Search Results: "ana"

23 March 2016

Petter Reinholdtsen: Full battery stats collector is now available in Debian

Since this morning, the battery-stats package in Debian include an extended collector that will collect the complete battery history for later processing and graphing. The original collector store the battery level as percentage of last full level, while the new collector also record battery vendor, model, serial number, design full level, last full level and current battery level. This make it possible to predict the lifetime of the battery as well as visualise the energy flow when the battery is charging or discharging. The new tools are available in /usr/share/battery-stats/ in the version 0.5.1 package in unstable. Get the new battery level graph and lifetime prediction by running:
/usr/share/battery-stats/battery-stats-graph /var/log/battery-stats.csv
Or select the 'Battery Level Graph' from your application menu. The flow in/out of the battery can be seen by running (no menu entry yet):
/usr/share/battery-stats/battery-stats-graph-flow
I'm not quite happy with the way the data is visualised, at least when there are few data points. The graphs look a bit better with a few years of data. A while back one important feature I use in the battery stats collector broke in Debian. The scripts in /usr/lib/pm-utils/power.d/ were no longer executed. I suspect it happened when Jessie started using systemd, but I do not know. The issue is reported as bug #818649 against pm-utils. I managed to work around it by adding an udev rule to call the collector script every time the power connector is connected and disconnected. With this fix in place it was finally time to make a new release of the package, and get it into Debian. If you are interested in how your laptop battery is doing, please check out the battery-stats in Debian unstable, or rebuild it on Jessie to get it working on Debian stable. :) The upstream source is available from github. As always, patches are very welcome.

21 March 2016

Russ Allbery: Term::ANSIColor 4.05

This Perl (core) module provides a variety of functions and tools for manipulating ANSI color and text style escape sequences. The primary change in this release is a few internal tweaks to reduce memory usage, which apparently had ballooned by 70% since Perl 5.14. Unfortunately, that also meant dropping support for non-ASCII characters in color aliases, which I think previously would have theoretically worked (not that it was ever documented or tested). I have mixed feelings, but since the memory usage was reported as a bug (and this is the sort of module that one might legitimately want to use in some space-constrainted situations as part of core), and no one ever mentioned non-ASCII color aliases, I decided to apply this patch. Yell at me if this broke something. I also cleaned up the metadata management following all the work that others helped me with for podlators. You can get the latest release from the Term::ANSIColor distribution page.

18 March 2016

Enrico Zini: Adjusting with Moore's Law

In my last post I used zxcvbn to check the strength of passwords, and it gave estimates in hundreds of centuries. However, there's Moore's law. If we assume that every 18 months the effective computing power will double...
#!/usr/bin/python3
import sys
years = int(sys.argv[1])
# How many 18 months intervals we spent
count = 0
# How many original-computation-time-months we compute each 18 months interval
step = 18
# How many original-computation-time-months we computed so far
total = 0
# How many original-computation-time-months we need
target = years * 12
# Iterate each 18 months interval
while True:
    count += 1
    total += step
    if total > target: break
    step *= 2
print(" :.2f  years needed".format(count / 12 * 18))
...then something that is now estimated in 152 centures is likely to take, well:
$ ./actual_years 15200
9.33 years needed
Update Fixed algorithm (thanks John MacGregor). Now the estimate is a little longer, but still:
$ ./actual_years 15200
21.00 years needed
ukasz Stelmach proposed an analytic solution:
There are two cars (remember phisics in primary school?). They both have the same speed V0. It is going to take "54.697 centuries" for car A to travel the desired distance at constant speed. Car B is accelerating, its speed is 2^(t/18m)*V0 (18 [m]onths). s = V0 * T (car A, T is 54.697 centuries) s = 2^(t/18)*V0 dt (car B, we're looking for t) It's been some time but as far as I can tell it is s = V0 * 2^(t/18) * 1/((1/18) * ln 2) 2^(t/18) * 1/((1/18) * ln 2) = 54.697 * 100 * 12 [months] 2^(t/18) = 2527.54 t = 18*log2(2527.54) t = 16.96 years (still reasonable strength).

17 March 2016

Patrick Matth i: Debian Jessie 8.3: Short howto for Corosync+Pacemaker Active/Passive Cluster with two nodes and DRBD/LVM

Hello, since I had to change my old heartbeat v1 setup to an more modern Corosync+Pacemaker setup, because heartbeat v1 does not support systemd (it first looks like it is working, but it fails on service start/stops), I want to share a simple setup: First you have to activate the jessie-backports repository, because the cluster stack is not available/broken in Debian Jessie. Install the required packages with:
apt-get install -t jessie-backports libqb0 fence-agents pacemaker corosync pacemaker-cli-utils crmsh drbd-utils
After that configure your DRBD and LVM (VG+LV) on it (there are enough tutorials for it). Then deploy this configuration to /etc/corosync/corosync.conf:
totem
version: 2
token: 3000
token_retransmits_before_loss_const: 10
clear_node_high_bit: yes
crypto_cipher: none
crypto_hash: none
transport: udpu
interface
ringnumber: 0
bindnetaddr: 192.168.99.0

logging
to_logfile: yes
logfile: /var/log/corosync/corosync.log
debug: off
timestamp: on
logger_subsys
subsys: QUORUM
debug: off

quorum
provider: corosync_votequorum
two_node: 1
wait_for_all: 1
nodelist
node
ring0_addr: node1-1

