Search Results: "ag"

13 November 2006

Jonathan McDowell: I ain't dead

Well, I've survived my stag weekend. I did have some fears I might not. TFM did a great job of arranging it; 15 of us ended up in 2 cottages at Park Farm Barns (most of us for Friday and Saturday, with a handful of us there until today). Paintball was played at Skirmish. Much meat was eaten (possibly the largest piece of beef I've seen up close). Much alcohol was consumed. And my arteries are going to take a while to recover from 3 mornings in a row of fried bacon for breakfast. All good though. Thanks to everyone who managed to make it.

Evan Prodromou: 21 Brumaire CCXV

Long day today (yesterday, actually, but I'm post-dating this in the interest of chronological flow). The baby's having a hard time coming off of West Coast time; she got up late and took a loooong nap till half-past three. Which was fine, because I needed the time to work on my NSLU2, which needed some attention. The NSLU2, or "Slug", is a tiny Linux computer from Linksys, about the size of a two packs of Marlboros laid side-by-side. My brother Nate gave me one last year for Christmas (thanks, nate), and I've been using it for network backups, but on our trip to SF Nate showed me that he's running all kinds of wild services off of his. So I decided to start shifting over some responsibilities to the little bugger. Which was just about time. Sometime during our trip to San Francisco, my main home server started having fan problems; it kept overheating and shutting itself down. It's going to take some time to diagnose the problem, but I figured that this was as good a time as any to move the critical services over to the Slug. The main one that needed budging was DNS. Maj's main domain, as well as my two .san-francisco.ca.us domains, run from home, because it's too hard to get the registrar to change them. The Unslung system I use for the Slug has a BIND package, which is a good thing to run, anyways. I was running MaraDNS on the big server, because I always root for the underdog, but there wasn't a MaraDNS package for the Slug. So I rewrote my zone files and things are up and running now. I don't know what else I'm going to put on there. Jabberd? Asterisk? A home wiki? Just not sure. tags:

Blah blah blah When the baby got up, we went to our local Loblaws, out towards the end of rue Rachel across from Canadian Tire. It's a pretty fantastic place to buy groceries -- it's the old CPR Angus Shops, a repair and maintenance facility for the Canadian Pacific Railway. The building is huge, with giant cranes and beams still attached to the roof. Amita and I grabbed a crapload of groceries and brought them home to Maj, who'd just had a massage at the centre around the corner and was feeling really good. She'd rented Tristram Shandy, the 2005 movie based on the 18th-century level-twisting novel. Me and Amita June made some baked potatoes, and we all watched the movie, and a good time was had. tags:
 

H****e en vrac One thing I always want to buy when I'm at the store in Quebec is the quite commonly available communion wafers. Yeah, really! big ol' 5-inches-diameter communion wafers, in the snack section next to the Doritos and the Humpty Dumpty potato chips. Quebec society has a had a precipitous secularization -- from around 90% church attendance in the 1950s to less than 10% today. But Catholicism still infuses all parts of life. For example, in Quebec, you cuss by using words from the church, including, of course, hostie ("the host"). So I can't figure out why hostie are a tasty snack treat. Is it a deliberate snub to the sacrament of communion by a secular society? Or did the practice antedate the Quiet Revolution, and did the formerly religious Quebecois eat communion wafers for fun? Or is it just a snork-snork funny thing to do, when the name of the food is actually a naughty word? I dunno. I'm fascinated, but not enough to buy a big bag of communion wafers to eat. (They're never cheese- or BBQ-flavored, by the way; they have a pristine seriousness to them.) More info solicited. tags:

Opinity One of the services mentioned in the Web 2.0 Summit infrastructure workshop was Opinity. Opinity seems to be a distributed reputation system, kind of like claimID but with a little more soft information. I think it looks pretty cool, and I'm glad to see another addition to the growing OpenID identity provider market. tags:

12 November 2006

Julien Danjou: Hacking in hostile env

I don't know why, but debmirror (or Perl ?) fails to work with Solaris. For example this code
     while(($res = $gunzf->gzreadline($line) > 0) 
           && !($line =~ /^$/))   
       $buf = $buf . $line; 
      
read the full buffer instead of reading a block of text separated by empty spaces...
Multiline matching (m//m) fails to work too. So I rewrote almost the full Packages.gz parser in a dirty Perl way for a friend, and it works. I 0\/\/N3d you, fucking OS. And there's people wanting to port Debian to that, good luck

John Goerzen: Desktop Linux: NFS or something else?

Recently, I asked for opinions on desktop Linux. Thanks very much to those that replied. I've set up an old laptop as an experiment. I'm using Debian, Gnome, and Systemimager. It's been an interesting project (especially getting SystemImager and a splash screen program to do what I want).

I'd like for my desktop machines to mount /home over the network. I could use NFS, but of course that has all the well-known security risks. Is there a better network filesystem that is easy to use, fast, and more secure than NFS?

