Search Results: "ag"

4 November 2007

Marc 'Zugschlus' Haber: exim4 vs. OpenSSL vs. GnuTLS

Judging from the long list of exim4 bugs, especially #446036, I find myself between a rock and a hard place, and having to choose between staying with GnuTLS and accepting a probably continuing flow of technical issues, or moving over to OpenSSL, setting an example against GNU software, and probably generating a new flow of license issues. GnuTLS is the “clearer” solution from a license point of view: The client library is LGPL, and it can thus be safely linked to everything that is part of Debian main. This is the main reason why we decided to use GnuTLS for exim4 years ago, so that we do not need to worry about licensing issues when some other library is linked to by exim some time in the future. On the other hand, my impression gets stronger and stronger that GnuTLS is not ready for prime-time. There is a truckload of interoperability problems with a number of “remote sides”. The most prominent issues are TLS aborts when exim4 is SMTP server for some clients, most notably Incredimail and some mobile Phones from Nokia and other vendors. Most of them can be nailed down to misnegotiation of certain ciphers, but exim does currently not allow disabling of some ciphers at run-time, and - even worse - one would need to disable them completely since one cannot judge in advance whether we are facing a client with issues or one without. The GnuTLS maintainers of both Debian and upstream try being helpful, but I do not see a long-term solution here. Additionally, nobody upstream knows its way around the GnuTLS related code in exim, which was contributed by Nikos Mavroyanopoulos years ago. So, there is little chance to get GnuTLS-related bugs ironed out from exim. OpenSSL, on the other hand, does not have these interoperability issues. At least, I haven’t heard of any, and the recommended fix for the reporters of GnuTLS related bugs, “recompile exim with OpenSSL” (which the packaging has been supporting for nearly two years now), usually fixes their problems. I am not in a position to judge whether this is caused by people actually testing against OpenSSL, or OpenSSL generally being more tolerant towards strange implementations, or GnuTLS being buggy or poorly written. However, building exim4 again OpenSSL may post the license issues that convinced us to use GnuTLS in the first place. Exim itself has an OpenSSL exception, and from what I have been told, the MySQL FLOSS License Exception allows linkage to OpenSSL as well. At least, it does now, since historical evidence in the exim4 package either shows that it used to be a license violation to link MySQL and OpenSSL in the past, or that we (the Debian exim4 team) wrongly thought so. On the other hand, if it is illegal to have OpenSSL and “really” GPLled code in the same execution space, we already have that license violation today, brought to us by PostgreSQL, which links against OpenSSL. ftpmaster has already indicated that they won’t consider an exim4 linked against OpenSSL a license violation and that the packages would go through, the packaging can handle the change by virtue of flipping a switch and rebuilding, but I am still not fully convinced that doing so is the right thing from a political and license point of view. I might still need that final nudge by feedback to this blog article, or have my reluctance fed. Please comment. No, I do not plan to take this to debian-legal; I’d prefer exim4 staying in Debian main.

MJ Ray: Alt.Satellite.TV.Europe FAQ: Loft Dishes and British TV

These questions came in as comments this week, but I think they're worth a whole post. Peter Swan asked:
"This may seem like a dumb question, but I have not seen anywhere the answer to it. Can a satellite dish be mounted in a loft space or must it be mounted outside?"
There are few dumb questions. DIY dish info is still rather hard to find. You can install a dish behind a window and I've read about special tiles which allow satellite frequencies through on analoguesat's pages about hiding dishes but I don't know anyone using them. A more usual solution is either a hidden location such as a flat roof with baffle boards (dishes only need to see the Clarke belt, which is an elevation of about 20 degrees in England) or to use a non-dish antenna like the digiglobe or the LX2000 pipe. I think it's a really good idea to put the dish somewhere that you can fix it easily. Even the best dish seems to age eventually. I suspect some "professional" installers put the dishes at tops of walls to encourage repair call-outs. Marcus asked:
"Is it possible to receive British satellite television in other countries? I am living in Finland and I was considering purchasing a sky system from the UK and installing it over here. Would it work? Also would I be able to connect a sky set-top box to a different dish?"
Yes, you can get British TV in other countries. Getting external TV like BBC World is easy, but BBC UK services are on Astra 2D, which is focused on the UK. Coverage maps are available on many sites and it looks like Finland isn't well-covered. You'd need a colossal dish. You can connect Sky boxes to other dishes. Sky dishes and Sky LNBs need to go together, sometimes called Skyware, but dishes and boxes are interchangeable. A Sky system will work in Finland, but will only receive services on the other beams like 2A and I doubt Sky will register you at a non-UK address (anyone know for sure?). Also, Sky boxes are horribly crippled for anything other than Sky services and hopefully BBC Freesat will make BBC UK services easier-to-use with standard boxes.