node
ring0_addr: node1-2

Both nodes require a passwordless keypair, which is copied to the another node, so that you can ssh from one to each other. Then you can start with crm configure:
property stonith-enabled=no
property no-quorum-policy=ignore
property default-resource-stickiness=100 primitive DRBD_r0 ocf:linbit:drbd params drbd_resource= r0 op start interval= 0 timeout= 240 \
op stop interval= 0 timeout= 100 \
op monitor role=Master interval=59s timeout=30s \
op monitor role=Slave interval=60s timeout=30s
primitive LVM_r0 ocf:heartbeat:LVM params volgrpname= data1 op monitor interval= 30s
primitive SRV_MOUNT_1 ocf:heartbeat:Filesystem params device= /dev/mapper/data1-lv1 directory= /srv/storage fstype= ext4 options= noatime,nodiratime,nobarrier op monitor interval= 40s primitive IP-rsc ocf:heartbeat:IPaddr2 params ip= 123.123.123.123 nic= eth0 cidr_netmask= 24 meta migration-threshold=2 op monitor interval=20 timeout=60 on-fail=restart
primitive IPInt-rsc ocf:heartbeat:IPaddr2 params ip= 192.168.99.4 nic= eth1 cidr_netmask= 24 meta migration-threshold=2 op monitor interval=20 timeout=60 on-fail=restart primitive MariaDB-rsc lsb:mysql meta migration-threshold=2 op monitor interval=20 timeout=60 on-fail=restart
primitive Redis-rsc lsb:redis-server meta migration-threshold=2 op monitor interval=20 timeout=60 on-fail=restart
primitive Memcached-rsc lsb:memcached meta migration-threshold=2 op monitor interval=20 timeout=60 on-fail=restart
primitive PHPFPM-rsc lsb:php5-fpm meta migration-threshold=2 op monitor interval=20 timeout=60 on-fail=restart
primitive Apache2-rsc lsb:apache2 meta migration-threshold=2 op monitor interval=20 timeout=60 on-fail=restart
primitive Nginx-rsc lsb:nginx meta migration-threshold=2 op monitor interval=20 timeout=60 on-fail=restart group APCLUSTER LVM_r0 SRV_MOUNT_1 IP-rsc IPInt-rsc MariaDB-rsc Redis-rsc Memcached-rsc PHPFPM-rsc Apache2-rsc Nginx-rsc
ms ms_DRBD_APCLUSTER DRBD_r0 meta master-max= 1 master-node-max= 1 clone-max= 2 clone-node-max= 1 notify= true colocation APCLUSTER_on_DRBD_r0 inf: APCLUSTER ms_DRBD_APCLUSTER:Master
order APCLUSTER_after_DRBD_r0 inf: ms_DRBD_APCLUSTER:promote APCLUSTER:start commit
The last (bold marked) lines made me some headache. In short they define that the DRBD device on the active node has to be the primary one and that it is required to start the APCLUSTER on the host, since the LVM, filesystem and services require to access its data. Just a short copy paste howto for an simple use case with not so much deep explanaitions..

14 March 2016

Lunar: Reproducible builds: week 46 in Stretch cycle

What happened in the reproducible builds effort between March 6th and March 12th:

Packages fixed The following packages have become reproducible due to changes in their build dependencies: dfc, gap-openmath, gnubik, gplanarity, iirish, iitalian, monajat, openimageio, plexus-digest, ruby-fssm, vdr-plugin-dvd, vdr-plugin-spider. The following packages became reproducible after getting fixed:
  • adduser/3.114 by Niels Thykier.
  • bsdmainutils/9.0.7 by Michael Meskes.
  • criu/2.0-1 by Salvatore Bonaccorso.
  • genometools/1.5.8+ds-2 by Sascha Steinbiss.
  • gfs2-utils/3.1.8-1 uploaded by Bastian Blank, fix by Christoph Berg.
  • gmerlin/1.2.0~dfsg+1-5 by IOhannes m zm lnig.
  • heroes/0.21-14 by Stephen Kitt.
  • kmc/2.3+dfsg-3 by Sascha Steinbiss.
  • polyml/5.6-3 by James Clarke.
  • sed/4.2.2-7.1 by Niels Thykier.
  • snpomatic/1.0-3 by Sascha Steinbiss.
  • tantan/13-4 by Sascha Steinbiss.
Some uploads fixed some reproducibility issues, but not all of them: Patches submitted which have not made their way to the archive yet:
  • #817979 on modernizr by Sascha Steinbiss: sort list of files included in feature-detects.js.
  • #818027 on snapper by Sascha Steinbiss: always use /bin/sh as shell.

tests.reproducible-builds.org Always use all cores on armhf builders. (h01ger) Improve the look of Debian dashboard. (h01ger)

Package reviews 118 reviews have been removed, 114 added and 15 updated in the previous week. 15 FTBFS have been filled by Chris Lamb. New issues: xmlto_txt_output_locale_specific.

Misc. Lunar seeks new maintainers for diffoscope, several mailing lists, and these very weekly reports.

13 March 2016

Vincent Sanders: I changed my mind, Erase and rewind

My recent rack design turned out to simply not be practical. It did not hold all the SBC I needed it to and most troubling accessing connectors was impractical. I was forced to remove the enclosure from the rack and go back to piles of SBC on a shelf.

View of the acrylic being laser cut through the heavily tinted window
This sent me back to the beginning of the design process. The requirement for easy access to connectors had been compromised on in my first solution because I wanted a compact 1U size. This time I returned to my initial toast rack layout but retaining the SBC inside their clip cases.

By facing the connectors downwards and providing basic cable management the design should be much more practical.

My design process is to use the QCAD package to create layered 2D outlines which are then converted from DXF into toolpaths with Lasercut CAM software. The toolpaths are then uploaded to the laser cutter directly from the PC running Lasercut.

Assembled sub rack enclosureDespite the laser cutters being professional grade systems the Lasercut software is a continuous cause of issues for many users, it is the only closed source piece of software in the production process and it has a pretty poor user interface. On this occasion my main issue with it was my design was quite large at 700mm by 400mm which caused the software to crash repeatedly. I broke the design down into two halves and this allowed me to continue.

Once I defeated the software the design was laser cut from 3mm clear extruded acrylic. The assembled is secured with 72 off M3 nuts and bolts. The resulting construction is very strong and probably contains much more material than necessary.

One interesting thing I discovered is that in going from a 1U enclosure holding 5 units to a 2U design holding 11 units I had increased the final weight from 320g to 980g and when all 11 SBC are installed that goes up to a whopping 2300g. Fortunately this is within the mechanical capabilities of the material but it is the heaviest thing I have ever constructed from 3mm acrylic.

bolted into the rack and operatingOnce installed in the rack with all SBC inserted and connected this finally actually works and provides a practical solution. The self is finally clear of SBC and has enough space for all the other systems I need to accommodate for various projects.

As usual the design files are all freely available though I really cannot see anyone else needing to replicate this.

Andreas Metzler: How to put on one's hardboots, when ligaments are damaged

I have finally managed to do (a little bit of) snowboarding again this weekend. Previously I had failed early, when trying to pull on my hard-boots. I had (partially) torn some ligament in the ankle joint in February and am generally fine now, but exactly this movement still caused pain. What worked was to
  1. take the liner out of the boot,
  2. pull on the liner,
  3. step into the outer shell.