Biella Coleman: The Limits of Technological Uses

In the past and for my hacker course, I have taught Paul Ceruzzi’s History of Modern Computing but the book was a little too dry to fly high with first year students but thanks to Joe Reagle’s excellent syllabus on the Impacts of Technology, I read a short but very sweet (and teachable) piece by him entitled An Unforseen Revolution: Computers and Epectations that not only gives a window into the early history of the computer but provides a very nice conceptual entry as to why it is hard for inventors of a new technology, such as the computer, to foresee and fully come to terms with its future uses, full range of capabilities, and utlimately its impact. Basically the context of invention combined with the training of inventors (which in this case, the first American digital computer, the ENIAC was invented by a physicst and an engineer for mathematical computing) stitches and thus initially limits the vision (and thus use) of the technology largely to its original purpose, while precedding technologies provide the conceptual juice drunk to understand the meaning of new technologlogies. So while today we clearly think of computers as a meta-machine, that can be whatever-machine-in-the-world-we-so-desire (so long as someone programs it to be that machine), in its time, with people so accustomed to machines as having one function, the cultural imagination was stuck. As Ceruzzie humorously conveys, a machine having such general capabilities seemed absurd, like a toaster that could sew buttons on a shirt. But the computer was just such a device; it could do many things its designers never anticipated. p. 126 With the passing of time came new innovations (Ceruzzi identifies new developments in programming as key in this regard) and use in new settings (notably businesses), the stitches were loosened and finally unraveled so that the computer came to take on the meaning it has acquired today. One perennial topic of inquiry in the field of STS concerns how particular contexts and other factors shape new meanings, visions, and uses, or just limit them, along with unearthing the labor that goes into making new inventions or scientific theories more generally accepted. This is a great little piece to teach incoming students about some of these concerns in STS, and without a lot of heavy-handed anything. And to make the project of teaching really fun, add this short clip from the Muppets, where Dr. Bunsen Honeydew totally ignores the Very Large Gorilla about to gobble him up because of his blind faith in technology.

Biella Coleman: Google-Diagnosis

While anyone who has had a 1) medical condition and 2) access to Internet in the last five years probably knows that patients are increasingly using the net (and now google) to diagnose medical conditions, it is only now that the medial establishment is starting to recognize or really admit to the reality of this widespread phenomenon and even doing studies on them, such as the one released a few days ago by the BJP Googling for a diagnosis use of Google as a diagnostic aid: internet
based study
. The study sought to ascertain how effective google was as an aid in medical diagnosis. As various new outfits are reporting it is moderately high. What I love about this study and the corollary reporting is the naive tone they have to assume, transmitting the news as if the public knew very little about this, and would in fact, be induced into surprise!!!!!!!!!! when first facing the new. But in fact, I think it works in the opposite way. The surprise is that they took so long to admit to what was in front of us for many years now. While the news articles reporting on the study stay within the province of doctors, the report acknowledges, in fact opens with, the fact that patients may be forging the path in Internet-diagnosis. The authors write in their second paragraph:
It seems that patients use Google to diagnose their own medical disorders too. After evaluating a 16 year old water polo player who presented with acute subclavain vein thrombosis, one of us (HT) started to explain that the cuase of the thrombosis was uncertain when the patients father blurted out But of course, he has paget-von Schrotter symdnome. Having previously googled the symptoms, he gave us a mini-tutorial.. and the correct treatment for the syndrome. This experience led us to ask How googe is google in helping doctors to reach the right diagnosis
Again, what I love about the tone of this opening is that it is as if these doctors stumbled on a great but deeply hidden fact to make a breath-taking discovery, one that, however, since is it is SO very emergent and thus still not *really* verified by Science, they must proceed with great caution, qualifying with phrasees like It seems that patients use Google to diagnose their own medical disorders too . I am sure they and most doctors are personally are not so na ve but since this has been something virtually without no official acknowledgment among professionals and in the journals, the genre of writing just requires it to be framed cautiously. As fun to read are the comments, for they stretch from moral panic:
The implication that ‘googling’ be an adjunct to proper medical school training, continuing medical education through courses and reading peer reviewed journals is laughable and bordering on dangerous. I am shocked that this has been published by the BMJ.
to celebration:
For the modern dermatologist, the internet is indispensible and google is only the start, and for this reason a desktop computer with high speed internet access is an essential tool for all clinicians. Long live the information superhighway!
While others muse on the broader emacipatory possibilities
One can imagine the benefit to young doctor in developing country who now have access to a grand medical library in their hands.
I am especially interested in this very dynamic because it is one pillar propping my next project on psychiatric survivors, which exceeds the particular topic of challenges to psychiatry in its general focus on medical/patient reconfigurations following from Intent-based activism, self-help, diagnosis, and critique. And for those who think I have made a radical departure from my last project, here is where I see one (of two or three) threads of continuity: for patients are generating an enormous amount of amateur knowledge, that I think is not unlike the peer-to-peer production of software hacking, and it is a form labor usually accompanied by a strong critique of expertise and other medical practices. I am now reading some literature on patient activism, like the issue from the February 2006 in Social Science and Medicine that collects 11 articles on patient organization movements. For those who work on this topic, the collection is worth your while and the editorial introduction by Kyra Landzelius is stellar. It is not only written beautifully (which I think is rare for these openings because it is often a rote, unimaginative regurgitation but this was a pleasure to read) but provides an engrossing overview of some new trends and some of the diverging forms of politics that arise from what is really a motley bunch of organizations and contests in patient and anti-patient activsm. She opens by defining four spheres that shape and inform the forms of contents that are part and parcel of these patient movements, the four being: 1. Revolutionary feats in technoscientific engineering
2. Restructuring of healthcare systems across industrialized nations
3. A Revised contract between science and the public stemming from a criss of confidence in science
4. An upsurge in the articulation and diversification of health activisms (p. 530) These four are key but I was shocked that there was no specific inclusion—though it comes out plenty in the introduction in other ways of the Internet. For while I am no techno-determinist, the Internet I think, can’t be ignored for it has fundamentally changed the map and tenor of patient activism, allowing for more rapid connections between various stakeholders, providing a medium by which those officially unrecognized illnesses are given shape and form, and where an ethical cultivation of self-help, self-diagnosis, self-medication, along with copious critique and forging of alternatives is happening, right before our eyes, virtually in real time. It is the medium by which a new chapter of patient activism is being written and I think it is a real mistake not to give it serious attention and credit. And perhaps one of the most interesting things about it is that it without it, it would leave many otherwise home-bound, sick folks, without a medium by which to engage in political activity or even community self-help, for let’s face it, these take a lot time and energy. When you are sick and home-bound, for example, there may be a limited number of types of engagements you literally have the energy to partiicpate in and the Internet lowers the barrier of political entry because of its ease and because you can still type away, even when feeling otherwise totally awful… This may be a brute material point but nonetheless, key to understanding the political power of the Internet. Now of course the question left is will Google capitalize on this and create “Google Diagnosis”?

