
I ogled with an
ASUS EeePC since it was announced, but didn’t want to
order one abroad. So I waited until they became available in
Switzerland.
Digitec is the official EeePC importer for Switzerland
and seeems also to be the moving power for yet to come the Swiss
localisation of the EeePC. But initially they only offered imported
EeePCs with German keyboard layout, but since I really got used to the
US layout, I didn’t want to buy ay new laptops or keyboards with
German layout.
When asking them about
US layouts they told me they won’t import from
the
US and that their competitor Steg Computer is importing
US models.
But I wasn’t comfortable with Steg and EeePCs also were more expensive
there, so I hesitated ordering at Steg.
So it was quite unexpected for me when
US models showed up on
digitec’s website. (Interestingly I never received any mail from their
advertised EeePC newsletter, not even when they added 2G models t
their repertoire.)
So at the end of March (and therefore later as most other geeks ;-) I
ordered an ASUS EeePC at digitec. For me, white laptops look like Macs
(and Macs are for sissies or masochists ;-) — so I had no
problems to decide that I want a black EeePC with
US keyboard layout.
2G was to small for my purposes (and also not that much cheaper) and
8G not available. So I went with the 4G, since
Debian doesn’t need so
much space if you choose the right packages (i.e. neither or at least
not that much of
GNOME or
KDE ;-). I preferred the 4G over the 4G Surf
because of the bigger battery capacity (and not because of the webcam
which I consider funny but useless:-).
Initially the delivery date was set the 28th of March. Then it was
subsequently set to “beginning of April”, “mid of April”, “end of
April” and “beginning of May”. It finally arrived on 8th of May. In
the meanwhile
there were
reports that even the 4G has been equipped with the smaller battery of
the 4G Surf because of some battery shortage after some battery plant
burnt down. But fortunately the delivery problems with black 4G
US
models doesn’t seem to have its reason there and my 4G has a 5200 mAh
battery (at least according to its label and ACPI).
I also ordered a 2
GB bar of
Corsair ValueSelect RAM so that I can pump up the
RAM of my EeePC
by factor four (for about 10% of the price of the EeePC itself)
resulting in having half as much
RAM as disk space. Well, I guess, I
won’t do suspend to disk in that configuration… ;-)
The original
Xandros based
Linux only noticed 1
GB of the installed 2
GB as already noted on many other places in the web. But that doesn’t
really matter, since it only lasted until I found out how to restore
it from
DVD in case I want to sell the EeePC later (e.g. for getting
the successor). It’s fine for novices, but Linuxes feel strange if you
can’t even get a console or a terminal with a command line. ;-)
The
Debian
EeePC installer worked fine except that it argued over a checksum
error on
our mirror
which wasn’t reproducable after the installation anymore. I’ve chosen
the EeePC to be my first (nearly) pure Lenny installation —
compared to the three machines running
Sid (i386, amd64 and
kfreebsd-i386). It though has a few packages from experimental (mostly
xulrunner-1.9) installed.
As window managers I have installed
ratpoison,
FLWM and
FVWM.
ratpoison — best described as
screen for X (although
you can’t detach and reattach) since it’s my personal preferences for
being productive without big screen resolutions and flwm for a
low-resource window manager which can be used intuitivly by both,
geeks and non-geeks (and still doesn’t look like Windows at all ;-).
And FVWM is installed because it’s my default window manager on all
machines with bigger or multiple screens – to be able to compare it
with my usual environment.
As web browser I’ve got
Opera as primary browser (as everywhere else,
too) and
Conkeror (the EeePC is the test-case for upcoming Debian
package of Conkeror) as well as
links2 and
lynx on the (nearly)
text-only side on it, although I need them seldomly.
As office programs (as I would ever need some ;-) I’ve got AbiWord and
Gnumeric installed since I already use a few
GNOME applications (e.g.
Network Manager,
Twitux, etc.) and
OpenOffice.org would take up 170
MB
more disk space (then including OOo Draw and OOo Impress) and
Siag
Office is no more in Debian since years. (Initially I had
OpenOffice.org installed instead of AbiWord and Gnumeric until I
noticed that I need some of the
GNOME libraries anyway.)
I also decided that I will need LaTeX then and when so TeX Live also
got its chunk of the 4
GB of disk space.
I also have a bunch of games on the EeePC.
Unfortunately there are a few games which don’t work well on the EeePC
due to it’s resolution being smaller than 800x600, so I deinstalled
them already again, e.g. I can’t play
Cuyo on the EeePC but
flobopuyo.
Sauerbraten segfaults, but Doom (
prboom
with
freedoom WADs) works fine. Further non-working games
unfortunately include
Battle of Wesnoth and XFrisk.
Still, although quite some parts of
GNOME and
GNOME Office, TeX Live,
ScummVM with Flight of the Amazon Queen and Beneath a Steel
Sky,
GNU Emacs 22,
Iceweasel 3 (
aka Mozilla Firefox 3),
Icedove
(
aka Mozilla Thunderbird) and the
Iceowl (
aka Mozilla Sunbird) are
installed, only 2.3
GB of the available hard disk space are used by
the installation (i.e. without my home directory).
