Search Results: "Russ Allbery"

26 June 2026

Russ Allbery: Review: Platform Decay

Review: Platform Decay, by Martha Wells
Series: Murderbot Diaries #8
Publisher: Tor
Copyright: 2026
ISBN: 1-250-82701-9
Format: Kindle
Pages: 245
Platform Decay is the eighth book in the Murderbot science fiction series. You absolutely should not start here, but you also don't need to remember the specifics of the previous books. As the story opens, Murderbot and a friend (the identity of whom is a spoiler for previous books) are infiltrating a Corporation Rim torus, a massive space station that encircles a mined-out planet. (Like most science fiction megastructures, this is more space than the plot really requires.) Murderbot's mission is to exfiltrate some of Dr. Mensah's family members who have become entangled in corporate shenanigans. The corporates are eager to get revenge for the events of System Collapse, not to mention the other times Preservation Station has upended corporate plans. Murderbot's job is to stop them. The group, in addition to one of Dr. Mensah's partners, includes an older woman and a young child. Murderbot is analytical and of course not at all emotional about children, which is reliably a good time. Also, the older woman is gruff, stubborn, and thoroughly enjoyable. There are, of course, complications that lead to picking up more children and going through rather more of the torus than Murderbot wanted to explore. Each section of the torus is run by a different corporation and has a different constructed environment and visual aesthetic, so there are a lot of opportunities for fights, daring escapes, and incidental trouble. Also, well:
So I had installed a mental health module. I know, I was surprised I did it too.
After the events of System Collapse, University Medical decided that Murderbot needed a bit more metal health support.
The only reason I agreed to it was that the mental health module didn't actually try to adjust my processing or core programming or anything; it just monitored my organic neural tissue. When my neural tissue started to generate weird chemicals and whatever, it would ping me to "check in with my emotional state." Seriously, I could have coded that myself. (I told Dr. Bharadwaj that, and she said, "Would you have ever coded that yourself?" which was totally unfair and also correct. I would never have done that.)
Speaking as someone whose neural tissue sometimes generates weird chemicals and whatever, I sympathize. The specific form this module takes is periodic "emotion check" parentheticals throughout the narration, which I found utterly delightful.
I ran that through risk assessment and it produced the equivalent of a shrug. (Emotion check: Shrug sigil right back at you, you piece of shit.)
This is otherwise an extended action movie sort of a book, much like several of the early novellas. There are no major political or interpersonal developments here and the usual cast (apart from Murderbot) is mostly absent. Instead, we get an extended, dangerous journey through a corporation-controlled habitat, mixed with Murderbot trying to interact with humans in a way that minimizes its annoyance while being hopefully reassuring. It's competence porn with awkward but surprisingly heartfelt emotional bonding, not that Murderbot in any way wants to bond or would appreciate that description. I doubt this will be anyone's favorite entry into the series since there are none of the big reveals or major leaps of character development there have been in the past few books. But, like all Murderbot books, the narrative tone is wonderful and all of the small asides and little moments of character interaction are an utter delight. If you've gotten this far in the series, you know what I mean and you'll be as happy to read more of it as I was. There is a part of me that is hoping for some major plot development, and I always want to see more of ART (who has no significant role in this book), but Wells has the narrative style down so perfectly that I would read and enjoy a book about Murderbot doing just about anything. If you're this far in the series, you probably don't need a review, and since this is an action-heavy adventure rather than a character growth novel, I don't have a lot more to add. There's a new short Murderbot novel out and you want to read it. Recommended to everyone who enjoys the series. Rating: 8 out of 10

26 May 2026

Russ Allbery: Review: The Keeper of Magical Things

Review: The Keeper of Magical Things, by Julie Leong
Publisher: Ace
Copyright: 2025
ISBN: 0-593-81593-9
Format: Kindle
Pages: 353
The Keeper of Magical Things is a cozy fantasy novel. It is set in the same universe as The Teller of Small Fortunes, but it doesn't share any characters or plot, they're not marketed as a series, and so far as I can remember neither book would spoil the other. It is Julie Leong's second novel. Certainty Bulrush is a novice mage with one reliable magical ability: She can talk to objects and occasionally convince them to do small things. This ability is clearly magical, which means Certainty is indeed a mage, but this appears to be all that her magic can do. The Guild has requirements for the level of magical ability required to become a full mage that go beyond talking stained quilts into unstaining themselves, which is why Certainty has been a novice for six years. This by itself is a problem, since Certainty's cohort keeps passing her by. Worse, though, is that she was counting on the wages of a full mage to pay for her brother's training to become an apothecary. The thought of failing him is extremely upsetting. Certainty therefore jumps at an offered mission to take a cartload of excess magical objects that are causing a dangerous build-up of energies in the Guildtower to safe storage in the small and very unmagical village of Shpelling. Successful completion of that mission will earn Certainty a promotion to Deputy Keeper and therefore to a full mage. This is the opportunity she didn't know to hope for. The only drawback is that she will have to work with Mage Aurelia, the famously off-putting farspeaker and magical scholar the other novices refer to as the ice witch. Aurelia is every bit as icy, formal, and condescending as Certainty was afraid she would be, Shpelling grows nothing but garlic, and the inhabitants are suspicious and hostile. The mission could be a disaster if it weren't for Certainty's stubborn good nature. It's arguably a spoiler to say that there's an enemies to lovers romance, but it's hinted at on the cover, mentioned in the publisher's blurb and, honestly, if you aren't expecting an enemies to lovers romance by a few chapters in, you probably haven't read many books of this sort. I found The Keeper of Magical Things quietly enjoyable but extremely predictable. If you're in the mood for what it's offering, the predictability may not be a problem, but it was the kind of book where the direction the plot was headed was so obvious that I got a bit bored waiting for it to arrive. Certainty has a good heart, humble origins, limited but specialized magical ability, and a self-esteem problem, and if you've read much fantasy, you've probably read two or three or a dozen other books with variations of this protagonist. You know how they generally turn out, and that is indeed what you're going to get after the obligatory setbacks and tragedies and looming catastrophes. Aurelia, similarly, is a variation on a character you've probably met before. Certainty discovers, not long into the book, that the brilliant over-achieving mage wears a necklace (supposedly to help her focus) that constantly whispers to her how inadequate she is and how much harder she needs to work. The necklace was given to her by her parents. This book is not exactly subtle. That said, there's nothing wrong with the characterization. Both Certainty and Aurelia are interesting characters with rounded-out personalities, although it takes a while before Certainty (or the reader) is allowed to see Aurelia's. Their interactions with the inhabitants of Shpelling are fun to watch in the same way that it can be fun to watch people play PowerWash Simulator. You're not in overwhelming suspense about what's going to happen, but the details are amusing and it is satisfying to watch people with good intentions slowly fix things. There is a plot, and a villain, and a not-subtle message about how everyone deserves acknowledgment and respect, and the hours I spent reading about these characters were enjoyable. The problem with this book isn't that there's anything wrong with it, but that it may not give you more enjoyment than another book you could have been reading. I quite liked The Teller of Small Fortunes in part because it surprised me in a few places and the main character felt a bit different than the typical fantasy protagonist. The Keeper of Magical Things felt less original and a bit more obvious and predictable. It was still quietly good-hearted and occasionally charming, and I think I'll still remember Certainty in a few months, but I'm not feeling the urge to push it into anyone's hands. If you're in the mood for a gentle fantasy about finding solutions to people's problems and waiting out the prickliness of people who desperately need a friend, you may enjoy this a great deal. Just don't expect unpredictable twists and turns or a surprising plot structure. An apparent third book in this loose series, The Isle of Lonely Monsters, is currently scheduled for publication in 2027. Rating: 6 out of 10

17 May 2026

Russ Allbery: Review: Unwinding Anxiety

Review: Unwinding Anxiety, by Judson Brewer
Publisher: Avery
Copyright: 2021
ISBN: 0-593-33045-5
Format: Kindle
Pages: 268
Unwinding Anxiety is a non-fiction self-help book about how to reduce anxiety. The author is a board-certified psychiatrist specializing in addiction and substance abuse, who has subsequently done clinical and research (and commercial, more on that later) work in anxiety. His previous book, The Craving Mind, was a pop science treatment of addiction research. This book is more deliberately structured as a self-help guide. (The cover will assure you that he has an M.D. and a Ph.D. I don't include honorifics and degrees in author listings as a small protest against the weird social rules about which degrees count and which don't.) There are a lot of self-help books out there about anxiety. There are a lot fewer that say something relatively original. I think this is one of the latter, but I certainly have not done a survey of the subgenre, and it's possible the ideas here are only new to me. Brewer makes three basic claims in this book, all of which I found personally useful:
  1. Anxiety can be usefully analyzed as a habit. The rumination loop and other related anxiety behaviors such as excessive analysis, reassurance-seeking, and negative anticipation take the form of deeply ingrained habits triggered by stimuli.
  2. Raw willpower is not a useful way to break habits in general and anxiety habits in particular. In order to displace the habit, you have to retrain the part of your brain that runs habits on autopilot. Attempting to override it with willful effort is exhausting and likely to fail.
  3. Habit loops in general, and anxiety loops in particular, can be defused and replaced using mindfulness techniques.
This is not the way Brewer lays out the book. He goes to some effort to lead the reader slowly through three techniques for handling anxiety (for which he uses the metaphor of "gears," like for a bicycle or car) by introducing them one at a time and encouraging the reader to become thoroughly familiar with each one before moving on to the next. Since this is a book review, I'm going to give you the whole argument at once so that you know where this book is going. This may be less helpful in practice; if you're trying to use this technique on your own anxiety, you may want to read the book instead and not jump ahead. Brewer's three gears are:
  1. Identify your habit loops and recognize when they're happening. (This part felt the most similar to traditional cognitive behavioral therapy to me.)
  2. Focus on how those habit loops make you feel. Rather than trying to force the habit loop to stop, let it happen but pay very close attention to the outcome and its effects on you.
  3. Find and focus on a different reaction that provides better rewards than the anxiety habit loop. Brewer suggests curiosity.
For me, the point where I thought "okay, you have my attention" is when Brewer described the way many people, particularly people without anxiety, tell people with anxiety to "just stop thinking about it" or "just do the thing you're anxious about anyway and you'll see it will be fine" and then described in detail why he believes that doesn't work. This is one of the few discussions of anxiety I've read where the author goes out of his way to stress that you cannot simply think your way out of anxiety and that repeatedly trying to do so and failing is exhausting and demoralizing. Everyone is different and I know some people find cognitive behavioral therapy very helpful, but I find the constant effort to challenge cognitive distortions more draining and demoralizing than useful. His second gear, of not directly confronting the habit loop but instead watching its effect and thinking about its outcome, feels so much more approachable to me. Assuming, of course, it works. Brewer's approach is essentially just mindfulness, although he mostly avoids the (to me at least) somewhat off-putting typical introduction to mindfulness via religious practice or general well-being and instead ties it to a theorized model of how habits work in the human brain. His contention is that habits, including anxiety, exist because at some point they provided a reward that was sufficiently compelling to make the habit-following part of your brain seek that reward. You were getting some benefit (a sense of control, a sense of being prepared, temporary reassurance, etc.) out of the anxiety reaction, which is why the anxiety habit formed in the first place. Once that habit is in place, it can continue without the reward. (Although in my experience there is probably still some short-term reward.) Rather than trying to force yourself to stop following the habit, Brewer instead suggests letting the habit happen but then focusing (via mindfulness) on how following the habit makes you feel, whether it improves your sense of well-being or worsens it, and whether other actions produce different feelings. The goal, in other words, is to undermine the assumption of reward and to challenge any short-term reward with the long-term discomfort that made you want to stop being anxious. This avoids using your conscious brain to exert direct willpower, which is exhausting and usually unsuccessful since the habit-following part of your brain is stronger (for various evolutionary psychology reasons he explains and that I found at least partly credible). Instead, you are using its strengths of observation and classification. You pay close attention to the ways in which the habit loop makes you feel bad, which in theory provides feedback to the habit-following part of your brain that can dislodge the habit. If the habit is recognized as no longer rewarding, it will weaken. Brewer's background is in addiction treatment, so he is predisposed to see addiction in everything and one should probably be a bit cautious about his enthusiasm. He claims a great deal of success with this approach in clinical settings, mostly with addiction but also with anxiety, but this is always hard to verify. (Few doctors who write self-help books rigorously document their failures.) He apparently also has a company that produces various phone apps that assist with this technique. I'm rather cynical about anyone who talks about products their company has produced in self-help books of this type, and I'm also rather cynical about anyone who calls himself "Dr. Jud," but the book doesn't seem to be a sales pitch and there's no direct information in it about how to get the apps. For me, the first two parts of the book were the most useful and the conception of anxiety reactions as habits made a surprising amount of intuitive sense. I thought the third part of the book, where he tries to describe a better in-the-moment reaction that you can try to build into a more beneficial habit, to be the weakest. It's mostly stock mindfulness advice that I've seen in other places, and you will be entirely unsurprised to learn that Brewer meditates and has studied meditation. I think it's clear that, for him, a feeling of curiosity works as an anxiety replacement; I'm not sure that's universal and I'm not sure it works for me. That core idea that anxiety reactions are a type of addictive habit that have outlived their useful rewards but continue because habits are hard to change felt both useful and at least a little bit true, though. Your mileage may, of course, vary, but I've been trying out various ideas from this book since I first started reading it, and I think it's helping. If any of this clicks with you and you're also prone to anxiety, it might be worth a read. One warning, though: Brewer's previous work on addiction includes binge eating, and while it's not a primary focus, he uses several weight loss and disordered eating examples and has a very traditional medical attitude towards weight. I'm somewhat dubious of the addiction model of weight gain in general, but more to the point, it's rather off-putting in a book supposedly about anxiety. It's something I was able to skim over, but be aware going in if you're likely to find this obnoxious. I do think this book is a case of an addiction researcher seeing everything through the lens of addiction, and I'm a little dubious this is the right model for everyone's anxiety. But this is one of the good reasons why there are a lot of books about anxiety: Different approaches suit different people. This one made more sense to me than most; maybe you are similar. I can't really recommend or not recommend a book like this, since I think so much will depend on whether you are one of the people for whom this specific explanation will click, but I'm glad that I read it and I think it's good to know that this model of anxiety exists. Rating: 8 out of 10

