This has been several months since I didn t use much my laptop, an Asus S5N: it was crippled by a short battery life and was hit by several bugs, most of them targeting the i855GME graphic chipset thanks to the use of GEM and KMS in the latest Xorg. I did not want to invest too much in a laptop and I have found a rebate from Lenovo for Thinkpad Edge series. Voil , I have a Thinkpad Edge 11 .

Hardware Thinkpad Edge is a entry-level notebook from Lenovo. In France, it is available for around 500 , thanks to the usual parity between dollar and euro.

Hardware configuration Lenovo do not sell directly in France. Therefore, you cannot configure your laptop as you want. There is two or three configurations available. This can be a bit frustrating if you want something specific. Here is the configuration that I bought:

• Intel Core i3 380UM at 1.33 GHz CPU.
• 11.6 LED screen, with a resolution of 1366x768.
• 4 GB RAM.
• 320 GB hard drive.
• Wireless network (Centrino Wireless-N) and bluetooth.
• Broadband modem (WWAN)

It s a small laptop but it is not as light as it should be (1.5 kg or 3.3 pounds). Apart from the power supply, you don t get any extra. My Asus was shipped with a wireless mouse, a transport bag, a sleeve, an USB key and a CD burner. On one side, you get two USB ports and on the other side, one USB port, an HDMI port, a network outlet and a speaker jack. The VGA connector is placed on the rear.

BIOS First step: checking BIOS settings. WiMAX can be disabled as well as any other component that you may not need. The keyboard can be configured so that function keys are available directly instead of having to use the Fn key. There is an option called Computrace from AbsoluteSoftware which seems targeted at find back your laptop in case it gets stolen or just let the FBI know where you are. I have disabled it.

Debian installation Debian can be installed from an USB stick. This is really easy now. You grab the ISO image you want to use (I take the one for AMD64 in testing because I will run unstable) and to copy it on the USB stick:

1	# dd if=debian-testing-amd64-netinst.iso of=/dev/sdb

The previous way of making the USB stick bootable, installing a kernel, an initrd and the ISO image is deprecated (and does not work). Moreover, using testing to install Debian allows me to use a 2.6.37 kernel and circumvent some problems that may have happen with an older kernel. During the installation, I choose a guided partitioning using encrypted LVM. I choose to have several partitions but I keep /usr in the root partition since having a separate /usr is less and less supported, especially with piece of software like udev. The partitioning tool in Debian installer do not allow to resize volumes, you need to destroy them and recreate them as well as their content. However, this is still faster than writing a patch for this. When the installation is finished, the laptop boots on a 2.6.38 kernel, asks for the passphrase to decrypt the LUKS volume and display the login prompt a few seconds later.

Software configuration Most of the hardware seems to be supported. No obscure commands to run to get a working network. Therefore, I start by setting up my usual environment.

Setting up the desktop First, I change /etc/apt/sources.list to get unstable:

deb http://ftp.fr.debian.org/debian/ unstable main
deb-src http://ftp.fr.debian.org/debian/ unstable main
deb http://ftp.fr.debian.org/debian/ experimental main contrib non-free

I also want that everything that is installed from experimental to be upgraded if an update is available in experimental. This is done by creating a file /etc/apt/preferences.d/experimental:

Package: *
Pin: release experimental
Pin-Priority: 101

Then, I install the following packages:

• zsh, my favourite shell with my hand-made maturating configuration. I should put it on GitHub one day.
• mg, is the editor that I use to quickly edit a configuration file. I don t like vi. I have used jed for a long time but its default configuration can be cumbersome and it misses some emacs keybinding.
• emacs, my work environment. I use it as a text editor and mail reader (with Gnus). I don t use it as a browser nor as a terminal. As for zsh, I have my configuration files ready to be copied anywhere.
• fvwm, my window manager since quite some time. I use fvwm-crystal on top of it. My configuration is described in another post. I also use conky.
• rxvt-unicode, a terminal. It has a very good terminal emulation and some fancy features like transparency (using compositing or not). It is light and fast and allows to search in the backbuffer. It can use a client/server system that will close all your windows when the server crashes. This almost never happens.
• unison, a synchronisation tool that allows me to keep the same files on my different computers.
• gdm3 is the only display manager that is able to talk correctly to ConsoleKit and get the rights set correctly without adding yourself to a lot of groups.

Nowadays, I use the kernel from Debian and I do not have to run my own configuration for it. The glory days where I had to recompile the kernel before plugging a new USB toy have passed. I remove rpcbind and nfs-common. I use ferm to setup a simple firewall. Here is my ferm.conf:

domain (ip ip6)  
  table filter  
chain INPUT  
    policy DROP;
    mod state state INVALID DROP;
    mod state state (ESTABLISHED RELATED) ACCEPT;
    interface lo ACCEPT;
    proto tcp dport ssh ACCEPT;
    
chain OUTPUT  
    policy ACCEPT;
    mod state state (ESTABLISHED RELATED) ACCEPT;
    
chain FORWARD  
    policy DROP;
    
     
 

unison will then sync my configuration files and my documents. After this step, my environment is ready.

Hardware configuration This is usually the most troublesome part. However, looking at the output of lspci and lsusb, everything seems pretty easy to get supported. Here is lspci output:

00:00.0 Host bridge: Intel Corporation Core Processor DRAM Controller (rev 02)
00:02.0 VGA compatible controller: Intel Corporation Core Processor Integrated Graphics Controller (rev 02)
00:16.0 Communication controller: Intel Corporation 5 Series/3400 Series Chipset HECI Controller (rev 06)
00:1a.0 USB Controller: Intel Corporation 5 Series/3400 Series Chipset USB2 Enhanced Host Controller (rev 06)
00:1b.0 Audio device: Intel Corporation 5 Series/3400 Series Chipset High Definition Audio (rev 06)
00:1c.0 PCI bridge: Intel Corporation 5 Series/3400 Series Chipset PCI Express Root Port 1 (rev 06)
00:1c.1 PCI bridge: Intel Corporation 5 Series/3400 Series Chipset PCI Express Root Port 2 (rev 06)
00:1c.5 PCI bridge: Intel Corporation 5 Series/3400 Series Chipset PCI Express Root Port 6 (rev 06)
00:1d.0 USB Controller: Intel Corporation 5 Series/3400 Series Chipset USB2 Enhanced Host Controller (rev 06)
00:1e.0 PCI bridge: Intel Corporation 82801 Mobile PCI Bridge (rev a6)
00:1f.0 ISA bridge: Intel Corporation Mobile 5 Series Chipset LPC Interface Controller (rev 06)
00:1f.2 SATA controller: Intel Corporation 5 Series/3400 Series Chipset 4 port SATA AHCI Controller (rev 06)
00:1f.3 SMBus: Intel Corporation 5 Series/3400 Series Chipset SMBus Controller (rev 06)
00:1f.6 Signal processing controller: Intel Corporation 5 Series/3400 Series Chipset Thermal Subsystem (rev 06)
03:00.0 Network controller: Intel Corporation Centrino Wireless-N 1000
09:00.0 Ethernet controller: Realtek Semiconductor Co., Ltd. RTL8111/8168B PCI Express Gigabit Ethernet controller (rev 03)
ff:00.0 Host bridge: Intel Corporation Core Processor QuickPath Architecture Generic Non-core Registers (rev 02)
ff:00.1 Host bridge: Intel Corporation Core Processor QuickPath Architecture System Address Decoder (rev 02)
ff:02.0 Host bridge: Intel Corporation Core Processor QPI Link 0 (rev 02)
ff:02.1 Host bridge: Intel Corporation Core Processor QPI Physical 0 (rev 02)
ff:02.2 Host bridge: Intel Corporation Core Processor Reserved (rev 02)
ff:02.3 Host bridge: Intel Corporation Core Processor Reserved (rev 02)

And lsusb output (I disabled the broadband modem in the BIOS and therefore, it does not appear here):

Bus 001 Device 001: ID 1d6b:0002 Linux Foundation 2.0 root hub
Bus 002 Device 001: ID 1d6b:0002 Linux Foundation 2.0 root hub
Bus 001 Device 002: ID 8087:0020 Intel Corp. Integrated Rate Matching Hub
Bus 002 Device 002: ID 8087:0020 Intel Corp. Integrated Rate Matching Hub
Bus 001 Device 003: ID 0bda:0158 Realtek Semiconductor Corp. USB 2.0 multicard reader
Bus 001 Device 004: ID 0a5c:217f Broadcom Corp. Bluetooth Controller
Bus 002 Device 003: ID 5986:01a7 Acer, Inc Lenovo Integrated Webcam

There is a dedicated page for the Thinkpad Edge 11 on ThinkWiki. This wiki is one of the best source of information when you get a Thinkpad. The kernel as shipped by Debian kernel team contains every module that you may need. One of them, thinkpad_acpi will handle most of the perks under the hood. I do not use a complete desktop like Gnome. I usually prefer to use command line tools and put them in .xsession for persistence. There is usually some graphical utility to do the same thing. There are however some configuration steps that are now far easier to do with a graphical tool. Since I use X all the time, I just rely on those tools when necessary.

