are keen to be the visionaries and leaders in a world where free software is the dominant paradigm, would you really feel satisfied if you got there on the back of proprietary solutions? Or are you concerned that taking such shortcuts is only going to put that vision further out of reach? Each time you solve a problem with free software, whether it is small or large, in your personal life or in your business, the process you went through strengthens you to solve bigger problems the same way. Each time you solve a problem using a proprietary solution, not only do you miss out on that process of discovery but you also risk conditioning yourself to be dependent in future. For those who hope to build a successful startup company or be part of one, how would you feel if you reach your goal and then the rug is pulled out underneath you when a proprietary software vendor or cloud service you depend on changes the rules? Personally, in my own life, I prefer to avoid and weed out proprietary solutions wherever I can and force myself to either make free solutions work or do without them. Using proprietary software and services is living your life like a rat in a maze, where the oligarchs in Silicon Valley can move the walls around as they see fit.

Michal Čihař: Weblate 2.13

Weblate 2.13 has been released today pretty much on the schedule. The most important change being more fine grained access control and some smaller UI improvements. There are other new features and bug fixes as well. Full list of changes: If you are upgrading from older version, please follow our upgrading instructions. You can find more information about Weblate on https://weblate.org, the code is hosted on Github. If you are curious how it looks, you can try it out on demo server. You can login there with demo account using demo password or register your own user. Weblate is also being used on https://hosted.weblate.org/ as official translating service for phpMyAdmin, OsmAnd, Aptoide, FreedomBox, Weblate itself and many other projects. Should you be looking for hosting of translations for your project, I'm happy to host them for you or help with setting it up on your infrastructure. Further development of Weblate would not be possible without people providing donations, thanks to everybody who have helped so far! The roadmap for next release is just being prepared, you can influence this by expressing support for individual issues either by comments or by providing bounty for them.

Filed under: Debian English Gammu phpMyAdmin SUSE Weblate 0 comments

11 April 2017

Matthew Garrett: Disabling SSL validation in binary apps

Reverse engineering protocols is a great deal easier when they're not encrypted. Thankfully most apps I've dealt with have been doing something convenient like using AES with a key embedded in the app, but others use remote protocols over HTTPS and that makes things much less straightforward. MITMProxy will solve this, as long as you're able to get the app to trust its certificate, but if there's a built-in pinned certificate that's going to be a pain. So, given an app written in C running on an embedded device, and without an easy way to inject new certificates into that device, what do you do?

First: The app is probably using libcurl, because it's free, works and is under a license that allows you to link it into proprietary apps. This is also bad news, because libcurl defaults to having sensible security settings. In the worst case we've got a statically linked binary with all the symbols stripped out, so we're left with the problem of (a) finding the relevant code and (b) replacing it with modified code. Fortuntely, this is much less difficult than you might imagine.

First, let's find where curl sets up its defaults. Curl_init_userdefined() in curl/lib/url.c has the following code:
set->ssl.primary.verifypeer = TRUE;
set->ssl.primary.verifyhost = TRUE;
#ifdef USE_TLS_SRP
set->ssl.authtype = CURL_TLSAUTH_NONE;
#endif
set->ssh_auth_types = CURLSSH_AUTH_DEFAULT; /* defaults to any auth
type */
set->general_ssl.sessionid = TRUE; /* session ID caching enabled by
default */
set->proxy_ssl = set->ssl;

set->new_file_perms = 0644; /* Default permissions */
set->new_directory_perms = 0755; /* Default permissions */

TRUE is defined as 1, so we want to change the code that currently sets verifypeer and verifyhost to 1 to instead set them to 0. How to find it? Look further down - new_file_perms is set to 0644 and new_directory_perms is set to 0755. The leading 0 indicates octal, so these correspond to decimal 420 and 493. Passing the file to objdump -d (assuming a build of objdump that supports this architecture) will give us a disassembled version of the code, so time to fix our problems with grep:
objdump -d target grep --after=20 ,420 grep ,493

This gives us the disassembly of target, searches for any occurrence of ",420" (indicating that 420 is being used as an argument in an instruction), prints the following 20 lines and then searches for a reference to 493. It spits out a single hit:
43e864: 240301ed li v1,493
Which is promising. Looking at the surrounding code gives:
43e820: 24030001 li v1,1
43e824: a0430138 sb v1,312(v0)
43e828: 8fc20018 lw v0,24(s8)
43e82c: 24030001 li v1,1
43e830: a0430139 sb v1,313(v0)
43e834: 8fc20018 lw v0,24(s8)
43e838: ac400170 sw zero,368(v0)
43e83c: 8fc20018 lw v0,24(s8)
43e840: 2403ffff li v1,-1
43e844: ac4301dc sw v1,476(v0)
43e848: 8fc20018 lw v0,24(s8)
43e84c: 24030001 li v1,1
43e850: a0430164 sb v1,356(v0)
43e854: 8fc20018 lw v0,24(s8)
43e858: 240301a4 li v1,420
43e85c: ac4301e4 sw v1,484(v0)
43e860: 8fc20018 lw v0,24(s8)
43e864: 240301ed li v1,493
43e868: ac4301e8 sw v1,488(v0)

Towards the end we can see 493 being loaded into v1, and v1 then being copied into an offset from v0. This looks like a structure member being set to 493, which is what we expected. Above that we see the same thing being done to 420. Further up we have some more stuff being set, including a -1 - that corresponds to CURLSSH_AUTH_DEFAULT, so we seem to be in the right place. There's a zero above that, which corresponds to CURL_TLSAUTH_NONE. That means that the two 1 operations above the -1 are the code we want, and simply changing 43e820 and 43e82c to 24030000 instead of 24030001 means that our targets will be set to 0 (ie, FALSE) rather than 1 (ie, TRUE). Copy the modified binary back to the device, run it and now it happily talks to MITMProxy. Huge success.

(If the app calls Curl_setopt() to reconfigure the state of these values, you'll need to stub those out as well - thankfully, recent versions of curl include a convenient string "CURLOPT_SSL_VERIFYHOST no longer supports 1 as value!" in this function, so if the code in question is using semi-recent curl it's easy to find. Then it's just a matter of looking for the constants that CURLOPT_SSL_VERIFYHOST and CURLOPT_SSL_VERIFYPEER are set to, following the jumps and hacking the code to always set them to 0 regardless of the argument)

comment count unavailable comments

Riku Voipio: Deploying OBS

Open Build Service from SuSE is web service building deb/rpm packages. It has recently been added to Debian, so finally there is relatively easy way to set up PPA style repositories in Debian. Relative as in "there is a learning curve, but nowhere near the complexity of replicating Debian's internal infrastructure". OBS will give you both repositories and build infrastructure with a clickety web UI and command line client (osc) to manage. See Hectors blog for quickstart instructions. Things to learned while setting up OBSMe coming from Debian background, and OBS coming from SuSE/RPM world, there are some quirks that can take by surprise. Well done packagingUsually web services are a tough fit for Distros. The cascade of weird dependencies and build systems where the only practical way to build an "open source" web service is by replicating the upstream CI scripts. Not in case of OBS. Being done by distro people shows. OBS does automatic rebuilds of reverse dependenciesAka automatic binNMUs when you update a library. This however means you need lots of build power around. OBS has it's own dependency resolver on the server that recalculate what packages need rebuilding when - workers just get a list of packages to install for build-depends. This a major divergence from Debian, where sbuild handles dependencies client side. The OBS dependency handler doesn't handle virtual packages* / alternative build-deps like Debian - you may have to add a specific "Prefer: foo-dev" into the OBS project config to solve alternative choices. OBS server and worker do http requests in both directionsOn startup workers connect to OBS server, open a TCP port and wait requests coming OBS. Having connections both directions is a bit of hassle firewall-wise. On the bright side, no need to setup uploads via FTP here.. Signing repositories is complicatedWith Debian 9.0 making signed repositories pretty much mandatory, OBS makes signing rather complicated. obs-signd isn't included in Debian, since it depends on gnupg patch that hasn't been upstreamed. Fortunately I found a workaround. OBS signs release files with /usr/bin/sign -d /path/to/release. Where replacing the obs-signd provided sign command your own script is easy ;) Git integration is rather bolted-on than integratedOBS provides a method to integrate with git using services. - There is no clickety UI to link to git repo, instead you make an xml file called _service with osc. There is no way to have debian/ tree in git. The upstream community is friendlyIncluding the happiest thanks from an upstream I've seen recently. SummaryAll in all rather satisfied with OBS. If you have a home-grown jenkins etc based solution for building DEB/RPM packages, you should definitely consider OBS. For simpler uses, no need to install OBS yourself, openSUSE public OBS will happily build Debian packages for you. *How useful are virtual packages anymore? "foo-defaults" packages seem to be the go-to solution for most real usecases anyways.