4 May 2026

Russ Allbery: Review: Full Speed to a Crash Landing

Review: Full Speed to a Crash Landing, by Beth Revis
Series: Chaotic Orbits #1
Publisher: DAW
Copyright: August 2024
ISBN: 0-7564-1947-6
Format: Kindle
Pages: 153
Full Speed to a Crash Landing is a science fiction novella and the first of a series. Beth Revis made the New York Times bestseller list for an earlier series of young adult science fiction novels, but somehow I had not heard of her before this series. Ada Lamarr is a salvager. She picks up material from crashed or dead ships for resale. As the story opens, she has a large hole in the side of her ship, she's running out of oxygen, and the other ship nearby is refusing to answer her distress call. By the time they finally respond, there is barely enough time to get aboard before she is entirely out of air. Ada's first-person narration drops hints that she may not be entirely what she seems. But then, neither is the Halifax, so it's only fair. The captain of the Halifax treats Ada with a great deal of suspicion and wants her out of the way of their ongoing salvage operation. However, the captain does not appear to be entirely in charge. Ada is immediately struck by the mysterious Rian White, who seems to have some authority over their mission and is more thoughtful and calculating than the rest of the crew. He's also handsome, which doesn't hurt. I was tempted to keep writing about the plot, but given the short length of this book, I should stop there and let you enjoy the twists and turns for yourself. This is a fun science fiction action romp: lots of banter, lots of tense moments, and a cagey first-person protagonist with an irrepressible sense of humor and a knack for brazening her way through conversations. It's not long on world-building (there isn't enough room), but Revis works in enough details to be intriguing and to set up some interesting motivations. This is the sort of book that lives and dies by how much you like the protagonist, something that you will easily figure out by the end of an ebook sample if you're the sort of reader who uses those. Ada is irreverent, talkative, and very adroit at diverting attention (entertainingly) onto anything other than the critical piece of information other people are missing. If you want to, I suspect you could easily figure out most of what Ada is up to before the book reveals it explicitly. It's not that complicated, and the book isn't really trying to hide, although it doesn't give you all the necessary information in advance. Personally, I was happy to sit back and enjoy the ride. There is no romance in this book beyond frequent comments from Ada that she would have liked there to be a romance in this book under different circumstances, but I will be surprised if that romance doesn't show up later in the series. Ada and Rian are clearly being set up as a pair. I didn't like Rian as much, mostly because he's less memorable as a character, but he comes into his own in the appendices after the plot proper. I thought those concluding appendices were the best part of the novella and question the Kindle formatting decision to treat them like supplemental material. They purport to be a series of government memos, fill in a lot more of the backstory and world building, and have the best footnotes. Don't skip them! This isn't the sort of book that I am inspired to immediately push into everyone's hands, but it's a fast, well-paced story that delivered a few reading sessions of entertainment. I'm not sure the political philosophy in the background makes a lot of sense, but at least not a standard stereotype of current politics seen in so much science fiction. It's going to set up some interesting character conflict in later books. I'm certainly intrigued enough to keep reading. Recommended when you're in the mood for some fast-paced fun that's short and undemanding. Followed by How to Steal a Galaxy. Rating: 7 out of 10

27 April 2026

Russ Allbery: Review: What We Are Seeking

Review: What We Are Seeking, by Cameron Reed
Publisher: Tor
Copyright: 2026
ISBN: 1-250-36474-4
Format: Kindle
Pages: 339
What We Are Seeking is a bit hard to classify beyond science fiction. I think I would call it anthropological science fiction, but it's also a first contact story and a planetary colony story. It is a standalone novel (well, so far as I know; see later in the review for caveats). This is Cameron Reed's second novel after the excellent and memorable cyberpunk novel The Fortunate Fall, first published in 1996 under Reed's former name of Raphael Carter. John Maraintha is a doctor from the world of Essius. He took what he thought was a temporary job on the Free Ship Edgar's Folly, where he's endured considerable culture shock. As the novel opens, John learns that the colonists on Scythia have requested a translator to talk to one of the native life forms, and a doctor since they're down to only one. John will be that doctor. The captain has decided, and by the rules of the free ships, John does not get a choice in the matter. The Scythian colony is about four hundred people, now located in a desert climate since the complex native life forms destroyed their previous settlement. The colonists are a split between Ischnurans and Zandaheans, two other human civilizations from the scatter of colony worlds left after Earth embraced AIs (aiyis here) and turned inward. Both of those groups marry, something John considers a moral abomination. Neither of them seem likely to understand Essian sexual ethics. More devastatingly, John had intended to spend some time as a ship doctor and then return home to a new place in Essian society. Once he lands on Scythia, the chances of that are gone; it is highly unlikely any ship would pick him up again and take him home. I have been trying to find the right books to compare What We Are Seeking with ever since I read it. The best I've come up with are Ursula K. Le Guin (particularly The Dispossessed), Eleanor Arnason's A Woman of the Iron People, and Becky Chambers's To Be Taught, If Fortunate. The start of the book felt like an intentional revisiting of an earlier era of science fiction, with somewhat updated science and politics, but the last half of the book, where the action picks up considerably, is a meditation on gender, social systems, religion, and small-group politics. All of that is mixed with biological exploration and a first-contact story with some quite-alien aliens. This is the sort of novel where the protagonist's culture is as foreign to the reader as any of the other cultures he counters, so the reader is assembling several jigsaw puzzles at once. John is dropped into an established colony with its own social norms and established hierarchies. The one other outsider, the translator Sudharma Jain, is, as his name implies, a Jain who keeps very strict religious observances. Half of the colony is from something akin to a fundamentalist Christian religious sect that practices patriarchy and strict marriage codes. The other half is more gently sexist (but still sexist) and has its own tradition of a third gender that becomes central to the story. John, meanwhile, is a strong believer in the Essian approach to social organization: Any two partners of any gender freely have sex by mutual consent and without obligation, and family is based solely on blood relations. These beliefs do not fit comfortably together, even when people are trying (as they mostly do) to be welcoming. The first half of this book is very slow. This gives all of the characters space to breathe and become comfortable, and the characterization is superb, but it is a book to start when you're in the mood for something slow and observational. There is a plot that gradually becomes apparent, or rather there are several plots that are intertwined, but tension and urgency are mostly reserved for the second half of the book. Instead, the book opens with a lot of close observation of alien flora and fauna and the untangling of subtle social dynamics among the Scythians. There is also a visitor from earth, much to the distress of the Scythians. Earth presence means the ships will not return and the colony may be cut off from any sort of technological resupply. Despite speaking a common language, that visitor is as mutually alien to the other groups as they are to the native flora. Her life is fully integrated with aiyis, giving her essentially godlike powers and the ability to turn off inconvenient emotions and disregard anything she doesn't want to see. What she and the Earth aiyis are doing on the planet is one of the early mysteries. The dialogue in this book is truly excellent. Each characters has their own voice, there are fascinating digressions on different words that lead to tidbits of world-building, and some of the culture-specific idioms are delightful.
"I'm making a mess of this. None of that matters. Let me fall out the window and come in the door again. This is how my story ought to start:"
The challenges for the characters in this story are slow but deep ones: belonging and self-definition, the conflict between cultural tradition and personal circumstance, and the sacrifices required to live with small groups in situations where civil war is viscerally attractive. It has one of the most comprehensive and fascinating treatments of transgender issues that I've read in science fiction. Its commentary on current politics is subtle and estranged in the way that science fiction does best, but still pointed and satisfying. And, well, there are passages like this that I absolutely adore:
"I wouldn't go that far. It could be they are right, the universe we see exists because a mind like ours created it at least, a mind enough like ours that we can say it wants one thing and not another, and when it acts it does so with intent. That's as good an idea as any. But it is certainly not plausible that such a being believes that people everywhere should marry, or that men should never visit men, or no one should become a jess. Look at what they have created. The universe could have been nothing at all, or one atom of hydrogen floating in a void, or a diamond crystal infinite in all directions, if their mind cared for simplicity or tidiness. Instead we have stars and planets and black holes and nebulas. It could have all been cold and dead, but there is life. They could have made one species for each world, or just a few, which could have stayed the same forever, but instead we have millions and millions, all of which are changing every moment, varying among themselves and boiling off in all directions. Such a god is like an artist who fills up a library of sketchbooks with their drawings of strange creatures, and when every scrap of paper in the place is used up, goes back with a different color ink and scribbles over them again. They are obsessed with variation they gorge themselves with it and never grow full. Do you really think a mind like that could want us all to live in the same way?"
I had one problem with this book, though, and for me it was a big one: There is no ending. Reed effectively builds tension, gets me caring about all of the characters, sets up several problems, starts down a path towards resolution, and then the book just... ends. Long-time readers of my reviews will know that I'm a denouement fanatic. I want the scouring of the shire, I want the chapter set in the happily ever after, I want the catharsis of an ending. This made me so grumpy! To be clear, this is not sequel bait (at least so far as I can tell). I can write a philosophical defense of the ending. The types of problems and lives that Reed set up don't have clear endings; this is, to some extent, the point. We muddle through, and then those who come after us muddle through some more, and the cumulative effect is called human civilization. And there is some denouement; Reed doesn't leave the reader at a cliffhanger or anything that egregious. But still, I wanted the happy ending, even though that was unrealistic for the style of story this is, because I'm a happy ending reader. This is not an ending sort of book; it's the sort of book where I get a sinking feeling at the 95% mark because there aren't enough pages left for the number of remaining unresolved problems. I've gotten less annoyed in the days since I finished the book, and I can appreciate the thematic point made by how the book ends, but I still feel like it's worth an advance warning if you're a reader like I am. I would be delighted by a sequel, but it didn't feel like that was the intent. Apart from that, this was both excellent and rather unlike a lot of current science fiction. I think the closest comparison I can make among recent novels I've read is Sue Burke's Semiosis. What We Are Seeking has a similar sort of world-building, but I liked these characters so much more. It felt like a classic literary science fiction novel, but very much written in 2026. Highly recommended, just beware of the lack of closure. Content notes: Sexism, homophobia, stomach illness, and some religious abuse. Rating: 8 out of 10

