Review:
Echo, by Jack McDevitt
| Series: |
Alex Benedict #5 |
| Publisher: |
Ace |
| Copyright: |
November 2010 |
| Printing: |
November 2011 |
| ISBN: |
1-937007-00-6 |
| Format: |
Mass market |
| Pages: |
367 |
This is the fifth book in the ongoing Alex Benedict series, but reading
the previous volumes is generally optional. While there are references to
earlier events (and indeed I resorted to Wikipedia at one point to refresh
my memory of the plot of the
the first book in
the series), they aren't critical to the plot. They mostly are
background for the reactions of other characters to Benedict and his firm.
Echo opens with the now-familiar prologue, giving us a fleeting and
limited glimpse into the mystery that Benedict and Chase Kolpath will be
pursuing for the rest of the book. This time, it features the explorer
Somerest Tuttle, who has spent most of his life looking for intelligent
alien life. (In the far future setting of these books, humanity has
spread through a large region of the galaxy but has only encountered one
other alien race.) In the twilight of his career and life, a friend who
works as a tour guide for astronomical tours comes to him with a story
about something she saw. What, we don't know, and won't for most of the
book. But, whatever it is, Tuttle never goes public with it, which is
directly contrary to what everyone would expect him to do with any news
about alien life.
Benedict and Kolpath get involved some years later, after Tuttle's death,
when a stone slab with unknown markings that was part of his estate shows
up on the future equivalent of Craigslist, free to the first person who
will haul it away. Benedict finds that interesting enough to go pick up,
but then is really hooked when someone else goes to considerable lengths
to try to make the slab disappear before anyone can get a good look at it.
This, slowly, leads into poking around Tuttle's life and connections, the
star tour industry, and the possible origins of the slab.
If you've read any of the previous books in this series,
Echo is
more of the same, and I mean that in a good way. I think McDevitt is at
his best when writing this sort of cross between scientific puzzle,
mystery, and non-military adventure, full of people who care deeply about
knowing and understanding things and don't like to be thwarted in their
efforts. There is McDevitt's trademark halting and red-herring-ridden
investigation that succeeds in being engrossing and compelling, plenty of
opportunities to guess what's really going on (a bit easier this book than
in some others), and a bit of action that I thought was better-handled
than the somewhat strained action scenes of
The Devil's Eye. The book moves right along, despite multiple
reversals in the progress of the investigation, and the final revelation
does indeed justify the strange behavior of the various people Benedict
encounters.
As with McDevitt in general and this series in particular, there is one
caveat: the astronomical details are often interesting, but the world
building in general is not terribly believable. Despite supposedly taking
place millennia into the future, the society is a straight transplant
(projection would imply more change than exists) of middle-class American
culture, with bonus air cars, space ships, and slightly better computers.
Similarly, alien ecologies suffer from severe
Star Trek problems:
all the planets feel like copies of Earth with a few minor tweaks. This
just goes with the territory, and if you're up to the fifth book of the
series, you've probably gotten used to it, but the unrealistic lack of
divergence is actually used as a plot point here. That strained my
suspension of disbelief a bit.
That said, this sort of extremely familiar social context does give the
books an oddly calm, comfortable feeling. It's tempting to describe
McDevitt as cozy science fiction. There's a bit of danger, a bit of
suspense, but one is fairly certain that everything will work out in the
end and the reader will leave the book knowing the solutions to most of
the mysteries raised without having to work very hard at understanding the
society or the puzzle. If that's what you're in the mood for (and I was
when I read
Echo), McDevitt delivers reliably.
If you like the Alex Benedict series in general, recommended, as this is
an excellent example of the type.
Rating: 8 out of 10