Antoine Beaupr : A report from Netconf: Day 1

As is becoming traditional, two times a year the kernel networking community meets in a two-stage conference: an invite-only, informal, two-day plenary session called Netconf, held in Toronto this year, and a more conventional one-track conference open to the public called Netdev. I was invited to cover both conferences this year, given that Netdev was in Montreal (my hometown), and was happy to meet the crew of developers that maintain the network stack of the Linux kernel. This article covers the first day of the conference which consisted of around 25 Linux developers meeting under the direction of David Miller, the kernel's networking subsystem maintainer. Netconf has no formal sessions; although some people presented slides, interruptions are frequent (indeed, encouraged) and the focus is on hashing out issues that are blocked on the mailing list and getting suggestions, ideas, solutions, and feedback from their peers.

Removing ndo_select_queue() One of the first discussions that elicited a significant debate was the ndo_select_queue() function, a key component of the Linux polling system that determines when and how to send packets on a network interface (see netdev_pick_tx and friends). The general question was whether the use of ndo_select_queue() in drivers is a good idea. Alexander Duyck explained that Intel people were considering using ndo_select_queue() for receive/transmit queue matching. Intel drivers do not currently use the hook provided by the Linux kernel and it turns out no one is happy with ndo_select_queue(): the heuristics it uses don't really please anyone. The consensus (including from Duyck himself) seemed to be that it should just not be used anymore, or at least not used for that specific purpose. The discussion turned toward the wireless network stack, which uses it extensively, but for other purposes. Johannes Berg explained that the wireless stack uses ndo_select_queue() for traffic classification, for example to get voice traffic through even if the best-effort queue is backed up. The wireless stack could stop using it by doing flow control completely inside the wireless stack, which already uses the fq_codel flow-control mechanism for other purposes, so porting away from ndo_select_queue() seems possible there. The problem then becomes how to update all the drivers to change that behavior, which would be a lot of work. Still, it seems people are moving away from a generic ndo_select_queue() interface to stack-specific or even driver-specific (in the case of Intel) queue management interfaces.

refcount_t followup There was a followup discussion on the integration of the refcount_t type into the network stack, which we covered recently. This type is meant to be an in-kernel defense against exploits based on overflowing or underflowing an object's reference count. The consensus seems to be that having refcount_t used for debugging is acceptable, but it cannot be enabled by default. An issue that was identified is that the networking developers are fairly sure that introducing refcount_t would have a severe impact on performance, but they do not have benchmarks to prove it, something Miller identified as a problem that needs to be worked on. Miller then expressed some openness to the idea of having it as a kernel configuration option. A similar discussion happened, on the second day, regarding the KASan memory error detector which was covered when it was introduced in 2014. Eric Dumazet warned that there could be a lot of issues that cannot be detected by KASan because of the way the network stack often bypasses regular memory-allocation routines for performance reasons. He also noted that this can sometimes mean the stack may go over the regular 10% memory limit (the tcp_mem parameter, described in the tcp(7) man page) for certain operations, especially when rebuilding out of order packets with lots of parallel TCP connections. Therefore it was proposed that these special memory recycling tricks could be optionally disabled, at run or compile-time, to instrument proper memory tracking. Dumazet argued this was a situation similar to refcount_t in that we need a way to disable high performance to make the network stack easier to debug with KAsan. The problem with optional parameters is that they are often disabled in production or even by default, which, in turn, means that critical bugs cannot actually be found because the code paths are not tested. When I asked Dumazet about this, he explained that Google performs integration testing of new kernels before putting them in production, and those toggles could be enabled there to find and fix those bugs. But he agreed that certain code paths are then not tested until the code gets deployed in production. So it seems the status quo remains: security folks wants to improve the reliability of the kernel, but the network folks can't afford the performance cost. Yet it was clear in the discussions that the team cares about security issues and wants those issues to be fixed; the impact of some of the solutions is just too big.

Lightweight wireless management packet access Berg explained that some users need to have high-performance access to certain management frames in the wireless stack and wondered how to best expose those to user space. The wireless stack already allows users to clone a network interface in "monitor" mode, but this has a big performance cost, as the radiotap header needs to be constructed from scratch and the packet header needs to be copied. As wireless improves and the bandwidth rises to gigabit levels, this can become significant bottleneck for packet sniffers or reporting software that need to know precisely what's going on over the air outside of the regular access point client operation. It seems the proper way to do this is with an eBPF program. As Miller summarized, just add another API call that allows loading a BPF program into the kernel and then those users can use a BPF filtering point to get the statistics they need. This will require an extra hook in the wireless stack, but it seems like this is the way that will be taken to implement this feature.

VLAN 0 inconsistencies Hannes Frederic Sowa brought up the seemingly innocuous question of "how do we handle VLAN 0?" In theory, VLAN 0 means "no VLAN". But the Linux kernel currently handles this differently depending on whether the VLAN module is loaded and whether a VLAN 0 interface was created. Sometimes the VLAN tag is stripped, sometimes not. It turns out the semantics of this were accidentally changed last time there was a change here and this was originally working but is now broken. Sowa therefore got the go-ahead to fix this to make the behavior consistent again.

Loopy fun Then it came the turn of Jamal Hadi Salim, the maintainer of the kernel's traffic-control (tc) subsystem. The first issue he brought up is a problem in the tc REDIRECT action that can create infinite loops within the kernel. The problem can be easily alleviated when loops are created on the same interface: checks can be added that just drop packets coming from the same device and rate-limit logging to avoid a denial-of-service (DoS) condition. The more serious problem occurs when a packet is forwarded from (say) interface eth0 to eth1 which then promptly redirects it from eth1 back to eth0. Obviously, this kind of problem can only be created by a user with root access so, at first glance, those issues don't seem that serious: admins can shoot themselves in the foot, so what? But things become a little more serious when you consider the container case, where an untrusted user has root access inside a container and should have constrained resource limitations. Such a loop could allow this user to deploy an effective DoS attack against a whole group of containers running on the same machine. Even worse, this endless loop could possibly turn into a deadlock in certain scenarios, as the kernel could try to transmit the packet on the same device it originated from and block, progressively filling the queues and eventually completely breaking network access. Florian Westphal argued that a container can already create DoS conditions, for example by doing a ping flood. According to Salim, this whole problem was created when two bits used for tracking such packets were reclaimed from the skb structure used to represent packets in the kernel. Those bits were a simple TTL (time to live) field that was incremented on each loop and dropped after a pre-determined limit was reached, breaking infinite loops. Salim asked everyone if this should be fixed or if we should just forget about this issue and move on. Miller proposed to keep a one-behind state for the packet, fixing the simplest case (two interfaces). The general case, however, would requite a bitmap of all the interfaces to be scanned, which would impose a large overhead. Miller said an attempt to fix this should somehow be made. The root of the problem is that the network maintainers are trying to reduce the size of the skb structure, because it's used in many critical paths of the network stack. Salim's position is that, without the TTL fields, there is no way to fix the general case here, and this constitutes a security issue. So either the bits need to be brought back, or we need to live with the inherent DoS threat.

Dumping large statistics sets Another issue Salim brought up was the question of how to export large statistics sets from the kernel. It turns out that some use cases may end up dumping a lot of data. Salim mentioned a real-world tc use case that calls for reading six-million entries. The current netlink-based API provides a way to get only 20 entries at a time, which means it takes forever to dump the state of all those policy actions. Salim has a patch that changes the dump size be eight times the NLMSG_GOOD_SIZE, which improves performance by an order of magnitude already, although there are issues with checking the user-space buffer size there. But a more complete solution is needed. What Salim proposed was a way to ask only for the states that changed since the last dump was requested. He has a patch to add a last_access field to the netlink_callback structure used by netlink_dump() to output data; that raised the question of how to actually use that field. Since Salim fetches that data every five seconds, he figured he could just tell the kernel to return all the nodes that changed in that period. But then if the dump takes more than five seconds to complete, the next dump may be missing states that changed during the extra delay. An alternative mechanism would be for the user-space utility to keep the time stamp it requested and use that as a delta for the next dump. It turns out this is a larger problem than just tc. Dumazet mentioned this was an issue with fq_codel classes: he would even like to be able to dump those statistics faster than every five seconds. Roopa Prabhu mentioned that Cumulus also has similar problems dumping stats from bridges, so clearly a more generic solution is needed here. There is, however, a fundamental problem with dumping large statistics sets from the kernel: those statistics are constantly changing while the dump is created and unless versioning or locking mechanisms are used which would slow things down the data returned is bound to be only an approximation of reality. Salim promised to send a set of RFC patches to further discussions regarding this issue, but during the following Netdev conference, Berg published a patch to fix this ten-year-old issue, which brought cheers from the audience.
The author would like to thank the Netconf and Netdev organizers for travel to, and hosting assistance in, Toronto. Many thanks to Berg, Dumazet, Salim, and Sowa for their time taken for a technical review of this article. Note: this article first appeared in the Linux Weekly News.

Antoine Beaupr : A report from Netconf: Day 2

This article covers the second day of the informal Netconf discussions, held on on April 4, 2017. Topics discussed this day included the binding of sockets in VRF, identification of eBPF programs, inconsistencies between IPv4 and IPv6, changes to data-center hardware, and more. (See this article for coverage from the first day of discussions).

