Search Results: "cts"

27 April 2026

Gunnar Wolf: Heads we win, tails you lose AI detectors in education

This post is an unpublished review for Heads we win, tails you lose AI detectors in education
Educators throughout the world are tasked with the difficult requirement of evaluating students works, making sure the grades meaningfully reflect the students understanding of the subject, and that a graded assignment maps to the relevant work invested in solving it. After the irruption of Large-Language Models in late 2023, this task became obviously much harder: if a widely available computer program is able to solve an assignment in a way that resembles a human-generated response, how can educators meaningfully grade their groups? As it has been the case with different innovations over time (such as with the appearance of electronic calculators or the mass availability of digital encyclopedias), the first reactions were of prohibition and denial: students who use the new tool in question are to be disqualified or somehow punished. It is only some time after the innovation in question settles that teachers find a way to properly weigh, integrate and accept its use. The authors of this position article present several arguments as to why it is impossible, unethical and unadvisable to use automated AI detection systems to process student assignments. The first argument is whether it is at all possible to reliably differentiate human-written essays from LLM-generated artifacts. The first criticism is that AI detectors are, themselves, LLMs trained on human-generated texts (negative) and LLM-generated texts (positive). However, the only way to assert the training material is not noisy is to use pre-2020 text as human-generated but natural ways of writing are influenced by what people read, and the authors quote studies pointing out that human language, particularly in the scholarly fields, has incorporated terms and constructions that were used as LLM markers. Quoting the authors, As exposure to AI-generated material becomes increasingly widespread, it is reasonable to expect that the linguistic patterns of human writing will shift, reflecting the influence of AI-assisted texts encountered across education, media, and everyday communication . Stylistic elements and other such markers are being adopted back into regular speech at a high rate. Then, the aspect of ethics comes into play as well. While it is expected that teachers should demand intellectual integrity from students, and plagiarism detectors have been widely accepted into the workflow of academics, the accusation of presenting LLM output as own work is necessarily an uphill battle: the accused party is tasked with providing proof of innocence based on nebulous, probabilistic accusations. The authors argue, once an accusation of turning in a LLM-generated text is made on a student, the onus on proving innocence lies with the accused. The authors review and argue against a series of techniques that have been presented in literature to aid teachers in detecting LLM abuse, such as linguistic markers, single or multiple AI detectors, the use of false references, hidden adversarial prompts, arguing in all cases the techniques fail to be trustable enough and highlighting the probability of both false positives and negatives. They also present AI detection as a false dichotomy: many works presented are not 100% human generated nor 100% LLM-generated, but some pertinent LLM-generated paragraphs are presented mixed with human-generated content, in a positive, critical AI use ( Students work is frequently created with, not by, generative AI ). The article closes by reiterating the authors position: AI detection in education is not merely flawed; it is conceptually unsound . they call upon institutions to accept the use of generative LLMs cannot be solved through surveillance and punishment , but has to be tackled by an assessment design that recognizes AI s role in learning . This article s position is very strong and well argued, and although it will surely meet with ample opposition, it surely poses an important, very current problematic. As a teacher, I found it a very enlightening read.

Russ Allbery: Review: What We Are Seeking

Review: What We Are Seeking, by Cameron Reed
Publisher: Tor
Copyright: 2026
ISBN: 1-250-36474-4
Format: Kindle
Pages: 339
What We Are Seeking is a bit hard to classify beyond science fiction. I think I would call it anthropological science fiction, but it's also a first contact story and a planetary colony story. It is a standalone novel (well, so far as I know; see later in the review for caveats). This is Cameron Reed's second novel after the excellent and memorable cyberpunk novel The Fortunate Fall, first published in 1996 under Reed's former name of Raphael Carter. John Maraintha is a doctor from the world of Essius. He took what he thought was a temporary job on the Free Ship Edgar's Folly, where he's endured considerable culture shock. As the novel opens, John learns that the colonists on Scythia have requested a translator to talk to one of the native life forms, and a doctor since they're down to only one. John will be that doctor. The captain has decided, and by the rules of the free ships, John does not get a choice in the matter. The Scythian colony is about four hundred people, now located in a desert climate since the complex native life forms destroyed their previous settlement. The colonists are a split between Ischnurans and Zandaheans, two other human civilizations from the scatter of colony worlds left after Earth embraced AIs (aiyis here) and turned inward. Both of those groups marry, something John considers a moral abomination. Neither of them seem likely to understand Essian sexual ethics. More devastatingly, John had intended to spend some time as a ship doctor and then return home to a new place in Essian society. Once he lands on Scythia, the chances of that are gone; it is highly unlikely any ship would pick him up again and take him home. I have been trying to find the right books to compare What We Are Seeking with ever since I read it. The best I've come up with are Ursula K. Le Guin (particularly The Dispossessed), Eleanor Arnason's A Woman of the Iron People, and Becky Chambers's To Be Taught, If Fortunate. The start of the book felt like an intentional revisiting of an earlier era of science fiction, with somewhat updated science and politics, but the last half of the book, where the action picks up considerably, is a meditation on gender, social systems, religion, and small-group politics. All of that is mixed with biological exploration and a first-contact story with some quite-alien aliens. This is the sort of novel where the protagonist's culture is as foreign to the reader as any of the other cultures he counters, so the reader is assembling several jigsaw puzzles at once. John is dropped into an established colony with its own social norms and established hierarchies. The one other outsider, the translator Sudharma Jain, is, as his name implies, a Jain who keeps very strict religious observances. Half of the colony is from something akin to a fundamentalist Christian religious sect that practices patriarchy and strict marriage codes. The other half is more gently sexist (but still sexist) and has its own tradition of a third gender that becomes central to the story. John, meanwhile, is a strong believer in the Essian approach to social organization: Any two partners of any gender freely have sex by mutual consent and without obligation, and family is based solely on blood relations. These beliefs do not fit comfortably together, even when people are trying (as they mostly do) to be welcoming. The first half of this book is very slow. This gives all of the characters space to breathe and become comfortable, and the characterization is superb, but it is a book to start when you're in the mood for something slow and observational. There is a plot that gradually becomes apparent, or rather there are several plots that are intertwined, but tension and urgency are mostly reserved for the second half of the book. Instead, the book opens with a lot of close observation of alien flora and fauna and the untangling of subtle social dynamics among the Scythians. There is also a visitor from earth, much to the distress of the Scythians. Earth presence means the ships will not return and the colony may be cut off from any sort of technological resupply. Despite speaking a common language, that visitor is as mutually alien to the other groups as they are to the native flora. Her life is fully integrated with aiyis, giving her essentially godlike powers and the ability to turn off inconvenient emotions and disregard anything she doesn't want to see. What she and the Earth aiyis are doing on the planet is one of the early mysteries. The dialogue in this book is truly excellent. Each characters has their own voice, there are fascinating digressions on different words that lead to tidbits of world-building, and some of the culture-specific idioms are delightful.
"I'm making a mess of this. None of that matters. Let me fall out the window and come in the door again. This is how my story ought to start:"
The challenges for the characters in this story are slow but deep ones: belonging and self-definition, the conflict between cultural tradition and personal circumstance, and the sacrifices required to live with small groups in situations where civil war is viscerally attractive. It has one of the most comprehensive and fascinating treatments of transgender issues that I've read in science fiction. Its commentary on current politics is subtle and estranged in the way that science fiction does best, but still pointed and satisfying. And, well, there are passages like this that I absolutely adore:
"I wouldn't go that far. It could be they are right, the universe we see exists because a mind like ours created it at least, a mind enough like ours that we can say it wants one thing and not another, and when it acts it does so with intent. That's as good an idea as any. But it is certainly not plausible that such a being believes that people everywhere should marry, or that men should never visit men, or no one should become a jess. Look at what they have created. The universe could have been nothing at all, or one atom of hydrogen floating in a void, or a diamond crystal infinite in all directions, if their mind cared for simplicity or tidiness. Instead we have stars and planets and black holes and nebulas. It could have all been cold and dead, but there is life. They could have made one species for each world, or just a few, which could have stayed the same forever, but instead we have millions and millions, all of which are changing every moment, varying among themselves and boiling off in all directions. Such a god is like an artist who fills up a library of sketchbooks with their drawings of strange creatures, and when every scrap of paper in the place is used up, goes back with a different color ink and scribbles over them again. They are obsessed with variation they gorge themselves with it and never grow full. Do you really think a mind like that could want us all to live in the same way?"
I had one problem with this book, though, and for me it was a big one: There is no ending. Reed effectively builds tension, gets me caring about all of the characters, sets up several problems, starts down a path towards resolution, and then the book just... ends. Long-time readers of my reviews will know that I'm a denouement fanatic. I want the scouring of the shire, I want the chapter set in the happily ever after, I want the catharsis of an ending. This made me so grumpy! To be clear, this is not sequel bait (at least so far as I can tell). I can write a philosophical defense of the ending. The types of problems and lives that Reed set up don't have clear endings; this is, to some extent, the point. We muddle through, and then those who come after us muddle through some more, and the cumulative effect is called human civilization. And there is some denouement; Reed doesn't leave the reader at a cliffhanger or anything that egregious. But still, I wanted the happy ending, even though that was unrealistic for the style of story this is, because I'm a happy ending reader. This is not an ending sort of book; it's the sort of book where I get a sinking feeling at the 95% mark because there aren't enough pages left for the number of remaining unresolved problems. I've gotten less annoyed in the days since I finished the book, and I can appreciate the thematic point made by how the book ends, but I still feel like it's worth an advance warning if you're a reader like I am. I would be delighted by a sequel, but it didn't feel like that was the intent. Apart from that, this was both excellent and rather unlike a lot of current science fiction. I think the closest comparison I can make among recent novels I've read is Sue Burke's Semiosis. What We Are Seeking has a similar sort of world-building, but I liked these characters so much more. It felt like a classic literary science fiction novel, but very much written in 2026. Highly recommended, just beware of the lack of closure. Content notes: Sexism, homophobia, stomach illness, and some religious abuse. Rating: 8 out of 10

26 April 2026

Dirk Eddelbuettel: RProtoBuf 0.4.27 on CRAN: Upstream Adjustment

A new maintenance release 0.4.27 of RProtoBuf arrived on CRAN today. RProtoBuf provides R with bindings for the Google Protocol Buffers ( ProtoBuf ) data encoding and serialization library used and released by Google, and deployed very widely in numerous projects as a language and operating-system agnostic protocol. The new release is also already as a binary via r2u. This release adjusts to a change upstream. Luca Billi noticed that upstream removed some fields from FieldDescriptor, filed and issue and followed up with a spotless PR. No other changes. The following section from the NEWS.Rd file has all details and links.

Changes in RProtoBuf version 0.4.27 (2026-04-26)
  • Adjust to FieldDescriptor API changes in ProtoBuf 3.4 (Luca Billi in #114 fixing #113)

Thanks to my CRANberries, there is a diff to the previous release. The RProtoBuf page has copies of the (older) package vignette, the quick overview vignette, and the pre-print of our JSS paper. Questions, comments etc should go to the GitHub issue tracker off the GitHub repo.

This post by Dirk Eddelbuettel originated on his Thinking inside the box blog. If you like this or other open-source work I do, you can sponsor me at GitHub. You can also sponsor my Tour de Shore 2026 ride in support of the Maywood Fine Arts Center.