25 April 2026

Russ Allbery: Review: The Genocidal Healer

Review: The Genocidal Healer, by James White
Series: Sector General #8
Publisher: Orb
Copyright: 1991
Printing: May 2003
ISBN: 0-7653-0663-8
Format: Trade paperback
Pages: 255
The Genocidal Healer is the eighth book in James White's medical science fiction series about the Sector General hospital. As with the rest of the series, detailed memory of the previous books is not required and the books could be read out of order if you didn't mind spoilers. I read this as part of the Orb General Practice omnibus. Surgeon-Captain Lioren is a Tarlan doctor who was in charge of the medical response to a newly-discovered civilization. The aliens were suffering from an apparently universal plague and an ongoing vicious war waged entirely through hand-to-hand combat, putting them on the edge of extinction. Lioren rushed the distribution of a possible cure against the advice of the doctors working on developing it, with catastrophic results. As The Genocidal Healer opens, Lioren is insisting on a court-martial in the hope of receiving the sentence it believes it deserves and was denied: death. (It pronouns are the convention in the Sector General series for all alien races and formal discussions, because even someone prone to bouts of gender essentialism such as White understood the need for avoiding gender assumptions in a science fiction medical context.) Predictably, both Sector General and the Monitor Corps that technically runs the hospital are flatly unwilling to execute Lioren. Instead, he is assigned as a new apprentice in the psychology department under the legendary O'Mara, where he is ordered to investigate the psychological fitness of a senior doctor named Seldal. This leads him to talk to Seldal's patients, which in turn leads to a challenging set of ethical dilemmas. The first five chapters (and more than sixty pages) are the story of Lioren's trial and a recounting of the events on Cromsag. The series is full of medical and cultural puzzles like this, and usually I like them, but I thought this one was less successful. We know the vague (and horrible) outline of the ending in advance, and the massive simplification and artificial universality that is required to make this puzzle work is particularly blatant. A universally infectious disease is more of a fiction plot than a believable biological concept, and the number of failures of communication, analysis, and misunderstanding that have to line up to create White's predetermined outcome were a bit much for me. Once the story gets past that and into Lioren's psychological work, the novel improves. Lioren is guilt-ridden and irrational, but also rather arrogant about his guilt and his concepts of professional responsibility in a way that I think mostly worked. Most of the novel consists of Lioren slowly discovering that people like him and enjoy talking to him, much to his bafflement. In that, it has the gentle kindness and sense of universal basic decency that is characteristic of this series. There are, of course, medical puzzles to solve, although this time they are primarily psychological in nature. Various characters from previous books make an appearance, but White re-explains their background in sufficient detail that you don't need to remember (or have read) those previous books. There are a lot of similarities between this book and the previous one, Code Blue Emergency. Both feature nonhuman viewpoint protagonists and amusing descriptions of human facial expressions from an alien perspective. Both feature protagonists with overly rigid ethical structures that partly clash with the generally human policies of Sector General. The Genocidal Healer is a bit more subtle and nuanced, although a lot of Lioren's psychological evaluation rests on an ethical difference that I found somewhat unbelievable. This book, though, tackles a subject the previous book did not: religion. The treatment isn't horrible, but I have some complaints. My primary issue is that Lioren, who starts as an atheist, does extensive research into religion to help a patient and then starts making statements summarizing the religions beliefs of the majority of known species that are just... Christianity. As someone raised Christian, I recognized it immediately as the sort of abstracted Christianity that Christians claim is universal while completely ignoring the opinions of the adherents of any other religion. Key components of this majority galactic religious pattern, according to Lioren, include an omnipotent and omnibenevolent creator god, a religious figure who preaches forgiveness and mercy and is persecuted, and emphasis on redemption. This simply is not some abstract universal religion. This is just Christianity in disguise. Even in religions that have some of those elements in their traditions, they do not get the same emphasis and are not handled the way that Lioren describes them. I therefore found Lioren's extended discussions of religion rather annoying, since he kept claiming as relatively universal principles beliefs that are not even held by the majority of religious adherents on Earth, let alone a wildly varying collection of alien races with entirely different biology and societal constructions. It caused a lot of problems for my suspension of disbelief, on top of the annoyance at this repetition of, frankly, Christian propaganda. Lioren goes, from that research, into theodicy (the problem of evil). The interesting part of this is White's earnest portrayal of a doctor's approach to societal problems: a desire to find workarounds and patches and fixes for anything that makes people unhappy, whether medical or social. It makes sense, given the horrible biologic hands that some of the aliens in this series have been dealt, that they would question the idea of a benevolent god, so this philosophical digression is justified in that sense. But you might guess that a mid-list science fiction author is not going to say something new about one of the oldest problems in Christianity, and indeed he does not. Lioren arrives at the standard handwaving about the unknowability of divine intent, which I found tedious to read but at least not fatal to the plot. White, thankfully, doesn't take the religious material too far. The characters recognize how sensitive of an issue religion is in a hospital, Lioren never adopts religion fully, and the resolution of the plot is as much biological as philosophical. White is going somewhere with the introduction of religion, and although some of the path there annoyed me, I think the destination worked. White was from Northern Ireland, and therefore well aware of the drawbacks of religion, and he abhorred violence (hence Sector General as a setting), so the reader is in better hands with him than with most authors who might attempt this plot. I think I know a bit too much about religion to be the best audience for this entry in the series, and I'm not sure the introductory five chapters quite worked. But as with all of the other books in the series, this kept me turning the pages and I'm glad I read it. The Genocidal Healer probably isn't worth seeking out unless you're reading the whole series, but if you're enjoying the rest of the series, you'll probably like this too. Followed by The Galactic Gourmet. Rating: 6 out of 10

20 April 2026

Russ Allbery: Review: Surface Detail

Review: Surface Detail, by Iain M. Banks
Publisher: Orbit
Copyright: October 2010
Printing: May 2011
ISBN: 0-316-12341-2
Format: Trade paperback
Pages: 627
Surface Detail is the ninth novel in Banks's Culture science fiction (literary space opera?) series. As with most of the Culture novels, it can be read in any order, although this isn't the best starting point. There is an Easter egg reference to Use of Weapons that would be easier to notice if you have read that book recently, but which is not that important to the story. Lededje Y'breq is an Indented Intagliate from the Sichultian Enablement. Her body is patterned from her skin down to her bones, covered with elaborate markings similar to tattoos that extend to her internal organs. As an intagliate, she is someone's property. In her case, she is the property of Joller Veppers, the richest man in the Enablement and her father's former business partner. Intagliates are a tradition of great cultural pride in the Enablement. They are a living representation of the seriousness with which debts and honor are taken, up to and including one's not-yet-born children becoming the property of one's debtor. Such children are decorated as living works of art of the highest skill and technical sophistication; after all, the Enablement are not barbarians. As the story opens, Lededje is attempting, not for the first time, to escape. This attempt is successful in an unexpected way. Prin and Chay are Pavulean researchers and academics who, as this story opens, are in Hell. They are not dead; they have infiltrated the Hell that Pavuleans are shown to scare them into proper behavior in order to prove that it is not an illusion and their society does indeed torture people in an afterlife, in more awful ways than people dare imagine. They have reached the portal through which temporary visitors exit, hoping to escape with firm evidence of the existence and horrors of the Pavulean afterlife. They will not be entirely successful. Yime Nsokyi is a Culture agent for Quietus, the part of Contact that concerns itself with the dead. Many advanced societies throughout the galaxy have invented and reinvented the ability to digitize a mind and then run it in a virtual environment. Once a society can capture the minds of every person in that society from that point forward, it faces the question of whether to do so and, if it does, what to do with those minds. More specifically, it faces the moral question of whether to punish the minds of people who were horrible in life. It faces the question of whether to create Hell. Vatueil is a soldier in a contestation, a limited and carefully monitored virtual war. The purpose of that war game is to, once and for all, resolve the question of whether civilizations should be allowed to create Hells. Some civilizations consider them integral to their religion or self-conception. Others consider them morally abhorrent, and that conflict was in danger of spilling over into war in the Real. Hence the War in Heaven: Both sides committed to fight in a virtual space under specific and structured rules, and the winner decides the fate of the galaxy's Hells. Vatueil is fighting for the anti-Hell side. The anti-Hell side is losing. There are very few authors who were better at big-idea science fiction than Iain M. Banks. I've been reading a few books about AI ships and remembered that I had two unread Culture novels that I was saving. It felt like a good time to lose myself in something sprawling. Surface Detail does sprawl. Even by Banks's standards, there was an impressive amount of infodumping in this book. Banks always has huge and lovingly described set pieces, and this book is no exception, but there are also paragraphs and pages of background and cultural musings and galactic politics. We are introduced to not one but three new Contact divisions; as well as the already-mentioned Quietus, there is Numina, which concerns itself with the races that have sublimed (transcended), and Restoria, which deals with hegemonizing swarms (grey goo nanotech, paperclip maximizers, and their equivalents). Infodumping is both a feature and a bane of big-idea science fiction, and it helps to be in the right mood. It also helps if the info being dumped is interesting, and this is where Banks shines. This is a huge, sprawling book, but it deals with some huge, sprawling questions and it has interesting and non-reductive thoughts about them. The problems posed by the plot come with history, failed solutions, multi-sided political disputes, strategies and tactics of varying morality and efficacy, and an effort to wrestle with the irreducible complexity of trying to resolve political and ethical disagreements in a universe full of profound disagreements and moral systems that one cannot simply steamroll. It also helps that the characters are interesting, even when they're not likable. Surface Detail has one fully hissable villain (Veppers) as a viewpoint character, but even Veppers is interesting in a "let me check the publication date to see if Banks was aware of Peter Thiel" sort of way. The Culture ships, of which there are several in this story, tend towards a gently sarcastic kindness that I find utterly charming. Lededje provides the compelling motive force of someone who has no involvement in the broader philosophical questions and instead intends to resolve one specific problem through lethal violence. Vatueil and Yime were a bit bland in personality, more exposition generators than characters I warmed to, but their roles and therefore the surrounding exposition were fascinating enough that I still enjoyed their sections. I'm sure this is not an original observation, but I was struck reading this book in the first half of 2026 that the Culture functions as an implementation of what the United States likes to think it is but has never been. It has a strong sense of shared ethics and moral principles, it tries to export them to the rest of the galaxy through example, persuasion, and careful meddling, but it tries to follow some combination of pragmatic and moral rules while doing so, partly to avoid a backlash and partly to avoid becoming its own sort of hegemonizing swarm. That is a powerfully attractive vision of how to be an advanced civilization, and the fact that every hegemon that has claimed that mantle has behaved appallingly just makes it more intriguing as a fictional concept. In this book, like in many Culture books, the Culture is painfully aware of the failure modes of meddling, and the story slowly reveals the effort the Culture put into staying just on a defensible side of their own moral lines. This is, in a sense, a Prime Directive story, but with a level of hard-nosed pragmatism and political sophistication that the endless Star Trek Prime Directive episodes never reach. Surface Detail does tend to sprawl, and I'm not sure Banks pulled together all the pieces of the plot. For example, if there was a point to the subplot involving the Unfallen Bulbitian, it was lost on me. (There is always a possibility with Banks that I wasn't paying close enough attention.) But the descriptions are so elaborate and the sense of politics and history are so deep that I was never bored, even when following a plot thread that meandered off into apparent irrelevance. The main plot line comes to a satisfying conclusion that may be even more biting social commentary today than it was in 2010. A large part of the plot does involve Hell, so a warning for those who haven't read much Banks: He adores elaborate descriptions of body horror and physical torture. The sections involving Prin and Chay are rather grim and horrific, probably a bit worse than Dante's Inferno. I have a low tolerance for horror and I was able to read past and around the worst bits, but be warned that Banks indulges his love for the painfully grotesque quite a bit. This was great, and exactly what I was hoping for when I picked it up. It's not the strongest Culture novel (for me, that's either The Player of Games or Excession), but it's one of the better ones. Highly recommended, although if you're new to the Culture, I would start with one of the earlier books that provide a more gradual introduction to the Culture and Special Circumstances. Followed, in the somewhat disconnected Culture series sense, by The Hydrogen Sonata. Content warnings: Rape (largely off-screen), graphic violence, lots of Bosch-style grotesque torture, and a lot of Veppers being a thoroughly awful human being as a viewpoint character. Rating: 8 out of 10

