Search Results: "msp"

18 September 2006

Evan Prodromou: F te du G nie CCXIV

Today's the "day of Genius" in the French Revolutionary Calendar -- a festival to celebrate human reason, innovation, and inspiration. Something that deserves our respect and attention. My big genius accolades today are for the people who put on the Piknic Electronik Summer Sundays in Montreal. We stopped by the last one for 2006 yesterday, and it was a great time. Our friend John Usher (in town to defend his Ph.D. thesis) came along with us, but we also met friends Jeff and Anne-Marie, Lou and Candace and little Olive, Patti and Meg and Lucinda and Damian and Douglas and... lots of folks. Piknic remains one of my favorite parties in Quebec. An afternoon dance party under a giant Calder stabile on a beautiful island park in the St. Laurence River? Truly genius! I hope Piknic 2007 keeps growing and going with the mellow, friendly atmosphere that it's had in the past. tags:

Web 2.0 Conference So, I'm sad to see that the Web 2.0 Conference in San Francisco in November is sold out. Maj and I made plans to visit SF during this time just to get to the conference, but I guess it's all filled up. Now I'm trying to track down a spare ticket or two. Anybody got a miracle? tags:

R RS There's now a draft version of the Revised Report on the algorithmic language Scheme (R RS). It's not much news for folks who read the recent status report on R RS, but it's still pretty interesting. Most of the good ideas seem to have gotten into the spec, and the icky idea of doing immutable pairs seems to be gone now. Check out http://www.r6rs.org/ for a copy of the draft spec and a signup form for the discussion list. tags:

SxSW Panels and Wiki I'm pretty excited to see that the new 2007 South-by-Southwest Interactive panel voting interface is up today. I proposed a panel called Commercialization of Wikis: Open Community that Pays the Bills, to discuss different ways that private companies are creating wikis and investing in Wiki technology. I was surprised to hear that, for SxSW Interactive 2007, it's the only proposed Wiki panel! If you're thinking about SxSW 2007, or if you just feel like voting on things, please drop by and give the wiki panel your support. tags:

Ms. P. I'm really proud of my cousin, Lisa Prodromo, who's a teacher in Chicago. Lisa's from the poor branch of the family that can't afford a "u" at the end of their name, but she's overcome that hardship and is now a really great English teacher. She's got a blog at http://www.msprodromo.com/ for her students, but I'm waiting for her to bust out with one for grownups, too. Anyways, she was just nominated for the prestigious Golden Apple award, a Chicago-area teachers award. I'm sure she's going to win. tags: : What's the protocal for commenting here in your bliki? Edit now and ask questions later has always worked for me, so I'll try that. When am I got to get an introduction to the illustrious Chicago Ms. P? We're doing some scheming here in Chicago and would love to include her. --TedErnst

2 June 2006

Uwe Hermann: OS Install Experiences - Part 3: PC-BSD [Update]


