Search Results: "Daniel Kahn Gillmor"

9 April 2011

Daniel Kahn Gillmor: EDAC i5000 non-fatal errors

I've got a Debian GNU/Linux lenny installation (2.6.26-2-vserver-amd64 kernel) running on a Dell Poweredge 2950 with BIOS 2.0.1 (2007-10-27). It has two Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU 5160 @ 3.00GHz processors (according to /proc/cpuinfo, 8 1GiB 667MHz DDR2 ECC modules (part number HYMP512F72CP8N3-Y5), according to dmidecode, and an Intel Corporation 5000X Chipset Memory Controller Hub (rev 12) according to lspci. The machine has been running stably for many months. On the morning of March 31st, i started getting the following messages from the kernel, on the order of one pair of lines every 3 seconds:
Mar 31 07:04:38 zamboni kernel: [16883514.141275] EDAC i5000 MC0: NON-FATAL ERRORS Found!!! 1st NON-FATAL Err Reg= 0x800
Mar 31 07:04:38 zamboni kernel: [16883514.141278] EDAC i5000: 	NON-Retry  Errors, bits= 0x800
A bit of digging turned up a redhat bug report that seems to suggest that these warnings are just noise, and should be ignorable. Another link thinks it's a conflict with IPMI, though i don't think this model actually has an IPMI subsystem correction: this machine does have IPMI, though i am not making use of it. However, i also notice from munin logs that at the same time the error messages started, the machine exhibited a marked change in CPU activity (including in-kernel activity) and local timer interrupts: [Individual interrupts - by month][CPU Usage - by month] I also note that more rescheduling interrupts started happening, and fewer megasas interrupts at about the same time. I'm not sure what this means. A review of other logs and graphs on the system turns up no other evidence of interaction that might cause this kind of elevated activity. One thought was that the elevated activity was just due to writing out a bunch more logs. So i tried removing the i5000_edac module just to keep dmesg and /var/log/kern.log cleaner. Leaving that turned off doesn't lower the CPU utilization or change the interrupts, though. Any suggestions on what might be going on, or further diagnostics i should run? The machine is in production, and I'd really rather not take down the machine for an extended period of time to do a lengthy memory test. But i also don't want to see this kind of extra CPU usage (more than double the machine's baseline).Tags: i5000_edac, troubleshooting

5 April 2011

Daniel Kahn Gillmor: Debian on Thecus N8800Pro

I recently set up debian on a Thecus N8800Pro. It seems to be a decent rackmount 2U chassis with 8 3.5" hot-swap SATA drives, dual gigabit NICs, a standard DB9 RS-232 serial port, one eSATA port, a bunch of USB 2.0 connectors, and dual power supplies. I'm happy to be able to report that Thecus appears to be attempting to fulfill their obligations under the GPL with this model (i'm fetching their latest source tarball now to have a look). Internally, it's an Intel Core 2 Duo processor, two DIMMS of DDR RAM, and a PCIe slot for extensions if you like. It has two internally-attached 128MiB SSDs that it wants to boot off of. The downsides as i see them:
BIOS
The BIOS only runs over VGA, which is not easy to access. I wish it ran over the serial port. It's also not clear how one would find an upgrade to the BIOS. dmidecode reports the BIOS as:
        Vendor: Phoenix Technologies, LTD
        Version: 6.00 PG
        Release Date: 02/24/2009
RAM
The mainboard has only two DIMM sockets. It came pre-populated with two 2GiB DDR DIMMs. memtest86+ reports those DIMMs clearly, but sees only 3070MiB in aggregate. The linux kernel also sees ~3GiB of RAM, despite dmidecode and lshw reporting that the two DIMM modules each are only 1GiB in size. I'm assuming this is a bios problem. Anyone know how to get access to the full 4GiB? Should i be reporting bugs on any of these packages?
SSDs
The internal SSDs are absurdly small and very slow for both reading and writing. This isn't a big deal because i'm basically only using them for the bootloader, kernel, and initramfs. But i'm surprised that they could even find 128MiB devices in these days of $10 1GiB flash units.
processor
/proc/cpuinfo reports two cores of a Intel(R) Core(TM)2 Duo CPU T5500 @ 1.66GHz, each with ~3333 bogomips, and apparently without hardware virtualization support. It's not clear to me whether the lack of virtualization support is something that could be fixed with a BIOS upgrade.
I used Andy Millar's nice description of how to get access to the BIOS -- I found i didn't need a hacksaw to modify the VGA cable i had. just pliers to remove the outer metal shield on the side of the connector i plugged into the open socket. lshw sees four SiI 3132 Serial ATA Raid II Controller PCI devices, each of which appears to support two SATA ports. I'm currently using only four of the 8 SATA bays, so i've tried to distribute the disks so that each of them is attached to an independent PCI device (instead of having two disks on one PCI device, and another PCI device idle). I don't know if this makes a difference, though, in the RAID10 configuration i'm using. There's also a neat 2-line character-based LCD display on the front panel which apparently can be driven by talking to a serial port, though i haven't tried. Apparently there are also LEDs that might be controllable directly from the kernel via ICH7 and GPIO, but i haven't tried that yet either. Any suggestions on how to think about or proceed with a BIOS upgrade to get access to the full 4GiB of RAM, BIOS-over-serial, and/or enable hardware virtualization?Tags: n8800pro, thecus

