
I recently attended the Play! concert in Oslo, with a friend who was visiting Oslo from Bergen.
The concert took place in an expo hall just outside Oslo, which was being used for the Electroworld electronics exposition. Wow, has that ever changed! I was there the first time, three-odd years ago, when it was arranged in Oslo Spektrum, and I was bitterly disappointed! It was nothing but a slightly larger Expert Electronics store. I was angry that I had actually been conned into paying for this.
This year, it was completely different. They had a gigantic venue, with lots of interesting booths. Yamaha showed off some truly gorgeous digital pianos, and electronic drum sets, NRK was there, to show off their beautiful HD-1 HDTV production bus, and all kinds of interesting things. Even so, it was very clear that Expert was trying to get you to buy stuff. Something just doesn’t sit right with me about paying money to enter a store which is marketed as an expo.
My previous experience with Electroworld meant I was not at all interested in repeating it. I wanted to catch the concert which was being held there. But they wouldn’t let me in unless I bought a ticket for the expo. Having already paid 70 EUR for a concert ticket, I was not enthusiastic about paying 15 more EUR to be allowed to enter the venue. But I relented, and was duly fleeced.
I only got around 30 minutes of time before the concert started, so I didn’t get all that much time to look around.
The first part of the concert started. The orchestra was the wonderful KORK (AKA Kringkastingsorkesteret, AKA “The Norwegian Radio Orchestra”). They started off with a beautiful fanfare by Nobuo Uematsu. However, their choice of music frustrates me deeply. They played some of the obvious classics, like Mario, Sonic The Hedgehog, some Zelda, but most of the time was wasted on some really lame music.
It seems that their repertoire was not chosen based on the musical merit of the games, but on the current popularity. Why else would they be devoting time to some dull, insipid incidental music from WoW, Halo, and Silent Hill, without even an identifiable motif, as opposed to more of Koji Kondo’s wonderful Mario or Zelda tunes, or - damnit - Nobuo Uematsu’s Final Fantasy music?
This is the thing that has left me the most disappointed. They practically ignored the elephant in the room of game music, Nobuo Uematsu. His compositions are absolutely beautiful, and they really shine when performed by a classical orchestra. You can practically tell that they’re meant to be performed by them, rather than some dinky Super Nintendo synthesizer chip. The Final Fantasy VI Opera, most of the Final Fantasy VII soundtrack…
They then proceed to play One by Metallica. …WTF, you ask? WTF, indeed. Their justification was that it’s in the soundtrack from Guitar Hero. That’s absurd. And it wasn’t even a very good performance. It was still pretty funny that this very serious-looking classically trained vocalist slowly walked up on stage and gave a really good performance - he really did sound like the Metallica vocalist.
Almost as an afterthought, at the very last, they play One-Winged Angel, one of the most dramatic and beautiful pieces from Final Fantasy VII. The audience breaks into absolutely wild applause. But - what - they bring in a METAL BAND on stage. A GODDAMNED METAL BAND! And they proceed to absolutely
slaughter the whole piece! The choir and orchestra are drowned out by loud electric guitars with riffs that don’t make sense, and a drummer that can’t even keep the damned
beat - the bass drum was all over the place!
Seemingly not content with simply omitting his music, they have to absolutely demolish the performance of it.
I actually have to say that this is by far the most disappointing concert I have ever gone to. Granted, my expectations were high, but just to witness a live performance by this wonderful orchestra of the Prelude, Anxious Heart, Tifa’s Theme, Eyes On Me, Fighting!, Still More Fighting! or Aerith’s Theme would’ve made the 85 EUR worth it. Judging from the audience’s applause when he first mentioned the Final Fantasy series, I think they agreed with me.