Search Results: "ag"

16 September 2008

Christoph Haas: MySQL to PostgreSQL - a Bacula conversion odyssey

Why is it that always the seemingly most simple things turn out to be the most annoying? This time I “just” wanted to get rid of one of my last MySQL databases and move it over to PostgreSQL. The Bacula catalog that saves which file I backed up when and to which storage medium. I tried with MySQL’s “mysqldump” and it’s PostgreSQL compatibility option - but apparently MySQL developers know nothing about PostgreSQL. Then I tried with “sqlfairy” - and found myself booting my system hard after it ate 2 GB of swap and died while converting 500 MB of data. So finally I asked in #bacula and was told to try CSV (comma-seperated values) as an intermediate format. Yuck… that satan-spawned format that reminds me of my dark past? Okay. First dump the catalog from MySQL: for table in BaseFiles CDImages Client Counters Device File Filename FileSet Job JobMedia Location LocationLog Log Media MediaType Path Pool Status Storage UnsavedFiles Version ; do mysqldump -u root -pmypassword -T. bacula $table; done (Okay, okay, this is not comma- but tab-seperated. But that’s even better for running the COPY-FROM command later.) This creates an ‘.sql’ (the schema) and a ‘.txt’ (the rows/records) file for each table in the current directory. Just don’t try to apply the schema to PostgreSQL. Instead better create a new schema. Bacula ships with a script for that purpose. Unless you have the PostgreSQL database for Bacula ready you should run something like… /usr/share/bacula-director/make_postgresql_tables -h localhost -U bacula …and… /usr/share/bacula-director/grant_postgresql_privileges -h localhost -U bacula Now on to read the tab-delimited data into PostgreSQL. The importing via the COPY command must be done with administrator privileges! And it’s important to explicitly state which columns correspond to which table columns (see the respective ‘.sql’ files) or otherwise you’ll get chaos. Of course this only has to be done for .txt files larger than 0 bytes. Oh, and the filename has to be absolute. Example: Unfortunately my “Job.txt” and “Media.txt” contained datestamp entries like “0000-00-00 00:00:00″ which are not valid for PostgreSQL. So I went into Vim and replaced it: s/0000-00-00 00:00:00/1970-01-01 00:00:00/g. Clear the table (DELETE FROM job) and import again. And finally it’s important to get the sequence numbers right as described in the Bacula manual. Morale: spend two extra-minutes to start with PostgreSQL right away instead of bothering about conversions later. And never assume converting from one database to another would work - just because both have “SQL” in their names.

Jan Wagner: Thanks

To make it short: many thanks to wouter, myon, weasel and especially santiago and panthera … you made my month, definetly!

Runa Sandvik: Can has lolcode?

HAI
CAN HAS ATTENTION? About a year ago I wrote a blog post about syntax highlighting and indenting for lolcode in vim. A lot has happened with the programming language since then, and I haven’t had the time to update the two files. Chris (aka cheepguava) was nice enough to do just that. The things he added includes multiline comments (OBTW … TLDR), special characters within strings (:) or :> or :o or :: or :”) and more language keywords to get it closer to the 1.2 spec. You can find the tarball at http://www.indentedlines.net/lolcode/vim.tar.gz Please note that you have to rename the two files to lolcode.vim Put the two files in $HOME/.vim/syntax and $HOME/.vim/indent respectively. You also need to have filetype plugin indent on in your .vimrc file. Using syntax on and filetype on is also a good idea. Because lolcode is a new filetype, you need to make sure it is detected by the system: mkdir ~/.vim/ftdetect Create a new file named lol.vim in that directory. In this file you need to have the following line: au BufRead,BufNewFile *.lol set filetype=lolcode Thanks to Chris for helping out, and I hope you enjoy! KTHXBYE

Christian Perrier: No more Danish, Ukrainian, Estonian, Slovenian, Latvian, Bosnian, Macedonian in D-I?

