Benjamin Mako Hill: Support Parallel Distribution Now!
My friend James Grimmelmann, currently a Resident Fellow of the
Information Society Project at Yale Law School and an Adjunct
Professor at New York Law School, contacted me recently because he
was concerned that it doesn't seem likely that parallel
distribution language is going to make it in latest draft of the
Creative Commons 3.0 licenses. The issues and arguments around
parallel distribution are complex but James and I both think that the
status quo represents a mistake and a lost opportunity by CC. As a
result, we have written a position statement that tries to explain
the issues simply, make a case for parallel distribution, and answer
some of the criticism that has been leveled against the idea.
Prompted by conversations with hackers from Debian (myself
included), CC lawyers recommend new "parallel distribution" language
at the beginning of the CC 3.0 license revision process as a way to
fix unanticipated effects of the current CC anti-DRM clause. Immediate
negative reactions by a number of people demoted the language to an
issue for debate. While the resulting debate has been both lengthy and
heated, it has not involved more than a small handful of voices or led
to any firm decisions. Time is running out for the drafts of CC's 3.0
licenses and unless something changes, the status quo -- no parallel
distribution -- will remain. As a result, it's extremely important
that users of CC licenses try to familiarize themselves with the issue
and to make their voice heard.
James and I feel the lack of a parallel distribution language in the
CC licenses represents a failure by CC to live up to its own ideals
and to do what is in the best interest of the users of CC
licenses. Please read our position statement, pass the link and
article around to others, and make yourself heard either on the
cc-licenses list by emailing cc-licenses@lists.ibiblio.org or by
posting a response on the comments page in my wiki.
Finally, as a Debian developer, it's important for me to say that I do
not think that the lack of parallel distribution makes the CC licenses
non-free under the DFSG -- especially in light of the recent
general resolution on the GFDL which deemed the GFDL, which
contains language that is extremely similar to the current CC text,
DFSG free. CC should use parallel distribution language because it is
the right thing to do for the free culture movement and for the users
of CC works and not because it will have any effect on the inclusion
of CC BY and BY-SA works in Debian.
You can find the position statement at:
http://wiki.mako.cc/ParallelDistribution


