Search Results: "lucas"

25 December 2010

Lucas Nussbaum: Merry christmas!

Seen on The Ruby Reflector (a blog aggregator for the Ruby community):
Under no circumstance should you install Ruby, Rubygems or any Ruby-related packages from apt-get. This system is out-dated and leads to major headaches. Avoid it for Ruby-related packages. We do Ruby, we know what s best. Trust us.
(source) It s always nice to see people appreciate your work. :-)

6 December 2010

Raphaël Hertzog: State of the Debian-Ubuntu relationship

Debian welcoming contributions from derivativesThe relationship between Debian and Ubuntu has been the subject of many vigorous debates over the years, ever since Ubuntu s launch in 2004. Six years later, the situation has improved and both projects are communicating better. The Natty Narwhal Ubuntu Developer Summit (UDS) featured like all UDS for more than 2 years a Debian Health Check session where current cooperation issues and projects are discussed. A few days after that session, Lucas Nussbaum gave a talk during the mini-Debconf Paris detailing the relationship between both projects, both at the technical and social level. He also shared some concerns for Debian s future and gave his point of view on how Debian should address them. Both events give valuable insights on the current state of the relationship. Lucas Nussbaum s Debian-Ubuntu talk Lucas started by introducing himself. He s an Ubuntu developer since 2006 and a Debian developer since 2007. He has worked to improve the collaboration between both projects, notably by extending the Debian infrastructure to show Ubuntu-related information. He attended conferences for both projects (Debconf, UDS) and has friends in both communities. For all of these reasons, he believes himself to be qualified to speak on this topic. Collaboration at the technical level He then quickly explained the task of a distribution: taking upstream software, integrating it in standardized ways, doing quality assurance on the whole, delivering the result to users, and assuring some support afterward. He pointed out that in the case of Ubuntu, the distribution has one special upstream: Debian. Indeed Ubuntu gets most of its software from Debian (89%), and only 7% are new packages coming from other upstream projects (the remaining 4% are unknown, they are newer upstream releases of software available in Debian but he was not able to find out whether the Debian packaging had been reused or not). From all the packages imported from Debian, 17% have Ubuntu-specific changes. The reasons for those changes are varied: bugfixes, integration with Launchpad/Ubuntu One/etc., or toolchain changes. The above figures are based on Ubuntu Lucid (10.04) while excluding many Ubuntu-specific packages (language-pack-*, language-support-*, kde-l10n-*, *ubuntu*, *launchpad*). The different agendas and the differences in philosophy (Debian often seeking perfect solutions to problems; Ubuntu accepting temporary suboptimal workarounds) also explain why so many packages are modified on the Ubuntu side. It s simply not possible to always do the work in Debian first. But keeping changes in Ubuntu requires a lot of work since they merge with Debian unstable every 6 months. That s why they have a strong incentive to push changes to upstream and/or to Debian. There are 3 channels that Ubuntu uses to push changes to Debian: they file bug reports (between 250 to 400 during each Ubuntu release cycle), they interact directly with Debian maintainers (often the case when there s a maintenance team), or they do nothing and hope that the Debian maintainer will pick up the patch directly from the Debian Package Tracking System (it relays information provided by patches.ubuntu.com). Lucas pointed out that those changes are not the only thing that Debian should take back. Ubuntu has a huge user base resulting in lots of bug reports sitting in Launchpad, often without anyone taking care of them. Debian maintainers who already have enough bugs on their packages are obviously not interested in even more bugs, but those who are maintaining niche packages, with few reports, might be interested by the user feedback available in Launchpad. Even if some of the reports are Ubuntu-specific, many of them are advance warnings of problems that will affect Debian later on, when the toolchain catches up with Ubuntu s aggressive updates. To make this easier for Debian maintainers, Lucas improved the Debian Package Tracking System so that they can easily get Ubuntu bug reports for their packages even without interacting with Launchpad. Human feelings on both sides Lucas witnessed a big evolution in the perception of Ubuntu on the Debian side. The initial climate was rather negative: there were feelings of its work being stolen, claims of giving back that did not match the observations of the Debian maintainers, and problems with specific Canonical employees that reflected badly on Ubuntu as a whole. These days most Debian developers find something positive in Ubuntu: it brings a lot of new users to Linux, it provides something that works for their friends and family, it brings new developers to Debian, and it serves as a technological playground for Debian. On the Ubuntu side, the culture has changed as well. Debian is no longer so scary for Ubuntu contributors and contributing to Debian is The Right Thing to do. More and more Ubuntu developers are getting involved in Debian as well. But at the package level there s not always much to contribute, as many bugfixes are only temporary workarounds. And while Ubuntu s community follows this philosophy, Canonical is a for-profit company that contributes back mainly when it has compelling reasons to do so. Consequences for Debian In Lucas s eyes, the success of Ubuntu creates new problems. For many new users Linux is a synonym for Ubuntu, and since much innovation happens in Ubuntu first, Debian is overshadowed by its most popular derivative. He goes as far as saying that because of that Debian becomes less relevant . He went on to say that Debian needs to be relevant because the project defends important values that Ubuntu does not. And it needs to stay as an independent partner that filters what comes out of Ubuntu, ensuring that quality prevails in the long term. Fixing this problem is difficult, and the answer should not be to undermine Ubuntu. On the contrary, more cooperation is needed. If Debian developers are involved sooner in Ubuntu s projects, Debian will automatically get more credit. And if Ubuntu does more work in Debian, their work can be showcased sooner in the Debian context as well. The other solution that Lucas proposed is that Debian needs to communicate on why it s better than Ubuntu. Debian might not be better for everybody but there are many reasons why one could prefer Debian over Ubuntu. He listed some of them: Debian has better values since it s a volunteer-based project where decisions are made publicly and it has advocated the free software philosophy since 