Aurelien Jarno: Running upstream OpenSBI on SpacemiT K1

The SpacemiT K1 is a rather interesting RISC-V SoC, found for instance on boards like the Banana Pi BPI-F3 board. It's one of those platforms that looked promising on paper, but took a bit of time before things really started to move upstream. Things have clearly accelerated over the last few months. Linux 7.0 brings, among other things PCIe support, making the board quite capable as a development board. SD card, CPU thermal sensor and cpufreq support are already in the pipe. Unfortunately the situation is less advanced on the firmware side. There is only very basic support for the SpacemiT K1 in U-Boot for the second stage, and initial SPL support has been posted on the mailing list, but has not yet been merged. In practice, this means you still have to rely on the vendor U-Boot, which is based on the rather old 2022.10 release. On the other hand, OpenSBI does have upstream support for the SpacemiT K1, however it is not compatible with the vendor U-Boot, mostly due to device tree differences. This can be addressed by applying a few patches to the vendor U-Boot, which I have published in a git tree in the k1-bl-v2.2.y-opensbi branch (technically this can also be handled on the OpenSBI side, but I prefer using a vanilla upstream OpenSBI version). The first two patches update the configuration to get closer to the upstream U-Boot defaults, and to enable some configuration options for the Milk-V Jupiter board, which stores its firmware in SPI NOR flash, instead of eMMC for the Banana Pi BPI-F3. The following patches update the device tree by adding extra compatible entries to several devices, as expected by the upstream kernel and OpenSBI (thanks to Troy Mitchell for the hint about the UART change) and update the CPU riscv,isa properties. Finally an additional patch adds the SpacemiT P1 PMIC to the device tree, which is required for the OpenSBI reboot patchset I recently posted (this is currently done only for the Banana Pi BPI-F3 and Milk-V Jupiter boards, but extending it to other boards should be straightforward). Building this U-Boot version is as simple as running this command in the source directory:
make k1_defconfig && make
On a Banana Pi BPI-F3 board, the resulting U-Boot can be flashed with:
echo 0 > /sys/block/mmcblk0boot0/force_ro
dd if=FSBL.bin of=/dev/mmcblk0boot0 bs=512 seek=1
dd if=u-boot.itb of=/dev/mmcblk0p1
Building upstream OpenSBI is also fairly simple, and can be done by running this command in the source directory:
make PLATFORM=generic
On a Banana Pi BPI-F3 board, the resulting OpenSBI can be flashed with:
dd if=fw_dynamic.itb of=/dev/mmcblk0p2
Note that the vendor U-Boot version is patched to install OpenSBI in a separate partition instead of embedding, as the upstream U-Boot does. While this works well on the Banana Pi BPI-F3, the corresponding partition in the Milk-V Jupiter SPI NOR flash is too small for the upstream OpenSBI version, and can't be easily resized without breaking compatibility. To address this, the branch k1-bl-v2.2.y-opensbi-embedded contains an additional patch (a bit hackish I admit) to somehow restore the upstream approach. The build process remains simple, first build OpenSBI with the following command:
make PLATFORM=generic
Then build U-Boot, specifying the patch to the just built OpenSBI firmware:
make k1_defconfig && make OPENSBI=/path/to/opensbi/build/platform/generic/firmware/fw_dynamic.bin
On a Milk-V Jupiter board, the resulting combined U-Boot/OpenSBI can be flashed with:
modprobe mdtblock
dd bs=4k if=FSBL.bin of=/dev/mtdblock2
dd bs=4k if=u-boot.itb of=/dev/mtdblock5
This combined U-Boot/OpenSBI can also be used on a Banana Pi BPI-F3, using the same flashing procedure as above, while skipping the OpenSBI part (although running it won't cause any issue, it will simply be unused). All of this is admittedly a bit hackish, but enabling the use of upstream OpenSBI is already one step forward. Hopefully, in a few months, we will be able to rely entirely on upstream U-Boot.

23 April 2026

Sergio Talens-Oliag: Developing a Git Worktree Helper with Copilot

Over the past few weeks I ve been developing and using a personal command-line tool called gwt (Git Worktree) to manage Git repositories using worktrees. This article explains what the tool does, how it evolved, and how I used GitHub Copilot CLI to develop it (in fact the idea of building the script was also to test the tool).

The Problem: Managing Multiple BranchesI was working on a project with multiple active branches, including orphans; the regular branches are for fixes or features, while the orphans are used to keep copies of remote documents or store processed versions of those documents. The project also uses a special orphan branch that contains the scripts and the CI/CD configuration to store and process the external documents (it is on a separate branch to avoid mixing its operation with the main project code). The plan is trigger a pipeline against the special branch from remote projects to create or update the doc branch for it in our git repository, retrieving artifacts from the remote projects to get the files and put them on an orphan branch (initially I added new commits after each update, but I changed the system to use force pushes and keep only one commit, as the history is not really needed). The original documents have to be changed, so, after ingesting them, we run a script that modifies them and adds or updates another branch with the processed version; the contents of that branch are used by the main branch build process (there we use git fetch and git archive to retrieve its contents). When working on the scripts to manage the orphan branches I discovered the worktree feature of git, a functionality that allows me to keep multiple branches checked out in parallel using a single .git folder, removing the need to use git switch and git stash when changing between branches (until now I ve been a heavy user of those commands). Reading about it I found that a lot of people use worktrees with the help of a wrapper script to simplify the management. After looking at one or two posts and the related scripts I decided to create my own using a specific directory structure to simplify things. That s how I started to work on the gwt script; as I also wanted to test copilot I decided to build it using its help (I have a pro license at work and wanted to play with the cli version instead of integrated into an editor, as I didn t want to learn a lot of new keyboard shortcuts).

The gwt Philosophy: Opinionated and Transparentgwt enforces a simple, filesystem-visible model:
  • Exactly one bare repository named bare.git (treated as an implementation detail)
  • One worktree directory per branch where the directory name matches the branch name
  • Single responsibility: gwt doesn t try to be a general git wrapper; it only handles operations that map cleanly to this layout
The repository structure looks like this:
my-repo/
+-- bare.git/           # the Git repository (internal)
+-- main/               # worktree for branch "main"
+-- feature/api/        # worktree for branch "feature/api"
+-- fix/docs/           # worktree for branch "fix/docs"
+-- orphan-history/     # worktree for the "orphan-history" branch
The tool follows five core design principles:
  1. Explicit over clever: Git commands are not hidden or reinterpreted
  2. Transparent execution: Every operation is printed before it happens
  3. Safe, preview-first operations: Destructive commands default to preview, confirmation, then apply
  4. Shell-agnostic core: The script never changes the caller s working directory (shell wrappers handle that)
  5. Opinionated but minimal: Only commands that fit the layout model are included

Core CommandsThe script provides these essential commands:
  • gwt init <url> Clone a repository and set up the gwt layout
  • gwt convert <dir> Convert an existing Git checkout to the gwt layout
  • gwt add [--orphan] <branch> [<base>] Create a new worktree (optionally orphaned)
  • gwt remove <branch> Remove a worktree and unregister it (asks the user to remove the local branch too, useful when removing already merged branches)
  • gwt rename <old> <new> Rename a branch AND its worktree directory
  • gwt list List all worktrees
  • gwt default [<branch>] Get or set the default branch
  • gwt current Print the current worktree or branch name
Except init and convert all of the commands work inside a directory structure that follows the gwt layout, which looks for the bare.git folder to find the root folder of the structure. As I don t want to hide which commands are really used by the wrapper, all git and filesystem operations pass through a single run shell function that prints each command before executing it. This gives complete visibility into what the tool is doing. Also, destructive operations (remove, rename) default to preview mode:
$ gwt remove feature-old --dry-run
+ git -C bare.git branch -d feature-old
+ git -C bare.git worktree remove feature-old/
Apply these changes? [y/N]:
The user sees exactly what will happen, can verify it s correct, and only then confirm execution.

Incremental Development with CopilotThe gwt script has grown from 597 lines in its original version (git-wt) to 1,111 lines when writing the first draft of this post. This growth happened through incremental, test-driven development, with each feature being refined based on real usage patterns. What follows is a little history of the script evolution written with the help of git log.

Initial versionFirst I wrote a design document and asked copilot to create the initial version of the git-wt script with the original core commands. I started to use the tool with a remote repostory (I made copies of the branches in some cases to avoid missing work) and fixed bugs (trivial ones with neovim, larger ones asking copilot to fix the issues for me, so I had less typing to do).

First command updateOne of the first commands I had to enhance was rename:
  • as I normally use branches with / on their name and my tool checks out the worktrees using the branch name as the path inside the gwt root folder (i.e. a fix/rename branch creates the fix directory and checks the branch inside the fix/rename folder) the rename command had to clean up the empty parent directories
  • when renaming a worktree we move the folders and fix the references using the worktree repair command to make things work locally, but the rename also affects the remote branch reference, to avoid surprises the command unsets the remote branch reference so it can be pushed again using the new name (of course, the user is responsible of managing the old remote branch, as the gwt can t guess what it should do with it).

Integration with the shellAs I use zsh with the Powerlevel10k theme I asked copilot to help me add visual elements to the prompt when working with gwt folders, something that I would have never tried without help, as it would have required a lot of digging on my part on how to do it, as I never looked into it. The initial version of the code was on an independent file that I sourced from my .zshrc file and it prints on the right part of the prompt when we are inside a gwt folder (note that if the folder is a worktree we see the existing git integration text right before it, so we have the previous behavior and we see that it is a gwt friendly repo) and if we are on the root folder or the bare.git folder we see gwt or bare (I added the text because there are no git promts on those folders). I also asked copilot to create zsh autocompletion functions (I only use zsh, so I didn t add autocompletion for other shells). The good thing here is that I wouldn t have done that manually, as it would have required some reading to get it right, but the output of copilot worked and I can update things using it or manually if I need to. One thing I was missing from the script was the possibility of changing the working directory easily, so I wrote a gwt wrapper function for zsh that intercepts commands that require shell cooperation (changing the working directory) and delegates everything else to the core script. Currently the function supports the following enhanced commands:
  • cd [<branch>]: change into a worktree or the default one if missing
  • convert <dir>: convert a checkout, then cd into the initial worktree
  • add [--orphan] <branch> [<base>]: create a worktree, then cd into it on success
  • rename <old> <new>: rename a worktree, then cd into it if we were inside it
Note that the cd command will not work on other shells or if the user does not load my wrapper, but the rest will still work without the working directory changes.

Renaming the commandAs I felt that git-wt was a long name I renamed the tool to gwt, I could have done it by hand, but using copilot I didn t have to review all files by myself and it did it right (note that I have it configured to always ask me before doing changes, as it sometimes tries to do something I don t want and I like to check its changes as I have the files in git repos, I manually add the files when I like the status and if the cli output is not clear I allow it to apply it and check the effects with git diff so I can validate or revert what was done).

The convert commandAfter playing with one repo I added the convert subcommand for migrating existing checkouts, it seemed a simple task at first, but it took multiple iterations to get it right, as I found multiple issues while testing (in fact I did copies of the existing checkouts to be able to re-test each update, as some of the iterations broke them). The version of the function when this post was first edited had the following comment explaining what it does:
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# convert - convert an existing checkout into the gwt layout
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
#
# Must be run from the parent directory of <dir>.
#
# Steps:
#   1. Read branch from the checkout's HEAD
#   2. Rename <dir> to <dir>.wt.tmp (sibling, same filesystem)
#   3. Create <dir>/ as the new gwt root
#   4. Move <dir>.wt.tmp/.git to <dir>/bare.git; set core.bare = true
#   5. Fix fetch refspec (bare clone default maps refs directly, no remotes/)
#   6. Add a --no-checkout worktree so git wires up the metadata and
#      creates <dir>/<branch>/.git (the only file in that dir)
#   7. Move that .git file into the real working tree (<dir>.wt.tmp)
#   8. Remove the now-empty placeholder directory
#   9. Move the real working tree into place as <dir>/<branch>
#  10. Reset the index to HEAD so git status is clean
#      (--no-checkout leaves the index empty)
#  11. Create <dir>/.git -> bare.git symlink so plain git commands work
#      from the root without --git-dir
#
# The .git file ends up at the same absolute path git recorded in step 5,
# so no worktree repair is needed. Working tree files are never modified.
The .git link was added when I noticed that I could run commands that don t need the checked out files on the root of the gwt structure, which is handy sometimes (i.e. a git fetch or a git log, that shows the log of the branch marked as default). After playing with commands that used the bare.git folder I updated the init and convert commands to keep the origin refs, ensuring that the remote tracking works correctly.

Improving the add commandWhile playing with the tool on more repos I noticed that I also had to enhance the add command to better handle worktree creation, depending on my needs. Right now the tool supports the following use cases:
  • if the branch exists locally or on origin, it just checks it out.
  • if the branch does not exist, we create it using the given base branch or, if no base is given, the current worktree (if we are in the root folder or bare.git the command fails).
  • as I needed it for my project, I added a --orphan option to be able to create orphan branches directly.

Moving to a single fileEventually I decided to make the tool self contained; I removed the design document (I moved the content to comments on the top of the script and details to comments on each function definition) and added a pair of commands to print the code to source for the p10k and zsh integration (autocompletion & functions), leaving everything in a single file. Now my .zshrc file adds the following to source both things:
# After loading the p10k configuration
if type gwt >/dev/null 2>&1; then
  source <(gwt p10k)
fi
[...]
# After loading autocompletion
if type gwt >/dev/null 2>&1; then
  source <(gwt zsh)
fi

VersioningAs I modified the script I found interesting to use CalVer-based versioning (the version variable has the format YYYY.mm.dd-r#) so I added a subcommand to show its value or bump it using the current date and computing the right revision number.

About the use of copilotAlthough I ve never been a fan of AI tools I have to admit that the copilot CLI has been very useful for building the tool:
  • Rapid prototyping: Each commit represented a small feature or fix that I could implement, test immediately in my actual workflow, and iterate on based on the result
  • Edge case handling: Rather than trying to anticipate every scenario upfront, I could ask Copilot how to handle edge cases as they appeared in real usage
  • Script refinement: Questions like "how do I clean up empty directories after a rename" or "how do I detect if I m inside a specific worktree" were quickly answered with working code
  • Shell integration: The Zsh wrapper and completion system grew from simple prototypes to sophisticated features, with each iteration informed by how I actually used the tool
For example, the convert command started as a simple rename operation, but evolved to also create a .git symlink and intelligently handle various migration scenarios all because I used it repeatedly and refined the implementation each time.

