Review:
Lord of Emperors, by Guy Gavriel Kay
| Series: |
Sarantine Mosaic #2 |
| Publisher: |
Eos |
| Copyright: |
2000 |
| Printing: |
February 2001 |
| ISBN: |
0-06-102002-8 |
| Format: |
Mass market |
| Pages: |
560 |
Lord of Emperors is the second half of a work that began with
Sailing to Sarantium and is best thought
of as a single book split for publishing reasons. You want to read the
two together and in order.
As is typical for this sort of two-part work, it's difficult to review the
second half without spoilers. I'll be more vague about the plot and the
characters than normal, and will mark one bit that's arguably a bit of a
spoiler (although I don't think it would affect the enjoyment of the
book).
At the end of
Sailing to Sarantium, we left Crispin in the great
city, oddly and surprisingly entangled with some frighteningly powerful
people and some more mundane ones (insofar as anyone is mundane in a Guy
Gavriel Kay novel, but more on that in a bit). The opening of
Lord
of Emperors takes a break from the city to introduce a new people, the
Bassanids, and a new character, Rustem of Karakek. While Crispin is still
the heart of this story, the thread that binds the entirety of the
Sarantine Mosaic together, Rustem is the primary protagonist for much of
this book. I had somehow forgotten him completely since my first read of
this series many years ago. I have no idea how.
I mentioned in my review of the previous book that one of the joys of
reading this series is competence porn: watching the work of someone who
is extremely good at what they do, and experiencing vicariously some of
the passion and satisfaction they have for their work. Kay's handling of
Crispin's mosaics is still the highlight of the series for me, but
Rustem's medical practice (and Strumosus, and the chariot races) comes
close. Rustem is a brilliant doctor by the standards of the time, utterly
frustrated with the incompetence of the Sarantine doctors, but also
weaving his own culture's belief in omens and portents into his actions.
He's more reserved, more laconic than Crispin, but is another character
with focused expertise and a deep internal sense of honor, swept
unexpectedly into broader affairs and attempting to navigate them by doing
the right thing in each moment. Kay fills this book with people like
that, and it's compelling reading.
Rustem's entrance into the city accidentally sets off a complex chain of
events that draws together all of the major characters of
Sailing to
Sarantium and adds a few more. The stakes are no less than war and
control of major empires, and here Kay departs firmly from recorded
history into his own creation. I had mentioned in the previous review
that Justinian and Theodora are the clear inspirations for this story;
that remains true, and many other characters are easy to map, but don't
expect history to go here the way that it did in our world. Kay's version
diverges significantly, and dramatically.
But one of the things I love the most about this book is its focus on the
individual acts of courage, empathy, and ethics of each of the characters,
even when those acts do not change the course of empires. The palace
intrigue happens, and is important, but the individual acts of Kay's large
cast get just as much epic narrative attention even if they would never
appear in a history book. The most globally significant moment of the
book is not the most stirring; that happens slightly earlier, in a chariot
race destined to be forgotten by history. And the most touching moment of
the book is a moment of connection between two people who would never
appear in history, over the life of a third, that matters so much to the
reader only because of the careful attention to individual lives and
personalities Kay has shown over the course of a hundreds of pages.
A minor spoiler follows in the next paragraph, although I don't think it
affects the reading of the book.
One brilliant part of Kay's fiction is that he doesn't have many villains,
and goes to some lengths to humanize the actions of nearly everyone in the
book. But sometimes the author's deep dislike of one particular character
shows through, and here it's Pertennius (the clear analogue of Procopius).
In a way, one could say the entirety of the Sarantine Mosaic is a rebuttal
of the
Secret History. But I think Kay's contrast between
Crispin's art (and Scortius's, and Strumosus's) and Pertennius's history
has a deeper thematic goal. I came away from this book feeling like the
Sarantine Mosaic as a whole stands in contrast to a traditional history,
stands against a reduction of people to dates and wars and buildings and
governments. Crispin's greatest work attempts to capture emotion, awe,
and an inner life. The endlessly complex human relationships shown in
this book running beneath the political events occasionally surface in
dramatic upheavals, but in Kay's telling the ones that stay below the
surface are just as important. And while much of the other art shown in
this book differs from Crispin's in being inherently ephemeral, it shares
that quality of being the art of life, of complexity, of people in
dynamic, changing, situational understanding of the world, exercising
competence in some area that may or may not be remembered.
Kay raises to the level of epic the bits of history that don't get
recorded, and, in his grand and self-conscious fantasy epic style,
encourages the reader to feel those just as deeply as the ones that will
have later historical significance. The measure of people, their true
inner selves, is often shown in moments that Pertennius would dismiss and
consider unworthy of recording in his history.
End minor spoiler.
I think
Lord of Emperors is the best part of the Sarantine Mosaic
duology. It keeps the same deeply enjoyable view of people doing things
they are extremely good at while correcting some of the structural issues
in the previous book. Kay continues to use a large cast, and continues to
cut between viewpoint characters to show each event from multiple angles,
but he has a better grasp of timing and order here than in
Sailing
to Sarantium. I never got confused about the timeline, thanks in part to
more frequent and more linear scene cuts. And
Lord of Emperors
passes, with flying colors, the hardest test of a novel with a huge number
of viewpoint characters: when Kay cuts to a new viewpoint, my reaction is
almost always "yes, I wanted to see what they were thinking!" and almost
never "wait, no, go back!".
My other main complaint about
Sailing to Sarantium was the
treatment of women, specifically the irresistibility of female sexual
allure. Kay thankfully tones that down a lot here. His treatment of
women is still a bit odd one notices that five women seem to all touch
the lives of the same men, and little room is left for Platonic friendship
between the genders but they're somewhat less persistently sexualized.
And the women get a great deal of agency in this book, and a great deal of
narrative respect.
That said,
Lord of Emperors is also emotionally brutal. It's
beautifully done, and entirely appropriate to the story, and Kay does
provide a denouement that takes away a bit of the sting. But it's still
very hard to read in spots if you become as invested in the characters and
in the world as I do. Kay is writing epic that borders on tragedy, and
uses his full capabilities as a writer to make the reader feel it. I love
it, but it's not a book that I want to read too often.
As with nearly all Kay, the Sarantine Mosaic as a whole is intentional,
deliberate epic writing, wearing its technique on its sleeve and making no
apologies. There is constant foreshadowing, constant attempts to draw
larger conclusions or reveal great principles of human nature, and a very
open, repeated stress on the greatness and importance of events while
they're being described. This works for me, but it doesn't work for
everyone. If it doesn't work for you, the Sarantine Mosaic is unlikely to
change your mind. But if you're in the mood for that type of story, I
think this is one of Kay's best, and
Lord of Emperors is the best
half of the book.
Rating: 10 out of 10