Antoine Beaupr : State of Mapping on the Debian Desktop

TL;DR: Mapbox Studio classic is not as good as Tilemill, Mapbox studio is very promising, but you still need to signup for access, and kosmtik seems to be working right now. Use kosmtik and help getting it in Debian.

The requirement I have been following the development of fascinating tools from the Development seed people, now seemingly all focused on the Mapbox brand. They created what seemed to me a revolutionary desktop tool called Tilemill. Tilemill allowed you to create custom map stylesheets on your desktop to outline specific areas or patterns or "things". My interest was to create outdoor maps - OSM has pretty good biking maps, but no generic outdoor tiles out there (I need stuff for skiing, canoeing, biking)... Mapbox has Mapbox outdoors but that's a paid plan as well. Oh and there's a place to download Garmin data files especially made for outdoors as well, and that could be loaded in Qmapshack, but they don't have coverage in Canada at all. Besides, I would like to print maps, I know, crazy... So I have been looking forward to seeing Tilemill packaged in Debian given how annoying it is to maintain Node apps (period). Unfortunately, by the time Debian people figured out all the Node dependencies, the Tilemill project stopped and has been stalled since 2012. It seems the Mapbox people have now been working on other products, and in the meantime, the community, scratching their heads, just switched to other projects.

Overview of alternatives I wrote this long post to the Debian bugtrackers to try to untangle all of this, but figured this would be interesting to a wider community than the narrow group of people working on Javascript packages, so I figured I would send this on Debian planet. So Here's a summary of what happened so far, after Tilemill development stopped. Hang on to your tiles boys and girls, there's a lot going on!

Mapbox Studio classic Mapbox people have released a new product in September 2014 named Mapbox studio classic. The code is still freely available and seems to be a fork of tilemill. Mapbox classic still has releases on github, last one is from November 2015. It looks like Mapbox studio classic has some sort of Mapbox.com lock-in, and there are certainly new copyright issues, if only with the bundled fonts, but it could probably be packaged after addressing those issues. There is an ITP for Mapbox Studio classic as well.

Mapbox Studio Then there's Mapbox Studio, which is a full rewrite of Mapbox Studio classic. You need to "signup" somehow to get access, even though parts of the code are free, namely the Mapbox GL studio project. It is an interesting project because it aims to make all this stuff happen in a web browser, which means it "should" work everywhere. Unfortunately for us, it means it doesn't work anywhere without a signup form, so that's out for me at least. There is an [ITP for Mapbox-studio][] yet it is unclear to me what that one means because the source code to Mapbox-studio doesn't seem to be available, as far as i can tell (and the ITP doesn't say either). That is actually the ITP for Mapbox studio classic.

Kosmtik The Openstreetmap-carto developers have mostly switched to kosmtik instead of Mapbox. Kosmtik is another Node desktop app that seems fairly lightweight and mostly based on plugins. Ross has an ITP for kosmtik. The package is waiting on other node dependencies to be uploaded (yes, again).

The future of Tilemill And there's still this RFP for tilemill, which should probably be closed now because the project seems dead and plenty of alternatives exist. I wonder if node some dependencies that were packaged for Tilemill actually now need to be removed from Debian, because they have become useless leaf packages... I am leaving the Tilemill RFP open for someone to clean that up.

CartoCSS Oh, and finally one could mention another Mapbox project, Carto, a command line CSS tools that implements some sort of standard CSS language that all those tools end up using to talk to Mapnik, more or less. There are no RFPs for that.

12 March 2016

Lars Wirzenius: Not-platform for Debian project leader elections 2016

After some serious thinking, I've decided not to nominate myself in the Debian project leader elections for 2016. While I was doing that, I wrote the beginnings of a platform, below. I'm publishing it to have a record of what I was thinking, in case I change my mind in the future, and perhaps it can inspire other other people to do something I would like to happen. Why not run? I don't think I want to deal with the stress. I already have more than enough stress in my life, from work. I enjoy my obscurity in Debian. It allows me to go away for long periods of time, and to ignore any discussions, topics, and people that annoy or frustrate me, if I don't happen to want to tackle them at any one time. I couldn't do that if I was DPL. NOT a platform for Debian project leader election, 2016 Apart from what the Debian constitution formally specifies, I find that the important duties of the Debian project leader are: I do not feel it is the job of the DPL to set goals for the project, technical or otherwise, any more than any other member of the project. Such goals tend to best come from enthusiastic individual developer who want something and are willing to work on it. The DPL should enable such developers, and make sure they have what they need to do the work. My plan, if elected
  1. Keep Debian running. Debian can run for a long time effectively on autopilot, even if the DPL vanishes, but not indefinitely. At minimum, the DPL should delegate the secretary and technical committee members, and decide on how money should be spent. I will make sure this minimum level is achieved.
  2. While I have no technical goals to set for the project, I have an organisational one. I believe it is time for the project to form a social committee whose mandate is to step in and help resolve conflicts in their early stages, before they grow big enough that the DPL, the tech-ctte, listmasters, or the DAM needs to involved. See below for more details on this. If I am elected, I will do my best to get a social committee started, and I will assume that any vote for me is also a vote for a social committee.
Social committee (Note: It's been suggested that this is a silly name, but I haven't had time to come up with anything better. I already rejected "nanny patrol".) We are a big project now. Despite our reputation, we are a remarkably calm project, but there are still occasional conflicts, and some of them spill out into our big mailing lists. We are not very good, as a project, in handling such situations. It is not a new idea, but I think its time has come, and I propose that we form a new committee, a social committee, whose job is to help de-escalate conflict situations while they are still small conflicts, to avoid them growing into big problems, and to help resolve big conflicts if they still happen. This is something the DPL has always been doing. People write to the DPL to ask for mediation, or other help, when they can't resolve a situation by themselves. We also have the technical committee, listmasters, GRs, and the expulsion process defined by the DAM. These are mostly heavy-weight tools and by the time it's time to consider their use, it's already too late to find a good solution. Having the DPL do this alone puts too much pressure on one person. We've learnt that important tasks should generally be handled by teams rather than just one person. Thus, I would like us to have a social committee that: About me I've been a Debian developer since 1996. I've been retired twice, while I spent large amounts of time on other things. I haven't been a member of any important team in Debian, but I've been around long enough that I know many people, and have a reasonable understanding of how the projects works.