19 April 2026

Russ Allbery: Review: Collision Course

Review: Collision Course, by Michelle Diener
Series: Class 5 #6
Publisher: Eclipse
Copyright: November 2024
ISBN: 1-7637844-0-1
Format: Kindle
Pages: 289
Collision Course is the sixth novel in the Class 5 science fiction series and the first that doesn't use the Dark X naming convention. There are lots of spoilers in this story for the earlier books, but you don't have to remember all the details of previous events. Like the novella, Dark Ambitions, this novel returns to Rose, Sazo, and Dav instead of introducing another Earth woman and Class 5 ship. In Dark Class, Ellie discovered an interesting artifact of a previously-unknown space-faring civilization. Rose, Sazo, and Dav are on their way to make first contact when, during a routine shuttle flight between the Class 5 and Dav's Grih military ship, Rose is abducted. The aliens they came to contact have an aggressive, leverage-based negotiating strategy. They're also in the middle of a complicated war with more sides than are readily apparent. What I liked most about Dark Horse, the first book of this series and our introduction to Rose, was the revealed ethical system and a tense plot that hinged primarily on establishing mutual trust when there were excellent reasons for the characters to not trust each other. As the series has continued, I think the plots have become more complicated but the ethical dilemmas and revealing moments of culture shock have become less common. That is certainly true of Collision Course; this is science fiction as thriller, with a complex factional conflict, a lot of events, more plot reversals than the earlier books, but also less ethics and philosophy. I'm not sure if this is a complaint. I kind of miss the ethics and philosophy, but Diener also hasn't had much new to say for the past few books. The plot of Collision Course is quite satisfyingly twisty for a popcorn-style science fiction series. I was kept guessing about the merits of some of the factions quite late into the book, although admittedly I was in the mood for light entertainment and was not trying too hard to figure out where the book was going. I did read nearly the entire book in one sitting and stayed up until 2am to finish it, which is a solid indication that something Diener was doing worked. I do have quibbles, though. One is that the ending is a bit unsatisfying. Like Sazo, I was getting quite annoyed at the people capturing (and recapturing) Rose and would have enjoyed somewhat more decisive consequences. Also, and here I have to be vague to avoid spoilers, I was expecting a bit more of a redemption arc for one of the players in the multi-sided conflict. The ending I did get was believable but rather sad, and I wish Diener had either chosen a different outcome (this is light happily-ever-after science fiction, after all) or wrestled more directly with the implications. There were a bit too many "wait, one more thing" ending reversals and not quite enough emotional payoff for me. The other quibble is that Collision Course was a bit too damsel in distress for this series. Rose is pregnant, which Diener uses throughout the book as a way to raise the stakes of the plot and also make Rose more annoyed but also less capable than she was in her earlier novel. Both Sazo and Dav are in full heroic rescue mode, and while Diener still ensures Rose is primarily responsible for her own fate, there is some "military men attempt to protect the vulnerable woman" here. One of the things I like about this series is that it does not use that plot, so while the balance between Rose rescuing herself and other people rescuing her is still tilted towards Rose, I would have liked this book more if Rose were in firmer control of events. I will mostly ignore the fact that a human and a Grih sexually reproducing makes little to no biological sense, since Star Trek did similar things routinely and it's an established genre trope. But I admit that it still annoys me a bit that the alien hunk is essentially human except that he's obsessed with Rose's singing and has pointy ears. Diener cares about Rose's pregnancy a lot more than I did, which added to my mild grumpiness at how often it came up. Overall, this was fine. I prefer a bit more of a protagonist discovering how powerful she is by making ingenious use of the ethical dilemmas her captors have trapped themselves in, and a bit less of Rose untangling a complicated political situation by getting abducted by every player serially, but it still kept the pages turning. Any book that is sufficiently engrossing for me to read straight through is working at some level. Collision Course was highly readable, undemanding, and distracting, which is what I was looking for when I read it. I would put it about middle of pack in the series. If Rose's pregnancy is more interesting to you than it was to me, that might push it a bit higher. If you have gotten this far in the series, you will probably enjoy this, although it does feel like Diener is running out of new things to say about this universe. That's unfortunate given the number of threads about AI sentience and rights that could still be followed, but I think tracing them properly would require more philosophical meat than Diener intends for these books. Which is why the next book I grabbed was a Culture novel. Currently this is the final book in the Class 5 series, but there is no inherent reason why Diener couldn't write more of them. Rating: 7 out of 10

12 April 2026

Russ Allbery: Review: The Teller of Small Fortunes

Review: The Teller of Small Fortunes, by Julie Leong
Publisher: Ace
Copyright: November 2024
ISBN: 0-593-81590-4
Format: Kindle
Pages: 324
The Teller of Small Fortunes is a cozy found-family fantasy with a roughly medieval setting. It was Julie Leong's first novel. Tao is a traveling teller of small fortunes. In her wagon, pulled by her friendly mule Laohu, she wanders the small villages of Eshtera and reads the trivial fortunes of villagers in the tea leaves. An upcoming injury, a lost ring, a future kiss, a small business deal... she looks around the large lines of fate and finds the small threads. After a few days, she moves on, making her solitary way to another village. Tao is not originally from Eshtera. She is Shinn, which means she encounters a bit of suspicion and hostility mixed with the fascination of the exotic. (Language and culture clues lead me to think Shinara is intended to be this world's not-China, but it's not a direct mapping.) Tao uses the fascination to help her business; fortune telling is more believable from someone who seems exotic. The hostility she's learned to deflect and ignore. In the worst case, there's always another village. If you've read any cozy found-family novels, you know roughly what happens next. Tao encounters people on the road and, for various reasons, they decide to travel together. The first two are a massive mercenary (Mash) and a semi-reformed thief (Silt), who join Tao somewhat awkwardly after Tao gives Mash a fortune that is far more significant than she intended. One town later, they pick up an apprentice baker best known for her misshapen pastries. They also collect a stray cat, because of course they do. It's that sort of book. For me, this sort of novel lives or dies by the characters, so it's good news that I liked Tao and enjoyed spending time with her. She's quiet, resilient, competent, and self-contained, with a difficult past and some mysteries and emotions the others can draw over time. She's also thoughtful and introspective, which means the tight third-person narration that almost always stays on Tao offers emotional growth to mull over. I also liked Kina (the baker) and Mash; they're a bit more obvious and straightforward, but Kina adds irrepressible energy and Mash is a good example of the sometimes-gruff soldier with a soft heart. Silt was a bit more annoying and I never entirely warmed to him, but he's tolerable and does get a bit of much-needed (if superficial) character development. It takes some time for the reader to learn about the primary conflict of the story (Tao does not give up her secrets quickly), so I won't spoil it, but I thought it worked well. I was momentarily afraid the story would develop a clear villain, but Leong has some satisfying alternate surprises in store. The ending was well-done, although it is very happily-ever-after in a way that may strike some readers as too neat. The Teller of Small Fortunes aims for a quiet and relaxed mood rather than forcing character development through difficult choices; it's a fine aim for a novel, but it won't match everyone's mood. I liked the world-building, although expect small and somewhat disconnected details rather than an overarching theory of magic. Tao's ability gets the most elaboration, for obvious reasons, and I liked how Leong describes it and explores its consequences. Most of the attention in the setting is on the friction, wistfulness, and small reminders of coming from a different culture than everyone around you, but so long ago that you are not fully a part of either world. This, I thought, was very well-done and is one of the places where the story is comfortable with complex feelings and doesn't try to reach a simplifying conclusion. There is one bit of the story that felt like it was taken directly out of a Dungeons & Dragons campaign to a degree that felt jarring, but that was the only odd world-building note. This book felt like a warm cup of tea intended to comfort and relax, without large or complex thoughts about the world. It's not intended to be challenging; there are a few plot twists I didn't anticipate, but nothing that dramatic, and I doubt anyone will be surprised by the conclusions it reaches. It's a pleasant time with some nice people and just enough tension and mystery to add some motivation to find out what happens next. If that's what you're in the mood for, recommended. If you want a book that has Things To Say or will put you on the edge of your seat, maybe save this one for another mood. All the on-line sources I found for this book call it a standalone, but The Keeper of Magical Things is set in the same world, so I would call it a loose series with different protagonists. The Teller of Small Fortunes is a complete story in one book, though. Rating: 7 out of 10