Oh, and
btw: Although except the very compact and a little bit wobbly
keyboard the EeePC doesn’t feel really small to me (I’ve got quite
small hands), but when I sat down in front of my 14” ThinkPad T61
after a day or two with EeePC, the T61, — especially screen and
keyboard — felt huge as if it would be some 17” or even bigger
notebook. ;-)
OTOH I
still think that a 1920×1200 (which means nearly four xterms in
a row) resolution on a 14” notebook would be a good idea, especially
compared to the 1440×900 (which means nearly three xterms in a
row) my T61 has. ;-)
Personal Resumée after one month
Pro EeePC
- It’s geeky. If you show up with it, people want to lift it to see
how much it weights and try the tiny keyboard. They’re surprised that
800x480 aren’t that small and that the performance isn’t that
bad.
- Very compact and robust. With the T61 I always fear that its edges
are too close to the the outside of my backpack and could be damaged
that way.
- The price of course: CHF 499 at digitec (plus CHF 54 for the 2 GB RAM)
- Runs Linux ex factory. So yu don’t have to expect that many driver
hassles.
- RAM upgrades are very straight forward and do not void the
warranty. (BTW: The sticker over one of the screws which probably
should prove the integrity can be removed and placed again easily…
:-)
- The weight. 0.92 kg can be easily held wit one hand, also because
of less leverage effect as with full-size laptops.
- The SSD despite it’s size. Being such lightweight you accelerate
the EeePC unmindfully even when it runs. But it doesn’t matter, at
least not to the hard disk. And it boots very fast, especially after
the usage of insserv.
- Intergrated Ethernet network interface. (Hey, the MacBook Air
hasn’t a builtin one, not even an external shipped with it! ;-)
- Three USB sockets (the MacBook Air has only one which is usually
taken for the Ethernet network adaptor — Ok, with the EeePC
usually one is taken for the Bluetooth dongle, but then are still two
sockets left… ;-)
- Great contrast on the builtin screen.
- External VGA output. You have to configure X.org to make the
virtual screen big enough (e.g. 2048×2048 instead of the default
800×800).
- Despite its size quite a lot of space for modifications inside the
case. Especially a bluetooth case mode should be no big deal.
Contra EeePC
- The keyboard: keys smaller than usually (ok, wouldn’t work
otherwise ;-), very wobbly, no precise contact depth (pressing Shift
and Fn with one finger often doesn’t press Fn right), not all keys on
the same plane, unusual offsets between the key rows (the number row
has about half a key width offset to the left) or position of keys (I
often hit Ins when I want Home, Del when I want Backspace or Fn when I
want Ctrl, the ~ key is between Esc and F1, Up is between Slash and
Right Shift, etc.)
- The position of the power button: It’s exactly where I want to put
thumb when holding the EeePC solely with the right hand. And yes, I
already accidentially switch it off several times because of
that. For luck the button doesn’t work at all when the lid is closed,
because you still can reach it easily while it’s closed.
- The mouse button(s): It only has two buttons which are one part
you can press more to the left and more to the right side. And if you
press it in the middle you randomly get either a left or a right
click. You have to press it very hard to get both clicks at the same
time. (e.g. to emulate a third middle button). Three separated mouse
buttons would have been way better.
- It has (only) a touchpad. I definitely prefer thumbsticks as the
ThinkPads have, but got used to it, though. I have seen worse
touchpads, too.
- The noisy and not very precisely beared fan, which seems to strife
its environment when the EeePC is being accelerated. Whih happens
quite often because of its size and weight and because the SSD doesn’t
mind acceleration. The fan does mind – and you hear it. :-(
- Some programs need minimum 800x600 resolution to work well.
Pro ThinkPad (in direct comparision)
- Thumbstick.
- One of the best laptop keyboards around.
- Three easy to distinguish mouse buttons.
- Even ressource-hungry programs like Liferea work fine.
- Quite big screen resolution (1440×900).
- Bigger battery, space for additional batteries.
- Could be a workstation replacement.
Pro Lenny on the EeePC
- The installer image of the Debian EeePC Project works out of the
box. All necessary drivers are available, if you include the non-free
repositories and the eeepc.debian.net repositories.
- Stable enough for daily use. (IMHO Debian Testing – and even
Debian Unstable – is more stable as many other distribution’s stable
releases, e.g. those from SuSE.)
Con Lenny on the EeePC
- My favourite feed reader Liferea has changed its cache format
since the version in Debian Etch, so I can’t sync Liferea caches between my
Debian Etch running T61 and the Testing running EeePC. Well,
fortunately the version of Liferea in Debian Etch still works on
Debian Lenny, so I just downgraded the package to the version from
Etch and set it on hold. I don’t use it on the EeePC though since it
needs way too long to start (about 10 to 15 minutes compared to 1 to 3
minutes on the T61)
Summary
I’m very happy with the EeePC and I didn’t expect that it would
replace my 14” ThinkPad in so many (but still not all) situations. :-)