11 March 2016

Steinar H. Gunderson: Agon and the Candidates tournament

The situation where Agon (the designated organizer of the Chess World Championship, and also the Candidates tournament, the prequalifier to said WC) is trying to claim exclusive rights of the broadcasting of the moves (not just the video) is turning bizarre. First of all, they have readily acknowledged they have no basis in copyright to do so; chess moves, once played, are facts and cannot be limited. They try to jump through some hoops with a New York-specific doctrine (even though the Candidates, unlike the World Championship, is played in Moscow) about hot news , but their main weapon seems to be that they simply will throw out anyone from the hall who tries to report on the moves, and then try to give them only to those that promise not to give them on. This leads to the previously unheard-of situation where you need to register and accept their terms just to get to watch the games in your browser. You have to wonder what they will be doing about the World Championship, which is broadcast unencrypted on Norwegian television (previous editions also with no geoblock). Needless to say, this wasn't practically possible to hold together. All the big sites (like Chessdom, ChessBomb and Chess24) had coverage as if nothing had happened. Move sourcing is a bit of a murky business where nobody really wants to say where they get the moves from (although it's pretty clear that for many tournaments, the tournament organizers will simply come to one or more of the big players with an URL they can poll at will, containing the games in the standard PGN format), and this was no exception ChessBomb went to the unusual move of asking their viewers to download Tor and crowdsource the moves, while Chessdom and Chess24 appeared to do no such thing. In fact, unlike Chessdom and ChessBomb, Chess24 didn't seem to say a thing about the controversy, possibly because they now found themselves on the other side of the fence from Norway Chess 2015, where they themselves had exclusive rights to the PGN in a similar controversy although it would seem from a tweet that they were perfectly okay with people just re-broadcasting from their site if they paid for a (quite expensive) premium membership, and didn't come up with any similar legal acrobatics to try to scare other sites. However, their ToS were less clear on the issue, and they didn't respond to requests for clarification at the time, so I guess all of this just continues to be on some sort of gentleman's agreement among the bigger players. (ChessBomb also provides PGNs for premium members for the tournaments they serve, but they expressly prohibit rebroadcast. They claim that for the tournaments they host, which is a small minority, they provide free PGNs for all.) Agon, predictably, sent out angry letters where they threatened to sue the sites in question, although it's not clear at all to me what exactly they would sue for. Nobody seemed to care, except one entity TWIC, which normally has live PGNs from most tournaments, announced they would not be broadcasting from the Candidats tournament. This isn't that unexpected, as TWIC (which is pretty much a one-man project anyway) mainly is about archival, where they publish weekly dumps of all top-level games played that week. This didn't affect a lot of sites, though, as TWIC's live PGNs are often not what you'd want to base a top-caliber site on (they usually lack clock information, and moves are often delayed by half a minute or so). I run a hobby chess relay/analysis site myself (mainly focusing on the games of Magnus Carlsen), though, so I've used TWIC a fair bit in the past, and if I were to cover the Candidates tournament (I don't plan to do so, given Agon's behavior, although I plan to cover the World Championship itself), I might have been hit by this. So, that was the background. The strange part started when worldchess.com, Agon's broadcasting site, promptly went down during the first round of the Candidates tournament today Agon blamed DDoS, which I'm sure is true, but it's unclear exactly how strong the DDoS was, and if they did anything at all to deal with it other than to simply wait it out. But this lead to the crazy situation where the self-declared monopolist was the only big player not broadcasting the tournament in some form. And now, in the trully bizarre move, World Chess is publishing a detailed rebuttal of Agon's arguments, explaining how it is bad for chess, not juridically sound, and also morally wrong. Yes, you read that right; Agon's broadcast site is carrying an op-ed saying Agon is wrong. You at least have to give them credit for not trying to censor their columinst when he says something they don't agree with. Oh, and if you want those PGNs? I will, at least for the time being, be pushing them out live on http://pgn.sesse.net/. I have not gone into any agreement with Agon, and they're hosted in Norway, far from any New York-specific doctrines. So feel free to relay from them, although I would of course be happy to know if you do.

Matthew Garrett: I stayed in a hotel with Android lightswitches and it was just as bad as you'd imagine

I'm in London for Kubecon right now, and the hotel I'm staying at has decided that light switches are unfashionable and replaced them with a series of Android tablets.
A tablet displaying the text UK_bathroom isn't responding. Do you want to close it?
One was embedded in the wall, but the two next to the bed had convenient looking ethernet cables plugged into the wall. So.

I managed to borrow a couple of USB ethernet adapters, set up a transparent bridge (brctl addbr br0; brctl addif br0 enp0s20f0u1; brctl addif br0 enp0s20f0u2; ifconfig br0 up) and then stuck my laptop between the tablet and the wall. tcpdump -i br0 showed traffic, and wireshark revealed that it was Modbus over TCP. Modbus is a pretty trivial protocol, and notably has no authentication whatsoever. tcpdump showed that traffic was being sent to 172.16.207.14, and pymodbus let me start controlling my lights, turning the TV on and off and even making my curtains open and close. What fun!

And then I noticed something. My room number is 714. The IP address I was communicating with was 172.16.207.14. They wouldn't, would they?

I mean yes obviously they would.

It's basically as bad as it could be - once I'd figured out the gateway, I could access the control systems on every floor and query other rooms to figure out whether the lights were on or not, which strongly implies that I could control them as well. Jesus Molina talked about doing this kind of thing a couple of years ago, so it's not some kind of one-off - instead, hotels are happily deploying systems with no meaningful security, and the outcome of sending a constant stream of "Set room lights to full" and "Open curtain" commands at 3AM seems fairly predictable.

We're doomed.