31 March 2026

Russ Allbery: Review: Code Blue Emergency

Review: Code Blue Emergency, by James White
Series: Sector General #7
Publisher: Orb
Copyright: 1987
Printing: May 2003
ISBN: 0-7653-0663-8
Format: Trade paperback
Pages: 252
Code Blue Emergency (annoying em-dash in original title) is the seventh book of James White's Sector General science fiction series about a vast multi-species hospital station. While there are some references to (and spoilers for) earlier books in the series, you don't have to remember the previous books to read this one. I had no trouble despite a nine-year gap. I read this as part of the Orb General Practice omnibus, which collects this novel and The Genocidal Healer. Cha Thrat is a Sommaradvan warrior-surgeon, member of a newly-discovered species that is beginning the process of contact with the Federation. She saved a Monitor corps human after an accident on her world, performing some some highly competent surgery on a species she had never seen before. That plus her somewhat outcast status on her own world due to her very traditional attitude towards medical ethics led Sector General to extend an offer of medical internship, and led her to leap into the unknown by accepting. This may have been a mistake; there is a great deal that Sector General does not understand about Sommaradvan medical ethics. This series entry is another proper (if somewhat episodic) novel and the first book of the series that doesn't primarily focus on Conway. He makes an appearance in his new role as Diagnostician, but only as a supporting character. Code Blue Emergency is told in the tight third-person perspective of Cha Thrat, an alien who finds many things about Sector General baffling, confusing, and ethically troubling (and who therefore provides a good reader surrogate for reintroducing the basics of how the hospital works). Using an alien viewpoint is a more sophisticated narrative technique than White has used previously. I'm glad he tried it, and it mostly works, although I have some complaints. Cha Thrat comes from the middle caste of a strictly hierarchical society of three castes, but is also immensely stubborn and used to a medical system in which doctors take sole responsibility for their patients. This creates a lot of cultural conflicts, and I do enjoy science fiction where the human attitudes are portrayed as the strange ones, but the cultural analysis offered by this novel is not very deep. The pattern of this book is for Cha Thrat to stumble into a successful approach to a problem while being either oblivious to or hostile to the normal hierarchical structure expected of medical trainees. This is believable as far as it goes. She is a skilled and intelligent doctor with some good instincts and a strong commitment to patient care, but is also culturally inclined to not ask for help. It makes sense for that to be a serious problem in a hospital. Unfortunately, no one says this directly. Sector General staff get quite upset in ways that seem more territorial than oriented towards patient safety, no one directly explains to Cha Thrat why following a process is important or shows examples of what could go wrong, and plot armor means that her mistakes usually have positive outcomes. One can extrapolate the reasons why she is not a good medical student, but the reader is forced to do the extrapolation. This is the sort of book where the narration makes clear there are unresolved cultural clashes that are going to cause problems but hides the details. To Cha Thrat, her perspective is so obvious she never bothers to explain it to the reader, so the specifics come as a surprise. As with the alien perspective, I've seen this technique used with more subtlety and sophistication in other books, but White's version mostly works. Cha Thrat is a sympathetic protagonist because she is truly trying to take the most ethical and empathetic action in every situation and is clearly competent. Most of my frustration as a reader, ironically, lands on the other Sector General doctors who seem to make little to no effort to understand her perspective when she fails to conform to their expectations. This is believable in the abstract, but the whole point of Sector General is that they're supposed to be wiser about interspecies difference than this. Also, sometimes their reactions just seem petty. Cha Thrat has a very hierarchical concept of medicine that matches the social classes of her culture. For her, the highest tier of doctor are wizards who treat rulers, because the work of rulers is mostly mental and intellectual and therefore the diseases of rulers are treated with magic spells performed with words to reshape their thinking rather than surgery on their bodies. O'Mara and the other Sector General psychologists take great offense at this, muttering about being called witch doctors, which I found completely absurd. This is a comprehensible, if odd, description of psychology from a wholly alien species. Surely one's first reaction should be that words like "wizard" or "magic" are translation errors. Don't get offended; look to see if the underlying substance matches, which it clearly does. Apart from cultural and psychological clashes, Code Blue Emergency has the standard episodic Sector General structure of interesting medical mysteries that require lateral thinking. I find this sort of puzzle story satisfying, particularly given the firm belief of every character in an essentially pacifist and empathetic approach to even the most alien of creatures. This determined non-violence is one of the more interesting things about this series, and it continues here. White does tend towards both biological and gender essentialism for everyone other than the protagonist and main supporting characters, but he seemed to be walking back some of the more outrageous limitations on women that appeared in previous books. There is still some nonsense in here about how females of any species can't be Diagnosticians, but then Cha Thrat, who is female, seems to violate the justification for that rule over the course of this novel (sadly without comment). Perhaps he's setting up for proving Sector General wrong about this prejudice. I picked this up after reading Elizabeth Bear's Machine, which is essentially a (better written) Sector General novel that got me in the mood for reading more. I wouldn't give Code Blue Emergency any awards, but it delivered exactly what I was looking for. This series is not as deep or well-written as some more recent SF, but it is reliably itself and reliably entertaining. There are worse things in a series. Recommended if you're in the mood for alien ER in space. The omnibus edition that I read has an introduction to both novels by John Clute. It does add some interesting insights, but (as is somewhat typical for Clute) it also spoils parts of both books. You may want to read it after you read the novels. Followed by The Genocidal Healer. Rating: 7 out of 10

30 March 2026

Russ Allbery: Review: The Cloak and Its Wizard

Review: The Cloak and Its Wizard, by R.Z. Nicolet
Publisher: UpLit Press
Copyright: February 2026
ISBN: 1-917849-15-X
Format: Kindle
Pages: 423
The Cloak and Its Wizard is a standalone (at least so far) urban fantasy superhero (sort of) novel. R.Z. Nicolet is the marketing pseudonym for Rachel Reddick. This is her first novel.
I'm picky about wizards. The wizards themselves will complain about that, but of course I'm picky. When I choose a wizard, barring utter abandonment of moral scruples, it's a till-death-do-us-part situation. (Their death, not mine. I'm the next best thing to indestructible.)
The Cloak of Sunset and Starlight is a major artifact, meaning that it has its own preferences and is capable of independent action. It has been sitting in a glass case in the wizards' library for about a hundred years, waiting for someone interesting. (Well, mostly sitting. Occasionally it sneaks out to eavesdrop or move the books around.) Veronica Noble is interesting. She's older than most initiates, thoughtful, observant, and clearly had some mundane career before joining the Order. Her aura is appealing, and her mental shields and resistance to influence are intriguing. Normally, the Cloak would take its time investigating a new potential wizard, but the Sword was making thoughtful rattling sounds, and no way is the Cloak going to let the Sword claim her first. Time to choose a new wizard!
It was nice, being draped over warm shoulders, and feeling a heartbeat again. I could tell she closed her eyes without even looking. She sighed. "I just got picked by the intransigent one, didn't I?"
The last time I picked a book from the Big Idea feature in Scalzi's Whatever blog, it didn't go that well, but if you're going to write a book specifically for me, I'm going to read it. There are very few tropes of SFF that I love more than intelligent companion objects, and Nicolet's introduction to the story was compelling. So I gave this book discovery method another chance. I'm glad I did, because this was exactly what I was in the mood for and a delight from cover to cover. Veronica Noble is not a typical wizard. She's a surgeon and was quite happy to be a surgeon until an unexpected encounter with a magical creature killed her brother. The forgetting spell cast by the wizards who came to handle the Cassandra wyrm didn't work on her, so she was dragged reluctantly into the secret magical world of the Order. This long-lived society of wizards quietly defends the world against magical intrusions from other planes of existence. Now she's a wizard with a magical cloak, which she is not at all sure she wants. Veronica is not the protagonist, though. The Cloak of Sunset and Starlight is. As far as it is concerned, its job is to assist its wizard, enjoy watching interesting feats of magic, and look fabulous doing so. It's protective, dramatic, rather vain, endlessly curious, easily bored, and intensely loyal. When it becomes clear that the Order has some serious problems, the Cloak knows what side it's on. This sounds a bit like urban fantasy, so I was surprised when the first superheroes showed up, although given the explicit Doctor Strange inspiration I probably should have expected them. The Order and the superheroes do not mix, at least at the start of the novel. The wizards view the superheroes as a loud and irritating intrusion and hide magical activities from them the same as they do the rest of the world. Veronica's opening opinion on superheroes is based on being a trauma surgeon in a hospital dealing with the aftermath of their fights (which makes me wonder if the author has read Hench, although the idea is older than that book). As with the Order, the role of superheroes in this world gets more complicated as the plot develops. There is a surprising amount of plot and some very nice world-building here, including multiple twists that I was not expecting. Veronica is the sort of stubborn and deeply ethical person who will not leave a problem alone if she has the ability to fix it, which is a good recipe for getting deeper and deeper into a complex plot. She's believable as a surgeon: somewhat taciturn, calm in emergencies, detail-oriented, methodical, and not at all dramatic. This makes the Cloak a perfect foil and complement. Watching their partnership develop was very satisfying. This is a sidekick novel, and like the best sidekick novels it makes the not-protagonist more interesting and more relatable by showing them from an outside and skewed perspective. Piecing together what Veronica must be thinking is part of the fun, as is sharing the Cloak's protectiveness towards her as it becomes clear how much she's been through and how good of a person she is. The Cloak's personality was a little too much like a cat for me I would have preferred a more unique viewpoint, fewer cat-coded shenanigans, and a bit less of the running laundry machine joke. But that's a quibble. Its endless curiosity drives the plot forward and uncovers more of the world-building, and I just love reading stories from the perspective of this sort of loyal and protective magical creature. I had so much fun with this book. It's a popcorn sort of book, and I thought the ending sputtered a little, but overall it was great. Parts of it could have been designed in a lab to appeal to me specifically, so I'm not sure if other people will enjoy it as much, but its hit rate with my friends so far has been good. Highly recommended, and I will be watching for any further novels from Nicolet. The Cloak and Its Wizard reaches a satisfying conclusion and doesn't advertise itself as part of a series, but there is room for a sequel. If Nicolet ever writes one, I'd read it. Rating: 8 out of 10

29 March 2026

Russ Allbery: Review: The Sovereign

Review: The Sovereign, by C.L. Clark
Series: Magic of the Lost #3
Publisher: Orbit
Copyright: September 2025
ISBN: 0-316-54286-5
Format: Kindle
Pages: 575
The Sovereign is the third and concluding book of C.L. Clark's Magic of the Lost high fantasy trilogy. I recommend reading the books of this series close together, since there are a lot of characters and a lot of continuity between books that is helpful to remember, but it was not quite as difficult this time to remember where the story left off. At the end of The Faithless, the political situation in Balladaire (not-France) was more stable, but the threat of a plague lay on the horizon. That threat arrives in earnest in this book, along with new threats from both Balladaire's former colonial conscript soldiers and from neighboring Taargen (not-Germany, sort of, although the parallel isn't as close). Luca and Touraine have finally admitted that they're deeply in love, but they are still very different people with different goals and ethics. Luca is determined to do anything necessary to save her kingdom, but her definition of her kingdom is sharp and brittle. Touraine is torn between far too many loyalties, plus the lingering worry that her morals and Luca's may not be compatible. I think the hardest part of this sort of series is finding an ending the reader will find satisfying. This one, unfortunately, did not work for me, but that may be more due to personal preference than objective flaws. There have been two threads through this series: an improbable romance embedded in a network of complex personal relationships, and a political commentary on colonialism and post-colonial wars. I was enjoying the former, but it was the latter that felt fresh and interesting to me. The plot threads in The Faithless outside of Balladaire expanded that complexity, and I was hoping the final volume would continue in that direction. How could a colonial power atone for its history? How does the former colony establish its own governance? Is there a path to freedom without violence? Are attempts to chart a more moral course doomed to open lines of attack for one's other enemies? It's clear that Clark was thinking about similar themes, but The Sovereign narrows the field instead of widens it, restricts the political options, and then resolves most questions in a massive war. This is not that surprising of a conclusion, but it's one that I found unsatisfying and, honestly, a little boring. Yes, one way to resolve all the competing tensions is for everyone to try to kill each other and whoever survives wins, and historically that's one of the more likely outcomes, but that ending doesn't wrestle with the politics as much as it collapses them. Clark instead focuses this concluding volume on the romance, which becomes even more fraught, tragic, and dramatic than it was in previous books (and that's saying something). The hard questions of divided loyalties and moral conflicts are mostly framed by questions about Touraine's loyalty to Luca and Luca's trust of Touraine. This is all very Shakespearean, full of hard choices, sudden reversals, miscommunication, and a very deep conflict between Luca's realpolitik and Touraine's stubborn personal morality. If this is what you were reading the series for, if you were hoping for a maximum-drama sapphic relationship, you may thoroughly enjoy this. I thought it had its moments, but I wish they had been balanced by more moments of cool-headed practicality and creative political ingenuity. My biggest frustration with this ending is that the characters largely stop doing politics. The political complexity was the strength of both The Unbroken and The Faithless: People who intensely dislike each other negotiate because there is something larger to be gained, personal decisions made without considering the political ramifications have costs, and multiple characters are trying hard to find a way to turn a nasty, exploitative world into something better without simply killing everyone who disagrees. Many of the characters were objectively bad at politics, inexperienced and immature, but they stumbled or dragged or fought their way into political solutions anyway. I thought Clark moved too far away from that in The Sovereign. Everyone goes deep into their own emotions and desire for vengeance or conquest or revolution and stops compromising. To a depressingly large extent, the story is resolved by killing everyone who disagrees. I think the story is poorer for it. One of the other threads of the series is Balladairan magic, or rather its odd absence. Luca has one understanding of it, the rebels introduced in The Faithless have a different understanding of it, and its pursuit is set up as critical to resolving the threat of a plague. We do get an explanation of sorts, but it's not as complete or as satisfying as I was hoping, and the symbolism of Balladaire's missing magic is left frustratingly murky. For me, this has some of the same problems as the political conclusion: I wanted an intellectual catharsis alongside the emotional catharsis, but that was not the direction Clark was taking the story. I like reading about these characters. All of Luca, Touraine, and Pruett are complex, comprehensible, flawed, and often intriguing. But my favorite character in the story, the person I latched on to as an emotional path through the story, was Sabine. Her refreshingly straightforward loyalty and lack of drama was a breath of fresh air. She has some great moments in this book, but there too I got wrong-footed by the direction Clark went with her arc and found its conclusion deeply unsatisfying. I'm not sure how many of these complaints are because of missed opportunities in the novel, how many were due to a mismatch of taste, and how many were due to not being in the right mood to read this conclusion. I'm sure that it didn't help that I read this simultaneous with another novel in which the characters were always miserable, or that I read it in early 2026 with, uh, all that entails. I suspect that if you came away from the first two books invested in the messy romance and wanting MOAR DRAMA, you may get exactly what you were hoping for. That, sadly, was not what I was hoping for. I can't really recommend this. I thought it dragged in places and didn't deliver the ending I wanted. But it has some great moments, it does wrap up the threads of the trilogy as advertised, and at least the romance gets a dramatic climax worthy of the tension that has been built through the previous books. If that matches what you were enjoying in the previous books, you may well enjoy this more than I did. Rating: 5 out of 10