29 March 2011

Daniel Kahn Gillmor: auto-built debirf images

jrollins and i recently did a bunch of cleanup work on debirf, with the result that debirf 0.30 can now build all the shipped example profiles without error (well, as long as debootstrap --variant=fakechroot is working properly -- apprently that's not the case for fakechroot 2.9 in squeeze right now, which is why i've uploaded a backport of 2.14). To try to avoid getting into a broken state again, we set up an autobuilder to create the images from the three example profiles (minimal, rescue, and xkiosk) for amd64 systems. The logs for these builds are published (with changes) nightly at:
git://debirf.cmrg.net/debirf-autobuilder-logs
But even better, we are also publishing the auto-generated debirf images themselves. So, for example, if you've got an amd64-capable machine with a decent amount of RAM (512MiB is easily enough), you can download a rescue kernel and image into /boot/debirf/, add a stanza to your bootloader, and be able to reboot to it cleanly, without having to sort out the debirf image creation process yourself. We're also providing ISOs so people who still use optical media don't have to format their own. Please be sure to verify the checksums of the files you download. The checksums themselves are signed by the OpenPGP key for Debirf Autobuilder <debirf@cmrg.net>, which i've certified and published to the keyserver network. What's next? It would be nice to have auto-built images for i386 and other architectures. And if someone has a good idea for a new example profile that we should also be auto-building, please submit a bug to the BTS so we can try to sort it out.Tags: debirf

16 March 2011

Daniel Kahn Gillmor: CryptLib and the OpenSSL License

I spent part of today looking at packaging Peter Gutmann's CryptLib for debian. My conclusion: it may not be worth my time. One of the main reasons i wanted to package it for debian is because i would like to see more OpenPGP-compliant free software available to debian users and developers, particularly if the code is GPL-compatible. Cryptlib makes it quite clear that it intends to be GPL-compatible:
cryptlib is distributed under a dual license that allows free, open-source use under a GPL-compatible license and closed-source use under a standard commercial license.
However, a significant portion of the cryptlib codebase (particularly within the bn/ and crypt/ directories) appears to derive directly from OpenSSL, and it retains Eric Young's copyright and licensing. This licensing retains the so-called "advertising clause" that is generally acknowledged to be deliberately incompatible with the GPL. (A common counterargument for this incompatibility is that OpenSSL should be considered a "System Library" for GPL'ed tools that link against it; whether or not you believe this for tools linked against OpenSSL, this counterargument clearly does not hold for a project that embeds and ships OpenSSL code directly, as CryptLib does) This does not mean that CryptLib is not free software (it is!), nor does it mean that you cannot link it against GPL'ed code (you can!). However, you probably can't distribute the results of linking CryptLib against any GPL'ed code, because the GPL is incompatible with the OpenSSL license. The un-distributability of derived GPL-covered works makes the CryptLib package much less appealing to me, since i want to be able to write distributable code that links against useful libraries, and many of the libaries i care about happen to be under the GPL. I also note that Peter Gutmann and CryptLib Security Software (apparently some sort of company set up to distribute CryptLib) may be in violation of Eric Young's License, which states:
 * 3. All advertising materials mentioning features or use of this software
 *    must display the following acknowledgement:
 *    "This product includes cryptographic software written by
 *     Eric Young (eay@cryptsoft.com)"
 *    The word 'cryptographic' can be left out if the rouines from the library
 *    being used are not cryptographic related :-).
A Google search for Eric Young's name on cryptlib.com yields no hits. I do find his name on page 340 of the Cryptlib manual, but that hardly seems like it covers "All advertising materials mentioning features or use of this software". I suppose it's also possible that CryptLib has negotiated an alternate license with Eric Young that I simply don't know about. In summary: i think CryptLib could go into debian, but its incorporation of OpenSSL-licensed code makes it less useful than i was hoping it would be. I have a few other concerns about the package after looking it over in more detail. I suspect these are fixable one way or another, but i haven't sorted them out yet. I'm not sure i'll spend the time to do so based on the licensing issues i sorted out above. But in case anyone feels inspired, the other concerns i see are:
embedded code copies
In addition to embedded (and slightly-modified) copies of bn/ and crypt/ from OpenSSL, CryptLib contains an embedded copy of zlib. Debian has good reasons for wanting to avoid embedded code copies. I've got it CryptLib building against the system copy of zlib, but the bits copied from OpenSSL seem to be more heavily patched, which might complicate relying on the system version.
executable stack
lintian reports shlib-with-executable-stack for the library after it is built. I don't fully understand what this means or how to fix it, but i suspect it derives from the following set of object files that also have an executable stack:
0 dkg@pip:~/src/cryptlib/cryptlib$ for foo in $(find . -iname '*.o'); do
>  if ! readelf -S "$foo"   grep -q .note.GNU-stack ; then
>   echo "$foo"
>  fi
> done
./shared-obj/desenc.o
./shared-obj/rc5enc.o
./shared-obj/md5asm.o
./shared-obj/castenc.o
./shared-obj/bfenc.o
./shared-obj/rmdasm.o
./shared-obj/sha1asm.o
./shared-obj/bn_asm.o
./shared-obj/rc4enc.o
0 dkg@pip:~/src/cryptlib/cryptlib$ 
They probably all need to be fixed, unless there's a good reason for them to be that way (in which case they need to be documented).
non-PIC code
lintian reports shlib-with-non-pic-code on the library after it is built. I don't fully understand what this means, or how to resolve it cleanly, but i imagine this is just a question of sorting out the details.
Anyone interested in using my packaging attempts as a jumping off point can start with:
git clone git://lair.fifthhorseman.net/~dkg/cryptlib
Oh, and please correct me about anything in this post; I'd be especially happy to hear that my analysis of the licensing issues above is wrong :) Tags: cryptlib, gpl, licensing, openssl

7 March 2011

Daniel Kahn Gillmor: PHP, MySQL, and SSL?