(edited: this previously claimed I could only access systems on my own floor, but it turns out that each floor is a separate broadcast domain and I just needed to set a gateway to access the others)

(further edit: I'm deliberately not naming the hotel. They were receptive to my feedback and promised to do something about the issue.)

comment count unavailable comments

Wouter Verhelst: File not found on exec

cat hello.c
#include <stdio.h>
int main(void)  
    printf("Hello World!\n");
    return 0;
 
A simple, standard, C program. Compiling and running it shouldn't produce any surprises... except when it does.
./hello
bash: ./hello: No such file or directory
The first time I got that, it was quite confusing. So, strace to the rescue -- I thought. But nope:
strace ./hello
execve("./hello", ["./hello"], [/* 14 vars */]) = -1 ENOENT (No such file or directory)
(output trimmed) No luck there. What's going on? No, it's not some race condition whereby the file is being removed. A simple ls -l will show it's there, and that it's executable. So what? When I first encountered this, I was at a loss. Eventually, after searching for several hours, I figured it out and filed it under "surprising things with an easy fix". And didn't think of it anymore for a while, because once you understand what's going on, it's not that complicated. But I recently realized that it's not that obvious, and I've met several people who were at a loss when encountering this, and who didn't figure it out. So, here goes: If you tell the kernel to run some application (i.e., if you run one of the exec system calls), it will open the binary and try to figure out what kind of application it's dealing with. It may be a script with a shebang line (in which case the kernel calls the appropriate interpreter), or it may be an ELF binary, or whatever. If it is an ELF binary, the kernel checks if the architecture of the binary matches the CPU we're running on. If that's the case, it will just execute the instructions in the binary. If it's not an ELF binary, or if the architecture doesn't match, it will fall back on some other mechanism (e.g., the binfmt_misc subsystem could have some emulator set up to run binaries for the architecture in question, or may have been set up to run java on jar files, etc). Eventually, if all else fails, the kernel will return an error:
./hello: cannot execute binary file: Exec format error
"Exec format error" is the error message for ENOEXEC, the error code which the kernel returns if it determines that it cannot run the given binary. This makes it fairly obvious what's wrong, and why. Now assume the kernel is biarch -- that is, it runs on an architecture which can run binaries for two CPU ISAs; e.g., this may be the case for an x86-64 machine, where the CPU can run binaries for that architecture as well as binaries for the i386 architecture (and its 32-bit decendants) without emulation. If the kernel has the option to run 32-bit x86 binaries enabled at compile time (which most binary distributions do, these days), then running i386 ELF binaries is possible, in theory. As far as the kernel is concerned, at least. So, the kernel maps the i386 binary into memory, and jumps to the binary's entry point. And here is where it gets interesting: When the binary in question uses shared libraries, the kernel not only needs to open this binary itself, but also the runtime dynamic linker (RTDL). It is then the job of the RTDL to map the shared libraries into memory for the process to use, before jumping to its code. But what if the RTDL isn't installed? Well, then the kernel won't find it. The RTDL is just this file, so that means it will produce an ENOENT error code -- the error message for which is "No such file or directory". And there you have it. The solution is simple, and the explanation too; but still, even so, it can be a bit baffling: the system tells you "the file isn't there", without telling you which file it's missing. Since you passed it only one file, it's reasonable for you to believe the missing file is the binary you're asking the system to execute. But usually, that's not the problem: the problem is that the file containing the RTDL is not installed, which is just a result of you not having enabled multiarch. Solution:
dpkg --add-architecture <target architecture>
apt update
apt install libc6:<target architecture>
Obviously you might need to add some more libraries, too, but that's not usually a problem.

Rapha&#235;l Hertzog: Freexian s report about Debian Long Term Support, February 2016

A Debian LTS logoLike each month, here comes a report about the work of paid contributors to Debian LTS. Individual reports In February, 112.50 work hours have been dispatched among 11 paid contributors. Their reports are available: Evolution of the situation The number of sponsored hours continued to decrease a little bit. It s not worrisome yet but we should try to get back to a positive slope if we want to be able to do an outstanding job for wheezy LTS. On the positive side, TOSHIBA renewed their platinum sponsorship for another 6 months at least and we have some contacts for new sponsors, though they are far from being concluded yet. We are now in transition between squeeze LTS and wheezy LTS. The paid contributors are helping the security team by fixing packages that were fixed in squeeze already but that are still outstanding in wheezy. They are also taking generic measures to prepare wheezy LTS (for example to ensure all packages work with OpenJDK 7.x since support for 6.x will be dropped in the LTS period). Thanks to our sponsors New sponsors are in bold (none this month).

No comment Liked this article? Click here. My blog is Flattr-enabled.

10 March 2016

Antoine Beaupr : Trying out Keybase

I was privileged enough to get access to the alpha preview of Keybase.io. Last year, the project raised 11M$ in venture capital and they seem to be attacking the hard problems, so it is a serious project, worth considering for any cryptography hacker like me. This was obviously discussed elsewhere previously but since Keybase has evolved a bit since then, I figured it would be worth adding my grain of salt.

The elite alpha problem My first problem with Keybase was of course that I wasn't in the elite club of invited people. Somehow, I finally got in but the problem remains for the everyone else. In my case, it was the Keybase filesystem announcement that brought my attention back to the project, although I have yet to test that itself - yet another invite-only problem (need to email chris@keybase.io to get access, I guess). Still, 10GB of storage might be interesting for some people, but considering the number of hurdles or "friction", as they say, that needs to be jumped over to get access, I am not sure how much traction this will get for now. The project has been in alpha for a while now (more than a year) with no announced public beta just yet, which is way slower than similarly challenging projects with less capital. Let's encrypt, as a comparison, was publicly announced in 2014 and by the end of 2015, the public beta was opened.

Private key leakage My second major concern is that Keybase does worrisome things to private key material. If you tell it to import your regular GPG keys, it will copy them into the keybase keyring, which is already a problem: now you have two places where you store sensitive secrets. But worse, Keybase offers you to upload your private key material on the server, without clearly and explicitely exposing the potential risks that means to the user. The key, presumably, is encrypted (at least that is what I can parse from the Keybase privacy policy). Yet this is still a concern: a determined attacker (e.g. the government or another malicious entity) could force Keybase to give up the encrypted private key material and install sniffers that would reveal the passphrase that would allow decryption and impersonation of the related identity. That is a huge deal. This is what caused Hushmail's demise in 2007: they had similar promises about how they had a "secure" email (in this case) service based on OpenPGP, but since they key was stored on the server, they only had to serve a malicious applet to victims and were able to give cleartext data to the US government (12 CDs!) under a Mutual Legal Assistance Treaty with Canada. In Keybase, When I generate a new key, it asks me if I want to upload the key to their servers, and "Yes" is chosen as a default, so it is clearly a policy that is encouraged. This is presumably to enable browser-based crypto, yet this could be done by storing keys within the browser, not on the server. The mere possibility that the client can meddle with secret key material in such a way is a problem. Even if uploading secret keys to the server is optional, the fact that it is a possibility widens the attack surface on the client significantly. GPG has been working on isolating private key operations to a different process (gpg-agent) or smart cards, SSH has privilege seperation. The idea of uploading secret key material online is so beyond current practices that it should bring the project to a full stop already. My private key material is pretty sensitive. I am a Debian developer: if someone gets access to that key, they can upload arbitrary code for thousands of packages, affecting thousands if not millions of users. That is a huge deal, and I am not ready to give that power to an arbitrary third party that I know little about.

