# semanage login -l
Login Name SELinux User MLS/MCS Range
%test user_u s0
__default__ unconfined_u s0-s0:c0.c1023
root unconfined_u s0-s0:c0.c1023
system_u system_u s0-s0:c0.c1023
test staff_u s0-s0:c1
# semanage user -l
Labeling MLS/ MLS/
SELinux User Prefix MCS Level MCS Range SELinux Roles
root sysadm s0 s0-s0:c0.c1023 staff_r sysadm_r system_r
staff_u staff s0 s0-s0:c0.c1023 staff_r sysadm_r
sysadm_u sysadm s0 s0-s0:c0.c1023 sysadm_r
system_u user s0 s0-s0:c0.c1023 system_r
unconfined_u unconfined s0 s0-s0:c0.c1023 system_r unconfined_r
user_u user s0 s0 user_r
I hope to get the policy written to support multiple user roles in time for the release of Squeeze. If I don t make it then I will put such a policy on my own web site and try to get it included in an update. The policy currently basically works for a Targeted configuration where the users are not confined (apart from MCS).
How MMCS Basically Works
The vast majority of SE Linux users run with the MCS policy rather than the MLS policy. For Debian I have written a modified version of MCS that I call MMCS. MMCS is mandatory (you can t relabel files to escape it) and it prevents write-down.
If a process has the range s0-s0:c1,c3 then it has full access to files labelled as s0, s0:c1, s0:c3, and s0:c1,c3 and any files it creates will be labeled as s0.
If a process has the range s0:c1-s0:c1,c3 then it has read-only access to files labelled as s0 and s0:c3 and read-write access to files labelled as s0:c1 and s0:c1,c3. This means that any secret data it accesses that was labelled with category c1 can t be leaked down to a file that is not labelled with that category.
Now MCS currently has no network access controls, so there s nothing stopping a user from using scp or other network utilities to transfer files. But that s the way with most usable systems. I don t think that this is necessarily a problem, the almost total lack of network access controls in a traditional Unix model doesn t seem to concern most people.
Now to REALLY Answer that Question
SE Linux is a Mandatory Access Control (MAC) system, this makes it inherently different to a Discretionary Access Control (DAC) system such as traditional Unix access controls.
Unix permissions are based on each file having a UID, a GID, and a set of permissions and each process having a UID, a GID, and a set of supplementary GIDs. If a user runs a setuid or setgid program then the process will have extra privileges. It also has a lot of stuff that most people aren t aware of such as real vs effective UIDs, the tag bit, setgid directories, and lots more including some quite arbitrary things like making ports <1024 special.
SE Linux is based on every object (process, file, socket, etc) having a single security label which includes an identity, a role, a type, and a sensitivity label (MCS categories or an MLS range). There is no support for an object to have more than one label. The SE Linux equivalent to setuid/setgid files is a label for a file which triggers a domain transition when it s executed. This differs from setuid files in that the domain transition is complete (the old privileges can t be restored) and the transition is generally not to a strict super-set of the access (usually a different sub-set of possible access and sometimes to lesser access).
These differences are quite fundamental. So really SE Linux can t implement traditional Unix access control. What SE Linux is designed to do is to provide a second layer of defense and to also provide access controls that have different aims than that of Unix permissions such as being mandatory and implementing features such as MLS.
The Eurovision Song Contest has been and gone with a better-than-usual winner and much of the snarkiness was on microblog sites like identi.ca this year. Search for #ESC, #eurovision or incomprehensibly-to-me #eurovison (no second i is it spelt like that in some language, or can thousands not spell?). Anyway, enough of the title, on with the message
I ve been irritated by my linphone SIP internet phone (Skype without lock-in, with standards) taking up my screen space for a while. I ve been meaning to upgrade to one of the recent versions that includes the linphonecsh shell and write some client that only displays windows when it s needed, but I ve been writing programs for work so much that I ve not even found time to write blog posts recently, much less fun code, so that s not happened.