Daniel Burrows: Close Encounters of the Automotive Kind

I got run over by a car on Wednesday.

Well, that's an exaggeration. My foot got run over by a car on Wednesday. I was trying to cross, in a crosswalk, in front of a red SUV that was stopped at a stop sign (my first mistake), when the driver suddenly decided to make a quick right turn. Luckily, I saw him start to do it and was able to jump out of the way of his vehicle -- except that I couldn't get my left foot out of the way in time. THUMP. And a few seconds later there was a SMACK as his passenger-side mirror creamed me, snapped off, and fell into the road.

The driver immediately realized what had happened and stopped to apologize. He offered me a ride; after quickly checking that my foot was NOT a mess of broken bones or a bloody pulp, I asked him to drive me to the bus stop. I was pretty shaken up from having just escaped death or major bodily injury by a matter of inches, so I didn't get his insurance information, name, phone number, or even license plate. Second mistake.

So, I got on the bus, flipped open my laptop to see if I could play a video game or something to calm down, and discovered that the screen of my practically new laptop was smashed. Probably it got hit by the passenger mirror -- and since I have no idea who hit me, I can't even politely ask him to pay for replacing it, let alone demand.

That's the bad news. The good news is that I went to a doctor and got a confirmation (with xrays) that no bones are broken in my foot. My foot and back are sore, but they're already quite a bit better than they were (I'm barely limping at all now) and the doctor said they should be fine in a week or two if I take it easy.

I suppose the whole thing was my fault, really; yeah, I had the legal right-of-way, but I should know by now that this is a meaningless concept; a driver who isn't signalling to you is always a potential hazard, especially in Seattle at rush hour.

The upshot of this, for people seeing this on Planet Debian, is that I probably won't be doing as much Debian work in the near future. I was using my laptop on the bus to catch up on emails and work on "easy" bugs, and I don't have the money to replace it right now (I probably won't until at least January, according to my back-of-the-envelope figuring). I can get some work done on weekends, but at an even more reduced pace than I've been able to since I got a paying job. :-(