BIOS upgrade From lshw output, I see that I already have the latest BIOS available. No need to update then. In case you need to update, yours, ThinkWiki has a documentation to upgrade. You can find memdisk image in syslinux package.

Graphic card The graphic card is integrated into the CPU. Intel usually ships graphic cards well supported by open source drivers. ThinkWiki tells us:

A very recent Linux distribution with kernel 2.6.33 and Intel Xorg driver 2.11 or newer is recommended. Note that XVideo (Xv) playback at certain frame sizes does not work properly unless you have at least version 2.12 of the Intel Xorg driver.

With Debian Wheezy, you get version 2.15. Therefore, configuring the graphic card is just a matter of installing xserver-xorg-video-intel and that s all. No /etc/X11/xorg.conf needed. HDMI and VGA outputs are detected without configuring anything. They can be enabled with xrandr. I did not try if it was possible to use both of them at the same time.

Screen 0: minimum 320 x 200, current 1366 x 768, maximum 8192 x 8192
LVDS1 connected 1366x768+0+0 (normal left inverted right x axis y axis) 256mm x 144mm
   1366x768       60.0*+   50.0  
   1360x768       59.8     60.0  
   1024x768       60.0  
   800x600        60.3     56.2  
   640x480        59.9  
VGA1 disconnected (normal left inverted right x axis y axis)
HDMI1 disconnected (normal left inverted right x axis y axis)
DP1 disconnected (normal left inverted right x axis y axis)

Compositing works without any problem. I use only transparency and therefore, I don t know what the speed is on a desktop with all effects turned on. Regarding video acceleration, XVideo is supported but the graphic card also features hardware decoding with i965-va-driver package. Here is the output of vainfo:

libva: libva version 0.32.0
libva: va_getDriverName() returns 0
libva: Trying to open /usr/lib/dri/i965_drv_video.so
libva: va_openDriver() returns 0
vainfo: VA API version: 0.32
vainfo: Driver version: i965 Driver 0.1
vainfo: Supported profile and entrypoints
  VAProfileMPEG2Simple            : VAEntrypointVLD
  VAProfileMPEG2Main              : VAEntrypointVLD
  VAProfileH264Baseline           : VAEntrypointVLD
  VAProfileH264Main               : VAEntrypointVLD
  VAProfileH264High               : VAEntrypointVLD

With Debian, VLC can make use of this if you put ffmpeg-hw=1 in your ~/.config/vlc/vlcrc. We are then greeted by this:

[0x2629040] avcodec decoder: Using VA API version 0.32 for hardware decoding.

Network The network card works out of the box. ThinkWiki tells us that there can be stability problems with 2.6.36 kernel. During the installation, a 2.6.37 was used without any problem. I am now running a 2.6.38 and never got a glitch. It is likely that the described problem was solved with 2.6.37.

UltraNav UltraNav is the combination of the usual touchpad and the trackpoint which is a small joystick in the center of the keyboard and is well known to Thinkpad users since most of them have one. The trackpoint is a great input device. Nowadays, all input devices are configured with the help of xinput command. Here is the output of xinput list:

  Virtual core pointer                      id=2    [master pointer  (3)]
      Virtual core XTEST pointer                id=4    [slave  pointer  (2)]
      SynPS/2 Synaptics TouchPad                id=11   [slave  pointer  (2)]
      TPPS/2 IBM TrackPoint                     id=12   [slave  pointer  (2)]
  Virtual core keyboard                     id=3    [master keyboard (2)]
  Virtual core XTEST keyboard               id=5    [slave  keyboard (3)]
  Power Button                              id=6    [slave  keyboard (3)]
  Video Bus                                 id=7    [slave  keyboard (3)]
  Power Button                              id=8    [slave  keyboard (3)]
  Integrated Camera                         id=9    [slave  keyboard (3)]
  AT Translated Set 2 keyboard              id=10   [slave  keyboard (3)]
  ThinkPad Extra Buttons                    id=13   [slave  keyboard (3)]

The command xinput list-props will give you additional information on each input device listed above. You can then configure any settings using xinput set-prop. For example, if you want to enable scrolling by using the edges of the touchpad and enable palm detection, you can use the following commands:

1 2	$ xinput set-int-prop "SynPS/2 Synaptics TouchPad" 'Synaptics Edge Scrolling' 8 1 1 0 $ xinput set-int-prop "SynPS/2 Synaptics TouchPad" 'Synaptics Palm Detection' 8 1

If you want to disable the touchpad and only use the trackpoint, use the following command:

1	$ xinput set-int-prop "SynPS/2 Synaptics TouchPad" 'Synaptics Off' 8 1

Each property has a type and a size. There is no place for guessing since every property is listed in man 4 synaptics. The same applies for the trackpoint but the correct manual page is man 4 evdev. For example, if you want to enable scrolling using the middle button, use:

1 2	$ xinput set-int-prop "TPPS/2 IBM TrackPoint" "Evdev Wheel Emulation" 8 1 $ xinput set-int-prop "TPPS/2 IBM TrackPoint" "Evdev Wheel Emulation Button" 8 2

All those commands can be tossed in ~/.xsession.

Keyboard hot keys Thinkpad laptops usually have a lot of hot keys. This is not the case of the Thinkpad Edge which only features a few of them:

• volume control
• brightness control
• webcam and external screen toggle
• wireless toggle
• multimedia keys

All those keys trigger an event in one of the keyboard listed in xinput list. Therefore, your window manager or any other application can intercept them and act upon. You can use evtest to check which key triggers which event on which keyboard. The acpid daemon listen on those keyboards and can also trigger some actions. For example, it will run ibm-wireless.sh when you hit the wireless toggle. By default, this will enable or disable your wireless card. But you can configure the script to use a multistate toggle and disable or enable the bluetooth card as well.

Sound card As for the network card, the sound card works out of the box. I use PulseAudio because it allows per-application volume control and per-application sound card selection. It comes handy if you have some bluetooth headset. To make PulseAudio the default application for most applications, I put this in my ~/.asoundrc:

pcm.!default  
  type pulse
 
ctl.!default  
  type pulse
 

Wireless card A firmware is needed to make this card work. On Debian, you need to install firmware-iwlwifi package. Then, iwlagn module needs to be loaded. You can check with rfkill list that the wireless card has not been disabled. iw list will then give the status:

Wiphy phy0
Band 1:
    Capabilities: 0x872
        HT20/HT40
        Static SM Power Save
        RX Greenfield
        RX HT20 SGI
        RX HT40 SGI
        No RX STBC
        Max AMSDU length: 3839 bytes
        No DSSS/CCK HT40
    Maximum RX AMPDU length 65535 bytes (exponent: 0x003)
    Minimum RX AMPDU time spacing: 4 usec (0x05)
    HT RX MCS rate indexes supported: 0-15, 32
    TX unequal modulation not supported
    HT TX Max spatial streams: 1
    HT TX MCS rate indexes supported may differ
    Frequencies:
        * 2412 MHz [1] (14.0 dBm)
        * 2417 MHz [2] (14.0 dBm)
        * 2422 MHz [3] (14.0 dBm)
        * 2427 MHz [4] (14.0 dBm)
        * 2432 MHz [5] (14.0 dBm)
        * 2437 MHz [6] (14.0 dBm)
        * 2442 MHz [7] (14.0 dBm)
        * 2447 MHz [8] (14.0 dBm)
        * 2452 MHz [9] (14.0 dBm)
        * 2457 MHz [10] (14.0 dBm)
        * 2462 MHz [11] (14.0 dBm)
        * 2467 MHz [12] (14.0 dBm) (passive scanning, no IBSS)
        * 2472 MHz [13] (14.0 dBm) (passive scanning, no IBSS)
    Bitrates (non-HT):
        * 1.0 Mbps
        * 2.0 Mbps (short preamble supported)
        * 5.5 Mbps (short preamble supported)
        * 11.0 Mbps (short preamble supported)
        * 6.0 Mbps
        * 9.0 Mbps
        * 12.0 Mbps
        * 18.0 Mbps
        * 24.0 Mbps
        * 36.0 Mbps
        * 48.0 Mbps
        * 54.0 Mbps
max # scan SSIDs: 20
Supported interface modes:
     * IBSS
     * managed
     * monitor