Note: This article is part of my OS Install Experiences series.
I'll continue with the recently released operating system PC-BSD 1.1, which is based on FreeBSD 6.1. This is actually the first time I installed a BSD-like OS, so I thought it would be a bit of a hassle. But I was surprised to find that the install was really pretty easy (which is a major goal of PC-BSD, as I understand it). I didn't even read a manual or installation instructions or anything... Install
  1. First, I downloaded a PC-BSD 1.1 CD #1 image, burned it on a CD, and booted from that.
  2. The first installer screen is text-based (later it's graphical), and allows you to choose between a normal install ("boot FreeBSD"), install "with ACPI", "safe mode", "single user mode", and "with verbose logging". You can also "escape to loader prompt", or "reboot".
  3. While the installer runs, it merely shows a nice desktop background, pressing any key shows you the boot messages.
  4. After a while you can select a screen resolution for the graphical installer, run fdisk, escape into an "emergency shell", chroot into the root partition, or reboot. Default is to start the installation at a pre-selected screen resolution.
  5. You can choose the language and keyboard layout. Although you can click "back" to return to previous steps in the installer, you can not go back to the language/keyboard selection later!
  6. Partitioning. First, you can choose on which disk to install, then choose the partition to use. The list only shows the primary partitions and an "extended DOS" partition. Device names for disks are a bit different in BSD world. /dev/ad0 (counting starts at 0) is the first disk, /dev/ad0s1 (counting starts at 1) the first "partition" (called "slice" in BSD). It doesn't seem to be possible to install PC-BSD on an extended partition (please correct me if I'm wrong), so I installed it on /dev/hda2 (/dev/ad0s2 in BSD-speak), which is a primary partition. To make things more complex and confusing, a BSD slice can contain multiple "partitions" (not the same as Linux partitions!). I now have /dev/ad0s2a, which is the boot partition, and /dev/ad0s2b, the swap partition. Confused? Me too.
  7. Note that changes made to the partition table seem to be effective immediately, there's no way to go back without losing data! Debian's installer is better at this. The default PC-BSD file system is UFS, btw.
  8. The hardware will be automatically detected (worked quite well for me).
  9. You can now choose to either install the BSD bootloader in the MBR, or install no bootloader at all. Not sure what the best thing for me is here, but I decided to install the BSD bootloader (overwriting GRUB). I might have to re-install GRUB (and tell it about PC-BSD) if the BSD bootloader cannot boot the other (Linux) OSes.
  10. Now I must enter the root password, and I can also create another user. I noticed that passwords can only contain alpha-numeric characters (no %$ ,.#+!? and so on). WTF? They can't be serious... Also, you must enter a real name for the normal user, it won't let you continue until you type something... Pretty annoying. There's a checkbox called "Auto-Login User?" which is enabled by default, but I didn't find out what exactly that does...
  11. The network is successfully auto-configured via DHCP. I was not asked for a hostname, but typed hostname after the install and I got PCBSD.localhost.
  12. Reboot. The CD is not ejected automatically, you have to remove it manually before booting up.
  13. I'm asked to insert CD 2 (language packs), which I don't have (or want), as I only burned CD 1. Clicking "abort" does the trick, and I can continue with English as the default language.
  14. Finally, I'm dropped into a KDE session, and that's it.
Security That's it. Comments, suggestions, flames? Update 2006-06-02: Added IPv6 netstat/sockstat output.

23 March 2006

Kai Hendry: Consumer hardware

This M$ Vista delay analysis got me thinking about the relationship between hardware manufacturers and well, us, the “Free software” geeks. Vista will no doubt drive hardware sales due to its high hardware requirements. Hardware manufacturers just love that. But does Ubuntu or Debian drive hardware sales? Erm, probably not. “competing hardware manufacturers are violating each others patents so much that they cannot publish specifications of their hardware without showing which patents they are violating.” -Aki I’m sure M$ has no qualms about signing NDAs with hardware companies. But for us, the future isn’t easy. I don’t think consumer hardware companies are going to shoot for Ubuntu’s certification scheme. And Ubuntu is the consumer version of GNU Debian/Linux right now.