Daniel Burrows: Lessig at the University of Washington

On Friday 2007-11-02, I watched Larry Lessig give a presentation at the University of Washington entitled Is Google (2008) Microsoft (1998)? Since it was Lessig, the talk was articulate and thought-provoking, and he used his slides very well (unlike many presenters who just read bullet points).

The argument he made is that Google is like Microsoft in some ways (and so are other companies like Facebook). In his analysis, the problem with Microsoft was that so many companies made themselves Microsoft-dependent, which both forced other companies to follow suit (due to network effects) and gave Microsoft leverage they could use against everyone in their ecosystem (e.g., Netscape). According to Lessig, Microsoft was not evil to use this leverage, but you have to recognize that Microsoft will do what is best for Microsoft, and this may not be what is best for you. He then suggested that we should be aware of the potential for the same thing to happen; in support of this point, he quoted excerpts from the terms of service from the APIs of Google and Facebook, which contain typical statements like we reserve the right to terminate your use of this service for any reason or for no reason, and asked: What if Microsoft had written this license agreement?

But it seemed to me that this wasn't his main point. He was using this observation as a springboard to talk about issues revolving around competition and public policy. Specifically, he feels that we should work towards a more just model of interaction between companies and users whose work makes the company more valuable (by contributing to a software ecosystem, by posting content on the Web site, etc). But the correct way to do this (he says) is not via competition, after-the-fact litigation, or voluntary codes of conduct: competition may not be around to enforce good behavior (as we've seen with Microsoft), litigation may be too late and ineffective (again, see Microsoft), and voluntary codes of conduct will disappear as soon as they get in the way of the bottom line. The correct approach, he argued, is across-the-board regulation so that all the companies have to play by the same rules.

From there he went on to talk about governmental corruption. He said (quoting Robert Reich's book Supercapitalism) that the reason we consistently look for solutions in the market and in voluntary compliance is that our governmental system is broken and does not effectively regulate corporations in the public interest. But Lessig is optimistic that we can change things (he joked that his publisher was unhappy with this point of view, because his brand has been built on pessimism). In his view, the politicians in Washington, by and large, want to be honest and do good, but they aren't able to within the current political system. For instance, on the few occassions that he managed to get access to lawmakers to discuss copyright issues, it was often the first time they had heard that there was more than one side to the argument. He thinks we need a national political movement that will shame politicians into being less corrupt.

This is all a simplification of what he said, of course; unfortunately, I wasn't able to find a recording of this talk on Lessig's Web site, or I'd point you at primary source material. I don't know if this is because he chose not to post it, or because it just hasn't been made available yet.

My view

In general, I thought that the speech was very interesting and well thought out. But as much as I'd like to buy into his optimism that we can fix our system, I don't think it's well-founded, for two reasons.

First, he argued that competition will resolve some of these problems (that was before and after he said we can't rely on competition, which I found confusing and may indicate that I misunderstood something). His evidence for this seemed to be that when Microsoft was dominating the world, users responded by reducing their dependence on Microsoft products and by switching to alternatives such as Linux. But, in fact, although more people may be using Linux than in the past, virtually everyone is still only using Windows, it's still almost impossible to find a programming job that isn't Windows-only, and Microsoft is still raking in money hand over fist; indeed, they're doing so well that they're planning to expand their workforce by a third. To take just one data point of many: I ride the bus to Seattle and back, and I regularly see other people using laptops as they commute. Virtually all the laptops run Windows. Occasionally I'll see a Mac, and every few months I'll see a guy running Linux on his laptop; I say "a guy" because it's the same guy every single time. So by my estimation, use of Linux on laptops in buses on the 545 route from Redmond to Seattle is way below 1%, with Macintoshes somewhere around 5%.