I don t know why, but 802.11a channels have been disabled. I don t have interest in them and therefore I did not search why this happens.

iwlagn 0000:03:00.0: Detected Intel(R) Centrino(R) Wireless-N 1000 BGN, REV=0x6C
iwlagn 0000:03:00.0: device EEPROM VER=0x15d, CALIB=0x6
iwlagn 0000:03:00.0: Device SKU: 0X9
iwlagn 0000:03:00.0: Valid Tx ant: 0X1, Valid Rx ant: 0X3
iwlagn 0000:03:00.0: Tunable channels: 13 802.11bg, 0 802.11a channels
iwlagn 0000:03:00.0: irq 44 for MSI/MSI-X
iwlagn 0000:03:00.0: loaded firmware version 128.50.3.1 build 13488

Wireless is one of the thing that make me use graphical applications like Network Manager. Command line tools are too low level to quickly connect to some random wireless network. There was a large debate in debian-devel@ldo to determine if Network Manager was ready to replace ifup and ifdown commands, even for servers. It seems that this is not something impossible and therefore, I think it has become flexible enough to ensure most of the configuration tasks I need.

Bluetooth The bluetooth chipset is hosted on the USB bus. hci_usb module will take care of it. It supports AD2P and can be used to listen to music with a compatible headset. hciconfig will tell us if the chipset is working. Again, bluetooth is easier to configure with a graphical tool. BlueZ, the bluetooth stack in Linux, uses DBus to communicate with other applications. The command line tools have been deprecated and therefore, you need to fight with some DBus binding to pair your computer to your headset. gnome-bluetooth package comes with an applet which allows you to quickly pair to any device. If you install pulseaudio-module-bluetooth package, any bluetooth headset should work out of the box.

Broadband (WWAN) To configure the broadband modem, the most difficult thing to do is to grab the appropriate firmware. ThinkWiki comes with various instructions to get it. I did not keep my Windows installation and therefore, I grabbed the Qualcomm Gobi 2000 Wireless WAN driver and I unpacked it with some Windows host with msiexec as instructed (I did have to execute the installation program first, otherwise, msiexec tells that the file is invalid). I choosed the default firmware since my laptop is unlocked. ThinkWiki page explains which firmware to choose in which situation. The package gobi-loader needs to be installed. The firmware files amss.mbn, apps.mbn and UQCN.mbn should be placed in /lib/firmware/gobi. They will be loaded by udev. To avoid to reboot, I used this command:

1	# /lib/udev/gobi_loader -2000 /dev/ttyUSB0 /lib/firmware/gobi

To configure the 3G connection, I just used Network Manager. Ensure with rfkill list that your WWAN card is not blocked. I did not test the GPS part that needs to be enabled on Windows.

Webcam Nowadays, USB webcam are UVC device and there is a driver to support this class of devices. Check that the uvcvideo module is correctly loaded and you should have something like this in your dmesg:

uvcvideo: Found UVC 1.00 device Integrated Camera (5986:01a7)

cheese is a small application that can be used to check if the webcam operates as expected.

Card reader Nothing to do. This works out of the box.

Suspend to memory and disk Install the uswsusp package which will also pull pm-utils. You will get pm-suspend and pm-hibernate commands. pm-suspend will enable suspend to memory. On resume, the system takes a whole minute to become operational. I get the following message:

r8169 0000:09:00.0: eth0: unable to apply firmware patch
PM: resume of devices complete after 60786.035 msecs
PM: Finishing wakeup.

Installing firmware-realtek package solves this issue. It should also be solved by a future kernel. I also have this message when I come back from sleep:

[drm:i915_hangcheck_ring_idle] *ERROR* Hangcheck timer elapsed... render ring idle [waiting on 9297, at 9297], missed IRQ?

The X server is then slow as hell. The message can be fixed by using i915.semaphores=1 as a kernel parameter but the X server is still slow. It seems that running powertop restores the original speed. This is a known problem. On sleep, the battery loses 2% every 6 hours. This allows you to keep your laptop on sleep for several days if needed. pm-hibernate enable suspend to disk. The suspend part works well but on resume, the kernel freezes after reading back the image into memory. There are some documentation to debug this problem but I prefer to wait for 2.6.39 which may just solves this issue.

Power management Let s see on how we could enhance battery life. First, cpufrequtils package will slow down the processor when it is not used by using the ondemand governor. The frequency will drop from 1.33 GHz to 666 MHz. Several tools are then available:

• pm-utils package comes with scripts to enable some powersaving features. Those scripts are run on ACPI events (for example, when you unplug the AC adapater). There is no way to put the laptop to sleep after two hours of inactivity for example. You need something like sleepd to handle this part. I have found nothing that could dim the screen on inactivity.
• laptop-mode-tools is also a set of script to be run on ACPI events. It is therefore somewhat superseded by pm-utils.
• gnome-power-manager is a daemon that makes use of upowerd. Despite its name, you can run it outside of the Gnome environment. It will put your laptop to sleep on inactivity and will dim the screen when needed. All other functionalities are handled to upowerd. This seems the way to go on today Linux desktops.

Behing the scene, upowerd will call at some point pm-powersave from pm-utils. This allows to run scripts when unplugging the AC adapter. There are some scripts shipped in /usr/lib/pm-utils/power.d. You can add your own in /etc/pm/power.d. Some scripts are configurable. For example, if you create /etc/pm/config.d/local and put SATA_ALPM_ENABLE=true in it, this will enable SATA ALPM mode on battery. You can check what needs to be done with powertop or go to a website like Less Watts to get some tips on what to configure to get a better battery life. Without adding any script, I get 5 hours of battery life with the laptop doing almost nothing. Lenovo tells that you should get 6 hours of battery life. I think that on moderate workloads, you should get 4 hours.

Conclusion This Lenovo Edge has a good value for money. It features a great keyboard for a laptop of its size. It could be lighter and thinner. Its battery life is pretty good. Almost everything works out of the box with GNU/Linux. I hope that 2.6.39 kernel will solve the remaining issues like the suspend on disk issue.

As previously announced in Ganneff s blog and Debian News, a special funding for DebConf11 is available for Debian Developers and Debian Maintainers who have either never attended a DebConf before, or who have not been to a DebConf since DebConf7 (in Scotland). How to apply Email the DebConf Newbies Team (newbies@debconf.org) providing the following information:

• estimate of your travel costs
• where you are traveling from
• amount you are unable to fund yourself
• dates you plan to arrive and leave
• if you have been to DebConf before
• if you will also need sponsored food and accommodation
• whether you have already registered for DebConf11 (if not - do so now!)

the DebConf team

Bug: never been to DebConf. Fix: DebConf newbies. Last year we have funded the DebConf newbies initiative to encourage Debian contributors who have never attended DebConf, to actually do so. There are plenty of reasons for doing that; as I wrote back then: My personal belief is that attending DebConf increases the enthusiasm of attendees and ultimately will make them better Debian citizens. It surely happened to me years ago: in the beginning of my Debian membership (as DD, since DMs did not exist back then) I just cared about my pet packages. It was only after meeting the Debian crowd in person at a FOSS event (LinuxTag 2004, IIRC) that I got really enthusiastic about Debian, gradually increasing my involvement in the project. I've never regretted it. This year, we are doing DebConf newbies again (see also Ganneff's blog post on the topic, for extra goodies). Deadline for applying (via newbies@debconf.org) is June 18th, although you should better register before May 19th to the conference proper to get sponsored accomodation.

---

Update: fix deadline date

Images Moved

So I've retired my old picture hosting sub-domain, and moved all the files which were hosted by the dynamic system into a large web-root. This means no more uploads are possible, but each link continues to work. For example:

• http://picshare.steve.org.uk/2OrKrfem9XQWz.jpg

Happily the system generated "random" links, and it was just a matter of moving each uploaded file into that static location, then removing the CGI application. The code for the new site has now been made public, although I suspect there will need to be some email-pong if anybody wishes to use it. Comments welcome.