Privacy policy issues Furthermore, the Keybase privacy policy explicitely states that "Logs of this information may persist for an indefinite period", which include, and I quote:
  • Your computer s IP address
  • Your preferences and settings (time zone, language, privacy preferences, application preferences, etc.)
  • The URL of the site that referred you to the Service
  • The buttons and controls you clicked on (if any) within the Service
  • How long you used the Service and which parts and features you used
  • Session times and lengths
For a company working to improve user's privacy, this is a pretty bad policy. It exposes Keybase users to undue surveillance, on a lot of private information that is not necessary to operate the service. I haven't actually read the remaining of the policy, as I was already scared as hell and figure I would just log off for now and try not to add any extra personal information in that already growing pile. Let's mention, while I'm here, that the keybase commandline client has this odd way of working that it forks a daemon in the background all the time, even to run just keybase status. One has to wonder if this thing is included in the surveillance data above, which would make the keybase client an amazing surveillance device in itself. To stop all this, you need:
keybase logout
keybase ctl stop
Not quite obvious...

Usability issues Which brings me to a series of usability issues I have found while working with Keybase. Having worked on usability myself in the Monkeysphere project, I understand how hard those problems can be. But right now, the fact is that keybase is only a commandline client, with some web-based sugar sprinkled on top. I recognize the huge efforts that have been done to make the user experience (UX) as easy as possible through the commandline, but this is definitely not "grand public" material yet. Even as a OpenPGP hacker, Keybase can get confusing. Since it has its own separate keyring from GPG, things that used to be obvious before are suddenly new things to learn. For example, I originally generated a key for anarcat@debian.org in keybase, thinking it would be a separate thing from my current GPG identity. Well, that ended up creating a new key in my GPG keyring, duplicating my existing identity, with no way for me to tell this was a Keybase copy. This could have ended up on the keyservers and confuse anyone looking for my PGP key.

Revoking keys So I revoked that key, which, in itself, is not such an obvious process either. I first had to "drop" the key:
keybase pgp drop '010143572d4e438f457a7447c9758804cc7be44c1ee2b7915c3904567d0a3fb5cf590a'
To find that magic number, I had to go on the website and click through the PGP key to end up on the revoke link which told me which magic string to put. The web UI was telling me I could use keybase status to get that information, but I couldn't find that in the output here:
$ keybase status
Username:      anarcat
Logged in:     no
Device:
    name:      angela
    ID:        070f6a13f2a66afbb463f49dadfd4518
    status:    active
Keybase keys:  unlocked
Session:       anarcat [salt only]
KBFS:
    status:    not running
    version:
    log:       /home/anarcat/.cache/keybase/keybase.kbfs.log
Service:
    status:    running
    version:   1.0.14-1
    log:       /home/anarcat/.cache/keybase/keybase.service.log
Platform Information:
    OS:        linux
    Runtime:   go1.5.3
    Arch:      amd64
Client:
    version:   1.0.14-1
Desktop app:
    status:    not running
    version:
    log:       /home/anarcat/.cache/keybase/Keybase.app.log
Config path:   /home/anarcat/.config/keybase/config.json
Default user:  anarcat
Other users:
command-line client:
    keybase status [pid: 14562, version: 1.0.14-1]
So keybase drop "deletes" the key from the keybase client (and presumably the server). One problem here is that we have three different verbs to mean the same thing: in some places, the website says "deleted" (in the web graph), the commandline client uses "drop" and everyone else using PGP in the world uses "revoke". So what is it? Also note that just dropping that key is not enough to eradicate that key: you still need to generate and import a revocation certificate on GPG's side as well, for that key. This makes sense, because you may have imported that key and you may not want to destroy it when you remove it from keybase, but there could be a little better guessing and UX here as well.

Password usage Then another problem is that, when you signup on the commandline, it asks you to choose a passphrase. It's not clear at all from the UI what that passphrase is for. Is it to protect the private key material? To login the website? Both? It turns out it is actually to login to the website and the Keybase API. It could also be the key to the private key material, but I haven't quite figured that out yet. Similarly, the "paper devices" are a little confusing to me as well. The registration process is fairly insistent that I need to write a series of secret words down on a piece of paper and put it my wallet. This is based on the idea that you can use that key to recover your account and setup new devices. However, it is not made clear at all how those credentials should be protected or used. What if I lose my wallet? What do I do then? Is it okay if i write it on the back of my laptop instead? I know it sounds like stupid questions to crypto geek, but it's definitely stuff people will do, and education, at all levels, is necessary here.

The existing web of trust Finally, I found it surprisingly counter-intuitive to sign keys with keybase. I was assuming the whole point of the thing was to expand the web of trust, but it seems their mission lies somewhere else: there is no facility to sign keys directly in keybase. You sign statements on various social sites (Github, Twitter, Reddit...) but doing traditional key exchanges seems to be off limits. My obvious use case was to sign my existing key material with my newly generated anarcat@keybase.io key, so that keybase would become another way of verifying my identity. Well, this is not possible with keybase directly - you still have to go through the regular:
gpg --sign-key DEADBEEF
Which is really unfortunate, because some craaaazy people like me insist on doing in person, actually secure key exchanges sometimes, and the tools to do this right now (mainly gpg, caff and monkeysign) really need a lot of love and help. Keybase could have helped a lot in pushing those initiatives forward and bring new ways of doing secure key exchanges, instead of only lowering the standards on cryptographic identity.

Usual proprietary startup rant I can't help but finish by noticing that the whole basic problem with Keybase is more fundamental than a few usability issues, which can all be fixed fairly easily. Keybase.IO is a web-based service that is entirely proprietary. The client is freely downloadable and free software - but the server side is not. This makes us rely on a central point of failure and the goodwill of those operators to not only keep the service running (for free?) indefinitely, but to protect us against all attackers, state-run or otherwise. This is definitely against basic free software principles and the open architecture of the internet federation, well embodied in the Franklin street statement. Online services should be decentralized and open like the OpenPGP keyservers have always been, period.