19 March 2006

Clint Adams: This report is flawed, but it sure is fun

91D63469DFdnusinow1243
63DEB0EC31eloy
55A965818Fvela1243
4658510B5Amyon2143
399B7C328Dluk31-2
391880283Canibal2134
370FE53DD9opal4213
322B0920C0lool1342
29788A3F4Cjoeyh
270F932C9Cdoko
258768B1D2sjoerd
23F1BCDB73aurel3213-2
19E02FEF11jordens1243
18AB963370schizo1243
186E74A7D1jdassen(Ks)1243
1868FD549Ftbm3142
186783ED5Efpeters1--2
1791B0D3B7edd-213
16E07F1CF9rousseau321-
16248AEB73rene1243
158E635A5Erafl
14C0143D2Dbubulle4123
13D87C6781krooger(P)4213
13A436AD25jfs(P)
133D08B612msp
131E880A84fjp4213
130F7A8D01nobse
12F1968D1Bdecklin1234
12E7075A54mhatta
12D75F8533joss1342
12BF24424Csrivasta1342
12B8C1FA69sto
127F961564kobold
122A30D729pere4213
1216D970C6eric12--
115E0577F2mpitt
11307D56EDnoel3241
112BE16D01moray1342
10BC7D020Aformorer-1--
10A7D91602apollock4213
10A51A4FDDgcs
10917A225Ejordi
104B729625pvaneynd3123
10497A176Dloic
962F1A57Fpa3aba
954FD2A58glandium1342
94A5D72FErafael
913FEFC40fenio-1--
90AFC7476rra1243
890267086duck31-2
886A118E6ch321-
8801EA932joey1243
87F4E0E11waldi-123
8514B3E7Cflorian21--
841954920fs12--
82A385C57mckinstry21-3
825BFB848rleigh1243
7BC70A6FFpape1---
7B70E403Bari1243
78E2D213Ajochen(Ks)
785FEC17Fkilian
784FB46D6lwall1342
7800969EFsmimram-1--
779CC6586haas
75BFA90ECkohda
752B7487Esesse2341
729499F61sho1342
71E161AFBbarbier12--
6FC05DA69wildfire(P)
6EEB6B4C2avdyk-12-
6EDF008C5blade1243
6E25F2102mejo1342
6D1C41882adeodato(Ks)3142
6D0B433DFross12-3
6B0EBC777piman1233
69D309C3Brobert4213
6882A6C4Bkov
66BBA3C84zugschlus4213
65662C734mvo
6554FB4C6petere-1-2
637155778stratus
62D9ACC8Elars1243
62809E61Ajosem
62252FA1Afrank2143
61CF2D62Amicah
610FA4CD1cjwatson2143
5EE6DC66Ajaldhar2143
5EA59038Esgran4123
5E1EE3FB1md4312
5E0B8B2DEjaybonci
5C9A5B54Esesse(Ps,Gs) 2341
5C4CF8EC3twerner
5C2FEE5CDacid213-
5C09FD35Atille
5C03C56DFrfrancoise---1
5B7CDA2DCxam213-
5A20EBC50cavok4214
5808D0FD0don1342
5797EBFABenrico1243
55230514Asjackman
549A5F855otavio-123
53DC29B41pdm
529982E5Avorlon1243
52763483Bmkoch213-
521DB31C5smr2143
51BF8DE0Fstigge312-
512CADFA5csmall3214
50A0AC927lamont
4F2CF01A8bdale
4F095E5E4mnencia
4E9F2C747frankie
4E9ABFCD2devin2143
4E81E55C1dancer2143
4E38E7ACFhmh(Gs)1243
4E298966Djrv(P)
4DF5CE2B4huggie12-3
4DD982A75speedblue
4C671257Ddamog-1-2
4C4A3823Ekmr4213
4C0B10A5Bdexter
4C02440B8js1342
4BE9F70EAtb1342
4B7D2F063varenet-213
4A3F9E30Eschultmc1243
4A3D7B9BClawrencc2143
4A1EE761Cmadcoder21--
49DE1EEB1he3142
49D928C9Bguillem1---
49B726B71racke
490788E11jsogo2143
4864826C3gotom4321
47244970Bkroeckx2143
45B48FFAEmarga2143
454E672DEisaac1243
44B3A135Cerich1243
44597A593agmartin4213
43FCC2A90amaya1243
43F3E6426agx-1-2
43EF23CD6sanvila1342
432C9C8BDwerner(K)
4204DDF1Baquette
400D8CD16tolimar12--
3FEC23FB2bap34-1
3F972BE03tmancill4213
3F801A743nduboc1---