1993. On the other hand, Ubuntu is under control of Canonical where some decisions are imposed, it advocates some proprietary web services (Ubuntu One), the installer recommends adding proprietary software, and copyright assignments are required to contribute to Canonical projects. Debian is also better in terms of quality because every package has a maintainer who is often an expert in the field of the package. As a derivative, Ubuntu does not have the resources to do the same and instead most packages are maintained on a best effort basis by a limited set of developers who can t know everything about all packages. In conclusion, Lucas explained that Debian can neither ignore Ubuntu nor fight it. Instead it should consider Ubuntu as a chance and should leverage it to get back in the center of the FLOSS ecosystem . The Debian health check UDS session While this session has existed for some time, it s only the second time that a Debian Project Leader was present at UDS to discuss collaboration issues. During UDS-M (the previous summit), this increased involvement from Debian was a nice surprise to many. Stefano Zacchiroli the Debian leader collected and shared the feedback of Debian developers and the session ended up being very productive. Six months later is a good time to look back and verify if decisions made during UDS-M (see blueprint) have been followed through. Progress has been made On the Debian side, Stefano set up a Derivatives Front Desk so that derivative distributions (not just Ubuntu) have a clear point of contact when they are trying to cooperate but don t know where to start. It s also a good place to share experiences among the various derivatives. In parallel, a #debian-ubuntu channel has been started on OFTC (the IRC network used by Debian). With more than 50 regulars coming from both distributions, it s a good place for quick queries when you need advice on how to interact with the distribution that you re not familiar with. Ubuntu has updated its documentation to prominently feature how to cooperate with Debian. For example, the sponsorship process documentation explains how to forward patches both to the upstream developers and to Debian. It also recommends ensuring that the patch is not Ubuntu-specific and gives some explanation on how to do it (which includes checking against a list of common packaging changes made by Ubuntu). The Debian Derivative Front Desk is mentioned as a fallback when the Debian maintainer is unresponsive. While organizing Ubuntu Developer Week, Ubuntu now reaches out to Debian developers and tries to have sessions on working with Debian . Launchpad has also been extended to provide a list of bugs with attached patches and that information has been integrated in the Debian Package Tracking system by Lucas Nussbaum. Still some work to do Some of the work items have not been completed yet: many Debian maintainers would like a simpler way to issue a sync request (a process used to inject a package from Debian into Ubuntu). There s a requestsync command line tool provided by the ubuntu-dev-tools package (which is available in Debian) but it s not yet usable because Launchpad doesn t know the GPG keys of Debian maintainers. Another issue concerns packages which are first introduced in Ubuntu. Most of them have no reason to be Ubuntu-specific and should also end up in Debian. It has thus been suggested that people packaging new software for Ubuntu also upload them to Debian. They could however immediately file a request for adoption (RFA) to find another Debian maintainer if they don t plan to maintain it in the long term. If Ubuntu doesn t make this effort, it can take a long time until someone decides to reintegrate the Ubuntu package into Debian just because nobody knows about it. This represents an important shift in the Ubuntu process and it s not certain that it s going to work out. As with any important policy change, it can take several years until people are used to it. Both issues have been rescheduled for this release cycle, so they re still on the agenda. This time the UDS session was probably less interesting than the previous one. Stefano explained once more what Debian considers good collaboration practices: teams with members from both distributions, and forwarding of bugs if they have been well triaged and are known to apply to Debian. He also invited Ubuntu to discuss big changes with Debian before implementing them. An interesting suggestion that came up was that some Ubuntu developers could participate in Debcamp (one week hack-together before Debconf) to work with some Debian developers, go through Ubuntu patches, and merge the interesting bits. This would nicely complement Ubuntu s increased presence at Debconf: for the first time, community management team member Jorge Castro was at DebConf 10 giving a talk on collaboration between Debian and Ubuntu. There was also some brainstorming on how to identify packages where the collaboration is failing. A growing number of Ubuntu revisions (identified for example by a version like 1.0-1ubuntu62) could indicate that no synchronization was made with Debian, but it would also identify packages which are badly maintained on the Debian side. If Ubuntu consistently has a newer upstream version compared to Debian, it can also indicate a problem: maybe the person maintaining the package for Ubuntu would be better off doing the same work in Debian directly since the maintainer is lagging or not doing their work. Unfortunately this doesn t hold true for all packages since many Gnome packages are newer in Ubuntu but are actively maintained on both sides. Few of those discussions led to concrete decisions. It seems most proponents are reasonably satisfied with the current situation. Of course, one can always do better and Jono Bacon is going to ensure that all Canonical teams working on Ubuntu are aware of how to properly cooperate with Debian. The goal is to avoid heavy package modifications without coordination. Conclusion The Debian-Ubuntu relationships used to be a hot topic, but that s no longer the case thanks to regular efforts made on both sides. Conflicts between individuals still happen, but there are multiple places where they can be reported and discussed (#debian-ubuntu channel, Derivatives Front Desk at derivatives@debian.org on the Debian side or debian@ubuntu.com on the Ubuntu side). Documentation and infrastructure are in place to make it easier for volunteers to do the right thing. Despite all those process improvements, the best results still come out when people build personal relationships by discussing what they are doing. It often leads to tight cooperation, up to commit rights to the source repositories. Regular contacts help build a real sense of cooperation that no automated process can ever hope to achieve.
This article was first published in Linux Weekly News. You can get my monthly summary of the Debian/Ubuntu news, all you have to do is to click here to subscribe to my free newsletter.