MySQL replacements?

Lets pretend I work for a company which has dealings with many MySQL users. Lets pretend that, even though it is true, such that I don't have to get into specifics. Let us pretend that we have many many hundreds of users who are very happy with MySQL, but that we have a few users who have "issues". That might be:

• mysqld segfaulting every few months, with no real idea why.
  • Transactions are involved. So are stored proceedures.
  • MySQL paid support might have been perfect, or it might have lead to "yup, its a bug. good luck rebuilding with this patch. let us know how it turns out kthxbai."
  • Alternatively it might not have been re-producable.
• Master-Master and Master-Slave setups being "unreliable" such that data inconsistencies arise despite MySQL regarding them as being in sync.
  • Good luck resolving that when you have two almost-identical "mysqldump" outputs which are 6Gb each and which cause "diff" to exit with "out of memory" even on a 64Gb host.
  • Is it possible to view differences in table-data, via the binary records? That'd be a fun project .. for a masochist.
• Poor usage of resources.
• Heavy concurrancy caused by poorly developed applications in a load-balanced environment, leading to stalling queries. (Wordpress + Poor wordpress plugins I'm looking at you; you're next on my killfile).

To compound this problem some of these installations may or may not be running Etch. let us pretend they are not, just to simplify things. (They mostly arent' these days, but I'm sure I could think of one or two if I tried) So, in this hypothetical situation what would you recommend? I know there are new forks aplenty of MySQL. Drizzle et al. I suspect most of the forks will be short-lived - lots of this stuff is hard and non-sexy. I suspect the long-lived forks are probably concentrating on edge-cases we've not hit (yet), or on sexy exciting things like new storage engines and going nosql like all the cool kids. Realistically going down the postgresql road is liable to lead to wholly different sets of problems, and a significant re-engineering of several sites, applications and tools with no proof of stability. Without wanting to jump ship entirely, what, if any, are our options?

PS. MySQL I still mostly love you, but my two most recent applications were written to use redis instead. Just a coincidence... I swear. No, put down that axe. Please can't we just talk about it?/p> ObQoote: "I've calculated your chance of survival, but I don't think you'll like it. " - Hitchhikers Film.

Like last years initiative from Joey we have another opening for DebConf Newbies . Turns out this year it is me doing the main work for it, so here we are: If

• you never have been to a DebConf, or
• you last saw the conference in 2007 (Scotland)
• you can schedule a week off in July
• fear you might not make it with the normal sponsorship process ( they will never ever pick ME, im too small an ant in this project )

then this is for you. To apply for this funding, email newbies@debconf.org before 18th of June. The earlier you mail, the better, as funding will be given out in a first-come/first-serve way. In your email include an estimate of your travel costs, from where you travel from and the amount you are unable to fund yourself. I also need to know the dates you plan to arrive and leave. Please indicate if you will also need sponsored food and accommodation. (At the time of this writing you can still get sponsored food and accommodation by simply registering with the conference, so if you read this before May 19th please ensure to register NOW). Please also ensure you register with the conference now (see DebConf11 registration, even if your plans are not fully secure at this time. There is no punishment if you can not attend later - simply do not follow the reconfirmation process shortly before the conference.

That was a damn busy week. It was mostly centered about attending SambaXP, the annual Samba user and developers conference, in G ttingen, Germany. The only free software conference I attend with expenses paid by my employer, Onera. This year was the 10th edition and, as last year, to the "who was there for the nth edition" game, I won by staying alone as they asked who attended all editions of the conference. :-) That was a great week, with time spent with people as interesting as Andrew Tridgell, Jeremy Allison, John Terpstra, Volker Lendecke, Kai Blin, to name a few. A good opportunity, again, to get input from our packaging work for that big piece of software, as well as getting visibility about the future of Samba. I also had a great, even if short talk, with the kind Karolin Seeger, the release manager of Samba for 3 years now. We talked about....children, as she's now a mother since last year (with a non negligible impact on her professionnal life, as often in Germany). Great meeting, too, with Brad Kuhn, from the Software Freedom Conservacy, who had a keynote about GPL licence enforcment activities. It becomes more and more sure that Samba3 and Samba4 will reconverge together after the Samba Team releases Samba 3.6. It brings plans for our packaging work: I think we'll stick with having samba 3.6 in wheezy while the brand new shiny Samba4 probably stays separate in some way. Our users (and /me first) clearly need stability in the file and print services first. Of course, I did some packaging work there: samba 3.6.0pre3 was uploaded to experimental, about 10 days after its official announcement. I also worked on the samba *binary* package bugs, triaging them as usual. We now have 51 bugs opened against the samba binary package: 18 unclassified, 11 moreinfo (several likely to be closed as unreproducible or user error), 1 wontfix, 8 with a pending patch and 13 forwarded upstream. I'm also thinking about a possible way to ask about SMB2 support in samba: it won't be activated by default in 3.6 (mostly because us, distros, requested for that and, by "us", I mean Debian, RHEL, SuSe and their derivatives, so quite a large consensus). Still, it would be good to put some light on SMB2 support and a debconf question about it could be a solution (not shown by default and defaulting to no SMB2). I also worked quite extensively on packages maintained by No l K the, Ralf Treinen and me, aka "the pkg-running team". I did setup a git repo for my new "garmin-ant-downloader" package, that allows downloading track files from Garmin Forerunner 405 GPS watches (guess what is the brand and model of mine!). My first packaging git repository! Thanks to Ralf for his advice and help in this. I triaged bugs in the other two packages we maintain: pytrainer (more bugs forwarded upstream) and garmin-forerunner-tools (which was later uploaded by Ralf). I also setup a team mailign list so, now, we're a real team...:-) Few activity on the l10n front: a few Smith reviews are in progress and I completed 1 or 2 French translations, and reviewed some others. Regular activity, then. The only specific stuff is that I'm now pushing harder for the French DDTP effort, doing many reviews and translations there. We try to reach 100% in the "popcon500" packages. Later, we'll try to head at reaching the hieghts reached by the Italian and German teams, who are, on this l10n activity, way ahead from us. Finally, during the SambaXP conference, and as usual (except last year because of too heavy work duties), I visited my German friends, living "close to" G ttingen, accomppanied by Luk Claes and his friend and colleague Ivo, who were also attending SambaXP. Great barbecue at Andreas and Kathrin Tille's place, facing the Wernigerode castle at sunset. And the best sp tzle ever at Meike and Alex Reichle's place in Hildesheim, with a french touch on the salad's dressing as well as great Chilean wine brought by Meike's coworker Wolfram. Always a great time to see these good friends even if that means driving a few hours (and being flashed....twice!...by german speed cameras on the way to and back Andreas place!) To complete the week, I ran a 34km/800m+ trail today in the Rambouillet forest, completing it in 3h31. I'll probably blog separately about running updates as it is now quite some time that I didn't. Guess what? I'll be sleeping well tonight...

There is actually some buzz around Gnome 3 and the new release of Ubuntu switching to Unity. I thought this was a good occasion to make this small post to tell that I still uses FVWM whose latest version was released a month ago. FVWM is a very old window manager. So old that nobody really knows what the F stands for. It comes with a ugly configuration by default and can be configured to look even uglier. However, FVWM is powerful and highly configurable. Moreover, it is pretty lightweight.

My FVWM configuration My configuration of FVWM is available on GitHub. It requires the use of fvwm-crystal. If you are running Debian or Ubuntu, there is a package for this. This is a set of powerful configuration files for FVWM which add a lot of goodies and themes. Unfortunately, the project site seems to have disappared. You can still grab the sources from your nearest Debian mirror. While those configuration files were great, I did not like to have such a complex desktop with all those icons and menus. However, what is great with fvwm-crystal is you can overlay your own configuration. If a file is present in your home directory, it will take precedence over the one installed on the system. So, I just wrote a new recipe. What you may want to steal from my configuration is the ability to alter the configuration depending on the fact that you are using one or two screens. With one screen, you get:

• an application panel (a launcher bar) on the upper left corner,
• an icon manager (which will contained iconified windows) on the upper right corner,
• a systray on the left of the icon manager
• a pager (which shows various desktops) just below it,
• two icon managers (which act as a taskbar) on the bottom, one for regular applications and the other one for terminal windows.