3EBEDB32Bchrsmrtn4123
3EA291785taggart2314
3E4D47EC1tv(P)
3E19F188Etroyh1244
3DF6807BEsrk4213
3D2A913A1psg(P)
3D097A261chrisb
3C6CEA0C9adconrad1243
3C20DF273ondrej
3B5444815ballombe1342
3B1DF9A57cate2143
3AFA44BDDweasel(Ps,Gs) 1342
3AA6541EEbrlink1442
3A824B93Fasac3144
3A71C1E00turbo
3A2D7D292seb128
39ED101BFmbanck3132
3969457F0joostvb2143
389BF7E2Bkobras1--2
386946D69mooch12-3
374886B63nathans
36F222F1Fedelhard
36D67F790foka
360B6B958geiger
3607559E6mako
35C33C1B8dirson
35921B5D8ajmitch
34C1A5BE5sjq
3431B38BApxt312-
33E7B4B73lmamane2143
327572C47ucko1342
320021490schepler1342
31DEB8EAEgoedson
31BF2305Akrala(Gs)3142
319A42D19dannf21-4
3174FEE35wookey3124
3124B26F3mfurr21-3
30A327652tschmidt312-
3090DD8D5ingo3123
30813569Fjeroen1141
30644FAB7bas1332
30123F2F2gareuselesinge1243
300530C24bam1234
2FD6645ABrmurray-1-2
2F95C2F6Dchrism(P)
2F9138496graham(Gs)3142
2F5D65169jblache1332
2F28CD102absurd
2F2597E04samu
2F0B27113patrick
2EFA6B9D5hamish(P)3142
2EE0A35C7risko4213
2E91CD250daigo
2D688E0A7qjb-21-
2D4BE1450prudhomm
2D2A6B810joussen
2CFD42F26dilinger
2CEE44978dburrows1243
2CD4C0D9Dskx4213
2BFB880A3zeevon
2BD8B050Droland3214
2B74952A9alee
2B4D6DE13paul
2B345BDD3neilm1243
2B28C5995bod4213
2B0FA4F49schoepf
2B0DDAF42awoodland
2A8061F32osamu4213
2A21AD4F9tviehmann1342
299E81DA0kaplan
2964199E2fabbe3142
28DBFEC2Fpelle
28B8D7663ametzler1342
28B143975martignlo
288C7C1F793sam2134
283E5110Fovek
2817A996Atfheen
2807CAC25abi4123
2798DD95Cpiefel
278D621B4uwe-1--
26FF0ABF2rcw2143
26E8169D2hertzog3124
26C0084FCchrisvdb
26B79D401filippo-1--
267756F5Dfrn2341
25E2EB5B4nveber123-
25C6153ADbroonie1243
25B713DF0djpig1243
250ECFB98ccontavalli(Gs)
250064181paulvt
24F71955Adajobe21-3
24E2ECA5Ajmm4213
2496A1827srittau
23E8DCCC0maxx1342
23D97C149mstone(P)2143
22DB65596dz321-
229F19BD1meskes
21F41B907marillat1---
21EB2DE66boll
21557BC10kraai1342
2144843F5lolando1243
210656584voc
20D7CA701steinm
205410E97horms
1FC992520tpo-14-
1FB0DFE9Bgildor
1FAEEB4A9neil1342
1F7E8BC63cedric21--
1F2C423BCzack1332
1F0199162kreckel4214
1ECA94FA8ishikawa2143
1EAAC62DFcyb---1
1EA2D2C41malattia-312
1E77AC835bcwhite(P)
1E66C9BB0tach
1E145F334mquinson2143
1E0BA04C1treinen321-
1DFE80FB2tali
1DE054F69azekulic(P)
1DC814B09jfs
1CB467E27kalfa
1C9132DDByoush-21-
1C87FFC2Fstevenk-1--
1C2CE8099knok321-
1BED37FD2henning(Ks)1342
1BA0A7EB5treacy(P)
1B7D86E0Fcmb4213
1B62849B3smarenka2143
1B3C281F4alain2143
1B25A5CF1omote
1ABA0E8B2sasa
1AB474598baruch2143
1AB2A91F5troup1--2
1A827CEDEafayolle(Gs)
1A6C805B9zorglub2134
1A674A359maehara
1A57D8BF7drew2143
1A269D927sharky
1A1696D2Blfousse1232
19BF42B07zinoviev--12
19057B5D3vanicat2143
18E950E00mechanix
18BB527AFgwolf1132
18A1D9A1Fjgoerzen
18807529Bultrotter2134
1872EB4E5rcardenes
185EE3E0Eangdraug12-3
1835EB2FFbossekr
180C83E8Eigloo1243
17B8357E5andreas212-
17B80220Dsjr(Gs)1342