Adam Rosi-Kessel: Toto, I Don't Think We're in Wikipedia Anymore

The last time I made any serious contributions to Wikipedia was back in 2001 or 2002. The community was exciting, friendly, and welcoming, and I enjoyed spreading the word as most non-technical people I knew had never heard of wikis or Wikipedia. Since then, I may have corrected the occasional typo or fixed a legal error, sometimes anonymously and sometimes under my account (apparently I “clarified the 13(c) protective arrangement issue” in the Urban Mass Transportation Act of 1970 back in the Fall of 2003, although I have no recollection of having done so), but I hadn’t started any new entries since the early days. At a recent presentation I attended by Sun’s Hal Stern, I learned that his eating club (Colonial Club) at Princeton University has a Wikipedia entry (as do all the other eating clubs). On further investigation, I learned there were no entries for any of the student cooperatives or other upperclassman eating options. To the uninitiated, it may be hard to understand why this matters beyond the insular Princeton community, but — suspend your disbelief just for a moment — the eating clubs have been called Princeton’s “peculiar institution” (a side-long reference to slavery) and have a storied and controversial history going back at least to the 1870’s (see, for example, this summary of the historical record from 1888-1993). It seemed to me that omitting the student cooperatives was akin to having a Wikipedia article on political parties that includes links to both the Republican and Democratic parties but leaves out any mention of the Green Party. Of course, the Green Party doesn’t wield the influence of either of the main parties, but its existence provides insight both into the American political system and the character of the two main parties. If no mention of the Green Party were included in Wikipedia, a foreign researcher attempting to learn about the American party system would come away with an incomplete and misleading understanding. The fact that the Green Party has not been particularly successful nationwide is, itself, interesting, useful, and relevant information. Although I wouldn’t pretend Princeton is as important or interesting as the American political system, it’s still a subject of scholarly investigation, and a topic that a fairly significant number of people are interested in learning about. I thought I would start basically a stub article for the Two Dickinson Street Co-op and spend a couple of days building it out and asking knowledgeable experts to contribute and add sources. Within a few seconds after I created the article, however, it was “speedily” deleted. A bit surprised, I tried to start an explanation as to why the entry warranted at least consideration for inclusion, and the article was deleted again and I found this message on my “talk” page:
This is your last warning.
The next time you vandalize a page, you will be blocked from editing Wikipedia. Diez2 14:55, 9 November 2006 (UTC)
I had gone from citizen to felon in two minutes flat! There then ensued several attempts to at least allow a debate on the deletion, but the article was unilaterally speedily deleted several times by several different editors. Even after one admin restored the article as not appropriate for “speedy deletion,” another admin stepped in and speedily deleted it again. I received some fairly acerbic retorts to my attempts — e.g. this: “We don’t have a page for every club in the world. If you want free web-hosting check out Myspace or usenet. Also anonymous postings do not make a topic notable or important.” (I’m not sure why he accused me of posting anonymously — I didn’t. Also, does “usenet” offer “free web-hosting?”) Finally, the deletion of the article was converted from a “speedy deletion” to a nomination as an “article for deletion” (‘AfD’), which allows at least for some discussion on the topic. The debate is ongoing — see it here — and some of the comments continue to be fairly corrosive. For example, one editor wrote:
Another editor called the debate a “pointless waste of time” over a “vanity article,” although I can’t find that comment any longer. I admit that I created the article without knowing much about the process, and certainly with little understanding of the numerous acronyms, flags, and the several different ways an article can be killed. Apparently, I didn’t contest the speedy deletion properly, although it wasn’t clear to me from the deletion notice exactly what I was supposed to do, and I assumed the restoration of the article by another admin meant that it would persist for at least a few days. I thus deserve some of the blame for not doing more pre-posting diligence, but I was relying for the most part on my 2001-2002 experience where you could create an article, spend a few days improving it, invite others to contribute, etc., and articles with a colorable argument for inclusion would generally stay in. It seems the new Wikipedia is a much less kind and less gentle Wikipedia. As another participant in the process wrote to me:
This whole situation is so strange. It makes me feel like I just stumbled into somebody else’s trench warfare. The defenders of notability! I wonder how long the constant vigilance of volunteers will hold out…
Of course, a similar phenomenon has occured with many open source projects. Initially, the doors are wide open and everyone’s contributions are, if not welcome, then at least tolerated. I suppose it is a sign of Wikipedia’s success that the front gates are locked so tightly. Still, I wonder how many potential good faith contributors are now permanently alienated by an initial bad experience such as this one, and whether Wikipedia will ultimately suffer from it. Low barriers to entry have traditionally been a key element to attracting participants to peer production efforts, but they seem to break down in direct relationship to the project’s external importance. Incidentally, Stern’s edit to the Colonial Club entry, mentioning F. Scott FitzGerald’s characterization of the club, was quickly reverted by another editor as “nonsense.”

