Search Results: "ag"

3 December 2008

Runa Sandvik: Mischief managed

I now have virtualbox running with windows xp, service pack 3 and windows live messenger with a working webcam. Also, itunes is happily chewing away on my ipod.

Uwe Hermann: Playing Starcraft on Linux using Wine

Wine logo Here's a quick HOWTO for using Wine to play Starcraft on a Linux machine.
  $ apt-get install wine (as root)
  $ winecfg
The winecfg (graphical) utility will setup some config file defaults in your ~/.wine directory. Click on Graphics and activate Allow DirectX apps to stop the mouse leaving their window. Also, click on Audio (a dialog will pop up, just click OK). This will autodect your soundcard and setup Wine to use it. Under Drives click Add (this will add D:) and change the path to /media/cdrom, so that Wine knows about your CD-ROM drive. Finally click OK to close winecfg and save the settings. winecfg screenshot The next step is to insert the Starcraft CD-ROM into the drive and start the installer using Wine:
  $ mount /media/cdrom (as root)
  $ wine /media/cdrom/setup.exe
Follow the instructions in the installer until the Starcraft install is finished (you'll need your CD key number), then exit the installer (don't start playing Starcraft right away). The next step is to get the latest patch and get rid of the need to insert the CD-ROM every time.
  $ wget http://ftp.blizzard.com/pub/starcraft/patches/PC/SC-116.exe
  $ wine SC-116.exe
After the patch is installed click OK and Starcraft will be started (very annoying). Leave the game again. We'll get rid of the CD-ROM requirement now:
  $ cp /media/cdrom/install.exe ~/.wine/drive_c/Programme/Starcraft/StarCraft.mpq
That's a pretty big file, it may take a while. You might have to change "Programme" in the path (I have the German Starcraft version). That's it. You can now play Starcraft (without needing the CD-ROM) using:
  $ wine ~/.wine/drive_c/Programme/Starcraft/StarCraft.exe
A good thing is, it even works nice and fast with the open-source nv NVIDIA driver (no need to install the proprietary driver). I noticed one very annoying "bug" with the mouse behaviour at first. The mouse would sometimes just get stuck during the game (which is a total disaster of course, if you're in the middle of a fast-paced game). Left-clicking somewhere would "unstuck" the mouse, but it's still very bad. After many, many hours of reading bugreports and trying various patches I finally found out the root cause for the problem. It's somehow related to my window manager (IceWM); whenever you move the mouse to the bottom of the Starcraft screen (where the IceWM status bar is, even though it's not on top or even visible, and even though Wine/Starcraft runs in full-screen mode!), something funny happens with X11/IceWM and the mouse gets stuck. I haven't yet found out if/which IceWM option could fix this behavior, but I have a small work-around. Just start Wine directly on a second X11 server with Starcraft (without any window manager being involved):
  $ xinit -e '/usr/bin/wine ~/.wine/drive_c/Programme/Starcraft/StarCraft.exe' -- :1
No patches needed (stock Wine from Debian unstable works fine, that's version 1.0.1 right now). I hope this saves other people some debugging time...

Jose Carlos Garcia Sogo: Fanatics did it again

Once again, a person died today murdered by terrorists in Spain. He was a businessman, who had a construction company in his town (Azpeitia) at Basque Country region. Close his house, he was murdered by gunshots. Just because his company was a contractor in the construction of AVE infraestructure in Basque Country, which will connect it with Madrid and France. Once again, a family has been hit forever. I was going to include a black strip with the article, but it’s better to see an image.

Neil McGovern: Meme time again...

I'm going to FOSDEM, the Free and Open Source Software Developers' European Meeting This should act as a reminder to anyone who gets accomodation with the Debian UK lot that I need to know by the 14th if you want somewhere to stay. Wiki page is advertised in the usual places, or catch me on IRC if you've forgotton!

