Search Results: "ag"

9 December 2006

Clint Adams: He kept kicking himself for the pleasure of Mick Jagger

Amaya, that was the 90s!

Adrian von Bidder: Categories

Completely changed all categories on my blog. I hope nothing has broken. While I like nanoblogger because it's quite simple, I really can't wrap my head around the logic of its commandline syntax. And thinking about categories: perhaps I should switch from categories to tags and do a nice tag cloud. I started blogging only after 80 year old grannies did it, so there's some time yet...

Adrian von Bidder: Samsung?

Daniel Burrows writes about Samsung embedding DRM in (some of?) its DVD drives. While I must say that I'm not surprised (not because it's Samsung, but because I expect DRM to be embedded deep in hardware more and more to counter software-based attacks won't work anymore), it will now make me feel bad about buying a Q40, which I'm thinking about doing: it's a really slick sub-note, only a bit more than 1kg (with the small battery) and running up to ca. 5 or 6 hours with the (included at no extra charge) high power battery (as per specs). Good display, too, from what I could see at the shop, and it has an Intel graphics chip. Memory stick/MMD/SD card reader included as well, so I'd have something to look forward to when kernel 2.6.48 or so comes out and these readers will finally work. And, opposed to what IBM/Lenovo produce, they actually have some competent designers^W^W^W^W^W^WI actually like how it looks. DRM: I think this battle will have to be fought in politics. Battling the vendors is fine, but will be endless, the real goal should be to anchor a broad right to tinker in the bill of rights which also extends to non-commercially used information. (Adding the “non-commercial” bit in here because authors do have the right to be reimbursed when somebody earns money with their creation.) What I do in private with the DVD I legally bought, or with the satellite signal that is sent to my home for free (and I can't even opt out) is non commercial use. Update: The problem is that Daniel is a doofus. (in his own words.) So Samsung's reputation is safe for now. But I have to agree with him, still: it is a realistic expectation in these days that the hardware supports DRM in some way.

Daniel Burrows: DRM: "If there is hope, it lies in the proles^H^H^H^H^Hpols"?

In response to my recent mistaken post about Samsung and DRM, Adrian von Bidder wrote that

I think this battle will have to be fought in politics7. Battling the vendors is fine, but will be endless, the real goal should be to anchor a broad [4]right to tinker in the bill of rights which also extends to non-commercially used information.


On one level, this is probably true. But this amounts to the government passing laws that increase the liberty of its citizens and decrease its own control over them, while at the same time exposing the corporate interests that sponsor the government to increased competition. Governments almost never do this, for obvious reasons -- probably the only example in recent American history that I can think of is the Civil Rights Act of 1964, over forty years old now, which addressed inequalities that the average person could understand easily and was preceded by significant popular unrest (much more than a few guys dressing up like hazardous-waste-disposal crews and walking around outside computer conferences).

In fact, the most likely outcome of the government getting involved in the DRM situation, in my opinion, is a bill making DRM mandatory for all hardware devices and requiring software (or at least software that can run on mass-market computers) to go through a process of certification that attests that it respects DRM. This will be the final nail in the coffin for the free software movement, and I don't think we want to hasten its arrival.

I think the best we can hope for in this context is the prayer from "Fiddler on the Roof":


Lord, bless and keep the Congress

... far away from us!

Daniel Burrows: Apologies to Samsung

I need to learn not to write blog posts after 9pm, given that my brain starts fogging up around 8:30pm.

Apparently the only reason I couldn't play DVDs is that I had forgotten to install the DVD decoder library. Doh. And apparently the reason the DVD wouldn't play yesterday is that the video program was trying to get the drive to decode the DVD for it -- which I can understand Samsung not wanting to do, since it would get them in legal hot water. (what ticked me off was that it looked like they were going beyond the minimum and keeping me from even reading the encrypted DVD data)

So, the problem is that Daniel is a doofus. I want to apologize again for being a little trigger-happy last night -- especially since this is syndicated, it sucks to have put incorrect information out there.