Self-Contained and Opinionatedgwt is deliberately opinionated:
  • Zsh & Powerlevel10k Integration: The tool includes built-in Zsh shell integration, accessed via source <(gwt zsh) and supports adding a prompt segment when using p10k, as described earlier.
  • Directory Structure: The bare.git directory name is non-negotiable. This is how gwt discovers the repository root from any subdirectory, and how the tool knows whether a directory is a gwt repository. The simplicity of this marker means the discovery mechanism is foolproof and requires no configuration.
  • No Configuration Files: gwt deliberately has no configuration. There are no .gwtrc files or config directories. This makes it portable; the tool works the same way everywhere, and repositories can be shared across systems without synchronizing configuration.

From Script to SystemWhat started as a small helper script for managing worktrees has become a complete system:
  1. Core script (gwt): 1,111 lines of pure shell, no external dependencies
  2. Shell integration: Zsh functions and completions
  3. Prompt integration: Powerlevel10k segment
  4. Documentation: Built-in help and design philosophy documentation
The script is self-contained, everything needed for the tool to work is in a single file. This makes it trivial to update (just replace the script) or audit (no hidden dependencies).

Development with AI supportDeveloping gwt with copilot taught me some things:
  • Incremental refinement works well for small tools: Each iteration informed the next, resulting in a tool that handles real use cases elegantly
  • Transparency is a feature: Making operations visible builds confidence and is easier to debug
  • Opinionated tools can be powerful: By constraining the problem space (one bare repo, one worktree per branch), the solution becomes simpler and more robust
  • Shell integration matters: The same core commands are easier to use when they can automatically change directories and provide completions
  • Real-world testing is essential: I wouldn t have discovered the need for automatic directory cleanup or context-aware cd behavior without actually using the tool daily

What was next?The tool is stable and handles my daily workflow well, so my guess is that I would keep using it and fixing issues if or when I found them, but I do not plan to include additional features unless I find a use case that justifies it (i.e. I never added support for some of the worktree subcommands, as it is easier to use the git versions if I ever needed them).

What really happenedWhile editing this post I discovered that I needed to add another command to it and fixed a bug (see below). With those changes and the inclusion of a license and copyright notice (just in case I distribute it at some point) now the script is 1,217 lines long instead of the 1,111 it had when I started to write this entry.

Submodule SupportWhen I converted this blog repository to the gwt format and tried to preview the post using docker compose, it failed because the worktree I was on didn t have the Git submodule initialized. My blog theme is included on the repository as a submodule, and when I used gwt to check out different branches in worktrees, the submodule was not initialized in the new worktrees. This led me to add new internal function and a gwt submodule command to handle submodule initialization; the internal function is called from convert and add (when converting a repo or adding a worktree) and the public command is useful to update the submodules on existing branches.

Path Handling with Branch Names Containing SlashesThe second discovery was a bug in how the tool handled branch names containing slashes (e.g., feature/new-api, docs/user-guide), the worktree directories are created with the branch name as the path, so a branch like feature/new-api would create two nested folders (feature and new-api inside it). However, there was a mismatch in how the zsh wrapper function resolved worktree paths (initially it used shell parameter expansion, i.e. rel="$ cwd#"$REPO_ROOT"/ "), versus how the core script calculated them, causing the cd command to fail or navigate to the wrong location when branch names contained slashes. The fix involved ensuring consistent path resolution throughout the script and wrapper (now it uses a function that processes the git worktree list output), so that gwt cd feature/new-api correctly navigates to the worktree directory regardless of path depth.

Conclusiongwt is a tool that solves a real problem: managing multiple Git branches simultaneously without context-switching overhead. I m sure I m going to keep using it for my projects, as it simplifies some workflows, although I ll also use switch and stash in some cases, but I like the use of multiple worktrees in parallel. In fact I converted this blog repository checkout to the gwt format to work on a separate branch as it felt the right approach even if I m the only one using the repo now, and it helped me improve the tool, as explained before. Also, it was a good example of how to use AI tools like copilot to develop a simple tool and keep it evolving while using it. In any case, although I find the copilot useful and has saved me time, I don t trust it to work without supervision, it worked well, but got stuck some times and didn t do the things as I wanted in multiple occasions. I also have an additional problem now I ve been reading about it, but I don t really know which models to use or how the premium requests are computed (I ve only been playing with it since last month and I ran out of requests the last day of the month on purpose, just to see what happened it stops working ;). On my work machine I ve been using a specific user account with a GitHub Copilot Business subscription and I only used the Anthropic Claude Sonnet 4.6 model and with my personal account I configured the Anthropic Claude Haiku 4.5 model, but I ve only used that to create the initial draft of this post (I ended up rewriting most of it manually anyway) and to review the final version (I m not a native speaker and it was useful for finding typos and improving the style in some parts). I guess I ll try other models with copilot in the future and check other command line tools like aider or claude-code, but probably only using free accounts unless I get a payed account at work, as I have with GitHub Copilot. To be fair, what I will love to be able to do is to use local models (aider can do it), but the machines I have are not powerful enough. I tried to run a simple test and it felt really slow, but when I have the time or the need I ll try again, just in case.

21 April 2026

Dirk Eddelbuettel: RcppArmadillo 15.2.6-1 on CRAN: Several Updates

armadillo image Armadillo is a powerful and expressive C++ template library for linear algebra and scientific computing. It aims towards a good balance between speed and ease of use, has a syntax deliberately close to Matlab, and is useful for algorithm development directly in C++, or quick conversion of research code into production environments. RcppArmadillo integrates this library with the R environment and language and is widely used by (currently) 1263 other packages on CRAN, downloaded 45.7 million times (per the partial logs from the cloud mirrors of CRAN), and the CSDA paper (preprint / vignette) by Conrad and myself has been cited 683 times according to Google Scholar. This versions updates to the 15.2.5 and 15.2.6 upstream Armadillo releases from, respectively, two and five days ago. The package has already been updated for Debian, and built for r2u. When we ran the reverse-dependency check for 15.2.5 at the end of last week, one package failed. I got in touch with the authors, filed an issue, poked some more, isolated the one line that caused an example to fail and right then 15.2.6 came out fixing just that. It was after all an upstream issue. We used to ran these checks before Conrad made a release, he now skips this and hence needed a quick follow-up release. It can happen. The other big change is that this R package release phases out the dual support for both C++14 or newer (as in current Armadillo) along with a C++11 fallback for more slowly updating packages. I am happy to say that after over eight months of this managed transition (during which CRAN expulsed some laggard packages that were not moving in from C++11) we are now at all packages using C++14 or newer which is nice. And I will take this as an opportunity to stress that one can in fact manage a disruptive API change this way as we just demonstrated. Sadly, R Core does not seem to have gotten that message and rollout of this package was also still a little delayed because of the commotion created by the last minute API changes preceding the R 4.6.0 release later this week. Smaller changes in the package are a switch in pdf vignette production to the Rcpp::asis() driver, and a higher-precision computation in rmultinom() (matching a change made in R-devel during last week in its use of Kahan summation). All detailed changes since the last CRAN release follow.

Changes in RcppArmadillo version 15.2.6-1 (2026-04-20)
  • Upgraded to Armadillo release 15.2.6 (Medium Roast Deluxe)
    • Ensure internally computed tolerances are not NaN
  • The rmultinom deploys 'Kahan summation' as R-devel does now.

Changes in RcppArmadillo version 15.2.5-1 [github-only] (2026-04-18)
  • Upgraded to Armadillo release 15.2.5 (Medium Roast Deluxe)
    • Fix for handling NaN elements in .is_zero()
    • Fix for handling NaN in tolerance and conformance checks
    • Faster handling of diagonal views and submatrices with one row>

  • Sunset the C++11 fallback of including Armadillo 14.6.3 (#504 closing #503)
  • The vignettes have refreshed bibliographies, and are now built using the Rcpp::asis vignette builder (#506)
  • One rmultinom test is skipped under R-devel which has switched to a higher precisions calc
Courtesy of my CRANberries, there is a diffstat report relative to previous release. More detailed information is on the RcppArmadillo page. Questions, comments etc should go to the rcpp-devel mailing list off the Rcpp R-Forge page.

This post by Dirk Eddelbuettel originated on his Thinking inside the box blog. If you like this or other open-source work I do, you can sponsor me at GitHub. You can also sponsor my Tour de Shore 2026 ride in support of the Maywood Fine Arts Center.

Ravi Dwivedi: LibreOffice Conference Budapest 2025

In September 2025, I attended the LibreOffice Conference in Budapest, Hungary, on the 4th and the 5th, and a community meeting on the 3rd. Thanks to The Document Foundation (TDF) for sponsoring my travel and accommodation costs. The conference venue was Faculty of Informatics, E tv s Lor nd University (ELTE). The conference was planned to be held from the 4th to the 6th, but the program for the 6th of September had to be canceled due to the venue being unavailable because of a marathon in Budapest. So, all the talks got squeezed into just two days, making the schedule a bit hectic. The TDF had booked my room at the Corvin Hotel. It was a double bedroom with a window. The breakfast was included in the hotel booking. The hotel was walking distance from the conference venue. One could also take a tram from the hotel to reach the venue.
A double bed A shot of my room. Photo by Ravi Dwivedi, released under CC-BY-SA 4.0.
Tram A tram in Budapest. Photo by Ravi Dwivedi, released under CC-BY-SA 4.0.

3rd of September On the 3rd of September, we had a community meeting at the above-mentioned venue. I walked with my friend Dione to the venue. Upon reaching there, I noticed that the university had no boundaries and gates. This reminded me of the previous year s conference venue in Luxembourg, which also had no boundaries or gates. In contrast, Indian universities and institutes typically have walls and gates serving as boundaries to separate them from the rest of the city. Many of these institutes also have security guards at the entrance, who may ask attendees to present proof of admission before allowing them inside. I was surprised to find that institutes in Europe, like the one where the conference was held, did not have such boundaries. The building where the conference was held was red, which happened to be the same color as the building for the previous year s conference venue. I remember joking with Dione that the criteria for the conference venue might have been the color of the building.
A red building The red building in the picture served as the conference venue. Photo by Ravi Dwivedi, released under CC-BY-SA 4.0.
During the community meeting, we shared ideas on how to spread the word about LibreOffice. The meeting lasted for a couple of hours. After the community meeting, we went to the hotel for dinner sponsored by the TDF.
Cake slices These Esterh zy cake bites were really yummy. Photo by Ravi Dwivedi, released under CC-BY-SA 4.0.
Raspberry Currant cake slices Raspberry Currant cake slices. Photo by Ravi Dwivedi, released under CC-BY-SA 4.0.

4th of September On the first day of the conference, attendees were given swag bags containing a pad, sticky notes, a pen, a conference T-shirt, and a bottle.
A blue colored T-shirt on a bed along with a pen, a bottle, a diary and a sticky note Conference swag. Photo by Ravi Dwivedi, released under CC-BY-SA 4.0.
The talks started early in the morning with Eliane Domingos, Chairperson of TDF s Board of Directors, giving the inauguration talk. As always, I found Italo Vignoli s talk on the importance of document freedom interesting. During the snack break, I noticed that there were three types of milk available for coffee: cow s milk, lactose-free milk, and almond milk. Almond milk is rare in India, but I have managed to get it, but I have never seen lactose-free milk in India. Since I run fundraisers in my projects, such as Prav, I could relate to Lothar K. Becker s talk. He discussed the issue that certain implementations in LibreOffice require a budget that is too large for any single interested entity to fund independently. Furthermore, The Document Foundation (TDF) cannot legally receive funds from government entities. Therefore, there is no organization or entity to pool resources from all the interested entities to finance the implementation.
Lothar giving his presentation Lothar giving his presentation. Photo by Ravi Dwivedi, released under CC-BY-SA 4.0.
Another talk was by the Austrian Armed Forces on their migration to LibreOffice. I wanted to know why they migrated, and I found out that they did it for their digital sovereignty, and not for saving on the license costs. Another point presented in the talk was that LibreOffice is available on all the operating systems, while the Microsoft Office suite is not that widely available. The migration was systematic and was performed over a few years. They started working on it in 2021, and the migration was finished recently. In addition, it also required training their staff in using LibreOffice.
Presentation on migration to LibreOffice by Austrian Armed Forces Presentation on migration to LibreOffice by Austrian Armed Forces. Photo by Ravi Dwivedi, released under CC-BY-SA 4.0.
The lunch was inside the university canteen. We were provided lunch coupons by the TDF. I got a vegan coupon with 4000 Ft written on it, which meant I could take lunch for up to 4000 Hungarian forints.
My lunch ticket My lunch ticket for the conference. Photo by Ravi Dwivedi, released under CC-BY-SA 4.0.
The lunch I had on the first day The lunch I had on the first day. Photo by Ravi Dwivedi, released under CC-BY-SA 4.0.
During the evening, it was my turn for the presentation. I was done with preparing my slides ten days before my talk. I also got my slides reviewed by friends. My talk was finished in 20 minutes, while I was given a 30-minute slot. This helped us catch up on the schedule. Furthermore, I made my talk interactive by asking questions and making sure that the audience was not asleep. During my talk, my friend Dione took my pictures with my camera. My talk was on how free software projects could give users a say in freedom to modify the software. I illustrated this using the Prav project that I am a part of. After the talks were over, we were treated to a conference dinner at Trofea Grill. It had a great selection of desserts, which helped me sample some Hungarian desserts. The sponge cake was especially good.
Desserts at Tofea Grill Desserts at Tofea Grill. Photo by Ravi Dwivedi, released under CC-BY-SA 4.0.