Michal Čihař: Semantic phpmyadmin.net

Today I published set of changes to phpMyAdmin website, which add microformats attributes where applicable. Currently hCard and hAtom were added. The first one enables you to grab contacts directly from web page (if your browser supports it, currently you need some extension such as Operator). I also added some rel attributes to links, so application browsing the website can know relevance of some links.

Ingo Juergensmann: SuperGarv strikes again!

Today it made clear to me why Garvin Hicking is called "SuperGarv". I've had a little problem with my s9y installation and asked Garvin by mail, because I know him since good old Grafik.Ger times in FidoNet.
The problem has been described in #502954 as well: you can create directories in the Media Manager, but you can't see or use them afterwards, although they are there in the filesystem.

Usually, one could have solved this by yourself, but it seemed more apparent that the application is buggy. Garvin, instead, got the idea pretty soon:

Hast du vielleicht nur Schreib- aber keine Leserechte f r die Verzeichnisse?
Translation: "Do you have just write but no read permissions for those directories?


It's in fact somewhat unusual that you can create directories, but cannot use them afterwards. Especially when you see them on disk, you are likely to suspect a problem in the application itself, not on the disk.
But Garvin was right:


#ls -l /usr/share/serendipity/www/
...
lrwxrwxrwx 1 root root 28 2008-12-02 09:18 uploads -> /var/lib/serendipity/uploads
...

# ls -l /var/lib/serendipity/
total 4
drwx-wxr-x 2 root www-data 6 2006-10-18 16:10 archives
-rw-rw---- 1 root www-data 0 2008-12-02 09:19 htaccess
drwx-wxr-x 13 root www-data 4096 2008-12-02 07:48 uploads
root@vserv1:/usr/local/drupal6/modules# chmod g+r /var/lib/serendipity/uploads/


I've checked with Adrian von Bidder (#502954 submitter) on IRC and this seems to be a bug in the Debian package indeed.

So, thanks to Garvin for the hinting and Adrian for the bugreport and checking on IRC! :-)

2 December 2008

Jeff Bailey: Distracted from moving by our government

A brief distraction from moving - I find it fascinating that people should vaguely think that a coalition appealing to the Governor General is undemocratic. As far as I can tell, this comes from watching too much American TV. As Canadians, we don't elect the government or the PM. We elect MPs to fill seats, and the GG chooses the government based on the available people who can form the most stable government.

This bit is important! The MP you voted for is *still* your MP. Now the people elected to run the country have to try and figure which group represents the best chance of running smooth government. For those of us not around to remember the last time this happened (1926, Lord Bynd as GG), it's perfectly reasonable for the GG to ask the opposition to try and form a working government.

By some measure, this is extraordinary, but I think of going for another election 7 weeks after the previous one to be the equivalent of seeking marriage counseling 7 weeks after starting dating someone. As in, it's perfectly okay to write it off and try the other available options.

Time to get some sleep for our first night in the new appartment. =)

Theodore Ts'o: Is the Linux community watching a setting Sun?