Daniel Burrows: Hungarian notation is a human-checked type system, redux

A while ago, I read an article that advocated the use of Hungraian Notation for purposes that can easily be folded into the type system and automatically checked. I wrote a blog post in reply that gave a rough sketch of a solution to the fundamental problem in Haskell. Well, someone else apparently read the same article and had the same idea; the only difference is that the solution he produced is infinitely superior to mine and everyone should go read it instead.

Russell Coker: Debian SE Linux policy bug

checkmodule -m -o local.mod local.te
semodule_package -o local.pp -m local.mod
semodule -u local.pp


Save the following policy as local.te and then run the above commands to make semodule work correctly and to also allow restorecon to access the console on boot.

module local 1.0;

require
class chr_file read write ;
class fd use;
type restorecon_t;
type tmpfs_t;
type initrc_t;
type semanage_t;
role system_r;
;

allow restorecon_t tmpfs_t:chr_file read write ;
allow semanage_t initrc_t:fd use;

David Moreno Garza: Races and classes

I’ve enjoyed reading Richard Gott’ article named Latin America is preparing to settle accounts with its white settler elite, where he goes deeply on how the recent political movements in the region has been marked more on lineage and classism than in anything else. Read the article in English here, or in Spanish, here (thanks to Rebeli n).

8 December 2006

Russell Coker: SE Linux on Debian in 5 minutes

Following from my 5 minute OSDC talk yesterday on 5 security improvements needed in Linux distributions I gave a 5 minute talk on installing SE Linux on Debian etch. To display the notes I formatted them such that they were in 24 line pages and used less at a virtual console to display them. The ultra-light laptop I was using has only 64M of RAM which isn't enough for a modern X environment and I couldn't be bothered getting something like Familiar going on it.

After base install you install the policy and the selinux-basics package:

# apt-get install selinux-basics selinux-policy-refpolicy-targeted
The following extra packages will be installed:
checkpolicy libsemanage1 mime-support policycoreutils python python-minimal
python-selinux python-semanage python-support python2.4 python2.4-minimal
selinux-utils
Suggested packages:
python-doc python-tk python-profiler python2.4-doc logcheck syslog-summary
The following NEW packages will be installed:
checkpolicy libsemanage1 mime-support policycoreutils python python-minimal
python-selinux python-semanage python-support python2.4 python2.4-minimal
selinux-basics selinux-policy-refpolicy-targeted selinux-utils
0 upgraded, 14 newly installed, 0 to remove and 0 not upgraded.
Need to get 6362kB of archives.
After unpacking 41.5MB of additional disk space will be used.
Do you want to continue [Y/n]?

The package install process also configures the policy for the machine. The next step is to label the filesystems, this took 26 seconds on my Celeron 500MHz laptop with 20,000 files on an old IDE disk. The time is in proportion to number of files, often bottlenecked on CPU. A more common install might have 5* as many files with a 5* faster CPU so 30 seconds is probably common for labelling. See the following:

# fixfiles relabel

Files in the /tmp directory may be labeled incorrectly, this command
can remove all files in /tmp. If you choose to remove files from /tmp,
a reboot will be required after completion.

Do you wish to clean out the /tmp directory [N]? y
Cleaning out /tmp
/sbin/setfiles: labeling files under /
matchpathcon_filespec_eval: hash table stats: 14599 elements, 14245/65536 buckets used, longest chain length 2
/sbin/setfiles: labeling files under /boot
matchpathcon_filespec_eval: hash table stats: 19 elements, 19/65536 buckets used, longest chain length 1
/sbin/setfiles: Done.

The next step is to edit /boot/grub/menu.list to enable SE Linux, auditing, and put it in enforcing mode:

title   Debian GNU/Linux, kernel 2.6.17-2-686
root (hd0,1)
kernel /vmlinuz-2.6.17-2-686 root=/dev/x selinux=1 audit=1 ro enforcing=1
initrd /initrd.img-2.6.17-2-686

Then reboot.