Only four days are left and these languages, as well as Amharic, Northern Sami, Slovenian, Albanian, Tagalog are in very high danger of being disabled in Debian Installer. For Bengali, I still have some hope as someone volunteered to fill in the gap left. Catalan is still missing its 5 miserable strings but I guess I won't have the guts to disable it just because it is missing strings that warn users that the translation could be incomplete (feel free to laugh at this paradox but if you think this is stupid, just also feel free to come and fix that bug or complete the damn translation). I can now confess that we will reach a point where we will have less translations for the installer in Lenny than we had in Etch. I don't see any reason for this to change in four days. And, yes, I call this sad news as we (particularly Frans) did a lot of improvement in D-I to lower down the requirements. PS: for those who wonder why I mention only 7 languages in that post's title, I indeed picked up those I still have a small hope I can wake up someone to complete the work in these last four days.

Biella Coleman: What Generation?

Siva Vaidhyanathan has written a short piece for the Chronicle of Higher Education that make a simple but very important move: he demystifies the idea that most youth in the US, much less the world, are part a tech-savvy generation. The point should be made as there are a slew of not only journalists (who let’s face it, exaggerate and simplify and well, there is not much we can do about it) but academics making making and circulating claims. These not only don’t hold much water, but also hide some serious disparities out there when it comes to access and also hides the fact that the phenomena people extend to wide swaths of the population are usually far more circumscribed and cultural in their orientation. I think his point hit home recently because my class on an uber-techie subject, hackers, is primarily composed of students who have never started a blog, don’t read blogs, have never used much less heard of RSS feed etc. I am not saying this either to disparage this fact (I am envious of these students in fact) but just to say note that those who are quite intimate with technology (and there is a small cluster of students in my class who represent such groups) are in fact a slice of the pie. This is an interesting slice and one that I study and one that I find really really interesting and can be used to track some braoder shifts and changes but in a far more limited register. But I think we should be suspect of any move that takes the slice to stand in for the whole pie. This rhetorical embellishment is one that I have come to expect form journalists (for better or for worse) but I am less forgiving of the academics who partake in this problematic form of puffery, in what is a leap over people’s everyday reality and into the realm of imagination, which is better left to fiction.

Patrick Schoenfeld: Hi Planet!

Today I got a mail from weasel, that my Debian account has been created. So in the end of my NM process everything went pretty fast. Now that I finally became a Debian Developer it feels like the end of a long journey, so I'd like to reflect on my process.

I started my "career" in Debian around 2006, when I got a co-maintainer of the smstools package. From then I got more involved with adopting some more packages etc. till I finally applied to become a DD on 31th August 2007. Until then most of my uploads where sponsored by Daniel Baumann (panthera), who therefore helped me learn a lot, and so he got my advocate. From that point on the most time of my NM process I've been waiting. Waiting for an AM, waiting for my AM (well, he also needed to wait for me because we both had busy times during my active processing), waiting for front desk. After all I had luck, because the DAM problem has been solved recently. I know that a part of the time I didn't feel like pushing my application forward fast, because I did not see where this would lead, except to a situation where I'd again wait for the DAM.

Now I'm quiet happy. And that is a good moment to thank some people, who helped me to get to this point: panthera for beeing my sponsor and advocate for some time, Thijs for beeing a sponsor and quiet helpful when it was about fixing security issues in mantis, naoliv for beeing a very reliable sponsor, pabs for beeing my AM, Myon for several actings on my NM application and off course the people involved in account creation. Thanks.

Gerfried Fuchs: webwml in git

Last week I wondered how much space a complete git conversion would actually need—and I was quite surprised:
$ du -hs webwml*
325M    webwml
416M    webwml.git
819M    webwml.svn
The first line is the regular CVS checkout. The third line is the SVN checkout that's available from alioth. You can see that the size is not really something one would want, especially since the real gain is extremely little: besides offline diff you rather have disadvantages with not being able to do much offline because anything history wise requires you to be online. In CVS you at least knew that revision 1.12 of a file is three commits above revision 1.9 of the same file; while in SVN you have no chance offline to know how many commits to a file happened between revision 512 and 1024, if any at all. The conversion to git took me quite a long time, practically almost three days of (non-constant) running git-cvsimport on my laptop. The time did not completely surprise me, at least when I noticed in the end that it were well over 83 thousand commits in well over 10 years, reaching back to July 1998. My first own commit was in July 2001, which wasn't too hard to find out with git neither, and required no online operation. git gives you complete offline access to the history. This is actually something that the build process can be based on. There propably will be some speed drawback with not being able to do simple-math for revision difference like in CVS, but that actually will have to be checked. I'm still convinced being able to do all the stuff offline without any strange hacks or needing to be online all the time is something worthwhile. Things left to do and which I propably won't find the time in the too near future because of ... erm, you know? Lenny? That we want to release? But anyway, to not have the list of things get lost, here is a (not complete) list of things in case you are bored and want to play around a bit: Playing around a bit? Well, you don't have to do the whole git-cvsimport on yourself: I've pushed my webwml.git repository to alioth: "git clone ssh://git.debian.org/git/users/alfie/webwml.git" should get you started. Please notice to play around in a seperate branch and not directly in origin to be able to pull further and update from time to time.