The title of this post was a headline that was probably written by an overly sensationalistic editor at http://www.searchenterpriselinux.com. The actual article, though, was written by Pam Derringer, was a pretty balanced piece (although it obviously could have been more in-depth; given length and time constraints, she talked to as many people as I think could have been expected, including a Sun spokeswoman, two analysts from different analyst companies, the chair of Apache Software Foundation, a Sun customer, and so on). I’m not sure I’d agree with Jim Jagielski when he claims that Sun has the “best and brightest business people in the world,” though. As I said in the article, and as I’ve said before, I have nothing but the highest respect for many of Sun’s engineers, especially those who work on Solaris. But their business people? I’m not so sure they have the best and brightest… in fact, I think that’s one of Sun’s greatest problems right now. Compare that with the job that Mark Hurd has done with HP, or with the work done by the executives at my employer (IBM), and I’m not so sure a strong case can be made for the excellence of Sun’s business folk. (I mean, how many people still believe that the $2 billion dollars which Sun spent to acquire Cobalt Networks, or the $4 billion dollars which Sun spent to acquire StorageTek, or the $1 billion dollars which Sun spent MySQL, were all good ideas? Sun is currently valued by the market at $2.4 billion dollars!) My bigger concern at the moment, however, is what happens if Sun gets purchased by a rival or by a corporate raider and gets broken up for parts? Since November 19th, when Sun’s stock price crashed through $3.27 (and has hit a low of $2.60 recently), it has been trading for less than its per-stock cash value. I say that not out of a sense of Schadenfreude, but out of concern about what happens if someone decides to buy the company, lay everyone off, and even after paying all of its debts, the resulting cash left over would be more than cost of completely buying the company — all of the real estate, the inventory, and the patent portfolio would all be pure profit. It’s the last I’m most concerned about; Sun has a very large patent portfolio! What if it fell into the hands of a patent troll? What damage could be done to not just Linux and the OSS comunity, but the software industry as a whole? Suppose Sun really does have patents that read upon many of NetApp’s products? If those patents fall into the hands of a patent troll, NetApp would no longer be able to negotiate a peace settlement based on its patents (if they survive the on-going patent re-examination process) that read on ZFS, since the patent troll would no longer be making any products based on ZFS. Maybe somewhere in Sun’s patent portfolio, there are patents that read on the GNOME and KDE desktops, but since Sun is trying to ship those with its Project Indiana/Open Solaris dekstop, it’s not bothering to assert them at this time? What if a patent troll, perhaps one funded by Microsoft, gets their hands on those patents? One final scary thought. Sun’s current market cap: $2.40 billion USD. Sun’s cash on hand: $2.63 billion USD. Microsoft’s current cash on hand: $19.71 billion USD. I can just imagine Steve Ballmer saying, “Chris, take it out of petty cash. I have an itsy-bitsy little acquistion I want to make…. Now I can embrace and extend Java all I want! And you know those term-limited, non-Open Source TCK licenses Sun gave to OpenJDK developers — not any more! They’re gone, within a year, the next time Red Hat needs to get the license renewed!” Could it happen? What do you think?

Dirk Eddelbuettel: Rcpp 0.6.2

Hot on the heels of the announcement for Rcpp I just made, version 0.6.2 follows with a small but important fix for the default linker flag output by the helper function Rcpp:::RcppLdFlags(). I also added a download section to the Rcpp page here where you can find the new version. CRAN should start propagating it by tomorrow.

Dirk Eddelbuettel: Rcpp relaunched with versions 0.6.0 and 0.6.1

I just announced Rcpp 0.6.0 and 0.6.1 on the low-volume R-packages list. Rcpp provides C++ classes that greatly facilitate interfacing C or C++ code in R packages using the .Call() interface provided by R. Rcpp provides matching C++ classes for a large number of basic R data types. Hence, a package author can keep his data in normal R data structure without having to worry about translation or transfer to C++. At the same time, the data structures can be accessed as easily at the C++ level, and used in the normal manner. The mapping of data types works in both directions. It is as straightforward to pass data from R to C++, as it is it return data from C++ to R. Rcpp was initially written by Dominick Samperi to in the context of the RQuantLib package and later released on its own, but had not seen any releases in twenty-four months. I have substantially expanded the documentation, simplified the build structure yet made it easier to use Rcpp from other packages, and started to add some new classes (notably microsecond time types). Rcpp is supported on Windows, Linux and Mac OS X (with special thanks to Simon for some extended help). More information for Rcpp can be found at the package homepage, the R-forge repository or the package CRAN page.

