Yes, Microsoft have
started swinging their patent bat a little harder. However, before
everyone gets all screamy about the "235 patents" thing, read a little
closer:
the Linux kernel [...] violates 42 Microsoft patents. The Linux graphical
user interfaces - essentially, the way design elements like menus and
toolbars are set up - run afoul of another 65, he claims. The Open Office
suite of programs, which is analogous to Microsoft Office, infringes 45
more. E-mail programs infringe 15, while other assorted FOSS programs
allegedly transgress 68.
While I can forgive a journalist the sin of not knowing the difference
between Linux-the-kernel and Linux-the-entire-FOSS-ecosystem, can people who
should have a clue about this please stop perpetuating the
inaccuracy?
Yes, 42 patents is still pretty bad, but it's not 235, and getting facts
straight is what we do on this side of the debate -- the frothing and
bullshit is what the
other guys do.
Once you start looking at the various categories of patent, it really does
make it obvious that there's some straw-grasping going on here. If GUI
elements really infringe on 65 Microsoft patents, it seems reasonable to
assume that KDE and Gnome have a subset each, so presumably nobody gets the
full brunt of that lot. Also, those 68 "assorted FOSS programs" patents
probably includes such widely-used classics as
this pearler of a program
(chosen at random from Freshmeat for it's likely small userbase; no other
ridicule is intended or implied).
What galls me, though, isn't the bandying around of random inaccurate
numbers, it's classy things like this:
[some Microsoft sock-puppet] refuses to identify specific patents or
explain how they're being infringed, lest FOSS advocates start filing
challenges to them.
Yeah, we'd hate it if the patent system were at
all used in the
manner in which it were intended. I don't suppose anyone else is getting
SCO-style "we've got 100,000 lines of infringing code, but we're not going
to tell you which ones" flashback at this point?
Personally, I think that if Microsoft ever
does starts with a
patent smackdown, it won't be 235 patents, it'll be two or three, the
strongest ones they can find, and 90 minutes after the plaintiff(s) is/are
served the infringing code will be history, and we'll go back to living our
lives as normal. That's even assuming that the patents are legit, which is
by no means a given (even with the US' insanely broad patent provisions).
As the linked article explains, the US Supreme Court has started getting a
bit noisy on the subject of over-broad and pointless software patents, so
perhaps Microsoft is just getting it's licks in before the Supremes take
it's noisy rattle away from it.
There's some side-commentary on this issue
at
Groklaw, and
the
Patent Law blog has a quick mention of it too (with all sorts of nice
frothy comments, to boot).