How to bind to specific sockets in VRF One of the first presentations was from David Ahern of Cumulus, who presented a few interesting questions for the audience. His first was the problem of binding sockets to a given interface. Right now, there are four different ways this can be done:
  • the old SO_BINDTODEVICE generic socket option (see socket(7))
  • the IP_PKTINFO, IP-specific socket option (see ip(7)), introduced in Linux 2.2
  • the IP_UNICAST_IF flag, introduced in Linux 3.3 for WINE
  • the IPv6 scope ID suffix, part of the IPv6 addressing standard
So there's a problem of having too many ways of doing the same thing, something that cannot really be fixed without breaking ABI compatibility. But even worse, conflicts between those options are not reported by the kernel so it's possible for a user to set up socket flags in a way that certain flags override others and there are no checks made or errors reported. It was agreed that the user should get some notification of conflicting changes here, at least. Furthermore, binding sockets to a specific VRF (Virtual Routing and Forwarding) device is not currently possible, so Ahern asked what the best way to do this would be, considering the many options available. A use case example is a UDP multicast socket that could be bound to a specific interface within a VRF. This is an old problem: Tom Herbert explained that there were previous discussions about making the bind() system call more programmable so that, for example, you could bind() a UDP socket to a discrete list of IP addresses or a subnet. So he identified this issue as a broader problem that should be addressed by making the interfaces more generic. Ahern explained that it is currently possible to bind sockets to the slave device of a VRF even though that should not be allowed. He also raised the question of how the kernel should tell which socket should be selected for incoming packets. Right now, there is a scoring mechanism for UDP sockets, but that cannot be used directly in this more general case. David Miller said that there are already different ways of specifying scope: there is the VRF layer and the namespace ("netns") layer. A long time ago, Miller reluctantly accepted the addition of netns keys everywhere, swallowing the performance cost to gain flexibility. He argued that a new key should not be added and instead existing infrastructure should be reused. Herbert argued this was exactly the reason why this should be simplified: "if we don't answer the question, people will keep on trying this". For example, one can use a VRF to limit listening addresses, but it gets complicated if we need a device for every address. It seems the consensus evolved towards using, IP_UNICAST_IF, added back in 2012, which is accessible for non-root users. It is currently limited to UDP and RAW sockets, but it could be extended for TCP.

XDP and eBPF program identification Ahern then turned to the problem of extracting BPF programs from the kernel. He gave the example of a simple cBPF (classic BPF) filter that checks for ARP packets. If the filter is read back from the kernel, the user gets a blob of binary data, which is hard to interpret. There is an kernel verifier that can show C-like output, but that is also difficult to interpret. Ahern then added annotations to his slide that showed what the original program actually does, which was a good demonstration of why such a feature is needed. Ahern explained that, at least for cBPF, it should be possible to recover the original plaintext, or at least something close to the original program. A first step would be to replace known constants (like 0x806 for ARP). Even with eBPF, it should be possible to improve the output. Alexei Starovoitov, the BPF maintainer, explained that it might make sense to start by returning information about the maps used by an eBPF program. Then more complex data structures could be inspected once we know their type. The first priority is to get simple debugging tools working but, in the long term, the goal is a full decompiler that can reconstruct instructions into a human-readable program. The question that remains is how to return this data. Ahern explained that right now the bpf() system call copies the data to a different file descriptor, but it could just fill in a buffer. Starovoitov argued for a file descriptor; that would allow the kernel to stream everything through the same descriptor instead of having many attach points. Netlink cannot be used for this because of its asynchronous nature. A similar issue regarding the way we identify express data path (XDP) programs (which are also written in BPF) was raised by Daniel Borkmann from Covalent. Miller explained that users will want ways to figure out which XDP program was installed, so XDP needs an introspection mechanism. We currently have SHA-1 identifiers that can be internally used to tell which binary is currently loaded but those are not exposed to user space. Starovoitov mentioned it is now just a boolean that shows if a program is loaded or not. A use case for this, on top of just trying to figure out which BPF program is loaded, is to actually fetch the source code of a BPF program that was deployed in the field for which the source was lost. It is still uncertain that it will be possible to extract an exact copy that could then be recompiled into the same program. Starovoitov added that he needed this in production to do proper reporting.

IPv4/IPv6 equivalency The last issue or set of issues that Ahern brought up was the question of inconsistencies between IPv4 and IPv6. It turns out that, because both protocols were (naturally) implemented separately, there are inconsistencies in how they are handled in the Linux kernel, which affect, among other things, the VRF framework. The first example he gave was the fact that IPv6 addresses added on the loopback interface generate unreachable routes in the main routing table, yet this doesn't happen with IPv4 addresses. Hannes Frederic Sowa explained this was part of the IPv6 specification: there are stronger restrictions on loopback interfaces in IPv6 than IPv4. Ahern explained that VRF loopback interfaces do not implement these restrictions and wanted to know if this was a problem. Another issue is that anycast routes are added to the wrong interface. This is apparently not specific to VRF: this was done "just because Java", and has been there from day one. It seems that the Java Virtual Machine builds its own routing table and assumes this behavior, so changing this would break every JVM out there, which is obviously not acceptable. Finally, Martin Kafai Lau asked if work should be done to merge the IPv4 and IPv6 FIB (forwarding information base) trees. The FIB tree is the data structure that represents routing tables in the Linux kernel. Miller explained that the two trees are not semantically equivalent: while IPv6 does source-address lookup and routing, IPv4 does not. We can't remove the source lookups from IPv6, because "people probably use that". According to Alexander Duyck, adding source tables to IPv4 would degrade performance to the level of IPv6 performance, which was jokingly referred to as an incentive to switch to IPv6. More seriously, Sowa argued that using the same compressed tree IPv4 uses in IPv6 could make sense. People may want to have source routing in IPv4 as well. Miller argued that the kernel is optimized for 32-bit addresses in IPv4, and conceded that it could be scaled to 64-bit subnets, but 128-bit addresses would be much harder. Sowa suggested that they could be limited to 64 bits, as global routes that are announced over BGP usually have such a limit, and more specific routes are usually at discrete prefixes like /65, /127 (for interconnect links) or /128 for (for point-to-point links). He expressed concerns over the reliability of such an implementation so, at this point, it is unlikely that the data structures could be merged. What is more likely is that the code path could be merged and simplified, while keeping the data structures separate.

Modules options substitutions The next issue that was raised was from Ji P rko, who asked how to pass configuration options to a driver before the driver is initialized. Some chips require that some settings be sent before the firmware is loaded, which leads to a weird situation where there is a need to address a device before it's actually recognized by the kernel. The question then can be summarized as to how to pass information to a device that doesn't exist yet. The answer seems to be that devlink could do this, as it has access to the full device tree and, therefore, to devices that can be addressed by (say) PCI identifiers. Then a possible devlink command could look something like:
    devlink dev pci/0000:03:00.0 option set foo bar
This idea raised a bunch of extra questions: some devices don't have a one-to-one mapping with the PCI bridge identifiers, for example, meaning that those identifiers cannot be used to access such devices. Another issue is that you may want to send multiple settings in a single transaction, which doesn't fit well in the devlink model. Miller then proposed to let the driver initialize itself to some state and wait for configuration to be sent when necessary. Another way would be to unregister the driver and re-register with the given configuration. Shrijeet Mukherjee explained that right now, Cumulus is doing this using horrible startup script magic by retrying and re-registering, but it would be nice to have a more standard way to do this.

Control over UAPI patches Another issue that came up was the problem of changes in the user-space API (UAPI) which break backward compatibility. P rko said that "we have to be more careful about those changes". The problem is that reviewers are not always available to make detailed reviews of such changes and may not notice API-breaking changes. P rko proposed creating a bot to check if a given patch introduces UAPI changes, changes in structs, or in netlink enums. Miller said he could block merges until discussions happen and that patchwork, which Miller uses to process patches from the mailing list, does some of this. He also pointed out there aren't enough test cases in the first place. Starovoitov argued UAPI isn't special, there are other ways of breaking backward compatibility. He expressed concerns that such a bot could create a false sense that everything is fine while a patch could break compatibility and not be detected. Miller countered that UAPI is special in that "we're stuck with it forever". He then went on to propose that, since there's a maintainer (or more) for each module, he can make sure that each maintainer explicitly approves changes to those modules.