Is there a way to access a MySQL database over the network from PHP and be confident that As far as i can tell, when using the stock MySQL bindings, setting MYSQL_CLIENT_SSL is purely advisory (i.e. it won't fail if the server doesn't advertise SSL support). This means it won't defend against an active network attacker performing the equivalent of sslstrip. Even if MYSQL_CLIENT_SSL was stronger than an advisory flag, i can't seem to come up with a way to tell PHP's basic MySQL bindings the equivalent of the --ssl-ca flag to the mysql client binary. Without being able to configure this, a "man-in-the-middle" should be able to intercept the connection by offering their own certificate on their endpoint, and otherwise relaying the traffic. A client that does not verify the server's identity would be none the wiser. One option to avoid a MITM attack would be for the server to require client-side certs via the REQUIRE option for a GRANT statement, but the basic MySQL bindings for php don't seem to support that either. PHP's mysqli bindings (MySQL Improved, i think) feature a command called ssl_set() which appears to allow client-side certificate support. But its documentation isn't clear on how it handles an invalid/expired/revoked server certificate (let alone a server that announces that it doesn't support SSL), and it also mentions:
This function does nothing unless OpenSSL support is enabled.
Given that debian MySQL packages don't use OpenSSL because of licensing incompatibilities with the GPL, i'm left wondering if packages built against yaSSL support this feature. And i'm more than a little bit leery that i have no way of telling whether my configuration request succeeded, or whether this function just happily did nothing because the interpreter got re-built with the wrong flags. Shouldn't the function fail explicitly if it cannot meet the user's request? Meanwhile, the PDO bindings for MySQL apparently don't support SSL connections at all. What's going on here? Does no one use MySQL over the network via PHP? Given the number of LAMP-driven data centers, this seems pretty unlikely. Do PHP+MySQL users just not care about privacy or integrity of their data? Or (please let this be the case) have i just somehow missed the obvious documentation? Tags: mysql, php, question, security, ssl, tls

1 March 2011

Daniel Kahn Gillmor: Turning my back on the IEEE

I used to maintain a membership with IEEE. I no longer do. The latest nonsense to come from them is a change for the worse in their copyright assignment policy, which i thought was already problematic. Other engineering societies (IETF, USENIX, etc) continue to do socially relevant, useful work without attempting to control copyright of work contributed to them. This just makes IEEE look like a power- and money-hungry organization, rather than a force for positive advancement of technology. For shame, IEEE. I will not consider reinstating my membership unless the organization changes their copyright assignment and publication policy to better reflect the spirit of scientific inquiry and technological advancement they should stand for.Tags: freedom, ieee, policy

16 January 2011

Daniel Kahn Gillmor: resetting passphrases for mapped LUKS volumes

Let's say you set up a machine using an encrypted disk with LUKS (debian-installer's partman makes this wonderfully easy!). You choose an initial passphrase, get the machine working, and it's working great. Then, you need to restart it, and realize that (for whatever reason) you've forgotten or lost the passphrase for the volume. oops! (i'm sure this has never happened to you -- let's just pretend it's your less-fortunate friend). If your system is still running, and you have superuser access to it, you can actually set a new passphrase for the LUKS volume using information that the dm-crypt kernel module has about the in-use mapping. In my examples, i'll imagine that the source volume is /dev/XXX2 and the exported cleartext volume is known by the device-mapper as XXX2_crypt In the bigger picture, this should serve as a reminder that even though your disk is encrypted, if someone gets live access to the superuser account on a system with the encryption keys loaded, your data is no longer secret. Before you do any tweaking, you might want to back up your LUKS header, just in case:
0 root@example:~# umask 077
0 root@example:~# cryptsetup luksHeaderBackup /dev/XXX2 --header-backup-file XXX2.luksheader.backup
0 root@example:~# 
Maybe also copy that off the machine, since a copy of the LUKS header stored within its own volume isn't terribly useful for a backup-recovery situation. You might also be interested in looking at the contents of the LUKS header:
0 root@example:~# cryptsetup luksDump /dev/XXX2
LUKS header information for /dev/XXX2
Version:       	1
Cipher name:   	aes
Cipher mode:   	cbc-essiv:sha256
Hash spec:     	sha1
Payload offset:	2056
MK bits:       	256
MK digest:      93 51 6c 66 ec ce 32 54 6f 6b 52 d1 27 9b 5a 62 6f 6b 52 d1
MK salt:       	b2 ca 20 49 9f 78 49 c2 fe 15 b4 0f 74 11 23 49
               	64 9e 61 bb f2 82 60 47 a5 76 fa a4 24 0e 5a 7e
MK iterations: 	10
UUID:          	052f1da0-21a1-11e0-ac64-0800200c9a66
Key Slot 0: ENABLED
	Iterations:         	218733
	Salt:               	f2 ae 8c 53 48 a5 f0 bf e1 2c 06 5f 5a bd ff d9
	                      	9a 2e d1 49 3a 63 f8 49 82 ed ae 86 7b 7b 7e 76 
	Key material offset:	8
	AF stripes:            	4000
Key Slot 1: DISABLED
Key Slot 2: DISABLED
Key Slot 3: DISABLED
Key Slot 4: DISABLED
Key Slot 5: DISABLED
Key Slot 6: DISABLED
Key Slot 7: DISABLED
0 root@example:~# 
Now, the fix: We pull the live "master key" from the running device map, and fill a new luksKeySlot from it (this example uses bash's <() syntax for process substitution -- if you use a different shell, i'm sure you can find a different way to do it):
0 root@example:~# cryptsetup --master-key-file <( 
> dmsetup --showkeys table   awk '/^XXX2_crypt: /  print $6  '   tr -d '\n'   perl -e 'print pack("H*", <STDIN>);' 
> ) luksAddKey /dev/XXX2
Enter new passphrase for key slot: abc123
Verify passphrase: abc123
2 root@example:~# 
(note that the luksAddKey invocation above returned an error code of 2 even though it succeeded. I think this is a bug in cryptsetup's return code, not a bug in the password resetting -- it should have returned 0 instead of 2). You can check to see that a new key slot was enabled by re-running cryptsetup luksDump And if you really want to double-check before you reboot, you can try enabling a third keyslot using the passphrase you just added, since this would not succeed if your new passphrase failed to unlock any of the existing keyslots:
0 root@example:~# cryptsetup luksAddKey /dev/XXX2
Enter any passphrase: abc123
Enter new passphrase for key slot: anotherpassphrase
Verify passphrase: anotherpassphrase
0 root@example:~# 
You can also get rid of the original keyslot (which you don't know the passphrase to) like this:
0 root@example:~# cryptsetup luksKillSlot /dev/XXX2 0
Enter any remaining LUKS passphrase: abc123
0 root@example:~# 
(the above commands were all demonstrated using debian testing, with cryptsetup 2:1.1.3-4 and dmsetup 2:1.02.48-4) Tags: cryptsetup, dmsetup, luks, tip