Wouter Verhelst: Hardware support

A while back, my brother's computer had issues. It would dump core of random programs, and would produce a BSOD under Windows at random times, too. Running memtest86 showed that something was wrong with the memory, so we replaced it. Unfortunately, that didn't help; so the conclusion I made was that there was something wrong with something between the processor and the RAM—the cache (L1 or L2), some data or address line degrading, or perhaps even the memory controller. In any way, that didn't matter; what mattered is fixing the issue. So we replaced the mainboard and the processor with something newer. He's now got a pretty modern mainboard, with all the interesting bits and pieces found in such a thing, and a Dual Core Pentium4 at 3.4Ghz. Occasionally, I must say that the socket 775 is pretty... weird. But I digress. Upon installing everything, I found that trying to run the system with broken memory had managed to corrupt whatever was on the hard disk; his ReiserFS superblock thought the filesystem was some incredible amount larger than it really was, and Windows would turn up a BSOD before even booting. The first was pretty easy to fix; I hit 'e' in the grub menu, added init=/bin/bash to the end of the kernel command line, and instructed some tool from the reiserfs toolkit to fix the filesystem. After that finished, and after a subsequent exec /sbin/init finished, Debian was up and running again. That took all of a few minutes. Having booted it, I proceeded to install the security updates that had accumulated for Sarge since the time his system had started to break down (which is a few months). Then I realized that I had to reconfigure the system to understand the new mainboard. Only that had already happened. Hotplug, discover, and perhaps some friends, had all done their work and there was nothing to be done anymore. Isn't that nice. The same couldn't be said for Windows. Booting from the install medium and choosing "recovery" in the install menu didn't fix things. Even reinstalling the system without formatting the hard drive didn't get us any further. The only thing we could do was to wipe the drive clean and reinstall. Windows better hardware support? My ass.

Jorge Salamero Sanz: Gluz 2 almost finished !

Last friday we masterized last iso images of Gluz 2, the GNU/Linux distro of the University of Zaragoza. This morning I've been testing them out and look ok. Just a couple of stupid bugs, so I hope to make the oficial release tomorrow in the morning. It's based on Kubuntu dapper, with some customized apps: ubiquity and an auto-configurator for the KDE PIM in order to use the University mail, jabber and wireless network. You can download *only today* the beta images from my home in pulsar. And of course some screenshots here. Enjoy !

Ian Murdock

Eric Schmidt: Making it simple for users to walk away from a Google service with which they are unhappy keeps the company honest and on its toes, and Google competitors should embrace this data portability principle.

Andreas Barth: Experimental and autobuilding

Experimental is autobuild, but on an best-effort basis (which is a different thing than what happens with unstable). In other words, it can happen that a package is not build on all architectures, and nobody does anything to fix that. If that happens to one of your packages, please contact us (Martin Zobel or me), and we'll try to fix that. I just have rescheduled glibc in experimental on two architectures.

Evan Prodromou: 20 Brumaire CCXV

We're back in Montreal again after more than two weeks in San Francisco. It was great being in the Bay Area, especially since this time of year in Montreal is kind of crappy. Cold rain knocks all the red-yellow-orange leaves off the trees and into the gutter, where they turn brown and gray. Everything's damp and muddy and icy, but there's no snow yet. Blech. Our friend John Usher stayed at our apartment while we were gone, which was great for us since he watched our cats. We had our regular Friday Night Pizza together last night at 9PM, after a very long day in the plane. Traveling eastward is hard on the sense of time. But pizza night made it a little better. We went up to Le Comptoir on rue Masson this morning for breakfast. It's a nice little place that you can always get into, regardless of the time of day (like, say, if you try going out for brunch at 11:30 on a Saturday...). The menu is a little too much in the Montreal Kitchen Sink style (10+ pages of every kind of food under the sun), but the b n dictines are good, they have mimosas, and they serve caf au lait in big bowls. So what's not to like? John rented a new apartment in Old Montreal while we were away. He's been a vagabond since early this summer when he left McGill and went back to his hometown of Beer in Devon. His new place is great -- 2000 ft top-floor loft around the corner from Basilisque Notre Dame. I plan to abuse his hospitality and throw big parties in his home, if I can get away with it. One nice thing is that he found the place on Montreal Craigslist. I think that's a pretty good sign that CL in MTL is becoming worth using, although they still don't have an interface in French. I don't know how you get away with an non-localized international Web site in 2006. tags:

Web 2.0 Summit Wrap-up LinuxWorld.com published my article on Day 1 of the Web 2.0 Conference, which I have to say I think is pretty OK good. I had originally written a gossipy article about who was where and who announced what and what it meant for Linux users and the Open Source community. Don Marti, who edited the article, didn't like it. He told me to identify the key technologies mentioned at the conference that people could actually use and should know about, and write more about them. So I did, and I think the article is much better for it. Days 2 and 3 of the conference coverage come out next week. I really liked writing about the Web 2.0 Summit; it gave me a chance to talk to people in-depth about their work. I didn't draw as much out of the conference itself as I would have liked, but by working press on it, I had to find stuff that interested me and communicate that interest. Which made it fun. tags:

Que Rico I'm pretty psyched that planning for next spring's Wikitravel Get-together 2007 is going so well. The Get-together (despite my finest effort, this seems to be the final name for the event) will be a convocation of Wikitravellers from all over the world on one spot to meet, talk about issues, but most of all, travel. Our chosen destination for this year's event is Puerto Rico (the product of a months-long selection process, with two rounds of voting). Our coverage of PR in English Wikitravel is sub-optimal, and we hope that by bringing a bunch of wiki people to the island for a week to hang out and explore, we can greatly improve the travel guide for this big area. Participants will be doing research before the event (April 14-22 2007) to determine those parts of the island that need better first-hand coverage. Then, we'll convene in San Juan (Puerto Rico) for a weekend before spreading out to cover the rest of the island. We'll meet back up in SJ the next weekend for some discussions and meetings before flying off to our respective homes. It should be a really fun trip -- I've never been to the Caribbean at all, and I think PR sounds like a really amazing place to visit. And I think this style of meetup for Wikitravellers could be super-fun for future events; it will be cool to see how this one goes. tags:

Poppies One endearing custom in Canada for Remembrance Day is wearing small, red poppies on one's lapel, evoking the classic Canadian poem ''In Flanders Fields''. It's a beautiful tradition, but hard to watch a bit on this day in 2006, when Canadian soldiers are being killed not in Ypres, but in Kandahar by, among others, heroin drug-lords, for whom poppies have other meanings. tags:

11 November 2006

Aurelien Jarno: Experimental is not autobuilt (at least for glibc)

Martin, I can’t let you say that experimental is autobuilt. I have uploaded a few versions of the glibc to experimental in the last few months and only arm, hppa and alpha have tried to build them. Before the summer mips and mipsel also have tried to build the experimental glibc. And the last version has not been tried on alpha, despite the fact it includes a fix and should now build correctly on this architecture.

Hopefully I have most Debian architectures at home, but alpha, m68k and ia64, so I can build the glibc on my own machines. For m68k and ia64, I can use debian.org machines. Concerning alpha, the debian porting machine, ie escher.debian.org, is locked down since the compromise about 4 months ago. And no answer to my mail to debian-admin… Hopefully a user kindly gave me an access on his machine, thanks. The glibc 2.5 is now building correctly on this machine, but I can’t upload the package because I can’t trust the machine. That really sucks. What about removing alpha from the release architectures? After all, it fails to comply with the etch candidate release architecture criteria for months. Update: Some build daemons had glibc in “weak-no-autobuild”. Thanks Martin for fixing that.

David Welton: Bicycling, Running, and Open Source Economics

I am very passionate about open source (or free software, or whatever you want to call it) software. In one way or the other, it seems I'm always drawn back to it, whatever else I'm supposed to be working on. I get a good feeling from the community aspects of it, believe in the potential for technological benefits, and appreciate that being open is often the best way to advance the state of the art. One thing that has always been something of a mystery though, is how the whole thing works in economic terms. There is no doubt in my mind that open source works in terms of creating value, but what isn't so simple is how it sustains itself, and where it makes sense. Some people, like Richard Stallman, sustain that all software should be free. Others take a more laissez faire attitude. Aside from philosophical debates, though, there is a very pragmatic question of how it works in practice, and if the process could be made more efficient, and in which cases should one simply decide to 'go proprietary' in terms of maximizing monetary returns. In the proprietary software world, this is all rather "simple" - (well, conceptually at least - it's not actually easy for anyone). If you write some software that you then sell, and people like it, they'll buy it, which in turn gives you money that you can funnel back into improving the product. If it stinks, you won't get any money, and presumably you'll move on to something you are more qualified for. It's a pretty simple and direct feedback loop. With free software though, it gets much more complex, because there is not necessarily an economic link between users and developers, which might mean that while the software provides very real economic benefits in terms of flexibility, avoiding vendor lock in, and low costs, none of those benefits necessarily flow to the person or people who actually wrote the software. This, in turn, means that they may have to support themselves in some other way and may not be able to dedicate much time to working on the code. This system is thus 'inefficient', because there is a disconnect between the value and the person who created it. A lot of thought has been dedicated to "solving" this problem, but it doesn't seem to have a satisfying answer just yet, although there are several free software companies that clearly do function, with a variety of models. One of the original ideas about how people would live in an entirely free software based economy, proposed by Stallman, is services. In other words, the software is free, but you get money to fix it, teach people about it, improve it, provide support for it, customize it and so on. While riding my bike around the Colli Euganei the other day, it occured to me that a pure services business is a lot like running. The minute you have fewer clients, go on vacation, or otherwise ease up... revenue drops proportionately, just as if you had slowed from a run to a walk. Ease off on the effort completely, and the money is gone, because you have no way of carrying your momentum forward. With a bicycle, on the other hand, it's more like a product-based business. It's certainly still an effort, and you have to be strong to beat your competitors, however, you can stop pedaling for a moment now and then, and you do get the descents after riding up the hills, and for a few meters at least, you can stop pedaling altogether and coast. What prompted me to think about products versus services was a small web application I developed recently. It's a nice ajaxy to-do list/time-tracker that I started developing with Ruby on Rails. My first instinct, and the easiest thing to do, of course, would be to open source it and let it go at that, but... I also wonder if I could make a little bit of money at it if I were to commercialize the product somehow. Not "get rich quick" money, but enough to pay me back for the time I sunk into making it work, and enough to let me justify doing more work on it to meet people's needs and requests. A couple of strategies come to mind: Whatever ends up happening with it, I'll be sure to post further information as it becomes available.