Data-center hardware changes Starovoitov brought up the issue of a new type of hardware that is currently being deployed in data centers called a "multi-host NIC" (network interface card). It's a single NIC that is connected to multiple servers. Facebook, for example, uses this in its Yosemite platform that shoves twelve servers into a 2U rack mount, in three modules. Each module is made of four servers connected to the traditional switch fabric with a single NIC through PCI-Express. Mellanox and and Broadcom also have similar devices. One question is how to manage those devices. Since they are connected through a PCI-Express bus, Linux will see them as a NIC, yet they are also a little like switches, in that they interconnect multiple servers. Furthermore, the kernel security model assumes that a NIC is trusted, and gladly opens its own memory to NICs through DMA; this can become a huge security issue when the NIC is under the control of another server. This can especially become problematic if we consider that there could be TLS hardware offloading in the future with the introduction of in-kernel TLS stacks. The other problem is the question of reliability: since those devices are currently "dumb", they need to be managed just like a regular NIC. If the host managing the card crashes, it could disable a whole set of servers that rely on the same NIC. There could be an election process among the servers, but that complicates significantly what used to be a simple PCI connection. Mukherjee pointed out that the model Cisco uses for this is that the "smart NIC" is a "slave" of the main switch fabric. It's a daughter card, which makes it easier to manage from a network perspective. It is clear that Linux will need a way to represent those devices, probably through the newly introduced switchdev or DSA (distributed switch architecture), but it will be something to keep an eye on as density increases in the data center. There were many more discussions during Netconf, too many to cover here, but in the end, Miller thanked everyone for all the interesting topics as the participants dispersed for a day off to travel to Montreal to attend the following Netdev conference.
The author would like to thank the Netconf and Netdev organizers for travel to, and hosting assistance in, Toronto. Many thanks to Alexei Starovoitov for his time taken for a technical review of this article. Note: this article first appeared in the Linux Weekly News.

Reproducible builds folks: Reproducible Builds: week 102 in Stretch cycle

Here's what happened in the Reproducible Builds effort between Sunday April 2 and Saturday April 8 2017: Media coverage Toolchain development and fixes Reviews of unreproducible packages 27 package reviews have been added, 14 have been updated and 17 have been removed in this week, adding to our knowledge about identified issues. Weekly QA work During our reproducibility testing, FTBFS bugs have been detected and reported by: tests.reproducible-builds.org Misc. This week's edition was written by Chris Lamb, Vagrant Cascadian & reviewed by a bunch of Reproducible Builds folks on IRC & the mailing lists.

10 April 2017

Daniel Pocock: If Alan Turing was born today, would he be a Muslim?

Alan Turing's name and his work are well known to anybody with a theoretical grounding in computer science. Turing developed his theories well before anybody invented file sharing, overclocking or mass surveillance. In fact, Turing was largely working in the absence of any computers at all: the transistor was only invented in 1947 and the microchip, the critical innovation that has made computing both affordable and portable, only came in 1960, four years after Turing's death. To this day, the Turing Test remains a well known challenge in the field of Artificial Intelligence. The most prestigious prize in computing, the A.M. Turing Award from the ACM, equivalent to the Nobel Prize in other fields of endeavour, is named in Turing's honour. (This year's award is another British scientist, Sir Tim Berners-Lee, inventor of the World Wide Web).
Potentially far more people know of Alan Turing for his groundbreaking work at Bletchley Park and the impact it had on cracking the Nazi's Enigma machines during World War 2, giving the allies an advantage against Hitler. While in his lifetime, Turing exposed the secret communications of the Nazis, in his death, he exposed something manifestly repugnant about his own society. Turing's challenges with his sexuality (or Britain's challenge with it) are just as well documented as his greatest scientific achievements. The 2014 movie The Imitation Game tells Turing's story, bringing together the themes from his professional and personal life. Had Turing chosen to flee British persecution by going abroad, he would be a refugee in the same sense as any person who crossed the seas to reach Europe today to avoid persecution elsewhere. Please prove me wrong In March, I blogged about the problem of racism that plagues Britain today. While some may have felt the tone of the blog was quite strong, I was in no way pleased to find my position affirmed by the events that occurred in the two days after the blog appeared. Two days and two more human beings (both immigrants and both refugees) subjected to abhorrent and unnecessary acts of abuse in Great Britain. Both cases appear to be fuelled directly by the evil that has been oozing out of number 10 Downing Street since they decided to have a referendum on "Brexit". What stands out about these latest crimes is not that they occurred (this type of thing has been going on for months now) but certain contrasts between their circumstances and to a lesser extent, the fact they occurred immediately after Theresa May formalized Britain's departure from the EU. One of the victims was almost beaten to death by a street gang, while the other was abused by men wearing uniforms. One was only a child, while the other is a mature adult who has been in the UK almost three decades, completely assimilated into British life, working and paying taxes. Both were doing nothing out of the ordinary at the time the abuse occurred: one had engaged in a conversation at a bus stop, the other was on a routine visit to a Government office. There is no evidence that either of them had done anything to provoke or invite the abhorrent treatment meted out to them by the followers of Theresa May and Nigel Farage. The first victim, on 30 March, was Stojan Jankovic, a refugee from Yugoslavia who has been in the UK for 26 years. He had a routine meeting at an immigration department office where he was ambushed, thrown in the back of a van and sent to rot in a prison cell by Theresa May's gestapo. On Friday, 31 March, it was Reker Ahmed, a 17 year old Kurdish-Iranian beaten to the brink of death by a crowd in south London. One of the more remarkable facts to emerge about these two cases is that while Stojan Jankovic was basically locked up for no reason at all, the street thugs who the police apprehended for the assault on Ahmed were kept in a cell for less than 48 hours and released again on bail. While the harmless and innocent Jankovic was eventually released after a massive public outcry, he spent more time locked up than that gang of violent criminals who beat Reker Ahmed. In other words, Theresa May and Nigel Farage's Britain has more concern for the liberty of violent criminals than somebody like Jankovic who has been working and paying taxes in the UK since before any of those street thugs were born. A deeper insight into Turing's fate With gay marriage having been legal in the UK for a number of years now, the rainbow flag flying at the Tate and Sir Elton John achieving a knighthood, it becomes difficult for people to relate to the world in which Turing and many other victims were collectively classified by their sexuality, systematically persecuted by the state and ultimately died far sooner than they should have. (Turing was only 41 when he died). In fact, the cruel and brutal forces that ripped Turing apart (and countless other victims too) haven't dissipated at all, they have simply shifted their target. The slanderous comments insinuating that immigrants "steal" jobs or that Islam is about terrorism are eerily reminiscent of suggestions that gay men abduct young boys or work as Soviet spies. None of these lies has any basis in fact, but repeat them often enough in certain types of newspaper and these ideas spread like weeds. In an ironic twist, Turing's groundbreaking work at Bletchley Park was founded on the contributions of Polish mathematicians, their own country having been the first casualty to Hitler, they were also both immigrants and refugees in Britain. Today, under the Theresa May/Nigel Farage leadership, Polish citizens have been subjected to regular vilification by the media and some have even been killed in the street. It is said that a picture is worth a thousand words. When you compare these two pieces of propaganda: a 1963 article in the Sunday Mirror advising people "How to spot a possible homo" and a UK Government billboard encouraging people to be on the lookout for people who look different, could you imagine the same type of small-minded and power-hungry tyrants crafting them, singling out a minority so as to keep the public's attention in the wrong place?
Many people have noticed that these latest UK Government posters portray foreigners, Muslims and basically anybody who is not white using a range of characteristics found in anti-semetic propaganda from the Third Reich: Do the people who create such propaganda appear to have any concern whatsoever for the people they hurt? How would Alan Turing have felt when he encountered propaganda like that from the Sunday Mirror? Do posters like these encourage us to judge people by their gifts in science, the arts or sporting prowess or do they encourage us to lump them all together based on their physical appearance? It is a basic expectation of scientific methodology that when you repeat the same experiment, you should get the same result. What type of experiment are Theresa May and Nigel Farage conducting and what type of result would you expect? Playing ping-pong with children If anybody has any doubt that this evil comes from the top, take a moment to contemplate the 3,000 children who were baited with the promise of resettlement from the Calais "jungle" camp into the UK under the Dubs amendment. When French authorities closed the "jungle" in 2016, the children were lured out of the camp and left with nowhere to go as Theresa May and French authorities played ping-pong with them. Given that the UK parliament had already agreed they should be accepted, was there any reason for Theresa May to dig her heels in and make these children suffer? Or was she just trying to prove her credentials as somebody who can bastardize migrants just the way Nigel Farage would do it? How do British politicians really view migrants? Parliamentarian Keith Vaz, former chair of the Home Affairs Select Committee (responsible for security, crime, prostitution and similar things) was exposed with young men from eastern Europe, encouraging them to take drugs before he ordered them "Take your shirt off. I'm going to attack you.". How many British MP's see foreigners this way? Next time you are groped at an airport security checkpoint, remember it was people like Keith Vaz and his committee who oversee those abuses, writing among other things that "The wider introduction of full-body scanners is a welcome development". No need to "take your shirt off" when these machines can look through it as easily as they can look through your children's underwear. According to the World Health Organization, HIV/AIDS kills as many people as the September 11 attacks every single day. Keith Vaz apparently had no concern for the possibility he might spread this disease any further: the media reported he doesn't use any protection in his extra-marital relationships. While Britain's new management continue to round up foreigners like Stojan Jankovic who have done nothing wrong, they chose not to prosecute Keith Vaz for his antics with drugs and prostitution. Who is Britain's next Alan Turing? Britain's next Alan Turing may not be a homosexual. He or she may have been a child turned away by Theresa May's spat with the French at Calais, a migrant bundled into a deportation van by the gestapo (who are just following orders) or perhaps somebody of Muslim appearance who is set upon by thugs in the street who have been energized by Nigel Farage. If you still have any uncertainty about what Brexit really means, this is it. A country that denies itself the opportunity to be great by subjecting itself to be ruled under the "divide and conquer" mantra of the colonial era. Throughout the centuries, Britain has produced some of the most brilliant scientists of their time. Newton, Darwin and Hawking are just some of those who are even more prominent than Turing, household names around the world. One can only wonder what the history books will have to say about Theresa May and Nigel Farage however. Next time you see a British policeman accosting a Muslim, whether it is at an airport, in a shopping centre, keeping Manchester United souvenirs or simply taking a photograph, spare a thought for Alan Turing and the era when homosexuals were their target of choice.