Biella Coleman: The Jury is Out

As someone who spends a lot, perhaps too much, time thinking, writing, and teaching about the politics of science and technology, I can’t help but feel flat out and down right infuriated when I read about the recent controversies concerning Bisphenol A (BPA), a chemical found in plastics and now suspected as playing a role in causing a small blizzard of health problems from type 2 diabetes to ADHD. Recently there have been a slew of tests and experiments that, while not conclusive, indicate that Bisphenol A may indeed be behind some ill health effects, reports of which pop up in the news at least every few weeks. And, yet the FDA has had the c*j*nes to declare the matter closed, they have ruled that Bisphenol A does not pose a hazard. (In their own words: “”safe and that exposure levels to BPA from food contact materials, including for infants and children, are below those that may cause health effects”) It seems like this not the time to unfurl such public declaration of confidence when clearly, if nothing else, the Jury is Out. No declaration is better than what the FDA has done. What is a least somewhat heartening is that recently the press, I think, has drawn on a panoply of experts, some of whom convey the danger and idiocy of letting the FDA be the ultimate arbiter in these (still) controversial matters:
Another expert, Dr. Rick Stahlhut, from the University of Rochester Medical Center in New York, agreed this study does not provide a causal link between BPA and heart disease and diabetes, but it’s the first step toward discovering such a link. “The findings are intriguing, but they have to be validated,” Stahlhut said. Stahlhut said he expects the controversy to continue. “It’s just like every other environmental exposure problem. We are always two decades behind. Ten to 20 years after the chemical is produced, suspicions start to rise. By then, it’s a multi-billion-dollar industry, and now there are forces whose job it is to keep it going — and that is what is happening now,” he said. Until all the facts are known about BPA, Stahlhut recommends not exposing yourself to things you do not need. Don’t take it for granted that because some “smiling guy on TV” says it’s OK, it is, he said.

Sandro Tosi: Ignition sequence. All engines are started. We have ignition. 2, 1, zero. We have a DD!! We have a DD!!

I just receive The Mail (tm) from weasel, and I can't be happier that this (mh, is my life too boring?): I just become a DD!!!!!!! Please join my happiness in this achievement!!

I'd like to thank all the people helped me in my way to Debian, both for a long and fruitful collaboration or for just a mail exchange, both for kind people and rude ones (ah, we all have our own character, so never mind :) ) and in doing this I'm sure I'll forget someone (so please excuse me for this, you're in my mind tough): so thank you Tony, Bernd, Piotr, Thomas, Vincent, Adeodato, Lucas, Luk, Sune, Joerg (yeah, I'm brave :) ), Paul, and many others!

Of course, congrats go also to my other colleagues that "laureate" with me in Mid September DD Class :D

John Goerzen: Jacob is Youtube's Youngest Fan

Ever since we got back from our train trip this summer, Jacob has loved to talk about trains. He used to call them a "toot" after the sound they make, but as his language skills improve, now he calls them "chains."

I thought one day that he might like to look at pictures of our train trips on the computer. So I brought him over, fired up digikam, and he sat on my lap for literally half an hour looking at train photos. He'd jabber the whole time, pointing out that there were trains on the screen, whether or not they had open doors, whether people were on the train or not ("on toot!"). This from a boy that was about 21 months old at the time.

So now, when he sees me arrive home, or sees the office door, or just about anything that reminds him of trains, he'll run over to me and say "chain? chain? CHAIN?!! CHAIN DA??!!" ("dad") I've had to set limits on how many times we go over to the computer and look at train pictures in a given evening.