Adrian von Bidder: I told you!

Antiamericanism is a more and more widespread feeling, not only in eastern countries, but also here in Europe. Despite all the admiration for the achievements of americans throughout history, I have to confess that I increasingly share that feeling. (I've blogged about the USA before, so you probably already know this.) Most recently:
Es h ufen sich Klagen von Gesch ftsreisenden ber Zollbeamte, die Daten auf Mobilcomputern einsehen wollen. [ ] Regierungsbeamte haben das Recht, nicht nur das Reisegep ck, sondern auch elektronische Datentr ger zu durchsuchen. W hrend es konkreter Verdachtsmomente und einer richterlichen Anordnung bedarf, damit Beamte private E-Mails oder vertrauliche Computerdateien lesen d rfen, [haben] Z llner das Recht, die Computer auch unverd chtiger Reisender ohne Angabe von Gr nden zu durchsuchen oder gar zu konfiszieren. [Neue Z rcher Zeitung, 10.11.2006, edited]
(Complaints of business travelers about customs officers, who want to investigate data on mobile computers are accumulating. [ ] Government officials have the right, to search not only the luggage, but also electronic Data media. While specific suspiciouns and judicial orders are required, for governement officials to read private emails or confidential computer files, customs officers have the right, to scan or even confiscate computers of any traveler without giving any reasons.) This is not complaining about travel to China, Africa, Belorussia or whatever, but is a warning issued by the Association of Corporate Travel Executives about crossing the U.S. border. The ACTE is, by the way, an international organisation based in the U.S.A., so they should know.

Lucas Nussbaum: List operators on files in shell ? (updated)

I often need to do list-like operations on files in shell, for example: Such operations are easy to do with a combination of sort, uniq, cut, diff, etc. But they are so basic operations that it is a bit annoying to write the small shell script each time I need to do one of them. Isn’t there a tool out there already providing all of them ? Also, it would be great if such operations could be achieved considering only the first n characters or words (a bit like uniq -w, or the removed uniq -W option). It would be an easy way to do :
i1 c1
i2 c2
i3 c3
i4 c4
minus
i2
i4
Comments are opened. Update: many people pointed me to moreutils‘ combine. It looks good, bug not exactly what I need, so I filed wishlist bugs #398187 (combine: provide aliases for set theory operators) and #398193 (combine: allow to compare only on a subset of the lines). I won’t have time to provide patches, so if somebody want to work on them …. :-)

Zak B. Elep: update-initramfs for teh win

Following up, I have found a solution in a related bugreport against initramfs-tools that needed a one-line edit and the above spell for 610 GET. My reward: Gomen Cat. Its a Caturday.

Russell Coker: more about securing an office

My post about securing an office received many comments, so many that I had to write another blog entry to respond to them and also add some other things I didn't think of before.

One suggestion was to use pam_usb to store passwords on a USB device. It sounds like it's worth considering, but really we need public key encryption. I don't want to have a USB device full of keys, I want a USB device that runs GPG and can decrypt data on demand - the data it decrypts could be a key to unlock an entire filesystem. One thing to note is that USB 2.0 has a bandwidth of 30MB/s while the IDE hard drive in my Thinkpad can sustain 38MB/s reads (at the start - it would be slower near the end). This means that I would approximately halve the throughput on large IOs by sending all the data to a USB device for encryption or decryption. Given that such bulk IO is rare this is feasible. There are a number of devices on the market that support public-key encryption, I would be surprised if any of them can deliver the performance required to encrypt all the data on a hard drive. But this will happen eventually.

Bill made a really good point about firewire. I had considered mentioning it in my post but refrained due to a lack of knowledge of the technology (it's something that I would disable on my own machines but in the past I couldn't recommend that others disable without more information). Could someone please describe precisely which 1394 (AKA Firewire) modules should be disabled for a secure system? If you don't need Firewire then it's probably best to just disable it entirely.

To enable encryption in Fedora Core 6 you need something like the following in /etc/crypttab:
home_crypt /dev/hdaX /path/to/key
swap /dev/hdaX /dev/random swap
Debian uses the same format for /etc/crypttab.