6 January 2011

Daniel Kahn Gillmor: Liberating Knowledge: A Librarian's Manifesto

A friend just pointed me to Liberating Knowledge: A Librarian's Manifesto for Change by Barbara Fister, an academic librarian who also happens to write mystery novels. She has an excellent perspective on the meaning of libraries, and the tradeoffs involved with the current societal trend toward privatizing knowledge through so-called "intellectual property" regulations. In a great critique of the passivity of academia and libraries in the face of attempts at intellectual enclosure by private corporations, she writes:
This uninformed indifference is laying the groundwork for a new tragedy of the commons: a world in which knowledge is turned into intellectual property, monetizied, and made artificially scarce.
She closes with a six-point manifesto that begins:
Liberation bibliography arises out of outrage at the injustice of the current system. It s not about saving money, it s about the empowering nature of knowledge and the belief that it shouldn t be a luxury good for the few.
The article abounds in examples of heinous arrangements in the current system that seem to be accepted as standard procedure, and clear thinking about what the actual tradeoffs are (and how we, as a society, are making them poorly). If i had one objection, it would be that she neglects to mention increased surveillance as one of the problems that come with privatization of knowledge. Our abilities to read privately and anonymously, and to correspond confidentially are at risk because of these systems of control. Anyway, I'd love to see more open allegiances between librarians and free software folks; the ideals and struggles are very much in parallel. Go talk to your librarian friends about this stuff today!Tags: academia, freedom, intellectual property, libraries

13 December 2010

Daniel Kahn Gillmor: converting eviews models to gretl?

Someone recently pointed me to some economic/statistical models that were designed for eviews (a proprietary tool). They were looking for help converting the model into a format that could work with gretl (the Gnu Regression, Econometrics and Time-series Library). I'm afraid i'm an economics dunce, and i have no experience with this stuff. Any pointers?Tags: conversion, economics, gretl

2 December 2010

Daniel Kahn Gillmor: forwarding unix domain sockets with ssh and socat

i suspect a lot of people are used to forwarding TCP sockets with SSH -- for example, to connect locally to a mysql daemon that runs only on the loopback interface of a remote machine (this is debian's default mysql-server configuration):
ssh -N -T -oExitOnForwardFailure=yes -L 3306:localhost:3306 remoteuser@mysqlserver.example
But sometimes, the remote service runs on a UNIX-domain socket, not on a TCP socket -- for example, debian's default configuration for postgresql is to have it listen only on a UNIX domain socket in /var/run/postgresql, and use SO_PEERCRED with a simple system account == psql account mapping scheme to authenticate users without needing any extra credentials. This is not quite as simple to forward over ssh, but it's doable as long as socat is installed on both your local host and on the remote postgres server. Here's one way to do it if $SOCKET_DIR points to the full path of a directory under the user's control (this is all one command, split across lines for easier reading):
socat "UNIX-LISTEN:$SOCKET_DIR/.s.PGSQL.5432,reuseaddr,fork" \
   EXEC:'ssh remoteuser@psqlserver.example socat STDIO UNIX-CONNECT\:/var/run/postgresql/.s.PGSQL.5432'
Then, you'd connect with something like:
psql "user=remoteuser host=$SOCKET_DIR"
Each such psql connection will trigger an ssh connection to be made. Of course, this won't work well if ssh has to prompt for passwords, but you should be using ssh-agent anyway, right? There are at least a couple nice features of being able to use postgresql from a local client like this: Of course, postgresql itself already comes with a nice range of high-quality network-capable authentication mechanisms you could use. But many of them (like GSSAPI or X.509 mutual key-based authentication over TLS) require additional infrastructure setup; and you probably already have sshd up and running on that machine -- so why not make use of it?Tags: postgresql, socat, ssh, tip, unix-domain socket

