Search Results: "Russ Allbery"

25 December 2016

Russ Allbery: DocKnot 1.01

This is the second release of my new documentation generation system for my packages. It's still probably not of much interest to anyone other than me, particularly since the metadata format is still rapidly evolving so I've not documented it yet. But the templates are getting fleshed out and it's generating more and more of my package documentation, which will make releases much easier. This release adds generation of build and test instructions for my packages from templates and metadata, with some support for adding a bit of custom wording. It also offers a few new options for expanding license notices, and for annotating packages with additional bootstrap requirements. You can get the latest version from the DocKnot distribution page.

Russ Allbery: DocKnot 1.01

This is the second release of my new documentation generation system for my packages. It's still probably not of much interest to anyone other than me, particularly since the metadata format is still rapidly evolving so I've not documented it yet. But the templates are getting fleshed out and it's generating more and more of my package documentation, which will make releases much easier. This release adds generation of build and test instructions for my packages from templates and metadata, with some support for adding a bit of custom wording. It also offers a few new options for expanding license notices, and for annotating packages with additional bootstrap requirements. You can get the latest version from the DocKnot distribution page.

Russ Allbery: Review: A Man Called Ove

Review: A Man Called Ove, by Fredrik Backman
Translator: Henning Koch
Publisher: Washington Square
Copyright: 2012, 2014
Printing: May 2015
ISBN: 1-4767-3802-5
Format: Trade paperback
Pages: 337
Ove is 59 years old and drives a Saab. He's grumpy, often taciturn, very particular in how things should be done, and extremely judgmental about how other people do them. He is the sort of person who regularly rants about how poorly things are done these days and how much better they used to be. Ove does not like change. A Man Called Ove opens with him terrorizing the employees of an Apple Store, trying to buy a computer, but this incident is actually foreshadowing, and will only make sense at the very end of the book. The story actually begins in the second chapter, with Ove making his morning rounds of the neighborhood in which he lives, discovering an out-of-place bicycle and a mangy cat, and then starting to put a hook in his ceiling. But just as he's getting started, he's interrupted by new neighbors, who are incapable of backing up a trailer properly without scraping it against his house. Not that motor vehicles are allowed in the area anyway. That inauspicious beginning changes Ove's life, mostly through the sheer persistence of other people's disasters. It's not obvious at first that it will, and at the start A Man Called Ove could be a funny collection of stories about a curmudgeon. But as Backman shows more of Ove's life and tells more of his background and situation, it becomes something so much more, something satisfying and heart-breaking and deeply human. I've been struggling to review this book because I find it hard to capture what makes it so wonderful. Making that even harder, several key plot elements are introduced gradually in the story in ways that add a lot to the rhythm of the plot, and I don't want to spoil them. I think the closest I can get in a spoiler-free review is that A Man Called Ove is about empathy. It's about human connection, even when people seem unlikable, unreachable, or angrily off-putting. And it's a book about seeing the best inside other people, and about finding ways to be persistently oneself while still changing enough to find new connections, and about recognizing those moments when someone is showing you their best without getting caught up on the surface presentation. The man Ove is the center of this story, the subject of tight third person perspective for nearly all of the book. He's 59 when the story opens, but by the end of the book, mostly through flashback chapters, the reader knows his childhood and early adulthood and much of the story of his marriage. At first, he seems to be an obnoxious, surly, angry curmudgeon, the sort of old man who yells at clouds. But the joy of this book is how the reader's perception changes, how one gains sympathy, and then respect, first for Ove's unshakable inner sense of morality that he got from his father and then for his rule-based approach to how the world should work. One never entirely agrees with him, but Backman demystifies and explains Ove's thought process and ties it into a different generation and a different way of interacting with work (although Ove was still uncommon even in his youth, just not as unique). As I write this review, news and opinion in the United States are very focused on the plight of the white working class and how that does or does not explain recent election results. Backman is Swedish (I read this book in translation), so it's not coming from US culture and the cultural fault lines are not quite the same. But I think this book says something deeply valuable and fascinating about the working-class culture of Ove's youth, something that's much less about specific politics and much more about how it feels to make things with one's hands, to build or rebuild one's own house, or to work for thirty years at the same job and not be interested in a promotion to management. Backman does a truly spectacular job conveying the sense of angry frustration at the changes in work and life, the difficulty communicating one's internal feelings meaningfully, and the quiet joy of finding those places in life where one can do things properly. Ove is, of course, not the only character in this book, and every character here is a delight in their own idiosyncratic ways. The main story arc involves the various people in his neighborhood, particularly his new next-door neighbors: a pregnant Iranian woman and her very laid-back husband who is incapable of doing things around the house but keeps trying. I think Parvaneh, the woman, is my favorite character of the story except for Ove, and it's fitting that she's the first to work out the broad outlines of what's happening in Ove's life and the tricky path to effectively helping him. In a way, she's Ove's opposite: fiery, mercurial, talkative, and meddling. But she sees things in Ove that no one else seems to notice. (And the scene between her and Ove when she's learning to drive is a thing of beauty.) This is a book that could have been extremely sad, and yet isn't. It's a book about somber, depressing topics that somehow manages to be delightfully funny. And it's about a curmudgeon who persistently fails to have any sort of stereotyped heart of gold, but is nonetheless one of the most satisfying, fascinating, ethical, and good-willed characters I've ever read about. It manages to treat a collection of very different characters with individualized deep empathy and appreciation, while never pushing them all into the same mold. And the ending is wonderful. I rarely read slice of life stories, but this one is worth making an exception for. It's one of the best books I've ever read. Highly, highly recommended. Rating: 10 out of 10