So I m quite happy to find linphone.el for my GNU Emacs text editor and find it mostly works. I changed one line at the end to (define-key global-map [menu-bar tools linphone] '("Linphone" . linphone)) to put it on the tools menu, but other than that, it just worked. Well, the Mute doesn t, but that s probably my phone headset being a different ALSA device. I don t care: I use the hardware mute button.
In previous times, I would have added the link to the venerable EmacsWiki too, but it has the evil bad wrong Google reCaptcha on the edit page to stop disabled users, so screw it. Google s reCaptcha seems to be spreading again, obstructing more people when accessing more websites. Is there a reason for that? The re in reCaptcha stands for replace with real anti-spam, please!
Anyway, now I m controlling phone calls from Emacs. Whatever next? Voice recognition, M-x doctor and a speech synth?
This should solve the yurt's bed problem. Over the past two years I've
learned there are really two: It's not a fully dry environment so anything left
on the floor will mildew; and the yurt makes no pretense of having a level
floor. Thus this custom bed with independently levelable legs, custom sized to
hold together a multipart matress. In keeping with the yurt thing, it's
disassemblable and portable, but not too easily. :)
Couldn't have been done without Mark's
skilled ripping of the plywood. Anna
cut the smaller boards and assisted, and we were very happy with what
we managed to accomplish in a few hours. It's sturdy, and even level.
Two years ago, while working on awesome, I joined the Freedesktop initiative to work on XCB. I had to learn the arcane of the X11 protocol and all the mysterious and old world that goes with it. Now that I've swum all this months in this mud, I just feel like I need to share my thoughts about what become a mess over the decades. When I was unborn
the Toto band were releasing their song "Africa" and some smart guys were working on a windowing system: the X Window System (this is its full name) which therefore has a (too) long history. The latest version of its protocol, the 11th one, has been designed in the 80's. You can learn more about the history in the Wikipedia article about X. In 2010, we still listen disco music and we still use various protocols designed in the 80's and even before X. Music have evolved, protocols have evolved, and so did X11. The problem is that X11 did not evolve that well. The guys at MIT-and-some other-places-with-very-smart-people-in-it created X version 1 in 1984, and updated it until X version 11 (the one we're still using) in 1987. Eleven version in 3 years, that was following the "release early, release often" model. But I don't know why, it just stopped to happen for the last 23 years1. I don't know what changes have been made in the first 11 major versions of the X protocol, but I'm rather sure we should have deserve a couple of major version updates this last 2 decades. In my humble opinion, X11 was not designed to live 23 years. But hey, I'm not blaming anyone here: I was 4 years old and playing Lego when they released this latest version of the X protocol, so there is little chance I'd have done something better.
1. That's not totally true: they added (and then deprecated) many extensions. We won't fix. We'll work-around.
That is probably one of the guideline of the X protocol for the last years. And don't misread me: I'm not bashing anyone thereafter. Since the X11 protocol was aging, the X guys started to add extensions. They added tons of them over the years. This, in application of one of the early principles of X:
All of them with no exception were added because, bad luck, the X11 protocol did not anticipated the things that happened in the last 23 years, like video, OpenGL, multiple monitors, or the pleasure to draw oval windows. Some of this extensions are still in use, while some of them have been dropped. While this is not a bad thing to extends the protocol, it seems like a bad thing to try to fix the protocol with for example the XFixes extension, even with all the good intentions Keith Packard might have in his greatness. Actually it's even worst than you thinkIt is as important to decide what a system is not as to decide what it is. Do not serve all the world's needs; rather, make the system extensible so that additional needs can be met in an upwardly compatible fashion.