After a little while of this, I started to get tired of looking at the same set of photos over and over. So I went to flickr to pull up some train photos. Jacob loved this, too. One evening, I must have used slightly different search terms -- maybe railroad or something. I hit the button to show the slideshow of the results, as I always do.

And here is where I forgot something -- that flickr now supports short videos. Here we were, happily looking at photos of trains, and all of a sudden we see a video of a steam engine in Ireland. Jacob looked surprised, and sat perfectly still while watching it. Then when it was over, he excitedly yelled, "CHAIN GO!!" He wanted to watch the train go over and over again.

You can imagine that I tired of that before long, so I figured that I could find more trains going on youtube. Sure enough. Dozens of videos of trains. Lots of them with someone standing with a camera aimed down the tracks and then a train simply goes by. Jacob loves to here the "DING!" from the gates these people usually stand by, then the "TOOT!" from the train approaching, and then watch the "CHAIN GO!".

That time Terah said he was sitting on my lap for 45 minutes solid.

So now Jacob wants to watch trains even more than before, and if I try to show him train pictures, it's "chain go? chain go?". Ah well. At least he's found a hobby.

Russell Coker: RSS Aggregation Software

The most commonly installed software for aggregating RSS feeds seems to be Planet and Venus (two forks of the same code base). The operation is that a cron job runs the Python program which syndicates a list of RSS feeds and generates a static web page. Of course the problems start if you have many feeds as polling each of them (even the ones that typically get updated at most once a week) can take a while. My experience with adding moderate numbers of feeds (such as all the feeds used by Planet Debian [1]) is that it can take as much as 30 minutes to poll them all - which will be a problem if you want frequent updates. Frequent polling is not always desired, it means more network load and a greater incidence of transient failures. Any error in updating a feed is (in a default configuration) going to result in an error message being displayed by Planet, which in a default configuration will result in cron sending an email to the sysadmin. Even with an RSS feed being checked every four hours (which is what I do for my personal Planet installations) it can still be annoying to get the email when someone’s feed is offline for a day. Now while there is usually no benefit in polling every 15 minutes (the most frequent poll time that is commonly used) there is one good reason for doing it if you can only poll. The fact that some people want to click reload on the Planet web page every 10 minutes to look for new posts is not a good reason (it’s like looking in the fridge every few minutes and hoping that something tasty will appear). The good reason for polling frequently is to allow timely retraction of posts. It’s not uncommon for bloggers to fail to adequately consider the privacy implications of their posts (let’s face it - professional journalists have a written code of ethics about this, formal training, an editorial board, and they still get it wrong on occasion - it’s not easy). So when a mistake is made about what personal data should be published in a blog post it’s best for everyone if the post can be amended quickly. The design of Planet is that when a post disappears from the RSS feed then it also disappears from the Planet web page, I believe that this was deliberately done for the purpose of removing such posts. The correct solution to the problem of amending or removing posts is to use the “Update Services” part of the blog server configuration to have it send an XML RPC to the syndication service. That can give an update rapidly (in a matter of seconds) without any polling. I believe that a cron job is simply the wrong design for a modern RSS syndication service. This is no criticism of Planet (which has been working well for years for many people) but is due to the more recent requirements of more blogs, more frequent posting, and greater importance attached to blogs. I believe that the first requirement for a public syndication service is that every blogger gets to specify the URL of their own feed to save the sysadmin the effort of doing routine URL changes. It should be an option to have the server act on HTTP 301 codes and record the new URL in the database. Then the sysadmin would only have to manage adding new bloggers (approving them after they have created an account through a web-based interface) and removing bloggers. The problem of polling frequency can be mostly solved by using RPC pings to inform the server of new posts if the RPC mechanism supports removing posts. If removing posts is not supported by the RPC then every blog which has an active post would have to be polled frequently. This would reduce the amount of polling considerably, for example there are 319 blogs that are currently syndicated on Planet Debian, there are 60 posts in the feed, and those posts were written by 41 different people. So if the frequent polling to detect article removal was performed for active articles, given the fact that you poll the bloggers feed URL not the article that would only mean 41 polls instead of 319 - reducing the polling by a factor of more than 7! Now even with support for RPC pings there is still a need to poll feeds. One issue is that feeds may experience temporary technical difficulty in sending the RPC as we don’t want to compel the authors of blog software to try and make the ping as reliable a process as sending email (if that was the requirement then a ping via email might be the best solution). The polling frequency could be implemented on a per-blog basis based on the request of the blogger and the blog availability and posting frequency. Someone who’s blog has been down for a day (which is not uncommon when considering a population of 300 bloggers) could have their blog polled on a daily basis. Apart from that the polling frequency could be based on the time since the last post. It seems to be a general pattern that hobby bloggers (who comprise the vast majority of bloggers syndicated in Planet installations) often go for weeks at a time with no posts and then release a series of posts when they feel inspired. In terms of software which meats these requirements, the nearest option seems to be the the Advogato software mod_virgule [2]. Advogato [3] supports managing accounts with attached RSS feeds and also supports ranking blogs for a personalised view. A minor modification of that code to limit who gets to have their blog archived, and fixing it so that a modified post only has the latest version stored (not both versions as Advogato does) would satisfy some of these requirements. One problem is that Advogato’s method of syndicating blogs is to keep an entire copy of each blog (and all revisions). This goes against the demands of many bloggers who demand that Planet installations not keep copies of their content for a long period and not have any permanent archives. Among other things if there are two copies of a blog post then Google might get the wrong idea as to which is the original. Does anyone know of a system which does better than Advogato in meeting these design criteria?