Miriam Ruiz: Collaborative maintenance of games between developers of different Linux and BSD systems

Games are probably the kind of software that needs more patching and maintenance. In some cases we even have to effectively act as upstreams ourselves. Currently every distro is doing that on their own, and we end up making n times similar patches to provide the same functionality (put files in the proper places, endianess and word size stuff, building with newer versions of gcc or free toolchains, etc). It makes a lot of sense to share among us all that stuff. Some of us, developers of different Linux distributions and BSD operative systems have started working together to reduce duplicated work, creating a distribution-agnostic mailing list in freedesktop servers as a first step. Debian Project News talks about this too. You can read more about our goals here. Wish us luck in this new quest, and join us if you’re interested too :)

David Moreno Garza: DirectoryIndex and the perl-script handler

Wouter Verhelst blogs about combining ScriptAlias (or a way to run CGIs) and DirectoryIndex in Apache. Recently, developing a TinyURL clone I had a similar (not identical, though) issue. Basically, I set SetHandler to perl-script on the “/” location, which basically means, everything accessed on a given virtual host, is affected. Because you are changing the handler for the entire location, DirectoryIndex will have no effect on it because mod_dir is the one dealing with the DirectoryIndex function, that is, using the DIR_MAGIC_TYPE handler. To fix this you can use a mod_perl (2, I never really used 1) Fixup phase handler:
<VirtualHost *:80>
	...
	# some stuff
	...
	# PerlSections rule.
	<Perl>
	$Location "/"  =  
		SetHandler => 'perl-script',
		# some stuff
		PerlFixupHandler => 'Axiombox::Awbox::Fixup',
		# some other stuff
		DirectoryIndex => 'whatever.html',
	 ;
	</Perl>
</VirtualHost>
If it looks incomplete is because some other information, out of the scope of this sample, like DocumentRoot or other mod_perl directives, are hidden as the “other stuff”. My Fixup.pm handler looks like this:
package Axiombox::Awbox::Fixup;
use strict;
use warnings FATAL => qw(all);
use Apache2::Const -compile => qw(DIR_MAGIC_TYPE OK DECLINED);
use Apache2::RequestRec;
sub handler  
	my $r = shift;
	if ($r->handler eq 'perl-script' &&
		-d $r->filename              &&
		$r->is_initial_req)
	 
		$r->handler(Apache2::Const::DIR_MAGIC_TYPE);
		return Apache2::Const::OK;
	 
	return Apache2::Const::DECLINED;
 
1;
Which is very straight-forward: If the request is set to perl-script, the requested file is a directory and if the current request is the main one, then change the handler and return to the normal flow of phases. Otherwise, decline the Fixup phase handler.