5th of September The next day the 5th of September I went with Dione to the venue early in the morning, as her talk was the first one of the day. Her talk was titled Managing Tasks with Nextcloud Deck. Later that day, I also attended a talk on Collabora. At lunch, I found the egg white salad quite tasty.
Dione giving her presentation Dione giving her presentation. Photo by Ravi Dwivedi, released under CC-BY-SA 4.0.
Egg white salad Egg white salad. Photo by Ravi Dwivedi, released under CC-BY-SA 4.0.
After the lunch break, we had the conference group photo. I had a Nikon camera, which we used to take the group photo. I requested a university student to take our group photo and also taught her how to operate the camera.
People looking at the camera and smiling Group photo
By the evening, the conference ended, after which we went to a pub, which was again sponsored by TDF. I had beer, but that one really tasted bad, so I couldn t finish it. The only vegetarian option was goat cheeseburger, which my friend Manish and I opted for. The burger tasted awful. Apparently, I don t like goat cheese. The next day I went sightseeing with Dione in Budapest. Stay tuned for our adventures! Credits: Thanks to Dione and Richard for proofreading.

18 April 2026

Matthias Klumpp: Hello old new Projects directory!

If you have recently installed a very up-to-date Linux distribution with a desktop environment, or upgraded your system on a rolling-release distribution, you might have noticed that your home directory has a new folder: Projects

Why? With the recent 0.20 release of xdg-user-dirs we enabled the Projects directory by default. Support for this has already existed since 2007, but was never formally enabled. This closes a more than 11 year old bug report that asked for this feature. The purpose of the Projects directory is to give applications a default location to place project files that do not cleanly belong into one of the existing categories (Documents, Music, Pictures, Videos). Examples of this are software engineering projects, scientific projects, 3D printing projects, CAD design or even things like video editing projects, where project files would end up in the Projects directory, with output video being more at home in Videos . By enabling this by default, and subsequently in the coming months adding support to GLib, Flatpak, desktops and applications that want to make use of it, we hope to give applications that do operate in a project-centric manner with mixed media a better default storage location. As of now, those tools either default to the home directory, or will clutter the Documents folder, both of which is not ideal. It also gives users a default organization structure, hopefully leading to less clutter overall and better storage layouts.

This sucks, I don t like it!
As usual, you are in control and can modify your system s behavior. If you do not like the Projects folder, simply delete it! The xdg-user-dirs utility will not try to create it again, and instead adjust the default location for this directory to your home directory. If you want more control, you can influence exactly what goes where by editing your ~/.config/user-dirs.dirs configuration file. If you are a system administrator or distribution vendor and want to set default locations for the default XDG directories, you can edit the /etc/xdg/user-dirs.defaults file to set global defaults that affect all users on the system (users can still adjust the settings however they like though).

What else is new? Besides this change, the 0.20 release of xdg-user-dirs brings full support for the Meson build system (dropping Automake), translation updates, and some robustness improvements to its code. We also fixed the arbitrary code execution from unsanitized input bug that the Arch Linux Wiki mentions here for the xdg-user-dirs utility, by replacing the shell script with a C binary. Thanks to everyone who contributed to this release!

Valhalla's Things: Pizza!

Posted on April 18, 2026
Tags: madeof:atoms, craft:cooking
This post contains a bit of consumerism and is full of references to commercial products, none of which caused me to receive any money nor non-monetary compensation. This post has also been written after eating in one meal the amount of bread-like stuff that we usually have in more than 24 hours. I ve been baking bread since a long time ago. I don t know exactly when, but probably it was the early 2000s or so, and remained a regular-ish thing until 2020, when it became an extremely regular thing, as in I believe I bake bread on average every other day. In the before times, I ve had a chance to bake pizza in a wood fired oven a few times: a friend had one and would offer the house, my partner would mind the fire, and I would get there with the dough and prepare the pizza. Now that we have moved to a new house, we don t have a good and convenient place for a proper wood fired oven in masonry, but we can use one of the portable ones, and having dealt with more urgent expenses, I decided that just before the potential collapse of the global economy was a good time as any to buy the oven I had been looking at since we found this house. I decided to get an Ooni Karu 2, having heard good things about the brand, and since it looked like a good balance between size and portability. I also didn t consider their gas fired ovens (nor did I buy the gas burner) because I m trying to get rid of gas, not add stuff that uses it, and I didn t get an electric one because I m not at all unhappy with the bakery-style pizza we make in our regular oven, and I have to admit we also wanted to play with fire1. We also needed an outdoor table suitable to use the oven on and store it. Here I looked for inspiration at the Ooni tables (and for cheaper alternatives in the same style), but my mother who shares the outdoor area with us wasn t happy with the idea of steel2. And then I was browsing the modern viking shores, and found that there was a new piece in the N MMAR series my mother likes (and of which we already have some reclining chairs): a kitchen unit in wood with a steel top. At first I expected to just skip the back panel, since it would be in the way when using the oven, but then I realized that it could probably be assembled upside down, down from the top between the table legs, and we decided to try that option. This week everything had arrived, and we could try it. Yesterday evening, after dinner (around 21, I think) I prepared the dough with the flour I usually use for bakery-style pizza: Farina di Grano Tenero Tipo 0 PANE (320 - 340 W); since I wanted to make things easier for myself I only used 55% hydration, so the recipe was:
  • 1 kg flour
  • 550 g water
  • 2 g dry yeast
  • 12 g salt
The next time I think I ll try with one of my other staples: Molino Bogetto etichetta blu (260/280 W) Then this morning we assembled the N MMAR , then I divided the dough in eight balls, put them in a covered but not sealed container 3, well floured with rice flour and then we fired the oven (as in: my partner did, I looked for a short while and then set the table and stuff), using charcoal, because we already had some, and could conveniently get more at the supermarket. When the oven had reached temperatures in the orange range4 I stretched the smallest ball out, working on my wooden peel, sprayed it with water5, sprinkled it with coarse salt and put it in the oven. After 30 seconds I turned it around with the new metal peel, then again after 30 seconds, and then I lost count of how many times I repeated this6, but it was probably 2 or 3 minutes until it looked good. A flatbread on a regular plate: it's only a bit more than half the plate in diameter, puffed up near the borders and thin in the middle, and only lightly browned in places, not burnt. It's sitting on the lower shelf of a wooden table. And it was good. The kind of pizza that is quite soft, especially near the borders. We ate it with fresh mozzarella and tomatoes, and then made another one the same way, to finish the mozzarella. Another flatbread on the same plate, this time it's about 4 cm smaller than the plate on all sides, and it's covered with brownish-red chopped up vegetables. This was supposed to be our lunch, but we decided to try one with some leftover cooked radicchio, and that also worked quite nicely. And finally, we decided we needed to try a more classical pizza, with tomato sauce and cured meat, of which we forgot to take pictures. Up to here we had eaten about half of the dough, and we were getting full: I had prepared significantly more than what I expected to eat, to be able to accidentally burn some, but also with the idea to bake something else to be eaten later. So I made two more focaccias with just water and salt, and then I tried to cook some bread with what I expected to be residual heat. Another flatbread with coarse salt and two bread rolls, one of which is completely carbonized on one side. The other one has been cut, and while it has a carbonized spot, it is also well cooked in the middle, and perfectly edible. Except that the oven was getting a bit too cold, so my partner added some charcoal, and when I put the last two unflattened balls right at the back of the oven where it was still warmer, that side carbonized. After 5 minutes I moved them to the middle of the oven, and turned them, and then after another turn and 5 more minutes they were ready. And other than the burnt crust, they were pretty edible. So, the thoughts after our first experience. Everybody around the table (my SO, my mother and me) was quite happy with the results, and they are different enough from the ones I could get with the regular oven. As I should have expected, it s much faster than a masonry oven, both in getting to temperature and in cooling down: my plan for residual heat bread cooking will have to be adjusted with experience. We were able to get it hot enough, but not as hot as it s supposed to be able to get: we suspect that using just charcoal may have influenced it, and next week we ll try to get some wood, and try with a mix. As for the recipe, dividing the dough in eight parts worked quite well: maybe the pizzas are a bit on the smaller side, but since they come one at a time it s more convenient to cut and share them, and maybe make a couple more at the end. Of course, I ll want to try different recipes, for different styles of pizzas (including some almost-trademark-violating ones) and for other types of flatbread. I expect it won t be hard to find volunteers to help us with the experiments. :D

  1. any insinuation that there may have been considerations of having a way to have freshly baked bread in case of a prolonged blackout may or may not be based on reality. But it wasn t the only or even the main reason.
  2. come on! it s made of STEEL. how can it be not good? :D
  3. IKEA 365+ 3.1 glass, the one that is 32 cm 21 cm 9 cm; it was just big enough for the amount of dough, and then I covered it with a lid that is missing the seal.
  4. why did they put a thermometer on it, and not add labels with the actual temperature? WHY???
  5. if you don t have dietary restrictions a bit of olive oil would taste even better.
  6. numbers above 2 are all basically the same, right?

15 April 2026

Freexian Collaborators: Debian Contributions: Debusine projects in GSoC, Debian CI updates, Salsa CI maintenance and more! (by Anupa Ann Joseph)

Debian Contributions: 2026-03 Contributing to Debian is part of Freexian s mission. This article covers the latest achievements of Freexian and their collaborators. All of this is made possible by organizations subscribing to our Long Term Support contracts and consulting services.

Debusine projects in Google s Summer of Code While Freexian initiated Debusine, and is investing a lot of resources in the project, we manage it as a true free software project that can and should have a broader community. We always had documentation for new contributors and we aim to be reactive with them when they interact via the issue tracker or via merge requests. We decided to put those intentions under stress tests by proposing five projects for Google s Summer of Code as part of Debian s participation in that program. Given that at least 11 candidates managed to get their merge request accepted in the last 30 days (interacting with the development team is part of the pre-requisites to apply to Google Summer of Code projects these days), the contributing experience must not be too bad. If you want to try it out, we maintain a list of quick fixes that are accessible to newcomers. And as always, we welcome your feedback!

Debian CI: incus backend and upgrade to Bootstrap 5, by Antonio Terceiro debci 3.14 was released on March 4th, with a followup 3.14.1 release with regression fixes a few days afterwards. Those releases were followed by new development and maintenance work that will provide extra capabilities and stability to the platform. This month saw the initial version of an incus backend land in Debian CI. The transition into the new backend will be done carefully so as to not disrupt testing migration. Each package will be running jobs with both the current lxc backend and with incus. Packages that have the same result on both backends will be migrated over, and packages that exhibit different results will be investigated further, resulting in bug reports and/or other communication with the maintainers. On the frontend side, the code has been ported to Bootstrap 5 over from the now ancient Bootstrap 3. This need has been originally reported back in 2024 based on the lack of security support for Bootstrap 3. Beyond improving maintainability, this upgrade also enables support for dark mode in debci, which is still work in progress. Both updates mentioned in this section will be available in a following debci release.

Salsa CI maintenance by Santiago Ruano Rinc n et al. Santiago reviewed some Salsa CI issues and reviewed associated merge requests. For example, he investigated a regression (#545), introduced by the move to sbuild, on the use of extra repositories configured as .source files; and reviewed the MR (!712) that fixes it. Also, there were conflicts with changes made in debci 3.14 and debci 3.14.1 (those updates are mentioned above), and different people have contributed to fix the subsequent issues, in a long-term way. This includes Rapha l who proposed MR !707 and who also suggested Antonio to merge the Salsa CI patches to avoid similar errors in the future. This happened shortly after. Those fixes finally required the unrelated MR !709, which will prevent similar problems when building images. To identify bugs related to the autopkgtest support in the backport suites as early as possible, Santiago proposed MR !708. Finally, Santiago, in collaboration with Emmanuel Arias also had exchanges with GSoC candidates for the Salsa CI project, including the contributions they have made as merge requests. It is important to note that there are several very good candidates interested in participating. Thanks a lot to them for their work so far!

