Review:
Hyperbole and a Half, by Allie Brosh
| Publisher: |
Touchstone |
| Copyright: |
November 2013 |
| ISBN: |
1-4767-6459-X |
| Format: |
Graphic novel |
| Pages: |
373 |
It's fundamentally pointless to write this review.
Some number of you have already heard of
Hyperbole and a Half.
Most of that group already own this book and are only reading this review
so that you can remember how much fun you had reading it. But, even
better, you could just stop reading this review and go read the book
again.
Some of you who have heard of
Hyperbole and a Half didn't know that
Allie Brosh had published a book. If that's you, you're probably not
reading this review any more, since you're now at your favorite book
seller buying a copy of the book, rendering the review somewhat pointless.
For those of you who have not heard of
Hyperbole and a
Half, there's no need to read a review, because it's a blog. So, rather
than reading this review, you can just follow that link and read it for
yourself. If you find yourself laughing uncontrollably (and occasionally
crying) and going "where can I get more of this?", well, there's a book.
Which you could have also found out from the blog itself. Like I said,
not much point.
If you read the blog and don't particularly care for it, well, I greatly
respect your position. The diversity of taste in the human race is what
leads to our wonderful variety of culture, philosophy, and art, and I
appreciate your substantial contribution to that diversity. However, you
should now make a mental note to never trust my humor recommendations, and
you shouldn't let this review change your mind.
But, since I'm here, I may as well write a review anyway.
Hyperbole and a Half is, as mentioned, a blog by Allie Brosh. Most
of the posts are quite long and substantial and in the form of cartoons
mixed with text, usually (but not always) telling some sort of story. The
cartoon style is what is often called "MS Paint," meaning that it looks
like something drawn in Microsoft Paint with its most basic tools. (Other
examples of this style are
the
Oatmeal and
Homestuck, although Brosh stays consistently with a rawer art
style than either of those.) It looks extremely simple, like child
drawings (and early childhood inspires much of Brosh's material), but once
one gets used to it, one realizes that Brosh gets amazing expressiveness
and character out of the art style.
As an aside, yes, I am wholeheartedly recommending a book that is full of
material about young children. Brosh is
that good.
The subtitle of this book is "unfortunate situations, flawed coping
mechanisms, mayhem, and other things that happened," and it's mostly based
on (exaggerated) incidents that occurred in Brosh's life. Most of them
are hilarious. Some of them are both hilarious and stunning psychological
insights. She has an amazing knack for storytelling and for exaggerating
just the right moments of the story, or summing up emotions in a wonderful
turn of phrase or a picture. She's also amazingly good at telling
embarrassing stories about herself in a way that makes you empathize rather
than just cringe, and then come away feeling like you understand both her
and yourself better.
If you've wandered around the Internet much, you have probably run across
the phrase "clean ALL the things!" and the corresponding picture. That's
from
Hyperbole and a Half (specifically,
"This is Why I'll Never Be an Adult") and is included in this book
(improved; see below). It's even better in context.
But, beyond storytelling, the other thing Brosh is amazingly good at is
capturing internal mental states and emotions in a way that the reader
understands and those who have experienced the emotion immediately go
"yes, THAT." The apex of this is her two-part post on depression, which
is hands-down the best description of depression that I've ever read.
That judgment has been echoed by multiple friends of mine with
depression. And yes, both of those posts are included in the book as
well, although you can also read them on the web.
As you've probably noticed, this book is partly a collection of material
that's freely available on the web. Unlike some web comics collections,
it's not entirely a reprint collection; there are entirely new stories
here (which for me was enough by itself to buy the book). Brosh's
post on the
book says that it's about 50% new material. But the ones that aren't
original have been edited and improved, sometimes substantially. For
example, I did a quick comparison of the book version with the web version
of "This is Why I'll Never be an Adult" and found Brosh redrew all of the
cartoons for the story. The book is also gorgeous, if you care about such
things like I do: high quality paper, thick pages, vibrant colors, and a
comfortable heft to the hardcover version. It's the sort of book that
feels like it will survive for decades, which is good since I intend to
re-read it for decades.
Brosh has a
lot of material on-line, so obviously only a small
fraction made it into the book and there's more to discover on the blog.
I can particularly recommend
"The Alot is Better Than You at Everything" and
"Boyfriend Doesn't Have Ebola. Probably.". The latter, which is mostly
about creating a better pain scale, is my favorite from the blog that
didn't make it into the book. And there are two more examples of the sort
of thing that you'll getting here.
So ends the probably pointless review. I absolutely adore
Hyperbole
and a Half. It is my favorite web comic, even surpassing
XKCD, which is saying something. Even if there
were no material, I would have bought this book in hardcover to support
Brosh and to have a high-quality printing of the blog posts. The
reworkings and improvements of the republished material and the brand new
additions are just bonuses. But there's no need to take my word for it;
the best possible advertisement for Brosh's work is on-line, from which
you can easily determine if you'll enjoy this book as much as I did.
Even the back cover and the inside flaps are awesome.
Rating: 10 out of 10