17796A60Bsfllaw1342
175CB1AD2toni1---
1746C51F4klindsay
172D03CB1kmuto4231
171473F66ttroxell13-4
16E76D81Dseanius1243
16C63746Dhector
16C5F196Bmalex4213
16A9F3C38rkrishnan
168021CE4ron---1
166F24521pyro-123
1631B4819anfra
162EEAD8Bfalk1342
161326D40jamessan13-4
1609CD2C0berin--1-
15D8CDA7Bguus1243
15D8C12EArganesan
15D64F870zobel
159EF5DBCbs
157F045DCcamm
1564EE4B6hazelsct
15623FC45moronito4213
1551BE447torsten
154AD21B5warmenhoven
153BBA490sjg
1532005DAseamus
150973B91pjb2143
14F83C751kmccarty12-3
14DB97694khkim
14CD6E3D2wjl4213
14A8854E6weinholt1243
14950EAA6ajkessel
14298C761robertc(Ks)
142955682kamop
13FD29468bengen-213
13FD25C84roktas3142
13B047084madhack
139CCF0C7tagoh3142
139A8CCE2eugen31-2
138015E7Ethb1234
136B861C1bab2143
133FC40A4mennucc13214
12C0FCD1Awdg4312
12B05B73Arjs
1258D8781grisu31-2
1206C5AFDchewie-1-1
1200D1596joy2143
11C74E0B7alfs
119D03486francois4123
118EA3457rvr
1176015EDevo
116BD77C6alfie
112AA1DB8jh
1128287E8daf
109FC015Cgodisch
106468DEBfog--12
105792F34rla-21-
1028AF63Cforcer3142
1004DA6B4bg66
0.zufus-1--
0.zoso-123
0.ykomatsu-123
0.xtifr1243
0.xavier-312
0.wouter2143
0.will-132
0.warp1342
0.voss1342
0.vlm2314
0.vleeuwen4312
0.vince2134
0.ukai4123
0.tytso-12-
0.tjrc14213
0.tats-1-2
0.tao1--2
0.stone2134
0.stevegr1243
0.smig-1-2
0.siggi1-44
0.shaul4213
0.sharpone1243
0.sfrost1342
0.seb-21-
0.salve4213
0.ruoso1243
0.rover--12
0.rmayr-213
0.riku4123
0.rdonald12-3
0.radu-1--
0.pzn112-
0.pronovic1243
0.profeta321-
0.portnoy12-3
0.porridge1342
0.pmhahn4123
0.pmachard1--2
0.pkern3124
0.pik1--2
0.phil4213
0.pfrauenf4213
0.pfaffben2143
0.p21243
0.ossk1243
0.oohara1234
0.ohura-213
0.nwp1342
0.noshiro4312
0.noodles2134
0.nomeata2143
0.noahm3124
0.nils3132
0.nico-213
0.ms3124
0.mpalmer2143
0.moth3241
0.mlang2134
0.mjr1342
0.mjg591342
0.merker2--1
0.mbuck2143
0.mbrubeck1243
0.madduck4123
0.mace-1-2
0.luther1243
0.luigi4213
0.lss-112
0.lightsey1--2
0.ley-1-2
0.ldrolez--1-
0.lange4124
0.kirk1342
0.killer1243
0.kelbert-214
0.juanma2134
0.jtarrio1342
0.jonas4312
0.joerg1342
0.jmintha-21-
0.jimmy1243
0.jerome21--
0.jaqque1342
0.jaq4123
0.jamuraa4123
0.iwj1243
0.ivan2341
0.hsteoh3142
0.hilliard4123
0.helen1243
0.hecker3142
0.hartmans1342
0.guterm312-
0.gniibe4213
0.glaweh4213
0.gemorin4213
0.gaudenz3142
0.fw2134
0.fmw12-3
0.evan1--2
0.ender4213
0.elonen4123
0.eevans13-4
0.ean-1--
0.dwhedon4213
0.duncf2133
0.ds1342
0.dparsons1342
0.dlehn1243
0.dfrey-123
0.deek1--2
0.davidw4132
0.davidc1342
0.dave4113
0.daenzer1243
0.cupis1---
0.cts-213
0.cph4312
0.cmc2143
0.clebars2143
0.chaton-21-
0.cgb-12-
0.calvin-1-2
0.branden1342
0.brad4213
0.bnelson1342
0.blarson1342
0.benj3132
0.bayle-213
0.baran1342
0.az2134
0.awm3124
0.atterer4132
0.andressh1---
0.amu1--2
0.akumria-312
0.ajt1144
0.ajk1342
0.agi2143
0.adric2143
0.adejong1243
0.adamm12--
0.aba1143