Conclusion I am curious to see where Keybase brings us, as a community. So far, I am concerned about centralization and devaluation of the web of trust as cryptographic system. I do not believe that trusting multiple corporate social networking sites bring much benefit to our security, although it does improve usability significantly and is certainly better than TOFU, so that part of the project is definitely interesting, especially since it allows leveraging classical internet protocols like DNS and HTTPS. Key exchange is a critical problem that still hasn't properly been resolved in the cryptographic community. Most efforts at building communication tools (say like Signal or Telegram) mostly ignore the problem and expect people to read up strings of numbers or rely on synchronous communications (see the Axolotl rachet for Signal's take on it). Keybase's attempts at fixing this are great, but needs much more work to actually resolve the PKI issues in a significant way. More fundamentally, the practice of storing keys on the servers should just stop: it is a definite no go for me, and a classic crypto mistake that has bitten way too many people. In my mind, it discredits the whole project. The point of OpenPGP is end to end encryption across devices: storing the keys on a server breaks that apart, and doesn't improve much on the existing HTTPS security systems already in place on the web. It is especially a problem given the new waves of attacks on cryptography from western governments, from the UK to California... Until those issues are resolved, I can't get myself to recommend Keybase to anyone just yet.

Post-scriptum Note to Keybase developers: I have considered filing issues regarding the above, but unfortunately, I was unable to filter through the gigantic github issues list for duplicates, and didn't have time to file detailed reports for everything. I apologize for bypassing those usual conventions. If you want to try out Keybase to make your own opinion, I do have 4 invites I can give away, but I will do so only if you need to test specific issues. Otherwise, I note that there is a Request For Package for the Debian package to become official, that Debian developers (or Keybase developers!) may be interested in completing.

Michal &#268;iha&#345;: Weblate 2.5

After almost six months of development Weblate 2.5 has been released. It brings lot of improvements and it's quite hard to point few ones. The most important ones include support for Python 3, reports generators, placeables highlighting, extended keyboard shortcuts, configurable dashboard or group based ACLs. Full list of changes for 2.5: If you are upgrading from older version, please follow our upgrading instructions. You can find more information about Weblate on https://weblate.org, the code is hosted on Github. If you are curious how it looks, you can try it out on demo server. You can login there with demo account using demo password or register your own user. Weblate is also being used https://hosted.weblate.org/ as official translating service for phpMyAdmin, OsmAnd, Aptoide, FreedomBox, Weblate itself and many other projects. Should you be looking for hosting of translations for your project, I'm happy to host them for you or help with setting it up on your infrastructure. Further development of Weblate would not be possible without people providing donations, thanks to everybody who have helped so far! The roadmap for next release is just being prepared, you can influence this by expressing support for individual issues either by comments or by providing bounty for them.

Filed under: English Weblate 0 comments

8 March 2016

Dirk Eddelbuettel: gtrendsR 1.3.3

A very nice new update to the gtrendsR package by Philippe and myself is now avilable via CRAN. I had only blogged about the initial 1.3.0 release, and we have added a whole slew of new features and fixes. Philippe rewrote a lot of the parsing to make it more robust to different encodings, and to add other features. So in no particular order, we can now sub-group by regions more finely, withstand various misfeatures in returned data sets, generally do better on connections, and more --- and also allow for intra-day, daily and weekly queries! That last part is pretty fun. Here is the code I ran last Saturday to look at the query for Donald Drumpf, a name brought to us via a beautiful John Oliver episode worth watching which ran about nine days ago. So last Saturday, when we were still within the seven day window, I ran
library(gtrendsR)
dp <- gtrends("Donald Drumpf", res="7d")
plot(dp) + ggplot2::ggtitle("The Drumpf") + ggplot2::theme(legend.position="none")
which resulted in the following chart Donald Drump query which highlights another nice feature: the ggplot2 object created by the plotting function is returned, so we can locally modify and tune it. Here we set a title and suppress the default legend. As I had not blogged about the interim bug-fix releases 1.3.1 and 1.3.2, here is the set of NEWS entries for the last three releases:

gtrendsR 1.3.3
  • A ggplot2 object can now be returned for further customization. plot(gtrends("NHL")) + ggtitle("NHL trend") + theme(legend.position="none")
  • Support for hourly and daily data (#67). For example, it is now possible to have hourly data for the last seven days with gtrends("nhl", geo = "CA", res = "7d"). Use ?gtrends for more information about the time resolution supported by the package.
  • Support for categorties (#46). Ex.: gtrends("NHL", geo = "US", cat = "0-20") will search only in the sport category.
  • Some countries (ex: Hong Kong) were missing from the list (#69).
  • Various typos and documentation work.

gtrendsR 1.3.2
  • Added support for sub-countries (#25). Ex.: gtrends("NHL", geo = "CA-QC") will return trends data for Qu bec province in Canada. The list of supported sub-countries can be obtained via data(countries).
  • Data parsing should work for any data returned by Google Trends (i.e. countries independent).
  • Better support for queries using keywords in different languages (#50, #57). Ex.: gtrends(" ", geo = "TW")
  • Now able to specify up to five countries (#53) via gtrends("NHL", geo = c("CA", "US"))
  • Fixing issue #51 allowing UK-based queries via geo = "GB"

gtrendsR 1.3.1
  • Fixing issue #34 where connection verification was not done properly.
  • Now able to use more latin character in query. For example: gtrends("montr al").
  • Can now deal with data returned other than in English language.

Courtesy of CRANberries, there is also a diffstat report for the this release. As always, more detailed information is on the gtrendsR repo where questions, comments etc should go via the issue tickets system.

This post by Dirk Eddelbuettel originated on his Thinking inside the box blog. Please report excessive re-aggregation in third-party for-profit settings.