17 November 2010

Daniel Kahn Gillmor: registrars and AAAA glue records

i've been on an IPv6 kick recently, getting dual-stack systems up and working for a bunch of folks.I'd like to make some of these services reachable by IPv6-only clients. this suggests that i need a range of details sorted out, but i think the one piece left for me is the glue records for the nameservice. i use in-bailiwick nameservers for DNS where possible, which means i want mandatory glue records. that is, the primary namserver for example.org is probably something like ns0.example.org, which means that the org nameservers themselves need to store not only the NS record, but an A record that corresponds to the name pointed to by the NS. But for IPv6-only clients that do their own name resolution, i need AAAA glue records, and i haven't yet found a registrar that will push AAAA glue records for the same names as the existing A glue into the org zone. Do you know of a registrar that will do this?I've tried:
dotster
Dotster seems to only allow IPv4 glue to be entered on their Register Nameserver config page (needs a dotster login to see it). They haven't yet yet responded to my query through their support web form about submitting AAAA glue
gandi
gandi at least offers the opportunity to enter AAAA glue, but apparently can't let me have both AAAA and A glue for the same name. A note to their support team got me a response that this is planned for Q1 or Q2 of 2011.
Any suggestions for reasonable registrars that offer this today? Am i being silly in wanting AAAA and A glue for the same names? i note that the root zone and the org zone both offer A and AAAA records for each of their dual-stack nameservers. You can check for yourself:
 dig @a.root-servers.net ns org
 dig @a.root-servers.net ns .
if i don't go for dual records, i could instead use gandi and go with distinct names for the v6 and v4 servers, like this:
;; QUESTION SECTION:
;example.org.				IN	NS
;; AUTHORITY SECTION:
example.org.      172800	IN	NS	a.ns.example.org.
example.org.      172800	IN	NS	b.ns.example.org.
example.org.      172800	IN	NS	c.ns.example.org.
example.org.      172800	IN	NS	d.ns.example.org.
;; ADDITIONAL SECTION:
a.ns.example.org. 172800	IN	A	192.0.2.3
b.ns.example.org. 172800	IN	A	192.0.2.4
c.ns.example.org. 172800	IN	AAAAA	2001:db8::3
d.ns.example.org. 172800	IN	AAAAA	2001:db8::4
But of course what i really want is this:
;; QUESTION SECTION:
;example.org.				IN	NS
;; AUTHORITY SECTION:
example.org.      172800	IN	NS	a.ns.example.org.
example.org.      172800	IN	NS	b.ns.example.org.
;; ADDITIONAL SECTION:
a.ns.example.org. 172800	IN	A	192.0.2.3
a.ns.example.org. 172800	IN	AAAAA	2001:db8::3
b.ns.example.org. 172800	IN	A	192.0.2.4
b.ns.example.org. 172800	IN	AAAAA	2001:db8::4
My concern about this is if some IPv4-only system gets a list like the first one, and decides to use c.ns.example.org or d.ns.example.org, which doesn't have an A record at all. That would be a silly implementation, of course. but uh, we have a lot of silly implementations of things out there.Feedback welcome!Tags: dns, ipv6

20 October 2010

Daniel Kahn Gillmor: Debian NYC Workshop: What's in a Package?

Debian NYC will be holding a workshop next week: What's in a Package? will happen at 7:00pm New York time on October 27, 2010. If you're in the New York area, interested in packaging things for debian and related systems, or just want to understand the packages in your system better, you should RSVP and come on out! This workshop will provide advanced theory useful for people modifying or creating packages. For people modifying packages, you'll learn many typical motifs and about various build systems. For creating packages, you'll be much better prepared to read and understand guides a deep level. However, this is still not a step-by-step guide in "how to build packages", but will get you very close to there. See you there!