15 January 2006

Edd Dumbill: XTech topic musings

Compiled over the last few weeks, here's a random list of some subjects I'd love to see covered in XTech 2006. There's now only three weeks left of the call for participation -- so it's definitely time get that proposal in! Mail me if you have any questions.
  • OpenDocument vs. Microsoft Office Open XML (am I the only one annoyed by how this format is abbreviated as "Open XML"?)
  • Ruby on Rails 1.0
  • Firefox 1.5, including its many new features for developers. I loved the idea from Tristan Nitot that extensions are a way to keep Firefox successful. There's a lot of potential here. Anybody want to attend a tutorial on making Firefox extensions?
  • W3C Rich Web Clients Activity
  • XSLT 2.0 adoption and implementation--anyone but Saxon?
  • The Web Desktop. I was incredibly interested in this post of Miguel de Icaza's. For a long time I've felt RDF could hold the desktop together, data-wise, but he also proposes that HTTP and web services could do a similar thing. I suspect these are two strands of development that go hand in hand.
  • Design, usability and patterns for AJAX web applications.
  • Open Content Alliance
  • RSS and Atom: despite the release of Atom, RSS continues to grow down its own path. I reckon it's about time to sort out where each are going, and what they're best for.
  • XSL-FO: I use this technology regularly for preparing PDFs with RenderX, and the specification itself is mature. It seems time to take stock of XSL-FO and where it might go in future.
Submit your proposal here: XTech 2006 Call for Participation. XTech will be held 16-19 May 2006, Amsterdam, Netherlands.

Edd Dumbill: XTech topic musings

Compiled over the last few weeks, here's a random list of some subjects I'd love to see covered in XTech 2006. There's now only three weeks left of the call for participation -- so it's definitely time get that proposal in! Mail me if you have any questions.
  • OpenDocument vs. Microsoft Office Open XML (am I the only one annoyed by how this format is abbreviated as "Open XML"?)
  • Ruby on Rails 1.0
  • Firefox 1.5, including its many new features for developers. I loved the idea from Tristan Nitot that extensions are a way to keep Firefox successful. There's a lot of potential here. Anybody want to attend a tutorial on making Firefox extensions?
  • W3C Rich Web Clients Activity
  • XSLT 2.0 adoption and implementation--anyone but Saxon?
  • The Web Desktop. I was incredibly interested in this post of Miguel de Icaza's. For a long time I've felt RDF could hold the desktop together, data-wise, but he also proposes that HTTP and web services could do a similar thing. I suspect these are two strands of development that go hand in hand.
  • Design, usability and patterns for AJAX web applications.
  • Open Content Alliance
  • RSS and Atom: despite the release of Atom, RSS continues to grow down its own path. I reckon it's about time to sort out where each are going, and what they're best for.
  • XSL-FO: I use this technology regularly for preparing PDFs with RenderX, and the specification itself is mature. It seems time to take stock of XSL-FO and where it might go in future.
Submit your proposal here: XTech 2006 Call for Participation. XTech will be held 16-19 May 2006, Amsterdam, Netherlands.

Edd Dumbill: XTech topic musings

Compiled over the last few weeks, here's a random list of some subjects I'd love to see covered in XTech 2006. There's now only three weeks left of the call for participation -- so it's definitely time get that proposal in! Mail me if you have any questions.
  • OpenDocument vs. Microsoft Office Open XML (am I the only one annoyed by how this format is abbreviated as "Open XML"?)
  • Ruby on Rails 1.0
  • Firefox 1.5, including its many new features for developers. I loved the idea from Tristan Nitot that extensions are a way to keep Firefox successful. There's a lot of potential here. Anybody want to attend a tutorial on making Firefox extensions?
  • W3C Rich Web Clients Activity
  • XSLT 2.0 adoption and implementation--anyone but Saxon?
  • The Web Desktop. I was incredibly interested in this post of Miguel de Icaza's. For a long time I've felt RDF could hold the desktop together, data-wise, but he also proposes that HTTP and web services could do a similar thing. I suspect these are two strands of development that go hand in hand.
  • Design, usability and patterns for AJAX web applications.
  • Open Content Alliance
  • RSS and Atom: despite the release of Atom, RSS continues to grow down its own path. I reckon it's about time to sort out where each are going, and what they're best for.
  • XSL-FO: I use this technology regularly for preparing PDFs with RenderX, and the specification itself is mature. It seems time to take stock of XSL-FO and where it might go in future.
Submit your proposal here: XTech 2006 Call for Participation. XTech will be held 16-19 May 2006, Amsterdam, Netherlands.