Lucas Nussbaum: New Debian Developers!

We got a lot of (>= 10) new Debian developers recently. I’m really happy to see that the bottlenecks in the New Maintainer process were (at least partially) solved. My first NM (actually my second, my first one is on hold) also became a DD today. So, how long does it take to become a DD ? Let’s take 2 examples. Both are very active and skilled new contributors, that probably were quite close from being the faster you can be through NM:
Name Applied AM assigned Approved by AM Account created
Chris Lamb 2008-05-01 2008-06-12 2008-07-22 2008-09-16
Sandro Tosi 2008-03-24 2008-05-06 2008-06-22 2008-09-16
We have the proof: provided you have all the required skills, you can become a DD in less than 6 months! Of course, some things are not perfect yet:

Lucas Nussbaum: Is Mozilla the new XFree86? Could Ubuntu actually help?

All the recent moves of Mozilla make me feel that they are really taking the XFree86 path. Reading the Launchpad bug log about the EULA shows that most of the posters agree on who is on the wrong side, and favor switching to IceWeasel or Epiphany+Webkit. Even if Mozilla is apparently going to back off on the EULA story, it looks like the harm was done. If they want to fix that, they will have to start listening to other players in the Free Software community. Or just watch Webkit eat their market share. Since Ubuntu leaders are apparently talking to Mozilla about that, I really hope that they are aiming for a solution that will help the Free Software community as a whole, and are not looking for a work-around that will “fix” the problem for Ubuntu. There has been a lot of noise about the lack of “giving back” to the community by Ubuntu. Using Ubuntu user base to weight in and solve such issues in a way that benefit the whole community would probably be seen as a much more valuable contribution than another bunch of patches.

MJ Ray: Web Foundation and While I Was Out

I concentrated on work after my return to the keyboard last week and then spent much of the weekend reroofing a shed, so today was my first day catching up with the news. Here’s what I noticed:-

15 September 2008

Adam Rosi-Kessel: WordPress Pages No Longer Work

All the “pages” linked from my weblog — for example, my “about” page and my PGP key — are broken. I’ve posted in the WordPress Support Forums with no luck. I’m not sure when or why they stopped working, but if any readers have any suggestions of how to troubleshoot, I’d love to hear about it. Nothing relevant appears in server logs. In the meantime, apologies if you came here trying to find out about me. I’m temporarily out of service.