Russ Allbery: Review: A Man Called Ove

Review: A Man Called Ove, by Fredrik Backman
Translator: Henning Koch
Publisher: Washington Square
Copyright: 2012, 2014
Printing: May 2015
ISBN: 1-4767-3802-5
Format: Trade paperback
Pages: 337
Ove is 59 years old and drives a Saab. He's grumpy, often taciturn, very particular in how things should be done, and extremely judgmental about how other people do them. He is the sort of person who regularly rants about how poorly things are done these days and how much better they used to be. Ove does not like change. A Man Called Ove opens with him terrorizing the employees of an Apple Store, trying to buy a computer, but this incident is actually foreshadowing, and will only make sense at the very end of the book. The story actually begins in the second chapter, with Ove making his morning rounds of the neighborhood in which he lives, discovering an out-of-place bicycle and a mangy cat, and then starting to put a hook in his ceiling. But just as he's getting started, he's interrupted by new neighbors, who are incapable of backing up a trailer properly without scraping it against his house. Not that motor vehicles are allowed in the area anyway. That inauspicious beginning changes Ove's life, mostly through the sheer persistence of other people's disasters. It's not obvious at first that it will, and at the start A Man Called Ove could be a funny collection of stories about a curmudgeon. But as Backman shows more of Ove's life and tells more of his background and situation, it becomes something so much more, something satisfying and heart-breaking and deeply human. I've been struggling to review this book because I find it hard to capture what makes it so wonderful. Making that even harder, several key plot elements are introduced gradually in the story in ways that add a lot to the rhythm of the plot, and I don't want to spoil them. I think the closest I can get in a spoiler-free review is that A Man Called Ove is about empathy. It's about human connection, even when people seem unlikable, unreachable, or angrily off-putting. And it's a book about seeing the best inside other people, and about finding ways to be persistently oneself while still changing enough to find new connections, and about recognizing those moments when someone is showing you their best without getting caught up on the surface presentation. The man Ove is the center of this story, the subject of tight third person perspective for nearly all of the book. He's 59 when the story opens, but by the end of the book, mostly through flashback chapters, the reader knows his childhood and early adulthood and much of the story of his marriage. At first, he seems to be an obnoxious, surly, angry curmudgeon, the sort of old man who yells at clouds. But the joy of this book is how the reader's perception changes, how one gains sympathy, and then respect, first for Ove's unshakable inner sense of morality that he got from his father and then for his rule-based approach to how the world should work. One never entirely agrees with him, but Backman demystifies and explains Ove's thought process and ties it into a different generation and a different way of interacting with work (although Ove was still uncommon even in his youth, just not as unique). As I write this review, news and opinion in the United States are very focused on the plight of the white working class and how that does or does not explain recent election results. Backman is Swedish (I read this book in translation), so it's not coming from US culture and the cultural fault lines are not quite the same. But I think this book says something deeply valuable and fascinating about the working-class culture of Ove's youth, something that's much less about specific politics and much more about how it feels to make things with one's hands, to build or rebuild one's own house, or to work for thirty years at the same job and not be interested in a promotion to management. Backman does a truly spectacular job conveying the sense of angry frustration at the changes in work and life, the difficulty communicating one's internal feelings meaningfully, and the quiet joy of finding those places in life where one can do things properly. Ove is, of course, not the only character in this book, and every character here is a delight in their own idiosyncratic ways. The main story arc involves the various people in his neighborhood, particularly his new next-door neighbors: a pregnant Iranian woman and her very laid-back husband who is incapable of doing things around the house but keeps trying. I think Parvaneh, the woman, is my favorite character of the story except for Ove, and it's fitting that she's the first to work out the broad outlines of what's happening in Ove's life and the tricky path to effectively helping him. In a way, she's Ove's opposite: fiery, mercurial, talkative, and meddling. But she sees things in Ove that no one else seems to notice. (And the scene between her and Ove when she's learning to drive is a thing of beauty.) This is a book that could have been extremely sad, and yet isn't. It's a book about somber, depressing topics that somehow manages to be delightfully funny. And it's about a curmudgeon who persistently fails to have any sort of stereotyped heart of gold, but is nonetheless one of the most satisfying, fascinating, ethical, and good-willed characters I've ever read about. It manages to treat a collection of very different characters with individualized deep empathy and appreciation, while never pushing them all into the same mold. And the ending is wonderful. I rarely read slice of life stories, but this one is worth making an exception for. It's one of the best books I've ever read. Highly, highly recommended. Rating: 10 out of 10

24 December 2016

Russ Allbery: rra-c-util 6.2

This is my general collection of utility functions, standard tests, and portability code, mostly for C but also including a fair bit of Perl these days. This release improves probing for GCC and Clang warning flags (thanks to Guillem Jover for a good hint there), adds a new is_file_contents test function to the Perl Test::RRA module for comparing whole files, and adds a new test that scans for non-https eyrie.org URLs in my documentation. It also fixes some issues with the Perl strictness test caused by not requiring a new enough version of Test::Strict. You can get the latest release from the rra-c-util distribution page.

Russ Allbery: Review: Warchild

Review: Warchild, by Karin Lowachee
Series: Warchild #1
Publisher: Warner Aspect
Copyright: April 2002
ISBN: 0-446-61077-1
Format: Mass market
Pages: 451
In a future world of deep space stations and starship trade routes, Jos Musey grew up on a merchant ship with a loving family and typical childhood companions. But, at the age of eight, his ship was taken by pirates and he's taken as a slave. That might have been the end of his story, but after a year of captivity he manages to escape during an alien attack on a distant frontier station. Jos then learns more than he ever expected to learn about the ongoing deep space war between the human military and the aliens and their human sympathizers. From both sides. Warchild feels so much like a collection of 1980s SF tropes that I'm a bit surprised it was published in 2002. Some of those have been part of SF well before the 1980s: the coming-of-age story of a child in space, deep-space combat and merchant fleets, pirates, and sketchy stations. But when one adds the Japanese-inspired philosophy and combat training, with a bit of Karate Kid feel, plus the (oddly bolted on) cyberpunk "burndiving," this book feels deeply embedded in a specific generation of SF storytelling. That's not necessarily a drawback. I like some of those tropes. The martial arts training coupled with careful and patient psychology worked very well for me. It may be a bit stereotyped, but Lowachee is careful to never present it as Asian; it's an alien philosophy and environment, and although it happens to wear its influences on its sleeves, it makes no attempt to tie that to any particular human culture. And the philosophy and, more to the point, the approach Niko takes with Jos is exactly what Jos needs. That section of the book (the second) was by far my favorite. I wish the whole book had been like that. Unfortunately, it's not. The first part is a deeply uncomfortable account of Jos's capture and enslavement (with bonus implied pedophilia). It's thankfully the shortest section of the book, but it's an endless parade of horrors that I didn't enjoy reading. Lowachee took the stylistic choice of writing it in the second person, which is a literary trick that rarely works for me and didn't work here. I'm sure the goal is to make it feel more immediate, but I didn't need this scene to be more immediate, and second person always reads as awkward and forced. If the authors write characters well, I will identify with them, but if I feel like I'm being forced to identify with them, I just start getting irritated. The third part of the book goes in yet a different direction: military SF, complete with hazing, camaraderie, esprit de corps, and bloody combat, with an uncomfortable undertone of constant stress due to Jos's complex and dangerous position. I wanted this to be much shorter and wanted the book to return to the part that I really liked. Unfortunately, that's not to be; the tone of this section is the tone for the rest of the book. To be fair, it's better than I expected it to be, and Jos's recovery and coming-of-age continues in more subtle and more satisfying ways than at first it seemed like it would. But Lowachee complicates and largely breaks a recovery that I was hoping would proceed down a more peaceful path, and replaced a beautiful and interesting (if a bit stereotyped) environment with bog-standard military SF. If you like that sort of thing, there's a lot of that thing here, but I've read a lot of books with that setting and far fewer about an Asian-inspired martial alien philosophy. I think Warchild has a bit too much stuff going on and not enough recovery space. The cyberpunk angle probably gets developed more in later books of the series (the next book is Burndive, which is the name for cyberpunk hacking in this book), but it felt bolted on here. Jos's story has multiple false starts and complications, and Lowachee keeps pulling the rug out from under him again until both he and the reader go a bit numb. The ending mostly works, but it's a brutal resolution to the complex psychological situation Lowachee sets up. This book reminds me a bit of C.J. Cherryh in that the characters seem constantly stressed beyond their ability to cope. I wanted something a bit kinder and softer. Despite that, the psychology and the brief moments of understanding and light are compelling enough that I'm still tempted to read on in this series. The subsequent books follow other characters; maybe they'll be a bit less nasty to their protagonists. Followed by Burndive. Rating: 6 out of 10