5 comments Liked this article? Click here. My blog is Flattr-enabled.

25 November 2010

Stefano Zacchiroli: h-index spoofing

Next time you are asked your h-index ... Next time you are asked your h-index, I suggest replying by pointing to related work by Ike Antkare [1].
[1] Ike Antkare. Ike Antkare one of the great stars in the scientific firmament.
April, 2010.
http://membres-lig.imag.fr/labbe/Publi/IkeAntkareSub.pdf,
retrieved November 25th, 2010.
Although some people still don't get it, the bottom line is always the same: you can't rely on a fully automatic method to evaluate intelligent entities which are aware of the evaluation method, as they are very likely to adapt to it. This is even more so when the automatic method relies on a data source which is not under the control of the evaluator(s). Thanks to Lucas for sharing the bibliography entry.

22 November 2010

Raphaël Hertzog: How Ubuntu builds up on Debian

I have been asked how Ubuntu relates to Debian, and how packages flow from one to the other. So here s my attempt at clarifying the whole picture.

Where do the packages come from? Most packages are created by Debian contributors and they are uploaded in Debian unstable (or Debian experimental). New packages are reviewed by the Debian ftpmasters before being accepted in the official archive. The packages are held in the NEW queue until the review is over, and the time spent there varies between a few hours and a few months (usually they are processed within one week or two). Ubuntu imports all the official Debian packages, but they also add some packages of their own. About 7% of the Ubuntu packages are third-party software that have been packaged for Ubuntu but not for Debian. What are the changes made by Ubuntu? From all the source packages coming from Debian, 17% have additional changes made by Ubuntu. Many of them are part of the main repository, which is actively maintained by Canonical and Ubuntu core developers. The universe repository is usually closer to the official Debian packages. Many of the changes made by Ubuntu are the results of the decisions taken during the Ubuntu Developer Summit in order to reach specific goals: provide a better user interface, offer faster boot times, become a better platform for third-party software developers, offer a good integration with their online services (Launchpad, Ubuntu One), etc. Other changes are simply the result of fixing bugs reported by Ubuntu users. Note that even non-modified source packages will result in different binary packages for Ubuntu. That s because Ubuntu has made changes to the build environment. They only support Intel-based computers with a 686-class (or newer) CPU, they enable some compiler options that Debian doesn t, etc. And all binary packages are modified by a program called pkgbinarymangler. Ubuntu s release cycle and the relation with Debian Ubuntu releases every 6 months (that s what time based releases is about). Debian has a very different schedule. How does Ubuntu manage to reuse Debian s work? Ubuntu imports packages from Debian unstable (even experimental sometimes) to get the newest packages. If the Ubuntu package already has Ubuntu-specific changes, they merge their changes in the updated Debian package. Otherwise the Debian package is simply grabbed and rebuilt in Ubuntu. This works well because Debian unstable is much more usable than the name suggests. And this process only goes on during the first 2 months of the cycle (until the Debian Import Freeze), so there s plenty of time afterward to fix the biggest problems. In the third and fourth month, it s still possible to pick updated packages from Debian but it must be requested by a developer, it won t be done automatically. At the end of the fourth month, the feature freeze is put in place. The 2 months left are dedicated to bug fixing and polishing the distribution. There are various sub-freezes that happen in this period, you can check the Natty release schedule as an example. Picking updated packages from Debian is now the exception, it will only be allowed if the update on the Debian side is a bug-fix only release. Credits: some figures taken from a talk of Lucas Nussbaum, they were collected based on the packages available in the Lucid Lynx release of Ubuntu. Click here to subscribe to my newsletter and get my monthly update on what s going on in Debian and Ubuntu.

15 comments Liked this article? Click here. My blog is Flattr-enabled.

16 November 2010

Lucas Nussbaum: Feedback on Gandi hosting?

For the last few years, I ve been a mostly happy customer of Sivit (now bought by Nerim). But recently, technical problems have become more frequent, and today, for the first time, a crash made me lose some data which was rather painful to restore from backups. Also, they are still stuck on with an ancient 2.6.16 kernel. So, I m looking into alternatives, and a promising one is Gandi hosting, based on virtual machines like Sivit. Thanks!

3 November 2010

Julien Viard de Galbert: Working on X isn t that hard !