Adam Rosi-Kessel: The man hears what he wants to hear

(and disregards the rest) Jonah Lehrer reports the result of a depressing but unsurprising experiment: The Facts Don’t Matter.
Political scientists Brendan Nyhan and Jason Reifler provided two groups of volunteers with the Bush administration’s prewar claims that Iraq had weapons of mass destruction. One group was given a refutation — the comprehensive 2004 Duelfer report that concluded that Iraq did not have weapons of mass destruction before the United States invaded in 2003. Thirty-four percent of conservatives told only about the Bush administration’s claims thought Iraq had hidden or destroyed its weapons before the U.S. invasion, but 64 percent of conservatives who heard both claim and refutation thought that Iraq really did have the weapons. The refutation, in other words, made the misinformation worse. A similar “backfire effect” also influenced conservatives told about Bush administration assertions that tax cuts increase federal revenue. One group was offered a refutation by prominent economists that included current and former Bush administration officials. About 35 percent of conservatives told about the Bush claim believed it; 67 percent of those provided with both assertion and refutation believed that tax cuts increase revenue. In a paper approaching publication, Nyhan, a PhD student at Duke University, and Reifler, at Georgia State University, suggest that Republicans might be especially prone to the backfire effect because conservatives may have more rigid views than liberals: Upon hearing a refutation, conservatives might “argue back” against the refutation in their minds, thereby strengthening their belief in the misinformation. Nyhan and Reifler did not see the same “backfire effect” when liberals were given misinformation and a refutation about the Bush administration’s stance on stem cell research.
It’s particularly interesting that the backfire effect is more pronounced with Republicans; this certainly resonates with my admittedly biased view. Better information doesn’t seem to fix the problem, either:
During the first term of Bill Clinton’s presidency, the budget deficit declined by more than 90 percent. However, when Republican voters were asked in 1996 what happened to the deficit under Clinton, more than 55 percent said that it had increased. What’s interesting about this data is that so-called “high-information” voters - these are the Republicans who read the newspaper, watch cable news and can identify their representatives in Congress - weren’t better informed than “low-information” voters.
Anyone have a better solution? Or should we just throw in the towel on democracy?

Eddy Petrișor: one week ago

This happened:


This is why lately I haven't been available.

Jeff Licquia: Free Software EULAs?

Ubuntu is now being forced to show a EULA before letting users run Firefox, on pain of losing the rights to the Firefox trademark. (You know, End User License Agreements: those pop-ups Windows and Mac users have to put up with all the time, with the big “I Accept” button at the bottom.) Mark Shuttleworth, Ubuntu top dog, weighs in on the bug:
Please feel free to make constructive suggestions as to how we can meet Mozilla’s requirements while improving the user experience. It’s not constructive to say “WTF?”, nor is it constructive to rant and rave in allcaps. Your software freedoms are built on legal grounds, as are Mozilla’s rights in the Firefox trademark. To act as though your rights are being infringed misses the point of free software by a mile.
This is a bit surprising, and a bit disappointing. Both the decision itself, and Mark’s take on it, are quite wrong. One of the most important benefits of free software is the legal agreement you work in. You don’t have to agree to some long contract every time you need to do something new on your system, or sometimes even when you get a “critical update” to something you’re already doing. You don’t have to read pages of legalese, or go through some long process with your company’s legal department, or just click the “make it go away” button with this vague unease that you’ve just signed your first-born child away to the Devil. Most importantly, you feel like you actually own your computer when you run free software on it. When you enter a situation where you always have to ask permission to do things, and have to be constantly reminded of the rules, you don’t feel comfortable. Clearly, the thing in front of you is not yours, whatever your credit card bill might say; if it were, there wouldn’t be all this stress over you doing something the real owners don’t like. Free software returns your computer to you, by guaranteeing that you don’t have to enter into all these contracts before you can use it. Well, unless that “free” software is Firefox 3.0.2 or later, it seems. It’s “free” by a technical definition (you can strip the Firefox trademark rather easily, and get rid of the EULA as well). But when users fire up Ubuntu, and decide to do some browsing, and get confronted with pages of legal garbage and ALL CAPS, they will ask: “What’s so different about this open source stuff? I thought I was getting rid of all this legal crap.” And, suddenly, they’re slogging through the same drudgery they had to endure with every Windows service pack, and they wonder what they’ve gained. Perhaps there is a price we should be willing to pay to help Mozilla preserve their trademarks, but this price is too great. Mozilla should never have asked this of us, and Ubuntu should never have decided, on our behalf, that this price was acceptable. Debian has already turned its back on Firefox, and I have yet to have a problem with Iceweasel (the branding Debian chose for its Firefox-alike) that was caused by the branding change. But I’m tempted to bring it back, in Debian’s “non-free” software repository. Perhaps we could provide Firefox, complete with nasty EULA, but launch Iceweasel instead of Firefox if the user clicks “No”. There are probably all kinds of reasons why this is a bad idea, but I’m still drawn to the idea of illustrating how silly and useless click-through EULAs are. But it would be much more productive for Mozilla to back down, and not ask us to sacrifice such a large part of our identity on the altar of their sacred mark. UPDATE: First, I notice I was remiss in not giving a hat tip to Slashdot. Second, Mark has posted another comment on the bug. I encourage people to read the whole comment, but here’s a telling part:
For example, at the moment, we’re in detailed negotiations with a
company that makes a lot of popular hardware to release their drivers as
free software - they are currently proprietary. It would not be possible
to hold those negotiations if every step of the way turned into a public
discussion. And yet, engaging with that company both to make sure Ubuntu
works with its hardware and also to move them towards open source
drivers would seem to be precisely in keeping with our community values. In this case, we have been holding extensive, sensitive and complex
conversations with Mozilla. We strongly want to support their brand
(don’t forget this is one of the few companies that has successfully
taken free software to the dragons lair) and come to a reasonable
agreement. We want to do that in a way which is aligned with Ubuntu’s
values, and we have senior representatives of the project participating
in the dialogue and examining options for the implementation of those
agreements. Me. Matt Zimmerman. Colin Watson. Those people have earned
our trust.
On the one hand, yes, I believe that the Canonical people have earned our trust, and I do appreciate the utility of quiet persuasion with a proprietary software company that doesn’t understand our community. On the other hand, I had been under the impression that Mozilla was not a proprietary software company, and didn’t need persuasion and secret negotiations to see our point of view. Is Mozilla still a free software company, or not? UPDATE 2: Cautious optimism is appropriate, I think. Mitchell Baker, Mozilla chair:
We (meaning Mozilla) have shot ourselves in the foot here given the old, wrong content. So I hope we can have a discussion on this point, but I doubt we ll have a good one until we fix the other problems.
The actual changes aren’t available yet, and I wonder how much of this had been communicated to Canonical beforehand. Still, it’s a good sign.