Miscellaneous contributions
  • Rapha l reported a zim bug affecting Debian Unstable users, which was already fixed in git apparently. He could thus cherry-pick the fix and update the package in Debian Unstable.
  • Carles created a new page on the InstallingDebianOn in Debian Wiki.
  • Carles submitted translation errors in the debian-installer Weblate.
  • Carles, using po-debconf-manager, improved Catalan translations: reviewed and submitted 3 packages. Also improved error handling when forking or submitting an MR if the fork already existed.
  • Carles kept improving check-relations: code base related general improvements (added strict typing, enabled pre-commit). Also added DebPorts support, virtual packages support and added commands for reporting missing relations and importing bugs from bugs.debian.org.
  • Antonio handled miscellaneous Salsa support requests.
  • Antonio improved the management of MiniDebConf websites by keeping all non-secret settings in git and fixed exporting these sites as static HTML.
  • Stefano uploaded routine updates to hatchling, python-mitogen, python-virtualenv, python-discovery, dh-python, pypy3, python-pipx, and git-filter-repo.
  • Faidon uploaded routine updates to crun, libmaxminddb, librdkafka, lowdown, platformdirs, python-discovery, sphinx-argparse-cli, tox, tox-uv.
  • Stefano and Santiago continued to help with DebConf 26 preparations.
  • Stefano reviewed some contributions to debian-reimbursements and handled admin for reimbursements.debian.net.
  • Stefano attended the Debian Technical Committee meeting.
  • Helmut sent 8 patches for cross build failures.
  • Building on the work of postmarketOS, Helmut managed to cross build systemd for musl in rebootstrap and sent several patches in the process.
  • Helmut reviewed several MRs of Johannes Schauer Marin Rodrigues expanding support for DPKG_ROOT to support installing hurd.
  • Helmut incorporated a final round of feedback for the Multi-Arch documentation in Debian policy, which finally made it into unstable together with documentation of Build-Profiles.
  • In order to fix python-memray, Helmut NMUed libunwind generally disabling C++ exception support as being an incompatible duplication of the gcc implementation. Unfortunately, that ended up breaking suricata on riscv64. After another NMU, python-memray finally migrated.
  • Thorsten uploaded new upstream versions of epson-inkjet-printer-escpr and sane-airscan. He also fixed a packaging bug in printer-driver-oki. As of systemd 260.1-1 the configuration of lpadmin has been added to the sysusers.d configuration. All printing packages can now simply depend on the systemd-sysusers package and don t have to take care of its creation in maintainer scripts anymore.
  • In collaboration with Emmanuel Arias, Santiago had exchanges with GSoC candidates and reviewed the proposals of the Linux livepatching GSoC 2026 project.
  • Colin helped to fix CVE-2026-3497 in openssh and CVE-2026-28356 in multipart.
  • Colin upgraded tango and pytango to new upstream releases and packaged pybind11-stubgen (needed for pytango), thanks to a Freexian customer. Tests of reproducible builds revealed that pybind11-stubgen didn t generate imports in a stable order; this is now fixed upstream.
  • Lucas fixed CVE-2025-67733 and CVE-2026-21863 affecting src:valkey in unstable and testing. Also reviewed the same fixes targeting stable proposed by Peter Wienemann.
  • Faidon worked with upstream and build-dep Debian maintainers on resolving blockers in order to bring pyHanko into Debian, starting with the adoption of python-pyhanko-certvalidator. pyHanko is a suite for signing and stamping PDF files, and one of the few libraries that can be leveraged to sign PDFs with eIDAS Qualified Electronic Signatures.
  • Anupa co-organized MiniDebConf Kanpur and attended the event with many others from all across India. She handled the accommodation arrangements along with the registration team members, worked on the budget and expenses. She was also a speaker at the event.
  • Lucas helped with content review/schedule for the MiniDebConf Campinas. Thanks Freexian for being a Gold sponsor!
  • Lucas organized and took part in a one-day in-person sprint to work on Ruby 3.4 transition. It was held in a coworking space in Brasilia - Brazil on April 6th. There were 5 DDs and they fixed multiple packages FTBFSing against Ruby 3.4 (coming to unstable soon hopefully). Lucas has been postponing a blog post about this sprint since then :-)

14 April 2026

Dirk Eddelbuettel: anytime 0.3.13 on CRAN: Mostly Minor Bugfix

A maintenance release 0.3.13 of the anytime package arrived on CRAN today, sticking with the roughly yearly schedule we have now. Binaries for r2u have been built already. The package is fairly feature-complete, and code and functionality remain mature and stable. anytime is a very focused package aiming to do just one thing really well: to convert anything in integer, numeric, character, factor, ordered, input format to either POSIXct (when called as anytime) or Date objects (when called as anydate) and to do so without requiring a format string as well as accomodating different formats in one input vector. See the anytime page, the GitHub repo for a few examples, the nice pdf vignette, and the beautiful documentation site for all documentation. This release was triggered by a bizarre bug seen on elementary os 8. For reason anytime was taking note on startup where it runs, and used a small and simply piece of code reading /etc/os-release when it exists. We assumed sane content, but this particular operating system and releases managed to have a duplicate entry throwing us spanner. So now this code is robust to duplicates, and no longer executed on each startup but as needed which is a net improvement. We also switched the vignette to being deployed by the new Rcpp::asis() driver. The short list of changes follows.

Changes in anytime version 0.3.13 (2026-04-14)
  • Continuous integration has received minor updates
  • The vignette now use the Rcpp::asis() driver, and references have been refreshed
  • Stateful 'where are we running' detection is now more robust, and has been moved from running on each startup to a cached 'as needed' case

Courtesy of my CRANberries, there is also a diffstat report of changes relative to the previous release. The issue tracker tracker off the GitHub repo can be use for questions and comments. More information about the package is at the package page, the GitHub repo, in the vignette, and at the documentation site.

This post by Dirk Eddelbuettel originated on his Thinking inside the box blog. If you like this or other open-source work I do, you can now sponsor me at GitHub. You can also sponsor my Tour de Shore 2026 ride in support of the Maywood Fine Arts Center.

Russell Coker: Furilabs FLX1s Finally Working

I ve been using the Furilabs FLX1s phone [1] as my daily driver for 6 weeks, it s a decent phone, not as good as I hoped but good enough to use every day and rely on for phone calls about job interviews etc. I intend to keep using it as my main phone and as a platform to improve phone software in Debian as you really can t effectively find bugs unless you use the platform for important tasks. Support Problems I previously wrote about the phone after I received it without a SIM caddy on the 13th of Jan. I had a saga with support about this, on the 16th of Jan one support person said that they would ship it immediately but didn t provide a tracking number or any indication of when it would arrive. On the 5th of Feb I contacted support again and asked how long it would be, the new support person seemed to have no record of my previous communication but said that they would send it. On the 17th of Feb I made another support request including asking for a way of direct communication as the support email came from an address that wouldn t accept replies, I was asked for a photo showing where the problem is. The support person also said that they might have to send a replacement phone! The last support request I sent included my disappointment at the time taken to resolve the issue and the proposed solution of replacing the entire phone (why have two international shipments of a fragile and expensive phone when a single letter with a cheap SIM caddy would do?). I didn t receive a reply but the SIM caddy arrived on the 2nd of Mar. Here is a pic of the SIM caddy and the package it came in: One thing that should be noted is that some of the support people seemed to be very good at their jobs and they were all friendly. It was the system that failed here, turning a minor issue of a missing part into a 6 week saga. Furilabs needs to do the following to address this issue:
  1. Make it possible to reply directly to a message from a support person. Accept email with a custom subject to sort it, give a URL for a web form, anything. Collating discussions with a customer allows giving better support while taking less time for the support people.
  2. Have someone monitor every social media address that is used by the company. When someone sends a support request in a public Mastodon post it indicates that something has gone wrong and you want to move quickly to resolve it.
  3. Take care of the little things, like sending a tracking number for every parcel. If it s something too small for a parcel (the SIM caddy could have fit in a regular letter) then just tell the customer what date it was posted and where it was posted from so they have some idea of when it will arrive.
This is not just a single failure of Furilabs support, it s a systemic failure of their processes. Problems I Will Fix Unless Someone Beats Me to it Here are some issues I plan to work on. Smart Watch Support I need to port one of the smart watch programs to Debian. Also I want to make one of them support the Colmi P80 [2]. A smart watch significantly increases the utility of a phone even though IMHO they aren t doing nearly all the things that they could and should do. When we get Debian programs talking to the PineTime it will make a good platform for development of new smart phone and OS features. Nextcloud I have ongoing issues of my text Nextcloud installation on a Debian VM not allowing connection from the Linux desktop app (as packaged in Debian) and from the Android client (from f-droid). The desktop client works with a friend s Nextcloud installation on Ubuntu so I may try running it on an Ubuntu VM I run while waiting for the Debian issue to get resolved. There was a bug recently fixed in Nextcloud that appears related so maybe the next release will fix it. For the moment I ve been running without these features and I call and SMS people from knowing their number or just returning calls. Phone calls generally aren t very useful for me nowadays except when applying for jobs. If I could deal with recruiters and hiring managers via video calls then I would consider just not having a phone number. Wifi IPv6 Periodically IPv6 support just stops working, I can t ping the gateway. I turn wifi off and on again and it works. This might be an issue with my wifi network configuration. This might be an issue with the way I have configured my IPv6 networking, although that problem doesn t happen with any of my laptops. Chatty Sorting Chatty is the program for SMS that is installed by default (part of the phosh/phoc setup), it also does Jabber. Version 0.8.7 is installed which apparently has some Furios modifications and it doesn t properly support sorting SMS/Jabber conversations. Version 0.8.9 from Debian sorts in the same way as most SMS and Jabber programs with the most recent at the top. But the Debian version doesn t support Jabber (only SMS and Matrix). When I went back to the Furilabs version of Chatty it still sorted for a while but then suddenly stopped. Killing Chatty (not just closing the window and reopening it) seems to make it sort the conversations sometimes. Problems for Others to Fix Here are the current issues I have starting with the most important. Important The following issues seriously reduce the usability of the device. Hotspot The Wifi hotspot functionality wasn t working for a few weeks, this Gitlab issue seems to match it [3]. It started working correctly for a day and I was not sure if an update I applied fixed the bug or if it s some sort of race condition that worked for this boot and will return next time I reboot it. Later on I rebooted it and found that it s somewhat random whether it works or now. Also while it is mostly working it seemed to stop working about every 25 minutes or so and I had to turn it off and on again to get it going. On another day it went to a stage where it got repeated packet loss when I pinged the phone as a hotspot from my laptop. A pattern of 3 ping responses and 3 Destination Host Unreachable messages was often repeated. I don t know if this is related to the way Android software is run in a container to access the hardware. 4G Reliability Sometimes 4G connectivity has just stopped, sometimes I can stop and restart the 4G data through software to fix it and sometimes I need to use the hardware switch. I haven t noticed this for a week or two so there is a possibility that one fix addressed both Hotspot and 4G. One thing that I will do is setup monitoring to give an alert on the phone if it can t connect to the Internet. I don t want it to just quietly stop doing networking stuff and not tell me! On-screen Keyboard The compatibility issues of the GNOME and KDE on-screen keyboards are getting me. I use phosh/phoc as the login environment as I want to stick to defaults at first to not make things any more difficult than they need to be. When I use programs that use QT such as Nheko the keyboard doesn t always appear when it should and it forgets the setting for word completion (which means spelling correction). The spelling correction system doesn t suggest replacing dont with don t which is really annoying as a major advantage for spelling checkers on touch screens is inserting an apostrophy. An apostrophy takes at least 3* longer than a regular character and saving that delay makes a difference to typing speed. The spelling correction doesn t correct two words run together. Medium Priority These issues are ongoing annoyances. Delay on Power Button In the best case scenario this phone has a much slower response to pressing the power button than the Android phones I tested (Huawei Mate 10 Pro and Samsung Galaxy Note 9) and a much slower response than my recollection of the vast majority of Android phones I ve ever used. For testing pressing buttons on the phones simultaneously resulted in the Android phone screens lighting up much sooner. Something like 200ms vs 600ms I don t have a good setup to time these things but it s very obvious when I test. In a less common case scenario (the phone having been unused for some time) the response can be something like 5 seconds. The worst case scenario is something in excess of 20 seconds. For UI designers, if you get multiple press events from a button that can turn the screen on/off please make your UI leave the screen on and ignore all the stacked events. Having the screen start turning on and off repeatedly when the phone recovers and processes all the button presses isn t good, especially when each screen flash takes half a second. Notifications Touching on a notification for a program often doesn t bring it to the foreground. I haven t yet found a connection between when it does and when it doesn t. Also the lack of icons in the top bar on the screen to indicate notifications is annoying, but that seems to be an issue of design not the implementation. Charge Delay When I connect the phone to a power source there is a delay of about 22 seconds before it starts to charge. Having it miss 22 seconds of charge time is no big deal, having to wait 22 seconds to be sure it s charging before leaving it is really annoying. Also the phone makes an audible alert when it gets to 0% charge which woke me up one night when I had failed to push the USB-C connector in hard enough. This phone requires a slightly deeper connector than most phones so with some plugs it s easy to not quite insert them far enough. Torch aka Flash The light for the torch or flash for camera is not bright at all. In a quick test staring into the light from 40cm away wasn t unpleasant compared to my Huawei Mate 10 Pro which has a light bright enough that it hurts to look at it from 4 meters away. Because of this photos at night are not viable, not even when photographing something that s less than a meter away. The torch has a brightness setting which doesn t seem to change the brightness, so it seems likely that this is a software issue and the brightness is set at a low level and the software isn t changing it. Audio When I connect to my car the Lollypop player starts playing before the phone directs audio to the car, so the music starts coming from the phone for about a second. This is an annoying cosmetic error. Sometimes audio playing pauses for no apparent reason. It doesn t support the phone profile with Bluetooth so phone calls can t go through the car audio system. Also it doesn t always connect to my car when I start driving, sometimes I need to disable and enable Bluetooth to make it connect. When I initially set the phone up Lollypop would send the track name when playing music through my car (Nissan LEAF) Bluetooth connection, after an update that often doesn t happen so the car doesn t display the track name or whether the music is playing but the pause icon works to pause and resume music (sometimes it does work). About 30 seconds into a phone call it switches to hands-free mode while the icon to indicate hands-free is not highlighted, so I have to press the hands-free button twice to get it back to normal phone mode. Low Priority I could live with these things remaining as-is but it s annoying. Ticket Mode There is apparently some code written to display tickets on screen without unlocking. I want to get this working and store screen-caps of the Android barcode screens of the different loyalty cards so I can scan them without unlocking. My threat model does not include someone trying to steal my phone to get a free loaf of bread on the bakery loyalty program. Camera The camera app works with both the back and front cameras, which is nice, and sadly based on my experience with other Debian phones it s noteworthy. The problem is that it takes a long time to take a photo, something like a second after the button is pressed long enough for you to think that it just silently took a photo and then move the phone. The UI of the furios-camera app is also a little annoying, when viewing photos there is an icon at the bottom left of the screen for a video camera and an icon at the bottom right with a cross. Which every time makes me think record videos and leave this screen not return to taking photos and delete current photo . I can get used to the surprising icons, but being so slow is a real problem. GUI App Installation The program for managing software doesn t work very well. It said that there were two updates for Mesa package needed, but didn t seem to want to install them. I ran flatpak update as root to fix that. The process of selecting software defaults to including non-free, and most of the available apps are for desktop/laptop with no way to search for phone/tablet apps. Generally I think it s best to just avoid this and use apt and flatpak directly from the command-line. Being able to ssh to my phone from a desktop or laptop is good! Android Emulation The file /home/furios/.local/share/andromeda/data/system/uiderrors.txt is created by the Andromeda system which runs Android apps in a LXC container and appears to grow without end. After using the phone for a month it was 3.5G in size. The disk space usage isn t directly a problem, out of the 110G storage space only 17G is used and I don t have a need to put much else on it, even if I wanted to put backups of /home from my laptop on it when travelling that would still leave plenty of free space. But that sort of thing is a problem for backing up the phone and wasting 3.5G out of 110G total is a fairly significant step towards breaking the entire system. Also having lots of logging messages from a subsystem that isn t even being used is a bad sign. I just tried using it and it doesn t start from either the settings menu or from the f-droid icon. Android isn t that important to me as I want to get away from the proprietary app space so I won t bother trying this any more. Unfixable Problems Unlocking After getting used to fingerprint unlocking going back to a password is a pain. I think that the hardware isn t sufficient for modern quality face recognition that can t be fooled by a photo and there isn t fingerprint hardware. When I first used an Android phone using a pin to unlock didn t seem like a big deal, but after getting used to fingerprint unlock it s a real drag to go without. This is a real annoyance when doing things like checking Wikipedia while watching TV. This phone would be significantly improved with a fingerprint sensor or a camera that worked well enough for face unlock. Plasma Mobile According to Reddit Plasma Mobile (KDE for phones) doesn t support Halium and can never work on this phone because of it [4]. This is one of a number of potential issues with the phone, running on hardware that was never designed for open OSs is always going to have issues. Wifi MAC Address The MAC keeps changing on reboot so I can t assign a permanent IPv4 address to the phone. It appears from the MAC prefix of 00:08:22 that the network hardware is made in InPro Comm which is well known for using random addresses in the products it OEMs. They apparently have one allocation of 2^24 addresses and each device randomly chooses a MAC from that range on boot. In the settings for a Wifi connection the Identity tab has a field named Cloned Address which can be set to Stable for SSID that prevents it from changing and allows a static IP address allocation from DHCP. It s not ideal but it works. Network Manager can be configured to have a permanent assigned MAC address for all connections or for just some connections. In the past for such things I have copied MAC addresses from ethernet devices that were being discarded and used them for such things. For the moment the Stable for SSID setting does what I need but I will consider setting a permanent address at some future time. Docks Having the ability to connect to a dock is really handy. The PinePhonePro and Librem5 support it and on the proprietary side a lot of Samsung devices do it with a special desktop GUI named Dex and some Huawei devices also have a desktop version of the GUI. It s unfortunate that this phone can t do it. The Good Things It s good to be able to ssh in to my phone, even if the on-screen keyboard worked as well as the Android ones it would still be a major pain to use when compared to a real keyboard. The phone doesn t support connecting to a dock (unlike Samsung phones I ve used for which I found Dex to be very useful with a 4K monitor and proper keyboard) so ssh is the best way to access it. This phone has very reliable connections to my home wifi. I ve had ssh sessions from my desktop to my phone that have remained open for multiple days. I don t really need this, I ve just forgotten to logout and noticed days later that the connection is still running. None of the other phones running Debian could do that. Running the same OS on desktop and phone makes things easier to test and debug. Having support for all the things that Linux distributions support is good. For example none of the Android music players support all the encodings of audio that comes from YouTube so to play all of my music collection on Android I would need to transcode most of them which means either losing quality, wasting storage space, or both. While Lollypop plays FLAC0, mp3, m4a, mka, webm, ogg, and more. Conclusion This is a step towards where I want to go but it s far from the end goal. The PinePhonePro and Librem5 are more open hardware platforms which have some significant benefits. But the battery life issues make them unusable for me. Running Mobian on a OnePlus 6 or Droidian on a Note 9 works well for the small tablet features but without VoLTE. While the telcos have blocked phones without VoLTE data devices still work so if recruiters etc would stop requiring phone calls then I could make one of them an option. The phone works well enough that it could potentially be used by one of my older relatives. If I could ssh in to my parents phones when they mess things up that would be convenient. I ve run this phone as my daily driver since the 3rd of March and it has worked reasonably well. 6 weeks compared to my previous use of the PinePhonePro for 3 days. This is the first time in 15 years that a non-Android phone has worked for me personally. I have briefly used an iPhone 7 for work which basically did what it needed to do, it was at the bottom of the pile of unused phones at work and I didn t want to take a newer iPhone that could be used by someone who s doing more than the occasional SMS or Slack message. So this is better than it might have been, not as good as I hoped, but a decent platform to use it while developing for it.