First, Hello Planet Debian ! Some words about me I m a new member of the X Strike Force, the debian team responsible for packaging Xorg. I basically stepped in with the openchrome driver.
I also have wider interest in free software or open source in general, but you can have a look at the rest of my blog, so I won t bother you with too much details. More about X Talking with various attendant at MiniDebConf Paris, I got the impression that people think working on Xorg is hard. I must say: It s not ! First debian work is mostly packaging, and the developers of the applications we package (debian call them upstream) are pretty responsive, so you won t be on your own.
Most of the work is preparing the packages for their new release, place them in experimental first, and ask for testers.
Then people test and the real work start: we receive bug reports.
Sometime seeing the report, it s easy to point the user to test some other version, do some change, remove some old libraries in /usr/local/lib.
Sometime we need to ask for more information. I said we, but for now unless it s about openchrome, I can t help much, but I follow the bugs on the X mailing list and learn from others response, I think I ll be able to help soon. An other way to help: TXBW I m sure you ve read about RCBW, kudos to every one posting some and to every BSP attendant.
But if you thought X was hard, you certainly find the remaining RC bugs too hard (Or if not, you might want some distraction with an easier task). So I have a proposition for you: Triage X Bugs of the Week (TXBW) As Lucas told on his blog I ve proposed him a patch to help triaging X bugs using UDD. And he accepted it, Thanks ! So here is the link I m using: XSF unstable bugs sorted by date.
But remember the udd database is not live data, if you close a bug, it won t disappear immediately.
Also please read the X Strike Force Bug Closing Procedure before starting. To conclude my TXBW data (well TXB of the Day so to speak) I hope this can be a success like the RCBW initiative is.
Currently there are hundreds of X bugs, more that a half are at least one year old so they deserve to be triaged ! The X Strike Force (still) needs you !

Lucas Nussbaum: Triaging X Strike Force bugs with UDD Bugs Search

Thanks to the work of Julien Viard de Galbert, UDD Bugs Search just gained the ability to help the triaging of X Strike Force bugs. He worked on the patch by installing his own copy of bugs.cgi on alioth. Don t hesitate to do the same with your team!

1 November 2010

Julien Valroff: Mini DebConf Paris 2010

I am now back home after 2 days spent at the first mini DebConf Paris. It was really nice to meet a lot of people, and to be able to discuss various aspects of Debian and Free Software in general. People came from all over Europe (at least from the UK, Spain, Italy, Germany, Switzerland, Austria, Greece, and obviously a majority of French people). All the talks I have been able to attend were really interesting, and some of the slides have already been made available by their author: I have also taken part to the keysigning party, which will now allows me to use my newly generated 4096R key. The group picture is also online, as well as a more comprehensive gallery. Thanks a lot to the organisation team, you guys have made an awesome work! See you all next year!

31 October 2010

Lucas Nussbaum: Mini DebConf Paris 2010

So, I m (almost) back from the first edition of MiniDebConf Paris, which was a success thanks to the great organizing skills in panic mode of Carl Chenet and Mehdi Dogguy. I think that everybody is already looking forward to the next edition. I met lots of people, and it was great to be able to finally put faces on names from the french free software community. I gave two talk there, the first one on Debian and Ubuntu (slides), the second one on Debian Quality Assurance (slides), which both went well (I think). I also hacked a bit: If you want to help me, here are some easy tasks that need takers (it s unlikely that I ll be able to tackle them anytime soon): One of the other things I d like to do is discuss ways to improve the synchronization of UDD (currently, it s synchronized at arbitrary times, while we could sync Sources+Packages just after dinstall, for example).

30 October 2010

Lucas Nussbaum: Debian becoming upstream for ubuntu-dev-tools?

Launchpad bug #643691: Please sync ubuntu-dev-tools 0.103 (universe) from Debian experimental (main) Did development of ubuntu-dev-tools move from Ubuntu to Debian? :-)

19 October 2010

Lucas Nussbaum: Reboot on kernel panic

Nice tip, I didn t know about it.

11 October 2010

Evgeni Golov: RC bugs 2010/40

Let s join gregora and zack (and others, too lazy to search for links/names) and fix some RC bugs in Debian!So what happened last week?What does that mean? Two bugs are (almost) closed, two need more work. And this leads me to a feature I miss from http://udd.debian.org/bugs.cgi: a comment field as http://bts.turmzimmer.net/ has it. Will ping lucas about this later today.Oh, and on a side-note, I joined http://ask.debian.net let s help our users :)

4 October 2010

Raphaël Hertzog: Can Debian offer a Constantly Usable Testing distribution?