Russell Coker: Software has No Intrinsic Value

In a comment on my Not All Opinions Are Equal [1] post AlphaG said “Anonymous comments = free software, no intrinsic value as you got it for nothing”. After considering the matter I came to the conclusion that almost all software has no intrinsic value (unless you count not being sued for copyright infringement as intrinsic value). When you buy software you generally don’t get a physical item (maybe a CD or DVD), to increase profit margins manuals aren’t printed for most software (it used to be that hefty manuals were shipped to give an impression that you were buying a physical object). Software usually can’t be resold (both due to EULA provisions and sites such as EBay not wanting to accept software for sale) and recently MS has introduced technical measures that prevent even using it on a different computer (which force legitimate customers to purchase more copies of Windows when they buy new hardware but doesn’t stop pirates from using it without paying). Even when software could be legally resold there were always new versions coming out which reduced the sale price to almost zero in a small amount of time. The difference between free software and proprietary software in terms of value is that when you pay for free software you are paying for support. This therefore compels the vendor to provide good support that is worth the money. Vendors of proprietary software have no incentive to provide good support - at least not unless they are getting paid a significant amount of money on top of the license fees. This is why Red Hat keeps winning in the CIO Vendor Value Studies from CIO Insight [2]. Providing value is essential to the revenue of Red Hat, they need to provide enough value in RHEL support that customers will forgo the opportunity to use CentOS for free. Thinking of software as having intrinsic value leads to the error of thinking of software purchases as investments. Software is usually outdated in a few years, as is the hardware that is used to run it. Money spent on software and hardware should be considered as being a tax on doing business. This doesn’t mean that purchases should be reduced to the absolute minimum (if systems run slowly they directly decrease productivity and also cause a loss of morale). But it does mean that hardware purchases should not be considered as investments - the hardware will at best be on sale cheap at an auction site in 3-5 years, and purchases of proprietary software are nothing but a tax.

Martin F. Krafft: 35 years ago

Today, 35 years ago was a dark day for the human age. I mourn the deaths of 4 innocent children as a result of the 16th Street Baptist Church bombing.

Next.

Previous.