After rebooting view the context of your shell, note that the login shell will have a domain of unconfined_t when the targeted policy is used:
# id -Z
system_u:system_r:unconfined_t

Now let's view all processes that are confined:
# ps axZ  grep -v unconfined_t grep -v kernel_t grep -v initrc_t
LABEL PID TTY STAT TIME COMMAND
system_u:system_r:init_t 1 ? Ss 0:02 init [2]
system_u:system_r:udev_t 1999 ? S.s 0:01 udevd --daemon
system_u:system_r:syslogd_t 3306 ? Ss 0:00 /sbin/syslogd
system_u:system_r:klogd_t 3312 ? Ss 0:00 /sbin/klogd -x
system_u:system_r:apmd_t 3372 ? Ss 0:00 /usr/sbin/acpid -c /etc
system_u:system_r:gpm_t 3376 ? Ss 0:00 /usr/sbin/gpm -m /dev/i
system_u:system_r:crond_t 3402 ? Ss 0:00 /usr/sbin/cron
system_u:system_r:local_login_t 3423 tty1 Ss 0:00 /bin/login --
system_u:system_r:local_login_t 3424 tty2 Ss 0:00 /bin/login --
system_u:system_r:getty_t 3425 tty3 Ss+ 0:00 /sbin/getty 38400 tty3
system_u:system_r:getty_t 3426 tty4 Ss+ 0:00 /sbin/getty 38400 tty4
system_u:system_r:getty_t 3429 tty5 Ss+ 0:00 /sbin/getty 38400 tty5
system_u:system_r:getty_t 3430 tty6 Ss+ 0:00 /sbin/getty 38400 tty6
system_u:system_r:dhcpc_t 3672 ? S.s 0:00 dhclient3 -pf /var/run/
The initial install of policy inserts modules to match installed software, if you install new software then you need to add new modules with the semodule command:

# semodule -i /usr/share/selinux/refpolicy-targeted/apache.pp
security: 3 users, 7 roles, 824 types, 67 bools
security: 58 classes, 11813 rules
audit(1165532434.664:21): policy loaded auid=4294967295
# semodule -i /usr/share/selinux/refpolicy-targeted/bind.pp
security: 3 users, 7 roles, 836 types, 68 bools
security: 58 classes, 12240 rules
audit(1165532467.874:22): policy loaded auid=4294967295

Note that the security and audit messages come from the kernel via printk, it is displayed on console login but you need to view the system log if logged in via ssh or running an xterm. Now you have to relabel the files that are related to the new policy:

# restorecon -R -v /etc /usr/sbin /var/run /var/log
restorecon reset /etc/bind context system_u:object_r:etc_t->system_u:object_r:named_zone_t
restorecon reset /etc/bind/named.conf context system_u:object_r:etc_t->system_u:object_r:named_conf_t
[...]
restorecon reset /etc/apache2 context system_u:object_r:etc_t->system_u:object_r:httpd_config_t
restorecon reset /etc/apache2/httpd.conf context system_u:object_r:etc_runtime_t->system_u:object_r:httpd_config_t
[...]
restorecon reset /usr/sbin/named context system_u:object_r:sbin_t->system_u:object_r:named_exec_t
restorecon reset /usr/sbin/apache2 context system_u:object_r:sbin_t->system_u:object_r:httpd_exec_t
restorecon reset /usr/sbin/rndc context system_u:object_r:sbin_t->system_u:object_r:ndc_exec_t
restorecon reset /usr/sbin/named-checkconf context system_u:object_r:sbin_t->system_u:object_r:named_checkconf_exec_t
[...]
restorecon reset /var/run/bind context system_u:object_r:var_run_t->system_u:object_r:named_var_run_t
restorecon reset /var/run/bind/run context system_u:object_r:var_run_t->system_u:object_r:named_var_run_t
restorecon reset /var/run/bind/run/named.pid context system_u:object_r:initrc_var_run_t->system_u:object_r:named_var_run_t
restorecon reset /var/run/motd context system_u:object_r:initrc_var_run_t->system_u:object_r:var_run_t
restorecon reset /var/run/apache2 context system_u:object_r:var_run_t->system_u:object_r:httpd_var_run_t
restorecon reset /var/run/apache2/cgisock.3558 context system_u:object_r:var_run_t->system_u:object_r:httpd_var_run_t
restorecon reset /var/run/apache2.pid context system_u:object_r:initrc_var_run_t->system_u:object_r:httpd_var_run_t
restorecon reset /var/log/apache2 context system_u:object_r:var_log_t->system_u:object_r:httpd_log_t
restorecon reset /var/log/apache2/error.log context system_u:object_r:var_log_t->system_u:object_r:httpd_log_t
restorecon reset /var/log/apache2/access.log context system_u:object_r:var_log_t->system_u:object_r:httpd_log_t