Debian s testing distribution is where Debian developers prepare the next stable distribution. While this is still its main purpose, many users have adopted this version of Debian because it offers them a good trade-off between stability and freshness. But there are downsides to using this distribution and the Constantly Usable Testing (CUT) project aims to resolve those. This article will present the project and the challenges involved to make it happen. About Debian unstable & testing Debian unstable is the distribution where developers upload new versions of their packages. It happens frequently that some packages are not installable due to changes in other packages or due to transitions not yet completed. Debian testing, on the contrary, is managed by a tool that ensures the consistency of the whole distribution: it picks updates from unstable only if the package has been enough tested (10 days usually), if it s free of new release-critical bugs, if it s available on all supported architectures, and if it doesn t break any other package already present in testing. The Release Team (RT) controls this tool and provide hints to help it find a set of packages that can flow from unstable to testing. Those rules also ensure that the packages that flow into testing are reasonably free of show-stopper bugs (like a system that doesn t boot, or X that doesn t work at all). This makes it very attractive to users who like to regularly get new upstream versions of their software without dealing with the biggest problems associated to them. This is all very attractive, yet several Debian developers advise people to not use testing. Why is that? Known problems with testing Disappearing software The release team use this distribution to prepare the next stable release and from time to time they remove packages from it. Either because it s needed to ensure that other packages can migrate from unstable to testing, or because they have long-standing release-critical bugs without progress towards a resolution. It also happens that they remove packages on request of the maintainers because they believe that the current version of the software cannot be supported (security-wise) for 2 years or more. The security team also regularly issues such requests. Long delays for security and important fixes Despite the 10-day delay in unstable, there are always some annoying bugs (and security bugs are no exceptions) that are only discovered when the package already has migrated to testing. The maintainer might be quick to upload a fixed package in unstable, and might even raise the urgency to allow the package to migrate sooner, but if the packages gets entangled in a large ongoing transition, it will not migrate before the transition is completed. Sometimes it can take weeks for that to happen. This delay can be avoided by doing direct uploads to testing (through testing-proposed-updates) but this is almost never used, except during a freeze, where targeted bugfixes are the norm. Not always installable With testing evolving daily, updates sometimes break the last installation images available (in particular netboot images that get everything from the network). The debian-installer (d-i) packages are usually quickly fixed but they don t move to testing automatically because the new combination of d-i packages has not necessarily been validated yet. Colin Watson sums up the problem:
Getting new installer code into testing takes too long, and problems remain unfixed in testing for too long. [...] The problem with d-i development at the moment is more that we re very slow at producing new d-i *releases*. [...] Your choices right now are to work with stable (too old), testing (would be nice except for the way sometimes it breaks and then it tends to take a week to fix anything), unstable (breaks all the time).
CUT s history CUT finds its root in an old proposal by Joey Hess: it introduces the idea that the stable release is not Debian s sole product and that testing could become with some work a suitable choice for end-users. Nobody took on that work and there was no visible progress in the last 3 years. But recently Joey brought up CUT again on the debian-devel mailing list and Stefano Zacchiroli (the Debian project leader) challenged him to setup a BoF on CUT for Debconf10. It turned out to be one of the most heavily attended BoF (video recording is here), there is clearly a lot of interest in the topic. There s now a dedicated wiki and an Alioth project with a mailing list. The rest of this article tries to summarize the various options discussed and how they re supposed to address the problems identified. The ideas behind CUT Among all the ideas, there are two main approaches that have been discussed. The first is to regularly snapshot testing at points where it is known to work reasonably well (those snapshots would be named cut ). The second is to build an improved testing distribution tailored to the needs of users who want a working distribution with daily updates, its name would be rolling . Regular snapshots of testing There s general agreement that regular snapshots of testing are required: it s the only way to ensure that the generated installation media will continue to work until the next snapshot. If tests of the snapshot do not reveal any major problem, then it becomes the latest cut . For clarity, the official codename would be date based: e.g. cut-2010-09 would be the cut taken during September 2010. While the frequency has not been fixed yet, the goal is clearly to be on the aggressive side: at the very least every 6 months, but every month has been suggested as well. In order to reach a decision, many aspects have to be balanced. One of them (and possibly the most important) is the security support. Given that the security team is already overworked, it s difficult to put more work on their shoulders by declaring that cuts will be supported like any stable release. No official security support sounds bad but it s not necessarily so problematic as one might imagine. Testing s security record is generally better than stable s one (see the security tracker) because fixes flow in naturally with new upstream versions. Stable still get fixes for very important security issues sooner than testing, but on the whole there are less known security-related problems in testing than in stable. Since it s only a question of time until the fixed version comes naturally from upstream, more frequent cut releases means that users get security fixes sooner. But Stefan Fritsch, who used to be involved in the Debian testing security team, has also experienced the downside for anyone who tries to contribute security updates:
The updates to testing-security usually stay useful only for a few weeks, until a fixed version migrates from unstable. In stable, the updates stay around for a few years, which gives a higher motivation to spend time on preparing them.
So if it s difficult to form a dedicated security team, the work of providing security updates comes back to the package maintainer. They are usually quite quick to upload fixed packages in unstable but tend to not monitor whether the packages migrate to testing. They can t be blamed because testing was created to prepare the next stable release and there is thus no urgency to get the fix in as long as it makes it before the release. CUT can help in this regard precisely because it changes this assumption: there will be users of the testing packages and they deserve to get security fixes much like the stable users. Another aspect to consider when picking a release frequency is the amount of associated work that comes with any official release: testing upgrades from the previous version, writing release notes and preparing installation images. It seems difficult to do this every month. With this frequency it s also impossible to have a new major kernel release for each cut (since they tend to come out only every 2 to 3 months) and the new hardware support that it brings is something worthwhile to many users. In summary, regular snapshots address the not always installable problem and changes the perception of maintainers towards testing, so that hopefully they care more of security updates in that distribution (and in cuts). But they do not solve the problem of disappearing packages. Something else is needed to fix that problem. A new rolling distribution? Lucas Nussbaum pointed out that regular snapshots of Debian is not really a new concept:
How would this differentiate from other distributions doing 6-month release cycles, and in particular Ubuntu, which can already be seen as Debian snapshots (+ added value)?
In Lucas s eyes, CUT becomes interesting if it can provide a rolling distribution (like testing) with a constant flux of new upstream releases . For him, that would be something quite unique in the Free Software world . The snapshots would be used as starting point for the initial installation, but the installed system would point to the rolling distribution and users would then upgrade as often as they want. In this scenario, security support for the snapshots is not so important, what matters is the state of the rolling distribution. If testing were used as the rolling distribution, the problem of disappearing packages would not be fixed. That s why there have been discussions of introducing a new distribution named rolling that would work like testing but with adapted rules, and the cuts would then be snapshots of rolling instead of testing. The basic proposal is to make a copy of testing and to re-add the packages which have been removed because they are not suited for a long term release while they are perfectly acceptable for a constantly updated release (the most recent example being Chromium). Then it s possible to go one step further: during freeze, testing is no longer automatically updated which makes it inappropriate to feed the rolling distribution. That s why rolling would be reconfigured to grab updates from unstable (but using the same rules than testing). Given the frequent releases, it s likely that only a subset of architectures would be officially supported. This is not a real problem because the users who want bleeding edge software tends to be desktop users on mainly i386/amd64 (and maybe armel for tablets and similar mobile products). This choice if made opens up the door to even more possibilities: if rolling is configured exactly like testing but with only a subset of the architectures, it s likely that some packages migrate to rolling before testing when non-mainstream architectures are lagging in terms of auto-building (or have toolchain problems). While being ahead of testing can be positive for the users, it s also problematic on several levels. First, managing rolling becomes much more complicated because the transition management work done by the release team can t be reused as-is. Then it introduces competition between both distributions which can make it more difficult to get a stable release out, for example if maintainers stop caring of the migration to testing once the migration to rolling has been completed. The rolling distribution is certainly a good idea but the rules governing it must be designed to avoid any conflict with the process of releasing a stable distribution. Lastly, the mere existence of rolling would finally fix the marketing problem plaguing testing: the name rolling does not suggest that the software is not yet ready for prime time. Conclusion Whether CUT will be implemented remains to be seen, but it s off for a good start: ftpmaster Joerg Jaspert said that the new archive server can cope with a new distribution, and there s now a proposal shaping up. The project might start quickly: there is already an implementation plan for the snapshot side of the project. The rolling distribution can always be introduced later, once it is ready. Both approaches can complement each other and provide something useful to different kind of users. The global proposal is certainly appealing: it would address the concerns of obsolescence of Debian s stable release by making intermediary releases. Anyone needing something more recent for hardware support can start by installing a cut and follow the subsequent releases until the next stable version. And users who always want the latest version of every software could use rolling after having installed a cut. From a user point of view, there are similarities with the mix of usual and long term releases of Ubuntu. But from the development side, the process followed would be quite different, and the constraints imposed by having a constantly usable distribution are stronger: any wide-scale change must be designed in a way that it can happen progressively in a transparent manner for the user.
This article was first published in Linux Weekly News. If you want to see more articles like this, join Flattr and click on the flattr button below every article that you like.
Flattr this Share/Bookmark 21 comments Support my work