Russ Allbery: C TAP Harness 4.1

This is a minor release of my test framework for C packages. The only notable addition is a new is_bool function in the test library, which compares a boolean value to a desired value. This doesn't add any functionality over ok, but sometimes code reads more clearly (particularly when testing for an expected false value). Of note mostly to me, this is the first release with the documentation generated by DocKnot. You can get the latest version from the C TAP Harness distribution page.

17 December 2016

Russ Allbery: INN 2.6.1

(As usual, Julien finished this release a bit back, and then I got busy with life stuff and haven't gotten the announcement out.) This is a bug-fix and minor feature release over INN 2.6.0. The biggest change is adding support for the new COMPRESS extension. It also fixes various bugs around state changes when negotiating various compression or integrity layers and fixes some issues with nnrpd's validation of newly-posted messages. (Messages with Received and Posted headers are no longer rejected; messages with all-whitespace headers now are.) This release also supports OpenSSL 1.1.0 and fixes an nntpsend bug under systemd. As always, thanks to Julien LIE for preparing this release and doing most of the maintenance work on INN! You can get the latest version from the official ISC download page or from my personal INN pages. The latter also has links to the full changelog and the other INN documentation.

22 November 2016

Steve Langasek: A new chapter

I don't often write on this blog, and when I do, it's either tech related, or light life stuff. Over the next few weeks, it's going to get a lot more political. If you currently follow this blog for its technical content, you may be tempted to tune out. I would encourage you to stay and listen. I'm passionate about the technology that I work on; but the greatest problems facing our world today are not ones that will be solved with software. American democracy is in bad shape, and it's because of what we're doing to it. This is not a problem of the Right or of the Left; it is not a problem that began with the election of Donald Trump, and it's not a problem that will go away at the end of his term. It is partly a structural problem with the way our elections work, but more than that it's a problem of how we're splitting into separate tribes, isolating ourselves from those who don't agree with us. As Russ Allbery wrote the morning after the election, everything about how we organize ourselves online today - and how we let Facebook and Twitter organize us - leads us to surround ourselves with people who already think the same way we do. That leaves all of us with huge blind spots for other people in our country, and it stifles the free exchange of ideas that is so essential for a healthy democracy. We need leaders who will work to make America a better and more just place for all our neighbors, not just a two-party system that plays tug-of-war using two different sets of voters that feel shut out. And the way we organize ourselves today (online and off) does not let us recognize those leaders. There's a lot of talk now about Facebook changing how it decides what to show people; and maybe they can manage to help everyone's online experience be a little less of a bubble. But part of the change needs to come from us. We need to be willing to engage, civilly, with people whose perspective is different from ours, and make the effort to understand where the other is coming from. So for the next few weeks, I'm going to talk. And I'm going to listen. I have no unique qualifications to speak about the country's issues. But I do have a perspective of my own, which might be different enough from yours to be useful. I was born and raised in Iowa, and graduated from college there. This election cycle, I learned that Iowa holds the distinction of being the state with the lowest percentage of college-educated whites. I'm part of that statistic, because a few years after graduating I moved to Portland, Oregon - a place that's notoriously so far to the left of what we think of as the middle, that it actually has anarchists who would shamefully use a peaceful protest as cover to commit property crime. So I know a few things about the people in each state, that I think the other should hear. I'm also that rarest of creatures, a Portlander who goes to church (Catholic). But I still choose as my neighbors the weird, wonderful, and welcoming community that we have here, whatever Glenn Beck might think. I have a son, and I worry about what kind of world he'll grow up to live in. I work in software, which means I'm doing a lot better than a lot of people in the country right now; it also means that from where I sit, I see trends already in progress that will have an effect on the working class and the middle class that makes NAFTA look like a gnat's fart in comparison. And so I worry for what kind of world we will all live in, if we don't make some changes fast. Let's have a conversation. No comments enabled on this blog, but you can find me on G+ or on Facebook.

