Jon Dowland: 1984
The UK now has it's own equivalent to China's great
firewall. My
current ISP "bethere" is one of several which have opted into using it. If
I try to access the wikipedia article on the Scorpion's album "Virgin
Killer" I receive a "404 not
found response" which does not originate from Wikipedia. This album had a
controversial picture of a young girl naked on the cover. The censoring proxy
has blocked access to both wikimedia's copy of the album cover but also the
entire article about it (including discussion about the album cover
controversy).
There are two things in particular that really annoy me about the way this has
been implemented. Firstly, the response I get for a censored page is an
unadorned 404. At the very least it should be an explanation of why I cannot
access the material, and who to contact if there has been a mistake (no doubt
in the eyes of our moral superiors there are no mistakes). Secondly, my ISP
has signed up for this and implemented it without telling me. I will shortly
be moving both my broadband and that of my parents away from them.
The scary thing for me about George Orwell's 1984 was not just the total
control but how ruthlessly efficiently it was implemented. So far this has
been implemented predictably poorly, first of all it's trivial to circumvent
the
block on
wikipedia, at least; secondly, they've inadvertently buggered up editing
Wikipedia
for those affected.