Edited 2016-03-08: Corrected code snipped and one grammar instance

Michal &#268;iha&#345;: Weekly phpMyAdmin contributions 2016-W09

The last week was mostly spent on bugfixing and cleanup after security releases. Hopefully the amount of security reports will go down now. Most of the bug fixes were in the SQL parser which influences quite a lot of parts of phpMyAdmin. It is responsible for splitting queries on import, generating queries for export or linting the queries as users type them. Additionally Debian packages were also updated, for both unstable and testing and for Ubuntu PPA. Handled issues:

Filed under: Debian English phpMyAdmin 0 comments

Guido G nther: Debian Fun in February 2016

Debian LTS February was the tenth month I contributed to Debian LTS under the Freexian umbrella. In total I spent 7 hours (of allocated 11.15 hours) working on squeeze-lts: and to make sure we have fewer issues that are fixed in squeeze-lts but affect wheezy On non LTS time I cooked up a script to make it simpler to check if a package has security support in a certain release. Now that squeeze-lts is history I'd like to thank the Debian Security Team for their help and answers to all the questions related to security tracker, DSAs, DLAs and whatnot. I'm looking forward to wheezy-lts now Other Debian stuff

Tassia Camoes Araujo: Some impressions of a flourishing community bits from the MiniDebConf Curitiba @ Montreal

Last month I more-or-less accepted an invitation that got me scared at first, panicking after a while. Why do I put myself in such an uncomfortable position? Well, I think that s how we grow up ;-) I was first contacted to talk about women participation in Debian, which I kindly refused, but I said I would maybe talk about motivating new contributors, possibly with some more friends that would maybe join me at the stage. I need to confess that at that moment I had no idea (ok, a vague idea ) about what I was going to talk. So I promptly emailed some Debian friends, shared the invitation, shared some thoughts, got feedbacks, got encouragement, and we finally made it! talk_transmission For the video conference we used mconf.org which worked super well (the downside is that it requires flash, maybe you could help them get rid of it?). I had also recorded a backup video with vokoscreen, just in case Murphy would decide to go to Curitiba but everything worked well. We a single moment with connection issues, but the torrent user kindly released the bandwidth The main point I made in the talk is that Debian as a Universal Operating System is still an utopia, especially when we extend our understanding of universality to our contributors. And as an utopia, it serves to make us walk! The more we advance, the more it gets further away, so we need to keep walking. Another important point was that diversity is not an issue that touches only woman. My audience was full of Portuguese native speakers, from a third world country, a few women, many more man, a couple of DDs, some longtime contributors, some newbies, and most of them are also part of minorities in our community. I bet many of them has already felt like a weed growing surrounded by concrete at least once in their lifetimes Solidarity towards our utopia was my final message. Just for fun, and to make a recap of our conversation at the end, I made a list of 10 steps that we could all give to contribute to a more universal Debian: 1. Read our Social Contract and make sure we are all at the same page
2. Improve Debian documentation
3. Remember that diversity does not concern only women
4. Keep an eye on minority groups and show solidarity
5. Be open and alert to the needs of newbies
6. Help Debian teams to be prepared to welcome new contributors
7. Reserve part of our time to integrate new members to the community
8. Promote hands-on meetings (local and remote)
9. Promote peer-mentoring among newbie contributors
10. Do not see Debian members as special beings, we are all humans! You can check my slides or the video of the live transmission if you want to see more. In case you can not follow the audio, I d be happy to provide subtitles (but I probably won t work on that if I don t receive have any request). And if you invite me to another conference, we can have a similar chat at with your community. Note: in person is more fun ;-) Finally, I d like to thank the participants of the mini-DebConf, those that followed this session and those who were practicing how to package on the other room, Paulo Santana and all the local organization team for the invitation, Ana Guerrero and Laura Arjona for the remote support and feedback, Andreas Tille for the efforts in integrating new contributors, Christian Perrier for the developer statistics, Val ssio for being in the audience and the Debian Project for the inspiration. What we had we Brazil this weekend was a taste of a flourishing and welcoming community, I am proud and honored to be part of it!

6 March 2016

Thorsten Glaser: mksh R52c, paxmirabilis 20160306 released; PA4 paper size PDF manpages

The MirBSD Korn Shell R52c was published today as bugfix-accumulating release of low upto medium importance. Thanks to everyone who helped squashing all those bugs; this includes our bug reporters who always include reproducer testcases; you re wonderful! MirCPIO was also resynchronised from OpenBSD, to address the CVE-2015- 1193,1194 test cases, after a downstream (wow there are so many?) reminded us of it; thanks!
This is mostly to prevent extracting ../foo either directly or from a symlink(7) from actually ending up being placed in the parent directory. As such the severity is medium-high. And it has a page now initially just a landing page / stub; will be fleshed out later. Uploads for both should make their way into Debian very soon (these are the packages mksh and pax). Uploading backports for mksh (jessie and wheezy-sloppy) have been requested by several users, but none of the four(?) DDs asked about sponsoring them even answered at all, and the regular (current) sponsors don t have experience with bpo, so SOL I ve also tweaked a bug in sed(1), in MirBSD. Unfortunately, this means it now comes with the GNUism -i too: don t use it, use ed(1) (much nicer anyway) or perlrun(1) -p/-n Finally, our PDF manpages now use the PA4 paper size instead of DIN ISO A4, meaning they can be printed without cropping or scaling on both A4 and US-american letter paper. And a from the last announcement: we now use Gentium and Inconsolata as body text and monospace fonts, respectively. (And propos, the website ought to be more legible due to text justification and better line spacing now.) I managed to hack this up in GNU groff and Ghostscript, thankfully. (LaTeX too) Currently there are PDF manpages for joe (jupp), mksh, and cpio/pax/tar. And we had Gr nkohl today! Also, new console-setup package in the WTF APT repository since upstream managed to do actual work on it (even fixed some bugs). Read its feed if interested, as its news will not be repeated here usually. (That means, subscribe as there won t be many future reminders in this place.) The netboot.me service appears to be gone. I ll not remove our images, but if someone knows what became of it drop us a message (IRC or mailing list will work just fine). PS: This was originally written on 20160304 but opax refused to be merged in time Happy Birthday, gecko2! In the meantime, the Street Food festival weekend provided wonderful food at BaseCamp, and headache prevented this from being finished on the fifth. Update 06.03.2016: The pax changes were too intrusive, so I decided to only backport the fixes OpenBSD did (both those they mentioned and those silently included), well, the applicable parts of them, anyway, instead. There will be a MirCPIO release completely rebased later after all changes are merged and, more importantly, tested. Another release although not set for immediate future should bring a more sensible (and mksh-like) buildsystem for improved portability (and thus some more changes we had to exclude at first). I ve also cloned the halfwidth part of the FixedMisc [MirOS] font as FixedMiscHW for use with Qt5 applications, xfonts-base in the WTF APT repo. (Debian #809979) tl;dr: mksh R52c (bugfix-only, low-medium); mircpio 20160306 (security backport; high) with future complete rebase (medium) upstream and in Debian. No mksh backports due to lacking a bpo capable sponsor. New console-setup in WTF APT repo, and mksh there as usual. xfonts-base too. netboot.me gone?

Next.

Previous.