The -v option to restorecon causes it to give verbose output concerning it's operations. Often you won't do it in real use, but it's good to illustrate the use.

Now you have to restart the daemons:

# killall -9 apache2
# /etc/init.d/apache2 start
Starting web server (apache2)....
# /etc/init.d/bind9 restart
Stopping domain name service...: bind.
Starting domain name service...: bind.

Apache and BIND now run in confined domains, see the following ps output:

system_u:system_r:httpd_t   3833 ?     Ss     0:00 /usr/sbin/apache2 -k start
system_u:system_r:httpd_t 3834 ? S 0:00 /usr/sbin/apache2 -k start
system_u:system_r:httpd_t 3839 ? Sl 0:00 /usr/sbin/apache2 -k start
system_u:system_r:httpd_t 3841 ? Sl 0:00 /usr/sbin/apache2 -k start
system_u:system_r:named_t 3917 ? Ssl 0:00 /usr/sbin/named -u bind

It's not particularly difficult. I covered the actual install of SE Linux in about 1.5 minutes. I had considered just ending my talk there on a note of "it's so easy I don't need 5 minutes to talk about it" but decided that it was best to cover something that you need to do once it's installed.

If you want to know more about SE Linux then ask on the mailing list (see http://www.nsa.gov/selinux for subscription details), or ask on #selinux on freenode.

Jeff Bailey

I can't really guess at how many social networking sites I've signed up to over the years. I was thinking about this a bit as I noticed some more LinkedIn mail. It's a site that seemed interesting, until I realised that I don't need to pay another company for the privilege of asking friends to introduce me to their friends. But I was thinking through the bits of electronic interaction that I have, and thinking back to my days at Hollinger where we actively spent time thinking about what content we could provide that would keep the user moving from one of our sites to another of our sites, always looking at our ads.

With this lens on, I was thinking about where I would take Google next if I were in a similar position there. I think that Google's future probably relies primarily on their crappiest product: Orkut. What places like MySpace do well is provide what I think of as the old CompuServe experience. You go, and in one spot you have different forums, chat, and downloads.

But what if Google were to make Orkut not suck? They've already started integrating Talk into it (although it still doesn't work with Apps for Your Domain), and I can only imagine that we'll soon see your account only a short while from where your Orkut page shows your public blog entries, as well as allows you to post to your own blog, or a community one. The relationships there are rich enough with Friends Groups and a gradient of friendship that the community FOAF bits could be represented easily. Picassa and their page builder things would allow people to setup myspace-like places for themselves without ever leaving the familiar framework of Orkut. Business could use all of these tools for internal corporate things, marking certain items as publish while the integrated checkout functionality let them to business quickly and efficiently.

But what other interactions then? Could we book a doctor's appointment by looking at their Calendar through their corporate page? Easily book venues for the band with the same? Use the presence notification in Talk figure out if there's someone I can deal with right now to finalise the plans for the upcoming gig?

And the cool part is that from what Google's done so far, they'll cheerfully let you integrate your own product into theirs through some sort of open standard.

James Morrison: Dancing Seoul

I've managed to go out dancing all night long (until 7am) two days in a row. There are some good parties in Seoul. Sleep is definitely not for this week.

Steve McIntyre: Is there nothing they won't stoop to?