16 November 2016

Russ Allbery: Review: The Philosopher Kings

Review: The Philosopher Kings, by Jo Walton
Series: Thessaly #2
Publisher: Tor
Copyright: June 2015
ISBN: 0-7653-3267-1
Format: Hardcover
Pages: 345
Despite the cliffhanger at the end of The Just City, The Philosopher Kings doesn't pick up immediately afterwards. Argh. It's a great book (as I'm about to describe), but I really wanted to also read that book that happened in between. Still, this is the conclusion to the problem posed in The Just City, and I wouldn't recommend reading this book on its own (or, really, either book separate from the other). Despite the unwanted gap, and another change at the very start of the book that I won't state explicitly since it's a spoiler but that made me quite unhappy (despite driving the rest of the plot), this is much closer to the book that I wanted to read. Walton moves away from the SF philosophical question that drove much of the second half of The Just City in favor of going back to arguments about human organization, the nature of justice, choices between different modes of life, and the nature of human relationships. Those were the best parts of The Just City, and they're elaborated here in some fascinating ways that wouldn't have been possible in the hothouse environment of the previous book. I also thought Apollo was more interesting here than in the previous book. Still somewhat infuriating, particularly near the start, but I felt like I got more of what Walton was trying for, and more of what Apollo was attempting to use this existence to understand. And, once the plot hits its stride towards the center of the book, I started really liking Apollo. I guess it took a book and a half for him to mature enough to be interesting. A new viewpoint character, Arete, gets most of the chapters in this book, rather than following the pattern of The Just City and changing viewpoint characters every chapter. Her identity is a spoiler for The Just City, so I'll leave that a mystery. She's a bit more matter-of-fact and observational than Maia, but she does that thing that I love in Walton's characters: take an unexpected, fantastic situation, analyze and experiment with it, and draw some practical and matter-of-fact conclusions about how to proceed. I think that's the best way to describe this entire series: take a bunch of honest, thoughtful, and mostly good people, put them into a fantastic situation (at first Plato's Republic, a thought experiment made real, and then some additional fantasy complexities), and watch them tackle that situation like reasonable human beings. There is some drama, of course, because humans will disagree and will occasionally do awful, or just hurtful, things to each other. But the characters try to defuse the drama, try to be thoughtful and fair and just in their approach, and encourage change, improvement, and forgiveness in others. I don't like everyone in these books, but the vast majority of them are good people (and the few who aren't stand out), and there's something satisfying in reading about them. And the philosophical debate is wonderful throughout this book (which I'm not saying entirely because the characters have a similar reaction to a newly-introduced philosophical system as I did as a reader, although that certainly helps). I'm not saying much about the plot since so much would spoil the previous book. But Walton adds some well-done complexities and complications, and while I was dubious about them at the start of the book, I definitely came around. I enjoyed watching the characters reinvent some typical human problems, but still come at them from a unique and thoughtful angle and come up with some novel solutions. And the ending took me entirely by surprise, in a very good way. It's better than the best ending I could have imagined for the book, providing some much-needed closure and quite a bit of explanation. (And, thankfully, does not end on another cliffhanger; in fact, I'm quite curious to see what the third book is going to tackle.) Recommended, including the previous book, despite the bits that irritated me. Followed by Necessity. Rating: 9 out of 10

15 November 2016

Russ Allbery: Review: The Broken Kingdoms

Review: The Broken Kingdoms, by N.K. Jemisin
Series: Inheritance #2
Publisher: Orbit
Copyright: November 2010
Printing: September 2011
ISBN: 0-316-04395-8
Format: Mass market
Pages: 395
The Broken Kingdoms is a fairly direct sequel to The Hundred Thousand Kingdoms and depends heavily on the end of that book. It had been a long time since I'd read the previous book (about five years), and I looked up plot summaries to remind myself what happened. It turned out that I probably didn't have to do that; the explanation does come when it's critical. But this book will definitely spoil the end of The Hundred Thousand Kingdoms. Oree is an artist who sells her work to tourists in Shadow, the city beneath the World Tree. It's a good enough living, particularly for a blind immigrant from Nimaro, the area settled by the survivors of the destruction of Maro. Oree is not strictly entirely blind, since she can see magic, but that's not particularly helpful in daily life. She's content to keep that quiet, along with her private paintings that carry a strange magic not found in her public trinkets. One of the many godlings who inhabit Shadow is Oree's former lover, so she has some connection to the powerful of the city. But she prefers her quiet life until, that is, she finds a man at sunrise in a pile of muck and takes him home to clean him up. A man who she ends up taking care of, despite the fact that he never speaks to her, and despite his total lack of desire or apparent capability to take care of himself or avoid any danger. Not that it seems to matter, since he comes back to life every time he dies. If you've read The Hundred Thousand Kingdoms, you have a pretty good guess at who the man Oree calls Shiny actually is. But that discovery is not the core plot of this book. Someone is killing the godlings. They're not immortal, although they don't age, but killing them should require immense power or the intervention of the Three, the gods who run the metaphysical universe of this series. Neither of those seem to be happening, and still godlings are being murdered. Nahadoth is not amused: the humans and godlings have one month to find the killer before he does something awful to all of them. Then Shiny somehow kills a bunch of priests of Itempas, and the Order is after both him and Oree. Desperate, she turns to her former boyfriend and the godlings for help, and is pulled into the heart of a dark conspiracy. The Broken Kingdoms adds a few new elements to Jemisin's world-building, although it never quite builds up to the level of metaphysics of the previous book. But it's mostly a book about Oree: her exasperated care of Shiny, her attempts to navigate her rapidly complicating life, and her determination to do the right thing for her friends. It's the sort of book that pits cosmic power and grand schemes against the determined inner morality of a single person who is more powerful than she thinks she is. That part of the story I liked quite a lot. Shiny, and Oree's complicated relationship with Shiny, I wasn't as fond of. Oree treats him like a broken and possibly healing person, which is true, but he's also passively abusive in his dark moping. Jemisin tries very hard throughout the book to help the reader try to grasp a bit of what must be going through Shiny's head, and she does succeed at times, but I never much cared for what I found there. And neither Nahadoth nor Yeine, when they finally make their appearance, are very likable. (Yeine in particular I found deeply disappointing and not up to her level of ethics in the first book.) Oree is still quite capable of carrying the story single-handed, and I did like her godling friends. But I felt like the ending required liking Shiny a lot more than I did, or being a lot more sympathetic to Nahadoth and Yeine than I was, and it left a bad taste in my mouth. I enjoyed reading about Oree, but I felt like this story gave her a remarkably depressing ending. This book is also structured with a long middle section where everything seems to get more and more horrible and the antagonists are doing awful things. It's a common structural way to build tension that I rarely like. Even knowing that there's doubtless an upward arc and protagonist triumph coming, those sections are often unpleasant and difficult to read through, and I had that reaction here. The Broken Kingdoms is less of a weird romance than The Hundred Thousand Kingdoms (although there is some romance), so you may enjoy it more if you thought that angle was overdone. It does have some interesting world-building, particularly at the godling level, and Lil is one of my favorite characters. I think Oree got a raw deal from the story and would have preferred a different ending, but I'm not sorry I read it. Followed by The Kingdoms of Gods. Rating: 7 out of 10

9 November 2016

Russ Allbery: Some thoughts on the US elections

I apparently am not going to get anything done today until I write this. Some thoughts, in no particular order. I don't have any profound conclusions. I'm honestly pretty upset. And pretty scared. But we have to talk to each other. And we have to listen to each other. And we have to persaude each other. And we have to be willing to be persuaded. And please go tell someone this morning that you have their back.