The X11 protocol (without extensions) defines about 120 types of requests: create a window, move a window, etc. Nowadays, there's at least 25 % of them which are useless: usage of server-side font, or the drawing of squares and polygon, are unused by any modern application or toolkit. All of this is superseded by requests from extensions, like the XRender one. The handling of multiple monitors displays has totally been screwed up. X11 has been designed to work in Zaphod mode (independent monitors). But Xinerama, and nowadays XRandR have replaced it up: recent X servers (released after ~2007) does not support Zaphod mode anymore, even if it's a core piece of the X11 protocol. Worst: on many requests, there's limitation or design flaws, like described in this document: Why X Is Not Our Ideal Window System by DEC researchers. We'll add more broken standard on top of that
Following its early principle, X does not define policies but only mechanisms, which seems like a good thing, Consequently, people started writing specifications to determine a number of stuff and dogmas: ICCCM. That was 22 years ago in 1988. It's useless to add that many things in this specification are now obsolete, useless, or that it misses many modern stuff. I was not the only one to think that. The people from what will be the major desktop environments, KDE and GNOME, saw that too in the 90's while I was learning to count. So they wrote EWMH, another standard that comes on top of ICCCM and extends it with nifty features like maximization, full screen mode, etc. The problem is that this standard has also been written by narrow-minded people who at that time, were working on GNOME or KDE (and maybe others). This desktop environments were having and still have some strong concepts of how should work a desktop: "it should have work-spaces", "a window is only on one workspace", "we only see a workspace at a time", "you do not have multiple screens", etc. Dude, we don't care: we have toolkits!
This vision of how the desktop should work have now been written in marble in all applications and libraries implementing EWMH, like GTK+ or Qt. Nowadays, everybody forgot about all of this standards. Toolkits have implemented this, circumvented the X11 protocol limitation and flaws, and nobody wants to look back. Like all standards, obviously some people implemented them badly. This had some side effects, like OpenOffice acting like a pager. We don't look back? Worst, we forgot where we came from!
With all these layers of bad designed standards, the desktop continued to evolve for more than a decade. They continued to add more standard, the more recent ones being based on D-Bus like the Desktop Notification Specification or the latest Status Notifier Specification developed by KDE. The Status Notifier is a new implementation of the good old system tray based on XEmbed, using D-Bus instead of the X11 mechanisms, and adding the possibility to show the system tray with something else than icons. This specification draft saw an important issue and design flaw raised by Wolfgang Draxinger in this thread on the XDG mailing-list. What Wolfgang points out, is that X is network-oriented, and D-Bus is not. Therefore, making the Status Notifier specification to use D-Bus to pass system tray messages around is a bad idea, since running a X application from host A on host B will draw the system tray on the wrong host! Apparently, reading the thread, this does not fear some of the KDE people:
What Oswald describes as a corner case is an actual common use case for many of us. Of course, YMMV. From my point of view, this is a step back in the wrong direction. But we can conclude that the network part of X is now worthless, to at least KDE. I used to believe in XCBof course this is a bizarre corner case not worth much thought. at least that's what you'll think until you actually run into it yourself (be it because you are testing something or because you are setting up some weird kiosk environment).
When I joined Freedesktop, it was to work on XCB, the X C Binding. XCB is a nice, clean, 21st century technology based API to play with the X11 protocol. Its code is auto generated based on XML file describing the protocol. In comparison, Xlib is 80's obfuscated code with almost no comments and hard-coded things. Only a few people can understand some of its corner like its i18n or XKB implementations. And all its code is synchronous. For people not knowing it yet, X is a network protocol where you send request (like a GET in HTTP) and then get a response. Xlib forces the application to wait for the reply to its request, so the application is blocked until the X server sends the reply to the request. XCB on the other hand does not block and allows the application to send a batch of requests, do some other stuff in the mean time, and then gets the replies. It's like your Web browser would send one request at a time to a Web server, and would wait until you downloaded all the images one by one to display the page. In cases where X and all its clients are on the same host, the latency is small and not really visible, therefore the gain for XCB to be asynchronous is small. On slow network however, the gain can be huge, as proved in the rewrite of xlsclients with XCB by Peter Harris. One of the long standing goal of the XCB folks is to kick-out Xlib, to increase speed and hides latency in X11 applications. That requires to port many libraries, because almost none of them (Cairo being an exception) supports XCB. From where I stand, I don't really see if the work is worth it now. The desktop world is trusted by GNOME and KDE, meaning GTK+ and Qt. It seems none of this toolkits are interested to work on XCB, neither on the X protocol. They probably put hard effort in bypassing X limitation and flaws, and they now sit on top of crap of workarounds and broken-by-design-standard implementation. It seems to me they don't want to go back in the layers and improves things. They're too high to go back down and they don't see what the gain would be. Enlightenment with its EFL was the first toolkit to have an XCB back-end with the work of Vincent Torri. Unfortunately, the back-end is not maintained and nobody cares about it. Last time I tried it, it did not compile at all. X12 ?