29 September 2010

Gunnar Wolf: Ruby dissonance with Debian, again

Lucas has written two long, insightful posts on the frustration about the social aspects of integrating Ruby stuff Debian The first one, on September 12 and the second one, on September 29. I cannot really blame (thoroughly) the Ruby guys for their position. After all, they have a vibrant community, and they are advancing great pieces of work. And they know who that code is meant for Fellow programmers. And yes, although it is a pain to follow their API changes (and several of the Gems I regularly use do often get refactorings and functionality enhancements which break compatibility but introduce very nice new features), they say that's solved with one of Gems' main features being the simultaneous installability of different versions. The key difference in Debian's worldview with Ruby's is they cater to Fellow programmers. Even leaving aside heaps of different positions and worldview/mindset, we have a fundamental difference: Debian cares about its users, whatever that means. So, our users should not even care what language a given application is implemented in They should only care that it works. We, as packagers, should take care of all the infrastructural stuff. And yes, that's where we find the conflicting spot: We don't want to ship many versions of a system library (that in this case would be a Gem). Specially if later versions fix known bugs in earlier versions and backports are not available or supported. Specially if upstream authors' only response to a bug in an older release will be "upgrade and rewrite whatever breaks in your application". As an example of this, I am not currently updating the gems I maintain, as Debian is on a freeze to get out the next stable release. Or if at all, I am targetting those uploads to our Experimental branch, in order not to create a huge backlog for me when the freeze is over (just a series of rebuilds targetted at unstable). And yes, I will have to be responsible for any bugs that will most likely not be supported by most of my upstreams during the next ~2 years. That's the role of a Linux distribution. And yes, as Lucas writes in the comments he got as responses to the first post This dissonance comes in no small part because the Ruby developer community is mostly made from non-linuxers. People coming from a background where (mostly propietary) applications bundle up everything they need, where static linking is more popular than dynamic libraries, where there is no coordination between parts of the system are much less likely to understand our work. And yes, the Perl community is a joy to work with in this regard. And that's the same I understand from the Python one. Because of their origins and where their main strength was grown and remains. PS - And yes, I will join the flock of people saying that... The specific person that attacked your work is a great programmer, but well known as intolerant and obnoxious. Fortunately, even if our respective cultures fail to mix so much, most of our interactions just end with a "sigh" of lack of understanding, and not with the flames you got targetted with :-/