Aigars Mahinovs: iPhone review from a free software guy

I got an iPhone on the very first day it was available officially in my country. I have used it every day since then and am now ready to decide how good it really is. Summary: it is a great piece of technology and the only tradeback is the locked down platform. I have abandoned my Palm and am not looking back. Hardware: the hardware is just perfect. 4 buttons (Home, Power, Volume Up and Down) and 1 switch (Mute) are all very clear, easy to find and press and frankly are enough. The touchscreen is reasonably fast and very precise nicely corrected by software that guides your presses toward UI points of interest if such are within your finger. The casing is absolutely solid - there is no gaps, no wobble, nothing. All glossy surfaces attract fingerprints, but a couple passes with a microfiber cloth (included) clean it up easily. The loudspeaker is phenomenal - all sound comes from a single small hole, but it can easily fill a small room with music. Call sound quality is impeccable. You can plug in any headphones, but if you use the included headphones you get a microphone with a button that can pickup and hand up calls, start/pause music and skip to the next track. I also love that the only charger included is a very small power brick that provides a power-only USB port and a USB charging cable. That is a good way to reduce number of power bricks for gadgets. The iPhone 3G (that is what I have) also has a GPS build-in, but let us be clear - it is not good enough to replace a car GPS, the iPhone GPS is slow (takes several seconds to refresh the location and tens of seconds to find it first time) and the precision is measured in meters or even tens of meters. The WiFi is very good at getting a connection and doing it very fast. Oh and there is an acceptable camera. Out of the box software: the software included surely is better than on any other phone I have seen (including Palm). The UI widgets are nicely written specially for a touchscreen interface - the best example is having click wheels instead of drop down menus. It is much easier mentally to flick a wheel up or down then to click on a list, click to scroll the list and then click to select an entry. And the click wheel makes it much easier to correct off-by-one errors. Switches that look like regular physical switches instead of checkboxes is another very useful UI concept. I think a lot of this can be reused on the desktop as well. iTunes: and here comes the bad spot, the lock-in part. To get anywhere with the iPhone you need to associate it with an installation of iTunes. It fails to work in Wine or even in a virtual machine - apparently there are some errors related to avahi or something. Unfortunately, this means that you need wither Windows or MacOS to do nything with your iPhone. iTunes is the only way to backup, restore and upgrade your iPhone, it is the only way to get contacts and music on the iPhone (there is an iTunes Store app in the newest version that allows purchasing music over the air). Even after doing a jailbreak (see further) it is currently not possible to add music to the iPhone from any third party applications, because the iTunes database has a hashed checksum that the build-in iPhone music player (and iTunes) check before doing anything. If the checksum is wrong the only thing you can do is a full restore of the phone from backup. Crypto geeks - please help decrypt that hash, so that we can sync iPhones to amaroK. The iTunes itself is a bit weird - to get music onto the phone you need to create a playlist and then you can sync that playlist over. One of the playlist options is a smart playlist with a random feature and a limit on number of matches. That is the way to get random music from your collection onto the phone. I do dislike the fact that iTunes syncs all the contacts from Google to the phone and not only contacts for a certain group or only those that have a phone number, for example. Search and favorites do help here. Third party software (iTunes Store): it is very easy to install new software on the phone over the WiFi and there is plenty to choose from. You do need a Mac to develop this software which restricts the developer base a bit. The main bases that I needed (or did not know I needed) are covered: Last.fm player, TwitterFon, LockBox password storage, Stanza ebook reader, Shazam music identificator, Wordpress client, BigOven cookbook and lots of fun games. Have not used any paid-for apps due to the fact that iTunes store is not available in Latvia and the official documentation recommends registering with a fake address in UK or US. :) Most of the software is rather stable and useful, but there is also a lot of fluff. User reviews and ratings help a lot, can we have those for Debian packages? Jailbreak and third party software (Cydia): thanks to some anonymous hackers, we have the ability to break the software jail on the iPhone and install software that Apple did not approve. The process is made very simple, but again it does require you to boot into Windows or MacOS X. The main thing the jailbreak process does is install an installer on the phone. Currently the best one is Cydia which is built on top of … apt-get and dpkg! After that is done, you can install a terminal, a ssh server and BossPrefs advanced preferences. There are also other interesting programs there - a different dock, file manager, caching youtube player, quake, themed app launcher with categories and startup page (winterboard). Theoretically the ssh server allows you to manage your music over WiFi from any platform, but unfortunately until the iTuned database hash algorithm is decoded, we can only copy music from the phone to the PC and not back. It is possible to copy files over using ssh and then play them using third-party players, but those players are very crude and featureless. To summarize: an iPhone is a great phone and a decent application platform. To make using an iPhone with Linux easier we need to make iTunes run in Wine (and allow it to see the iPhone) and reverse engineer the iTunes database hashing algorithm so that we can get music on our phones with Linux tools. I also wish there was a way to develop iPhone apps in Linux, but that really is reaching for the stars.

Michal &#268;iha&#345;: Gammu test version 1.21.93

After few weeks of debugging build system, new Gammu version is out. This time most fixes are in build system area, especially now it is possible to compile Gammu using Borland C++ 5.5. Also my hacks for crosscompilation to Windows on Linux have been dropped in favour of crosscompilation features in CMake 2.6. Full list of changes: You can download from usual place: http://cihar.com/gammu/, Debian users will find packages in experimental soon.