With two screens, the organization is different. The two icon managers at the bottom are on their own screens. The pager is between the two screens and the other elements are on the upper left of the right screen. If I am using a single screen and I plug another one, I do something like this to get my setup updated:

1 2	$ xrandr --output VGA-1 --auto --output DVI-I-1 --auto --right-of VGA-1 $ killall trayer ; FvwmCommand Restart

I also uses conky, a light-weight system monitor. It is started in my .xsession, not through FVWM.

Building wallpapers for dual-screen One difficulty with a multi-head setup is how to get the background set properly? . I have made a small script for generating one. Use it like this:

1	$ ./build-wallpaper.py -d ~/.fvwm/wallpapers -c -t ~/tmp/mywallpaper.png

It will randomly select two wallpapers and put them together to look nice on your dual-screen setup. It will also correct the aspect ratio, either by cropping the image or centering the image. You need the following dependencies to make script work: python-xpyb and python-imaging. UPDATE: Thomas Adam pointed to Nitrogen, a graphical wallpaper utility supporting multi-head setups. It is a great tool if you want to set manually your wallpaper but it does not allow to select a random one. Nowadays, I grab most of my wallpapers from InterfaceLIFT.

You know, GNOME Shell and I are not really strangers to each other for a long time now. I have been using it almost daily as my main desktop since late 2009, when I started shipping it to Debian experimental. That means that I had ample opportunity to both get used to it and witness the huge improvements it had with every new release. My general feeling towards GNOME 3 is this: . Yes, I love it! I love the new themes, I love the window borders, I love the top panel, the overview, the dynamic workspaces, I love the Me menu, I love the clock and the calendar, the system indicators with the beautiful symbolic icons, being able to search for applications in such a nice way, the window animations, the multi-screen support, the new nautilus, the dash, looking glass. It s hard for me to even express how thankful I am and how much admiration I have for the awesome folks who helped bring this to life. Thanks so much! After all this time, there are only two things I can say I dislike about GNOME3, apart from some minor wishlists: the alt-tab behaviour and the message tray. Let me expand on those. Message Tray Of the very few things I dislike, there is only 1 I hate and cannot see myself living with: the accordion animation in the message tray. No, really, it s such a terrible, terrible idea. Every single time I try to use that thing I overshoot while moving the mouse to the left, then overshoot again moving the mouse to the right because the frigging icon has moved. It s no good knowing that I can click in the text or in the empty area to its right, it feels wrong. It s terrible that my actual target is moving at all. Every single time I use it is a small frustration for me it s as if the message tray was playing games with me, laughing at me for not having good enough mouse pointer driving skills even more than the infamous sub-menus used to. And I had to go through that penance whenever I wanted to find the person I was chating with to resume the conversation. I wrote an extension that disables the accordion animation by simply not showing the title at all when you hover the icon, and I patched GNOME Shell s CSS to make the icons a bit bigger, so that it s easier for me to hit them with the mouse. It s clearly not ideal, and you still have to click the various people icons to figure out which of your friends who were lazy enough to not add a picture to their IM profiles is that one, but it s still much better than chasing the (smaller) ones around to figure that out. Perhaps we should have the icons be bigger and always have the title bellow them? I don t know, I trust the awesome designers who designed the awesomess that s everywhere else will come up with a great idea. Alt Tab The number 1 feature of workspaces for me has always been locality being able to not see all of the other applications and windows that are open elsewhere. This lowers the amount of noise when I m trying to find something. The overview is very nice in this matter only windows in the current workspace are shown, and even when you have an extra screen, the windows in there appear in that screen. The alt-tab behaviour, on the other hand, of showing all windows and apps, even with the separator, bothers me. It s really useful to have when you want to go to a specific window no matter where it is (I usually use the dash for that, though), but it adds noise when you want to go to a specific window _in this_ workspace, which is the most common use case for my usage. So I copied the alt-tab code over to an extension and modified it so that only windows in the current workspace would be considered. In addition to that, with the windows in the extra screen always being there no matter what workspace you re in (which I think is an awesome idea), they are effectively in all workspaces, so they add constant noise even with my extension. It s also weird to have to look at the main screen to switch to a window in the extra screen. There s a huge discontinuity. What I would prefer is having alt-tab to follow the mouse regarding screens only show windows in the extra screen if you hit alt-tab in there, making sure the selector thing appears in there as well.

After a bit of work, today I decided to start using mpm, the mancoosi package manager, to upgrade my laptop. My first use of it on a production system - until now I run all my experiments in throw-away virtual machines - and it works ! Not rocket science here. During the last month David Kalnischkies (of APT fame) visited our offices in Paris and together with zack worked out a communication protocol between apt-get and the mancoosi cudf solvers (EDSP). I guess somebody is going to announce all details about this endeavor soon. This cooperation enabled us to advance in the integration of apt-get and the mancoosi technology. Reusing the same protocol and backend I developed to translate the apt problem to cudf (and to call a suitable solver), I've re-wrote large part of mpm and added the possibility to generate the installation plan before calling dpkg and really installing the selected packages. Below notice the intermediate calls as Inject Model , Simulate, Compare Models . These are at the moment stubs that are going to call the simulation framework developed at mancoosi. The food : Reg the installation plan, this is an xml file that will be passed to a simulator developed by the university of L'Aquila to make sure that the installation script (well, a model of them), will not cause any problem during the installation. The format is a very simple xml file as follows : Soon APT will ship a patch to use the very same infrastructure of mpm (yeii !!!). This will on one hand make mpm useless as package manager on its own. It is a simple hack in python and I never tough to compete with its big brothers. On the other hand I think it will stand as a nice workbench to experiment with new ideas, to prototype new features and to make it easier for poeple that are not c++ experts to play with the APT library (thanks to python-apt) in a semi structured environment. The code is in the mancoosi svn if you want to have a look.

After a bit of work, today I decided to start using mpm, the mancoosi package manager, to upgrade my laptop. My first use of it on a production system - until now I run all my experiments in throw-away virtual machines - and it works ! Not rocket science here. During the last month David Kalnischkies (of APT fame) visited our offices in Paris and together with zack worked out a communication protocol between apt-get and the mancoosi cudf solvers (EDSP). I guess somebody is going to announce all details about this endeavor soon. This cooperation enabled us to advance in the integration of apt-get and the mancoosi technology. Reusing the same protocol, and backend I developed to translate the apt problem to cudf (and to call a suitable solver), I've re-wrote large part of mpm and added the possibility to generate the installation plan before calling dpkg and really installing the selected packages. Below notice the intermediate calls as Inject Model , Simulate, Compare Models . These are at the moment stubs that are going to call the simulation framework developed at mancoosi. The food : Reg the installation plan, this is an xml file that will be passed to a simulator developed by the university of L'Aquila to make sure that the installation script (well, a model of them), will not cause any problem during the installation. The format is a very simple xml file as follows : Soon APT will ship a patch to use the very same infrastructure of mpm (yeii !!!). This will on one hand make mpm useless as package manager on its own. It is a simple hack in python and I never tough to compete with its big brothers. On the other hand I think it will stand as a nice workbench to experiment with new ideas, to prototype new features and to make it easier for poeple that are not c++ experts to play with the APT library (thanks to python-apt) in a semi structured environment. The code is in the mancoosi svn if you want to have a look.

LightDM's a from-scratch implementation of an X display manager, ie the piece of software that handles remote X connections, starts any local X servers, provides a login screen and kicks off the initial user session. It's split into a nominally desktop-agnostic core (built directly on xcb and glib) and greeters, the idea being that it's straightforward to implement an environment-specific greeter that integrates nicely with your desktop session. It's about 6500 lines of code in the core, 3500 lines of code in the gtk bindings to the core and about 1000 in the sample gtk greeter, for a total of about 11,000 lines of code for a full implementation. This compares to getting on for 60,000 in gdm. Ubuntu plan to switch to LightDM in their next release (11.10).

This is a ridiculous idea.

To a first approximation, when someone says "Lightweight" what they mean is "I don't understand the problems that the alternative solves". People see gtk and think "Gosh, that's kind of big for a toolkit library. I'll write my own". And at some point they have to write a file dialog. And then they need to implement support for handling remote filesystems. And then they need to know whether the system has a functioning network connection or not, and so they end up querying state from Network Manager. And then they suddenly have a library that's getting on for the size of gtk, has about the same level of complexity and has had much less testing because why would you want to use a lightweight toolkit that either does nothing or is 90% of the size of the alternative and crashes all the time.