The Peregrine blog entry in response to my entry made some really good points. I wasn't aware of what SUSE had done as I haven't done much with SUSE in the past. I'm currently being paid to do some SUSE work so I will learn more about what SUSE offers, but given the SUSE/MS deal I'm unlikely to use it when I don't have to. Before anyone asks, I don't work for SUSE and given what they have just done I will have to reject any offer of employment that might come from them.

I had forgotten about rsh and telnet. Surely those protocols are dead now? I use telnet as a convenient TCP server test tool (netcat isn't installed on all machines) and never use rsh. But Lamont was correct to mention them as there may be some people still doing such things.

The Peregrine blog made an interesting point about Kerberised NFS being encrypted, I wasn't aware of this and I will have to investigate it. I haven't used Kerberos in the past because most networks I work on don't have a central list of accounts, and often there is no one trusted host.

I strongly disagree with the comment about iSCSI and AoE "Neither protocol provides security mechanisms, which is a good thing. If they did, the additional overhead would affect their performance". Lack of security mechanisms allows replay attacks. For example if an attacker compromises a non-root account on a machine that uses such a protocol for it's root filesystem, the victim might change their password but the attacker could change the data back to it's original values even it if was encrypted. Encryption needs to have sequence numbers embedded to be effective, this is well known - the current dmcrypt code (used by cryptsetup) encrypts each block with the block ID number so that blocks can not be re-arranged by someone who can't decrypt them (a weakness of some earlier disk encryption systems). When block encryption is extended to a network storage system I believe that the block ID number needs to be used as well as a sequence ID number to prevent reordering of requests. CPU performance has been increasing more rapidly than hard drive performance for a long time. Some fairly expensive SAN hardware is limited to 40MB/s (I won't name the vendor here but please note that it's not a company that I have worked for), while there is faster SAN hardware out there I think it's reasonable to consider 40MB/s as adequate IO performance. A quick test indicates that the 1.7GHz Pentium-M CPU in my Thinkpad can decrypt data at a rate of 23MB/s. So to get reasonable speed with encryption from a SAN you might require a CPU which is twice as fast as in my Thinkpad for every client (which means most desktop machines sold for the last two years and probably all new laptops now other than the OLPC machine). You would also require a significant amount of CPU power at the server if multiple clients were to sustain such speeds. This might be justification for making encryption optional or for having faster (and therefore less effective) algorithms as an option.

I believe that the lack of built-in security in the AoE and iSCSI protocols gives a significant weakness to the security of the system which can't be fully addressed. The CPU requirements for such encryption can be met with current hardware even when using a strong algorithm such as AES. There are iSCSI accellerator cards being developed, such cards could also have built in encryption if there was a standard algorithm. This would allow good performance on both the client and the server without requiring the main CPU.

Finally the Peregrine blog entry recommended Counterpane. Bruce Schneier is possibly the most widely respected computer security expert. Everything he does is good. I didn't mention his company in my previous post because it was aimed at people who are on a strict budget. I didn't bother mentioning any item that requires much money, and I don't expect Counterpane to be cheap.

Simon noted that developing a clear threat model is the first step. This is absolutely correct, however most organizations don't have any real idea. When advising such organizations I usually just invent a few possible ways that someone with the same resources and knowledge as I might attack them and ask whether such threats seem reasonable, generally they agree that such things should be prevented and I give further advice based on that. It's not ideal, but advising clients who don't know what they want will never give an ideal result.

One thing that I forgot to mention is the fact that good security relies on something you have as well as something you know. For logging in it's ideal to use a hardware security token. RSA sells tokens that display a pseudo-random number every minute, the server knows the algorithm used to generate the numbers and can verify that the number entered was generated in the last minute or two. Such tokens are sold at low prices to large corporations (I can't quote prices, but one of my clients had prices that made them affordable for securing home networks), I will have to discover what their prices are to small companies and individuals (I have applied to evaluate the RSA hardware). Another option is a GPG smart-card, I already have a GPG card and just need to get a reader (this has been on my to-do list for a while). The GPG card has the advantage of being based on free software.

One thing I have believed for some time is that Debian should issue such tokens to all developers, I'm sure that purchasing ~1200 tokens would get a good price for Debian and the security benefits are worth it. The use of such tokens might have prevented the Debian server crack of 2003 or the Debian server crack of 2006. The Free Software Foundation Fellowship of Europe issues GPG cards to it's members, incidentally the FSFE is a worthy organisation that I am considering joining.

Lucas Nussbaum: Feature request: confirmation for non-member posts in mailman

There are basically two kinds of setups for mailing lists managed using Mailman, regarding posts from non-members : It would be great if Mailman could ask the sender for confirmation (either email-based or web-based) before accepting the mail or putting it in the moderation queue. This would greatly reduce the amount of spam on the list or in the moderation queue. This is also known as Mailman feature request #673265. A similar feature has apparently been in Sympa for nearly 4 years.

Next.

Previous.