6 November 2016

Russ Allbery: Review: Digger

Review: Digger, by Ursula Vernon
Publisher: Sofawolf
Copyright: October 2013
ISBN: 1-936689-32-4
Format: Graphic novel
Pages: 837
As Digger opens, the eponymous wombat is digging a tunnel. She's not sure why, or where to, since she hit a bad patch of dirt. It happens sometimes, underground: pockets of cave gas and dead air that leave one confused and hallucinating. But this one was particularly bad, it's been days, she broke into a huge cave system, and she's thoroughly lost. Tripping on an ammonite while running from voices in the dark finally helps her come mostly to her senses and start tunneling up, only to break out at the feet of an enormous statue of Ganesh. A talking statue of Ganesh. Digger is a web comic that ran from 2005 to 2011. The archives are still on the web, so you can read the entire saga for free. Reviewed here is the complete omnibus edition, which collects the entire strip (previously published in six separate graphic novels containing two chapters each), a short story, a bonus story that was published in volume one, a bunch of random illustrated bits about the world background, author's notes from the web version, and all of the full-color covers of the series chapters (the rest of the work is in black and white). Publication of the omnibus was originally funded by a Kickstarter, but it's still available for regular sale. (I bought it normally via Amazon long after the Kickstarter finished.) It's a beautiful and durable printing, and I recommend it if you have the money to buy things you can read for free. This was a very long-running web comic, but Digger is a single story. It has digressions, of course, but it's a single coherent work with a beginning, middle, and end. That's one of the impressive things about it. Another is that it's a fantasy work involving gods, magic, oracles, and prophecies, but it's not about a chosen one, and it's not a coming of age story. Digger (Digger-of-Needlessly-Convoluted-Tunnels, actually, but Digger will do) is an utterly pragmatic wombat who considers magic to be in poor taste (as do all right-thinking wombats), gods to be irritating underground obstacles that require care and extra bracing, and prophecies to not be worth the time spent listening to them. It's a bit like the famous Middle Earth contrast between the concerns of the hobbits and the affairs of the broader world, if the hobbits were well aware of the broader world, able to deal with it, but just thought all the magic was tacky and irritating. Magic and gods do not, of course, go away just because one is irritated by them, and Digger eventually has to deal with quite a lot of magic and mythology while trying to figure out where home is and how to get back to it. However, she is drawn into the plot less by any grand danger to the world and more because she keeps managing to make friends with everyone, even people who hate each other. It's not really an explicit goal, but Digger is kind-hearted, sensible, tries hard to do the right thing, and doesn't believe in walking away from problems. In this world, that's a recipe for eventual alliances from everything from warrior hyenas to former pirate shrews, not to mention a warrior cult, a pair of trolls, and a very confused shadow... something. All for a wombat who would rather be digging out a good root cellar. (She does, at least, get a chance to dig out a good root cellar.) The characters are the best part, but I love everything about this story. Vernon's black and white artwork isn't as detailed as, say, Dave Sim at his best, and some of the panels (particularly mostly dark ones) seemed a bit scribbly. But it's mostly large-panel artwork with plenty of room for small touches and Easter eggs (watch for the snail, and the cave fish graffiti that I missed until it was pointed out by the author's notes), and it does the job of telling the story. Honestly, I like the black and white panels better than the color chapter covers reproduced in the back. And the plot is solid and meaty, with a satisfying ending and some fantastic detours (particularly the ghosts). I think my favorite bits, though, are the dialogue.
"Do you have any idea how long twelve thousand years is?"
"I know it's not long enough to make a good rock."
Digger is snarky in all the right ways, and sees the world in terms of tunnels, digging, and geology. Vernon is endlessly creative in how she uses that to create comebacks, sayings, analysis, and an entire culture. This is one of the best long-form comics I've read: a solid fantasy story with great characters, reliably good artwork, a coherent plot arc, wonderful dialogue, a hard-working and pragmatic protagonist (who happens to be female), and a wonderfully practical sense of morality and ethics. I'm sorry it's over. If you've not already read it, I highly recommend it. Remember tunnel 17! Rating: 9 out of 10

5 November 2016

Russ Allbery: podlators 4.09

This package contains the Pod::Man and Pod::Text formatters for Perl. This is a bug-fix release that fixes a long-standing problem with Pod::Text on EBCDIC systems. The code to handle non-breaking spaces and soft hyphens hard-coded the ASCII code points and deleted the open bracket character on EBCDIC systems. The fix here adopts the same fix that was done in Pod::Simple (but with backward compatibility to older versions of Pod::Simple). I also made a bit more progress on modernizing the test suite. All of the Pod::Man tests now use a modern coding style, and most of them have been moved to separate snippets, which makes it easier to look at the intended input and output and to create new tests. You can get the latest version from the podlators distribution page.