24 March 2026

Russ Allbery: Review: A Shadow in Summer

Review: A Shadow in Summer, by Daniel Abraham
Series: Long Price Quartet #1
Publisher: Tor
Copyright: March 2006
ISBN: 0-7653-1340-5
Format: Hardcover
Pages: 331
A Shadow in Summer is a high fantasy novel, the first of (as the name implies) a completed four-book series. Daniel Abraham is perhaps better known as half of the writing pair behind James S.A. Corey, author of the Expanse series. This was his first novel. Otah was the sixth son of a Khai, sent like many of the unwanted later children of the powerful to learn the secrets of the andat and be trained as a poet. He learned his lessons well enough to reject the school and its teachings and walk away. Amat Kyaan has worked her way up from nothing to become the senior overseer of the foreign Galtic House Wilsin in the sun-drenched port city of Saraykeht. Liat is her apprentice, distracted by young love. Maati is a new apprentice poet, having endured his training and sent to learn from Heshai how to eventually hold the andat Removing-The-Part-That-Continues, better known as Seedless. None of them know they will find themselves entangled in a plot to destroy the poet of Saraykeht and, through him, the city's most potent economic tool. A poet in this world is not what we would think of a poet. They are, in essence, magical slave-drivers who capture the essence of an andat, a spirit embodying an idea that is coerced into the prison of volition and obedience by the poet. The andat Seedless, the embodiment of the concept of removing the spark of life, is central to the economic wealth of Saraykeht in a way that is startling in its simplicity: Seedless can remove the seeds from a warehouse full of cotton at a thought. This gives Saraykeht a massive productivity advantage in the cotton trade. Seedless is also a powerful potential weapon. What he can do to cotton, he could as easily do to any other crop, or to people. The Galts are not fond of the independence and power of Saraykeht, but as long as the city controls a powerful andat, they do not dare to attack it directly. Indirectly, though... that's another matter. This is one of those fantasy novels with meticulous and thoughtful world-building, careful and evocative prose, and a complex ensemble cast of interesting characters that the novel then attempts to make utterly miserable and complicit in their own misery. There should be a name for this style of writing. It's not tragedy because the ending is not tragic, precisely. It's not magic realism; the andats are openly magical, which makes this clearly high fantasy. But Abraham approaches the story from the type of realist frame that considers the pain and desperation of the characters to be more interesting than their ability to overcome challenges. Amat starts the story as an admirable, sharp-witted expert manager, so her life is destroyed and she's subjected to sexual violence. Heshai loathes himself and veers between a tragic figure and a wastrel as the story systematically undermines opportunities for redemption. Maati is young and idealistic, so of course every character in the book sets out to crush his idealism under the weight of unforeseen consequences. There is a sad and depressing love triangle, because this is exactly the sort of book that has a sad and depressing love triangle. At the end of the novel, everyone who survives is older and wiser in the sense that some stories seem to think wisdom comes from the accumulation of trauma. I find books like this so immensely frustrating because their merits are so clear. The world-building is careful and detailed in a way that includes economic systems, unlike so much fantasy. It is full of small, intriguing touches, such as the use of posture and gesture to communicate the emotional valence of one's words. Abraham understands the moral implications of poets and andats and the story tackles them head-on. The writing flows beautifully and gave me a strong sense of the city. I wanted to like this book for the obvious skill that went into it, and sometimes I even managed. And yet, it's taken me three months to finish A Shadow in Summer because I simply do not want to spend this much time around miserable people. I would get through one or two chapters in a night and then wanted to read something happy or defiant or heroic, rather than watching slow-motion train wrecks intermixed with desperate attempts to navigate stifling layers of immoral systems. It's not that the story lacks a moral compass. The characters are sincerely trying to make the world a better place, with some success. It even delivers a happy ending of sorts. But so much of the journey was watching the lives of the characters fall apart. I am completely unsurprised that some people loved this book. I'm still intrigued enough by the world-building that I'm half-tempted to try to read the sequel even after having to drag myself through this one. I had a similar reaction to Abraham's The Dragon's Path, though, so I think Abraham is just not for me. I may get back to the Expanse at some point, but having to drag myself through both of his solo novels I've tried, in two different series, probably indicates an incompatibility between author and reader. That's a shame, given the quality of the writing. Followed by A Betrayal in Winter. Content notes: Sexual and reproductive violence as significant plot elements. Rating: 6 out of 10

23 March 2026

Russ Allbery: Review: Dark Class

Review: Dark Class, by Michelle Diener
Series: Class 5 #5
Publisher: Eclipse
Copyright: 2022
ISBN: 0-6454658-2-8
Format: Kindle
Pages: 349
Dark Class is the fifth novel (not counting the skippable novella) in Michelle Diener's Class 5 romantic science fiction series. As with the previous novels, this follows romance series conventions: There are new protagonists, but characters from the previous books make an appearance. It's helpful but not that necessary to remember the details of the previous books; the necessary background is explained enough to follow the story. By now, series readers know the formula. Yet another Earth woman was secretly abducted by the Tecran, encounters a Class 5 ship, and finds a way to be surprisingly dangerous and politically destabilizing. This time, Ellie has been mostly unconscious since her abduction and awakes in a secret Tecran base after the Tecran have all been murdered. There is a Class 5 AI involved, but not a full ship; instead, Dark Class picks up (or, arguably, manufactures) a loose end from Dark Minds. Other than that break from the formula, you know what to expected by now: a hunky Grih, a tricky political standoff, a protective Class 5, a slow-burn romance, and a surprisingly capable protagonist who upends politics through plucky grit and refusal to tolerate poor treatment. Oh, and a new selection of salvaged clothing and weapons to make Ellie beautiful and surprisingly dangerous. If you are this far into the series, you probably like the formula. That's my position. I don't care about the romance, but something about the prisoner to threat evolution of the kidnapped protagonists and the growing friendship with an AI makes me happy. This is not great literature, but it is reliably entertaining with a guaranteed victorious protagonist and happy ending, making it a comfortable break from more difficult books with emotionally wrenching scenes. Dark Class is one of the better executions of the formula because it has long stretches of my favorite parts of these books: exploration of mostly-abandoned surroundings for neat gadgets while the AI and the protagonist slowly build a relationship of mutual respect. This book has bonus drones with minds of their own and an enigmatic alien spaceship that provides a fun mid-novel twist. The Tecran and the Grih repeatedly underestimate Ellie and are caught by surprise at dramatically satisfying moments. It's just fun to read, and I save this series for when I need that type of book. As with the other books of the series, Diener's writing is serviceable but not great. She repeats herself, uses way too many paragraph breaks for emphasis, and is not going to win any literary awards for prose quality. The series is in the upper half of self-published works, and I've certainly read worse, but either the formula will click with you or it won't. If it doesn't, the prose is not going to salvage the book. There is some development of the series plot, but it's mostly predictable fallout from Dark Matters. This book is mostly tactical and smaller in scale. I am a little curious where Diener is going with political developments, since the accumulated Earth women and Class 5 ships are in some danger of becoming a sort of shadow government through sheer military power, but I'm dubious this series will have enough political sophistication to dig into the implications. It's best enjoyed as small-scale episodic wish fulfillment for female protagonists, and that's good enough for me. If you've read this far in the series, recommended; this is one of the stronger entries. Followed by Collision Course, which breaks the title convention for the series. Rating: 7 out of 10

16 March 2026

Russ Allbery: Review: The Martian Contingency

Review: The Martian Contingency, by Mary Robinette Kowal
Series: Lady Astronaut #4
Publisher: Tor
Copyright: 2025
ISBN: 1-250-23703-3
Format: Kindle
Pages: 390
The Martian Contingency is the fourth book of the mostly-realistic science fiction alternate history series that began with the novelette "The Lady Astronaut of Mars" and the novel The Calculating Stars. It returns to Elma York as the main character, covering her second trip to Mars after the events of The Fated Sky. It's helpful to remember the events of the previous two books to follow some of the plot. Elma is back on Mars, this time as second in command. The immediate goal of the second Mars mission is to open more domes and land additional crew currently in orbit, creating the first permanent human settlement on Mars. The long-term goal is to set up Mars as a refuge in case the greenhouse effect caused by the meteor strike in The Calculating Stars continues to spiral out of control. Elma is anxious and not looking forward to being partly in charge, particularly since her position is partly due to her fame with the public (and connection with the American president). She'd rather just be a pilot. But she'll do what the mission needs from her, and at least this time her husband is with her on Mars. As one might expect from earlier installments of this series, The Martian Contingency starts with the details and rhythms of life in a dangerous, highly technical, and mission-driven scientific environment: hard science fiction of the type most closely modeled on NASA and real space missions. Given that this is aimed at permanent Mars colonies that would theoretically have to be independent of Earth, it requires a huge amount of suspension of disbelief for the premise, but Kowal at least tries for verisimilitude in the small details. I am not an expert in early space program technology (Kowal's alternate history diverges into a greatly accelerated space program in the 1950s and, for example, uses female mathematicians for most calculations), so I don't know how successful this is, but it feels crunchy and believable. As with the previous books, though, this is not just a day in the life of an astronaut. There's something wrong, something that happened during the first Mars expedition while Elma was in orbit and left odd physical clues, and no one is willing to talk about it. Elma is just starting to poke around before the politics at home go off the rails (again), exacerbated by a cringe-worthy social error by Elma herself, and she once again has to navigate egregious sexism and political meddling in a highly dangerous environment a long way from home. It is a little surprising that I like this series as much as I do. I don't particularly care for pseudo-realistic science fiction, although I admit there is something deeply satisfying about reading about people following checklists properly. The idea of permanent Mars colonies as an escape from a doomed Earth is unbelievable and deeply silly, but Kowal locked herself into that alternate future with "The Lady Astronaut of Mars," which is still set in the future of all of the books so far. A primary conflict in each of the books comes from the egregious sexism and racism of a culture based on 1950s American attitudes towards both, and the amount of progress Elma can make against either is limited, contingent, and constantly compromised. And yet. At its best, this series is excellent competence porn, both in the spirit of the Apollo 13 movie and for the navigation of social and political obstacles and idiocy. Elma is highly competent in a believable and sympathetic way, with strengths, weaknesses, and an ongoing struggle with anxiety. There is something rewarding in watching people solve problems and eventually triumph by being professional, careful, principled, and creative. It's enough to make a good book, even if I am not that interested in the setting and technology. As with the rest of the series, this will not be for everyone. You have to be up for reading about a lot of truly awful sexism and racism without the payoff of a complete triumph. This is a system that Elma navigates, not overthrows, and that's not going to be enough for some readers. You also have to accept the premise of a Mars colony, which in an otherwise hard science fiction novel is a bit much despite Kowal's attempts to acknowledge some of the difficulties. But if you don't mind that drawbacks, this series continues to be an opportunity to read about people being quietly and professionally competent. This is not my favorite entry, mostly because Elma makes a rather humiliating mistake that's central to the plot and has a lot of after-effects (and therefore a lot of time in the spotlight), and because there is rather a lot of discussion of sexuality that felt childish to me. The intent was to try to capture the way people in the 1950s talked about sex, and perhaps Kowal was successful in that, but I didn't enjoy the experience. But I still found myself pulled into the plot and happily rooting for the characters, even though a reader of "The Lady Astronaut of Mars" has a pretty good idea of how everything will turn out. If you liked the series so far, recommended, although I doubt it will be the favorite entry for most readers. If you did not like the earlier books of the series, this one will not change your mind. Content notes: Way, way too much detailed discussion of an injury to a fingernail than I wanted to read, as well as some other rather explicit description of physical injury. Reproductive health care through the lens of the 1950s, so, uh, yeah. A whole lot of sexism, racism, and other forms of discrimination that is mostly worked around rather than confronted. Rating: 7 out of 10