Adding functionality means that code gets larger. Given two codebases that are of significantly different sizes, the two possible conclusions are either that (a) the smaller one is massively more competently written than the larger one, or (b) the smaller one does less. The gdm authors have never struck me as incompetent, even if some people may disagree with some of their design decisions, and the LightDM authors don't seem to have argued on that basis either. So the obvious conclusion is that LightDM does less.

And, indeed, LightDM does less. Part of this is by design - as the proposal to the Gnome development list shows, one of the key advantages of LightDM is claimed as it not starting a Gnome session. And from that statement alone, we can already see that there's been a massive failure of understanding the complexity of the problem.

Let's go back to the comparisons of code size. LightDM's simple GTK greeter is about 1000 lines of code. gdm's greeter is almost 20,000. Some of this is arbitrary shiny stuff like the slidy effects that occur, but a lot of it is additional functionality. For example, some of it is devoted to handling the interface with AccountsService so gdm can automatically update when users are created or deleted. Some of it is providing UI for accessibility functionality. Some of it is drawing a clock, which I'll admit may be a touch gratuitous.

But if your argument is that your software is better because it's doing less, you should be able to ensure that you can demonstrate that the differences aren't important. And the differences here are important. For example, one of the reasons gdm starts a local gnome session is that it wants gnome-power-manager to be there to handle power policy. Closing the lid of my laptop should suspend the system regardless of whether it's logged in or not. LightDM takes a different approach. Because there's no session, it has to take care of this kind of thing itself. So the backend daemon code speaks to upower directly, and the greeters ask the daemon to implement their policy decisions.

This is pretty obviously miserable. Now you've got two sets of policy - one at the login screen, and one in your session. How do I ensure they're consistent? The only sane solution is to ignore the functionality the backend provides and have my greeter run gnome-power-manager. And now how about accessibility preferences? Again, if I want to have the same selection of policy, I need to run the same code. So you end up with a greeter that's about as complex and large as the gdm one, and unused functionality in the backend. Lighter weight through code duplication. We have always been at war with Eurasia.

The entirety of LightDM's design is based on a false premise - that you can move a large set of common greeter functionality into a daemon and just leave UI presentation up to the greeter code. And if you believe that, then yes, you can absolutely implement a greeter in 1000 lines of code. It'll behave differently to your desktop - the range of policy you can implement will be limited to what the daemon provides, even if your desktop environment has a different range of features. It'll have worse accessibility for much the same reason. And eventually you'll end up with a daemon that's absolutely huge in order to attempt to provide the superset of functionality that each different desktop makes use of.

The only real problem LightDM solves is that it makes it easier to write custom greeters, and if you're really seeking to differentiate your project based on your login screen then maybe your priorities are a little out of line. I'm sure that Ubuntu will release with a beautiful 3D greeter that has a wonderful transition to the desktop. It's just a shame that it won't do any of the useful things that the existing implementations already do.

And if you think that when LightDM finally has the full feature set of gdm, kdm and lxdm it'll still be fewer lines of code and take less memory - I hear the BSD kernel is lighter weight than Linux. Have fun with it.

I did not write much code or merge much of my prototype code, but some things happened since the last blog post about APT2 specific things in August and I forgot to write about them. First of all, I dropped the GVariant-based cache. The format strings were simply getting ugly long and were not very understandable, performance was just much too slow (needing more than a few nanoseconds for a package lookup is obviously too slow for solving dependency problems); furthermore, building the cache was also slow and complicated because we needed all attributes of an object at once to pass them to GVariant, leading to ugly API. I replaced the GVariant cache with one that can be easily mmap()ed and is described completely in C. It s derived from APT s cache design (but more robust, as it includes the size of the cache and we can thus detect to small files, although that s scheduled for the next ABI break in APT as well), but has fewer duplicate data, and uses arrays where APT uses linked lists. The reason for arrays is simple: They take up less space and can be represented naturally in Python and other languages using array-based lists. The cache also contains a coalesced hash table which does use a linked list, but that one is a bit different, as it is for searching only and not exposed. Everything non-stringy is 64-bit aligned in order to keep things as simple as possible. All integers are fixed size, thus the format is architecture-independent if you fix byte orders. The format is described at http://people.debian.org/~jak/apt2-doc/apt-Cache-Format.html. I stole one more idea from cupt and changed the configuration system to verify types of variables. APT2 s configuration system knows more types than cupt s, though, including regular expressions, directory and filenames (i.e. it does not let you store a value /d/ in a file variable), strings (which store everything), unsigned and signed integers, and boolean options; all of which are checked when parsing files (producing warnings) or command-line options (producing errors). I have also simplified the type world by removing all iterator types except for one, replacing them with get_thing() and n_things() functions in the objects holding the arrays. Makes cool bindings slightly harder, but makes the C API much easier to use from C. Most things expected from a package manager are still missing, but what is there looks good in most cases (especially AptConfiguration has a nice API, and no complaints from valgrind anywhere). Currently I am working on Python bindings so I can interact with the functions easily and check things in an interactive fashion; and I am also writing a document explaining the concepts behind APT2, drafts at http://people.debian.org/~jak/midlevel.pdf. I also have some more code pending further thoughts (including complete index parsing), but it might still take some time before I have something usable in the wild. On other package managers: From time to time I also use Cupt, look at Cupt code, hack Cupt code, and report bugs against Cupt. I still do not really understand the (extreme) nesting of directory structures in the source code, why there are so (extremely) many source files split all over them, or the general concepts of Cupt, but I can hack together what I need for my personal testing. I also play with yum whenever I end up on a Fedora system (which happens from time to time).
Filed under: APT2

Software in the Public Interest (the organisation behind debian and many more) will hold a public board meeting later today (Wednesday) at 20:30 UTC (=21:30 BST, 22:30 CEST or date -d @1305145800 to you). SPI meetings are held in #spi on irc.spi-inc.org (the OFTC network). The agenda for the meeting is available at http://www.spi-inc.org/meetings/agendas/2011/2011-05-11/ At the time of writing, there s a single resolution regarding Jenkins joining as an SPI associated project. Jenkins (formerly known as Hudson until the Oracalypse) monitors execution of jobs like software builds or scheduled tasks. Its website is http://jenkins-ci.org/ Why not come along and wish Jenkins well? Or just see if I m awake after a #koha meeting at 3am UK time?

I'm playing with btrfs to get a feel for what's coming up in linux filesystems. To be daring, i've configured a test machine using only btrfs for its on-disk filesystems. I really like some of the ideas put forward in the btrfs design. (i'm aware that btrfs is considered experimental-only at this point). I'm happy to report that despite several weeks of regular upgrade/churn from unstable and experimental, i have yet to see any data loss or other serious forms of failure. Unfortunately, i'm not impressed with the performance. The machine feels sluggish in this configuratiyon, compared to how i remember it running with previous non-btrfs installations. So i ran some benchmarks. The results don't look good for btrfs in its present incarnation. UPDATE: see the comments section for revised statistics from a quieter system, with the filesystems over the same partition (btrfs is still much slower). The simplified test system i'm running has Linux kernel 2.6.39-rc6-686-pae (from experimental), 1GiB of RAM (no swap), and a single 2GHz P4 CPU. It has one parallel ATA hard disk (WDC WD400EB-00CPF0), with two primary partitions (one btrfs and one ext3). The root filesystem is btrfs. The ext3 filesystem is mounted at /mnt I used bonnie++ to benchmark the ext3 filesystem against the btrfs filesystem as a non-privileged user. Here are the results on the test ext3 filesystem:

consoleuser@loki:~$ cat bonnie-stats.ext3 
Reading a byte at a time...done
Reading intelligently...done
start 'em...done...done...done...done...done...
Create files in sequential order...done.
Stat files in sequential order...done.
Delete files in sequential order...done.
Create files in random order...done.
Stat files in random order...done.
Delete files in random order...done.
Version  1.96       ------Sequential Output------ --Sequential Input- --Random-
Concurrency   1     -Per Chr- --Block-- -Rewrite- -Per Chr- --Block-- --Seeks--
Machine        Size K/sec %CP K/sec %CP K/sec %CP K/sec %CP K/sec %CP  /sec %CP
loki          2264M   331  98 23464  11 10988   4  1174  85 39629   6 130.4   5
Latency             92041us    1128ms    1835ms     166ms     308ms    6549ms
Version  1.96       ------Sequential Create------ --------Random Create--------
loki                -Create-- --Read--- -Delete-- -Create-- --Read--- -Delete--
              files  /sec %CP  /sec %CP  /sec %CP  /sec %CP  /sec %CP  /sec %CP
                 16  9964  26 +++++ +++ 13035  26 11089  27 +++++ +++ 11888  24
Latency             17882us    1418us    1929us     489us      51us     650us
1.96,1.96,loki,1,1305039600,2264M,,331,98,23464,11,10988,4,1174,85,39629,6,130.4,5,16,,,,,9964,26,+++++,+++,13035,26,11089,27,+++++,+++,11888,24,92041us,1128ms,1835ms,166ms,308ms,6549ms,17882us,1418us,1929us,489us,51us,650us
consoleuser@loki:~$ 