Russ Allbery: Review: The Just City

Review: The Just City, by Jo Walton
Series: Thessaly #1
Publisher: Tor
Copyright: 2014
Printing: January 2015
ISBN: 0-7653-3266-3
Format: Hardcover
Pages: 368
The premise for The Just City is easy to state: The time-traveling goddess Athene (Athena) decides to organize and aid an attempt to create the society described in Plato's Republic. She chooses Thera (modern Santorini) before the eruption, as a safe place where this experiment wouldn't alter history. The elders of the city are seeded by people throughout history who at some point prayed to Athene, wanting to live in the Republic. The children of the age of ten that Plato suggested starting with are purchased as slaves from various points in history and transported by Athene to the island. Apollo, shaken and confused by Daphne wanting to turn into a tree rather than sleep with him, finds out about this experiment as Athene tries to explain the concept of consent to him. He decides that becoming human for a while might help him learn about volition and equal significance, and that this is the perfect location. He's one of the three viewpoint characters. The others are two women: one (Maia) from Victorian times who prayed to Athene in a moment of longing for the tentative sexual equality of the Republic and was recruited as one of the elders, and another (Simmea) who is bought as a slave and becomes one of the children. I should admit up-front that I've never read Plato's Republic, or indeed much of Plato at all, just small bits for classes. The elders (and of course the gods) all have, and are attempting to stick quite closely to Plato's outline of the ideal city. The children haven't, though, so the book is quite readable for people like me who only remember a few vague aspects of Plato's vision from school. The reader learns the principles alongside Simmea. One of Walton's strengths is taking a science fiction concept, putting real people into it, and letting the quotidian mingle with the fantastic. Simmea is my favorite character here: her journey to the city is deeply traumatic, but the opportunity she gets there is incredible and unforeseen, and she comes to love the city while still understanding, and arguing about, its possible flaws. Maia is nearly as successful; Walton does a good job with committee debates and discussions, avoids coming down too heavily on the drama, and shows a believable picture of people with very different backgrounds and beliefs coming together to flesh out the outlines of something they all agree with, or at least want to try. I found Apollo less engaging as a character, partly because I never quite understood his motives or his weird failure to understand the principles of consent. Walton doesn't portray him as either hopelessly arrogant or hopelessly narcissistic, which would have been easy outs, but in avoiding those two obvious explanations for his failures of empathy, I felt like she left him with an odd and unexplained hole in his personality. He's a weirdly passive half-character for much of the book, although he does develop a bit more towards the end (which was probably the point). Half the fun of this book is working out what the Republic would be like in practice, and what breakdowns and compromises would happen as soon as you put real people in it. Athene obviously has to do a bit of cheating to make a utopia invented as an intellectual exercise work out in practice, plus a bit more for comfort (electricity and indoor plumbing, for instance). The most substantial cheat is robots to replace slaves and do quite a bit that slaves couldn't. Birth control (something Plato obviously never would have thought of) is another notable cheat; it's postulated to be an ancient method since lost, but even if that existed, there's no way it would be this reliable. But otherwise, the society mostly works, and Walton shows enough of the arguing and mechanics to make that believable, while still avoiding infodumps and boring descriptions. It's neatly done, although I'm still a bit dubious that the elders from later eras would have put up with the primitive conditions with this little complaint. The novel needs a plot, of course, and that's the other half of the fun. I can't talk about this in any detail without spoiling the book, since the plot only kicks in about halfway through once the setup and character introductions are complete. That makes it hard to explain why I found this a bit less successful, although parts of it are brilliant. What worked for me is the growth of Simmea and her friends as students and philosophers, the arguments and discussions (and their growing enthusiasm for argument and discussion), and the way Greek mythology is woven subtly and undramatically into the story. It really does feel like sitting in on ancient Greek philosophical arguments and experiments, and by that measure Walton has succeeded admirably in her goal. What didn't work for me was the driving conflict of the story, once it's introduced. I can't describe it without spoilers, but it's an old trope in science fiction and one with little scientific basis. It may seem weird to argue that point in a book with time-traveling Greek gods, a literal Lethe, and a Greek idea of souls, but those are mythological background material. The SF trope is something about which I have personal expertise and which simply doesn't work that way, and I had a harder time getting past that than alternate metaphysical properties. It threw me out of the book a bit. I see why Walton chose the conflict she did, but I felt like she could have gotten to the same place in the plot, admittedly with more difficulty, by using some of the more dubious aspects of Plato's long-term plan plus some other obstacles that were already built into the world. This more direct approach added a bit of SF-style analysis of the unknown that seemed weirdly at odds with the rest of the story (even if the delight of one of the characters is endearing). That complaint aside, I really enjoyed reading this book. Apollo didn't entirely work for me, but all of the other characters are excellent, and Walton keeps the story moving at a comfortable clip. Given the amount of description required, particularly for an audience that may not have read the Republic, a lesser writer could have easily slipped into the infodump trap. Walton never does. Fair warning, though: The Just City does end on a cliffhanger, and is in no way a standalone novel. You will probably want to have the sequel on hand. Followed by The Philosopher Kings. Rating: 7 out of 10

Russ Allbery: Fall haul post

It's been a while since I've done one of these. danah boyd It's Complicated (non-fiction)
Jeffrey A. Carver Eternity's End (sff)
Becky Chambers A Closed and Common Orbit (sff)
Stephen Deas The Adamantine Palace (sff)
Robert Heinlein The Green Hills of Earth / The Menace from Earth (sff)
Robert Heinlein Revolt in 2100 / Methuselah's Children (sff)
Marjorie M. Liu The Iron Hunt (sff)
Larry Niven The Ringworld Engineers (sff)
Don Norman The Design of Everyday Things (non-fiction)
Kurt Vonnegut Slaughterhouse-Five (sff)
Jo Walton Necessity (sff)
Eileen Wilks Tempting Danger (sff) I picked up some extra used books since I was placing a book order to pick up Necessity anyway, and fleshed out my early Heinlein novels mostly out of curiousity. I've already reviewed The Design of Everyday Things, which I got from the work book club.

28 October 2016

Russ Allbery: Term::ANSIColor 4.06

A small maintenance release to my Perl module for generating and manipulating ANSI color escape sequences. In 4.00, I added 256-color support, using ansi0 through ansi15 for the colors that match the normal 16 colors and then rgbNNN and greyN names for the RGB and greyscale colors. One module user requested the ability to address all of the colors via ansi0 through ansi255 so that there's a consistent naming scheme for all the colors. This release adds that. (The more specific names are still returned by uncolor() when reversing escape sequences.) This module tends to get included all over the place, so I did spend a bit of time when preparing this release trying to determine if adding a bunch more entries to various internal hash tables and arrays would noticably increase memory usage, since Perl is notoriously bad about memory consumption. It does cause a small increase, but it's on the order of about 100KB, and a minimum Perl program to load the module requires about 5.5MB of memory (aie), so it wasn't enough for me to do anything about. It does look like if I lazily added entries to the built-in hash tables and instead added some more code to calculate escape sequences on the fly, I could save about 300KB of memory usage in the module. Not sure if it's worth it given how small the memory usage is compared to Perl itself, but maybe I'll look at that later when I'm feeling like fiddling with the module again. (Oh, and all the documentation was regenerated by DocKnot, since I'm still having fun with that. It needed a few new features, which will be in an upcoming 1.01 release.) You can get the latest version from the Term::ANSIColor distribution page.