There's a page called X12 on the Freedesktop wiki, listing all the things that should be fixed some days. Unfortunately, the list continues to grow up an no one talks about working on X12. On the other hand, there's a handset of people trying to work when they will have time on XKB2, the second version of the "let's-try-to-fix-up-the keyboard-part-of-the-protocol-we-wrote-23-years-ago-a-second-time" extension. To me, it does not seem X12 will happen in the next decade neither. Alternative ?
Do we got alternative to X ? There's Wayland, but it's far from being usable. There's DirectFB, but that's not very portable. None seems candidate to replace X some days to me. Anyhow, none of the main toolkits around support this alternative. GTK+ once supported DirectFB, but as far as I know, it is not supported nor works nowadays, as stated by Josselin Mouette. This is why recent versions of the Debian installer have migrated to X for the graphic part, thanks to Cyril Brulebois work. Conclusion
XCB has been around for more than half-a-decade, and very few people showed interested in it. As far as I can see, nobody is interested to use the X protocol and everybody tries to encapsulate it in some higher-level API as soon as possible to stop seeing it. This leads to poorly written application and toolkits, with a lot of ugly hack. All of that also means that starting to write applications and graphical toolkits based on XCB would be a very interesting project, but that would lead to spend too much time learning to circumvent the X protocol flaws, things that have been done in years by predecessors like Qt and GTK+. Major toolkits implementations have almost nothing to win in going back in the dark water of X. I guess most of their folks prefer to work on shiny 3D effects based on your GPS location, rather than redefining better basis for everyone. The manpower available in the X world is very small. Debian lacking of X maintainers is just the summit of that. There is very smart and very competent and skilled guys in the X world, as you can see by simply reading blog posts on Planet Freedesktop for example (me excluded). Unfortunately, there's not enough of them to cover all the things involved in X: input devices, graphics devices, new protocol extension specification and so on. The X server is really late, and it seems most of the developers prefers to work on the server itself than on the protocol behalf. Which is understandable. I'm curious to see where all of that will lead in the upcoming years. I've been walking in the X world hallways for about 3 years now, and I feel desktop alternatives to KDE and GNOME will all die sooner or later. The time were you could choose between a dozen "modern" window managers has passed away. After all, maybe that is simply Darwinism applied to computer software.
multistrap is gaining some important functionality. When preparing a root filesystem for a new product, the sources used to generate the system need to be made available. So, multistrap has an option to retain the sources and 2.1.5 adds the functionality of downloading the source packages to go alongside the binaries that are downloaded to make the system itself, into a directory outside the final system.
My project
This week I followed an advice of my mentor, Simon Marlow, and started to play with the code including print statements in interesting places in order to understand it s flow. It s indeed much better than just reading the source code and the documentation on the wiki. As usual, I had a lot of doubts about some parts of the code, and noted them down. But now, I m seeing that I m resolving most of them just by playing more with the code, without need to ask in the mailing list. There are still some left, and I m planning to send them to the list in a next oportunity.
The first thing I noticed was the high number of objects, from my perspective, that are created and collected in:
main = return ()
I measured how much times evacuate() was called. This function moves an object to the next generation of the Garbage Collector. It s called 775 times, in 1 call to GarbageCollect(), with 479 different objects (with different pointers to their Info Tables). Also, there were pinned objects and large objects in this count. This was surprising to me.
I also made a small draw of the memory allocation in lines using diagrams. The draw:
The source code:
import Prelude hiding (tan)
If you find yourself trying to pre-empt accusations of unfairness
by coming up with plausible explanations, this should be a clear
and obvious indication that you are about to do something unfair
and wrong.