9 April 2017

Antoine Beaupr : Contribute your skills to Debian in Montreal, April 14 2017

Join us in Montreal, on April 14 2017, and we will find a way in which you can help Debian with your current set of skills! You might even learn one or two things in passing (but you don't have to). Debian is a free operating system for your computer. An operating system is the set of basic programs and utilities that make your computer run. Debian comes with dozens of thousands of packages, precompiled software bundled up for easy installation on your machine. A number of other operating systems, such as Ubuntu and Tails, are based on Debian. The upcoming version of Debian, called Stretch, will be released later this year. We need you to help us make it awesome :) Whether you're a computer user, a graphics designer, or a bug triager, there are many ways you can contribute to this effort. We also welcome experience in consensus decision-making, anti-harassment teams, and package maintenance. No effort is too small and whatever you bring to this community will be appreciated. Here's what we will be doing:

Goals and principles This is a work in progress, and a statement of intent. Not everything is organized and confirmed yet. We want to bring together a heterogeneous group of people. This goal will guide our handling of sponsorship requests, and will help us make decisions if more people want to attend than we can welcome properly. In other words: if you're part of a group that is currently under-represented in computer communities, we would like you to be able to attend. We are committed to providing a friendly, safe and welcoming environment for all, regardless of level of experience, gender, gender identity and expression, sexual orientation, disability, personal appearance, body size, race, ethnicity, age, religion, nationality, or other similar personal characteristic. Attending this event requires reading and respecting the Debian Code of Conduct, that sets the standards in terms of behaviour for the whole event, including communication (public and private) before, while and after. The space where this event will take place is unfortunately not accessible to wheelchairs. Food (including vegetarian options) should be provided for lunch. If you have any specific needs regarding food, please let us know when registering, and we will do our best.

What we will be doing This will be an informal session to confirm and fix bugs in Debian. If you have never worked with Debian packages, this is a good opportunity to learn about packaging and bugtracker usage. Bugs flagged as Release Critical are blocking the release of the upcoming version of Debian. To fix them, it helps to make sure the bug report documents the up-to-date status of the bug, and of its resolution. One does not need to be a programmer to do this work! For example, you can try and reproduce bugs in software you use... or in software you will discover. This helps package maintainers better focus their work. We will also try to actually fix bugs by testing patches and uploading fixes into Debian itself. Antoine Beaupr , a seasoned Debian developer, will be available to sponsor uploads and teach people about basic Debian packaging skills.

Where? When? How to register? See https://wiki.debian.org/BSP/2017/04/ca/Montreal for the exact address and time.

Christoph Egger: Secured OTP Server (ASIS CTF 2017)

This weekend was ASIS Quals weekend again. And just like last year they have quite a lot of nice crypto-related puzzles which are fun to solve (and not "the same as every ctf"). Actually Secured OTP Server is pretty much the same as the First OTP Server (actually it's a "fixed" version to enforce the intended attack). However the template phrase now starts with enough stars to prevent simple root.:
def gen_otps():
    template_phrase = '*************** Welcome, dear customer, the secret passphrase for today is: '
    OTP_1 = template_phrase + gen_passphrase(18)
    OTP_2 = template_phrase + gen_passphrase(18)
    otp_1 = bytes_to_long(OTP_1)
    otp_2 = bytes_to_long(OTP_2)
    nbit, e = 2048, 3
    privkey = RSA.generate(nbit, e = e)
    pubkey  = privkey.publickey().exportKey()
    n = getattr(privkey.key, 'n')
    r = otp_2 - otp_1
    if r < 0:
        r = -r
    IMP = n - r**(e**2)
    if IMP > 0:
        c_1 = pow(otp_1, e, n)
        c_2 = pow(otp_2, e, n)
    return pubkey, OTP_1[-18:], OTP_2[-18:], c_1, c_2
Now let A = template * 2^(18*8), B = passphrase. This results in OTP = A + B. c therefore is (A+B)^3 mod n == A^3 + 3A^2b + 3AB^2 + B^3. Notice that only B^3 is larger than N and is statically known. Therefore we can calculate A^3 // N and add that to c to "undo" the modulo operation. With that it's only iroot and long_to_bytes to the solution. Note that we're talking about OTP and C here. The code actually produced two OTP and C values but you can use either one just fine.
#!/usr/bin/python3
import sys
from util import bytes_to_long
from gmpy2 import iroot
PREFIX = b'*************** Welcome, dear customer, the secret passphrase for today is: '
OTPbase = bytes_to_long(PREFIX + b'\x00' * 18)
N = 27990886688403106156886965929373472780889297823794580465068327683395428917362065615739951108259750066435069668684573174325731274170995250924795407965212988361462373732974161447634230854196410219114860784487233470335168426228481911440564783725621653286383831270780196463991259147093068328414348781344702123357674899863389442417020336086993549312395661361400479571900883022046732515264355119081391467082453786314312161949246102368333523674765325492285740191982756488086280405915565444751334123879989607088707099191056578977164106743480580290273650405587226976754077483115441525080890390557890622557458363028198676980513
WRAPPINGS = (OTPbase ** 3) // N
C = 13094996712007124344470117620331768168185106904388859938604066108465461324834973803666594501350900379061600358157727804618756203188081640756273094533547432660678049428176040512041763322083599542634138737945137753879630587019478835634179440093707008313841275705670232461560481682247853853414820158909864021171009368832781090330881410994954019971742796971725232022238997115648269445491368963695366241477101714073751712571563044945769609486276590337268791325927670563621008906770405196742606813034486998852494456372962791608053890663313231907163444106882221102735242733933067370757085585830451536661157788688695854436646
x = N * WRAPPINGS + C
val, _ = iroot(x, 3)
bstr = "%x" % int(val)
for i in range(0, len(bstr) // 2):
    sys.stdout.write(chr(int(bstr[2*i:2*i+2], 16)))
print()

Michael Stapelberg: manpages.debian.org: what s new since the launch?

On 2017-01-18, I announced that https://manpages.debian.org had been modernized. Let me catch you up on a few things which happened in the meantime: The list above is not complete, but rather a selection of things I found worth pointing out to the larger public. There are still a few things I plan to work on soon, so stay tuned :).

Matthew Garrett: A quick look at the Ikea Tr dfri lighting platform

Ikea recently launched their Tr dfri smart lighting platform in the US. The idea of Ikea plus internet security together at last seems like a pretty terrible one, but having taken a look it's surprisingly competent. Hardware-wise, the device is pretty minimal - it seems to be based on the Cypress[1] WICED IoT platform, with 100MBit ethernet and a Silicon Labs Zigbee chipset. It's running the Express Logic ThreadX RTOS, has no running services on any TCP ports and appears to listen on two single UDP ports. As IoT devices go, it's pleasingly minimal.

That single port seems to be a COAP server running with DTLS and a pre-shared key that's printed on the bottom of the device. When you start the app for the first time it prompts you to scan a QR code that's just a machine-readable version of that key. The Android app has code for using the insecure COAP port rather than the encrypted one, but the device doesn't respond to queries there so it's presumably disabled in release builds. It's also local only, with no cloud support. You can program timers, but they run on the device. The only other service it seems to run is an mdns responder, which responds to the _coap._udp.local query to allow for discovery.

From a security perspective, this is pretty close to ideal. Having no remote APIs means that security is limited to what's exposed locally. The local traffic is all encrypted. You can only authenticate with the device if you have physical access to read the (decently long) key off the bottom. I haven't checked whether the DTLS server is actually well-implemented, but it doesn't seem to respond unless you authenticate first which probably covers off a lot of potential risks. The SoC has wireless support, but it seems to be disabled - there's no antenna on board and no mechanism for configuring it.

However, there's one minor issue. On boot the device grabs the current time from pool.ntp.org (fine) but also hits http://fw.ota.homesmart.ikea.net/feed/version_info.json . That file contains a bunch of links to firmware updates, all of which are also downloaded over http (and not https). The firmware images themselves appear to be signed, but downloading untrusted objects and then parsing them isn't ideal. Realistically, this is only a problem if someone already has enough control over your network to mess with your DNS, and being wired-only makes this pretty unlikely. I'd be surprised if it's ever used as a real avenue of attack.

Overall: as far as design goes, this is one of the most secure IoT-style devices I've looked at. I haven't examined the COAP stack in detail to figure out whether it has any exploitable bugs, but the attack surface is pretty much as minimal as it could be while still retaining any functionality at all. I'm impressed.