27 October 2016

Russ Allbery: DocKnot 1.00

I'm a bit of a perfectionist about package documentation, and I'm also a huge fan of consistency. As I've slowly accumulated more open source software packages (alas, fewer new ones these days since I have less day-job time to work on them), I've developed a standard format for package documentation files, particularly the README in the package and the web pages I publish. I've iterated on these, tweaking them and messing with them, trying to incorporate all my accumulated wisdom about what information people need. Unfortunately, this gets very tedious, since I have dozens of packages at this point and rarely want to go through the effort of changing every one of them every time I come up with a better way of phrasing something or change some aspect of my standard package build configuration. I also have the same information duplicated in multiple locations (the README and the web page for the package). And there's a lot of boilerplate that's common for all of my packages that I don't want to keep copying (or changing when I do things like change all eyrie.org URLs to HTTPS). About three years ago, I started seriously brainstorming ways of automating this process. I made a start on it during one self-directed day at my old job at Stanford, but only got it far enough to generate a few basic files. Since then, I keep thinking about it, keep wishing I had it, and keep not putting the work into finishing it. During this vacation, after a week and a half of relaxing and reading, I finally felt like doing a larger development project and finally started working on this for long enough to build up some momentum. Two days later, and this is finally ready for an initial release. DocKnot uses metadata (which I'm putting in docs/metadata) that's mostly JSON plus some documentation fragments and generates README, the web page for the package (in thread, the macro language I use for all my web pages), and (the other thing I've wanted to do and didn't want to tackle without this tool) README.md, a Markdown version of README that will look nice on GitHub. The templates that come with the package are all rather specific to me, particularly the thread template which would be unusable by anyone else. I have no idea if anyone else will want to use this package (and right now the metadata format is entirely undocumented). But since it's a shame to not release things as free software, and since I suspect I may need to upload it to Debian since, technically, this tool is required to "build" the README file distributed with my packages, here it is. I've also uploaded it to CPAN (it's my first experiment with the App::* namespace for things that aren't really meant to be used as a standalone Perl module). You can get the latest version from the DocKnot distribution page (which is indeed generated with DocKnot). Also now generated with DocKnot are the rra-c-util and C TAP Harness distribution pages. Let me know if you see anything weird; there are doubtless still a few bugs.

25 October 2016

Russ Allbery: Review: Lord of Emperors

Review: Lord of Emperors, by Guy Gavriel Kay
Series: Sarantine Mosaic #2
Publisher: Eos
Copyright: 2000
Printing: February 2001
ISBN: 0-06-102002-8
Format: Mass market
Pages: 560
Lord of Emperors is the second half of a work that began with Sailing to Sarantium and is best thought of as a single book split for publishing reasons. You want to read the two together and in order. As is typical for this sort of two-part work, it's difficult to review the second half without spoilers. I'll be more vague about the plot and the characters than normal, and will mark one bit that's arguably a bit of a spoiler (although I don't think it would affect the enjoyment of the book). At the end of Sailing to Sarantium, we left Crispin in the great city, oddly and surprisingly entangled with some frighteningly powerful people and some more mundane ones (insofar as anyone is mundane in a Guy Gavriel Kay novel, but more on that in a bit). The opening of Lord of Emperors takes a break from the city to introduce a new people, the Bassanids, and a new character, Rustem of Karakek. While Crispin is still the heart of this story, the thread that binds the entirety of the Sarantine Mosaic together, Rustem is the primary protagonist for much of this book. I had somehow forgotten him completely since my first read of this series many years ago. I have no idea how. I mentioned in my review of the previous book that one of the joys of reading this series is competence porn: watching the work of someone who is extremely good at what they do, and experiencing vicariously some of the passion and satisfaction they have for their work. Kay's handling of Crispin's mosaics is still the highlight of the series for me, but Rustem's medical practice (and Strumosus, and the chariot races) comes close. Rustem is a brilliant doctor by the standards of the time, utterly frustrated with the incompetence of the Sarantine doctors, but also weaving his own culture's belief in omens and portents into his actions. He's more reserved, more laconic than Crispin, but is another character with focused expertise and a deep internal sense of honor, swept unexpectedly into broader affairs and attempting to navigate them by doing the right thing in each moment. Kay fills this book with people like that, and it's compelling reading. Rustem's entrance into the city accidentally sets off a complex chain of events that draws together all of the major characters of Sailing to Sarantium and adds a few more. The stakes are no less than war and control of major empires, and here Kay departs firmly from recorded history into his own creation. I had mentioned in the previous review that Justinian and Theodora are the clear inspirations for this story; that remains true, and many other characters are easy to map, but don't expect history to go here the way that it did in our world. Kay's version diverges significantly, and dramatically. But one of the things I love the most about this book is its focus on the individual acts of courage, empathy, and ethics of each of the characters, even when those acts do not change the course of empires. The palace intrigue happens, and is important, but the individual acts of Kay's large cast get just as much epic narrative attention even if they would never appear in a history book. The most globally significant moment of the book is not the most stirring; that happens slightly earlier, in a chariot race destined to be forgotten by history. And the most touching moment of the book is a moment of connection between two people who would never appear in history, over the life of a third, that matters so much to the reader only because of the careful attention to individual lives and personalities Kay has shown over the course of a hundreds of pages. A minor spoiler follows in the next paragraph, although I don't think it affects the reading of the book. One brilliant part of Kay's fiction is that he doesn't have many villains, and goes to some lengths to humanize the actions of nearly everyone in the book. But sometimes the author's deep dislike of one particular character shows through, and here it's Pertennius (the clear analogue of Procopius). In a way, one could say the entirety of the Sarantine Mosaic is a rebuttal of the Secret History. But I think Kay's contrast between Crispin's art (and Scortius's, and Strumosus's) and Pertennius's history has a deeper thematic goal. I came away from this book feeling like the Sarantine Mosaic as a whole stands in contrast to a traditional history, stands against a reduction of people to dates and wars and buildings and governments. Crispin's greatest work attempts to capture emotion, awe, and an inner life. The endlessly complex human relationships shown in this book running beneath the political events occasionally surface in dramatic upheavals, but in Kay's telling the ones that stay below the surface are just as important. And while much of the other art shown in this book differs from Crispin's in being inherently ephemeral, it shares that quality of being the art of life, of complexity, of people in dynamic, changing, situational understanding of the world, exercising competence in some area that may or may not be remembered. Kay raises to the level of epic the bits of history that don't get recorded, and, in his grand and self-conscious fantasy epic style, encourages the reader to feel those just as deeply as the ones that will have later historical significance. The measure of people, their true inner selves, is often shown in moments that Pertennius would dismiss and consider unworthy of recording in his history. End minor spoiler. I think Lord of Emperors is the best part of the Sarantine Mosaic duology. It keeps the same deeply enjoyable view of people doing things they are extremely good at while correcting some of the structural issues in the previous book. Kay continues to use a large cast, and continues to cut between viewpoint characters to show each event from multiple angles, but he has a better grasp of timing and order here than in Sailing to Sarantium. I never got confused about the timeline, thanks in part to more frequent and more linear scene cuts. And Lord of Emperors passes, with flying colors, the hardest test of a novel with a huge number of viewpoint characters: when Kay cuts to a new viewpoint, my reaction is almost always "yes, I wanted to see what they were thinking!" and almost never "wait, no, go back!". My other main complaint about Sailing to Sarantium was the treatment of women, specifically the irresistibility of female sexual allure. Kay thankfully tones that down a lot here. His treatment of women is still a bit odd one notices that five women seem to all touch the lives of the same men, and little room is left for Platonic friendship between the genders but they're somewhat less persistently sexualized. And the women get a great deal of agency in this book, and a great deal of narrative respect. That said, Lord of Emperors is also emotionally brutal. It's beautifully done, and entirely appropriate to the story, and Kay does provide a denouement that takes away a bit of the sting. But it's still very hard to read in spots if you become as invested in the characters and in the world as I do. Kay is writing epic that borders on tragedy, and uses his full capabilities as a writer to make the reader feel it. I love it, but it's not a book that I want to read too often. As with nearly all Kay, the Sarantine Mosaic as a whole is intentional, deliberate epic writing, wearing its technique on its sleeve and making no apologies. There is constant foreshadowing, constant attempts to draw larger conclusions or reveal great principles of human nature, and a very open, repeated stress on the greatness and importance of events while they're being described. This works for me, but it doesn't work for everyone. If it doesn't work for you, the Sarantine Mosaic is unlikely to change your mind. But if you're in the mood for that type of story, I think this is one of Kay's best, and Lord of Emperors is the best half of the book. Rating: 10 out of 10