6 October 2010

Daniel Kahn Gillmor: monkeysphere and distributed naming

Roland Mas writes an interesting article about decentralized naming, in which he says:
Monkeysphere aims at adding a web of trust to the SSL certificates system, but the CA chain problem seems to persist (although I must admit I'm not up to speed with the actual details).
Since i'm one of the Monkeysphere developers, i figure i should respond! Let me clarify that Monkeysphere doesn't just work in places where X.509 (the SSL certificate system) works. It works in other places too (like SSH connections). And I don't think that the CA chain problem that remains in Monkeysphere is anything like the dangerous mess that common X.509 usage has given us. I do think that at some level, people need to think about who is introducing them to other people -- visual or human-comprehensible representations of public key material are notoriously difficult to make unspoofable. On the subject of distributed naming: OpenPGP already allows distributed naming: every participant in the WoT is allowed to assert that any given key maps to any given identity. Duplicates and disagreements can exist just fine. How an entity decides to certify another entity's ID without a consensus global namespace is a tough one, though. If i've always been known as "John Smith" to my friends, and someone else has also been known as "John Smith" to his friends, our friends aren't actually disagreeing or in conflict -- it's just that neither of us has a unique name. The trouble comes when someone new wants to find "John Smith" -- which of us should they treat as the "correct" one? I think the right answer probably has to do with who they're actually looking for, which has to do with why they're looking for someone named "John Smith". If they're looking for John Smith because the word on the street is that John Smith is a good knitter and they need a pair of socks, they can just examine what information we each publish about ourselves, and decide on a sock-by-sock basis which of us best suits their needs. But if they're looking for "John Smith" because their cousin said "hey, i know this guy John Smith. I think you would like to argue politics over a beer with him", then what matters is the introduction. And OpenPGP handles that just fine -- if their cousin has only ever met a single John Smith, that's the right one. If their cousin has met several John Smiths, then the searcher would do well to ask their cousin some variant of "hey, do you mean John Smith or John Smith ", or even "do you mean the John Smith who Molly has met, or the one who Charles has met?" (assuming that Molly and Charles have each only certified one John Smith in common with the cousin, and not the same one as each other), or to get a real-time introduction to a particular John Smith, where his specific key is somehow recordable by the searcher for future conversations (or beer drinking). This is what we do in the real world anyway. We currently lack good UIs for doing this over the network, but the certification infrastructure is in place already. What we're lacking in infrastructure, though, is a way to have a distributed addressing. Roland's proposal was to publish addresses corresponding to cryptographic identities within some DNS zone, or in freenet or gnutella. Another approach (piggybacking on existing infrastructure) would be to include IP address information in the OpenPGP self-certification, so the holder of the name could claim exactly their own IP address. This could be distributed through the keyserver network, just like other updates are today, and it could be done simply and immediately with a well-defined OpenPGP notation. I'd be happy to talk to interested people about how to specify such a notation, and what possible corner cases we might run into. Drop a note here, or mail the Monkeysphere mailing list or hop onto #monkeysphere on irc.oftc.netTags: authentication, distributed naming, identity, monkeysphere

29 September 2010

Russell Coker: Links September 2010

Kevin Stone gave an interesting TED talk about the biological future of joint replacement [1]. Using stem cells and animal tissue which has been prepared to destroy the chemicals that trigger immune responses the tissues can regrow. Replacing joints with titanium and ceramic lets people walk again, regrowing them with Kevin s methods allows them to compete at the highest levels of sporting contests! Derek Sivers gave a brief and interesting TED talk advising people to keep their goals secret if they want to achieve them [2]. The Parrot AR.Drone is an interesting device [3], it s a four-propeller helicopter that is controlled by WiFi. Apparently there is little security (it binds to the first WiFi client it sees) which is a significant down-side. It returns a video feed to the controlling iPhone as it flys and can hover when it loses it s connection. It will be interesting to see when people write software for other devices (Android etc). Also I wonder whether there will be open source weapons kits for it. If you could have those devices use either a nerf gun or a lance to attack each other s turbines then you could have drone jousting. Don Marti had an interesting new idea for a crime game [4]. The main concept is to use the element of mistrust that is present in real criminal gangs. The new guy you invite to join a job might inform the police and you won t know for sure. Sometimes a heist will be discovered by the police through bad luck (or good police work) and you will wonder whether there was an informant. The aim is for a simple game design and with the complexity in email discussions between the players. The C64 isn t dead, it s even on the Internet [5], an original C64 is running a web site! Tan Li gave an interesting TED talk about a new headset to read brain-waves [6]. The device in question can be applied in minutes, requires no gel or abrasion of the scalp, connects to the computer wirelessly and is relatively cheap at $300US. The developer s kit (which I think includes a headset) is $500US. I wonder if the community can develop a cheaper version of this which is more open. Lisa Margonelli gave an interesting TED talk about the politics of oil [7]. One of her insightful points is that the subsidies for oil should be shifted from the oil industry to middle-class consumers. But she goes off track a bit by suggesting gradual oil tax increases until 2020, according to the best estimates of groups such as the CSIRO they won t need to have taxes to give a high oil price in 2020! She is aiming for a 20% reduction in petrol use by 2020, but I m not aware of any serious group of scientists who have evidence to suggest that the production capacity in 2020 will be close to 80% what it is now. Slate has a good article about The Innocence Project which uses DNA tests to overturn false convictions [8], it s scarey how badly the justice system works. Rachel Sussman gave an interesting talk about the World s Oldest Living Things [9], nothing less than 2000 years old is included. Nicholas Negroponte gave an interesting EG 2007 talk about the OLPC project [10]. While some of the content about OLPC production is a little dated the OLPC history is relevant and his personal opinions regarding the benefits that children receive from computers are insightful. Jayne Poynter gave an interesting TED talk about life in Biosphere 2 [11]. Her work on mini-biospheres is also interesting. Let s hope we get a permanent Biosphere running outside the Earth sometime soon. Sheryl WuDunn gave an informative TED talk titled Our Century s Greatest Injustice about the plight of women in most of the world [12]. Daniel Kahn Gillmor wrote a good article about the use of ssh-agent [13]. You really should use it to secure your ssh keys. Mark Shuttleworth has described the development process for the Ubuntu font [14]. This is a very interesting project and IMHO one of the most significant things that Ubuntu has done. Prior to this an entirely closed development process has been used for font development. Now we are getting a major new font family developed with a free and open process and with some new legal developments for a font license! One thing to note that this project appears to have involved a lot of work from professional font designers, it sounds like Canonical spent a significant amount of money on this project.