[1] Formerly Broadcom

comment count unavailable comments

8 April 2017

Dirk Eddelbuettel: #4: Simpler shoulders()

Welcome to the fourth post in the repulsively random R ramblings series, or R4 for short. My twitter feed was buzzing about a nice (and as yet unpublished, ie not-on-CRAN) package thankr by Dirk Schumacher which compiles a list of packages (ordered by maintainer count) for your current session (or installation or ...) with a view towards saying thank you to those whose packages we rely upon. Very nice indeed. I had a quick look and run it twice ... and had a reaction of ewwww, really? as running it twice gave different results as on the second instance a boatload of tibblyverse packages appeared. Because apparently kids these day can only slice data that has been tidied or something. So I had another quick look ... and put together an alternative version using just base R (as there was only one subfunction that needed reworking):
source(file="https://raw.githubusercontent.com/dirkschumacher/thankr/master/R/shoulders.R")
format_pkg_df <- function(df)   # non-tibblyverse variant
    tb <- table(df[,2])
    od <- order(tb, decreasing=TRUE)
    ndf <- data.frame(maint=names(tb)[od], npkgs=as.integer(tb[od]))
    colpkgs <- function(m, df)   paste(df[ df$maintainer == m, "pkg_name"], collapse=",")  
    ndf[, "pkg"] <- sapply(ndf$maint, colpkgs, df)
    ndf
 
A nice side benefit is that the function is now free of external dependencies (besides, of course, base R). Running this in the ESS session I had open gives:
R> shoulders()  ## by Dirk Schumacher, with small modifications
                               maint npkgs                                                                 pkg
1 R Core Team <R-core@r-project.org>     9 compiler,graphics,tools,utils,grDevices,stats,datasets,methods,base
2 Dirk Eddelbuettel <edd@debian.org>     4                                  RcppTOML,Rcpp,RApiDatetime,anytime
3  Matt Dowle <mattjdowle@gmail.com>     1                                                          data.table
R> 
and for good measure a screenshot is below:
I think we need a catchy moniker for R work using good old base R. SoberVerse? GrumbyOldFolksR? PlainOldR? Better suggestions welcome. Edit on 2017-04-09: And by now Dirk Schumacher fixed that little bug in thankr which was at the start of this. His shoulders() function is now free of side effects, and thankr is now a clean micropackage free of external depends from any verse, be it tiddly or grumpy. I look forward to seeing it on CRAN soon!

This post by Dirk Eddelbuettel originated on his Thinking inside the box blog. Please report excessive re-aggregation in third-party for-profit settings.

7 April 2017

Arturo Borrero Gonz lez: openvpn deployment with Debian Stretch

Debian Openvpn Debian Stretch feels like an excellent release by the Debian project. The final stable release is about to happen in the short term. Among the great things you can do with Debian, you could set up a VPN using the openvpn software. In this blog post I will describe how I ve deployed myself an openvpn server using Debian Stretch, my network environment and my configurations & workflow. Before all, I would like to reference my requisites and the characteristics of what I needed: I agree this is a rather complex scenario and not all the people will face these requirements. The service diagram has this shape: VPN diagram (DIA source file) So, it works like this:
  1. clients connect via internet to our openvpn server, vpn.example.com
  2. the openvpn server validates the connection and the tunnel is established (green)
  3. now the client is virtually inside our network (blue)
  4. the client wants to access some intranet resource, the tunnel traffic is NATed (red)
Our datacenter intranet is using public IPv4 addressing, but the VPN tunnels use private IPv4 addresses. To don t mix public and private address NAT is used. Obviously we don t want to invest public IPv4 addresses in our internal tunnels. We don t have this limitations in IPv6, we could use public IPv6 addresses within the tunnels. But we prefer sticking to a hard dual stack IPv4/IPv6 approach and also use private IPv6 addresses inside the tunnels and also NAT the IPv6 from private to public. This way, there are no differences in how IPv4 and IPv6 network are managed. We follow this approach for the addressing: The NAT runs in the VPN server, since this is kind of a router. We use nftables for this task. As the final win, I will describe how we manage all this configuration using the git version control system. Using git we can track which admin made which change. A git hook will deploy the files from the git repo itself to /etc/ so the services can read them. The VPN server networking configuration is as follows (/etc/network/interfaces file, adjust to your network environments):
auto lo
iface lo inet loopback
# main public IPv4 address of vpn.example.com
allow-hotplug eth0
iface eth0 inet static
        address x.x.x.4
        netmask 255.255.255.0
        gateway x.x.x.1
# main public IPv6 address of vpn.example.com
iface eth0 inet6 static
        address x:x:x:x::4
        netmask 64
        gateway x:x:x:x::1
# NAT Public IPv4 addresses (used to NAT tunnel of client 1)
auto eth0:11
iface eth0:11 inet static
        address x.x.x.11
        netmask 255.255.255.0
# NAT Public IPv6 addresses (used to NAT tunnel of client 1)
iface eth0:11 inet6 static
        address x:x:x:x::11
        netmask 64
# NAT Public IPv4 addresses (used to NAT tunnel of client 2)
auto eth0:12
iface eth0:12 inet static
        address x.x.x.12
        netmask 255.255.255.0
# NAT Public IPv6 addresses (used to NAT tunnel of client 2)
iface eth0:12 inet6 static
        address x:x:x:x::12
        netmask 64
Thanks to the amazing and tireless work of the Alberto Gonzalez Iniesta (DD), the openvpn package in debian is in very good shape, ready to use. In vpn.example.com, install the required packages:
% sudo aptitude install openvpn openvpn-auth-ldap nftables git sudo
Two git repositories will be used, one for the openvpn configuration and another for nftables (the nftables config is described later):
% sudo mkdir -p /srv/git/vpn.example.com-nft.git
% sudo git init --bare /srv/git/vpn.example.com-nft.git
% sudo mkdir -p /srv/git/vpn.example.com-openvpn.git
% sudo git init --bare /srv/git/vpn.example.com-openvpn.git
% sudo chown -R :git /srv/git/*
% sudo chmod -R g+rw /srv/git/*
The repositories belong to the git group, a system group we create to let systems admins operate the server using git:
% sudo addgroup --system git
% sudo adduser admin1 git
% sudo adduser admin2 git
For the openvpn git repository, we need at least this git hook (file /srv/git/vpn.example.com-openvpn.git/hooks/post-receive with execution permission):
#!/bin/bash
NAME="hooks/post-receive"
OPENVPN_ROOT="/etc/openvpn"
export GIT_WORK_TREE="$OPENVPN_ROOT"
UNAME=$(uname -n)
info()
 
        echo "$ UNAME  $ NAME  $1 ..."
 
info "checkout latest data to $GIT_WORK_TREE"
sudo git checkout -f
info "cleaning untracked files and dirs at $GIT_WORK_TREE"
sudo git clean -f -d
For this hook to work, sudo permissions are required (file /etc/sudoers.d/openvpn-git):
User_Alias      OPERATORS = admin1, admin2
Defaults        env_keep += "GIT_WORK_TREE"
 
OPERATORS       ALL=(ALL) NOPASSWD:/usr/bin/git checkout -f
OPERATORS       ALL=(ALL) NOPASSWD:/usr/bin/git clean -f -d
Please review this sudoers file to match your environment and security requirements. The openvpn package deploys several systemd services:
% dpkg -L openvpn   grep service
/lib/systemd/system/openvpn-client@.service
/lib/systemd/system/openvpn-server@.service
/lib/systemd/system/openvpn.service
/lib/systemd/system/openvpn@.service
We don t need all of them, we can use the simple openvpn.service:
% sudo systemctl edit --full openvpn.service
And put a content like this:
% systemctl cat openvpn.service
# /etc/systemd/system/openvpn.service
[Unit]
Description=OpenVPN server
Documentation=man:openvpn(8)
Documentation=https://community.openvpn.net/openvpn/wiki/Openvpn23ManPage
Documentation=https://community.openvpn.net/openvpn/wiki/HOWTO
 
[Service]
PrivateTmp=true
KillMode=mixed
Type=forking
ExecStart=/usr/sbin/openvpn --daemon ovpn --status /run/openvpn/%i.status 10 --cd /etc/openvpn --config /etc/openvpn/server.conf --writepid /run/openvpn/server.pid
PIDFile=/run/openvpn/server.pid
ExecReload=/bin/kill -HUP $MAINPID
WorkingDirectory=/etc/openvpn
ProtectSystem=yes
CapabilityBoundingSet=CAP_IPC_LOCK CAP_NET_ADMIN CAP_NET_BIND_SERVICE CAP_NET_RAW CAP_SETGID CAP_SETUID CAP_SYS_CHROOT CAP_DAC_READ_SEARCH CAP_AUDIT_WRITE
LimitNPROC=10
DeviceAllow=/dev/null rw
DeviceAllow=/dev/net/tun rw
 
[Install]
WantedBy=multi-user.target
We can move on now to configure nftables to perform the NATs. First, it s good to load the NAT configuration at boot time, so you need a service file like this (/etc/systemd/system/nftables.service):
[Unit]
Description=nftables
Documentation=man:nft(8) http://wiki.nftables.org
 