To broaden my point, I think Lessig has fallen into a trap that highly intelligent people, particularly those in academia, tend to fall into. In academia, you are surrounded by people who value learning and thinking deeply about the world. These are people who will give serious and unbiased consideration to questions like what is the social effect of my acceptance of the Facebook Terms of Service? and If I become dependent on this service, will that possibly affect me in five years if the company decides to act against my interests? The problem with this is that these people are not representative of the population at large. The population at large thinks why is this check-box getting in the way of me sending pictures to my friends? And I have no doubt that any kid who, e.g., refuses to sign up for Facebook as a protest against their TOS will be roundly mocked in their social circles for being a weird antisocial nonconformist. (of course, this may not apply to the small minority of people like myself whose social circles consist of weird antisocial nonconformists)

Second, Lessig's optimism about the political system seemed to be based on his observation that the people in government are, by and large, not venally corrupt: they want to do good, but the system is constructed in a way that makes this impossible. To me, that's a tremendously disheartening statement. If our problem were simply a few, or even many, corrupt politicians, this would be a solvable problem: even nowadays, Americans have some ability to choose who gets elected, and I believe that a sufficiently well-coordinated campaign could replace bad politicians with good ones.

But if the problem is that the system is corrupt even when the individuals are honest, it's a much deeper problem and frankly one that I don't know how to solve. While individuals have some direct control over who gets elected, we have no way to directly change the system that produces the corruption; the levers to do this are in the hands of the politicians elected through that broken system. It's unlikely that the politicians themselves will fix the problem, because they've benefited deeply from it: if the system is left as it is, well over 90% of Congress members will keep
their jobs
in the next election cycle, and any effective change seems likely (by definition) to disrupt this cushy arrangement.

On the other hand, running new candidates for office will not fix the problem. After all, if the problem is that the system is corrupt even when the participants are honest, then putting more honest people into government will have no effect. In order to get elected, these new politicians will have to become just as corrupt as the old ones, because that's how the system is set up. So we might change the faces, but we'll have the same old problems.

I recall two specific concrete proposals that Lessig made to make the system more responsive. First, he suggested shaming politicians who engage in corrupt behavior -- presumably taking large donations from interested parties. I don't see how this will help. Americans generally have a very low regard for the political class as it is; will pointing out particular examples of politicians taking money really make a difference when it comes to votes? And if it doesn't, will it really produce any change in their behavior? Politicians are motivated by votes the same way corporations are motivated by money; unless they stand a chance of losing their job (which is virtually impossible in any event), there's no reason for them to change how they behave.

His second proposal was for a system of contributions where it's impossible for any individual to prove they had donated a particular amount of money to a particular candidate. Even assuming it could be implemented perfectly, I don't think this will really solve the problem, for two reasons. First, it's not generally a secret what moneyed interests want. Politicians who want to attract large donations can just take positions that they know will appeal to donors of that sort. The donors themselves can make this easier on the candidates by, e.g., posting public position statements on issues of the day. Secondly, and this is far more insidious, even if politicians honestly represent their positions, then because success in running for office is so tied to the amount of money the candidate can raise, only candidates who hold opinions favorable to large corporations and wealthy individuals will be able to get elected. In fact, for all I know this is what happens already!

But with all that said, it was a really interesting talk and Lessig tied together some things you might not think would go together. If a video or Flash presentation becomes available, I would recommend watching through it. And hopefully my pessimistic predictions will be wrong; it's certainly happened before.