And here are the results for btrfs (on the main filesystem):

consoleuser@loki:~$ cat bonnie-stats.btrfs 
Reading a byte at a time...done
Reading intelligently...done
start 'em...done...done...done...done...done...
Create files in sequential order...done.
Stat files in sequential order...done.
Delete files in sequential order...done.
Create files in random order...done.
Stat files in random order...done.
Delete files in random order...done.
Version  1.96       ------Sequential Output------ --Sequential Input- --Random-
Concurrency   1     -Per Chr- --Block-- -Rewrite- -Per Chr- --Block-- --Seeks--
Machine        Size K/sec %CP K/sec %CP K/sec %CP K/sec %CP K/sec %CP  /sec %CP
loki          2264M    43  99 22682  17 10356   6  1038  79 28796   6  86.8  99
Latency               293ms     727ms    1222ms   46541us     504ms   13094ms
Version  1.96       ------Sequential Create------ --------Random Create--------
loki                -Create-- --Read--- -Delete-- -Create-- --Read--- -Delete--
              files  /sec %CP  /sec %CP  /sec %CP  /sec %CP  /sec %CP  /sec %CP
                 16  1623  33 +++++ +++  2182  57  1974  27 +++++ +++  1907  44
Latency             78474us    6839us    8791us    1746us      66us   64034us
1.96,1.96,loki,1,1305040411,2264M,,43,99,22682,17,10356,6,1038,79,28796,6,86.8,99,16,,,,,1623,33,+++++,+++,2182,57,1974,27,+++++,+++,1907,44,293ms,727ms,1222ms,46541us,504ms,13094ms,78474us,6839us,8791us,1746us,66us,64034us
consoleuser@loki:~$ 

As you can see, btrfs is significantly slower in several categories:

• writing character-at-a-time is *much* slower: 43K/sec vs. 331K/sec
• reading block-at-a-time is slower: 28796K/sec vs. 39629K/sec
• all forms of file creation and deletion are nearly an order of magnitude slower
• Random seeks are almost as fast, but they swamp the CPU

I'm hoping that i just configured the test wrong somehow, or that i've done something grossly unfair in the system setup and configuration. (or maybe i'm mis-reading the bonnie++ output?) Maybe someone can point out my mistake, or give me pointers for what to do to try to speed up btrfs. I like the sound of the features we will eventually get from btrfs, but these performance figures seem like a pretty rough tradeoff.Tags: benchmarks, bonnie, btrfs, ext3

It looks like I am going to Debconf11! Vacation time is booked, registration is in, only some final approvals inside Accenture are pending to pay my flights. I must say after working in Finland for the whole winter, I need to get out and get to friendly (and relatively chatty) Debian people more than ever.

Almost a year ago I put together a simple picture sharing site, which was designed to accept uploaded images via OpenID logins and then share them. It was created because none of the existing image sharing sites allowed OpenID logins - and because frankly I rarely trust sites I don't control. (Especially when they're free sites, with no obvious revenue stream. We can reference recent compromises if we wish to be topical, but even without them it is all about trust.) I opened up the site to allow others to use it, but assumed it would remain Steve-only - After all why would somebody choose to use my site rather than imgur, or similar? Over the year I've spotted several minor problems with the site. The built-in support for comments was never used, primarily because I didn't have any other users, and some of the tagging aspects were hard to use. Since I've started using twitter I again found myself wanting a picture-hosting site, one with "short links". I started using twitpic.com, but wasn't happy with it. So the plan was formed; build another picture sharing site. But this time with short URLS. Sadly my first choice of http://picc.ie was denied to me - I couldn't register it as I don't live in Ireland. But my second choice http://linkti.me was free. As a challenge to myself this site uses Redis for storing all user-details, all image details, and all session data. It hasn't been difficult to implemenet a multi-user site, with logins, file uploads, and tagging. I guess I cheated as a lot of the code is borrowed from the previous site, but this time it looks prettier and there have been many cleanups due to my previous experience. This time round I was more focussed upon short links, so each image is allowed an incrementing number, which is then encoded using base 36 math - which is the alphabet you get if you use [0-9A-Z]. I designed three shareable links for each image to keep it simple:

• http://linkti.me/v/S - Show a HTML page with the image embedded.
• http://linkti.me/i/S - Show a raw image.
• http://linkti.me/r/S - Show a "thumbnail" of the image.

Why "/r" for the thumbnail? Well because it is a random thumbnail. To cope with difference sizes, and allow the recent image display to look regular, I wanted each thumbnail to be 150x150 pixels. My thumbnail generation simply picks a random X,Y co-ordinate from the image and then cuts out a 150x150 square block starting at that offset. The results of a random segment of an uploaded image are sometimes very cool, altough equally often they are misleading. If I upload naked people there is the possability that we'll just get a nipple or a cock - but I'm actually quite smug about the way it turned out. Simpler to code than to resize, scale, or similar and surprisingly random when you see 9x9 random images (as you do on the front page). Anyway that's all for now. I was tempted to talk about implementation or migration, but I've written too much for an early morning already. Some other time? ObQuote: "He's just trying to freak us out. " - 30 Days of Night.

As announced on my French blog, I m attending Solutions Linux this week (10-12 May). I ll be on the Debian booth with a few other members of Debian France. If you re in Paris during those days, make sure to come by. I ll be pleased to meet you, and we ll be a bunch of Debian contributors ready to answer your questions. And if you feel like it, feel free to stop for a few hours and give us some help at the booth. It tends to be crowded and we re never enough to answer the questions. As usual, I ll come with a copy of the book Cahier de l Admin Debian (the one that I want to translate into English) to show, and I ll be glad to dedicate the book to whoever brings his copy with him/her. While speaking of conferences, this summer I m going to Banja Luka for DebConf 2011. I ve bought my plane tickets and I ll be there the whole week (24-31 july). Joining a DebConf is a completely different experience. DebConf is made by Debian people for Debian people. It s an opportunity to meet many of the people that you mainly know over IRC/email. And you don t need to be a hardcore Debian contributor to join. In fact, it s a great experience for anyone who just started contributing to Debian. Read this email of Asheesh Laroia as a proof. Note that the sponsored registration period has been extended up to the 17th of May. Register now! I m looking forward to DebConf11. On request of Stefano, I registered a Debian Rolling Bof. It will be a good occasion to see how far we are and to discuss future plans.

No comment Liked this article? Click here. My blog is Flattr-enabled.

I ve been a little sick the last days and decided to be productive instead of just drinking tea all the time.The result are some (10) squashed bugs from pkg-games, and one long standing nmu.adonthell#624998 LP#765984
FTBFS: py_adonthell_wrap.cc:27357:44: error: taking address of temporary [-fpermissive]
Patch by Peter De Wachter, I just had to sign and upload.alex4#624884
FTBFS: stat.h:106:22: error: expected identifier or ( before [' token
Include defs.h *after* particle.h, thus not redifining __unused from glibc's bits/stat.hfenix#554286 LP#770962
FTBFS with binutils-gold
Fixed since 0.92a.dfsg1-6, bug closed. Found different FTBFS though, fix uploaded as -9.freeciv#554411
FTBFS with binutils-gold
Closed after verifying that it is fixed since at least 2.2.1 as upstream wrote.kball#624978
FTBFS: src/gamemenu.cpp:224:52: error: 'mkdir' was not declared in this scope
Include sys/stat.h in 06_homedir_game.patch and 07_homedir_editor.patch.kiki-the-nano-bot#625047 LP#770970
FTBFS: ../src/../SWIG/KikiPy_wrap.cpp:13045:63: error: taking address of temporary [-fpermissive]
Patch by Peter De Wachter, I just had to sign and upload.late#624937 LP#770857
FTBFS: ball.h:113:19: error: NULL was not declared in this scope
Include stddef.h in ball.h to define NULL.libclaw#625038 #624919 LP#770805
FTBFS: avl_base.hpp:137:15: error: ptrdiff_t does not name a type
Patch by Julien Jorge, I just had to sign and upload.liquidwar#555468
FTBFS with binutils-gold
Patch by Stephen Kitt, I just had to sign and upload.lordsawar#555564
FTBFS with binutils-gold
Closed after verifying that it is fixed since at least 0.1.8xnecview#621392
FTBFS on armel: expected identifier before numeric constant
R0 is already taken as a register name on armel, rename xnecview s constant to DEFFAULTR0. (Patch basically stolen from Ubuntu)