In the UK, the Gowers review of Intellectual Property (sigh at the usual conflation) was released this week. Amongst a whole slew of other recommendations, he stated quite clearly that the term of current music copyright protection in the UK was already long enough, and extending it was not in the public interest: "Recommendation 3: The European Commission should retain the length of protection on sound recordings and performers' rights at 50 years." "Recommendation 4: Policy makers should adopt the principle that the term and scope of protection for IP rights should not be altered retrospectively." The review was published shortly after a slew of propaganda from various bodies in the UK representing the music industry, all essentially claiming "the sky is falling". Yesterday, there was even a full-page advertisement in the Financial Times signed by several thousand UK recording artists calling for "fair play for musicians". However, as Lessig points out, there's a small problem with that ad: at least some of the so-called signatories are dead, and have been for some time. I suppose by now we should be used to the fact that the large media corporations are corrupt and self-serving - that's hardly news any more. But this really takes the biscuit...

Biella Coleman: Small Claims Court and the Insurance-Industrial Complex

I prefer the study of the law over being personally embroiled with the law in the real world, but if indeed Blue Cross Blue Shield does not pony up the money to cover my recent mole surgeries, I think I am going to take them to small claims court, which I know nothing of, except that it is a cheap way to try to get something done when you are getting screwed by a large faceless organization or some facefull twit. So the basic story is that since I had a lapse in my insurance (thanks to good Old Rutgers University!!), when I decided that I should buy my own just in case, I fell into a “pre-existing” clause, which means basically the insurance company can make your life a living bureaucratic hell because they have to review and approve every single procedure or doctor visit for over a year. Super. So of course when I got my mole diagnosis (dysplastic) and then the surgeries (the total cost being almost 3500) they went for review, but of course Blue Cross is taking their sweet time… The derm office has called for me to get involved so I spent the morning talking to a Ms. Flood from Blue Cross/Blue Shield and she explained to me that all the documentation from the doctor’s office was only received November 1st and then they will take 60-90 days to review the case before making the decision. Now, the insurance coordinator at the dermatology office told me that Blue Cross told her that Blue Cross can take up to FIVE years (not months, Years) to make a decision which seems, well just like they type of thing they would do, but somewhat illegal, maybe, no???!!! Anyway, my plan is to wait those 90 days and then if they deny my coverage or keep flip flopping around saying they need more info, I think I am going to proceed to the small claims court option. Honestly I don’t know if this is a realistic option (though I hope my lawyer friends write back soon) and it is a pain in the neck but I refuse refuse refuse to let this go…. because well, my mole condition was not pre-existing! Sure I had them, but they were happy healthy moles… And I even had seen another dermatologist with my Blue Cross Blue Shield insurance about 6 months earlier and all was good!! Yes I am upset :-( Anyone else ever fought the insurance industrial complex along these lines? Or have used small claims courts? This makes me want to stay in Canada… forever.. but actually I am due back in NYC by August for a permanent job but more on that later.

Uwe Hermann: Serious remotely exploitable hole in GnuPG

Just in case you haven't heard of this yet: GnuPG = 1.4.5 contains a remotely exploitable security issue which has been fixed in 1.4.6. You should really upgrade ASAP, as this problem can (theoretically) occur when GnuPG decrypts/checks encrypted email messages/signatures (for example). If you're running Debian unstable: apt-get install gnupg

MJ Ray: Free-to-air satellite reception will still be better for radio, music and films after digital switchover

UK media regulator Ofcom released Ofcom sets Digital Switchover related licence conditions about the terrestial broadcast network, including a consultation on self-help relays. Essentially, the public service station multiplexes (BBC Royal Charter, Digital 3 & 4 and Freeview, labelled 1, 2 and B on this list ) will be available from all current public analogue transmitters, but the commercial multiplexes (SDN/itv and National Grid Wireless, which are A, C and D on the list) only need to continue the current coverage. So, free-to-air satellite reception will still be better for radio, music and films in most current poor-DTT areas.