27 September 2010

Daniel Kahn Gillmor: You should be using ssh-agent

If you're not using ssh-agent to authenticate yourself to SSH servers, you should be. (i'm assuming you're already using PubkeyAuthentication; if you're still using PasswordAuthentication, ChallengeResponseAuthentication or KbdInteractiveAuthentication, fix that please). You should use ssh-agent for a number of reasons, actually, but the simplest is this: when you authenticate to a text-based channel on a remote server, you should never have to type anything about that authentication into the channel that will eventually be controlled by the remote server. That's because a malicious server could simply accept your connection as an anonymous connection and print out the exact prompt you're expecting. Then, whatever you're typing goes into the remote server instead of into your authentication scheme. and congrats, you just gave away the passphrase for your key. With ssh-agent, you talk first to your agent. Then, you talk to the server and your ssh client talks to the agent. Your keys and your passphrase are never exposed. the second reason is that the agent is a much smaller piece of code than the ssh client, and it doesn't talk to the network at all (unless you force it to). It holds your key and never releases it to querying processes; It even runs in a protected memory space so other processes can't peek at it. So if this protected, isolated agent is what holds your key, you're in much better shape than if a non-protected, larger, network-active process (the ssh client) has direct access to your secret key material. The third reason is that it's just more convenient -- you can put a key in your agent, and ask it to prompt you when its use is requested. you don't actually need to re-type your passphrase each time. you can just hit enter or type "yes". And if that scares you security-wise then you can put the key in for a limited period of time, as well. (btw, you should be using the ssh-agent that ships with OpenSSH, probably not the implementation offered by gnome, which doesn't offer a confirmation prompt, doesn't run in protected memory space, and links in a ton more libraries) So how do you use the agent? It's probably already installed and running on your computer if you run a desktop with debian or another reasonable free operating system. Query what keys are in your agent:
0 dkg@pip:~$ ssh-add -l
The agent has no identities.
1 dkg@pip:~$ 
Add a standard OpenSSH secret key to your agent, prompting for confirmation after each use:
0 dkg@pip:~$ ssh-add -c ~/.ssh/id_rsa
Enter passphrase for /home/dkg/.ssh/id_rsa: your nice long passphrase here
Identity added: /home/dkg/.ssh/id_rsa (/home/dkg/.ssh/id_rsa)
The user must confirm each use of the key
0 dkg@pip:~$ 
(if you drop the -c, you will not be prompted at each use) Add a standard OpenSSH secret key to your agent, with a lifespan of one hour (3600 seconds)
0 dkg@pip:~$ ssh-add -t 3600 ~/.ssh/id_rsa
Enter passphrase for /home/dkg/.ssh/id_rsa: your nice long passphrase here
Identity added: /home/dkg/.ssh/id_rsa (/home/dkg/.ssh/id_rsa)
Lifetime set to 3600 seconds
0 dkg@pip:~$ 
(note that you can combine the -t $SECONDS and -c flags to get key that is time-constrained and requires a confirmation prompt at each use) Add a monkeysphere-style key (an authentication-capable subkey from your GnuPG secret keyring) to the ssh-agent (this will prompt you for your GnuPG passphrase with a graphical ssh-askpass program during this keyload, if such a program is available), for one hour:
0 dkg@pip:~$ monkeysphere subkey-to-ssh-agent -t 3600
Identity added: Daniel Kahn Gillmor <dkg@fifthhorseman.net> (Daniel Kahn Gillmor <dkg@fifthhorseman.net>)
Lifetime set to 3600 seconds
0 dkg@pip:~$ 
If you don't already have such a subkey, but you want to use the monkeysphere, you'll need to run monkeysphere gen-subkey to create one first. Note also that you can use both -c and -t $SECONDS with monkeysphere subkey-to-ssh-agent, just like they are used with ssh-add. Remove all keys from your running agent:
0 dkg@pip:~$ ssh-add -D
All identities removed.
0 dkg@pip:~$ 
I hope this is helpful to people! Tags: security, ssh, ssh-agent, tip

21 September 2010

Daniel Kahn Gillmor: hotmail thinks powerpc means mobile

Apparently, live.com thinks that any browser coming from a ppc architecture is a mobile device. This sucks for the users of the hundreds of thousands of powerpc desktops still in service. I don't use hotmail myself, but i do support people who use it. I set one of my clients up with debian squeeze on their PPC machine because all the proprietary vendors have basically given up on that architecture -- debian represents the best way to get modern tools on these machines (and other machines too, but that's a different argument). However, this client couldn't get to their hotmail account, despite using the latest version of iceweasel (3.5.12). They were directed to a crippled interface that didn't include the ability to attach files, and was a gross waste of the desktop screen space. It appears to be the "mobile" version of live.com's services. However, the same version of iceweasel on an i686 test machine could access the standard version of hotmail with no trouble. My friend jeremyb helpfully suggested fiddling with the User Agent string exported by the browser. Some experimentation shows that the presence of the string "ppc" within any parenthetical expression in the UA makes live.com show the crappy interface. You can try it yourself (if you have a hotmail account) on your x86 or amd64 machine by adding (ppc) to the default valule of general.useragent.extra.firefoxComment in about:config. Stupid stupid stupid. I'd like to have fixed this by overriding the browser's reported architecture (or simply by removing it -- why does a web server need to know the hardware architecture of my client?). But there doesn't appear to be a way to do that with the way that mozilla constructs the UA. Instead, i needed to add a new string key named general.useragent.override which is not exposed by default in about:config. This raises some questions: Any ideas?Tags: browser, hotmail, powerpc, ppc, useragent, wtf