Today we had a very interesting demonstration. People who know me for some time know I like to be a part of demonstrations, adding my voice to the people. And even though I know most demonstrations, as massive as they might be, have no real and tangible effect... Well, I try to be there. Today we had a large demonstration in Mexico City of people angry with the government's tactics on the war on drugs Have you been to Mexico before 2007? You will remember we have always had our problems, but violence was basically limited to keeping an eye open, not flashing your money/jewels, and not looking too touristy. We were, all in all, a quiet country Known even as "the country where nothing happens, even if it happens". Five years later, a good portion of the country lives really in war-like conditions, and close to 45,000 people have been killed. At some point about a year ago (where the body count was at ~22,000), our oh-so-bright de-facto president said that "only" 10% of them were civilians. If that is still the case, and if proportions are held, we can now talk about ~4,500 people killed just because they were there Oh, but remember the country is not at war, and death penalty has very long been abolished, so we cannot give the other 90% a different status. We have had over 45,000 killed people. That means at least ~200,000 torn lifes. About six weeks ago, the cry from a father who lost his son started getting heard. And no, I do not want to talk about specific names or anything like that It is just the voice-bearer of many people who are fed up. Four days ago, he and a group of people left Cuernavaca city on a caravan and walked to Mexico city. Yesterday evening they arrived to the National University (UNAM), and were greeted by an amazing open-air concert: Mozart's Requiem. Today, our day started very early. My mother wanted to help, as many more anonymous citizens did, so we started making and packing sandwiches and apples at ~5:30AM, delivered them to the camp where they were staying and grouping with other people, and came back home for our breakfast. Later, at around 9AM, as the demonstration started going by our house (we live a block from UNAM), my girlfriend, father and me started walking with them. Why do I say this was a different demonstration than others I have been to?

1. Much longer. We walked for close to 16Km, for about five hours. Most demonstrations I have been part of are 3-5Km long
2. A different kind of support. I was surprised, even laughed at first when I saw a lady standing by us with a sign that read, I cannot join you today, but I'm there in spirit . But then I saw more, more people that just went out of their houses to a point close to where we walked on, and just stayed there on the streets. Not walking, yes, but being part of it.
3. The march was silent And yes, this is the first time I see it for true. At the very beginning we heard some people chanting, cheering, but the cheerers were requested not to be noisy. People wearing political parties' logos were requested not to wear them (as political parties are at an all-time low prestige). No, we were not silent for the whole 5 hours; we were talking with each other, but it felt... just very different from any other times.
4. Not only were people supporting, but this is the first time I saw this amount of people wanting to materially help. As I said, my mother delivered a little breakfast for 50 people, for those that slept at the camp, for those that had already walked ~70Km. But all along the road we were offered oranges, cookies, water, bread... Whatever people were able to offer, to somehow help. Very nice feeling of solidarity.
5. Contrary to all other times, we were really spread out, it was a very low density walk, os it was quite pleasant. Of course, I have not even seen an estimation of the number of participants... And I doubt anyboy can be decently close to it

Will this change anything? I doubt it. I am happy that for the first time, the de-facto president (remember a large percentage of Mexicans still believe he lost the presidential election, and it was only due to his lack of legitimacy that he pushed the army to the streets to start this war on drugs) is recognizing that this might not be the best strategy but it is the only one he has... People are still, despite what I saw many felt, very far from organized. And, yes, no short-term concrete proposals are made on how to stop the killing I feel the population agrees that drugs should be legalized and regulated, that would at least shift the problem, reduce the direct violence (and money) related to it... But, of course, it is plainly not feasible with our current reality. Anyway, after a 5hr walk today (and even after a nice nap and shower), I don't want to dig into hypotheses anymore. I just wanted to share about a very interesting and different experience I had the opportunity to be part of.

Date for end of sponsored registrations for this years DebConf11 in Banja Luka was set for May 8th, today that date has officially been extended to May 19th. Now to answer your question on why are you extending sponsored registrations 12 hours before it ends here s the answer. Registrations are going fine, we have more then 300 attendees who registered so far, it is due to change in our monetary resources as sponsorship level has changed from one to another, and we ve be granted to welcome more people. But it is also to give some possible attendees more time and information, as I ve got a feeling a lot of people from this region and elsewhere have been lacking some even general information, and thus I d like to bring everything closer to everybody. Before anything, heading to our website might be a good start as we have immense amount of information up there. Since government of Republika Srpska is our greatest and main financial sponsor, local team has made a document for them in which we tried to explain most basic and crucial things from what DebCamp and DebConf is over logistical/statistical data to what we have planned for Fun and Free time, so checking out that document might be a good idea as well DebConf11 Plan and Program. Since that might be too much for somebody as the documents stretches to some ~30 pages, I ll try to give answers to most common/asked questions. Registrations Who should register? In plain English, everybody. Only people that don t need to register are people who will attend Debian day, please see Plan and Program section 5.3 for more information on Debian Day. If you want to attend any of the DebConf lectures/presentations/whatever you should register. Registrations will play great deal in this years DebConf as if you register you ll get accreditation with your name on it and what you re allowed to do. Whether you have sponsored food/accommodation and thus allowed to eat for free or that you can sleep in certain hotel, or whether you re allowed to the pools for free; also as we re planning to have tight security in our Venue, in order for you to even enter Venue building you ll need to have accreditation on you. So, if you re planning to do anything with DebConf please do register. What is DebCamp/should I attend DebCamp? Please refer to Plan and Program document it s all said at the end of page 15. Sponsorship After registrations this is next thing that is brought up and that is most unclear to most of you. You re able to request travel, accommodation and food sponsorship, what each of those means is pretty self elaborate. But the real question here might be, who is eligible to request sponsorship? Again, everybody. What are is the criterion for getting sponsorship? There really isn t a written rule who gets the sponsorship and who doesn t but if you have ever been involved or contributed in any sort of way to Debian, or even have contributed or have been involved in any open source projects you re more then welcome to apply for sponsorship. Furthermore, due to the funds that we have been granted from Government of Republika Srpska, I even encourage you to ask sponsorship, don t be intimidated and just do it Professional/Corporate This is category for those who are sent by their companies, and whose participation/attendance is sponsored by the same. Professional covers the price of actual costs of their visit, while the corporate is double that price, which is for those who besides paying the actual costs also want to contribute money and help Debian. Organized transport and getting to Banja Luka Now, for those who are flying to Banja Luka I personally told you to come to via Zagreb. Why did I do this, if Banja Luka has its own airport? I told you this because Zagreb is much larger airport and thus has many budget companies, meaning cheaper flights. Once the registrations are closed, based on your arrival/departure dates we ll be able to statistically predict how many of you will be coming to Zagreb on each date and each time as we re planning to have organized transport. This means that we ll send buses/shuttles to pick people up in Zagreb. Of course to have this organized we ll need to set up arrival/departure pages with all the information that s need for us to have this organized. Now, for those who want to come directly to Banja Luka airport this might be bit pricer then going via Zagreb, but not by much. I personally value my time and I even fly from Zagreb to Sarajevo Phil for example booked his flight just this morning from London via Ljubljanja to Banja Luka and it wasn t that much more expensive then Zagreb. Also worth noting is that Banja Luka might be limited for some destinations, but I for a fact know that there are flights coming from Zurich, Ljubljanja, Belgrade and so on. Maybe someone from Banja Luka could follow up on this one with more information. Questions? With this post I hope I have brought some of these topics closer to you and that I made some things clearer. If you have any questions, please feel free to leave your comments or email whatever you re concerned about to our mailing list on: debconf11-localteam@lists.debconf.org Further reading:
Gunnar Wolf Posts explaining DebConf