Lucas Nussbaum: How to demotivate people (Re: Making Debian Responsible For Its Actions)

In my Ruby packaging in Debian and Ubuntu: Mythbusting and FAQ, I wrote The Ruby developers (or expert users) community is generally very hostile towards Debian. Many harsh words and insults are used in discussions mentioning Debian in the ruby-core@ mailing list, and there are frequent recommendations to avoid the Debian packages and install from sources, which is quite demotivating (Actually, what prompted that blog post is someone calling Debian-specific changes unforgivable). Zed A. Shaw just provided a very good example of that. Quoting the most juicy parts:
It s simply a tactic to make sure that you are stuck on Debian.
If we look at this problem from an open source perspective, Debian is at a minimum being a horrible citizen.
What is happening is control is not aligned with responsibility. Debian has taken control of the software package and recrafted it for their very narrow set of system administrator users. However, they refuse to take responsibility for the defect and quality problems they create. Instead I end up being responsible for their mistakes, which is wrong.
If Debian is in control, then Debian should be made responsible. That s the only way to get them to change it. If they don t want to be responsible, then they should let me be in control.
I m imagining a mass petition, maybe some funny ad campaigns, in-person confrontations meant to embarrass package maintainers, SEO tricks to get people off Debian, promotion of any alternative to Debian, anything to make them pay, apologize, and listen.
If you write software and you re sick of Debian screwing up your gear, then shoot me ideas for how we can make this happen. I think that if enough of us band together to make Debian responsible for its actions we can actually get them to start asking us before they package our software to find out how we think it should be packaged.
On the technical part of the post: The problem that Zed is experiencing is unknown to me, and also to the Debian and Ubuntu bug trackers. To my knowledge, rubygems doesn t not require openssl or net/scp to work, and a simple grep through the sources kind-of confirms that. But of course, that blog post was written as a rant, not as a proper bug report. My best guess is that the gem that Zed is installing requires openssl and net/scp. But of course, rubygems can t just depend on all the libraries that applications or libraries installed via rubygems could possibly require. Regarding openssl, we had a problem in Ruby because of the licensing situation of Ruby (dual licensed GPLv2+ and Ruby license, linked with openssl, which might raise some eyebrows), so it was split off the main standard library package until recently (and, apparently, in the version Zed is using). For net/scp, it is not part of the standard library, and not a dependency of rubygems, so I don t see why Zed expects it to be installed. On the rest of the post: Following my last post, several people volunteered to help with Ruby on Debian (and Ubuntu). In particular, Laurent Arnoud has been doing some fantastic work fixing the pkg-ruby-extras team s RC bugs. Also, all the messages of support both in the comments of my last post were very much appreciated. But I m really wondering why the Ruby community generates so many poisonous people. All my work on Debian is done on a volunteer basis, and it s really hard to get so much shit from it.

19 September 2010

Gregor Herrmann: RC bugs 2010/37

thanks to Lucas' recent archive rebuild & bug filing we have new stuff to work on :) my activities in the last week:

18 September 2010

Lucas Nussbaum: UDD bugs search news

Many changes to the UDD-backed Debian Bugs Search: Enjoy!

Lucas Nussbaum: Helping improve Ruby on Debian and Ubuntu

After my last blog post on Ruby in Debian and Ubuntu, I got a few offers for help, which is excellent. So I ve decided to update this wiki page with pointers to the various team resources, and some examples of tasks that newcomers can do. I d like to stress that many pending tasks are really doable by someone not very qualified in Debian packaging. They are not done just because nobody has the time to do them. Some good examples are the libinotify-ruby, libimage-size-ruby, libffi-ruby RC bugs.

13 September 2010

Lucas Nussbaum: Debian Bugs Search using UDD

After a few hours of hacking, I came up with Debian Bugs Search. This Ultimate Debian Database tool enables to query different kinds of Debian bugs (especially RC bugs using a multi-criteria search. It is aimed at being a replacement for the unofficial RC Bugs tracker, which has some bugs and fails to display the correct status for some bugs (Debian Bugs Search sees 450 RC bugs affecting squeeze, vs 278 for the unofficial RC bugs tracker). While Debian Bugs Search still lacks some features that the unofficial RC bugs tracker has, it also brings some new features. The main advantage is that it makes it easy to find some classes of interesting bugs, for example: RC bugs affecting squeeze and sid, tagged patch, sorted by time of last change. Why weren t they fixed using the patch? RC bugs affecting squeeze and sid, tagged pending, sorted by time of last change. Why weren t they fixed by an upload if they were tagged pending a long time ago? Bugs affecting squeeze but not sid, and marked as done. Why didn t the fixed packages migrate to testing? I m open to suggestions of improvements, bug reports, or better, patches. Since it is UDD-based, it is quite easy to add more information. My own TODO list is:
- add popcon information (also enable sorting by popcon)
- add a way to display/hide additional columns (popcon, package s versions)