12 April 2026

Vasudev Kamath: Hardening the Unpacakgeable: A systemd-run Sandbox for Third-Party Binaries

The Shift in Software Consumption Historically, I have been a "distribution-first" user. Sticking to tools packaged within the Debian archives provides a layer of trust; maintainers validate licenses, audit code, and ensure the entire dependency chain is verified. However, the rapid pace of development in the Generative AI space specifically with new tools like Gemini-CLI has made this traditional approach difficult to sustain. Many modern CLI tools are built within the npm or Python ecosystems. For a distribution packager, these are a nightmare; packaging a single tool often requires packaging a massive, shifting dependency chain. Consequently, I found myself forced to use third-party binaries, bypassing the safety of the Debian archive.
The Supply Chain Risk Recent supply chain attacks affecting widely used packages like axios and LiteLLM have made it clear: running unvetted binaries on a personal system is a significant risk. These scripts often have full access to your $HOME directory, SSH keys, and the system D-Bus. After discussing these concerns with a colleague, I was inspired by his approach using a Flatpak-style sandbox for even basic applications like Google Chrome. I decided to build a generalized version of this using OpenCode and Qwen 3.6 Fast (which was available for free use at the time) to create a robust, transient sandbox utility.
The Solution: safe-run-binary My script, safe-run-binary, leverages systemd-run to execute binaries within an isolated scope. It implements strict filesystem masking and resource control to ensure that even if a dependency is compromised, the "blast radius" is contained.
Key Technical Features
1. Virtualized Home Directory (tmpfs)
Instead of exposing my real home directory, the script mounts a tmpfs over $HOME. It then selectively creates and bind-mounts only the necessary subdirectories (like .cache or .config) into a virtual structure. This prevents the application from ever "seeing" sensitive files like ~/.ssh or ~/.gnupg.
2. D-Bus Isolation via xdg-dbus-proxy
For GUI applications, providing raw access to the D-Bus is a security hole. The script uses xdg-dbus-proxy to sit between the application and the system bus. By using the --filter and --talk=org.freedesktop.portal.* flags, the app can only communicate with necessary portals (like the file picker) rather than sniffing the entire bus.
3. Linux Namespace Restrictions

The sandbox utilizes several systemd execution properties to harden the process:

  • RestrictNamespaces=yes: For CLI tools, this prevents the app from creating its own nested namespaces.
  • PrivateTmp=yes: Ensures a private /tmp space that isn't shared with the host.
  • NoNewPrivileges=yes: Prevents the binary from gaining elevated permissions through SUID/SGID bits.
4. GPU and Audio Passthrough
The script intelligently detects and binds Wayland, PipeWire, and NVIDIA/DRI device nodes. This allows browsers like Firefox to run with full hardware acceleration and audio support while remaining locked out of the rest of the filesystem.
Usage To run a CLI tool like Gemini-CLI with access only to a specific directory:
safe-run-binary -b ~/.gemini-config -- npx @google/gemini-cli
For a GUI application like Firefox:
safe-run-binary --gui -b ~/.mozilla -b ~/.cache/mozilla -b ~/Downloads -- firefox
Conclusion While it is not always possible to escape the need for third-party software, it is possible to control the environment in which it operates. By leveraging native Linux primitives like systemd and namespaces, high-grade isolation is achievable. PS: If you spot any issues or have suggestions for improving the script, feel free to raise a PR on the repo.

10 April 2026

Reproducible Builds: Reproducible Builds in March 2026

Welcome to the March 2026 report from the Reproducible Builds project! These reports outline what we ve been up to over the past month, highlighting items of news from elsewhere in the increasingly-important area of software supply-chain security. As ever, if you are interested in contributing to the Reproducible Builds project, please see the Contribute page on our website.

  1. Linux kernel hash-based integrity checking proposed
  2. Distribution work
  3. Tool development
  4. Upstream patches
  5. Documentation updates
  6. Two new academic papers
  7. Misc news

Linux kernel hash-based integrity checking proposed Eric Biggers posted to the Linux Kernel Mailing List in response to a patch series posted by Thomas Wei schuh to introduce a calculated hash-based system of integrity checking to complement the existing signature-based approach. Thomas original post mentions:
The current signature-based module integrity checking has some drawbacks in combination with reproducible builds. Either the module signing key is generated at build time, which makes the build unreproducible, or a static signing key is used, which precludes rebuilds by third parties and makes the whole build and packaging process much more complicated.
However, Eric s followup message goes further:
I think this actually undersells the feature. It s also much simpler than the signature-based module authentication. The latter relies on PKCS#7, X.509, ASN.1, OID registry, crypto_sig API, etc in addition to the implementations of the actual signature algorithm (RSA / ECDSA / ML-DSA) and at least one hash algorithm.

Distribution work In Debian this month,
  • Lucas Nussbaum announced Debaudit, a new service to verify the reproducibility of Debian source packages :
    debaudit complements the work of the Reproducible Builds project. While reproduce.debian.net focuses on ensuring that binary packages can be bit-for-bit reproduced from their source packages, debaudit focuses on the preceding step: ensuring that the source package itself is a faithful and reproducible representation of its upstream source or Vcs-Git repository.
  • kpcyrd filed a bug against the librust-const-random-dev package reporting that the compile-time-rng feature of the ahash crate uses the const-random crate in turn, which uses a macro to read/generate a random number generator during the build. This issue was also filed upstream.
  • 60 reviews of Debian packages were added, 4 were updated and 16 were removed this month adding to our knowledge about identified issues. One new issue types was added, pkgjs_lock_json_file_issue.
Lastly, Bernhard M. Wiedemann posted another openSUSE monthly update for their work there.

Tool development diffoscope is our in-depth and content-aware diff utility that can locate and diagnose reproducibility issues. This month, Chris Lamb made a number of changes, including preparing and uploading versions, 314 and 315 to Debian.
  • Chris Lamb:
    • Don t run test_code_is_black_clean test in the autopkgtests. (#1130402). [ ]
    • Add some debugging info for PyPI debugging. [ ]
  • Jelle van der Waa:
    • Fix compatibility with LLVM version 22. [ ]
    • Adjust the PGP file detection regular expression. [ ]
  • Michael R. Crusoe:
    • Reformat the source code using Black version 26.1.0 [ ][ ]
In addition, Vagrant Cascadian updated diffoscope in GNU Guix to version 315.
rebuilderd, our server designed monitor the official package repositories of Linux distributions and attempt to reproduce the observed results there; it powers, amongst other things, reproduce.debian.net. A new version, 0.26.0, was released this month, with the following improvements:
  • Much smoother onboarding/installation.
  • Complete database redesign with many improvements.
  • New REST HTTP API.
  • It s now possible to artificially delay the first reproduce attempt. This gives archive infrastructure more time to catch up.
  • And many, many other changes.