24 October 2016

Russ Allbery: Review: The Design of Everyday Things

Review: The Design of Everyday Things, by Don Norman
Publisher: Basic Books
Copyright: 2013
ISBN: 0-465-05065-4
Format: Trade paperback
Pages: 298
There are several editions of this book (the first under a different title, The Psychology of Everyday Things). This review is for the Revised and Expanded Edition, first published in 2013 and quite significantly revised compared to the original. I probably read at least some of the original for a class in human-computer interaction around 1994, but that was long enough ago that I didn't remember any of the details. I'm not sure how much impact this book has had outside of the computer field, but The Design of Everyday Things is a foundational text of HCI (human-computer interaction) despite the fact that many of its examples and much of its analysis is not specific to computers. Norman's goal is clearly to write a book that's fundamental to the entire field of design; not having studied the field, I don't know if he succeeded, but the impact on computing was certainly immense. This is the sort of book that everyone ends up hearing about, if not necessarily reading, in college. I was looking forward to filling a gap in my general knowledge. Having now read it cover-to-cover, would I recommend others invest the time? Maybe. But probably not. There are several things this book does well. One of the most significant is that it builds a lexicon and a set of general principles that provide a way of talking about design issues. Lexicons are not the most compelling reading material (see also Design Patterns), but having a common language is useful. I still remember affordances from college (probably from this book or something else based on it). Norman also adds, and defines, signifiers, constraints, mappings, and feedback, and talks about the human process of building a conceptual model of the objects with which one is interacting. Even more useful, at least in my opinion, is the discussion of human task-oriented behavior. The seven stages of action is a great systematic way of analyzing how humans perform tasks, where those actions can fail, and how designers can help minimize failure. One thing I particularly like about Norman's presentation here is the emphasis on the feedback cycle after performing a task, or a step in a task. That feedback, and what makes good or poor feedback, is (I think) an underappreciated part of design and something that too often goes missing. I thought Norman was a bit too dismissive of simple beeps as feedback (he thinks they don't carry enough information; while that's not wrong, I think they're far superior to no feedback at all), but the emphasis on this point was much appreciated. Beyond these dry but useful intellectual frameworks, though, Norman seems to have a larger purpose in The Design of Everyday Things: making a passionate argument for the importance of design and for not tolerating poor design. This is where I think his book goes a bit off the rails. I can appreciate the boosterism of someone who feels an aspect of creating products is underappreciated and underfunded. But Norman hammers on the unacceptability of bad design to the point of tedium, and seems remarkably intolerant of, and unwilling to confront, the reasons why products may be released with poor designs for their eventual users. Norman clearly wishes that we would all boycott products with poor designs and prize usability above most (all?) other factors in our decisions. Equally clearly, this is not happening, and Norman knows it. He even describes some of the reasons why not, most notably (and most difficultly) the fact that the purchasers of many products are not the eventual users. Stoves are largely sold to builders, not kitchen cooks. Light switches are laid out for the convenience of the electrician; here too, the motive for the builder to spend additional money on better lighting controls is unclear. So much business software is purchased by people who will never use it directly, and may have little or no contact with the people who do. These layers of economic separation result in deep disconnects of incentive structure between product manufacturers and eventual consumers. Norman acknowledges this, writes about it at some length, and then seems to ignore the point entirely, returning to ranting about the deficiencies of obviously poor design and encouraging people to care more about design. This seems weirdly superficial in this foundational of a book. I came away half-convinced that these disconnects of incentive (and some related problems, such as the unwillingness to invest in proper field research or the elaborate, expensive, and lengthy design process Norman lays out as ideal) are the primary obstacle in the way of better-designed consumer goods. If that's the case, then this is one of the largest, if not the largest, obstacle in the way of doing good design, and I would have expected this foundational of a book to tackle it head-on and provide some guidance for how to fight back against this problem. But Norman largely doesn't. There is some mention of this in the introduction. Apparently much of the discussion of the practical constraints on product design in the business world was added in this revised edition, and perhaps what I'm seeing is the limitations of attempting to revise an existing text. But that also implies that the original took an even harder line against poor design. Throughout, Norman is remarkably high-handed in his dismissal of bad design, focusing more on condemnation than on an investigation of why bad design might happen and what we, as readers, can learn from that process to avoid repeating it. Norman does provide extensive analysis of the design process and the psychology of human interaction, but still left me with the impression that he believes most design failures stem from laziness and stupidity. The negativity and frustration got a bit tedious by the middle of the book. There's quite a lot here that someone working in design, particularly interface design, should be at least somewhat familiar with: affordances, signifiers, the importance of feedback, the psychological model of tasks and actions, and the classification of errors, just to name a few. However, I'm not sure this book is the best medium for learning those things. I found it a bit tedious, a bit too arrogant, and weirdly unconcerned with feasible solutions to the challenge of mismatched incentives. I also didn't learn that much from it; while the concepts here are quite important, most of them I'd picked up by osmosis from working in the computing field for twenty years. In that way, The Design of Everyday Things reminded me a great deal of the Gang of Four's Design Patterns, even though it's a more readable book and less of an exercise in academic classification. The concepts presented are useful and important, but I'm not sure I can recommend the book as a book. It may be better to pick up the same concepts as you go, with the help of Internet searches and shorter essays. Rating: 6 out of 10

Next.

Previous.