Sam Hocevar: Oh, the nullity

Erich Schubert writes:
[A rather erroneous rebuttal of Anderson s new tool]
Please. If you are going to use maths to refute a paper, at least read the paper, not the BBC news article. In fact, dividing by zero can be useful in calculus. What the guy did is design a consistent system (I trust him at least on this) that resembles the IEEE floating point algebra, except that in his system = while NaN NaN. Such a distinction makes it possible to write and solve equations where may be involved. Of course the final result may yield but the important part is that it is consistent, proven, and remains valid whatever the input values. What should be really questioned is:

Alexander Sack: noteworthy things from the firefox & linux front

mconnor (Mozilla Corp) and caillon (Red Hat) give hope that mozillas attitude finally starts to change (in the right direction): That’s all good news, but even better … “Red Hat and Novell are both going to commit some effort into maintaining the Firefox 1.5.0.x line past the current EOL date this spring” ... thank $GOD for that ;-)

Jonathan McDowell: Small World?

Having been reading about Small World Phenomenon (which I've been calling Small World Syndrome for some time now, guess I'll have to change) the other day I was vaguely interested in LOST when I was pointed at it. It doesn't really help model the interconnectedness of the matrix as it's a tree structure AFAICT, but I think it's an fun idea with about as much point as most social networking sites and none of the claims to usefulness. :) I'd heard of Milgram before; my Mum did some stuff around Milgram's Experiment. SWP seems quite a different topic to me - are there similarities I'm missing or is it just the social psychologist equivalent of hacking on kernel code one day and a web app the next?

Evan Prodromou: 17 Frimaire CCXV

One problem with keeping your journal in the French Revolutionary Calendar is that you have to keep looking up what the date is. It is nice to know that there are functions for converting Julian dates to French Revolutionary dates in PHP. Also a nice link on that page to the strange and mellow http://bottoms-dream.de/ , which isn't anywhere near as pornographic as it sounds. tags:

Blinky Redux I had Blinky Hockey again tonight -- the first time in a month that I've gone. (Blinky is the pickup hockey team my friends Meg and Patti started. It's for people who don't play hockey so good but want to learn. Like me.) Last time we had it, I flew out to California at 6AM the next day for 2 weeks, so I missed two practices in between. And then last time I had everyone over for Thanksgiving dinner, and I fell asleep putting the baby down. Doh. So it was good to go out this time around. I've been going to our local hockey rink, Ar na Mont-Royal, for free skating from 4-5PM a couple of times per week since we got home, and I think I'm getting a little steadier on the ice. I still haven't got the whole stop-on-a-dime thing or skate-forwards-backwards-forwards thing, but I'm able to get around without going face down. Which is good. Tonight we did some more sophisticated drills and had a good scrimmage at the end of practice. I didn't score but I had an awesome shot. It would have been cool if it were a score. Anyways, I think I'm going to have to keep practicing on my own. Going to the Ar na is great, but maybe I should fill our parking lot out back with water, like this R ves de Glace site suggests. That'd be cool. tags:

Calendar wishlist So, I'm always trying to learn to use my calendar application, whatever's easiest and most available. I have a Treo 650 and Evolution, and they work OK, but they don't work great. I have a lot of things that I wish calendar programs had.
  • Project management integration. This is probably the biggest one for me. I can't believe that we have two different kinds of programs for planning the exact same information: what you're going to do with your time. On top of that it's remarkable that so few of project planner programs talk to calendars (or vice versa).
  • Hierarchical TODO lists. I'd like to break up tasks into sub-tasks that depend on each other.
  • Effort estimates. I'd like to be able to make notes about how long I think a task is going to take, and when I'll get it done.
  • Repeating TODOs. Probably the most egregiously un-ergonomic thing about modern calendaring programs. Almost everything I have to do in my life I have to do on a repeating schedule. I have to take out the recycling once a week before Wednesday morning. I have to pay rent before the 1st. I understand it's a tricky problem, but that doesn't mean I don't want a program to do it.
  • Open invitations. I'd like to be able to send open event invitations to mailing lists and have people RSVP automatically (if they want). All the systems I've used require that I know the email address of each invitee ahead of time. And they rarely work across calendaring systems.
  • Skipped TODOs. Sometimes I give myself a task todo and I just don't get around to doing it. I'd like to be able to mark a task as not done, but no longer important. I don't want to forget it forever, just remember that it never got done.
  • Logging. It'd be nice if there were more and nicer interfaces to say what I did with my day after it's done. When did I finish that module? When was the last time Niko came over for dinner? It would be nice if my calendar helped me remember the past as well as plan the future.
  • Sharing by default. I want to set up calendar sharing once, have my local and remote calendar synched transparently, and never worry about it again. CalDAV seems neat, but I have got no idea how to get it working.
  • More shared calendars. I like using shared calendars; I wish more organizations published them. I'd like it if Bell Canada published a calendar that told me when to pay my phone bill, and I'd like it if MSLUG published a calendar of their meetings. I'd like it if I could mark my phone bill as paid, and RSVP for an MSLUG meeting, through my calendar interface.
  • ACLs. Different people need to see different parts of my calendar. It'd be nice to have finer-grained control than "public" and "private".
tags:

Erich Schubert: British now divide by zero?

British now divide by zero. Either this "Dr James Anderson, from the University of Reading's computer science department" is a crappy computer scientist (not to speak of his mathematical skills), or this is a case of really bad journalism. Apart from having some facts wrong (infinity and -infinity aren't numbers, they're symbols outside of the numbers), he basically defines "0/0 = Nullity". Well, some of us might prefer the name "NaN" for this. "Not a Number". In floating point calculations, 0/0 may (if you've disabled exceptions) return NaN. So it is nothing new. And it's not particularly useful either, because all it solves is not having to raise an exception, but being able to continue your calculations (which will continue to return NaN) and handle the error at the end. With modern languages designed around exception handling, this of course is rarely ever used anymore. Some simple calculations you might find convincing: 2 * Nullity = 2 * (0/0) = (2*0)/0 = 0/0 = Nullity Nullity + 1 = (0/0) + (1/1) = (0*1 + 1*0)/(0*1) = 0/0 = Nullity Nullity / Nullity = (0/0) / (0/0) = (0/0) * (0/0) = (0*0)/(0*0) = (0/0) = Nullity So if you ever have Nullity anywhere in your equation the whole equation equals nullity. There is no way to remove Nullity from your results, since even Nullity/Nullity is Nullity. So you could just call it "I divided by zero, so the result is invalid". Thats probably not as pretty as "Nullity", but as useful. Some simple calculation, why you must not be allowed to divide by zero (independently from any nullity or whatever):
1*0 = 0 = 2*0     (This equation is right, isn't it?)
1 = 2             (I divided by 0 on both sides, removing the *0 factor)
This works for any number, not only for 1 or 2. So: if you divide by zero, all your numbers are equal (if you keep standard calculus rules such as associativity, distributivity etc. used in above equations). If that is okay for you, then you can divide by zero. I do prefer having 1 life to 0 life. And if 1 = 1000000, can you give me $1000000, I'll give you $1 back tomorrow... But: Maybe it's just a bad piece of journalism. He's a computer science guy. Maybe he knows about NaN. Maybe he's just trying to teach kids to use NaN when calculating, instead of teaching them to never divide by zero. There might be didactic benefits from this approach. The 1200 year old problem (Pythagoras, cited in the article lived 2500 years ago, I have no idea how they made up this number) IS easy to solve, if the result is called "invalid" instead of just having no valid result... That won't make your airplane land better, if it notices it's current height is Nullity... and what if his heart pacemaker obtains a result of "nullity", what is it supposed to do (as opposed to noticing it miscalculated?) [Update: he has published papers on this, too. Unbelievable... So above theory that it maybe is good for educational purposes is incorrect. Anyway, journalists shouldn't have reported on this without talking to some serious mathematicians...] [Update: Zoy, thats why I wrote "if you keep standard calculus rules such as associativity, distributivity, etc. - and I find these exceptionally useful. The last example is not using his rules, but standard math, but treats zero like all other numbers, to show that a canonical extension will just not give useful results. My whole point is NOT that you can't define 0/0=Nullity, but that it's not compatible with the standard calculus we're used to and relying on.]

Next.

Previous.