12 September 2010

Lucas Nussbaum: Ruby packaging in Debian and Ubuntu: Mythbusting and FAQ

A lot is being said on how Ruby is packaged in Debian and Ubuntu. In this post, I m trying to go through the most common myths and give my position as a Debian Ruby maintainer. Note that those are my views, not necessarily those of the other Debian Ruby maintainers. Myth: Ruby is completely outdated in Debian and Ubuntu There s a culture in the Ruby community of always using the latest bleeding-edge version. There s also a culture (though this one has recessed a bit, I think) that it s perfectly fine to change APIs in incompatible ways if it makes the software slightly better. In Debian (and Ubuntu) stable releases, we try to provide a rock-solid version of Ruby that won t be allowed to change API during the support lifetime of a release. Bugfixes for important bugs can be applied, but that s basically all. So it s not surprising that Ruby in released versions of Debian and Ubuntu is behind the latest upstream version. In development branches, we are following the latest upstream versions quite closely. Debian 6.0 squeeze , to be released by the end of the year, includes Ruby 1.8.7-p302, and will include 1.9.2-p0 (the currently of Ruby 1.9.2 in squeeze is currenty a SVN snapshot from beginning of august). There are people interested in installing a packaged Ruby that just works, and other people interested in installing their own version of Ruby (through RVM and such). People in the Ruby community tend to forget about the first category, and consider that, because they install Ruby from source or with RVM, that should be the solution for everybody. We need the Ruby community to respect that different people have different ways of using Ruby, and to stop recommending that everyone using Debian and Ubuntu should install Ruby from source. We also need to leverage the backports services for both Debian and Ubuntu to provide a way to install the latest upstream version on stable releases. The only reason why we are not doing it yet is lack of time. Myth: Ruby is split into a myriad of packages in Debian In the past (pre-2005), a decision was made to split some libraries from the standard library into separate packages. This was motivated by: Most of the split was undone a very long time ago, and the readline and openssl splits were undone this year. The current package in Debian squeeze has: It is always possible to merge more packages, but merging any of the other packages would significantly increase the size of what you get by default, and might discourage people to use it in some contexts (disk space is not always cheap. Think embedded systems and smartphones). Myth: Rubygems is crippled in Debian There are two differences in the rubygems Debian packages. First, gems are installed in /var/lib/gems, not /usr/local/lib/gems. That is because rubygems are seen as state for the Rubygems package, not independant software installed separately. A change for this is currently being discussed, and should be done after the squeeze release. (I don t think that it s reasonable to push that change now). A consequence of installing to /var/lib/gems is that gems binary are outside of $PATH. After the change, gems binary would also be installed in /usr/local/bin. Second, gem update --sytem is disabled in the Debian package, because that would replace code from the Rubygems Debian package with code downloaded from the Internet, and can break your system in subtle ways. We have changed this (in SVN, not in any package in the archive yet) to allow gem update --system if a specific environment variable is set, which gives us the opportunity to display a warning message. Myth: Ruby is slow on Debian Ruby is built with the pthread threading code, because not using it breaks many native Ruby libraries (Ruby-gnome2, for example). And other Linux distributions are doing the same. There are some very old benchmark results floating around in some blogs that show that the pthread code has a performance impact of about 20%. There are been patches for that for a long time (applied in Ruby Enterprise Edition), but they were never properly sent back. Actually, all the discussions about this issue were rumors and blog posts, and there wasn t even a bug report about it! After the bug was reported properly, it was fixed in a timely manner. The fix is not yet included in the Ruby 1.8.7, but is being applied as a patch to the Debian package since 1.8.7.299-2. (So the Debian package is actually newer and faster than upstream Ruby in that regard). What makes Ruby so difficult to maintain in Debian? The main problems we have with Ruby are portability issues. The only officially supported platform for Ruby is IA32 (i386 in Debian), and everything else is best effort. It means that it is not even supported officially on x86_64/amd64! Debian supports a dozen of architectures, and the Ruby package has to work on each of them. Ruby 1.8 is mostly OK nowadays thanks to the help of Debian porters, but we still have serious problems with 1.9.2, since the test suite fails on sparc, hppa, ia64 and Debian GNU/kFreeBSD. Why doesn t Ruby use the alternatives system on Debian? The alternatives system provides a way to switch between different software providing the same functionality. Currently, if you want to use Ruby 1.9.2, you need to use the ruby1.9.1 executable (1.9.1 = ruby compatibility version here). The alternatives system would allow to switch ruby to ruby1.9.1 on a system-wide basis. However, the situation of applications and libraries working only with Ruby 1.8 should be clarified: those should use /usr/bin/ruby1.8 instead of /usr/bin/ruby. Another problem is that the way to specify packages dependencies still need to be determined. There s nothing impossible to do about that, it just needs someone to do the work. Where do we go from here? The Ruby developers (or expert users) community is generally very hostile towards Debian. Many harsh words and insults are used in discussions mentioning Debian in the ruby-core@ mailing list, and there are frequent recommendations to avoid the Debian packages and install from sources, which is quite demotivating (Actually, what prompted that blog post is someone calling Debian-specific changes unforgivable). This atmosphere makes it hard to recruit people, and the Debian Ruby teams are completely understaffed, which is clearly the major blocker to improving the situation further. We are 3 co-maintainers for the interpreter packages, and I m the only Debian Developer that is really active on a regular basis in the pkg-ruby-extras team (that does libraries and applications packaging). We desperately need help, but at the same time I have no time to improve our documentation and make it easier to join the team. While I haven t reached a final decision yet, I am also likely to stop doing Ruby work in Debian after squeeze is released, as I am getting increasingly tired and demotivated.

Next.

Previous.