19 May 2010

Daniel Kahn Gillmor: NYC SYEP still requires Microsoft Software

A year ago, i wrote about how New York City's Summer Youth Employment Program (SYEP) requires the use of Internet Explorer to apply online (and it even appears to require IE just to download the PDF of the application!) Sadly, the situation has not changed, a year later. Today, I'm writing to Dan Garodnick, Chair of The City Council's Committee on Technology (and the rest of the committee members), Carole Post, Commissioner of DoITT (the city's Department of Information Technology and Telecommunications), and Jeanne B. Mullgrav, Commissioner of DYCD (the Department of Youth and Community Development, which runs SYEP). Here's what i wrote:
For the last two years at least, the DYCD's Summer Youth Employment Program
(SYEP) has been only available to users of Internet Explorer:
 https://application.nycsyep.com/
Internet Explorer (IE) is only made by Microsoft, and is only available for
people running Microsoft operating systems.  Users of other operating systems,
such as GNU/Linux, Macintosh, or others cannot access the SYEP application
process.  Even users of Windows who care about their online security or simply
desire a different web browsing experience might prefer to avoid Internet
Explorer.
Not only is the online form inaccessible from browsers other than IE, even
retrieving a copy of the PDF to print out and fill in manually is unavailable
for web browsers other than IE.
What is the city's policy is on access to government sites?  Is it city policy
to mandate a single vendor's software for access to city resources?  Should NYC
youth be required to purchase software from Microsoft to be able to apply
for the Summer Youth Employment Program?
The sort of data collection needed by such an application is a mainstay of the
standards-based web, and has been so for over 15 years now.  There is no reason
to require particular client on an open platform.  I can point you toward
resources who would be happy to help you make the system functional for users
of *any* web browser, if you like.
I raised this issue over a year ago (see nyc.gov correspondence #1-1-473378926,
and a public weblog posted around the same time [0]), and got no effective
remedy.  It's worrisome to see that this is still a problem.
Please let me know what you plan to do to address the situation.
Regards,
	--dkg
[0] https://www.debian-administration.org/users/dkg/weblog/47
Feel free to send your own message to the folks above (especially helps if you live in or near NYC) Finally, Carole Post, the head of DoITT will also be present at a panel tonight in Soho, which i'm unfortunately be unable to attend. If you go there, you might ask her about the situation.Tags: policy

26 April 2010

Debian News: Brief Updates: d-i l10n status, DebConf, snapshot service, GSOC

25 April 2010

Daniel Kahn Gillmor: Talks and tracks at debconf 10

I'm helping out on the talks committee for debconf 10 this summer in NYC (so yes, i'm going to be here for it, even though i don't have that little badge thingy). This is a call for interested folks to let us know what you want to see at debconf! Talks If you haven't already, submit your proposal for a talk, performance, debate, panel, BoF session, etc! We know you've got good ideas, and the final call for contributions went out yesterday, due in less than a week. Please propose your event soon! Tracks Also, we want to introduce Tracks as a new idea for debconf this summer. A good track would thematically group a consecutive set of debconf events (talks, panels, debates, performances, etc) to encourage a better understanding of a broader theme. For this to work, we need a few good people to act as track coordinators for the areas where they are knowledgeable and engaged. A track coordinator would have a chance to set the tone and scope for their track, schedule events, assemble panels or debates, introduce speakers, and report back at the end of debconf to the larger gathering. We also hope that a coordinator could identify potential good work being done in their area, encourage people to submit relevant events for debconf, and shepherd proposals in their track through the submission process. Are you interested in coordinating a track on some topic? Or do you have a suggestion for someone else who might do a good job on a topic you want to see well-represented at debconf? You can contact the talk committee privately if you have questions at talks@debconf.org, or you can contact the whole team publicly at debconf-team@lists.debconf.org. Some ideas about possible tracks: We can't guarantee that any particular track will happen at dc10, but we can guarantee that it won't happen if no one proposes it or wrangles the relevant events together. Help us make this the best debconf ever and make sure that your own topical itch gets scratched! Tags: debconf, debconf10

23 March 2010

Daniel Kahn Gillmor: Avoiding erroneous OpenPGP certifications

i'm aware that people don't always take proper measures during mass OpenPGP keysignings. Apparently, some keys even get signed with no one at the keysigning present speaking for that key (for example, if the key was submitted to the keysigning via online mechanisms beforehand, but the keyholder failed to show up). Unverified certifications are potentially erroneous, and erroneous certifications are bad for the OpenPGP web of trust. Debian and other projects rely on the OpenPGP web of trust being reasonable and healthy. People should make a habit of doing proper verifications at keysignings. People who make unverified certifications should probably be made aware of better practices. So for future keysignings, i may introduce a key to the set under consideration and see what sort of OpenPGP certifications that key receives. I won't pretend to hold that key in person, won't speak for it, and it won't have my name attached to it. But it may be on the list. Depending on the certifications received on that key (and the feedback i get on this blog post), i'll either publish the list of wayward certifiers, or contact the certifiers privately. Wayward certifiers should review their keysigning practices and revoke any certifications they did not adequately verify. Remember, at a keysigning party, for each key: After the keysigning, when you go to actually make your OpenPGP certifications: Feedback welcome! Tags: keysigning, openpgp, tip

Next.

Previous.