Gustavo Noronha Silva: So, the long-awaited release of gksu-polkit is here

I’m looking for people who are interested in testing the first release of gksu-polkit. I uploaded the first tarball to http://people.debian.org/~kov/gksu/gksu-polkit-0.0.1.tar.gz. There are also x86 packages available (built on a sid with a lot of experimental stuff, so if you have trouble installing please email me and I’ll have that fixed =P). For some history and discussion on the whys and hows do take a look at the README which exists inside the tarball (or git repo), and on the small page I wrote about it. For those who want to fiddle with the code, and perhaps help me finding bugs and fixing them, here’s my public git tree: git://git.debian.org/~kov/gksu-polkit.git

MJ Ray: Bristol Alternative Christmas Quiz

I’m working away from the office today because the office window is being replaced (an end to leaky draughty windows - yay! - but it does mean it’s about 3 degrees in there while it’s happening). For some reason, some things aren’t working over the wifi (the least of my network problems recently - blew up the router at the weekend), so I’m working in batches. I’ll let the phone go to voicemail and reply from a fixed line when I can. Pics and stuff about yesterday’s trade fair will appear later. I usually shy away from stuff labelled “geek” but here’s Bristol Wireless’s Christmas-time geek quiz night fundraiser on the 19th. D’ya reckon Woodsy will wear that bow-tie again when running the quiz?

1 December 2008

Russell Coker: Gmail and Anti-Spam

I have just received an email with a question about SE Linux that was re-sent due to the first attempt being blocked by my anti-spam measures. I use the rfc-ignorant.org DNSBL services to stop some of the spam that is sent to me. The purpose of rfc-ignorant.org is to list systems that are run by people who don’t know how to set up mail servers correctly. But the majority of mail that is blocked when using them comes from large servers owned by companies large enough that they almost certainly employ people who know the RFCs (and who could for a trivial fraction of their budget hire such people). So it seems more about deliberately violating the standards than ignorance. The person who sent me the email in question said “hopefully, Google knows how to make their MTA compliant with RFC 2142“, such hope is misplaced as a search for gmail.com in the rfc-ignorant.org database shows that it is listed for not having a valid postmaster address [1]. A quick test revealed that two of the Gmail SMTP servers support the postmaster account (or at least it doesn’t give an error response to the RCPT TO command that is referenced in the complaint). However Gmail administrators have not responded to the auto-removal requests, which suggests that postmaster@gmail.com is a /dev/null address. However that is not a reason to avoid using Gmail. Some time ago Gmail took over the role of “mail server of last resort” from Hotmail. If you have trouble sending email to someone then using a free Gmail account seems to be the standard second option. Because so many people use Gmail and such a quantity of important mail is sent through that service (in my case mail from clients and prospective clients) it is not feasible to block Gmail. I have whitelisted Gmail for the rfc-ignorant.org tests and if Gmail starts failing other tests then I will consider additional white-lists for them. Gmail essentially has a monopoly of a segment of the market (that of free webmail systems). They don’t have 100%, but they have enough market share that it’s possible to ignore their competitors (in my experience). When configuring mail servers for clients I make sure that whatever anti-spam measures they request don’t block Gmail. As a rule of thumb, when running a corporate mail server you have to set up anti-spam measures to not block the main ISPs in the country (this means not blocking Optus or Telstra BigPond for Australian companies) and not block Gmail. Not blocking Yahoo (for “Yahoo Groups”) is also a good thing, but I have had a client specifically request that I block Yahoo Groups in the past - so obviously there is a range of opinions about the value of Yahoo. Someone contacted Biella regarding an email that they couldn’t send to me [2]. I have sent an email to Biella’s Gmail account from my Gmail account - that should avoid all possibility of blocking. If the person who contacted Biella also has a Gmail account then they can use that to send me email to my Gmail account (in the event that my own mail server rejects it - I have not whitelisted Gmail for all my anti-spam measures and it is quite possible for SpamAssassin to block mail from Gmail). It turns out that the person in question used an account on Verizon’s server, according to rfc-ignorant.org Verizon have an unusually broken mail server [3]. If your ISP is Optus, BigPond, Verizon, or something similarly broken and you want to send mail to people in other countries (where your ISP is just another annoyance on the net and not a significant entity that gets special treatment) then I suggest that you consider using Gmail. If nothing else then your Gmail account will still work even after your sub-standard ISP “teaches you a lesson” [4].