[Service]
Type=oneshot
RemainAfterExit=yes
StandardInput=null
ProtectSystem=full
ProtectHome=true
WorkingDirectory=/etc/nftables.d
ExecStart=/usr/sbin/nft -f ruleset.nft
ExecReload=/usr/sbin/nft -f ruleset.nft
ExecStop=/usr/sbin/nft flush ruleset
 
[Install]
WantedBy=multi-user.target
The nftables git hooks are implemented as described in nftables managed with git. We are interested in the git hooks: (file /srv/git/vpn.example.com-nft.git/hooks/post-receive):
#!/bin/bash
NAME="hooks/post-receive"
NFT_ROOT="/etc/nftables.d"
RULESET="$ NFT_ROOT /ruleset.nft"
export GIT_WORK_TREE="$NFT_ROOT"
UNAME=$(uname -n)
info()
 
        echo "$ UNAME  $ NAME  $1 ..."
 
info "checkout latest data to $GIT_WORK_TREE"
sudo git checkout -f
info "cleaning untracked files and dirs at $GIT_WORK_TREE"
sudo git clean -f -d
info "deploying new ruleset"
set -e
cd $NFT_ROOT && sudo nft -f $RULESET
info "new ruleset deployment was OK"
This hook moves our nftables configuration to /etc/nftables.d and then applies it to the kernel. So a single commit changes the runtime configuration of the server. You could implement some QA using the git hook update, check this file! Remember, git hooks requires exec permissions to work. Of course, you will need again a sudo policy for these nft hooks. Finally, we can start configuring both openvpn and nftables using git. For the VPN you will require the configure the PKI side: server certificates, and the CA signing your client s certificates. You can check openvpn s own documentation about this. Your first commit for openvpn could be the server.conf file:
plugin		/usr/lib/openvpn/openvpn-plugin-auth-pam.so common-auth
mode		server
user		nobody
group		nogroup
port		1194
proto		udp6
daemon
comp-lzo
persist-key
persist-tun
tls-server
cert		/etc/ssl/private/vpn.example.com_pub.crt
key		/etc/ssl/private/vpn.example.com_priv.pem
ca		/etc/ssl/cacert/clients_ca.pem
dh		/etc/ssl/certs/dh2048.pem
cipher		AES-128-CBC
dev		tun
topology	subnet
server		192.168.100.0 255.255.255.0
server-ipv6	fd00:0:1:35::/64
ccd-exclusive
client-config-dir ccd
max-clients	100
inactive	43200
keepalive	10 360
log-append	/var/log/openvpn.log
status		/var/log/openvpn-status.log
status-version	1
verb		4
mute		20
Don t forget the ccd/ directory. This directory contains a file per user using the VPN service. Each file is named after the CN of the client certificate:
# private addresses for client 1
ifconfig-push		192.168.100.11 255.255.255.0
ifconfig-ipv6-push	fd00:0:1::11/64
# routes to the intranet network
push "route-ipv6 x:x:x:x::/64"
push "route x.x.3.128 255.255.255.240"
# private addresses for client 2
ifconfig-push		192.168.100.12 255.255.255.0
ifconfig-ipv6-push	fd00:0:1::12/64
# routes to the intranet network
push "route-ipv6 x:x:x:x::/64"
push "route x.x.3.128 255.255.255.240"
You end with at leats these files in the openvpn git tree:
server.conf
ccd/CN=CLIENT_1
ccd/CN=CLIENT_2
Please note that if you commit a change to ccd/, the changes are read at runtime by openvpn. In the other hand, changes to server.conf require you to restart the openvpn service by hand. Remember, the addressing is like this: Addressing (DIA source file) In the nftables git tree, you should put a ruleset like this (a single file named ruleset.nft is valid):
flush ruleset
table ip nat  
	map mapping_ipv4_snat  
		type ipv4_addr : ipv4_addr
		elements =  	192.168.100.11 : x.x.x.11,
				192.168.100.12 : x.x.x.12  
	 
	map mapping_ipv4_dnat  
		type ipv4_addr : ipv4_addr
		elements =  	x.x.x.11 : 192.168.100.11,
				x.x.x.12 : 192.168.100.12  
	 
	chain prerouting  
		type nat hook prerouting priority -100; policy accept;
		dnat to ip daddr map @mapping_ipv4_dnat
	 
	chain postrouting  
		type nat hook postrouting priority 100; policy accept;
		oifname "eth0" snat to ip saddr map @mapping_ipv4_snat
	 
 
table ip6 nat  
	map mapping_ipv6_snat  
		type ipv6_addr : ipv6_addr
		elements =  	fd00:0:1::11 : x:x:x::11,
				fd00:0:1::12 : x:x:x::12  
	 
	map mapping_ipv6_dnat  
		type ipv6_addr : ipv6_addr
		elements =  	x:x:x::11 : fd00:0:1::11,
				x:x:x::12 : fd00:0:1::12  
	 
	chain prerouting  
		type nat hook prerouting priority -100; policy accept;
		dnat to ip6 daddr map @mapping_ipv6_dnat
	 
	chain postrouting  
		type nat hook postrouting priority 100; policy accept;
		oifname "eth0" snat to ip6 saddr map @mapping_ipv6_snat
	 
 
table inet filter  
	chain forward  
		type filter hook forward priority 0; policy accept;
		# some forwarding filtering policy, if required, for both IPv4 and IPv6
	 
 
Since the server is in fact routing packets between the tunnel and the public network, we require forwarding enabled in sysctl:
net.ipv4.conf.all.forwarding = 1
net.ipv6.conf.all.forwarding = 1
Of course, the VPN clients will require a client.conf file which looks like this:
client
remote vpn.example.com 1194
dev tun
proto udp
resolv-retry infinite
comp-lzo
verb 5
nobind
persist-key
persist-tun
user nobody
group nogroup
 
tls-client
ca      /etc/ssl/cacert/server_ca.crt
pkcs12  /home/user/mycertificate.p12
verify-x509-name vpn.example.com name
cipher AES-128-CBC
auth-user-pass
auth-nocache
Workflow for the system admins:
  1. git clone the openvpn repo
  2. modify ccd/ and server.conf
  3. git commit the changes, push to the server
  4. if server.conf was modified, restart openvpn
  5. git clone the nftables repo
  6. modify ruleset
  7. git commit the changes, push to the server
Comments via email welcome!

Dirk Eddelbuettel: #3: Follow R-devel

Welcome to the third post in the rarely relevant R recommendation series, or R4 for short. Today will be brief, but of some importance. In order to know where R is going next, few places provide a better vantage point than the actual ongoing development. A few years ago, I mentioned to Duncan Murdoch how straightforward the setup of my CRANberries feed (and site) was. After all, static blog compilers converting textual input to html, rss feed and whatnot have been around for fifteen years (though they keep getting reinvented). He took this to heart and built the (not too pretty) R-devel daily site (which also uses a fancy diff tool as it shows changes in NEWS) as well as a more general description of all available sub-feeds. I follow this mostly through blog aggregations -- Google Reader in its day, now Feedly. A screenshot is below just to show that it doesn't have to be ugly just because it is on them intertubes:
This shows a particularly useful day when R-devel folded into the new branch for what will be the R 3.4.0 release come April 21. The list of upcoming changes is truly impressive and quite comprehensive -- and the package registration helper, focus of posts #1 and #2 here, is but one of these many changes. One function I learned about that day is tools::CRAN_package_db(), a helper to get a single (large) data.frame with all package DESCRIPTION information. Very handy. Others may have noticed that CRAN repos now have a new top-level file PACKAGES.rds and this function does indeed just fetch it--which you could do with a similar one-liner in R-release as well. Still very handy. But do read about changes in R-devel and hence upcoming changes in R 3.4.0. Lots of good things coming our way.

This post by Dirk Eddelbuettel originated on his Thinking inside the box blog. Please report excessive re-aggregation in third-party for-profit settings.

Norbert Preining: Stella Stejskal Im Mezzanin

A book about being woman, mother in a modern but still traditional society. About happiness and fulfillment, love and sex, responsibility and dependency, about life: Stella Stejskal s Im Mezzanin (in German).
Written by a friend back from my old times in Vienna, Stella Stejskal, like me an emigrant, I saw parts of this book during writing, and I was happy to see the final product and read it. The first novel of Stella turns around Anna, the protagonist, a wife, mother, and woman, trying to find her balance between the house, family, kids, work, and her incredible power and thrive to live, live to the fullest.
Dein Leben in der Vorstadt, im Einfamilienhaus mit dem Garten, macht Dich nicht gl cklich. Vordergr ndig hast Du alles, was eine Frau sich w nscht und doch fehlt Dir etwas Wesentliches: Verlangen und Leidenschaft.
(Your life in the suburb, in the one-family home with garden, it doesn t make you happy. On the surface you do have everything what a woman could wish for, but you are missing something essential: desire and passion) The author does not shy away from explicit language without ever dropping into the Vernacolo, the banalities. She manages to convey the incredible tension many of those being stretched out between the necessities of daily life and the need for a more personal life. Last but not least, I loved this book for quoting one of my most favorite lines from a song:
Konstantin Weckers Was passiert in den Jahren, drangen leise durch den Raum. Komm, wir gehen mit der Flut und verwandeln mit den Wellen unsere Angst in neuen Mut , sang ich mit und dachte an den Sommer
For those capable of German, very recommendable.

