Biella Coleman: Rethinking Blogs: The importance of fewer posts and preaching to the choir
It is hard to believe that I have been blogging for over five years. And what is clear is that being an assistant professor is not all that conducive for blogging and this is materially evident in my sparse posting pattern over the last few months. It has been particularly bad in the last month thanks to a week long international trip, back-to-back sickness over Thanksgiving week, and finally going to Washington D.C. for the AAAs.
But this retreat from blogging as well as teaching on so-called Web 2.0 software, like blogs, has made me rethink the value and limits of the craft of blogging and so I am going to take some time (that I feel like I don t really have, but oh-well..) to write them down as I am preparing a short piece for on the politics of Web 2.0 and I hope I can transfer some of these ideas there.
So as I have already mentioned, I am an now infrequent blogger. Prior to the era of RSS, this could have meant the death of my blog because if people went to visit my page and there was no new post and then this happened a few more times, they would just stop visiting.
The magic of RSS is that it brings the blog post to you and this alters the landscape of possibilities within the context of what has been nothing short of a seismic explosion of blogs. What I am finding and this will be no surprise to anyone is that it is just too difficult to keep up too many of a certain class of blogger the prolific poster who posts medium to long posts and worse, nearly everyday! To make a point about the effects of this, allow me to tell a story: Two blogs I really like are Joe Reagle’s blog on Open Communities as well as Tenured Radical. Both provide captivating posts but I recently unsubscribed to Radical Tenure and not Joe Reagle s. Why? My decision was purely pragmatic. Because she posts way too much, I just can t keep up. If I stop reading her blog for 2 weeks, and then pay a visit via bloglines, I am faced with a blogolanche and I am trying to avoid, at all costs, overwhelming situations. On the other hand, if I stop reading Joe s blog for 2 weeks, there may be one or two posts so I feel like I can spare the time to continue reading. Ironically, I will now visit Tenured Radical every month, much as I did prior to the RSS era, just to take a quick scan and see if there is anything I must read.
There is another class of blogs, such as Sivacracy, that update their site frequently but the posts are tidy and short and so I can usually keep up and they provide important news for my projects. But the type of blog that provides longer ruminations has proliferated (and I really like reading those) but I suspect that as the blogosphere has expanded, less people can commit to those types of blogs. In other words, today, you may hang on to more readers, if you only blog 1 to 2 times a week instead of 3-5 weekly posts that are medium to long in length.
Now I may be completely OFF the mark with this by generalizing my own experience so I would be interested in hearing people s experiences or better, if anyone could point me to someone who studies these types of pattern, I would really appreciate it.
On a related note, last week I taught a now famous piece by Cass Sunstein on political balkanization on the Internet that is in part secured by blogging. His core argument, which I think stands to some degree, is that the blogosphere is less an arena where people with different inclinations and views meet to debate, and thus change their views, but is an arena where your pre-existing ideas are reinforced because you are simply reading and debating with people who hold your worldview.
As I mentioned, I think this is true in so far as you don t see people on the left and right engaging in some debate that substantially transforms their ideas. But the argument is faulty or missing something crucial about the nature of politics, in so far as that the so called left or right or so called liberal and conservative positions are truly not unitary so that if different types of liberals/lefties are engaging with each other to change positions and ideas within that group, well then, the critical function of blogging is in fact well and alive. To state using an example, there are plenty of liberals who, in my opinion, could use a little radicalization and perhaps this is happening in the blogosphere because people come across a spectrum of ideas and positions from within their political pole.
Finally and this point really is not mine but I am poaching it from Jeff Juris who made it last weekend at the AAA meeting during his presentation on activist videos. One of his findings was that activists were the only ones watching video s documenting protests when hosted on radical political sites like Indymedia. When they were placed on Youtube, the audience expanded considerably: conservatives were also watching them, but they effect was not to make their more sympathetic toward the left and their political points, but simply to reinforce their position, which is evident in the archived comments expressing their great distaste of the left. This is a perfect example of the Balkanization that Sunstein talks about but with an important reversal: it comes from confronting difference not avoiding it!
But Jeff made the excellent point that there is a critical function in preaching to the choir: it ensures that the choir will not stop singing! That is, your political passions are not simply ensured, they must be renewed and given the massive amounts of apathy peppering our population, renewal by confronting what you believe in, is vital.
So my advice is keep producing posts, keep reading even if it tends to be stuff you already believe in BUT please, post less. Less, I think, is really becoming the new more….
I'm looking for a scanner, with the following requirements:
Introducing biometric authentication in our systems is a very good idea. It is the key to
Congratulations to Yves-Alexis Perez (Corsac), Nicolas Fran ois (Nekral) and Sune Vuorela (Pusling) too \o/
Finally, some accounts (~30 ?) were created and i’m in.
Thanks to all people involved in Debian and Kubuntu. In particular (no order) my co-maintainers, sponsors, helpers and application manager:
Katherine and I celebrated our first wedding anniversary over the
weekend. We still don't think marriage has changed us or our
relationship that much; having lived together for many years beforehand
was really a much bigger step.
A number of fairly major other events have happened to me in the past
year, which I don't think either of us could have predicated.
)
I'm pleased my home state of Queensland (which bills itself as the Smart
State) has finally decided to
Someone commented rightfully that I should explain how I got debian installed on the DG33TL.
* I was too tired to write this yesterday. Yes, it was very hectic day (but great fun!). Things started very well. Sam and Bubulle did great presentations (specially,
My @debian.org account’s now been created. Thanks santiago, anibal and kapil for your sponsorships during all this time. I learned quite a lot from you all. Thanks are also due my AM, myon and my advocate, gwolf.