27 December 2005

Matt Brown: Miredo/Toredo Patent Status

Miredo is an implementation of the Teredo - IPv6 over IPv4 tunnelling protocol which I have been playing with lately. I have filed an ITP bug to get Miredo into Debian, however this has been delayed while I try and get a handle on some of the patent issues surrounding the Teredo protocol. While Miredo itself is licensed under the GPLv2 the state of the Toredo protocol is less clear. Teredo was created by Christian Huitema, an architect with Microsoft. It is currently a Proposed Internet Standard waiting for the IETF editor to review it and assign an RFC number for it, IANA will then assign a permanent prefix for use by Teredo clients, servers and relays. According to the IETF IPR disclosure page, Microsoft has filed a statement of claim against the technologies described in the Proposed Standard. Microsoft states that they will provide a Royalty-Free, Reasonable and Non-Discriminatory License to All Implementers in their statement. Specifically the license that they offer the Teredo protocol under is called the Microsoft Royalty Free Protocol License Agreement. This is a catch-all license that Microsoft uses for all client-server protocols used by Windows. The license itself doesn’t make any claims about Microsoft’s IP rights, it simply gives you a license to use any rights Microsoft may have in the specific protocol you are using. For example at the end of the license agreement you select which protocols you wish to have covered under the agreement. Alongside Teredo you can also choose protocols such as IPv4, DNS, 6to4 and lots of other common protocols. The actual patent application for Teredo is incredibly difficult to find, the IETF IPR disclosoure doesn’t link to it, none of the proposed standards link to it and googling for “Teredo Patent Application” isn’t particularly successful either. In the end it turns out that the title is quirkily named “Allowing IPv4 clients to communicate over an IPv6 network when behind a network address translator with reduced server workload” and was published as Patent Application 20040190549 on the 30th September 2004. Incidentally if anyone knows of a nicer way to link to a US Patent Application than the ugly URL above, I would love to know. Half the reason that the Patent Application was hard to find is that it doesn’t actually mention Microsoft anywhere at all, unlike the ~5000 odd other Patent Applications currently filed by Microsoft. From what I can tell it appears that Christian Huitema has filed the application through is own personal attorneys independently of Microsoft. So where does this leave us in terms of getting Miredo into Debian? The short answer is I’m not entirely sure. I can’t seem to find a definitive statement regarding Debian’s position on patents anywhere, the best I’ve been able to come up with is a debian-legal post from Andrew Suffield from Jan 2005 which offhandedly describes the informal Debian patent policy as:
“ignore patents until somebody starts to wave them around, then drop the offending thing like a hot rock”
So maybe I’ve already shot Miredo in the foot, by investigating its Patent Status… :( My take on the situation seems to be that Debian is perfectly happy (and perhaps has no other option but) to ignore patents applicable to software in Debian until it becomes apparent that a particular patent is being enforced or has the potential to be enforced. So the question now becomes whether the Microsoft Royalty Free Patent License is acceptable enough to Debian to allow Miredo to be included in main or non-free, or whether it simply can’t be redistributed at all. The main problem I see with the license is that it does not permit you to sublicense other parties to make use of the Toredo technology used by Miredo. If this were a copyright license then that would most certainly fail to pass the Debian Free Software Guidelines, does Debian treat patents in the same manner? I think it’s time for me to post to debian-legal to seek some “official” guidance on the situation, but hopefully this post has ordered my thoughts enough that I can now write a coherent mail seeking help. If you have any comments or pointers to Debian statements on this sort of situation that I have missed they would be most welcome.

15 December 2005

Edd Dumbill: XTech topic musings

Compiled over the last few weeks, here's a random list of some subjects I'd love to see covered in XTech 2006. There's now only three weeks left of the call for participation -- so it's definitely time get that proposal in! Mail me if you have any questions. Submit your proposal here: XTech 2006 Call for Participation. XTech will be held 16-19 May 2006, Amsterdam, Netherlands.

Next.

Previous.