MJ Ray: Movements 2007-11-04

While bumbling about on a search engine, I found slides from a talk I gave in 2001 and these 2005 consultation submissions to the Department of Culture... about TV and the WSIS Civil Society Internet Governance Caucus Here's some other stuff on other sites I wrote about since the last round-up of this sort:
A Cambridge Co-operator: Sorry!
EASF :: View topic - What happened to Norwich Citywide Co-op?
Bond films and the Roger Moore humor controversy Ultimate James Bond Fan Blog
Does Having Fewer Rules Inspire Hard Work? etbe
The Right Width for Your Blog
The Right Width for Your Blog
Shine OpenStreetMap Cycle Map :: GravityStorm
Social mapping Tom Chance's website
Russ Nelson: Chordite versus CyKey
The prescient TomTom
robmyers - Bender's Big Score
Citing References in Blog Posts etbe
Matt Lee - Advogato Exploring Freedom
Ross Burton
Inside the Box Blog Archive Linux On a Mobile PC
Javascript performance in browsers
Bryan Clark : Web Browser Homepage
BBC SPORT Sport Editors' Blog Behind the Scenes at BBC Sport: Weekend feedback
][ stefano maffulli The end of a phase
A Cambridge Co-operator: Shoefayre / Cambridge City
(Persone) 12 25 Septembro 2007, 5:21
Buxy: DSA needs a leader

Paul van Tilburg: Taking and Giving

From Debian I downloaded, installed and toyed around with Liquidsoap. It took me a few moments to understand the language, but once I did, I got very enthusiastic about it. I always wanted something more than just streaming a set for my friends now and then and this tool allows me to created a quite contrived webradio setup. More about that later… To Debian unstable I finally uploaded Camping, a small Ruby web framework for MCV type applications. It is in NEW now. I’ve been writing (or at least started writing) quite a few apps based on Camping the past few months. Primarily because it is fun, but also because I like its flexibility and strength very much (see also some examples). Once Camping is in Debian, I’d like to put more Camping apps out in the open.

Mario Iseli: Birthday v2.0

Hello World :) ok, second night of my birhday is over, went again to the pub with some of my very important people. The day today was quite different - not only joy, fun, and … Today also other facts were playing an important role - Remember people who can’t be here tonight (dead), lost love and new targets. Nevertheless, I’m quite happy and enjoy the last hours of this night. Regards, Mario (with different emotions)

3 November 2007

Andreas Schuldei: Dear Lazyweb: How to make less coding errors

I just read Daniel J. Bernstein's paper on how to write secure software. It basically boils down to "Don't make programming errors!". This reminded me of an article which I read roughly a decade ago in c't magazine about a technique to reduce the numbers of errors when coding. If i recall correctly it worked like this: Write code, then debug it and pay attention what kind of errors you made and in what part of the process you made them. Then figure out ways to avoid those errors in similar situations in the future.

Despite spending some quality time with google I could not find a trace of this technique, let alone a name. Can someone please help me?

David Watson: Open Source social networking

There seems to have been a lot of talk recently about using Open Source software for social networking, which has been something that has been at the back of my mind for quite a while now. If you could take a web site and using the presence information and IM features from jabber, you already have the beginnings of a social networking or community site. The main advantage I can see is that anyone could start their own social networking site, rather than joining one of the larger existing (closed source) sites or basing a community around a web forum (which I tend to avoid if at all possible). Now if I can just properly gather my thoughts on this I would start some coding.

David Watson: Open Source social networking

There seems to have been a lot of talk recently about using Open Source software for social networking, which has been something that has been at the back of my mind for quite a while now. If you could take a web site and using the presence information and IM features from jabber, you already have the beginnings of a social networking or community site. The main advantage I can see is that anyone could start their own social networking site, rather than joining one of the larger existing (closed source) sites or basing a community around a web forum (which I tend to avoid if at all possible). Now if I can just properly gather my thoughts on this I would start some coding.

Yves-Alexis Perez: Xfce freezing on Debian testing.

If you're running Debian lenny (testing) and since the last upgrade it seems that Xfce freezes randomly, you're not crazy, it's a real bug (#449050 and #449134 already reported). xfwm4 freezes in certain condition with gtk 2.12 wich has entered testing yesterday. xfwm4 4.4.1-3 in unstable fixes the problem, and it'll reach testing really soon now (it just built on arm and should transition in the next days). In the meanwhile you should be able to take the unstable package and install it on testing without problem. Sorry for the mess, from the pkg-xfce team.