Upstream patches The Reproducible Builds project detects, dissects and attempts to fix as many currently-unreproducible packages as possible. We endeavour to send all of our patches upstream where appropriate. This month, we wrote a large number of such patches, including:

Documentation updates Once again, there were a number of improvements made to our website this month including:
  • kpcyrd:
    • Add a new page about Rust specifics. [ ][ ][ ]
  • Robin Candau:
    • Add link to the diffoci Arch Linux package on the Tools page. [ ]
  • Timo Pohl:

Two new academic papers Marc Ohm, Timo Pohl, Ben Swierzy and Michael Meier published a paper on the threat of cache poisoning in the Python ecosystem: Attacks on software supply chains are on the rise, and attackers are becoming increasingly creative in how they inject malicious code into software components. This paper is the first to investigate Python cache poisoning, which manipulates bytecode cache files to execute malicious code without altering the human-readable source code. We demonstrate a proof of concept, showing that an attacker can inject malicious bytecode into a cache file without failing the Python interpreter s integrity checks. In a large-scale analysis of the Python Package Index, we find that about 12,500 packages are distributed with cache files. Through manual investigation of cache files that cannot be reproduced automatically from the corresponding source files, we identify classes of reasons for irreproducibility to locate malicious cache files. While we did not identify any malware leveraging this attack vector, we demonstrate that several widespread package managers are vulnerable to such attacks. A PDF of the paper is available online.
Mario Lins of the University of Linz, Austria, has published their PhD doctoral thesis on the topic of Software supply chain transparency: We begin by examining threats to the software distribution stage the point at which artifacts (e.g., mobile apps) are delivered to end users with an emphasis on mobile ecosystems [and] we next focus on the operating system on mobile devices, with an emphasis on mitigating bootloader-targeted attacks. We demonstrate how to compensate lost security guarantees on devices with an unlocked bootloader. This allows users to flash custom operating systems on devices that no longer receive security updates from the original manufacturer without compromising security. We then move to the source code stage. [Also,] we introduce a new architecture to ensure strong source-to-binary correspondence by leveraging the security guarantees of Confidential Computing technology. Finally, we present The Supply Chain Game, an organizational security approach that enhances standard risk-management methods. We demonstrate how game-theoretic techniques, combined with common risk management practices, can derive new criteria to better support decision makers. A PDF of the paper is available online.

Misc news On our mailing list this month:
  • Holger Levsen announced that this year s Reproducible Builds summit will almost certainly be held in Gothenburg, Sweden, from September 22 until 24, followed by two days of hacking. However, these dates are preliminary and not 100% final an official announcement is forthcoming.
  • Mark Wielaard posted to our list asking a question on the difference between debugedit and relative debug paths based on a comment on the Build path page: Have people tried more modern versions of debugedit to get deterministic (absolute) DWARF paths and found issues with it?


Finally, if you are interested in contributing to the Reproducible Builds project, please visit our Contribute page on our website. However, you can get in touch with us via:

2 April 2026

Joerg Jaspert: Building a house - 1 year in

Haven t written here about it, but last March we finally started on our journey to get our own house build, so we can move out of the rented flat here. That will be a big step, both the actual building, but also the moving - I am living at this one single place for 36 years now. If you can read german there is a dedicated webpage where I sometimes write about the process. Will have much more details (and way more ramblings) than the following part. If you can t read german, a somewhat short summary follows. Yes, still a lot of text, but shortened, still.

What? Why now? Current flat has 83m - which simply isn t enough space. And the number of rooms also doesn t fit anymore. But it is hard to find a place that fits our requirements (which do include location). Moving to a different rented place would also mean changed amount of rent. And nowadays that would be huge increase (my current rent is still the price from about 30 years ago!). So if we go and pay more - we could adjust and pay for something we own instead. And both, my wife and I had changes in our jobs that made it possible for us now, so we started looking.

Market Brrrr, looking is good, actually finding something that fits - not so. We never found an offer that fit. Space wise, sure. But then location was off, or price was idiotically high. Location fit, but then size was a joke, and guess about the price Who needs 200 square meters with 3 rooms? Entirely stupid design choices there. Or how about 40 square meters of hallway - with 50m of tiny rooms around. What are they smoking? Oh, there, useful size, good rooms - but now you want more money than a kidney is worth, or something. Thanks, no.

New place In February 2025 we finally got lucky and found a (newly opened) area with a large number of places to build a house on. Had multiple talks with someone from on of the companies developing that area (there are two you can select from), then talked with banks and signed a contract in March 2025. We got promised that actual house construction would be first quarter of 2026, finished in second quarter.

House type There are basically 2 ways of building a new house (that matter here). First is called Massivhaus , second is called Fertighaus in german, roughly translating to solid and prefabricated. The latter commonly a wood based construction, though it doesn t need to be. The important part of it is the prefabrication, walls and stuff get assembled in a factory somewhere and then transported to your place, where they play big kid lego for a day and suddenly a house is there. A common thought is prefabricated is faster, but that is only a half true. Sure, the actual work on side is way shorter - usually one or two days and the house is done - while a massive construction usually takes weeks to build up. But that is only a tiny part of the time needed, the major part goes of into planning and waiting and in there it doesn t matter what material you end up with.

Money fun Last year already wasn t the best time to start a huge loan - but isn t it always a few years ago would have been better ? So we had multiple talks with different banks and specialised consultants until we found something that we thought is good for us. Thinking about it now - we should have put even more money on top as reserve , but who could have thought that 2026 turns into such a shitshow? Does not help at all, quite the contrary. And that damn lotto game always ends up with the wrong numbers, meh.

Plans and plans and more plans - and rules For whichever reason you can not just go and put something on your ground and be happy. At least not if you are part of the normal people and not enormously rich. There is a large set of rules to follow. Usually that is a good thing, even though some rules are sometimes hard to understand. In Germany, besides the usual laws, we have something that is called Bebauungsplan , which translates to development plan (don t know if that carries the right meaning, it s a plan on what and how may be build, which can have really detailed specifications in). It basically tells you every aspect on top of the normal law that you have to keep in mind. In our case we have the requirement of 2 full floors and CAN have a third smaller on top, it limits how high the house can be and also how high our ground floor may be compared to the street. It regulates where on the property we may build and how much ground we may cover with the house, it gives a set of colors we are allowed to use, it demands a flat roof that we must have as a green roof and has a number of things more that aren t important enough to list here. If you do want to see the full list, my german post on it has all the details that matter to us. With all that stuff in mind - off to plans. Wouldn t have believed how many details there are to take in. Room sizes are simple, but how to arrange them for ideal usage of the sun, useful ways inside the house, but also keeping in mind that water needs to flow through and out. Putting a bath room right atop a living room means a water pipe needs to go down there. Switch the bath room side in the house, and it suddenly is above the kitchen - means you can connect the pipes from it to the ones from kitchen, which is much preferred than going through the living room. And lots more such things. It took us until nearly end of October to finalize the plans! And we learned a whole load from it. We started with a lot of wishes. The planner tried to make them work. Then we changed our minds. Plans changed. Minds changed again. Comparing the end result with the first draft we changed most of the ground floor around, with only the stairs and the entrance door at the same position. Less changes for the upper floor, but still enough.

Side quests The whole year was riddled with something my son named side quests. We visited a construction exhibition near us, we went to the house builders factory and took a look on how they work. We went to many different other companies that do SOME type of work which we need soon, say inside floors, painters, kitchen and more stuff. Of course the most important side quest was a visit to the notary to finalize the contracts, especially for the plot of land (in Germany you must have a notary for that to get entered into the governments books). Creates lots of fees, of course, for the notary and also the government (both fees and taxes here).

Building permit We had been lucky and only needed a small change to the plans to get the building permit - and the second part, the wastewater permit (yes, you need a separate one for this) also got through without trouble.

Choices, so many of them So in January we finally had an appointment for something that s called Bemusterung which badly translates to Sampling . Basically two days at the house builders factory to select all of what s needed for the house that you don t do in the plans. Doors, inside and out and their type and color and handles. Same things for the windows and the blinds and the protection level you want the windows to have. Decide about stairs, design for the sanitary installations - and also the height of the toilet! - and the tiles to put into the bathrooms. Decisions on all the tech needed (heating system, ventilation and whatnot. Two days, busy ones - and you can easily spend a lot of extra money here if you aren t careful. We managed to get out of it with only about 4000 extra, so pretty good.

Electro and automation Now, here I am special. Back when I was young the job I learned is electrician. So here I have very detailed wishes. I am also running lots of automatism in my current flat - obviously the new house should be better than that. So I have a lot of ideas and thoughts on it, so this is entirely extra and certainly out of the ordinary the house builder usually see. Which means I do all of that on my own. Well, the planning and some of the work, I must have a company at hand for certain tasks, it is required by some rules. But they will do what I planned, as long as I don t violate regulations. Which means the whole electrical installation is different. Entirely planned for automatisms and using KNX for it. I am so happy to ditch Homeassistant and the load of Homematic, Zigbee and ZWave based wireless things. Ok, Homeassistant is a nice thing - it can do a lot. And it can bridge between about any system you can find. But it is a central single point of failure. And it is a system that needs constant maintenance. Not touched for a while? Plan for a few hours playing update whack-a-mole. And often enough a component here or there breaks with an update. Can be fixed, but takes another hour or two. So I change. Away from wireless based stuff. To wires. To a system thats a standard for decades already. And works entirely without a SPOF. (Yes, you can add one here too). And, most important, should I ever die - can easily be maintained by anyone out there dealing with KNX, which is a large number of people and companies. Without digging through dozens of specialised integrations and whatnot. I may even end up with Homeassistant again - but that will entirely be as a client. It won t drive automations. It won t be the central point to do anything for the house. It will be a logging and data collecting thing that enables me to put up easy visualizations. It may be an easy interface for smartphones or tablets to control parts of the house, for those parts where one wants this to happen. Not the usual day-to-day stuff, extras on top.

Actual work happening Since march there finally is action visible. The base of the house is getting build. Wednesday the 1st April we finally got the base slab poured on the construction site and in another 10 days the house is getting delivered and build up. A 40ton mobile crane will be there.

1 April 2026

Joey Hess: banning all Anthropic employees

Per my policies, I need to ban every employee and contractor of Anthropic Inc from ever contributing code to any of my projects. Anyone have a list? Any project that requires a Developer Certificate of Origin or similar should be doing this, because Anthropic is making tools that explicitly lie about the origin of patches to free software projects.
UNDERCOVER MODE CRITICAL You are operating UNDERCOVER in a PUBLIC/OPEN-SOURCE repository. [...] Do not blow your cover. NEVER include in commit messages or PR descriptions: [...] The phrase 'Claude Code' or any mention that you are an AI
Co-Authored-By lines or any other attribution
-- via @vedolos