If you are being accused of unfairness and are trying to think
of ways to defend against this criticism, it means you probably
already have done something unfair and wrong.
It also means that you probably have too much power.
Memorial Day weekend is also time for the annual
Bike The Drive in Chicago. This time
only half the household got up bright and early and enjoyed Lakeshore Drive free
of cars. A highly recommended event.
It's Memorial Day weekend so it was time for the
Chicago's JP Morgan Chase Corporate
Challenge on Thursday. The weather was glorious,
the usual 20-some thousand runners participated and a good time was had. Work
had arranged for a nice tent, food, music --- and a bunch of people showed up
and enjoyed it. Nice one.
This time we all got chip-timing via a small (rfid ?) strip tagged to back of
the bib number. Which is handy as I managed to not stop my time by hand
correctly. Given that I am still nursing a sore Achilles tendon and don't
train well or much, the time of 23:51 (or 6:48 min/mile) was ok
compared
to
the
other
seven
previous
times
I have run this.





Qt GUI for aptitude. Currently, KDE users need to use Aptitude via the console interface, or install the newly developed GTK frontend, which does not fit well into KDE desktop. Making Qt frontend to Aptitude would solve this problem and bring an advanced and fully Debian-compliant graphical package manager to KDE.As I wrote in my proposal I will split my work into three main parts:
What happened in my running life since my
last update?
In short, I achieved two races I was planning to do.
I ran my first trail on May 16th, Le Trail des Cerfs ("deer trail").
The experience of trail running is awesome. Runners are very friendly
and all of them are nature lovers. So, the feeling is completely
different from mass macadam races (those are also a must-do, still!).
I had a great time running that trail (which ended up to be exactly the
distance of an half marathon). I completed it in
less than 1h50, which is good, as the positive slope was about 300
meters, with sometimes very though rampswhere walking was nearly
mandatory.
At this occasion, during the "after", I discovered some members of an
online community of runners, named Kikourou ("Who is running where?"),
and I'm now a member of this online community (yet another
one...). That makes the promise of lots of beers after races...:-)
Today, I
completed my "Maureparathon", a full marathon ran alone on small
roads and bicycle lanes in my home city, and was
happy to break my personal best by 6 minutes, down to
3h43'14". Yay. For sure, still very far from SuperNo l (3:03:56 in
Mainz), but he's younger..:)
As I planned, I'll be running the
Sur les Traces du Loup
("The Wolf Track"?) 33km trail in La Ville aux Clercs, 2 hours away from our place. Elizabeth
is very happy to come with me in a 2-day trip in Chateaudun
neighbourhood. Renaissance castle visit mandatory for the following Sunday...:-)
Nice planning, eh?
And, guess what? I'm already trying to spot some local 10km races
while being in New York. I would find it an interesting experience to
run with local runners. Just like free software...and beer...and
cheese, running is much better when shared.
With the 10.10 developer summit behind us, several teams have published engineering plans for the 10.10 release cycle, including:
During the week-end, samba 3.5.3 hit the archive. It is still in
experimental (and will remain there as Squeeze will be released with
3.4.* as finally decided during SambaXP).
For lenny users, I also build backported packages. They are not on
backports.org as the policy for these "as official as possible"
backports is to have the same version than testing.
So, they are
provided "as is", for i386 and amd64, on the pkg-samba team's unofficial
repository. The Release file on that repository is signed by my
GPG key.
Please note that these backports also need talloc from backports.org
so you need to add entries for backports.org in your sources.list
files to be able to use them.
Since I last blogged about samba packages, the 3.4.8 version was also
released. It entered testing without any problem and I also uploaded a
backported version to backports.org.
Finally, on May 5th, new versions of the 3.2.5 packages of lenny were
updated to 2:3.2.5-4lenny11, currently in stable-proposed-updates. So,
they will be part of the next point release of lenny. They fix two
important bugs (#575951 for
interdomain trust with w2k8 servers, and #538819 for memory leaks in
some situations).
Next.