6 April 2017

Reproducible builds folks: Reproducible Builds: week 101 in Stretch cycle

Here's what happened in the Reproducible Builds effort between Sunday March 26 and Saturday April 1 2017: Media coverage Sylvain Beucler wrote a follow-up post Practical basics of reproducible builds 2, which like last weeks article is about his experiences making software build reproducibly. Reproducible work in other projects Colin Watson started writing a patch to make launchpad store .buildinfo files. (It's not yet deployed.) Toolchain development and fixes Ximin Luo continued to work on BUILD_PATH_PREFIX_MAP patches for GCC 6 and dpkg. Packages reviewed and fixed, and bugs filed Chris Lamb: Mattia Rizzolo: Reviews of unreproducible packages 49 package reviews have been added, 25 have been updated and 42 have been removed in this week, adding to our knowledge about identified issues. 1 issue type has been updated: Weekly QA work During our reproducibility testing, FTBFS bugs have been detected and reported by: diffoscope development diffoscope 81 was uploaded to experimental by Chris Lamb. It included contributions from: reprotest development reprotest development continued in git, including contributions from: buildinfo.debian.net development buildinfo.debian.net development continued in git, including contributions from: reproducible-website development Holger switched reproducible-builds.org and www.reproducible-builds.org to letsencrypt certificates. Misc. This week's edition was written by Ximin Luo and Holger Levsen & reviewed by a bunch of Reproducible Builds folks on IRC & the mailing lists.

Norbert Preining: Planet Earth I From Pole to Pole

In preparation for watching the new Planet Earth II (BBC page, Wiki) by David Attenborough, I re-watched the original 2006 BBC Planet Earth, episode one, From Pole to Pole, fortunately it is now available on Netflix. I have forgotten how great it is. I was moved to tears. This is now 10 years old but still top of the technique, even compared to the new Cosmos series. The nature shots, often in slow motion, give spectacular views onto animals hardly seen in this way. Here is a male Superb bird of paradise posing in front of a female, making a very strange impression (bad screenshot, sorry). White sharks are dangerous, we all know, but did you know that they can actually fly? Well, not actually fly, but they can jump as far as completely leaving the sea: The first episode finishes in the Okavango Delta with elephants bathing in the sea. Here is a young club dancing under water. Deeply impressed, deeply moved. In light of anti-environmental anti-climate-change anti-intelligence comedian at the White House, more of us should actually see these great pieces of journalism, let it influence our thinking, and hopefully vote differently when it is our turn again.

5 April 2017

Steinar H. Gunderson: Nageru 1.5.0 released

I just released version 1.5.0 of Nageru, my live video mixer. The biggest feature is obviously the HDMI/SDI live output, but there are lots of small nuggets everywhere; it's been four months in the making. I'll simply paste the NEWS entry here:
Nageru 1.5.0, April 5th, 2017
  - Support for low-latency HDMI/SDI output in addition to (or instead of) the
    stream. This currently only works with DeckLink cards, not bmusb. See the
    manual for more information.
  - Support changing the resolution from the command line, instead of locking
    everything to 1280x720.
  - The A/V sync code has been rewritten to be more in line with Fons
    Adriaensen's original paper. It handles several cases much better,
    in particular when trying to match 59.94 and 60 Hz sources to each other.
    However, it might occasionally need a few extra seconds on startup to
    lock properly if startup is slow.
  - Add support for using x264 for the disk recording. This makes it possible,
    among other things, to run Nageru on a machine entirely without VA-API
    support.
  - Support for 10-bit Y'CbCr, both on input and output. (Output requires
    x264 disk recording, as Quick Sync Video does not support 10-bit H.264.)
    This requires compute shader support, and is in general a little bit
    slower on input and output, due to the extra amount of data being shuffled
    around. Intermediate precision is 16-bit floating-point or better,
    as before.
  - Enable input mode autodetection for DeckLink cards that support it.
    (bmusb mode has always been autodetected.)
  - Add functionality to add a time code to the stream; useful for debugging
    latency.
  - The live display is now both more performant and of higher image quality.
  - Fix a long-standing issue where the preview displays would be too bright
    when using an NVIDIA GPU. (This did not affect the finished stream.)
  - Many other bugfixes and small improvements.
1.5.0 is on its way into Debian experimental (it's too late for the stretch release, especially as it also depends on Movit and bmusb from experimental), or you can get it from the home page as always.

Jonathan Carter: GNOME Shell Extensions in Debian 9.0

About GNOME 3 introduced an extensions framework that allows its users to extend the desktop shell by writing extensions using JavaScript and CSS. It works quite well and dozens of extensions have already been uploaded to the extensions site. Some of these solve some annoyances that users typically share with GNOME, while others add useful functionality. During DebCamp last year, I started packaging some of these for Debian. That s been going really well. Now that Ubuntu is finally dropping Unity in favour of GNOME, it helps to serve as a nudge to get this blog post out that s been stuck in drafts. These extensions also make their way into Ubuntu and other Debian/Ubuntu derivatives. Here are some extensions I ve been packaging that s already in the archive: gnome-shell-extension-dashtodock Provides a multitude of options for the shell dock. Not only really useful but also well maintained by upstream, see their website for more info. This is a great extension if you support previous Unity users, since you can set your panel to look and behave very similarly to Unity. I think the app launcher is slightly better in Gnome because apps are easier to discover. gnome-shell-extension-hide-activities Simple extension that hides the Activities button from the top left corner. gnome-shell-extension-impatience Speeds up shell animations. Animations can make the system more usable, but it can also be either distracting or cause some slight delays while waiting for the animation to complete. This gives you a sliding scale that lets you choose how much you d like to speed it up. gnome-shell-extension-move-clock Simple extension that moves the clock from the center of the panel to the right. gnome-shell-extension-refreshwifi In gnome-shell, network manager doesn t automatically refresh the list of available network, which can be quite annoying. Currently a user has to turn wifi off and back on in order to see a refreshed list. This has been fixed upstream and will be in the next version of GNOME. In the meantime, this extension fixes that. Update: Refreshing wifi in the background has been fixed in Gnome 3.22.2, which is now in stretch. This extension will be removed from the archives. gnome-shell-extension-remove-dropdown-arrows Items in the top panel contain dropdown arrows, which are useful for new users who might not be aware that they expand into more entries. For more experience users, the arrows tend to result in extra clutter in the panel, this extension hides those arrows. gnome-shell-extension-better-volume This allows you to hover over the volume control indicator and scroll up and down to increase/decrease the volume. Probably another extension that should really just be integrated into gnome-shell by default. gnome-shell-extension-hard-disk-led Many new laptops either don t have a hard disk L.E.D. anymore, or they hide it so that it s not really all that visible. This extension shows you hard disk activity in your panel. There s also work being done to make it report reads and writes separately. I ll be looking at backporting that when it s available. gnome-shell-extension-disconnect-wifi Allows you to disconnect from the current network without having to turn off wi-fi entirely. gnome-shell-extension-pixelsaver Title bars can be incredibly pixel-hungry, which isn t great on small displays. This extension hides the title bar when a window is maximised, and adds control buttons for that window to the top panel. gnome-shell-extension-system-monitor gnome-shell-extension-trash Displays a trash icon to the top panel when there are items in trash. From there you can view or delete the trash contents. gnome-shell-extension-multi-monitors This extension adds some tweaks for users of multiple monitors. It s most useful feature is that you can have desktop overviews on both displays and easily move apps between them. More extensions Here are some more extensions packaged in Debian that others have packaged: Didn t make it this time Both Debian and Ubuntu are in feature freeze right now, and the following didn t make it in the archives in time, but should be in the following releases (they re still installable via the extensions site in the meantime): Next steps Consider auto-enable Currently, when you install these debian packages, (most of) the extensions won t be enabled by default. Users have to use the gnome-tweak-tool to enable them after installation. The rationale behind this is that a system administrator of a network of computers might only want to enable certain extensions for certain users. After some more consideration, I think such administrators will probably already have a system (like a configuration management system) in place to manage this. So, to make it easier for the typical user, I think it s worth considering enabling these by default with installation. Feedback welcome :) Debian team The list of packaged extensions are growing fast, and it would be nice to have these team-maintained. It might be a good idea to start a team for this or use an existing team under the Debian gnome team namespace. Packaging guide I ve packaged enough Gnome extensions to be aware of the typical gotchas and things that need fixing. They re overall easy to package and a good place to start for someone who wants to get into packaging. I want to put together a good short guide on how to properly package gnome-shell extensions. Anything else? Any other extensions you d like to see packaged? Let me know. Even better, package it yourself and help test my extension package guide (once it exists) so that we can improve that too.

Next.

Previous.