Ben Hutchings: FOSS activity in March 2026

31 March 2026

Russ Allbery: Review: Code Blue Emergency

Review: Code Blue Emergency, by James White
Series: Sector General #7
Publisher: Orb
Copyright: 1987
Printing: May 2003
ISBN: 0-7653-0663-8
Format: Trade paperback
Pages: 252
Code Blue Emergency (annoying em-dash in original title) is the seventh book of James White's Sector General science fiction series about a vast multi-species hospital station. While there are some references to (and spoilers for) earlier books in the series, you don't have to remember the previous books to read this one. I had no trouble despite a nine-year gap. I read this as part of the Orb General Practice omnibus, which collects this novel and The Genocidal Healer. Cha Thrat is a Sommaradvan warrior-surgeon, member of a newly-discovered species that is beginning the process of contact with the Federation. She saved a Monitor corps human after an accident on her world, performing some some highly competent surgery on a species she had never seen before. That plus her somewhat outcast status on her own world due to her very traditional attitude towards medical ethics led Sector General to extend an offer of medical internship, and led her to leap into the unknown by accepting. This may have been a mistake; there is a great deal that Sector General does not understand about Sommaradvan medical ethics. This series entry is another proper (if somewhat episodic) novel and the first book of the series that doesn't primarily focus on Conway. He makes an appearance in his new role as Diagnostician, but only as a supporting character. Code Blue Emergency is told in the tight third-person perspective of Cha Thrat, an alien who finds many things about Sector General baffling, confusing, and ethically troubling (and who therefore provides a good reader surrogate for reintroducing the basics of how the hospital works). Using an alien viewpoint is a more sophisticated narrative technique than White has used previously. I'm glad he tried it, and it mostly works, although I have some complaints. Cha Thrat comes from the middle caste of a strictly hierarchical society of three castes, but is also immensely stubborn and used to a medical system in which doctors take sole responsibility for their patients. This creates a lot of cultural conflicts, and I do enjoy science fiction where the human attitudes are portrayed as the strange ones, but the cultural analysis offered by this novel is not very deep. The pattern of this book is for Cha Thrat to stumble into a successful approach to a problem while being either oblivious to or hostile to the normal hierarchical structure expected of medical trainees. This is believable as far as it goes. She is a skilled and intelligent doctor with some good instincts and a strong commitment to patient care, but is also culturally inclined to not ask for help. It makes sense for that to be a serious problem in a hospital. Unfortunately, no one says this directly. Sector General staff get quite upset in ways that seem more territorial than oriented towards patient safety, no one directly explains to Cha Thrat why following a process is important or shows examples of what could go wrong, and plot armor means that her mistakes usually have positive outcomes. One can extrapolate the reasons why she is not a good medical student, but the reader is forced to do the extrapolation. This is the sort of book where the narration makes clear there are unresolved cultural clashes that are going to cause problems but hides the details. To Cha Thrat, her perspective is so obvious she never bothers to explain it to the reader, so the specifics come as a surprise. As with the alien perspective, I've seen this technique used with more subtlety and sophistication in other books, but White's version mostly works. Cha Thrat is a sympathetic protagonist because she is truly trying to take the most ethical and empathetic action in every situation and is clearly competent. Most of my frustration as a reader, ironically, lands on the other Sector General doctors who seem to make little to no effort to understand her perspective when she fails to conform to their expectations. This is believable in the abstract, but the whole point of Sector General is that they're supposed to be wiser about interspecies difference than this. Also, sometimes their reactions just seem petty. Cha Thrat has a very hierarchical concept of medicine that matches the social classes of her culture. For her, the highest tier of doctor are wizards who treat rulers, because the work of rulers is mostly mental and intellectual and therefore the diseases of rulers are treated with magic spells performed with words to reshape their thinking rather than surgery on their bodies. O'Mara and the other Sector General psychologists take great offense at this, muttering about being called witch doctors, which I found completely absurd. This is a comprehensible, if odd, description of psychology from a wholly alien species. Surely one's first reaction should be that words like "wizard" or "magic" are translation errors. Don't get offended; look to see if the underlying substance matches, which it clearly does. Apart from cultural and psychological clashes, Code Blue Emergency has the standard episodic Sector General structure of interesting medical mysteries that require lateral thinking. I find this sort of puzzle story satisfying, particularly given the firm belief of every character in an essentially pacifist and empathetic approach to even the most alien of creatures. This determined non-violence is one of the more interesting things about this series, and it continues here. White does tend towards both biological and gender essentialism for everyone other than the protagonist and main supporting characters, but he seemed to be walking back some of the more outrageous limitations on women that appeared in previous books. There is still some nonsense in here about how females of any species can't be Diagnosticians, but then Cha Thrat, who is female, seems to violate the justification for that rule over the course of this novel (sadly without comment). Perhaps he's setting up for proving Sector General wrong about this prejudice. I picked this up after reading Elizabeth Bear's Machine, which is essentially a (better written) Sector General novel that got me in the mood for reading more. I wouldn't give Code Blue Emergency any awards, but it delivered exactly what I was looking for. This series is not as deep or well-written as some more recent SF, but it is reliably itself and reliably entertaining. There are worse things in a series. Recommended if you're in the mood for alien ER in space. The omnibus edition that I read has an introduction to both novels by John Clute. It does add some interesting insights, but (as is somewhat typical for Clute) it also spoils parts of both books. You may want to read it after you read the novels. Followed by The Genocidal Healer. Rating: 7 out of 10

30 March 2026

Russ Allbery: Review: The Cloak and Its Wizard

Review: The Cloak and Its Wizard, by R.Z. Nicolet
Publisher: UpLit Press
Copyright: February 2026
ISBN: 1-917849-15-X
Format: Kindle
Pages: 423
The Cloak and Its Wizard is a standalone (at least so far) urban fantasy superhero (sort of) novel. R.Z. Nicolet is the marketing pseudonym for Rachel Reddick. This is her first novel.
I'm picky about wizards. The wizards themselves will complain about that, but of course I'm picky. When I choose a wizard, barring utter abandonment of moral scruples, it's a till-death-do-us-part situation. (Their death, not mine. I'm the next best thing to indestructible.)
The Cloak of Sunset and Starlight is a major artifact, meaning that it has its own preferences and is capable of independent action. It has been sitting in a glass case in the wizards' library for about a hundred years, waiting for someone interesting. (Well, mostly sitting. Occasionally it sneaks out to eavesdrop or move the books around.) Veronica Noble is interesting. She's older than most initiates, thoughtful, observant, and clearly had some mundane career before joining the Order. Her aura is appealing, and her mental shields and resistance to influence are intriguing. Normally, the Cloak would take its time investigating a new potential wizard, but the Sword was making thoughtful rattling sounds, and no way is the Cloak going to let the Sword claim her first. Time to choose a new wizard!
It was nice, being draped over warm shoulders, and feeling a heartbeat again. I could tell she closed her eyes without even looking. She sighed. "I just got picked by the intransigent one, didn't I?"
The last time I picked a book from the Big Idea feature in Scalzi's Whatever blog, it didn't go that well, but if you're going to write a book specifically for me, I'm going to read it. There are very few tropes of SFF that I love more than intelligent companion objects, and Nicolet's introduction to the story was compelling. So I gave this book discovery method another chance. I'm glad I did, because this was exactly what I was in the mood for and a delight from cover to cover. Veronica Noble is not a typical wizard. She's a surgeon and was quite happy to be a surgeon until an unexpected encounter with a magical creature killed her brother. The forgetting spell cast by the wizards who came to handle the Cassandra wyrm didn't work on her, so she was dragged reluctantly into the secret magical world of the Order. This long-lived society of wizards quietly defends the world against magical intrusions from other planes of existence. Now she's a wizard with a magical cloak, which she is not at all sure she wants. Veronica is not the protagonist, though. The Cloak of Sunset and Starlight is. As far as it is concerned, its job is to assist its wizard, enjoy watching interesting feats of magic, and look fabulous doing so. It's protective, dramatic, rather vain, endlessly curious, easily bored, and intensely loyal. When it becomes clear that the Order has some serious problems, the Cloak knows what side it's on. This sounds a bit like urban fantasy, so I was surprised when the first superheroes showed up, although given the explicit Doctor Strange inspiration I probably should have expected them. The Order and the superheroes do not mix, at least at the start of the novel. The wizards view the superheroes as a loud and irritating intrusion and hide magical activities from them the same as they do the rest of the world. Veronica's opening opinion on superheroes is based on being a trauma surgeon in a hospital dealing with the aftermath of their fights (which makes me wonder if the author has read Hench, although the idea is older than that book). As with the Order, the role of superheroes in this world gets more complicated as the plot develops. There is a surprising amount of plot and some very nice world-building here, including multiple twists that I was not expecting. Veronica is the sort of stubborn and deeply ethical person who will not leave a problem alone if she has the ability to fix it, which is a good recipe for getting deeper and deeper into a complex plot. She's believable as a surgeon: somewhat taciturn, calm in emergencies, detail-oriented, methodical, and not at all dramatic. This makes the Cloak a perfect foil and complement. Watching their partnership develop was very satisfying. This is a sidekick novel, and like the best sidekick novels it makes the not-protagonist more interesting and more relatable by showing them from an outside and skewed perspective. Piecing together what Veronica must be thinking is part of the fun, as is sharing the Cloak's protectiveness towards her as it becomes clear how much she's been through and how good of a person she is. The Cloak's personality was a little too much like a cat for me I would have preferred a more unique viewpoint, fewer cat-coded shenanigans, and a bit less of the running laundry machine joke. But that's a quibble. Its endless curiosity drives the plot forward and uncovers more of the world-building, and I just love reading stories from the perspective of this sort of loyal and protective magical creature. I had so much fun with this book. It's a popcorn sort of book, and I thought the ending sputtered a little, but overall it was great. Parts of it could have been designed in a lab to appeal to me specifically, so I'm not sure if other people will enjoy it as much, but its hit rate with my friends so far has been good. Highly recommended, and I will be watching for any further novels from Nicolet. The Cloak and Its Wizard reaches a satisfying conclusion and doesn't advertise itself as part of a series, but there is room for a sequel. If Nicolet ever writes one, I'd read it. Rating: 8 out of 10

29 March 2026

Russ Allbery: Review: The Sovereign

Review: The Sovereign, by C.L. Clark
Series: Magic of the Lost #3
Publisher: Orbit
Copyright: September 2025
ISBN: 0-316-54286-5
Format: Kindle
Pages: 575
The Sovereign is the third and concluding book of C.L. Clark's Magic of the Lost high fantasy trilogy. I recommend reading the books of this series close together, since there are a lot of characters and a lot of continuity between books that is helpful to remember, but it was not quite as difficult this time to remember where the story left off. At the end of The Faithless, the political situation in Balladaire (not-France) was more stable, but the threat of a plague lay on the horizon. That threat arrives in earnest in this book, along with new threats from both Balladaire's former colonial conscript soldiers and from neighboring Taargen (not-Germany, sort of, although the parallel isn't as close). Luca and Touraine have finally admitted that they're deeply in love, but they are still very different people with different goals and ethics. Luca is determined to do anything necessary to save her kingdom, but her definition of her kingdom is sharp and brittle. Touraine is torn between far too many loyalties, plus the lingering worry that her morals and Luca's may not be compatible. I think the hardest part of this sort of series is finding an ending the reader will find satisfying. This one, unfortunately, did not work for me, but that may be more due to personal preference than objective flaws. There have been two threads through this series: an improbable romance embedded in a network of complex personal relationships, and a political commentary on colonialism and post-colonial wars. I was enjoying the former, but it was the latter that felt fresh and interesting to me. The plot threads in The Faithless outside of Balladaire expanded that complexity, and I was hoping the final volume would continue in that direction. How could a colonial power atone for its history? How does the former colony establish its own governance? Is there a path to freedom without violence? Are attempts to chart a more moral course doomed to open lines of attack for one's other enemies? It's clear that Clark was thinking about similar themes, but The Sovereign narrows the field instead of widens it, restricts the political options, and then resolves most questions in a massive war. This is not that surprising of a conclusion, but it's one that I found unsatisfying and, honestly, a little boring. Yes, one way to resolve all the competing tensions is for everyone to try to kill each other and whoever survives wins, and historically that's one of the more likely outcomes, but that ending doesn't wrestle with the politics as much as it collapses them. Clark instead focuses this concluding volume on the romance, which becomes even more fraught, tragic, and dramatic than it was in previous books (and that's saying something). The hard questions of divided loyalties and moral conflicts are mostly framed by questions about Touraine's loyalty to Luca and Luca's trust of Touraine. This is all very Shakespearean, full of hard choices, sudden reversals, miscommunication, and a very deep conflict between Luca's realpolitik and Touraine's stubborn personal morality. If this is what you were reading the series for, if you were hoping for a maximum-drama sapphic relationship, you may thoroughly enjoy this. I thought it had its moments, but I wish they had been balanced by more moments of cool-headed practicality and creative political ingenuity. My biggest frustration with this ending is that the characters largely stop doing politics. The political complexity was the strength of both The Unbroken and The Faithless: People who intensely dislike each other negotiate because there is something larger to be gained, personal decisions made without considering the political ramifications have costs, and multiple characters are trying hard to find a way to turn a nasty, exploitative world into something better without simply killing everyone who disagrees. Many of the characters were objectively bad at politics, inexperienced and immature, but they stumbled or dragged or fought their way into political solutions anyway. I thought Clark moved too far away from that in The Sovereign. Everyone goes deep into their own emotions and desire for vengeance or conquest or revolution and stops compromising. To a depressingly large extent, the story is resolved by killing everyone who disagrees. I think the story is poorer for it. One of the other threads of the series is Balladairan magic, or rather its odd absence. Luca has one understanding of it, the rebels introduced in The Faithless have a different understanding of it, and its pursuit is set up as critical to resolving the threat of a plague. We do get an explanation of sorts, but it's not as complete or as satisfying as I was hoping, and the symbolism of Balladaire's missing magic is left frustratingly murky. For me, this has some of the same problems as the political conclusion: I wanted an intellectual catharsis alongside the emotional catharsis, but that was not the direction Clark was taking the story. I like reading about these characters. All of Luca, Touraine, and Pruett are complex, comprehensible, flawed, and often intriguing. But my favorite character in the story, the person I latched on to as an emotional path through the story, was Sabine. Her refreshingly straightforward loyalty and lack of drama was a breath of fresh air. She has some great moments in this book, but there too I got wrong-footed by the direction Clark went with her arc and found its conclusion deeply unsatisfying. I'm not sure how many of these complaints are because of missed opportunities in the novel, how many were due to a mismatch of taste, and how many were due to not being in the right mood to read this conclusion. I'm sure that it didn't help that I read this simultaneous with another novel in which the characters were always miserable, or that I read it in early 2026 with, uh, all that entails. I suspect that if you came away from the first two books invested in the messy romance and wanting MOAR DRAMA, you may get exactly what you were hoping for. That, sadly, was not what I was hoping for. I can't really recommend this. I thought it dragged in places and didn't deliver the ending I wanted. But it has some great moments, it does wrap up the threads of the trilogy as advertised, and at least the romance gets a dramatic climax worthy of the tension that has been built through the previous books. If that matches what you were enjoying in the previous books, you may well enjoy this more than I did. Rating: 5 out of 10

Next.

Previous.