1 February 2026

Russ Allbery: Review: Paladin's Faith

Review: Paladin's Faith, by T. Kingfisher
Series: The Saint of Steel #4
Publisher: Red Wombat Studio
Copyright: 2023
ISBN: 1-61450-614-0
Format: Kindle
Pages: 515
Paladin's Faith is the fourth book in T. Kingfisher's loosely connected series of fantasy novels about the berserker former paladins of the Saint of Steel. You could read this as a standalone, but there are numerous (spoilery) references to the previous books in the series. Marguerite, who was central to the plot of the first book in the series, Paladin's Grace, is a spy with a problem. An internal power struggle in the Red Sail, the organization that she's been working for, has left her a target. She has a plan for how to break their power sufficiently that they will hopefully leave her alone, but to pull it off she's going to need help. As the story opens, she is working to acquire that help in a very Marguerite sort of way: breaking into the office of Bishop Beartongue of the Temple of the White Rat. The Red Sail, the powerful merchant organization Marguerite worked for, makes their money in the salt trade. Marguerite has learned that someone invented a cheap and reproducible way to extract salt from sea water, thus making the salt trade irrelevant. The Red Sail wants to ensure that invention never sees the light of day, and has forced the artificer into hiding. Marguerite doesn't know where they are, but she knows where she can find out: the Court of Smoke, where the artificer has a patron.
Having grown up in Anuket City, Marguerite was familiar with many clockwork creations, not to mention all the ways that they could go horribly wrong. (Ninety-nine times out of a hundred, it was an explosion. The hundredth time, it ran amok and stabbed innocent bystanders, and the artificer would be left standing there saying, "But I had to put blades on it, or how would it rake the leaves?" while the gutters filled up with blood.)
All Marguerite needs to put her plan into motion is some bodyguards so that she's not constantly distracted and anxious about being assassinated. Readers of this series will be unsurprised to learn that the bodyguards she asks Beartongue for are paladins, including a large broody male one with serious self-esteem problems. This is, like the other books in this series, a slow-burn romance with infuriating communication problems and a male protagonist who would do well to seek out a sack of hammers as a mentor. However, it has two things going for it that most books in this series do not: a long and complex plot to which the romance takes a back seat, and Marguerite, who is not particularly interested in playing along with the expected romance developments. There are also two main paladins in this story, not just one, and the other is one of the two female paladins of the Saint of Steel and rather more entertaining than Shane. I generally like court intrigue stories, which is what fills most of this book. Marguerite is an experienced operative, so the reader gets some solid competence porn, and the paladins are fish out of water but are also unexpectedly dangerous, which adds both comedy and satisfying table-turning. I thoroughly enjoyed the maneuvering and the culture clashes. Marguerite is very good at what she does, knows it, and is entirely uninterested in other people's opinions about that, which short-circuits a lot of Shane's most annoying behavior and keeps the story from devolving into mopey angst like some of the books in this series have done. The end of this book takes the plot in a different direction that adds significantly to the world-building, but also has a (thankfully short) depths of despair segment that I endured rather than enjoyed. I am not really in the mood for bleak hopelessness in my fiction at the moment, even if the reader is fairly sure it will be temporary. But apart from that, I thoroughly enjoyed this book from beginning to end. When we finally meet the artificer, they are an absolute delight in that way that Kingfisher is so good at. The whole story is infused with the sense of determined and competent people refusing to stop trying to fix problems. As usual, the romance was not for me and I think the book would have been better without it, but it's less central to the plot and therefore annoyed me less than any of the books in this series so far. My one major complaint is the lack of gnoles, but we get some new and intriguing world-building to make up for it, along with a setup for a fifth book that I am now extremely curious about. By this point in the series, you probably know if you like the general formula. Compared to the previous book, Paladin's Hope, I thought Paladin's Faith was much stronger and more interesting, but it's clearly of the same type. If, like me, you like the plots but not the romance, the plot here is more substantial. You will have to decide if that makes up for a romance in the typical T. Kingfisher configuration. Personally, I enjoyed this quite a bit, except for the short bleak part, and I'm back to eagerly awaiting the next book in the series. Rating: 8 out of 10

31 January 2026

Russ Allbery: Review: Dragon Pearl

Review: Dragon Pearl, by Yoon Ha Lee
Series: Thousand Worlds #1
Publisher: Rick Riordan Presents
Copyright: 2019
ISBN: 1-368-01519-0
Format: Kindle
Pages: 315
Dragon Pearl is a middle-grade space fantasy based on Korean mythology and the first book of a series. Min is a fourteen-year-old girl living on the barely-terraformed world of Jinju with her extended family. Her older brother Jun passed the entrance exams for the Academy and left to join the Thousand Worlds Space Forces, and Min is counting the years until she can do the same. Those plans are thrown into turmoil when an official investigator appears at their door claiming that Jun deserted to search for the Dragon Pearl. A series of impulsive fourteen-year-old decisions lead to Min heading for a spaceport alone, determined to find her brother and prove his innocence. This would be a rather improbable quest for a young girl, but Min is a gumiho, one of the supernaturals who live in the Thousand Worlds alongside non-magical humans. Unlike the more respectable dragons, tigers, goblins, and shamans, gumiho are viewed with suspicion and distrust because their powers are useful for deception. They are natural shapeshifters who can copy the shapes of others, and their Charm ability lets them influence people's thoughts and create temporary illusions of objects such as ID cards. It will take all of Min's powers, and some rather lucky coincidences, to infiltrate the Space Forces and determine what happened to her brother. It's common for reviews of this book to open with a caution that this is a middle-grade adventure novel and you should not expect a story like Ninefox Gambit. I will be boring and repeat that caution. Dragon Pearl has a single first-person viewpoint and a very linear and straightforward plot. Adult readers are unlikely to be surprised by plot twists; the fun is the world-building and seeing how Min manages to work around plot obstacles. The world-building is enjoyable but not very rigorous. Min uses and abuses Charm with the creative intensity of a Dungeons & Dragons min-maxer. Each individual event makes sense given the implication that Min is unusually powerful, but I'm dubious about the surrounding society and lack of protections against Charm given what Min is able to do. Min does say that gumiho are rare and many people think they're extinct, which is a bit of a fig leaf, but you'll need to bring your urban fantasy suspension of disbelief skills to this one. I did like that the world-building conceit went more than skin deep and influenced every part of the world. There are ghosts who are critical to the plot. Terraforming is done through magic, hence the quest for the Dragon Pearl and the miserable state of Min's home planet due to its loss. Medical treatment involves the body's meridians, as does engineering: The starships have meridians similar to those of humans, and engineers partly merge with those meridians to adjust them. This is not the sort of book that tries to build rigorous scientific theories or explain them to the reader, and I'm not sure everything would hang together if you poked at it too hard, but Min isn't interested in doing that poking and the story doesn't try to justify itself. It's mostly a vibe, but it's a vibe that I enjoyed and that is rather different than other space fantasy I've read. The characters were okay but never quite clicked for me, in part because proper character exploration would have required Min take a detour from her quest to find her brother and that was not going to happen. The reader gets occasional glimpses of a military SF cadet story and a friendship on false premises story, but neither have time to breathe because Min drops any entanglement that gets in the way of her quest. She's almost amoral in a way that I found believable but not quite aligned with my reading mood. I also felt a bit wrong-footed by how her friendships developed; saying too much more would be a spoiler, but I was expecting more human connection than I got. I think my primary disappointment with this book was something I knew going in, not in any way its fault, and part of the reason why I'd put off reading it: This is pitched at young teenagers and didn't have quite enough plot and characterization complexity to satisfy me. It's a linear, somewhat episodic adventure story with some neat world-building, and it therefore glides over the spots where an adult novel would have added political and factional complexity. That is exactly as advertised, so it's up to you whether that's the book you're in the mood for. One warning: The text of this book opens with an introduction by Rick Riordan that is just fluff marketing and that spoils the first few chapters of the book. It is unmarked as such at the beginning and tricked me into thinking it was the start of the book proper, and then deeply annoyed me. If you do read this book, I recommend skipping the utterly pointless introduction and going straight to chapter one. Followed by Tiger Honor. Rating: 6 out of 10