I spend quite a long time to fully configure my new Thinkpad X60s laptop. This will be my work computer and i wish to use Debian Etch on it. Since it is for my job, i want to use a stable debian release. The aim of this laptop is to always have something that works -- to keep focus on my job.
The configuration was tricky because there is a lot of people reporting that everything works with this laptop, but not a lot of people describing problems they encounter. Here is a list:
Sound:
The people who think the default wiki.d.o theme is nice, should think again. Thanks to an anonymous reader I was pointed to
Like most things, the scale of decisions that have to be made by a person
or organisation fall across a wide spectrum. At one end, you've got the
fine-detail work: lines of code, individual config settings, IP addresses,
that sort of thing. This is crucial work, because it's this detail that
ultimately produces saleable results. Travelling all the way to the other
end, there's the "big picture" decisions: the "visionary" stuff. What
market segment will we target? What will we do (in large-scale terms)
to get there?
I am convinced that individuals naturally gravitate towards one end of this
spectrum or the other, depending on their psychology. While people usually
can work at all scales, they have a "most comfortable" point where they
work the most naturally. The further away from this point they are pushed,
the less comfortable and effective they are.
No level of thinking is better or worse than the other; they're just
different. While "large scale thinker" and "small scale thinker"
could be taken as being insulting, I certainly don't mean it that way.
I should point out that "Strategy" isn't (just) about setting goals. A
strategist isn't someone who comes out with grand pronouncements like "By
the end of next year this company should be providing telecommunications
services to 20% of the Fortune 500" without knowing how to get there.
That's not a strategist, that's a poor-quality management consultant.
People whose only skill is making vague pronouncements should just be taken
out and shot. They're not doing anything useful for anyone.
A strategist is someone who is good at planning the goal of "20%
of the Fortune 500". They're thinking about the big picture issues,
without getting bogged down in the minutiae. A tactician, given the job of
planning something at the macro scale, will chase some good idea down an
intricately detailed rabbit hole, and miss the other dozen or so large
issues that need to be considered. The strategist's planning needs to stop
at a certain level and let other people take on the detail work.
Conversely, a good tactician can focus on the individual details
without getting distracted by the big picture. A strategist put into a
tactical role will miss all the important minutiae because they're working
out how their little part fits into the big picture, instead of working out
how to make their little part work, in and of itself.
It's important, for individual happiness, to try and work out what level
you're most comfortable thinking at, and then trying to find a job that
puts you there. It's almost as important to make sure that the people who
are working at the more and less detail levels around you are equally
comfortable.
Take, for example, the micromanager. We've all either been there ourselves
or have heard multiple stories on the subject. I think the micromanager is
nothing more than a person who wants to work at a smaller scale than they're
being forced to by their organisational rank. Since they can't do
the detail work any more, their only outlet is working vicariously through
their subordinates. Voila! Instant micromanagement.
An even more painful case of micromanagement would be when the subordinate
wants to think at a larger scale than the superior. In that case, the
subordinate will naturally be thinking large scale, and will miss the
details. To the small scale thinking superior, that is incompetence, and
will naturally be dealt with by more micromanagement. In reality, both
parties are incompetent at their jobs, and they should really swap roles,
so that everyone is in their element.
It would be nice if companies stopped thinking hierarchically in this way
-- that a more "senior" person has to think at larger levels. Just because
you've been somewhere longer (or have been working in an industry longer, or
got higher marks, or whatever), it doesn't mean that you're more of a
strategist. This is probably the Peter Principle restated: people get
promoted to a level where they just can't comfortably think at the necessary
scale any more. If instead people were put into a planning hierarchy based
on their natural scale of thinking, we'd all be a lot better off. There'd
be a lot less power games, though, which makes me think it's not going to
happen any time soon.
A business, at whatever size it might be, needs an appropriate mix of
strategists and tacticians. A really small business (1-10 people) can get
away without needing large scale thinkers, in the same way that a really
small boat can get away without needing a rudder or pilot. If a really
small boat gets itself into trouble, everyone on board can grab an oar or
bucket and help get the boat out it's predicament -- it's small and nimble
enough to be able to do that.
As the company expands, though, it's important to make sure you've got some
strategists around. If you don't have anyone to keep an eye out for
problems and plan around them, your small-to-medium sized boat is likely to
have a hole punched in it by a submerged rock. Even if somebody on board
happens to notice the rock before you actually hit it, once you get to a
certain size you can't physically stop or turn the boat in time.
If you don't understand the growth issues in the company, you might not
even realise that you're no longer the nimble and low-inertia dinghy until
you're up to your knees in sea water.
Although an obvious solution to this problem might be to say that all
businesses should be small and nimble ones, it's as impractical as saying
that all boats should be dinghies. A fleet of dinghies isn't going to be
able to support the worldwide sea freight market, and a fleet of small
companies doesn't have the necessary resources on hand to take on the big
projects that are so often needed. Also, a dinghy is at risk of being
swamped by one freak wave, while a larger ship can weather significant
storms without going under.
Regardless of the size of the business, there always needs to be a good
supply of tacticians. A boat (of whatever size) full of people who are all
looking out for rocks isn't going to go anywhere, because nobody's making
the thing move. Similarly, a company full of strategists isn't
going to be doing any of the day-to-day work that actually earns money, and
no money means no company.
The single most important thing, though, is be self-aware enough to know
what sort of person you are, and try to find something that lets you work at
the level you're most comfortable at. Otherwise you're just setting
yourself up for unhappiness.
I've set up a quick 







