There's a lot of debate going on across Planet freedesktop.org (okay, so
just Havoc), and Planet GNOME (most everyone else) about marketing of
media players right now. Discussing iAudios seems pretty timely.
Convinced by Jimmac, and also the shiny look, I skipped off to buy one
while I was in the UK late last year. My iRiver was alright, but it was
absolutely massive and very heavy, so it just had to go. I grabbed one,
and have been very happy with it ever since. But with a few bumps in the
road.
In April or so, my remote's display suddenly stopped working. Apparently
this was a known issue with that one batch of remotes, and everything else
was OK. So I eBayed a new remote at a cost of around $au115. Ouch.
Some time after that, I was attempting to reset it on the train, after it
hung. Turns out that the reset button is a relatively small part of a
small plastic mount, perpendicular to the mainboard. And if you poke the
wrong part of it with a pen, you can snap the whole bloody thing off.
About a month ago, I just lost the ability to charge off AC; you could
only do it if you were holding it at a weird angle, and eventually it just
lost that ability. Which I found weird, since it's not a direct plug;
there's a small breakout adapter which contains the plug for it. So it's
not like the contacts on the plug in the device itself are just weird.
Same problem with the cradle. So I resorted to overnight charges off USB
(gah).
A while ago, the final straw in terms of it finally losing day-to-day
usability was that it stopped making proper contact with the 3.5mm
headphone plug, so if you held it at an angle, it just barely worked, but
you got the occasional burst of awful, loud, electrical noise.
It hasn't been treated especially badly; just a
lot of use, in
my pocket every day, contending with my phone for space. But in just
under a year, it's almost completely disintegrated.
The only reason why I bought it really, was because a lot of my older CDs
have been destroyed (two roadtrips with a friend, and his car turned out
to have some sand in the tray ...), and I'd really rather not transcode
from Vorbis to either MP3 or AAC. But I'm pretty sure my next purchase
will be a G3 40G iPod off eBay, because the clickwheel is an utter
abomination. Say what you will about their marketing, sales in Europe,
or whatever (FWIW: they're mindblowingly popular in Australia), but the
G3 design is far and away the best design I have ever seen in any music
device since my beloved
MZ-R900, which
met an unfortunate end when it hit ashphalt at high speed. It's quite
beautiful, and the UI Just Works.
Compare this with the iRiver, which is clunky and awful to use,
and the iAudio, which is the same, but with some bizzare additions.
Such as the two clickable jog wheels. One of them is the 'action' button
(think: the Navi key on Nokia phones), and the other brings up a context
menu. Except when you go into the options, whereby the action button
brings you back to the main screen, and the context menu thing is the
'action' or 'OK' button. Totally bizzare.