3 January 2026

Russ Allbery: Review: Challenges of the Deeps

Review: Challenges of the Deeps, by Ryk E. Spoor
Series: Arenaverse #3
Publisher: Baen
Copyright: March 2017
ISBN: 1-62579-564-5
Format: Kindle
Pages: 438
Challenges of the Deeps is the third book in the throwback space opera Arenaverse series. It is a direct sequel to Spheres of Influence, but Spoor provides a substantial recap of the previous volumes for those who did not read the series in close succession (thank you!). Ariane has stabilized humanity's position in the Arena with yet another improbable victory. (If this is a spoiler for previous volumes, so was telling you the genre of the book.) Now is a good opportunity to fulfill the promise humanity made to their ally Orphan: accompaniment on a journey into the uncharted deeps of the Arena for reasons that Orphan refuses to explain in advance. Her experienced crew provide multiple options to serve as acting Leader of Humanity until she gets back. What can go wrong? The conceit of this series is that as soon as a species achieves warp drive technology, their ships are instead transported into the vast extradimensional structure of the Arena where a godlike entity controls the laws of nature and enforces a formal conflict resolution process that looks alternatingly like a sporting event, a dueling code, and technology-capped total war. Each inhabitable system in the real universe seems to correspond to an Arena sphere, but the space between them is breathable atmosphere filled with often-massive storms. In other words, this is an airship adventure as written by E.E. "Doc" Smith. Sort of. There is an adventure, and there are a lot of airships (although they fight mostly like spaceships), but much of the action involves tense mental and physical sparring with a previously unknown Arena power with unclear motives. My general experience with this series is that I find the Arena concept fascinating and want to read more about it, Spoor finds his much-less-original Hyperion Project in the backstory of the characters more fascinating and wants to write about that, and we reach a sort of indirect, grumbling (on my part) truce where I eagerly wait for more revelations about the Arena and roll my eyes at the Hyperion stuff. Talking about Hyperion in detail is probably a spoiler for at least the first book, but I will say that it's an excuse to embed versions of literary characters into the story and works about as well as most such excuses (not very). The characters in question are an E.E. "Doc" Smith mash-up, a Monkey King mash-up, and a number of other characters that are obviously references to something but for whom I lack enough hints to place (which is frustrating). Thankfully we get far less human politics and a decent amount of Arena world-building in this installment. Hyperion plays a role, but mostly as foreshadowing for the next volume and the cause of a surprising interaction with Arena rules. One of the interesting wrinkles of this series is that humanity have an odd edge against the other civilizations in part because we're borderline insane sociopaths from the perspective of the established powers. That's an old science fiction trope, but I prefer it to the Campbell-style belief in inherent human superiority. Old science fiction tropes are what you need to be in the mood for to enjoy this series. This is an unapologetic and intentional throwback to early pulp: individuals who can be trusted with the entire future of humanity because they're just that moral, super-science, psychic warfare, and even coruscating beams that would make E.E. "Doc" Smith proud. It's an occasionally glorious but mostly silly pile of technobabble, but Spoor takes advantage of the weird, constructed nature of the Arena to provide more complex rules than competitive superlatives. The trick is that while this is certainly science fiction pulp, it's also a sort of isekai novel. There's a lot of anime and manga influence just beneath the surface. I'm not sure why it never occurred to me before reading this series that melodramatic anime and old SF pulps have substantial aesthetic overlap, but of course they do. I loved the Star Blazers translated anime that I watched as a kid precisely because it had the sort of dramatic set pieces that make the Lensman novels so much fun. There is a bit too much Wu Kong in this book for me (although the character is growing on me a little), and some of the maneuvering around the mysterious new Arena actor drags on longer than was ideal, but the climax is great stuff if you're in the mood for dramatic pulp adventure. The politics do not bear close examination and the writing is serviceable at best, but something about this series is just fun. I liked this book much better than Spheres of Influence, although I wish Spoor would stop being so coy about the nature of the Arena and give us more substantial revelations. I'm also now tempted to re-read Lensman, which is probably a horrible idea. (Spoor leaves the sexism out of his modern pulp.) If you got through Spheres of Influence with your curiosity about the Arena intact, consider this one when you're in the mood for modern pulp, although don't expect any huge revelations. It's not the best-written book, but it sits squarely in the center of a genre and mood that's otherwise a bit hard to find. Followed by the Kickstarter-funded Shadows of Hyperion, which sadly looks like it's going to concentrate on the Hyperion Project again. I will probably pick that up... eventually. Rating: 6 out of 10

1 January 2026

Russ Allbery: 2025 Book Reading in Review

In 2025, I finished and reviewed 32 books, not counting another five books I've finished but not yet reviewed and which will therefore roll over to 2026. This was not a great reading year, although not my worst reading year since I started keeping track. I'm not entirely sure why, although part of the explanation was that I hit a bad stretch of books in spring of 2025 and got into a bit of a reading slump. Mostly, though, I shifted a lot of reading this year to short non-fiction (newsletters and doom-scrolling) and spent rather more time than I intended watching YouTube videos, and sadly each hour in the day can only be allocated one way. This year felt a bit like a holding pattern. I have some hopes of being more proactive and intentional in 2026. I'm still working on finding a good balance between all of my hobbies and the enjoyment of mindless entertainment. The best book I read this year was also the last book I reviewed (and yes, I snuck the review under the wire for that reason): Bethany Jacobs's This Brutal Moon, the conclusion of the Kindom Trilogy that started with These Burning Stars. I thought the first two books of the series were interesting but flawed, but the conclusion blew me away and improved the entire trilogy in retrospect. Like all books I rate 10 out of 10, I'm sure a large part of my reaction is idiosyncratic, but two friends of mine also loved the conclusion so it's not just me. The stand-out non-fiction book of the year was Rory Stewart's Politics on the Edge. I have a lot of disagreements with Stewart's political positions (the more I listen to him, the more disagreements I find), but he is an excellent memoirist who skewers the banality, superficiality, and contempt for competence that has become so prevailing in centrist and right-wing politics. It's hard not to read this book and despair of electoralism and the current structures of governments, but it's bracing to know that even some people I disagree with believe in the value of expertise. I also finished Suzanne Palmer's excellent Finder Chronicles series, reading The Scavenger Door and Ghostdrift. This series is some of the best science fiction I've read in a long time and I'm sad it is over (at least for now). Palmer has a new, unrelated book coming in 2026 (Ode to the Half-Broken), and I'm looking forward to reading that. This year, I experimented with re-reading books I had already reviewed for the first time since I started writing reviews. After my reading slump, I felt like revisiting something I knew I liked, and therefore re-read C.J. Cherryh's Cyteen and Regenesis. Cyteen mostly held up, but Regenesis was worse than I had remembered. I experimented with a way to add on to my previous reviews, but I didn't like the results and the whole process of re-reading and re-reviewing annoyed me. I'm counting this as a failed experiment, which means I've still not solved the problem of how to revisit series that I read long enough ago that I want to re-read them before picking up the new book. (You may have noticed that I've not read the new Jacqueline Carey Kushiel novel, for example.) You may have also noticed that I didn't start a new series re-read, or continue my semi-in-progress re-reads of Mercedes Lackey or David Eddings. I have tentative plans to kick off a new series re-read in 2026, but I'm not ready to commit to that yet. As always, I have no firm numeric goals for the next year, but I hope to avoid another reading slump and drag my reading attention back from lower-quality and mostly-depressing material in 2026. The full analysis includes some additional personal reading statistics, probably only of interest to me.

Russ Allbery: Review: This Brutal Moon

Review: This Brutal Moon, by Bethany Jacobs
Series: Kindom Trilogy #3
Publisher: Orbit
Copyright: December 2025
ISBN: 0-316-46373-6
Format: Kindle
Pages: 497
This Brutal Moon is a science fiction thriller with bits of cyberpunk and space opera. It concludes the trilogy begun with These Burning Stars. The three books tell one story in three volumes, and ideally you would read all three in close succession. There is a massive twist in the first book that I am still not trying to spoil, so please forgive some vague description. At the conclusion of These Burning Stars, Jacobs had moved a lot of pieces into position, but it was not yet clear to me where the plot was going, or even if it would come to a solid ending in three volumes as promised by the series title. It does. This Brutal Moon opens with some of the political maneuvering that characterized These Burning Stars, but once things start happening, the reader gets all of the action they could wish for and then some. I am pleased to report that, at least as far as I'm concerned, Jacobs nails the ending. Not only is it deeply satisfying, the characterization in this book is so good, and adds so smoothly to the characterization of the previous books, that I saw the whole series in a new light. I thought this was one of the best science fiction series finales I've ever read. Take that with a grain of salt, since some of those reasons are specific to me and the mood I was in when I read it, but this is fantastic stuff. There is a lot of action at the climax of this book, split across at least four vantage points and linked in a grand strategy with chaotic surprises. I kept all of the pieces straight and understood how they were linked thanks to Jacobs's clear narration, which is impressive given the number of pieces in motion. That's not the heart of this book, though. The action climax is payoff for the readers who want to see some ass-kicking, and it does contain some moving and memorable moments, but it relies on some questionable villain behavior and a convenient plot device introduced only in this volume. The action-thriller payoff is competent but not, I think, outstanding. What put this book into a category of its own were the characters, and specifically how Jacobs assembles sweeping political consequences from characters who, each alone, would never have brought about such a thing, and in some cases had little desire for it. Looking back on the trilogy, I think Jacobs has captured, among all of the violence and action-movie combat and space-opera politics, the understanding that political upheaval is a relay race. The people who have the personalities to start it don't have the personality required to nurture it or supply it, and those who can end it are yet again different. This series is a fascinating catalog of political actors the instigator, the idealist, the pragmatist, the soldier, the one who supports her friends, and several varieties and intensities of leaders and it respects all of them without anointing any of them as the One True Revolutionary. The characters are larger than life, yes, and this series isn't going to win awards for gritty realism, but it's saying something satisfyingly complex about where we find courage and how a cause is pushed forward by different people with different skills and emotions at different points in time. Sometimes accidentally, and often in entirely unexpected ways. As before, the main story is interwoven with flashbacks. This time, we finally see the full story of the destruction of the moon of Jeve. The reader has known about this since the first volume, but Jacobs has a few more secrets to show (including, I will admit, setting up a plot device) and some pointed commentary on resource extraction economies. I think this part of the book was a bit obviously constructed, although the characterization was great and the visible junction points of the plot didn't stop me from enjoying the thrill when the pieces came together. But the best part of this book was the fact there was 10% of it left after the climax. Jacobs wrote an actual denouement, and it was everything I wanted and then some. We get proper story conclusions for each of the characters, several powerful emotional gut punches, some remarkably subtle and thoughtful discussion of political construction for a series that tended more towards space-opera action, and a conclusion for the primary series relationship that may not be to every reader's taste but was utterly, perfectly, beautifully correct for mine. I spent a whole lot of the last fifty pages of this book trying not to cry, in the best way. The character evolution over the course of this series is simply superb. Each character ages like fine wine, developing more depth, more nuance, but without merging. They become more themselves, which is an impressive feat across at least four very different major characters. You can see the vulnerabilities and know what put them there, you can see the strengths they developed to compensate, and you can see why they need the support the other characters provide. And each of them is so delightfully different. This was so good. This was so precisely the type of story that I was in the mood for, with just the type of tenderness for its characters that I wanted, that I am certain I am not objective about it. It will be one of those books where other people will complain about flaws that I didn't see or didn't care about because it was doing the things I wanted from it so perfectly. It's so good that it elevated the entire trilogy; the journey was so worth the ending. I'm afraid this review will be less than helpful because it's mostly nonspecific raving. This series is such a spoiler minefield that I'd need a full spoiler review to be specific, but my reaction is so driven by emotion that I'm not sure that would help if the characters didn't strike you the way that they struck me. I think the best advice I can offer is to say that if you liked the emotional tone of the end of These Burning Stars (not the big plot twist, the character reaction to the political goal that you learn drove the plot), stick with the series, because that's a sign of the questions Jacobs is asking. If you didn't like the characters at the end (not the middle) of the first novel, bail out, because you're going to get a lot more of that. Highly, highly recommended, and the best thing I've read all year, with the caveats that you should read the content notes, and that some people are going to bounce off this series because it's too intense and melodramatic. That intensity will not let up, so if that's not what you're in the mood for, wait on this trilogy until you are. Content notes: Graphic violence, torture, mentions of off-screen child sexual assault, a graphic corpse, and a whole lot of trauma. One somewhat grumbly postscript: This is the sort of book where I need to not read other people's reviews because I'll get too defensive of it (it's just a book I liked!). But there is one bit of review commentary I've seen about the trilogy that annoys me enough I have to mention it. Other reviewers seem to be latching on to the Jeveni (an ethnic group in the trilogy) as Space Jews and then having various feelings about that. I can see some parallels, I'm not going to say that it's completely wrong, but I also beg people to read about a fictional oppressed ethnic and religious minority and not immediately think "oh, they must be stand-ins for Jews." That's kind of weird? And people from the US, in particular, perhaps should not read a story about an ethnic group enslaved due to their productive skill and economic value and think "they must be analogous to Jews, there are no other possible parallels here." There are a lot of other comparisons that can be made, including to the commonalities between the methods many different oppressed minorities have used to survive and preserve their culture. Rating: 10 out of 10

Next.

Previous.