Raphaël Hertzog: Unexpected move on the DSA front

One should never loose hope apparently. After my previous posts on the topic, Sam put some more pressure and expressed strongly his disappointment in the lack of progress on the DSA front and warned that he might have to look for more radical solution. Phil Hands (who was really quiet in the discussions) decided that the situation had lasted long enough already and proposed to add Peter Palfrader (weasel@debian.org) to the team if nobody expressed any opposition in 24 hours. And this morning, Phil added weasel to the “adm” group… which make of Peter a full DSA member! :-) I really didn’t expect this outcome after so many months of negociations and discussions. But I’m really relieved to see some new blood in the DSA team. I wish him good luck and I’ll hope he will be able to foster cooperation with non-DSA people like I tried since the beginning of the year. Thank you Phil! Partagez cet article / Share This

Sam Hocevar: Bits from the DPL: DSA and a few other things

I have been rather quiet during the last few months. Not really because I wasn t doing anything, but because most of what I have been doing was done by private e-mail. Apparently people are expecting the DPL to disappear around the middle of their term, because I did not get many complaints. But yes, I know that sucked. And well, I now have a reason to regain motivation. \o/ DSA++ \o/ Bananas 1Bananas 2Bananas 3 I am very, very pleased to let you know that this morning Phil Hands (fil) added Peter Palfrader (weasel) to the adm group. Which means that the DSA team now has a new member! The first since, wow, quite some time. I am grateful to everyone who made this possible, for bearing with my insistance, for making concessions, for being patient, and I hope this is only the first step to bigger and better teams in Debian. Of course the path is still long but I must admit this is truly refreshing. I wish great success to Peter for the thankless job that awaits him. Nexenta After meeting Michael Man and several Sun people at Debconf and seeing Michael s great talk I got really convinced that the technology present in OpenSolaris could benefit Debian in many ways. And the shortest path to there seemed to be Nexenta. I am currently discussing the possibility of having a Nexenta machine accessible to Debian developers to port and test their packages. I also suggested the Nexenta people to submit patches directly to Debian and try to join friendly packaging teams. Please be nice to them! Conferences Last month I attended Encuentro Linux 2007 in Arica, Chile where I gave a talk about the history and organisation of Debian and how to help and become a member of the project. Due to various issues (such as my passport being stolen when I was 2000 km away from the conference) I did not have the time to give my other planned talk about attracting developers who do not speak English to Debian and FLOSS projects. Fortunately I was able to discuss it with members of the local communities. My goal is to understand why such a large Spanish-speaking area has so few Debian developers, and what we can do about that. One of my observations was that two very important documents (the Debian Policy and the Debian Developer s Reference) were not translated into Spanish, while for instance there is a French translation of the latter. Any volunteers?

Joerg Jaspert: Locating old Debian source packages

Additionally to what Romain wrote: If one is a DD - one might want to look at merkel.debian.org:/org/ftp.debian.org/morgue/* for old source package stuff.

Romain Francoise: Locating old Debian source packages

So you want to import your pet package into the new and shiny VCS of the day, but you don't have the complete source history at hand, and some of the revisions are too old to be on snapshot.debian.net or were never part of a Debian release and aren't on archive.debian.org?

Here's an easy way out:
  1. For each missing source package, look into the debian-devel-changes archive for the MD5 sum of the corresponding .diff.gz file, it's present in the mail sent by katie.
  2. Google this MD5 sum. If your source package is sitting somewhere in the ether, the dsc file contains the sum and Google probably indexes it.
  3. Fetch your source package, check the signature on the dsc and the integrity of the .diff.gz. If everything looks good, go to step 1.
For the record, I found some of mine on old-releases.ubuntu.com, apt.freespire.org and these snapshots.

Martin Zobel-Helas: Removing spam from Debian s mailinglist archive

Listmaster Thomas Viehmann wrote (IMHO) a very good summary for a policy on how to proceed with spam in the public archives of the Debian mailing lists. Some of them might need further discussions. Please help the listmasters and write your own ideas and opinions about his proposal. Also many thanks to Frans Pop, who first drafted some of them listmaster-internally quite a while ago.

MJ Ray: Current Issues / Cycling News

I've been asked by a local news mag to write an item about cycling around here.  What do you think I should write about?

I'm inclined to write about safe Winter winter and safe driving around Winter cyclists, but maybe that's dwelling too much on the negatives, is it?

