In the real world, David does not always win over Goliath.
That's sad, but it's true. Particularly in the case of a big
corporation using its wealth, influence, and minions to stomp down
invividuals, to prevent them from reducing those all-important
profits. A corporation must profit, by any means necessary. Profit
is more important than people.
A corporation has exactly as little ethics, morals, conscience,
and good behavior as it can get away with. It all pretty much rests
the officers, and their personal balance between greed and being
good people.
While most CEOs and managers and other decision makers in a
corporation aren't going to do big evil, say, have people killed,
they might not mind being a little bit nasty occasionally. If you
have a large corporation, with a culture of profit-worshipping,
you'll have a large number of people willing to be a little bit
nasty, and that amounts to a lot of nastiness.
That's all a long prelude to this: earlier this year, the PTFS
corporation bought Liblime, a competitor. They did this to get a
controlling interest on Koha, the free software librarary mangament
system. Much to their surprise, you can't buy a healthy free
software project like that.
The community of users and developers of Koha has resisted
PTFS's strongarm tactics. PTFS wants control of the code base,
version control systems, mailing lists, domains, web pages, wikis,
and decision making, but the community doesn't let them.
Right now they are attacking Nicole Engard, the documentation
manager for the Koha community, spreading lies about her. Nicole is
one of the Koha community members who has spoken against PTFS's
actions. She also works for a PTFS competitor, another sin against
PTFS.
This is an unfortunate situation for Nicole, for Koha, and for
free software in general. If corporations like PTFS manage to
silence their critics by nastiness, then nastiness is a working
strategy and will be used more in the future. We need to squash
this every time it happens, so it does not spread. However, for
PTFS to lose, Nicole will have to have the courage to stand up
against even more aggression.
In the old world, before the Internet, this would have been
quite hard. She would have had to get newspapers interested in her
case. PTFS would almost certainly have been able to prevent that,
by using their PR muscle to conduct a smear campaign against
her.
However, with the Internet, it's easier. Anyone can step up and
help defend Nicole.
That's what this is. I've never actually met Nicole, but in my
brief involvement with the Koha community, she was always helpful
and professional. She has, personally, helped Koha and free
software spread farther than it would otherwise have. She does
good.
Like pretty much everyone in the Koha community, she is
considerate, polite, and just to a fault, even when dealing with
those attacking her.
PTFS, on the other hand, has done only one honorable thing that
I am aware of: they finally released their version of Koha. Every
other action from PTFS seems to be an attempt to gain an upper hand
by underhanded stratagems. Luckily, they seem to be failing.
Let's see if giving more publicity to the attack on Nicole will
make it, too, fail.
See
Nicole's post
about this for more information.