Matthew Garrett: Thintel

ICH8 docs, section 5.13.5.1:

To eliminate the audible noise caused by aggressive voltage ramps when exiting C4 states at a regular, periodic frequency, the ICH8 supports a method to slow down the
voltage ramp at the processor VR for certain break events.


Sounds good. Section 9.8.1.6:

C4_TIMING_CNT: Bit 6 Slow-C4 Exit Enable When 1, this bit enables the Slow-C4 Exit functionality.

Well, hey, we can quirk this on and make life better for everyone oh wait section 9.8.1.4:

Bit 0 C-STATE_CONFIG_LOCK: When set to 1, this bit locks down the C-State configuration parameters. The following configuration bits become read-only when this bit is set:
...
The entire C4 Timing Control Register (C4_TIMING_CNT)


Thanks, Intel. Thintel.

Michael Prokop: Schluchtenscheisser!

grml release delayed through a CBS commedy series. News at 11<Rhonda /> There we go: there’s a new grml release (you know, the Debian based Linux Live-CD for sysadmins and texttool users). The release with codename Schluchtenscheisser and version number 2008.11 is available in different variants. The 32bit versions grml, grml-medium and grml-small as well as grml64, grml64-medium and (new!) grml64-small are available through grml.org/download/. For details regarding the changes in the new release check out the release announcements. Happy grml-ing, dear Schluchtenscheissers - and to the rest of the world. 8-)

Aigars Mahinovs: Copyright infringement is like walking into a concert without a ticket

In light of Ted’s post on copyright, it is clear that we are bogged down by a hostile terminology. Copyright infringement is not piracy - gunmen on seas killing people, looting ships and holding hostages is piracy. Copyright infringement is not theft. When my bike was stolen, I no longer had it. Stealing a bicycle is theft. Copyright infringement is more like sneaking into a concert. You enjoy the show, but did not pay for it. If the concert is held in a small venue then it is easy to spot someone who gets in without paying, but if you hold a concert in an open field, then expecting everyone in the surrounding area to be forced to pay you is rather absurd. If you have a concert in a field with a fence around it and someone makes a hole in that fence (posts a a recording to a P2P site), then the one making the hole might be punishable (property damage), but can any person that enters that hole really be prosecuted for theft, property damage and enabling further theft by not closing the hole (uploading that is inherent in the P2P protocols) ? I do not think so. A similar analogy is using public transport without a ticket. If there is a bus that goes from A to B and I get on it without buying a ticket from the driver, then in the current copyright enforcement world I would get arrested by the police, prosecuted and get a fine that is tens of thousand times more than the price of the ticket. This has multiple problems - 1. the police has no way of knowing if I have some kind of legal right to use the bus without a ticket (monthly ticket, free ride for seniors, …) before arresting me and bringing me to court, the police has no business wasting their time and taxpayer money until it is 100% certain that a crime has actually occured; 2. if a hacker disables the ticket composters in the bus and removes all signs about prices how am I to know that the bus is not free (like the park and ride buses in many locations); 3. the fines are excessive - I’ve not seen a public transport fine that is much more then 10 times the price of the ticket, and it only applies to one ride - you can not be retroactivelly fined for all free rides you took in the last year; 4. it actually is not possible to be 100% certain who is the person doing the act - you can only trace the IP which can be used by any number of computers and additionally the computers might be infected with a botnet acting as an unwilling proxy zombie. There is no way (except a confession) to prove that a particular person does a particular download. Now we just need a short and simple word or phrase that describes that. Any ideas?

Next.

Previous.