Thanks for any help.

Cord Beermann: mutt: autoviewing text/html

it sometimes funny, i'm working with mutt since about 10years, (the 5years before i was using elm) and just found out how i can view pure text/html-Mails without fiddeling with piping and things.

set implicit_autoview

in .muttrc does the trick.

but now mutt also prefers the text/html-part of multipart/alternative-mails, this is going to far for me. i want the text/plain-part if available. mutt has also a solution here:

alternative_order text/plain text/html

and done. no more piping to html2text. One day i'll read through the whole manual again...

Biella Coleman: Nadia Abu El-Haj Tenure

It is nice to read the New York Times and get some good news. Nadia Abu El-Haj was granted tenure after a bitter public battle opposing her appointment. As someone who has taken graduate courses with her in Chicago and who was advised by her, I know Columbia and Barnard made the right choice.

Biella Coleman: On Bats, The Suckage of American Health Insurance and Paperwork Warfare

Two nights ago I was having dinner with a colleague who recounted a truly horrible experience he had with the modern-day American health care “system.” While in Montana over the summer, he got bit by a bat and well, as a result, he and his entire family had to get rabies shots. These shots are hard to get and priceeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeey. The final bill was $ 20,000 and his NYU based health insurance, United Health Care is claiming they are not responsible!### Like getting bit by a bat and the possibility of rabies are not bad enough. Isn’t the point of health insurance to take care of the unexpected?? Someone also pointed me to The Daily Kos’ wrangle with BCBS of California and well, they picked the wrong guy to mess with given there are so many many many many eyeballs tuned to his blog, everyday (just check out the number of comments). I wonder if the public relations director will contact him as they did with me after I blogged about my trials and tribulations. I certainly don’t have the audience and readers he does, so I am always surprised they ever contacted me in the first place. The Daily Kos also provided a link for a site that I was thinking of creating if my problems with BCBS were not solved (glad to see someone else has) called Sick of Blue Cross. I personally like the name I came up with a little better Blue Cross No Shield but the important thing is that a site like that exists and it is very good site, design and content wise. There should be a site created for every health insurance company and they should federate and pool resources to gain more visiblity. While I am not hopeful that the health insurance industry will change within, I think mounting and steady consumer pressure can do a lot to force the industry to change their awful ways. And while I think the bad publicity is a key part to putting pressure on the health insurance to change, I actually think that the power of the consumers also can come from elsewhere, and this elsewhere is overwhelming the administrative channels within and outside of the health insurance. The gist is if they send us a lot of (useless) paperwork, send them A LOT of paperwork back. On the Daily Kos, a lot of people noted that things got moving when they complained to the Department of Banking and Insurance. While my own complaint to that department did not produce any immediate fruit, it did get the ball moving for the appeal process, which eventually panned out for me. That is, I learned a lot and started to get decent customer service. Doors opened. Now, it took me weeks to find out that I could complain to the Department of Banking and Insurance and I am sure many find themselves in that situation of walking in a no man’s land of confusion and frustration. If more and more people know that you can file a complaint to these Departments (and why are doctor’s offices not relaying this information??!!), they and the health insurance companies will get inundated with that which they love to inflict on us, paperwork. This may slow things down for you but at a certain point, state governments will get the message that something is deeply wrong. So, people MUST use these channels and overwhelm these agencies with complaints, faxes, emails as this is a powerful and very material message that something is deeply wrong and broken and must be fixed. Also, send faxes and letters to various departments in your health insurance company (appeals, customer service, medical director’s office, public relations office…) get people’s email’s and send them emails. Inundate them with a barrage of administrative paperwork. If they are not being helpful, send a fax or two a day concerning your case until you get clear answers. While individual faxes won’t make much of a difference, imagine if there are 300 a day coming in or 3000…. This can work with the numbers are there and I have a feeling that the numbers Are There. So spread the word for housebreaking your health insurance and push the paperwork back on them.

Mario Iseli: Mario.age++;

So, I just came back home (quite drunk), had a very nice evening with my girlfriend and then went to the pub where I got quite a lot of free beer after 00:00, I’m finally 18 now! That does mean I’m no more underage! :D Regards, Mario

Next.

Previous.